{"id":"https://openalex.org/W4385189142","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1111/josp.12543","title":"An irreducible understanding of animal dignity","display_name":"An irreducible understanding of animal dignity","publication_year":2023,"publication_date":"2023-07-24","ids":{"openalex":"https://openalex.org/W4385189142","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1111/josp.12543"},"language":"en","primary_location":{"id":"doi:10.1111/josp.12543","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1111/josp.12543","is_oa":true,"landing_page_url":"https://doi.org/10.1111/josp.12543","pdf_url":"https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdfdirect/10.1111/josp.12543","source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S142541857","display_name":"Journal of Social Philosophy","issn_l":"0047-2786","issn":["0047-2786","1467-9833"],"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":true,"listed_in":["anvur-class-a","anvur-scientific","cwts-core","erih-plus","jufo-2","norway-1","poland-70","russia-white-list-1","vabb-shw"],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/P4310320595","host_organization_name":"Wiley","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/P4310320595"],"host_organization_lineage_names":["Wiley"],"type":"journal"},"license":"cc-by","license_id":"https://openalex.org/licenses/cc-by","version":"publishedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":true,"raw_source_name":"Journal of Social Philosophy","raw_type":"journal-article"},"volume":null,"type":"article","indexed_in":["crossref"],"open_access":{"is_oa":true,"oa_status":"hybrid","oa_url":"https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdfdirect/10.1111/josp.12543","any_repository_has_fulltext":false},"authorships":[{"author_position":"first","author":{"id":"https://openalex.org/A5083271040","display_name":"Simon Coghlan","orcid":"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6021-9878","observed_orcids":["https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6021-9878"]},"institutions":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/I165779595","display_name":"The University of Melbourne","ror":"https://ror.org/01ej9dk98","country_code":"AU","type":"education","lineage":["https://openalex.org/I165779595"]}],"countries":["AU"],"is_corresponding":true,"raw_author_name":"Simon Coghlan","raw_affiliation_strings":["Centre for AI and Digital Ethics, School of Computing and Information Systems, The University of Melbourne, Melbourne, Australia"],"raw_orcid":"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6021-9878","affiliations":[{"raw_affiliation_string":"Centre for AI and Digital Ethics, School of Computing and Information Systems, The University of Melbourne, Melbourne, Australia","institution_ids":["https://openalex.org/I165779595"]}]}],"institutions":[],"countries_distinct_count":1,"institutions_distinct_count":1,"corresponding_author_ids":["https://openalex.org/A5083271040"],"corresponding_institution_ids":["https://openalex.org/I165779595"],"apc_list":{"value":3040,"currency":"USD","value_usd":3040},"apc_paid":{"value":3040,"currency":"USD","value_usd":3040},"fwci":17.8738,"has_fulltext":false,"cited_by_count":10,"citation_normalized_percentile":{"value":0.98963963,"is_in_top_1_percent":false,"is_in_top_10_percent":true},"cited_by_percentile_year":{"min":96,"max":98},"biblio":{"volume":"55","issue":"1","first_page":"124","last_page":"142"},"is_retracted":false,"is_paratext":false,"is_xpac":false,"primary_topic":{"id":"https://openalex.org/T14206","display_name":"Animal Law and Welfare","score":0.861299991607666,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/3308","display_name":"Law"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/33","display_name":"Social Sciences"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},"topics":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/T14206","display_name":"Animal Law and Welfare","score":0.861299991607666,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/3308","display_name":"Law"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/33","display_name":"Social Sciences"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},{"id":"https://openalex.org/T10297","display_name":"Philosophical Ethics and Theory","score":0.13330000638961792,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1211","display_name":"Philosophy"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/12","display_name":"Arts and Humanities"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},{"id":"https://openalex.org/T12819","display_name":"Environmental Philosophy and Ethics","score":0.0017999999690800905,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/2309","display_name":"Nature and Landscape Conservation"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/23","display_name":"Environmental Science"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/3","display_name":"Physical Sciences"}}],"keywords":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/animal-dignity","display_name":"animal dignity","score":0.9990000128746033},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/human-dignity","display_name":"human dignity","score":0.9160000085830688},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/nonhuman-animals","display_name":"non-human animals","score":0.6309999823570251},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/relational-dignity","display_name":"relational dignity","score":0.5630000233650208},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/social-status","display_name":"social