{"id":"https://openalex.org/W4402139579","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1111/heyj.14346","title":"Henri de Lubac and The Question of Original Sin for Catholic Theology","display_name":"Henri de Lubac and The Question of Original Sin for Catholic Theology","publication_year":2024,"publication_date":"2024-09-01","ids":{"openalex":"https://openalex.org/W4402139579","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1111/heyj.14346"},"language":"en","primary_location":{"id":"doi:10.1111/heyj.14346","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1111/heyj.14346","is_oa":true,"landing_page_url":"http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/heyj.14346","pdf_url":"https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdfdirect/10.1111/heyj.14346","source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S196796222","display_name":"The Heythrop Journal","issn_l":"0018-1196","issn":["0018-1196","1468-2265"],"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":false,"listed_in":["erih-plus","jufo-1","norway-1"],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/P4310320595","host_organization_name":"Wiley","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/P4310320595"],"host_organization_lineage_names":["Wiley"],"type":"journal"},"license":null,"license_id":null,"version":"publishedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":true,"raw_source_name":"The Heythrop Journal","raw_type":"journal-article"},"volume":null,"type":"article","indexed_in":["crossref"],"open_access":{"is_oa":true,"oa_status":"bronze","oa_url":"https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdfdirect/10.1111/heyj.14346","any_repository_has_fulltext":false},"authorships":[{"author_position":"first","author":{"id":"https://openalex.org/A5106935482","display_name":"SJ Philip Moller","orcid":null,"observed_orcids":[]},"institutions":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/I40120149","display_name":"University of Oxford","ror":"https://ror.org/052gg0110","country_code":"GB","type":"education","lineage":["https://openalex.org/I40120149"]}],"countries":["GB"],"is_corresponding":true,"raw_author_name":"Philip Moller, SJ","raw_affiliation_strings":["Campion Hall The Faculty of Theology and Religion, University of Oxford","Campion Hall, The Faculty of Theology and Religion, University of Oxford"],"raw_orcid":null,"affiliations":[{"raw_affiliation_string":"Campion Hall The Faculty of Theology and Religion, University of Oxford","institution_ids":["https://openalex.org/I40120149"]},{"raw_affiliation_string":"Campion Hall, The Faculty of Theology and Religion, University of Oxford","institution_ids":["https://openalex.org/I40120149"]}]}],"institutions":[],"countries_distinct_count":1,"institutions_distinct_count":1,"corresponding_author_ids":["https://openalex.org/A5106935482"],"corresponding_institution_ids":["https://openalex.org/I40120149"],"apc_list":{"value":2760,"currency":"USD","value_usd":2760},"apc_paid":null,"fwci":0.0,"has_fulltext":true,"cited_by_count":0,"citation_normalized_percentile":{"value":0.17172821,"is_in_top_1_percent":false,"is_in_top_10_percent":false},"cited_by_percentile_year":null,"biblio":{"volume":"65","issue":"5","first_page":"477","last_page":"486"},"is_retracted":false,"is_paratext":false,"is_xpac":false,"primary_topic":{"id":"https://openalex.org/T12862","display_name":"Catholicism and Religious Studies","score":0.5913000106811523,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1202","display_name":"History"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/12","display_name":"Arts and Humanities"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},"topics":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/T12862","display_name":"Catholicism and Religious Studies","score":0.5913000106811523,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1202","display_name":"History"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/12","display_name":"Arts and Humanities"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},{"id":"https://openalex.org/T12440","display_name":"Karl Barth and Christian Theology","score":0.23229999840259552,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1211","display_name":"Philosophy"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/12","display_name":"Arts and Humanities"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},{"id":"https://openalex.org/T12857","display_name":"Medieval Philosophy and Theology","score":0.09070000052452087,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1211","display_name":"Philosophy"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/12","display_name":"Arts and