{"id":"https://openalex.org/W4313639593","doi":"https://doi.org/10.14321/crnewcentrevi.22.1.0157","title":"Prosthetic Symbiosis","display_name":"Prosthetic Symbiosis","publication_year":2022,"publication_date":"2022-03-01","ids":{"openalex":"https://openalex.org/W4313639593","doi":"https://doi.org/10.14321/crnewcentrevi.22.1.0157"},"language":"en","primary_location":{"id":"doi:10.14321/crnewcentrevi.22.1.0157","doi":"https://doi.org/10.14321/crnewcentrevi.22.1.0157","is_oa":false,"landing_page_url":"https://doi.org/10.14321/crnewcentrevi.22.1.0157","pdf_url":null,"source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S995569539","display_name":"CR The New Centennial Review","issn_l":"1532-687X","issn":["1532-687X","1539-6630"],"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":false,"listed_in":["anvur-scientific","jufo-1","norway-1","poland-70","russia-white-list-2"],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/P4310315741","host_organization_name":"Michigan State University Press","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/P4310315741"],"host_organization_lineage_names":["Michigan State University Press"],"type":"journal"},"license":null,"license_id":null,"version":"publishedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":true,"raw_source_name":"CR: The New Centennial Review","raw_type":"journal-article"},"volume":null,"type":"article","indexed_in":["crossref"],"open_access":{"is_oa":false,"oa_status":"closed","oa_url":null,"any_repository_has_fulltext":false},"authorships":[{"author_position":"first","author":{"id":"https://openalex.org/A5020095141","display_name":"Derek Woods","orcid":null,"observed_orcids":[]},"institutions":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/I98251732","display_name":"McMaster University","ror":"https://ror.org/02fa3aq29","country_code":"CA","type":"education","lineage":["https://openalex.org/I98251732"]}],"countries":["CA"],"is_corresponding":true,"raw_author_name":"Derek Woods","raw_affiliation_strings":["McMaster University"],"raw_orcid":null,"affiliations":[{"raw_affiliation_string":"McMaster University","institution_ids":["https://openalex.org/I98251732"]}]}],"institutions":[],"countries_distinct_count":1,"institutions_distinct_count":1,"corresponding_author_ids":["https://openalex.org/A5020095141"],"corresponding_institution_ids":["https://openalex.org/I98251732"],"apc_list":null,"apc_paid":null,"fwci":4.325,"has_fulltext":false,"cited_by_count":14,"citation_normalized_percentile":{"value":0.94864006,"is_in_top_1_percent":false,"is_in_top_10_percent":true},"cited_by_percentile_year":{"min":89,"max":100},"biblio":{"volume":"22","issue":"1","first_page":"157","last_page":"186"},"is_retracted":false,"is_paratext":false,"is_xpac":false,"primary_topic":{"id":"https://openalex.org/T13308","display_name":"Cybernetics and Technology in Society","score":0.4657999873161316,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1207","display_name":"History and Philosophy of Science"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/12","display_name":"Arts and Humanities"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},"topics":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/T13308","display_name":"Cybernetics and Technology in Society","score":0.4657999873161316,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1207","display_name":"History and Philosophy of Science"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/12","display_name":"Arts and Humanities"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},{"id":"https://openalex.org/T10778","display_name":"Philosophy and History of Science","score":0.1826000064611435,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1207","display_name":"History and Philosophy of Science"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/12","display_name":"Arts and Humanities"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},{"id":"https://openalex.org/T10738","display_name":"Posthumanist Ethics and Activism","score":0.057500001043081284,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/3316","display_name":"Cultural Studies"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/33","display_name":"Social