status","score":0.7289999723434448},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/social-respect","display_name":"social respect","score":0.593999981880188},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/degrading-treatment","display_name":"degrading treatment","score":0.6809999942779541},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/animal-exploitation","display_name":"animal exploitation","score":0.42800000309944153},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/captive-animals","display_name":"captive animals","score":0.4650000035762787},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/elephants","display_name":"elephants","score":0.335999995470047},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/moral-status-of-animals","display_name":"moral status of animals","score":0.5740000009536743},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/animal-ethics","display_name":"animal ethics","score":0.35899999737739563}],"concepts":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/C2778745096","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q274782","display_name":"Dignity","level":2,"score":0.9790906310081482},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C95124753","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q875686","display_name":"Environmental ethics","level":1,"score":0.5683324933052063},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C2777102381","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q455118","display_name":"Animal ethics","level":2,"score":0.46032679080963135},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C144024400","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q21201","display_name":"Sociology","level":0,"score":0.44520682096481323},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C136815107","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q154242","display_name":"Nothing","level":2,"score":0.4168481230735779},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C111472728","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q9471","display_name":"Epistemology","level":1,"score":0.3480013608932495},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C138885662","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q5891","display_name":"Philosophy","level":0,"score":0.3131483197212219},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C199539241","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q7748","display_name":"Law","level":1,"score":0.31222808361053467},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C17744445","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q36442","display_name":"Political science","level":0,"score":0.2103274166584015}],"mesh":[],"locations_count":1,"locations":[{"id":"doi:10.1111/josp.12543","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1111/josp.12543","is_oa":true,"landing_page_url":"https://doi.org/10.1111/josp.12543","pdf_url":"https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdfdirect/10.1111/josp.12543","source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S142541857","display_name":"Journal of Social Philosophy","issn_l":"0047-2786","issn":["0047-2786","1467-9833"],"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":true,"listed_in":["anvur-class-a","anvur-scientific","cwts-core","erih-plus","jufo-2","norway-1","poland-70","russia-white-list-1","vabb-shw"],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/P4310320595","host_organization_name":"Wiley","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/P4310320595"],"host_organization_lineage_names":["Wiley"],"type":"journal"},"license":"cc-by","license_id":"https://openalex.org/licenses/cc-by","version":"publishedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":true,"raw_source_name":"Journal of Social Philosophy","raw_type":"journal-article"}],"best_oa_location":{"id":"doi:10.1111/josp.12543","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1111/josp.12543","is_oa":true,"landing_page_url":"https://doi.org/10.1111/josp.12543","pdf_url":"https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdfdirect/10.1111/josp.12543","source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S142541857","display_name":"Journal of Social Philosophy","issn_l":"0047-2786","issn":["0047-2786","1467-9833"],"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":true,"listed_in":["anvur-class-a","anvur-scientific","cwts-core","erih-plus","jufo-2","norway-1","poland-70","russia-white-list-1","vabb-shw"],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/P4310320595","host_organization_name":"Wiley","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/P4310320595"],"host_organization_lineage_names":["Wiley"],"type":"journal"},"license":"cc-by","license_id":"https://openalex.org/licenses/cc-by","version":"publishedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":true,"raw_source_name":"Journal of Social Philosophy","raw_type":"journal-article"},"sustainable_development_goals":[],"sustainable_development_goals_aurora":[{"id":"https://metadata.un.org/sdg/16","display_name":"Peace, justice, and strong