{"id":"https://openalex.org/W7204193965","doi":"https://doi.org/10.48550/arxiv.2608.21850","title":"Consistently Good vs. Occasionally Great: A Rubric for Open-Ended Feedback Quality from Humans and Machines","display_name":"Consistently Good vs. Occasionally Great: A Rubric for Open-Ended Feedback Quality from Humans and Machines","alternate_titles":[],"publication_year":2026,"publication_date":"2026-08-22","ids":{"openalex":"https://openalex.org/W7204193965","doi":"https://doi.org/10.48550/arxiv.2608.21850"},"language":"en","primary_location":{"id":"pmh:oai:arXiv.org:2608.21850","doi":null,"is_oa":true,"landing_page_url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2608.21850","pdf_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2608.21850","source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S4306400194","display_name":"arXiv (Cornell University)","issn_l":"2331-8422","issn":["2331-8422"],"is_oa":true,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":false,"listed_in":[],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/I205783295","host_organization_name":"Cornell University","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/I205783295"],"host_organization_lineage_names":[],"type":"repository"},"license":null,"license_id":null,"version":"submittedVersion","is_accepted":false,"is_published":false,"raw_source_name":null,"raw_type":"text"},"parent_works":[],"lineage":["https://openalex.org/W7204193965"],"child_works_count":0,"type":"preprint","is_traditional":true,"indexed_in":["arxiv","datacite"],"open_access":{"is_oa":true,"oa_status":"green","oa_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2608.21850","any_repository_has_fulltext":true},"authorships":[{"author_position":"first","author":{"id":"https://openalex.org/A5101837457","display_name":"Binglin Chen","orcid":"https://orcid.org/0000-0001-9033-1281","observed_orcids":["https://orcid.org/0000-0001-9033-1281"]},"institutions":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/I157725225","display_name":"University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign","ror":"https://ror.org/047426m28","country_code":"US","type":"education","lineage":["https://openalex.org/I157725225"]}],"countries":["US"],"is_corresponding":false,"raw_author_name":"Chen, Binglin","raw_affiliation_strings":["University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign , Urbana , IL , USA"],"raw_orcid":null,"affiliations":[{"raw_affiliation_string":"University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign , Urbana , IL , USA","institution_ids":["https://openalex.org/I157725225"]}]},{"author_position":"middle","author":{"id":"https://openalex.org/A5034389713","display_name":"Rajarshi Haldar","orcid":null,"observed_orcids":[]},"institutions":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/I157725225","display_name":"University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign","ror":"https://ror.org/047426m28","country_code":"US","type":"education","lineage":["https://openalex.org/I157725225"]}],"countries":["US"],"is_corresponding":false,"raw_author_name":"Haldar, Rajarshi","raw_affiliation_strings":["University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign , Urbana , IL , USA"],"raw_orcid":null,"affiliations":[{"raw_affiliation_string":"University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign , Urbana , IL , USA","institution_ids":["https://openalex.org/I157725225"]}]},{"author_position":"middle","author":{"id":"https://openalex.org/A5091001653","display_name":"Max Fowler","orcid":"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-4730-447X","observed_orcids":["https://orcid.org/0000-0002-4730-447X"]},"institutions":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/I157725225","display_name":"University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign","ror":"https://ror.org/047426m28","country_code":"US","type":"education","lineage":["https://openalex.org/I157725225"]}],"countries":["US"],"is_corresponding":false,"raw_author_name":"Fowler, Max","raw_affiliation_strings":["University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign , Urbana , IL , USA"],"raw_orcid":null,"affiliations":[{"raw_affiliation_string":"University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign , Urbana , IL , USA","institution_ids":["https://openalex.org/I157725225"]}]},{"author_position":"middle","author":{"id":"https://openalex.org/A5001110474","display_name":"Matthew West","orcid":"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-7605-0050","observed_orcids":["https://orcid.org/0000-0002-7605-0050"]},"institutions":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/I157725225","display_name":"University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign","ror":"https://ror.org/047426m28","country_code":"US","type":"education","lineage":["https://openalex.org/I157725225"]}],"countries":["US"],"is_corresponding":false,"raw_author_name":"West, Matthew","raw_affiliation_strings":["University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign , Urbana , IL , USA"],"raw_orcid":null,"affiliations":[{"raw_affiliation_string":"University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign , Urbana , IL , USA","institution_ids":["https://openalex.org/I157725225"]}]},{"author_position":"last","author":{"id":"https://openalex.org/A5066756473","display_name":"Craig