Sciences"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}}],"keywords":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/symbiosis","display_name":"symbiosis","score":0.9700000286102295},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/symbiogenesis","display_name":"symbiogenesis","score":0.9879999756813049},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/horizontal-gene-transfer","display_name":"horizontal gene transfer","score":0.7799999713897705},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/lichens","display_name":"lichens","score":0.6830000281333923},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/mycorrhizal-fungi","display_name":"mycorrhizal fungi","score":0.9229999780654907},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/evolutionary-novelty","display_name":"evolutionary innovation","score":0.5709999799728394},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/tree-of-life","display_name":"tree of life","score":0.4860000014305115},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/endosymbionts","display_name":"endosymbionts","score":0.5199999809265137},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/prokaryotes","display_name":"prokaryotes","score":0.4659999907016754},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/eukaryotes","display_name":"eukaryotes","score":0.503000020980835},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/mutualism","display_name":"mutualism","score":0.32600000500679016},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/parasitism","display_name":"parasitism","score":0.921999990940094},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/lynn-margulis","display_name":"Lynn Margulis","score":0.8510000109672546}],"concepts":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/C43144210","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q121610","display_name":"Symbiosis","level":3,"score":0.6163185834884644},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C127313418","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q1069","display_name":"Geology","level":0,"score":0.23945441842079163},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C151730666","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q7205","display_name":"Paleontology","level":1,"score":0.0762629508972168},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C523546767","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q10876","display_name":"Bacteria","level":2,"score":0.06548535823822021}],"mesh":[],"locations_count":2,"locations":[{"id":"doi:10.14321/crnewcentrevi.22.1.0157","doi":"https://doi.org/10.14321/crnewcentrevi.22.1.0157","is_oa":false,"landing_page_url":"https://doi.org/10.14321/crnewcentrevi.22.1.0157","pdf_url":null,"source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S995569539","display_name":"CR The New Centennial Review","issn_l":"1532-687X","issn":["1532-687X","1539-6630"],"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":false,"listed_in":["anvur-scientific","jufo-1","norway-1","poland-70","russia-white-list-2"],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/P4310315741","host_organization_name":"Michigan State University Press","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/P4310315741"],"host_organization_lineage_names":["Michigan State University Press"],"type":"journal"},"license":null,"license_id":null,"version":"publishedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":true,"raw_source_name":"CR: The New Centennial Review","raw_type":"journal-article"},{"id":"pmh:oai:muse.jhu.edu:/article/874474","doi":null,"is_oa":false,"landing_page_url":"https://muse.jhu.edu/pub/26/article/874474","pdf_url":null,"source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S4377196299","display_name":"Project Muse (Johns Hopkins University)","issn_l":null,"issn":null,"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":false,"listed_in":[],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/I145311948","host_organization_name":"Johns Hopkins