institutions","score":0.5199999809265137}],"study_designs":[],"awards":[],"funders":[],"has_content":{"grobid_xml":false,"pdf":true},"content_urls":{"pdf":"https://content.openalex.org/works/W4385189142.pdf"},"referenced_works_count":33,"referenced_works":["https://openalex.org/W628989348","https://openalex.org/W652932451","https://openalex.org/W1500164099","https://openalex.org/W1633990585","https://openalex.org/W2011364886","https://openalex.org/W2065218325","https://openalex.org/W2067520127","https://openalex.org/W2089882152","https://openalex.org/W2103492963","https://openalex.org/W2124365103","https://openalex.org/W2133049717","https://openalex.org/W2140339219","https://openalex.org/W2159777451","https://openalex.org/W2326189837","https://openalex.org/W2478564754","https://openalex.org/W2485427673","https://openalex.org/W2489860937","https://openalex.org/W2558475594","https://openalex.org/W2559899157","https://openalex.org/W2738847361","https://openalex.org/W2762494388","https://openalex.org/W2770102517","https://openalex.org/W2771051719","https://openalex.org/W2787852332","https://openalex.org/W2981716921","https://openalex.org/W3005024348","https://openalex.org/W3084310444","https://openalex.org/W3094286395","https://openalex.org/W3122857957","https://openalex.org/W4242481487","https://openalex.org/W4253928373","https://openalex.org/W4362582233","https://openalex.org/W7001334114"],"related_works":["https://openalex.org/W4409691843","https://openalex.org/W2558475594","https://openalex.org/W7009212117","https://openalex.org/W1940365652","https://openalex.org/W2998797425","https://openalex.org/W3164346236","https://openalex.org/W7164791031","https://openalex.org/W7139727883","https://openalex.org/W3122857957","https://openalex.org/W7054506085"],"abstract_inverted_index":{"Alongside":[0],"lively":[1],"philosophical":[2,205],"debate":[3],"about":[4,86,831,995,1057,2248,2442,2507,2618,2694,2762,3538,4553],"human":[5,127,165,389,477,513,542,571,927,1198,1674,2380,2774,3435,3773,3812,3820,3830,3851,4694],"dignity":[6,44,113,209,226,305,311,332,359,370,455,498,514,545,572,622,639,649,679,685,712,721,793,827,893,968,1001,1070,1133,1145,1288,1315,1328,1545,1630,1649,1670,1682,1741,1755,1837,1854,2202,2209,2631,2710,2741,2786,3166,3310,3371,3576,3793,4292,4308],"(Etinson,":[7],"2020;":[8,29],"Rosen,":[9],"2012),":[10],"several":[11,408,1774],"philosophers":[12,109,553,566],"have":[13,567,677,762,1134,1785,2087,2188,2235,2291,2701,2982,3237,3304,3492,3744,3853,3925,4390,4651],"begun":[14],"asking":[15],"whether":[16,323,3554,3593],"\"dignity\"":[17,150,470,864,1792,2671],"could":[18,163,432,2757,3123,3236,3578],"also":[19,46,326,676,687,761,836,920,1733,1871,2503,2732,3069,3189,3212,3256,4438],"illuminate":[20],"our":[21,537,1166,1169,2492,2673,2743,3182,3316,3751,3795,3946,4035,4079,4589,4607,4633],"moral":[22,119,181,237,607,644,664,776,911,1084,1119,1208,1247,1565,1608,1660,1759,1795,2539,2558,2660,2679,3131,3147,3327,3376,3423,3441,3489,3497,3540,3603,3628,3656,3682,3821,3939,3996,4168,4445,4498,4660],"relations":[23,1105],"with":[24,101,190,371,475,494,602,640,650,666,803,1042,1185,1618,1842,1851,1955,2021,2162,2174,2196,2243,2287,2318,2360,2772,2777,2918,2962,3126,3175,3660,3841,3920,3958,3986,4135,4359],"nonhuman":[25,696,1132,4696],"animals":[26,125,526,1258,1277,1363,1637,4050,4220,4262],"(e.g.,":[27,515,1846,2222],"Abbate,":[28],"Anderson,":[30],"2005;":[31],"Gruen,":[32],"2014;":[33],"Humphreys,":[34,705],"2016;":[35],"Nussbaum,":[36,720],"2006;":[37],"Ortiz,":[38],"2004).":[39],"Increasing":[40],"talk":[41,953],"of":[42,207,224,235,244,262,282,303,310,330,356,358,368,381,388,396,403,482,509,512,548,560,620,725,775,826,842,847,892,926,954,967,1000,1020,1032,1073,1083,1103,1131,1172,1295,1298,1314,1332,1359,1387,1412,1445,1502,1561,1576,1591,1603,1629,1694,1709,1726,1740,1754,1766,1816,1836,1847,1853,1896,1919,1935,1957,1971,2024,2115,2126,2149,2199,2363,2384,2397,2491,2541,2551,2598,2664,2667,2684,2698,2709,2740,2765,2785,2822,2829,3022,3064,3165,3195,3291,3315,3384,3408,3412,3418,3433,3466,3488,3523,3542,3544,3560,3575,3613,3627,3672,3769,3786,3792,3810,3819,3829,3862,3876,3954,3965,3983,4081,4112,4175,4198,4225,4256,4265,4307,4316,4324,4349,4362,4387,4403,4441,4456,4489,4516,4539,4597,4632,4659,4677],"animal":[43,170,208,225,304,369,397,544,621,638,728,792,1036,1058,1069,1235,1531,1710,2201,2220],"is":[45,77,83,95,114,188,194,202,210,276,325,334,360,471,507,573,597,698,748,800,814,828,835,1236,1256,1454,1569,1683,1686,1945,2028,2056,2390,2423,2427,2432,2447,2481,2583,2653,2996,3219,3255,3274,3318,3336,3350,3636,3664,3777,3799,3857,3869,3944,3991,4023,4057,4066,4087,4279,4310,4415,4503,4530,4544,4561,4569,4583,4625,4697],"occurring":[47],"in":[48,60,126,713,870,1071,1081,1100,1115,1232,1252,1259,1319,1499,1782,2112,2308,2366,2379,2452,2681,3199,3224,3329,3410,3517,3832,3866,4018,4040,4138,4314,4396,4518,4556,4640],"public":[49],"and":[50,117,129,198,239,265,274,287,344,406,479,543,557,600,605,626,691,716,735,778,787,799,846,849,881,913,916,922,929,1006,1039,1054,1075,1080,1097,1127,1140,1168,1192,1194,1197,1209,1279,1347,1362,1367,1463,1469,1495,1578,1613,1656,1745,1761,1793,1802,1861,1900,1910,1913,1924,2001,2064,2075,2094,2185,2263,2294,2415,2446,2499,2530,2605,2662,2672,2792,2802,2842,2862,2874,2886,2895,2925,2947,2970,2998,3002,3058,3084,3149,3203,3223,3288,3321,3356,3378,3388,3453,3504,3533,3547,3563,3641,3654,3705,3843,3859,3872,4008,4069,4227,4267,4327,4370,4384,4411,4427,4437,4443,4550,4564],"even":[51,336,535,659,899,1450,1584,2070,2095,2437,2586,2606,2978,3507,4685],"legal":[52],"discourse":[53],"(Kotzmann":[54],"&":[55],"Seery,":[56],"2017).":[57],"For":[58,563,719,817,898,1519,1804,1947,2207,2386,3425,3605,4026],"example,":[59,435,564,818,1520,3349,3426,3606],"a":[61,67,71,115,195,233,253,259,372,378,549,574,632,678,695,701,795,840,1013,1043,1161,1317,1330,1422,1427,1521,1625,1736,1886,1904,2082,2124,2163,2244,2271,2288,2306,2310,2313,2319,2391,2428,2505,2682,2781,2858,2865,2909,2916,2957,3020,3076,3121,3162,3192,3305,3431,3535,3557,3717,3906,3921,3955,3959,3962,4027,4067,4136,4147,4195,4253,4357,4373,4657,4693],"recent":[62,618],"habeas":[63],"corpus":[64],"hearing":[65],"for":[66,144,434,539,581,612,754,990,1190,1249,1338,1447,1539,1893