Humanities"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}}],"keywords":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/henri-de-lubac","display_name":"Henri de Lubac","score":0.9710000157356262},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/original-sin","display_name":"original sin","score":0.9750000238418579},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/nature-and-grace","display_name":"nature and grace","score":0.5849999785423279},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/beatific-vision","display_name":"beatific vision","score":0.7670000195503235},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/creation-theology","display_name":"creation theology","score":0.640999972820282},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/theological-anthropology","display_name":"theological anthropology","score":0.7749999761581421},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/image-and-likeness-of-god","display_name":"image and likeness of God","score":0.6660000085830688},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/adam-and-eve","display_name":"Adam and Eve","score":0.7179999947547913},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/ressourcement","display_name":"ressourcement","score":0.6200000047683716},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/catholic-theology","display_name":"Catholic theology","score":0.5580000281333923},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/sin-and-death","display_name":"sin and death","score":0.3019999861717224},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/philo-of-alexandria","display_name":"Philo of Alexandria","score":0.5619999766349792},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/gregory-of-nyssa","display_name":"Gregory of Nyssa","score":0.4970000088214874},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/gregory-of-nazianzus","display_name":"Gregory of Nazianzus","score":0.6589999794960022}],"concepts":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/C138885662","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q5891","display_name":"Philosophy","level":0,"score":0.7704212665557861},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C2780279293","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q1367940","display_name":"Catholic theology","level":2,"score":0.6410142183303833},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C27206212","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q34178","display_name":"Theology","level":1,"score":0.6241838932037354}],"mesh":[],"locations_count":1,"locations":[{"id":"doi:10.1111/heyj.14346","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1111/heyj.14346","is_oa":true,"landing_page_url":"http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/heyj.14346","pdf_url":"https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdfdirect/10.1111/heyj.14346","source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S196796222","display_name":"The Heythrop Journal","issn_l":"0018-1196","issn":["0018-1196","1468-2265"],"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":false,"listed_in":["erih-plus","jufo-1","norway-1"],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/P4310320595","host_organization_name":"Wiley","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/P4310320595"],"host_organization_lineage_names":["Wiley"],"type":"journal"},"license":null,"license_id":null,"version":"publishedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":true,"raw_source_name":"The Heythrop Journal","raw_type":"journal-article"}],"best_oa_location":{"id":"doi:10.1111/heyj.14346","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1111/heyj.14346","is_oa":true,"landing_page_url":"http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/heyj.14346","pdf_url":"https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdfdirect/10.1111/heyj.14346","source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S196796222","display_name":"The Heythrop Journal","issn_l":"0018-1196","issn":["0018-1196","1468-2265"],"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":false,"listed_in":["erih-plus","jufo-1","norway-1"],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/P4310320595","host_organization_name":"Wiley","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/P4310320595"],"host_organization_lineage_names":["Wiley"],"type":"journal"},"license":null,"license_id":null,"version":"publishedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":true,"raw_source_name":"The Heythrop Journal","raw_type":"journal-article"},"sustainable_development_goals":[],"sustainable_development_goals_aurora":[{"id":"https://metadata.un.org/sdg/10","display_name":"Reduced