University","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/I145311948"],"host_organization_lineage_names":[],"type":"repository"},"license":null,"license_id":null,"version":"submittedVersion","is_accepted":false,"is_published":false,"raw_source_name":"","raw_type":"text"}],"best_oa_location":null,"sustainable_development_goals":[],"sustainable_development_goals_aurora":[],"study_designs":[],"awards":[],"funders":[],"has_content":{"pdf":false,"grobid_xml":false},"content_urls":null,"referenced_works_count":45,"referenced_works":["https://openalex.org/W176458337","https://openalex.org/W361715151","https://openalex.org/W561221116","https://openalex.org/W589722103","https://openalex.org/W596898432","https://openalex.org/W1483945426","https://openalex.org/W1510936538","https://openalex.org/W1551804795","https://openalex.org/W1629105406","https://openalex.org/W1916207017","https://openalex.org/W1964306176","https://openalex.org/W1995174848","https://openalex.org/W2032498967","https://openalex.org/W2132212565","https://openalex.org/W2164278327","https://openalex.org/W2169651905","https://openalex.org/W2528415436","https://openalex.org/W2610143713","https://openalex.org/W2617369555","https://openalex.org/W2618944847","https://openalex.org/W2790318023","https://openalex.org/W2796527002","https://openalex.org/W3028425781","https://openalex.org/W3077872740","https://openalex.org/W3121982615","https://openalex.org/W3135864904","https://openalex.org/W3145563855","https://openalex.org/W3199459280","https://openalex.org/W3209029592","https://openalex.org/W3214949894","https://openalex.org/W3215746001","https://openalex.org/W4205431088","https://openalex.org/W4230385535","https://openalex.org/W4230654387","https://openalex.org/W4235669254","https://openalex.org/W4243937523","https://openalex.org/W4249883514","https://openalex.org/W4250101496","https://openalex.org/W4289810510","https://openalex.org/W4300750523","https://openalex.org/W4304183639","https://openalex.org/W4312867191","https://openalex.org/W4388331297","https://openalex.org/W4393083029","https://openalex.org/W7039559731"],"related_works":["https://openalex.org/W4388228117","https://openalex.org/W819173789","https://openalex.org/W7100284715","https://openalex.org/W7055333870","https://openalex.org/W1759691579","https://openalex.org/W2498122497","https://openalex.org/W3135274450","https://openalex.org/W2095459472","https://openalex.org/W4231954854","https://openalex.org/W4388246200"],"abstract_inverted_index":{"Symbiosis":[0,958,1106,1928,2183,2201,3104,9525,9567,9807],"refers":[1,194,335,2748],"to":[2,54,195,209,213,336,365,376,395,470,488,496,532,575,627,663,753,825,842,893,903,919,938,954,1024,1075,1081,1188,1193,1388,1406,1463,1514,1525,1556,1579,1591,1596,1604,1619,1630,1638,1683,1698,1704,1733,1849,1901,1967,1979,1987,1999,2087,2095,2199,2214,2371,2374,2399,2419,2433,2442,2491,2565,2590,2749,2771,2794,2803,2852,2956,3042,3073,3100,3109,3144,3207,3229,3239,3250,3293,3317,3377,3391,3397,3429,3435,3473,3504,3571,3580,3598,3613,3669,3739,3775,3777,3800,3808,3816,3858,3897,3920,3932,4087,4100,4124,4135,4193,4256,4260,4281,4298,4382,4437,4461,4491,4511,4607,4614,4688,4726,4772,4778,4823,4854,4872,4874,4907,4986,5055,5085,5093,5110,5160,5204,5212,5273,5280,5297,5313,5348,5354,5367,5410,5445,5469,5507,5540,5600,5679,5720,5767,5842,5859,5993,6029,6213,6345,6370,6486,6508,6571,6630,6639,6753,6847,6866,6959,6987,7073,7126,7136,7142,7158,7185,7196,7227,7240,7429,7511,7542,7564,7610,7631,7665,7678,7766,7789,7967,7989,8074,8081,8096,8148,8176,8213,8274,8425,8480,8518,8535,8607,8621,8655,8680,8706,8719,8725,8756,8761,8774,9098,9206,9334,9364,9386,9391,9396,9400,9424,9518,9589,9627,9697,9714,9724,9733,9758,9805,9824],"intimate":[3,2415],"relations":[4,606,791,1080,2265,6879,7068,7839,7892,7919,8265,8347,8749,9561],"between":[5,18,29,536,607,615,666,931,1102,1435,1446,1914,1929,1931,1935,2138,2601,2775,3406,3749,3870,3937,4421,4445,4742,5077,5380,5395,5494,5514,5583,5706,6172,6574,6584,6691,6893,6923,6933,7031,7360,7477,7742,7757,7769,7803,7864,7880,7889,7893,7927,7960,8208,8779,8808,9094,9101,9557,9629],"life":[6,687,708,800,899,1062,1404,1469,1766,1847,2260,2655,3381,3985,4447,5040,5381,5424,5515,5664,5730,6182,6316,6697,6935,7364,7505,7618,7859,8067,8098,8409],"forms":[7,688,801,1069,1848,2261,3125