,1915,2005,2060,2066,2273,2637,2735,3307,3345,3352,3420,3601,3737,3909,3936,3967,4017,4049,4144,4200,4338],"Bronx":[68],"Zoo":[69],"elephant,":[70],"Judge":[72],"declared":[73],"that":[74,112,191,227,257,333,338,349,391,469,497,523,534,570,577,591,615,658,750,791,822,863,889,931,949,969,1250,1272,1354,1460,1554,1699,1735,1833,1863,2013,2043,2088,2177,2233,2259,2284,2350,2407,2424,2494,2513,2627,2650,2670,2705,2737,2929,2980,3050,3071,3098,3119,3176,3181,3214,3226,3252,3270,3309,3335,3340,3380,3406,3481,3577,3588,3610,3633,3662,3669,3703,3724,3783,3803,3845,3849,3860,3881,3945,4033,4041,4084,4095,4120,4132,4219,4228,4236,4273,4280,4309,4382,4391,4408,4492,4502,4575,4586,4604,4611,4642,4674,4692],"the":[75,279,298,363,480,495,528,561,653,723,887,1018,1101,1275,1452,1472,1500,1547,1622,1641,1645,1691,1727,1747,1763,1790,1858,1894,1920,1925,1936,1968,1972,1991,1994,1998,2006,2019,2022,2025,2045,2051,2067,2113,2140,2160,2197,2223,2332,2339,2354,2361,2364,2387,2395,2408,2413,2425,2435,2463,2538,2552,2561,2584,2659,2695,2753,2763,2778,2834,2845,2851,2872,2889,2963,2990,3016,3039,3043,3153,3196,3200,3215,3244,3271,3280,3313,3326,3330,3346,3353,3362,3381,3385,3389,3413,3427,3449,3458,3479,3509,3539,3611,3614,3622,3639,3670,3692,3710,3741,3790,3808,3817,3827,3846,3913,3952,3968,3976,3979,3987,3994,4001,4011,4102,4118,4167,4172,4179,4189,4201,4257,4294,4325,4339,4346,4350,4385,4388,4401,4430,4490,4514,4527,4535,4540,4570,4617,4690],"elephant":[76],"\"a":[78],"dignified":[79,85],"creature\"":[80],"but":[81,518,834,1158,1396,1850,2062,2109,2166,3005,3188,4603],"\"there":[82],"nothing":[84,2074],"her":[87,1941,2147,2150,2158,2180,2242,2250,2261,2264,2269,2286,2293,2297,2469,2475,2804,2809,2826,2923,2937,3011,3060,3080,3292,3300,3634,3655,3661,3673,3929,3984,4145,4212],"captivity\"":[88],"(Wilson,":[89],"2022,":[90],"p.":[91,174,490,532,682,809,856,1108,1156,1178,1202,1226,1323,1383,1433,1489,1511,1830,1931,2039,2154,2205,2344,2401,2458,2479,2624,4245,4664],"4).":[92],"Such":[93,684,1095,1369,3471],"language":[94,1951,2711,3311],"perhaps":[96,519,1614,3068,3343,4010,4070,4186,4252],"beginning":[97],"to":[98,140,177,229,232,240,251,278,337,393,452,461,772,784,907,951,973,992,1125,1149,1165,1242,1282,1292,1349,1398,1420,1429,1632,1650,1659,1671,1690,1718,1720,1757,1762,1771,1780,1788,1939,1982,1989,1993,2009,2031,2172,2178,2225,2228,2238,2270,2368,2374,2420,2468,2471,2474,2483,2536,2594,2655,2678,2714,2789,2818,2850,2880,2922,2936,3028,3061,3079,3087,3160,3191,3239,3299,3323,3372,3529,3667,3680,3701,3806,3816,3892,3894,3912,4051,4074,4092,4117,4188,4241,4344,4509,4512,4526,4592,4616],"resonate":[99],"more":[100,350,445,458,603,804,974,1014,2562,3699,4071],"people":[102,136,1418,1784,2086,2629,2648,3248,3267,3762,3973],"than":[103,351,1111,1426,1966,4178],"it":[104,341,1041,1685,1712,1768,1954,2376,2686,2876,3338,3555,3663,3686,3697,3731,3779,3824,4045,4153,4161,4165,4477,4506,4594,4624],"once":[105],"did.":[106],"Nonetheless,":[107,858,1730,2281,3246],"some":[108,241,385,510,565,1214,1293,2175,2550,2628,2647,2665,2703,2724,3266,3589,3875,4106,4472,4631,4675],"seriously":[110],"doubt":[111,945,4059],"coherent":[116],"useful":[118],"idea":[120,496,2198,3480,4491,4691],"(Zuolo,":[121,807],"2016).":[122,706],"Dressing":[123],"circus-kept":[124],"clothes":[128,2381],"laughing":[130,2897],"at":[131,1589,1909,1912,2136,2312,2331,2353,2888,2898,3015,3264,3520,4109,4394,4533,4620],"them":[132,1087,2003,2017,2036,2049,2055,4053],"may":[133,419,686,943,977,1371,2534,2591,2675,3116,3179,3552,3721,3749,4003,4248,4354,4420,4432],"strike":[134,1864],"modern":[135],"as":[137,312,422,426,449,503,700,730,739,770,782,980,1147,1160,1213,1316,1329,1376,1442,1654,1663,1798,1857,1866,1922,1927,2337,2544,2808,2892,2900,3075,3103,3134,3140,3168,3766,3772,3814,3961,4006,4043,4127,4146,4365,4467,4486,4595,4613],"cruelly":[138],"demeaning":[139],"those":[141,933,1350,1975,2569,3113,3400,3467,3482,4139,4286,4417,4493,4557],"nonhumans.":[142,483,1128],"Yet":[143,3874],"critics,":[145,179],"these":[146,752,940,1051,1542,1809,2511,2542,2548,2557,2619],"apparent":[147,3897],"assaults":[148,3562],"on":[149,306,374,384,745,877,904,946,1310,1343,1546,1703,1773,1885,1974,2018,2035,2159,2394,2602,2796,2825,2871,2882,3242,3279,3448,3457,3638,3763,3899,4356,4372,4429,4471,4566],"are":[151,521,546,555,873,1407,1573,1587,1638,1814,2100,2712,2972,3184,3392,3461,3484,3501,3591,3644,4238,4271,4331,4400,4449,4681],"ethically":[152,353,1077],"trivial":[153],"or":[154,167,271,315,425,583,642,663,905,936,982,1065,1088,1118,1187,1238,1261,1340,1357,1379,1394,1484,1557,1658,1707,1952,1960,2053,2217,2227,2252,2370,2411,2450,2467,2522,2524,2580,2634,2749,3090,3105,3146,3170,3258,3416,3440,3477,3491,3494,3594,3598,3625,3753,3794,3927,4089,4125,4275,4284,4305,4464,4469,4474,4537,4581,4600,4647,4684,4695,4699],"else":[155],"merely":[156,423],"indirect":[157],"wrongs\u2014objectionable":[158],"only":[159,2926,3186,4290],"because":[160,2572,4034,4204,4398,4542,4623,4687],"such":[161,1653,1662,1797,1856,1950,2033,2194,2599,3120,3133,4281,4352,4364,4484],"treatment":[162,1356,1441,1453,2356,2409,2600,3383,3726,3809,4086,4096,4282,4485,4579,4612,4680],"upset":[164],"witnesses":[166],"generally":[168],"promote":[169,3597],"exploitation":[171],"(Martin,":[172],"2019,":[173],"94).":[175],"According":[176,3911],"dignity's":[178],"other":[180,236,242,1616,1758,3130,3756,3833,4180,4360,4473],"concepts":[182,238,806,976,1760],"can":[183,894,959,1240,1335,1437,1497,1524,1598,1742,2091,3838,4097,4221,4231,4609,4637,4654,4671],"far":[184],"better":[185,895],"explain":[186,4093,4171],"what":[187,1817,2690,2934,3993,4560,4576],"wrong":[189,2063,2232],"treatment.":[192,289