inequalities","score":0.4399999976158142}],"study_designs":[],"awards":[],"funders":[],"has_content":{"pdf":true,"grobid_xml":true},"content_urls":{"pdf":"https://content.openalex.org/works/W4402139579.pdf","grobid_xml":"https://content.openalex.org/works/W4402139579.grobid-xml"},"referenced_works_count":0,"referenced_works":[],"related_works":["https://openalex.org/W4391375266","https://openalex.org/W2748952813","https://openalex.org/W2461963665","https://openalex.org/W2276740543","https://openalex.org/W2912137438","https://openalex.org/W2803307177","https://openalex.org/W1494974852","https://openalex.org/W1030430500","https://openalex.org/W2346533055","https://openalex.org/W3214635344"],"abstract_inverted_index":{"The":[0,94,208,266,1006,1077,1399,1410,1652,1698,2630,2681,3507,4390,4414,4530,4731,4761],"Jesuit":[1],"theologian":[2],"Henri":[3,165,1893,2125],"de":[4,54,166,1894,2025,2119,2130,2184,2219,3104,3173,3270,3407,3691,3940,4341,4433,4580,4700],"Lubac":[5,167,1895,2131,2185,2260,2389,2444,2566,2936,3075,3105,3271,3464,3692,3847,3941,4342,4434],"(1896\u20131991)":[6],"is":[7,49,190,221,240,455,487,492,574,584,928,1013,1028,1065,1084,1098,1106,1110,1115,1119,1132,1146,1152,1205,1210,1251,1260,1372,1526,1574,1583,1588,1701,1805,1888,2021,2114,2143,2159,2179,2225,2329,2336,2368,2375,2393,2456,2461,2590,2603,2617,2621,2639,2683,2699,2744,2769,2773,2803,2895,2898,2968,2980,2996,3001,3015,3048,3063,3080,3161,3196,3227,3249,3384,3429,3472,3636,3742,3796,3810,3886,3889,3972,4017,4045,4082,4133,4137,4150,4165,4233,4260,4288,4296,4301,4308,4317,4324,4328,4377,4383,4425,4438,4468,4500,4505,4628,4663,4787,4811],"most":[8,1007,1982,2595],"often":[9,2160],"associated":[10],"with":[11,62,142,406,820,1562,1776,1814,1847,1913,1930,2354,2509,2626,2950,3517,3891,4174,4198,4412,4839],"the":[12,17,20,23,29,34,40,43,66,69,73,80,98,105,125,130,136,146,152,155,162,169,179,195,199,231,235,242,248,257,271,275,289,295,301,308,314,331,344,350,377,385,390,435,438,443,450,456,462,473,476,480,493,513,516,524,529,535,542,555,585,601,605,614,620,633,640,650,656,703,706,714,719,724,727,738,742,752,757,806,822,843,849,882,917,936,948,953,983,1032,1066,1121,1138,1183,1187,1192,1219,1226,1233,1256,1267,1270,1285,1298,1312,1335,1341,1348,1354,1376,1403,1414,1459,1500,1532,1542,1551,1576,1584,1602,1610,1626,1633,1637,1641,1656,1660,1666,1674,1692,1702,1708,1722,1733,1736,1740,1744,1751,1755,1761,1770,1777,1781,1787,1810,1815,1836,1841,1848,1859,1862,1902,1914,1921,1946,1953,1975,1981,1990,1997,2005,2011,2036,2047,2052,2059,2065,2084,2088,2099,2102,2107,2133,2147,2151,2154,2168,2174,2199,2214,2226,2231,2235,2254,2262,2269,2278,2281,2288,2291,2343,2362,2386,2401,2406,2417,2424,2431,2468,2474,2485,2488,2493,2510,2526,2534,2545,2559,2581,2585,2594,2599,2604,2608,2612,2619,2672,2677,2694,2700,2704,2718,2727,2757,2789,2808,2813,2818,2842,2854,2858,2867,2887,2902,2908,2915,2951,2961,2993,3036,3042,3045,3060,3090,3098,3109,3121,3175,3179,3199,3213,3217,3221,3224,3235,3244,3247,3257,3275,3285,3293,3296,3306,3310,3316,3324,3370,3374,3417,3431,3438,3449,3456,3477,3486,3497,3522,3528,3540,3543,3556,3564,3580,3600,3603,3612,3629,3634,3642,3661,3709,3725,3747,3763,3784,3787,3791,3798,3823,3835,3852,3861,3865,3874,3878,3914,3928,3935,3947,3950,3960,3968,4008,4057,4072,4096,4113,4123,4128,4147,4162,4175,4190,4193,4196,4201,4205,4212,4272,4345,4354,4357,4396,4452,4460,4466,4475,4486,4497,4508,4511,4528,4543,4559,4593,4600,4603,4610,4645,4652,4669,4694,4707,4710,4715,4718,4728,4737,4753,4767,4772,4799,4802,4808,4815,4828,4831,4842,4848],"infamous":[13],"nature\u2013grace":[14,2272],"debates":[15],"of":[16,22,33,57,65,68,83,107,118,124,129,132,145,148,154,157,164,171,186,198,203,211,216,223,237,244,251,274,293,303,310,316,319,343,379,415,421,430,449,475,482,515,528,554,569,590,604,607,624,635,693,705,723,735,756,774,786,790,851,868,884,888,919,935,955,962,977,1015,1023,1055,1090,1161,1186,1194,1199,1229,1235,1266,1277,1295,1304,1314,1345,1350,1362,1378,1405,1413,1422,1451,1462,1468,1493,1502,1553,1567,1578,1595,1601,1604,1625,1628,1643,1655,1669,1679,1694,1724,1735,1754,1757,1772,1780,1794,1803,1851,1861,1866,1870,1901,1917,1925,1948,1965,1989,1992,2040,2054,2061,2077,2086,2090,2101,2111,2135,2140,2150,2153,2170,2176,2201,2209,2253,2256,2268,2283,2290,2302,2309,2312,2331,2345,2408,2419,2426,2448,2536,2587,2598,2607,2614,2632,2668,2674,2679,2703,2729,2835,2841,2860,2892,3011,3027,3092,3111,3139,3142,3181,3201,3216,3223,3232,3234,3246,3256,3259,3277,3288,3295,3298,3309,3318,3328,3376,3416,3420,3459,3469,3482,3542,3566,3570,3617,3628,3633,3687,3711,3727,3739,3749,3786,3794,3800,3825,3837,3864,3867,3876,3910,3930,3937,3949,3953,3965,4034,4074,4099,4125,4130,4185,4192,4195,4208,4214,4228,4304,4347,4359,4388,4392,4402,4404,4429,4454,4465,4488,4510,4513,4527,4532,4545,4569,4572,4647,4655,4685,4709,4717,4720,4736,4739,4749,4755,4763,4769,4790,4801,4833,4845,4853],"twentieth":[18,1745