B. Zilles","orcid":"https://orcid.org/0000-0003-4601-4398","observed_orcids":["https://orcid.org/0000-0003-4601-4398"]},"institutions":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/I157725225","display_name":"University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign","ror":"https://ror.org/047426m28","country_code":"US","type":"education","lineage":["https://openalex.org/I157725225"]}],"countries":["US"],"is_corresponding":false,"raw_author_name":"Zilles, Craig","raw_affiliation_strings":["University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign , Urbana , IL , USA"],"raw_orcid":null,"affiliations":[{"raw_affiliation_string":"University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign , Urbana , IL , USA","institution_ids":["https://openalex.org/I157725225"]}]}],"institutions":[],"countries_distinct_count":1,"institutions_distinct_count":1,"corresponding_author_ids":[],"corresponding_institution_ids":["https://openalex.org/I157725225"],"apc_list":null,"apc_paid":null,"fwci":null,"has_fulltext":true,"cited_by_count":0,"citation_normalized_percentile":null,"cited_by_percentile_year":null,"biblio":{"volume":null,"issue":null,"first_page":null,"last_page":null},"is_retracted":false,"is_pulled":false,"is_paratext":false,"is_xpac":false,"primary_topic":{"id":"https://openalex.org/T10533","display_name":"Teaching and Learning Programming","score":0.4426000118255615,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1706","display_name":"Computer Science Applications"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/17","display_name":"Computer Science"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/3","display_name":"Physical Sciences"}},"topics":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/T10533","display_name":"Teaching and Learning Programming","score":0.4426000118255615,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1706","display_name":"Computer Science Applications"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/17","display_name":"Computer Science"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/3","display_name":"Physical Sciences"}},{"id":"https://openalex.org/T11902","display_name":"Intelligent Tutoring Systems and Adaptive Learning","score":0.3075999915599823,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1702","display_name":"Artificial Intelligence"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/17","display_name":"Computer Science"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/3","display_name":"Physical Sciences"}},{"id":"https://openalex.org/T10959","display_name":"Student Assessment and Feedback","score":0.10840000212192535,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/3304","display_name":"Education"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/33","display_name":"Social Sciences"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}}],"keywords":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/automatic-feedback","display_name":"automated feedback","score":0.5740000009536743},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/introductory-programming-education","display_name":"introductory programming education","score":0.8709999918937683},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/llm-generated-feedback","display_name":"LLM-generated feedback","score":0.7239999771118164},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/conversational-tone","display_name":"conversational tone","score":0.6159999966621399}],"concepts":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/C111640148","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q847349","display_name":"Rubric","level":2,"score":0.9308000206947327},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C2779530757","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q1207505","display_name":"Quality (philosophy)","level":2,"score":0.5679000020027161},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C15744967","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q9418","display_name":"Psychology","level":0,"score":0.5163000226020813},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C41008148","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q21198","display_name":"Computer science","level":0,"score":0.4661000072956085},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C196083921","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q7915758","display_name":"Variance (accounting)","level":2,"score":0.4207000136375427},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C192209626","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q190909","display_name":"Focus (optics)","level":2,"score":0.4194999933242798},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C75630572","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q538904","display_name":"Applied psychology","level":1,"score":0.3896999955177307},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C42058189","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q7160400","display_name":"Peer feedback","level":2,"score":0.35339999198913574},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C509550671","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q126945","display_name":"Medical education","level":1,"score":0.35089999437332153},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C18762648","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q42213","display_name":"Work (physics)","level":2,"score":0.34470000863075256},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C2778755073","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q10858537","display_name":"Scale (ratio)","level":2,"score":0.3359000086784363},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C120912362","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q136822","display_name":"Higher education","level":2,"score":0.30640000104904175},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C3017962763","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q427492","display_name":"Feedback regulation","level":2,"score":0.3028999865055084},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C2777548347","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q5456937","display_name":"Flagging","level":2,"score":0.2985000014305115},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C186886427","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q5441213","display_name":"Feedback loop","level":2,"score":0.2883000075817108},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C177264268","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q1514741","display_name":"Set (abstract data type)","level":2,"score":0.28619998693466187},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C180747234","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q23373","display_name":"Cognitive psychology","level":1,"score":0.2825999855995178},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C22156102","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q5341294","display_name":"Educational measurement","level":3,"score":0.2806999981403351},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C42525527","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q1209955","display_name":"Formative assessment","level":2,"score":0.27970001101493835},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C93586867","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q62527","display_name":"Negative feedback","level":3,"score":0.2757999897003174},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C3020716817","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q4132092","display_name":"Visual feedback","level":2,"score":0.2741999924182892},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C56995899","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q1126687","display_name":"Focus group","level":2,"score":0.2734000086784363},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C145420912","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q853077","display_name":"Mathematics education","level":1,"score":0.27320000529289246},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C2780801425","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q5164392","display_name":"Construct (python library)","level":2,"score":0.2619999945163727}],"mesh":[],"locations_count":2,"locations":[{"id":"pmh:oai:arXiv.org:2608.21850","doi":null,"is_oa":true,"landing_page_url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2608.21850","pdf_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2608.21850","source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S4306400194","display_name":"arXiv (Cornell University)","issn_l":"2331-8422","issn":["2331-8422"],"is_oa":true,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":false,"listed_in":[],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/I205783295","host_organization_name":"Cornell University","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/I205783295"],"host_organization_lineage_names":[],"type":"repository"},"license":null,"license_id":null,"version":"submittedVersion","is_accepted":false,"is_published":false,"raw_source_name":null,"raw_type":"text"},{"id":"doi:10.48550/arxiv.2608.21850","doi":"https://doi.org/10.48550/arxiv.2608.21850","is_oa":true,"landing_page_url":"https://doi.org/10.48550/arxiv.2608.21850","pdf_url":null,"source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S4306400194","display_name":"arXiv (Cornell University)","issn_l":"2331-8422","issn":["2331-8422"],"is_oa":true,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":false,"listed_in":[],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/I205783295","host_organization_name":"Cornell University","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/I205783295"],"host_organization_lineage_names":[],"type":"repository"},"license":null,"license_id":null,"version":null,"is_accepted":false,"is_published":false,"raw_source_name":null,"raw_type":"Preprint"}],"best_oa_location":{"id":"pmh:oai:arXiv.org:2608.21850","doi":null,"is_oa":true,"landing_page_url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2608.21850","pdf_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2608.21850","source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S4306400194","display_name":"arXiv (Cornell University)","issn_l":"2331-8422","issn":["2331-8422"],"is_oa":true,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":false,"listed_in":[],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/I205783295","host_organization_name":"Cornell University","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/I205783295"],"host_organization_lineage_names":[],"type":"repository"},"license":null,"license_id":null,"version":"submittedVersion","is_accepted":false,"is_published":false,"raw_source_name":null,"raw_type":"text"},"sustainable_development_goals":[{"score":0.9235000014305115,"id":"https://metadata.un.org/sdg/4","display_name":"Quality