,2501,2668,3172,3262,3549,4413],"Dignity":[193,431,484],"complex":[196],"notion":[197,256,1313],"providing":[199],"lucid":[200],"accounts":[201,871,1130],"challenging.":[203],"Furthermore,":[204,3263],"analysis":[206],"relatively":[211],"limited.":[212],"It":[213,985,1204,1985,3093,3565,4572],"warrants":[214],"greater":[215],"attention.":[216],"In":[217,362,963,1750,2255,2727,2811,3042,3173,3970,4210,4341],"this":[218,291,812,1021,1413,1533,2603,2728,2770,3253,3473,3747,3776,3882,3896,4022,4567],"paper,":[219],"I":[220,248,320,365,450,1024,1696,1731,1806,1818,1917,2730,2767,2981],"explore":[221,249],"an":[222,427,504,997,1234,1299,1529,1562,1605,1752,2372,2632,2643,2759,2797,2839,3784,4060,4302,4614],"understanding":[223,247,294,331,395,999,1046,1181,1628,1647,1753,2784,3325,3559,4174],"seems":[228,2687,3094,3339,3698,3891,4166,4478,4508,4667],"be":[230,252,420,457,692,971,978,988,1003,1336,1416,1907,1983,1987,2092,2358,2592,2676,2747,2758,2878,2949,2986,3124,3161,3208,3580,3619,3688,4004,4015,4222,4232,4249,4434,4629,4638],"irreducible":[231,335,404,998,1756],"range":[234,2683],"conceptions":[243,1668,1845],"dignity.":[245,763,955,1059,1695,2699,2766,3900],"The":[246,587,1060,1596,1822,1977,2102,2231,2327,2486,2904,3402,3525,3888,3941],"appears":[250,1981,3528,4574],"sui":[254,292,1044,1626,1642,1680,1737,2782],"generis":[255,293,1045,1627,1643,1681,1738,2783],"involves":[258,499,722],"special":[260,270,4552],"kind":[261,966,1331,1739,2229,3407,4197],"non-natural":[263],"harm":[264,273,1523,3287,4525],"assault":[266,275,1973,3898],"upon":[267,4405],"animals.":[268,540,2638,2793,3910,4287],"This":[269,347,506,885,1121,1180,2080,2582,3684,3835],"distinctive":[272,796,868,935,2579,3393],"related":[277,1794,2593,4068],"cognate":[280],"notions":[281,774],"defiling,":[283,2496,4044],"degrading,":[284,2497,3545],"demeaning,":[285,2498,3546],"dishonoring,":[286],"honoring":[288],"Presenting":[290],"requires":[295],"examining":[296,2689],"arguably":[297,1687,4300],"most":[299,2821],"compelling":[300,1868,3536],"current":[301],"account":[302,656,781,1067,1122,1549,1765,3364,3368,3404,3474,3527,3719,3890,4029],"offer\u2014a":[307],"\"relational\"":[308,328],"conception":[309,380,825,1031],"social":[313,379,439,1030,1061,1104,1210,1333,1548,1619,1623,1646,1692,1728,1748,1764,2754,2779,3363,3403,3414,3469,3526,3623,3718,3889,3914,3963,4028,4099,4142,4173,4196,4213,4295,4598,4645],"respect":[314,538,580,1064,1248,3490],"status.":[316,3470],"Although":[317,2532],"very":[318,4531],"important,":[319],"shall":[321,1697,1732,1807,2721,2768],"ask":[322,3553],"there":[324,520,2004,3500,3571,4065,4543],"another":[327,4319],"way":[329,355,2991,4042,4181],"account\u2014although":[339],"importantly":[340],"might":[342,456,820,860,919,1002,1123,2404,2692,3035,3048,3067,3211,3429,3687,3878,4031,4380],"complement":[343,1744],"deepen":[345,1746],"it.":[346,3584,4317],"suggests":[348,1353,2042,2349,2626],"one":[352,749,819,1026,2533,3013,3800],"important":[354,1005,1027,1673,2595,2718,2760,2798,3573,4061,4072,4303],"conceiving":[357],"possible.":[361],"following,":[364],"outline":[366],"criticisms":[367],"focus":[373,1772],"reductionist":[375,550,588,947],"attacks,":[376],"identify":[377,4593],"dignity,":[382,398,405,744,1767,2508,4176],"reflect":[383,1702],"key":[386],"examples":[387,1778,1852,2488,2543,4455],"behavior":[390,1215,1551,3197,3707],"seem":[392,1716],"facilitate":[394],"briefly":[399],"introduce":[400,2769],"positive":[401],"forms":[402,1386,2666,3574],"consider":[407,2723,2733],"objections,":[409],"before":[410],"concluding.":[411],"Like":[412,1621],"\"human":[413],"dignity\"":[414,418,655,769,4407],"(Cochrane,":[415],"2010),":[416],"\"animal":[417],"attacked":[421,4376],"rhetorical":[424],"excessively":[428],"indeterminate":[429],"concept.":[430,562],"mean,":[433],"inherent":[436,641,1301,1326,1607,1848,2215,2520,3091],"value,":[437,1327],"virtue,":[438],"rank,":[440],"bodily":[441,4465],"integrity,":[442],"autonomy\u2026and":[443],"much":[444],"(Schroeder,":[446],"2010).":[447],"However,":[448,1678,3550,3716],"attempt":[451],"do":[453,1474,3511,3568,4154],"below,":[454],"carefully":[459,2555],"specified":[460],"avoid":[462,524],"damaging":[463],"vagueness.":[464],"Some":[465,1385],"pro-animal":[466],"thinkers":[467],"worry":[468],"too":[472,866,1229,4024,4504],"closely":[473],"associated":[474],"higher":[476],"abilities":[478],"denigration":[481,4100],"talk,":[485],"says":[486,590,657],"Will":[487,2621,2863,3704],"Kymlicka":[488,2622],"(2018,":[489,2623],"771),":[491],"\"is":[492],"saturated":[493],"not":[500,829,1146,1455,1475,1588,1688,1714,1841,2029,2057,2106,2211,2247,2443,2448,2482,2706,2746,2932,3158,3185,3485,3512,3567,3579,3595,3618,3733,3781,3950,4239,4311,4450,4453,4461,4584],"being":[501,1112,2130,2444,2545,3240,3277],"treated":[502,1239,3221,3297,3854,4495],"animal.