],"century,":[19,708,1746],"inauguration":[21],"ressourcement":[24],"method":[25],"for":[26,79,97,104,114,182,365,371,612,713,741,805,836,1031,1397,1402,1537,1613,1889,1996,2004,2094,2115,2245,2250,2357,2438,2463,2623,2738,2792,2807,2914,2953,2956,3265,3437,3476,3502,3651,3724,3760,3857,4014,4019,4052,4056,4078,4088,4161,4249,4344,4451,4496,4515,4595,4664,4734],"theological":[27,109,173,1011,1034,1795,2007,2246,3450,3512,4446,4582,4696,4712,4729,4776],"reflection,":[28],"ecclesiology":[30],"and":[31,36,42,120,127,168,201,259,281,284,291,305,321,338,352,373,392,403,409,446,496,505,563,578,588,622,647,661,665,733,737,754,763,777,870,932,960,987,1036,1069,1075,1092,1100,1154,1171,1201,1232,1274,1302,1316,1365,1424,1430,1434,1556,1671,1683,1696,1715,1730,1783,1817,1822,1826,1854,1880,1906,1920,1937,1955,1984,2033,2096,2109,2123,2198,2203,2212,2230,2233,2248,2274,2373,2414,2436,2487,2676,2693,2742,2784,2907,2927,2985,3008,3023,3055,3069,3120,3150,3157,3169,3194,3280,3321,3332,3337,3353,3390,3393,3399,3443,3447,3552,3568,3599,3666,3672,3808,3840,3894,3913,3955,3987,4037,4049,4070,4106,4117,4157,4203,4211,4223,4264,4277,4362,4373,4409,4421,4550,4574,4596,4614,4757,4765,4781,4792,4847,4850],"catholicity":[32],"Church,":[35],"right":[37,3362],"relations":[38],"between":[39,730,1904,2228,3563],"sacred":[41],"secular":[44],"in":[45,91,135,151,175,194,206,234,241,256,260,288,334,376,432,512,523,564,571,619,639,781,792,797,829,855,881,921,951,967,982,1060,1072,1094,1104,1120,1211,1263,1283,1311,1334,1393,1447,1489,1515,1545,1618,1646,1673,1743,1786,1791,1960,2017,2064,2106,2188,2190,2223,2277,2337,2348,2366,2381,2410,2507,2580,2628,2642,2659,2691,2723,2750,2753,2776,2788,2933,2975,2986,3034,3052,3081,3129,3158,3165,3178,3206,3220,3243,3305,3356,3363,3423,3430,3461,3480,3521,3593,3611,3626,3668,3685,3755,3775,3818,3873,3899,3974,3985,4065,4234,4256,4274,4297,4311,4320,4371,4386,4400,4407,4474,4541,4552,4617,4759,4774],"contemporary":[46,137],"society.":[47],"It":[48,239,1887,2068,2113,2178,4040,4259,4627,4662,4786],"frequently":[50,2023],"overlooked,":[51,2024],"however,":[52,991,1408,2846,2889],"that":[53,214,247,270,282,630,677,811,892,916,926,995,1014,1114,1129,1150,1155,1198,1202,1248,1269,1278,1288,1356,1366,1382,1443,1534,1763,1892,2118,2194,2316,2327,2358,2391,2400,2416,2453,2479,2492,2547,2572,2575,2618,2658,2713,2717,2762,2772,2896,2939,2966,2999,3078,3103,3381,3427,3448,3569,3639,3694,3698,3718,3767,3882,3888,3980,4042,4068,4285,4322,4365,4395,4477,4586,4605,4622,4633,4667,4668,4672,4676,4807],"Lubac's":[55,2026,2120,2220,2651,3408,3622,4581,4701],"critique":[56,3415],"\u2018pure":[58,2237,3421,3868],"nature\u2019":[59,2238,3422],"theory,":[60,3872],"along":[61,819,1775],"his":[63,172,380,397,572,700,798,1019,1363,1386,1484,1897,2240,2800,2882,3733,3771,3776,3963,4153,4292,4442],"recovery":[64],"tradition":[67,459,950],"natural":[70,95,1994,2369,2516,3046,3061,3435,3550,3722,3880,3906,4097,4423,4639],"orientation":[71,4171,4424],"to":[72,161,177,230,348,396,425,503,559,581,669,699,717,847,860,930,1004,1135,1148,1197,1207,1218,1246,1253,1385,1427,1441,1483,1547,1550,1557,1620,1766,1829,1858,1878,1883,1944,1952,1962,2010,2035,2046,2072,2192,2377,2385,2396,2451,2501,2505,2518,2558,2689,2725,2732,2755,2778,2786,2798,2811,2826,2831,2857,2880,2884,2900,2904,2910,2945,2970,2977,2983,3013,3057,3107,3113,3123,3126,3146,3163,3211,3238,3343,3350,3365,3379,3425,3492,3496,3505,3586,3591,3606,3637,3658,3708,3732,3757,3820,3843,3859,3976,4021,4028,4083,4139,4172,4200,4239,4267,4280,4334,4379,4472,4522,4537,4599,4612,4631,4641,4692,4797,4814,4823],"beatific":[74,99,536,1998,2758,3439,4058,4419,4560,4601,4816],"vision,":[75,174,1999,2759,4420,4561],"carry":[76],"monumental":[77],"consequences":[78,1718,2060,4783,4832],"traditional":[81],"doctrine":[82,117,131,147,185,606,1022,1544,1627,1756,1924,1967,2039,2255,2661,3200,3276,3375,4129,4358,4391,4453,4768],"original":[84,133,149,187,252,608,1051,1130,1162,1203,1249,1327,1346,1369,1389,1418,1433,1444,1452,1497,1503,1568,1579,1605,1629,1667,1758,1834,1852,1926,2041,2062,2141,2171,2210,2257,2263,2449,2588,2637,2708,2832,2893,2918,2958,3086,3155,3202,3278,3319,3351,3377,3445,3483,4131,4455,4489,4553,4740,4779,4834],"sin":[85,134,150,188,253,609,654,694,732,765,852,883,957,1052,1064,1131,1196,1204,1250,1370,1406,1419,1445,1498,1528,1569,1573,1668,1690,2063,2142,2172,2264,2450,2589,2894,2959,3279,3378,3484,4132,4741,4780,4835],"as":[86,111,113,355,534,549,653,766,865,1191,1499,1511,1521,1570,1659,1689,1720,2043,2045,2350,2514,2685,2866,2877,3284,3346,3360,3499,3534,3546,4135],"it":[87,454,709,973,1118,1209,1338,1487,1519,1549,1582,1631,1845,2335,2556,2748,2821,2873,3226,3240,3250,3262,3347,3488,3809,3822,3989,3998,4016,4020,4024,4090,4136,4263,4302,4307,4316,4323,4327,4478],"has":