education"}],"study_designs":[],"awards":[],"funders":[],"has_content":{"pdf":true,"grobid_xml":true},"content_urls":{"pdf":"https://content.openalex.org/works/W7204193965.pdf","grobid_xml":"https://content.openalex.org/works/W7204193965.grobid-xml"},"referenced_works_count":45,"referenced_works":["https://openalex.org/W1519422139","https://openalex.org/W1985269288","https://openalex.org/W2024845009","https://openalex.org/W2038636594","https://openalex.org/W2067142841","https://openalex.org/W2096394886","https://openalex.org/W2104386136","https://openalex.org/W2129741299","https://openalex.org/W2135995390","https://openalex.org/W2164777277","https://openalex.org/W2167504123","https://openalex.org/W2169206180","https://openalex.org/W2560140854","https://openalex.org/W3184396411","https://openalex.org/W3188564437","https://openalex.org/W4382652775","https://openalex.org/W4386044264","https://openalex.org/W4387402078","https://openalex.org/W4389519254","https://openalex.org/W4389966389","https://openalex.org/W4390315357","https://openalex.org/W4390414972","https://openalex.org/W4392564669","https://openalex.org/W4392639864","https://openalex.org/W4392858532","https://openalex.org/W4395483820","https://openalex.org/W4396916202","https://openalex.org/W4399627833","https://openalex.org/W4400208028","https://openalex.org/W4400267611","https://openalex.org/W4400268488","https://openalex.org/W4400335533","https://openalex.org/W4400642852","https://openalex.org/W4402476574","https://openalex.org/W4404910467","https://openalex.org/W4405494100","https://openalex.org/W4407841797","https://openalex.org/W4408363699","https://openalex.org/W4409211663","https://openalex.org/W4413069692","https://openalex.org/W4413888953","https://openalex.org/W4415797148","https://openalex.org/W6968000452","https://openalex.org/W7133239970","https://openalex.org/W7203709493"],"related_works":["https://openalex.org/W4400267611","https://openalex.org/W4413889009","https://openalex.org/W7162645507","https://openalex.org/W7166044042","https://openalex.org/W7166885068","https://openalex.org/W7222174853","https://openalex.org/W4415192165","https://openalex.org/W7136001892","https://openalex.org/W7154900570","https://openalex.org/W4405826149"],"abstract_inverted_index":{"Providing":[0],"high-quality":[1],"feedback":[2,13,24,59,102,111,167,216,224],"on":[3,23,41],"student":[4,67,118],"work":[5],"is":[6],"essential":[7],"for":[8,25,57,81,195,221],"learning,":[9],"yet":[10],"delivering":[11],"such":[12],"at":[14,71],"scale":[15],"remains":[16],"challenging.":[17],"In":[18],"this":[19,98],"paper,":[20],"we":[21,100,156],"focus":[22],"open-ended":[26],"short":[27],"answer":[28],"questions":[29],"in":[30,54,188,214,225],"introductory":[31],"programming,":[32],"with":[33,120],"the":[34,45,66,88,139,142,169],"goal":[35],"of":[36,65,87,204,212],"nudging":[37],"students":[38],"toward":[39],"success":[40],"reattempts":[42],"without":[43],"revealing":[44],"correct":[46,63],"answer.":[47],"We":[48,200],"develop":[49],"a":[50,105],"five-criteria":[51],"rubric":[52],"grounded":[53],"educational":[55,226],"literature":[56],"evaluating":[58],"quality:":[60,168],"(1)":[61],"acknowledging":[62],"portions":[64],"answer,":[68,89],"(2)":[69],"identifying":[70],"least":[72],"one":[73,135],"flaw":[74],"(if":[75],"present),":[76],"(3)":[77],"providing":[78],"actionable":[79],"guidance":[80],"improvement,":[82],"(4)":[83],"maintaining":[84],"appropriate":[85,94],"concealment":[86],"and":[90,123,207,218],"(5)":[91],"using":[92,163],"an":[93,124],"conversational":[95],"tone.":[96],"Using":[97],"rubric,":[99],"compare":[101],"generated":[103],"by":[104,153],"frontier":[106],"LLM":[107,125,143,170,208],"(OpenAI":[108],"o1)":[109],"to":[110,165],"from":[112],"nine":[113],"teaching":[114],"assistants":[115],"across":[116],"90":[117],"responses,":[119],"three":[121],"researchers":[122,196],"independently":[126],"scoring":[127],"all":[128],"feedback.":[129],"Our":[130],"results":[131],"show":[132],"that":[133],"while":[134],"TA":[136,206,215],"often":[137],"produced":[138],"best":[140],"feedback,":[141],"demonstrated":[144],"consistently":[145],"higher":[146,176],"average":[147],"performance":[148],"than":[149,177],"TAs,":[150],"as":[151],"evaluated":[152],"humans.":[154],"However,":[155],"also":[157],"uncover":[158],"significant":[159],"self-preference":[160],"bias":[161],"when":[162],"LLMs":[164],"evaluate":[166],"systematically":[171],"rated":[172],"its":[173],"own":[174],"outputs":[175],"human":[178],"experts":[179],"did.":[180],"This":[181],"bias,":[182],"which":[183],"research":[184],"suggests":[185],"persists":[186],"even":[187],"cross-model":[189],"evaluation,":[190],"raises":[191],"important":[192],"methodological":[193],"concerns":[194],"employing":[197],"LLM-based":[198],"evaluation.":[199],"provide":[201],"detailed":[202],"characterization":[203],"both":[205],"performance,":[209],"analyze":[210],"sources":[211],"variance":[213],"quality,":[217],"discuss":[219],"implications":[220],"deploying":[222],"LLM-generated":[223],"settings.":[227]},"cited_by_api_url":"https://api.openalex.org/works?filter=cites:W7204193965","counts_by_year":[],"updated_date":"2026-11-16T12:05:36.265796","created_date":"2026-08-26T00:00:00"}