\"":[505],"true":[508],"analyses":[511],"Kateb,":[516],"2011),":[517],"approaches":[522],"throwing":[525],"\"under":[527],"bus\"":[529],"(Kymlicka,":[530],"2018,":[531],"779)\u2014and":[533],"enlarge":[536],"Both":[541],"targets":[547],"attack":[551,813],"by":[552,623,839,1035,1137,1724,2047,2133,2156,2240,2267,2275,2434,2547,2752,2800,3007,3054,3260,3276,3583,3621,3933],"who":[554,2814,2907],"dismissive":[556],"sometimes":[558,1743],"damning":[559],"forcefully":[568],"claimed":[569],"useless":[575],"concept":[576],"simply":[578,1390],"means":[579,703,1725,3078],"persons":[582],"autonomy":[584,662,3089,3229,3293],"(Macklin,":[585],"2003).":[586],"critic":[589],"\"dignity,\"":[592],"while":[593],"apparently":[594,1633,4077],"fine":[595],"sounding,":[596],"ultimately":[598],"uninformative":[599],"replaceable":[601],"fundamental":[604],"valuable":[606,1007,1078,1174,1374,1582,4149],"ideas.":[608],"Federico":[609],"Zuolo":[610,764,789],"(2016),":[611],"instance,":[613],"argues":[614],"reductionism":[616,3532],"undermines":[617],"characterizations":[619],"Michael":[624,766],"Meyer":[625,629],"Martha":[627,779],"Nussbaum.":[628],"(2001)":[630],"proposes":[631],"Kant-inspired":[633],"\"simple":[634,654,768],"dignity,\"":[635],"which":[636,872,1233,1783,2309,4076,4334],"identifies":[637],"intrinsic":[643,672,882,910,1564,1664,3422,3496,3677,3938,4497],"worth.":[645,673,1665,3092,3424,3604,3822,3940,4446,4499],"While":[646,3775],"Kant":[647],"connected":[648],"rational":[651,661],"autonomy,":[652,1657,3145],"without":[660,743,1532,3085,3864],"equality":[665],"humans,":[667,760],"sentient":[668],"nonhumans":[669],"nevertheless":[670],"possess":[671],"They":[674,2502,2884],"thus":[675,1205,1980,2295,3303,4573],"(Meyer,":[680],"2001,":[681,2343,2400,2457],"120).":[683],"ground":[688],"various":[689,726,1440,2218,2588,2715,3373,3847],"rights":[690,2221],"offended":[693,2296],"when":[694,1451,1585,1700,2097],"dignity-bearer":[697],"used":[699,4639],"mere":[702,1423,3077,3141],"(see":[704,1870],"Unlike":[707,1325],"Meyer,":[708],"Nussbaum":[709],"(2006)":[710],"locates":[711,1068],"natural":[714,727,755,785,832,878,914,1117,1594,1651,1898,2078,2213,2465,2609,3286,3514,3700,4524],"wellbeing":[715,833,879,1655],"species-typical":[717],"flourishing.":[718,756],"realization":[724],"capabilities\u2014such":[729],"emotional":[731],"expression,":[732],"play,":[733],"health,":[734],"relationships\u2014that":[736],"we":[737,859,942,1010,1345,1701,2720,3036,3047,3099,3115,3178,3210,3551,3586,3608,3743,3837,4289,4299,4379,4459,4481,4587,4605],"recognize":[738,4462],"important.":[740],"A":[741,2615],"life":[742,2226,2251,2262],"Nussbaum's":[746,780,823],"account,":[747,1287,2780,3915,4214,4297],"lacks":[751,794,2440],"possibilities":[753],"Thus,":[757,3152],"animals,":[758],"like":[759,909,1151,1903,2181,2527,4054],"attacks":[765],"Meyer's":[767],"reducible":[771,783,1148,1689,2713],"broad":[773],"considerability":[777],"living":[786,915],"wellbeing.":[788],"concludes":[790],"ethical":[797,1844,2564,2596],"meaning":[798,3027],"best":[801],"replaced":[802],"informative":[805],"2016,":[808,2153,2204],"1119).":[810],"Perhaps":[811,4021],"unfairly":[815],"reductionist.":[816],"say":[821,993,2406,3070,3213,3251,3365,3975,4218],"naturalistic":[824,2589],"just":[830,2058,3658],"partly":[837,4622,4683],"constituted":[838,3620],"sense":[841,3432,4511],"wonder":[843],"toward":[844,851,1086,1216,1221,1552,1676,4101],"flourishing":[845],"\"waste":[848],"tragedy\"":[850],"damaged":[852],"lives":[853],"(Nussbaum,":[854],"2006,":[855],"346).":[857],"still":[861,3722,3879,4507],"feel":[862,1890,2649,3180,3269,3723,3880],"does":[865,1713,2210,2931,3157,3727,3732,3780,3949],"little":[867,3493],"work":[869],"so":[874,1228,1280,2975,3150,3569,4494],"strongly":[875],"centered":[876],"(Nussbaum)":[880],"worth":[883,912,1090,1566,2521,3436,3771,3788,3828,3997,4348],"(Meyer).":[884],"raises":[886],"possibility":[888],"relational":[890,901,1028,1052,1162,2738],"understandings":[891,902,934,1053],"resist":[896,3530],"reductionism.":[897],"if":[900,1009,1417,2587,2607,3570,3730,4501],"depend":[903],"refer":[906],"features":[908,1543,2590],"wellbeing,":[917],"they":[918,1586,1882,2072,2335,2567,2573,2575,2691,2893,2901,3596,4121,4237,4399,4448,4688],"include":[921],"foreground":[923],"significant":[924,2608,3502,4254],"ways":[925,1072,1231,1358,1575,1602,3225,3848,4641],"relating":[928],"behaving":[930],"render":[932,1274],"special.":[937],"By":[938],"revealing":[939],"possibilities,":[941],"cast":[944,1372],"moves":[948],"seek":[950],"banish":[952],"Doing":[956],"so,":[957,3337,4064],"however,":[958,2641,3097,3943],"create":[960],"further":[961,2725],"problems.":[962],"particular,":[964],"any":[965,1503,1535,1593,2453,3676,3755],"cannot":[970,1011,2948,4014],"reduced":[972,3434,4601],"familiar":[975,2219,2563,2716,3375],"criticized":[979],"illusory":[981],"morally":[983,1004,1173,1283,1867,1942,2279,2578,2717,3037,4148,4548,4551,4562],"trivial.":[984],"will":[986,1047,1769,2731,2943,2977,3268],"therefore":[987,4046],"necessary":[989,2654,3322],"us":[991,1865,3877,4130],"something":[994,2577,4184,4545],"why":[996,4094,4259,4416,4480],"(even":[1008,3729],"provide":[1012],"extended":[1015],"defense":[1016],"within":[1017],"confines":[1019],"paper).":[1022],"Next,":[1023],"describe":[1025,1940,2657,3101],"account\u2014a":[1029],"dignity\u2014recently":[1033],"advanced":[1034],"philosophers.":[1037],"Comparing":[1038],"contrasting":[1040],"hopefully":[1048],"clarify":[1049,1967],"both":[1050,1667,2658,2790,3319],"advance":[1055],"discussion":[1056,2771],"(or":[1062,1244,4451,4588],"social-moral)":[1063],"status":[1066,4296],"presenting":[1074],"viewing":[1076,1360],"individuals":[1079,1553,3483],"expressions":[1082,1098],"(dis)respect":[1085],"their":[1089,1880,2098,3056,3421,3770,4113,4229,4269,4342],"(Anderson,":[1091],"2005,":[1092],"pp.":[1093,1267,1305,1404],"282\u2013283).":[1094],"presentations":[1096],"occur":[1099,1389,1498],"space":[1102],"(Bird,":[1106],"2013,":[1107],"161)":[1109],"rather":[1110,1159,1425,1965,4177],"principally":[1113,4686],"located":[1114],"either":[1116],"\"properties.