[88,1339,3829,4011,4158,4448],"been":[89,898,1481,4519],"understood":[90,3533,4535],"Catholic":[92,212],"theology.":[93],"desire":[96,1103,1113,1995,2517,3436,3723,3881,3994,4013,4051,4087,4238,4273,4287,4295,4437,4613,4640],"vision":[100,537,2728,3440,3513,3726,3785,3824],"holds":[101,2761,3717,4394],"essential":[102,325,3667],"significance":[103,4800],"whole":[106,2631,3297,4346],"modern":[108],"anthropology,":[110,2247],"well":[112,2044],"a":[115,121,143,183,224,356,362,407,467,550,691,769,784,866,893,975,1242,1394,1449,1563,1597,1622,1792,1867,1949,1987,1993,2018,2030,2070,2073,2080,2091,2156,2195,2299,2306,2346,2482,2496,2515,2553,2646,2839,2850,2890,3021,3024,3115,3130,3136,3140,3166,3184,3230,3254,3361,3402,3414,3434,3500,3535,3559,3646,3721,3743,3830,3993,4012,4066,4219,4225,4237,4349,4426,4494,4524,4539,4638],"recovered":[116,4445],"creation,":[119,158,217,2087,2615,2633,4846],"clarified":[122],"understanding":[123,3138,3233],"place":[126,4191],"power":[128,3541,4036],"era.":[138],"This":[139,1102,1593,3029,4283,4294,4444,4504],"paper":[140],"begins":[141,1846],"consideration":[144,4735],"light":[153,2418,4852],"context":[156,197,243,2175,3294,3327,4762,4773,4789],"before":[159,1685,3095,3442],"turning":[160],"case":[163,1287,2282,3222,3245],"implications":[170,2003,2244,4450],"order":[176,1546,1619,1961,2191,2724,2754,2777,2976,3359,3364,3424,3710,3756,3819,3975,4073],"see":[178,599,2519,2542,3102,3758,4240,4642,4693,4824],"hopeful":[180],"prospects":[181],"renewed":[184,2081],"which":[189,359,460,642,779,979,1083,1097,1109,1141,1259,1371,1391,1507,1587,1635,1706,1874,1968,2000,2020,2158,2183,2314,2616,2670,2698,2768,3019,3117,3147,3159,3187,3195,3239,3261,3301,3583,3654,3729,3740,3773,3814,3833,3933,3997,4112,4188,4254,4499,4542,4775,4794,4804],"more":[191,261,1564,2074,2145,2270,2465,2522,3325],"properly":[192],"framed":[193],"wider":[196],"creation":[200,232,245,568,4393,4756,4791],"redemption":[202,1818,1863,2204,2705,3460,4209,4363,4758,4793],"all":[204,215,412,628,670,678,812,1045,3229,3253,3341,4366,4375,4405,4410,4677,4819],"things":[205,4367,4406],"Christ.":[207,490,2629,2680,3462,4215,4760],"basic":[209,225,4350],"position":[210,1440,1612,3116],"theology,":[213,3607,4516],"especially":[218,2051,3625],"human":[219,276,336,451,477,615,743,808,845,937,984,1046,1221,1230,1236,1710,2078,2092,2103,2318,2441,2469,2719,2809,2828,2947,2962,3176,3432,3478,3503,3597,3838,4009,4043,4100,4119,4148,4415,4809],"beings,":[220],"possessed":[222,2495],"inner":[226],"goodness,":[227,448],"reaches":[228,3302],"back":[229],"account":[233,1054,1160,1361,1600,3738,4568],"book":[236],"Genesis.":[238],"theology":[246,1603,1617,1768,1782,2311,2447,2455,3468,3644,3860,4217,4348],"doctrinal":[249,1767],"question":[250,2265,2367,3317,4706,4727,4738],"arises,":[254],"both":[255,1080,3330,3335,3441],"Scriptures":[258],"systematic":[262,1623],"reflections":[263],"upon":[264,1174,2925],"them.":[265,4389],"Genesis":[267,725],"testimony":[268],"indicates":[269],"originary":[272],"state":[273,364,976,1678,2791,3141,3180,3866,4540],"person":[277,616,828,894,985,2104,2720,2810,2869,2963,3177,3433,3479,4010,4149,4416,4810],"was":[278,466,472,545,558,617,695,747,780,814,831,1329,1420,1446,1488,1764,1875,1986,2286,2481,2543,2654,2715,2721,2822,2837,2874,2922,3348,3489,3530,3655,3753,4398,4534,4742],"very":[279,1243,2022,2048,2605,2997,4629],"good,":[280],"male":[283],"female":[285],"were":[286,2671,3152],"created":[287,369,507,2105,2352,2722],"image":[290,378,573,587,621,2108],"likeness":[292,589,623,631,2110],"God":[294,328,368,548,591,835,1087,2351,2627,2730,3389,3728,3759,3761,4053,4064,4089,4247,4616],"creator":[296],"(Gen.":[297],"1:26\u201327).":[298],"But":[299,453,596,745,1760,3714],"following":[300],"exclusion":[302],"Adam":[304,351,465,498,518,544,698,762,821,885,1200,1357,1383,1471,1670,1714,2675,2794,2862,2921],"Eve":[306,353],"from":[307,327,697,817,1039,1086,1713,1824,2173,2611,2816,3035,3040,3388,3455],"Garden":[309],"Eden,":[311],"worked":[312,1009,1765,1819,4062],"on":[313,508,580,671,751,1053,1134,1159,1223,1360,1417,1649,2083,2098,2992,3273,3315,3323,3369,3539,3737,4567,4778],"basis":[315],"their":[317,1169,1677,1687,3207,3669,4570,4577,4656],"exercise":[318],"freedom":[320,2883,2913,3504],"consequent":[322],"unfaithfulness,":[323],"an":[324,426,878,1111,1800,1884,2355,2765,2878,3003,3006,3016,4031,4170,4183,4501,4745],"alienation":[326,429],"came":[329,3509,3514],"into":[330,3515,3962,4116,4181,4705,4726],"world,":[332,391,1096],"manifesting":[333],"sinfulness,":[335],"suffering,":[337,1721],"death.1":[339],"Later":[340,857],"exegetical":[341],"traditions":[342],"Old":[345,2402],"Testament":[346,2403],"begin":[347],"interpret":[349],"story":[354],"literal":[357],"event":[358,783,1881],"brought":[360],"forth":[361],"changed":[363],"humanity:":[366],"\u2018for":[367],"us":[370,375,2353,2439,2737,4250,4321,4796],"incorruption,":[372],"made":[374,546,618,2736,3064,3754,3762,4369,4399],"own":[381,3208,3549,3670,4003],"eternity,":[382],"but":[383,772,1486,1514,1531,1928,2490,2584,2820,2872,3005,3038,3051,3291,3545,3608,3957,4300,4326,4562,4751],"through":[384,632,658,662,3192,4111],"devil's":[386],"envy":[387],"death":[388,667,933,1099,1175,4646],"entered":[389,655],"those":[393,506],"who":[394,471,499,510,557,583,895,997,2285,2656,4330,4547,4589],"belong":[395,4333],"company":[398],"experience":[399,1536,1828,1879],"it\u2019":[400],"(Wis.":[401],"2:23\u201334)":[402],"\u2018[s]in":[404],"began":[405,1813,1896],"woman,":[408],"we":[410,598,626,643,1070,1465,1535,3101,4329,4673,4689],"must":[411,1508,2165,2205,2320,3452,4025,4060,4091,4584],"die":[413,998,4548],"because":[414,934,941,1289,2555,4246,4459],"her\u2019":[416],"(Sir.":[417],"25:24).":[418],"And":[419,1117,1323,1539,3778,3917,4121],"Philo":[420],"Alexandria":[422],"also":[423,2491,3716,3958,4724],"refers":[424],"actual":[427,879],"historical":[428,637,721,971,1899,1966,4206],"humanity":[431,813,927,1058,2409,3383,3680,3719,3795,3883,4376,4411,4483],"history.2":[433],"In":[434,947,1238,3267,3525,4683],"New":[436],"Testament,":[437],"four":[439],"gospels":[440],"underscore":[441],"mainly":[442,1331],"inherent":[444,1460,4843],"dignity,":[445],"hence":[447],"person.":[452],"(earlier)":[457],"Pauline":[458,602],"complexifies":[461],"anthropological":[463],"position:":[464],"created,":[468],"living":[469],"being":[470,768,3699,4182],"prototype":[474],"sustained":[478],"by":[479,547,834,958,1017,1050,1125,1137,1168,1255,1293,1457,1590,1640,1769,1820,1864,1974,2266,2323,2333,2398,2434,2499,2570,2591,2707,3066,3071,3085,3089,3154,3198,3615,3905,3908,3927,4001,4030,4063,4108,4507,4660,4699,4703],"\u2018breath":[481],"God\u2019,":[483],"yet":[484,840,900,2326],"this":[485,565,672,1095,1126,1477,1525,1591,1747,1798,1890,2180,2382,2548,3268,3357,3511,3526,3594,3871,3900,4242,4251,4286,4418,4422,4618,4665,4788],"depiction":[486],"insufficient":[488],"without":[489,3391,4144],"Christ":[491,2420,2428,2538,2576,2602],"second,":[494],"true,":[495,1388],"ultimate":[497],"gives":[500],"\u2018spiritual":[501],"life\u2019":[502],"humanity,":[504,3652],"earth":[509],"share":[511,522,1071,3770],"existence":[514,527],"first":[517,543,1653,2279,2682,3314,4658],"may":[519,3188,3700,3815,3884,3902,3923,3990,4674],"one":[520,556,636,659,773,778,1421,1873,3127,3578,3653,3887],"day":[521],"eschatological,":[525],"spiritual":[526,1395,1827],"second":[530,1699,2652,2695,3919],"Adam,":[531,1305,2435],"latterly":[532],"known":[533,1658,2513,2684],"(1":[538],"Cor.":[539,594],"15:42\u201350).":[540],"Crucially,":[541],"\u2018figure":[551],"[or":[552],"type]":[553],"come\u2019":[560],"(Rom.":[561,680],"5:14),":[562],"way":[566,2216,2267,2339,3083,4067,4476],"God's":[567,787,1463,1475,1725,4035,4038],"man":[570,638,660],"now":[575,2644,3573,4469],"further":[576,1495],"specified":[577],"mapped":[579],"Christ,":[582,1821,2643,4372,4408],"visible":[586],"himself":[592],"(2":[593],"4:4).3":[595],"later":[597,799,1615,1837,1922,1976],"how":[600,689,1426],"version":[603,2308],"becomes":[610,4218],"relevant,":[611],"although":[613,682,1324],"God,":[625,1315,2095,2500,2741,2926,4015,4241,4643,4825],"have":[627,644,1480,2242,2711,2735,2930,3885,3992,4592,4609],"lost":[629,2433,2578],"fault":[634],"past,":[641],"somehow":[645],"inherited,":[646,1153],"herein":[648],"lies":[649],"problematic:":[651],"\u2018[t]herefore,":[652],"world":[657,3529],"sin,":[663,1068,1300,1390,1513,1835,1853,1927,2042,2211,2638,2861,2919,3087,3156,3320,3352,3446,4456,4490,4554],"death,":[664],"so":[666,1943,2964,3766,4055,4318],"passed":[668,1133,1384],"basis,":[673],"namely":[674,810],"[\u1f10\u03c6\u2019":[675],"\u1fa7],":[676],"sinned\u2014\u2019":[679],"5:12),":[681],"here":[683],"Paul":[684,920],"does":[685,841,992,2421,2848,3031,3943],"not":[686,767,897,906,993,1330,1527,1912,2213,2422,2457,2804,2838,2929,3002,3032,3049,3251,3283,3322,3473,3656,3674,3944,3991,4265,4303,4332,4457,4471,4521,4564,4608,4766],"explain":[687,1442],"exactly":[688],"such":[690,1190,1719,2324],"legacy":[692],"transmitted":[696,1206,1252,1482],"descendants.4":[701],"By":[702,3312],"time":[704,1734],"fourth":[707],"had":[710,896,901,1472,1969,2001],"become":[711,1970,2552],"axiomatic":[712],"church":[715],"fathers":[716],"recognise":[718,3212,4798],"literal,":[720],"truth":[722,4526],"account,":[726],"causal":[728],"link":[729],"Adam's":[731,956,1056,1061,1073],"loss":[734,1089,1450,1501],"grace,":[736,1225,1684,1726,1907,2325,2669,2871,3193,3932,3956],"resulting":[739],"condition":[740,846,1711],"race.":[744],"there":[746,2480,2662,3428,3572,4081,4164,4179,4232],"no":[748,903,2338,2592,3082,3531,4159,4166,4743],"widespread":[749],"agreement":[750],"nature":[753,1228,1905,2229,2407,2815,2829,3014,3079,3119,3182,3336,3494,3750,3802,3805,3817,3954,3970,3981,4029,4044,4101,4104,4187,4236],"effect":[755],"fall:":[758,2855],"Irenaeus":[759],"(c.130\u2013202)":[760],"explains":[761,1676],"Eve's":[764],"malicious":[770],"act,":[771,1123],"youthful":[775],"disobedience,":[776],"any":[782,3289,4050,4085],"part":[785,4428],"broader":[788],"plan":[789,2562,2610],"salvation":[791],"Christ.5":[793],"Differently,":[794],"Origen":[795],"(c.185\u2013254)":[796],"period":[800,1742],"ventures":[801],"two":[802,1931,2664,3575,3587,3662,3951,4093],"non-exclusive":[803],"reasons":[804],"postlapsarian":[807,863,3382],"condition,":[809,875,938,2583],"collectively":[815],"excluded":[816],"paradise":[818,3345],"archetype,":[823],"or":[824,909,1455,1505,1523,1972,2058,2364,2471,3096,3705,3995,4154],"else":[825],"each":[826,4387,4606,4635],"individual":[827],"history":[830,4210],"proleptically":[832],"expelled":[833],"some":[837],"unspecified":[838],"reason,":[839],"understand":[842],"present":[844,2066,2582,3358],"be":[848,1001,1509,2321,2502,2506,3124,3190,3453,3903,3925,4022,4026,4061,4084,4140,4245,4681],"consequence":[850,2840,2891,3481],"committed":[853],"prior":[854,2009,2384,2830,2856,3349,3495],"time.6":[856],"theologians":[858,1812],"(differently":[859],"Irenaeus)":[861],"explained":[862],"sinfulness":[864],"result":[867],"weakness":[869],"ignorance":[871],"given":[872,1806,2774],"our":[873,2207,2251,2379,2440,2745,2780,2912,2972,3801,3892,3896,3918,4235,4275,4312,4430,4491],"mortal":[874,1359],"rather":[876,939,969,1929,2342,2370,4752],"than":[877,940,970,1882,2146,2371,2466,2524,4291,4441],"participation":[880],"itself:":[886],"Gregory":[887,961],"Nazianzus":[889],"(c.328\u2013390)":[890],"taught":[891,1381],"baptised,":[899],"done":[902],"wrong,":[904],"did":[905,1942,2928,4607],"deserve":[907],"glory":[908],"punishment,7":[910],"while":[911,1809],"John":[912],"Chrysostom":[913],"(c.347\u2013407)":[914],"indicated":[915,925],"verses":[918],"Romans":[922],"chapter":[923],"five":[924],"condemned":[929],"suffering":[931,4487],"they":[942,1308,4556,4623],"are":[943,1048,1165,1272,1466,4368,4557,4590,4597,4624,4690,4821,4836],"sinful":[944,1262,1709,2528,2868],"per":[945,1529],"se.":[946],"Eastern":[949,1040,1336],"particular,":[952,1239],"description":[954],"Athanasius":[959],"Nyssa":[963],"(c.335\u2013394)":[964],"appears":[965],"primarily":[966],"metaphysical":[968,1871,1918,3519],"terms:":[972],"signifies":[974],"non-being":[978],"brings":[980,1217],"corruption":[981],"(body":[986],"soul).8":[988],"That":[989],"tradition,":[990,1035,1189,1337,4803],"hold":[994,3946,4473],"infants":[996,1157,1367,4546,4588,4649,4679],"unbaptised":[999,1173,1307,4591,4648,4678],"will":[1000,1317,2949,3047,3062,3149,4268],"necessarily":[1002,3584],"confined":[1003],"hell.":[1005],"fully":[1008,1029],"out":[1010,2405,3264],"synthesis":[1012,1328,1839,1916,2049,3632,4467],"Augustine:":[1016],"397,":[1018],"newly":[1020],"named":[1021],"\u2018original":[1024],"sin\u2019":[1025],"(peccatum":[1026],"originale)":[1027],"developed":[1030,1438],"Western":[1033,1343],"differs":[1037],"markedly":[1038],"developments.9":[1041],"On":[1042],"Augustine's":[1043,1180,1325,1432,1439,1559,2310,2446,2454,2660,3467],"formulation,":[1044],"beings":[1047],"stained":[1049],"transgression:":[1057],"shares":[1059],"sin.":[1062,1279,1759,2258],"Original":[1063,1572,1650],"true":[1067,1373,1512,2814,3682],"guilt":[1074,1151,1303,4575],"punishment.":[1076],"punishment":[1078,1093,1533,4566],"constitutes":[1079],"eternal":[1081,2624,4653],"punishment,":[1082],"separation":[1085,1779,2483,3948,3961],"(the":[1088],"immortality),":[1091],"desire.":[1101],"particular":[1105,3849],"sexual":[1107,1122,1257],"desire,":[1108,1128],"excessive":[1112,1127],"sinful.":[1116],"characterised":[1124],"children":[1136,1254],"same":[1139],"act":[1140,1258,4033],"generates":[1142],"them.10":[1143],"Accordingly,":[1144,3790,4005,4146,4216],"Augustine":[1145,2397,2477,2530,2573,2714],"able":[1147,4691],"conclude":[1149],"newborn":[1156,1291],"suffer":[1158,1176,1318],"sin:":[1163,1347],"\u2018they":[1164],"proved":[1166],"guilty":[1167,1310],"misery\u2019,":[1170],"if":[1172,1306,4006,4080,4374,4634],"necessary":[1177,3475,3491],"damnation.11":[1178],"Although":[1179,2218],"theory":[1181,3971,4124,4531],"incorporates":[1182],"main":[1184],"lines":[1185],"Christian":[1188,3218,3299,3576,3688,4360,4854],"relation":[1193,1903,2227],"humanity's":[1195],"children,":[1208],"many":[1212],"respects":[1213],"highly":[1214],"novel.":[1215],"He":[1216,1941,3133],"fore":[1220],"reliance":[1222],"divine":[1224,2609,2770,2954,3072,3093,3