\"":[1120],"apply":[1124],"humans":[1126,1217,1223,1361,2090,2791,4039],"Social":[1129],"been":[1135,2236,3026],"developed":[1136],"Lori":[1138],"Gruen":[1139,1143,1265],"C.E.":[1141],"Abbate.":[1142],"describes":[1144],"\"properties\"":[1150],"\"autonomous":[1152],"nature\"":[1153],"(Gruen,":[1154,1176,1200,1224],"2014,":[1155,1177,1201,1225],"232)":[1157],"property":[1163],"linked":[1164],"own":[1167,3081],"community's":[1170],"perception":[1171],"others":[1175,1375,4650],"234).":[1179,1203],"has":[1182,1206,2322,2908,3025,3675],"historical":[1183],"connections":[1184],"\"social":[1186,1195],"civic":[1188],"demands":[1189],"recognition":[1191,1560,3818],"respect\"":[1193,4242],"harmony":[1196],"fulfillment\"":[1199],"intertwined":[1207],"dimensions.":[1211],"Just":[1212],"\"reinforces":[1218],"negative":[1219],"attitudes\"":[1220],"certain":[1222,1230,1672,1704,4085,4261,4578],"235),":[1227],"presented":[1237],"tend":[1241],"undermine":[1243],"occasionally":[1245],"promote)":[1246,3735],"individual":[1251],"society.":[1253],"An":[1254],"example":[1255,1411,2104,3156,3164],"making":[1257],"zoos":[1260],"circuses":[1262],"appear":[1263,3159],"ridiculous.":[1264],"(2014,":[1266],"238\u2013239)":[1268],"cites":[1269],"zoo":[1270],"enclosures":[1271],"visibly":[1273],"contained":[1276],"pathetic":[1278],"difficult":[1281],"respect.":[1284],"On":[1285],"Abbate's":[1286,1492],"violations":[1289,3395,3503],"\"essentially":[1290],"amount":[1291],"form":[1294,1693,3314],"disrespectful":[1296,1355,1574,3768],"treatment\"":[1297],"individual's":[1300,1563],"value":[1302],"(Abbate,":[1303,1321,1381,1402,1431,1487,1509,4243],"2020,":[1304,1322,1382,1403,1432,1488,1510,4244],"771,":[1306],"776).":[1307,1512],"She":[1308,2951],"draws":[1309],"Jeremy":[1311],"Waldron's":[1312],"\"status\"":[1318],"society":[1320,2992,3804,3883],"772).":[1324,1490],"standing":[1334,4619],"affected":[1337],"good":[1339,3163],"ill":[1341,1537],"depending":[1342],"how":[1344],"treat":[1346,4052],"relate":[1348,1779,2568],"individuals.1":[1351],"Abbate":[1352,1458,4215],"constitute":[1364],"dignitary":[1365,1461,1493,1517,1522,2613,3394,3397,3561],"wrongs":[1366,1462,1468,1494,2417,3052],"harms.":[1368,1595,2079,3564],"behaviors":[1370,1572,1617,1675,3428,3590,4107],"intrinsically":[1373],"objects,":[1377],"instruments,":[1378],"tools":[1380],"777).":[1384],"disrespect":[1388,1414,1446,1597,3419,3600,3736,3935,3966,4048,4143,4199,4278,4337,4599,4646],"from,":[1391],"say,":[1392,1481,2462,2519],"inflicting,":[1393],"attempting":[1395],"failing":[1397],"inflict,":[1399],"unnecessary":[1400],"suffering":[1401,1483,1592,2265,3284,3956,4371,4428],"777\u2013778).":[1405],"Others":[1406],"instead":[1408,4224,4264],"culturally":[1409],"created\u2014an":[1410],"would":[1415,1963,1986,2014,2187,2234,2290,2877,3100,3249,3361,3566,3924,3974,4482],"were":[1419,3572],"assign":[1421],"number":[1424],"name":[1428],"children":[1430],"779).":[1434],"Our":[1435,3901],"cultures":[1436,3852],"help":[1438,1770],"determine":[1439],"profoundly":[1443],"expressive":[1444,4115,4392,4440,4488,4596],"others'":[1448],"worth,":[1449,1609,2216,3148],"otherwise":[1456],"harmful.":[1457],"claims":[1459],"harms":[1464,1470,1496,1507,1514,2610,3398,3505,3515],"differ":[1465],"from":[1466,1516,1526,1600,1610,1615,1839,2515,2560,2966,3691],"\"ordinary\"":[1467],"since":[1471,2941,3630],"former":[1473],"themselves":[1476],"damage":[1477,3227],"\"experiential\"":[1478],"welfare":[1479,1506],"by,":[1480],"causing":[1482,1534,3059],"preventing":[1485],"satisfaction":[1486],"Indeed,":[1491,2566],"absence":[1501],"ordinary":[1504,1536],"harm\u2014non-experiential":[1505],"included2":[1508],"Dignitary":[1513],"follow":[1515,3782],"violations.":[1518],"result":[1525],"contemptuously":[1527],"mocking":[1528],"oblivious":[1530],"effects":[1538],"them.":[1540,4422],"Bringing":[1541],"together:":[1544],"concerns":[1550,2105],"socially":[1555,3708,3712,3734,3825,4114,4276],"promotes":[1556],"expresses":[1558,4047,4141,4194],"insufficient":[1559],"(however":[1567],"\"worth\"":[1568],"understood).":[1570],"These":[1571,1777,1812,2639],"wronging":[1577],"(perhaps)":[1579],"thereby":[1580,2416],"harming":[1581],"individuals,":[1583],"risk":[1590],"stem":[1599],"cultural":[1601],"marking":[1604],"animal's":[1606],"showing":[1611],"contempt,":[1612],"overtones.3":[1620],"conception,":[1624],"relates":[1631,2305],"distinctive\u2014but":[1634],"often":[1635,2611],"ignored\u2014ways":[1636],"treated.":[1639],"Neither":[1640],"nor":[1644],"reduces":[1648],"features,":[1652],"properties,":[1661],"Instead,":[1666,3823],"link":[1669],"individuals.":[1677,3401],"although":[1679],"relational,":[1684],"suggest":[1698,1734,3587],"telling":[1705,1775],"experiences":[1706,1781],"descriptions":[1708],"treatment,":[1711],"always":[1715,2748],"possible":[1717,2696],"explain\u2014or":[1719],"fully":[1721,2750,3324,3486,4312],"explain\u2014those":[1722],"phenomena":[1723,1869,2559],"account.":[1729,2755],"conception.":[1749],"outlining":[1751],"examples.":[1776,2620,2775,3359],"felt":[1786],"compelled":[1787],"employ":[1789],"term":[1791,1937,2636],"terms":[1796,1810,3411,4315,4635],"\"degrade,\"":[1799],"\"defile,\"":[1800],"\"demean,\"":[1801],"\"dishonor.\"":[1803],"convenience,":[1805],"call":[1808,1819],"d-terms.":[1811],"d-terms":[1813,2744,3796],"part":[1815,4111,4255,4397],"\"dignity":[1820,2651],"language.