618,3788,3812,3931,4114,4381],"impaired":[1227],"freedom,":[1231],"tragedy":[1234],"life.":[1237,3916],"he":[1240,1281,2540,2760,2943,3741,3768,4270,4723],"supplies":[1241],"cogent":[1244],"argument":[1245,3411],"posit":[1247],"inherently":[1261],"itself,":[1264,2050],"regardless":[1265],"fact":[1268,1448,1490,2200,2586,2987,3053,4213,4604],"parents":[1271],"baptised":[1273],"therefore":[1275,3988,4046],"cleansed":[1276],"Moreover,":[1280,2016],"sets":[1282,1609,2404,4771],"stone":[1284],"strong":[1286],"every":[1290],"child":[1292],"reason":[1294,1891,2117,4573,4666],"conception":[1296,1344,2252],"suffers":[1297],"inherited":[1299,1712],"corruption,":[1301],"remain":[1309,3664],"eyes":[1313],"final":[1319,3588,3649,3683,3703,3792,3897,3920,4252],"damnation":[1320],"after":[1321,1856,2473,2817,2853,3097,3444,3485,4827],"death.":[1322],"quite":[1326],"taken":[1332],"up":[1333,1665,2187,2504,3026,3413,3562,3640],"shaped":[1340],"entire":[1342],"Council":[1349,1377,1642,2014],"Carthage":[1351],"(418)":[1352],"affirmed":[1353],"conclusion":[1355],"became":[1358],"sin,12":[1364],"possess":[1368],"sin.13":[1374],"Similarly,":[1375],"Orange":[1379],"(529)":[1380],"offspring":[1387],"resulted":[1392,1790],"enslavement":[1396],"humankind.14":[1398],"precise":[1400,2181],"mechanisms":[1401],"transmission":[1404],"remained,":[1407],"undefined.15":[1409],"principal":[1411,1849,2221,3623],"task":[1412],"scholastic":[1415,1616,1838,3418,4747],"reflection":[1416,4777],"reception,":[1423],"specifically":[1425,2249],"nuance,":[1428],"deepen,":[1429],"soften":[1431],"trenchant":[1435,2300],"synthesis.":[1436,1886,1978],"Anselm":[1437],"(human)":[1453],"righteousness":[1454],"justice:":[1456],"losing":[1458],"principles":[1461],"justice,":[1464,1476,1680,2349],"capable":[1467],"sinning.":[1469],"If":[1470,3204,4231,4818],"indeed":[1473,3400,4007],"retained":[1474],"capacity":[1478,4160,4495,4594],"would":[1479,4650],"descendants,":[1485],"lost.":[1491],"Alexander":[1492],"Hales":[1494],"defined":[1496],"justice":[1504],"righteousness,":[1506],"recognised":[1510],"its":[1516,1647,2411,3067,3281,3303,3548,3681,3702,3712,4002,4782],"material":[1517],"aspect":[1518,2053],"presents":[1520],"concupiscence":[1522],"covetousness:":[1524],"se,":[1530],"sin.16":[1538],"Aquinas":[1540,3695,3715],"received":[1541],"Augustinian":[1543],"submit":[1548],"system":[1552,3419,3520],"Aristotelian":[1554,1773,4721],"philosophy,":[1555,1774],"displace":[1558],"rhetorical":[1560],"argumentation":[1561,1634],"optimistic":[1565,2075],"notion":[1566,1991],"privation.":[1571],"formally":[1575],"privation":[1577],"justice;":[1580],"materially,":[1581],"internal":[1585],"disorder":[1586],"caused":[1589],"privation.17":[1592],"is,":[1594],"course,":[1596],"less":[1598,1876],"pessimistic":[1599],"sin.18":[1606],"Aquinas's":[1607],"framework":[1608,1749],"classical":[1611,1748,1915,1977,2236],"subsequent":[1614],"supply":[1621,2901,3679],"analysis":[1624],"sin;":[1630],"provided":[1632],"supplied":[1636,1750],"conclusions":[1638,1831],"promulgated":[1639],"Trent":[1644],"(1545\u201363)":[1645],"Decree":[1648],"Sin.19":[1651],"element":[1654,1700,4464],"synthesis,":[1657,1799,4713],"peccatum":[1661,1703,2055,4461],"originale":[1662,1704,2056,4462],"originans,":[1663],"takes":[1664,2186,2275,3412,3848,4189,4784],"Even":[1672,2521],"garden,":[1675],"holiness,":[1681],"communion,":[1682],"describing":[1686],"fall":[1688],"under":[1691,2636,4122,4485],"form":[1693,2301],"pride":[1695],"envy.20":[1697],"originatum,":[1705,2057],"articulates":[1707],"Eve,":[1716],"including":[1717,4714],"deprivation":[1723],"disordered":[1727],"desires":[1728,3783,3806,4248,4417,4657],"(\u2018concupiscence\u2019),":[1729],"death.21":[1731],"From":[1732],"sixteenth":[1737],"century":[1738],"until":[1739,2747,3641],"inter-war":[1741],"standard":[1752],"interpretation":[1753,3451,3964],"systematisation":[1762],"introduction":[1771,2859],"structural":[1778,1807],"philosophy":[1784,3567,3592,3676,4227],"faculties":[1785],"preceding":[1788],"period,":[1789],"reversal":[1793,2182],"method.22":[1796],"Under":[1797,3870],"expanded":[1801],"metaphysics":[1802,4748],"evil":[1804,1919],"priority:":[1808],"patristic":[1811,1956],"incarnation":[1816,2202,4361],"reasoned":[1823],"Christology":[1825],"suppose":[1830],"about":[1832],"(subsequent)":[1833],"inverted":[1840],"methodological":[1842,1950],"order.":[1843,2067],"Instead,":[1844],"problem":[1850],"only":[1855,2805,3189,3394,3609,3731,3811,3879,3924,4244,4309],"comes":[1857,4180],"necessity":[1860,2332],"process":[1865],"certain":[1868,2716],"kind":[1869],"reasoning,":[1872,4722],"attentive":[1877],"abstractive":[1885],"pivotal":[1898]},"counts_by_year":[],"updated_date":"2026-08-28T12:50:07.497085","created_date":"2025-10-10T00:00:00"}