\"":[1821],"approach":[1823],"here":[1824,1979,3506],"tracks":[1825],"Kaufmann":[1826],"et":[1827],"al.'s":[1828],"(2011,":[1829],"24:2)":[1831],"suggestion":[1832],"conceptual":[1834],"investigation":[1835],"profits":[1838],"starting":[1840],"abstract":[1843],"worth)":[1849],"violations,":[1855,3462],"degradations,":[1859],"defilements,":[1860],"humiliations":[1862],"Luban,":[1872],"2009;":[1873],"Margalit,":[1874],"1998).":[1875],"sport":[1876],"brightly-colored":[1877],"clown":[1878],"collars\u2026In":[1879],"paws":[1881],"clutch":[1883],"balloons,":[1884],"string\u2026It":[1887],"makes":[1888,3905,4577],"me":[1889,2960],"sorry,":[1891],"embarrassed":[1892],"bear\u2026stripped":[1895],"its":[1897,3886],"nakedness,":[1899],"dressed":[1901],"up":[1902],"clown.":[1905],"To":[1906,3207,4628],"looked":[1908],"laughed":[1911],"photographed":[1914],"tourists.":[1916],"think":[1918,3049,3118,3702,4381,4513],"bear":[1921],"defiled,":[1923],"photographer":[1926],"pimp":[1928],"(Cataldi,":[1929],"2002,":[1930],"106).":[1932],"Cataldi's":[1933],"choice":[1934],"\"defiled\"":[1938],"unsettling":[1943],"experience":[1944,2073],"noteworthy.":[1946],"Cataldi,":[1948],"rejecting":[1949],"substituting":[1953],"ideas":[1956,3377],"physical":[1958],"cruelty":[1959],"diminished":[1961,3713],"flourishing,":[1962,2529],"obscure":[1964],"full":[1969,3193,3558],"nature":[1970,2661],"bears.":[1976],"violation":[1978,3290,3409],"\"non-natural.\"":[1984],"simpler":[1988],"cart":[1990],"bags":[1992],"incinerator":[1995,2007],"immediately":[1996],"after":[1997,2939],"[killing]":[1999],"session":[2000],"leave":[2002],"crew":[2008],"dispose":[2010,3029],"of.":[2011,3030],"But":[2012,4251,4378,4447],"mean":[2015],"leaving":[2016,2048],"dump":[2020],"rest":[2023],"weekend's":[2026],"scourings\u2026He":[2027],"prepared":[2030],"inflict":[2032],"dishonour":[2034],"(Coetzee,":[2037],"1999,":[2038],"144).":[2040],"Coetzee":[2041],"dishonoring":[2044,2195,2500],"corpses5":[2046],"amongst":[2050],"rubbish":[2052,3023,3281,3459,3764,3867],"beating":[2054],"distressing":[2059],"Lurie,":[2061],"bad":[2065],"dead":[2068,2089,2994,3272,3615,3761,3811,3855,4389,4528],"dogs,":[2069],"though":[2071,2183,2438,3342,3508],"suffer":[2076,3062,3513],"no":[2077,2944,3285,3289,4058,4523],"parallels":[2081],"conviction":[2083],"many":[2084,3247,3972],"(most?)":[2085],"wronged":[2093],"harmed":[2096,2433,2451],"bodies":[2099,2995,3813,3856,3863,4555],"\"desecrated.\"":[2101],"next":[2103],"post-mortem":[2107],"indignity,":[2108],"putative":[2110],"indignity":[2111],"act":[2114,4002,4206],"killing.":[2116],"Cat":[2117],"shovel":[2118,2245,2289,3903,3922,3960,4137],"case:":[2119,2301,4191],"Philosopher":[2120,2302],"Raimond":[2121],"Gaita":[2122,2144,2191,2257,3917],"tells":[2123,2952,3534],"story":[2125,3537],"his":[2127,2134,2137,3228,3261,3651,4205],"cat":[2128,3902,3957,3981],"Tosca":[2129,2167,2239,3919,4134],"mortally":[2131],"wounded":[2132],"dog":[2135],"home.":[2138],"Witnessing":[2139],"cat's":[2141,3995,4012],"terrible":[2142,4436,4549,4563],"suffering,":[2143,2528],"considers":[2145],"\"putting":[2146],"out":[2148,2828,2870,2961,3063],"misery\"":[2151,3985],"(Gaita,":[2152,2203],"94)":[2155],"hitting":[2157],"head":[2161],"near-to-hand":[2164],"shovel,":[2165],"disappears.":[2168],"Later,":[2169],"he":[2170,2282,3024,3231,3235,3923,3931],"comes":[2171,3805],"realize":[2173],"shock":[2176],"kill":[2179],"that,":[2182],"painless":[2184],"merciful,":[2186],"dishonored":[2189,2292],"her.":[2190,2254,2418,4209],"explicitly":[2192],"connects":[2193],"assaulting":[2200],"35).":[2206],"Gaita,":[2208],"concern":[2212,2506,2516],"welfare,":[2214],"right":[2224],"treatment).":[2230],"done":[2237],"striking":[2241],"was":[2246,2278,3296],"ending":[2249,2260],"hurting":[2253],"fact,":[2256,3971],"believed":[2258,2283],"(perhaps":[2266],"taking":[2268],"veterinarian":[2272],"euthanasia":[2274],"lethal":[2276],"injection)":[2277],"right.":[2280],"killing":[2285,3953,4038,4133],"dignity.6":[2298],"Baboon":[2299],"ridicule":[2300,2436],"Cora":[2303],"Diamond":[2304,2348,2403],"scene7":[2307],"worker":[2311],"Head":[2314],"Injury":[2315],"Lab":[2316],"poses":[2317],"baboon":[2320,2414,2426],"\"who":[2321],"massive":[2323],"cranial":[2324],"hemispherical":[2325],"sutures.\"":[2326],"lab":[2328],"staff":[2329],"\"laugh":[2330],"animal,":[2333,2373],"whom":[2334],"tease":[2336],"having":[2338],"'punk'":[2340],"look\"":[2341],"(Diamond,":[2342,2399,2456],"148,":[2345],"fn":[2346],"41).":[2347],"\"moral":[2351],"disgust\"":[2352],"baboon's":[2355,2464],"\"may":[2357],"compared":[2359],"response":[2362],"Dayaks":[2365],"Borneo":[2367],"ridiculing":[2369],"humiliating":[2371],"dressing":[2375],"(for":[2377],"example)":[2378],"'in":[2382],"parody":[2383],"humanity'.\"":[2385],"Dayaks,":[2388],"\"this":[2389],"great":[2392,4425],"crime,":[2393],"level":[2396,4358],"incest\"":[2398],"137).":[2402,2459],"well":[2405,3117],"demeans":[2410],"degrades":[2412,4285],"Essential":[2419],"Diamond's":[2421,2484],"point":[2422,2617,2887,3908,4073],"genuine":[2429],"victim:":[2430],"she":[2431,2439,2930,2942],"desires":[2441],"humiliated":[2445],"violated":[2449],"\"naturalistic":[2454],"sense\"":[2455],"Damage":[2460],"to,":[2461],"capabilities,":[2466],"ability":[2470],"flourish":[2472],"according":[2473,3298],"telos":[2476],"(Schultz-Bergin,":[2477],"2017,":[2478],"844),":[2480],"point.8":[2485],"above":[2487,2553,3040],"highlight":[2489,2504],"uses":[2490],"\"d-terms,\"":[2493],"is,":[2495,4105,4159],"understood":[2509,3167],"via":[2510,4293],"terms,":[2512,3114],"differs":[2514,3690],"focused":[2517],"on,":[2518],"rights,":[2523],"\"natural\"":[2525],"properties":[2526],"autonomy.":[2531,3524],"choose":[2535,4421],"interpret":[2537],"import":[2540],"underpinned":[2546],"notions,9":[2549],"authors":[2554],"distinguish":[2556],"categories.":[2565],"scenes":[2570],"precisely":[2571],"believe":[2574,3668],"reveal":[2576],"unique.":[2581],"case":[2585,3519,3695,3904],"aspects":[2597],"(more":[2601],"later)":[2604],"accompany":[2612],"assaults.":[2614],"final":[2616],"770)":[2625],"find":[2630],"\"awkward":[2633]},"counts_by_year":[{"year":2026,"cited_by_count":2},{"year":2025,"cited_by_count":4},{"year":2024,"cited_by_count":4}],"updated_date":"2026-10-30T12:39:25.321706","created_date":"2023-07-25T00:00:00"}