,3986,4400,4420,5294,6936,7619],"that":[8,37,56,252,274,390,474,514,552,571,636,724,734,820,864,875,1139,1153,1183,1231,1240,1283,1305,1352,1368,1444,1498,1535,1574,1680,1760,1791,1875,1905,2018,2054,2100,2191,2505,2542,2607,2628,2654,2665,2755,2811,2828,2912,2950,2988,2990,2997,3087,3150,3210,3234,3252,3260,3338,3512,3527,3535,3583,3771,3782,3834,3885,3895,3942,4166,4209,4214,4288,4316,4345,4358,4385,4419,4454,4470,4484,4497,4509,4573,4586,4601,4645,4655,4762,4799,4862,4882,4923,4981,4994,5032,5051,5147,5157,5197,5236,5284,5300,5620,5838,5869,5960,5971,6021,6057,6078,6121,6129,6194,6287,6313,6330,6341,6413,6427,6449,6456,6522,6537,6698,6822,6844,6901,6949,7020,7028,7069,7085,7094,7160,7177,7199,7224,7260,7271,7281,7352,7380,7395,7549,7568,7604,7617,7660,7676,7731,7775,7818,7903,7910,7948,7970,8065,8085,8143,8362,8387,8528,8555,8592,8598,8646,8653,8717,8797,8881,8950,8966,8982,8991,9005,9039,9241,9285,9301,9408,9480,9591,9635,9707,9793],"involve":[9],"strong":[10],"interdependence.":[11],"Some":[12,293,1395],"well-known":[13],"examples":[14,48,96,1313,2652,2906,3132,3253,5233,6927],"are":[15,57,68,74,130,174,297,443,468,556,601,802,876,968,1031,1310,1320,1333,1762,1771,1781,1918,2262,2862,2921,2941,2999,3005,3011,3136,3155,3199,3214,3340,3590,3773,3855,3960,4588,5186,5481,5518,5893,5903,6227,6271,6541,6721,7095,7166,7451,7503,7509,7821,8170,8271,8628,9471],"the":[16,26,35,47,63,66,117,135,142,146,190,233,300,317,342,359,472,522,534,539,550,565,618,683,693,729,793,827,846,859,870,885,894,904,912,929,977,980,987,998,1000,1034,1100,1174,1189,1213,1220,1241,1257,1278,1293,1323,1392,1397,1459,1464,1468,1471,1485,1547,1551,1554,1557,1588,1598,1620,1625,1631,1649,1672,1696,1721,1725,1728,1743,1749,1754,1824,1844,1855,1873,1897,1911,1942,1996,2072,2079,2107,2134,2139,2143,2152,2170,2189,2207,2234,2243,2254,2356,2363,2367,2382,2400,2411,2420,2429,2448,2475,2481,2511,2530,2535,2547,2568,2577,2588,2592,2605,2626,2629,2637,2682,2691,2709,2713,2719,2729,2739,2758,2762,2790,2812,2868,2888,2926,2945,2962,3026,3033,3111,3120,3148,3162,3169,3179,3208,3225,3258,3333,3415,3422,3430,3445,3524,3553,3573,3581,3616,3641,3662,3677,3680,3702,3724,3732,3750,3809,3914,3934,3969,4009,4029,4050,4060,4080,4085,4097,4106,4112,4150,4160,4169,4195,4210,4217,4319,4346,4360,4383,4395,4407,4417,4426,4438,4479,4505,4530,4544,4557,4563,4574,4592,4640,4647,4691,4700,4727,4736,4759,4790,4858,4885,4932,4936,4948,4959,4965,4976,4979,5030,5033,5049,5057,5078,5082,5102,5137,5166,5182,5213,5254,5282,5298,5314,5390,5402,5451,5492,5501,5574,5604,5621,5627,5631,5634,5638,5661,5667,5680,5688,5696,5703,5707,5710,5712,5721,5724,5737,5742,5745,5753,5768,5775,5791,5813,5826,5836,5850,5886,5891,5897,5925,5933,5938,5941,5945,5957,5985,5988,6010,6030,6043,6046,6050,6055,6064,6076,6096,6099,6109,6113,6149,6153,6184,6187,6191,6214,6232,6238,6247,6261,6296,6299,6302,6331,6347,6351,6363,6371,6375,6395,6399,6411,6415,6429,6451,6481,6520,6525,6528,6547,6555,6569,6579,6590,6598,6620,6633,6642,6694,6719,6724,6738,6761,6765,6781,6787,6799,6861,6872,6881,6898,6903,6907,6912,6929,6947,6954,6980,6998,7014,7026,7053,7080,7089,7092,7105,7109,7161,7174,7197,7205,7218,7222,7229,7237,7241,7302,7305,7324,7341,7346,7358,7391,7423,7430,7459,7478,7489,7494,7520,7531,7547,7565,7625,7632,7635,7651,7658,7679,7716,7740,7767,7776,7797,7819,7836,7899,7914,7925,7946,7957,7968,7974,8004,8026,8032,8045,8050,8075,8082,8110,8113,8150,8206,8215,8250,8283,8291,8311,8325,8331,8340,8354,8360,8363,8367,8390,8411,8415,8445,8449,8452,8497,8502,8507,8514,8519,8529,8537,8543,8563,8604,8616,8633,8636,8729,8733,8769,8777,8793,8806,8835,8841,8847,8850,8853,8856,8864,8910,8947,8956,8961,8980,8985,8988,9001,9020,9026,9037,9040,9044,9092,9099,9130,9136,9139,9144,9162,9175,9183,9188,9207,9221,9238,9265,9291,9296,9304,9338,9357,9367,9376,9432,9436,9459,9464,9492,9503,9508,9550,9595,9613,9630,9642,9648,9656,9670,9690,9705,9715,9725,9735,9739,9753,9762,9765,9772,9786,9816,9828],"associations":[17,53],"flowers":[19],"and":[20,23,31,33,65,77,86,128,162,183,215,240,249,280,303,345,353,402,412,429,464,480,538,547,590,609,644,668,676,727,738,745,805,829,850,901,914,933,944,947,952,979,1079,1092,1104,1142,1165,1178,1206,1215,1268,1274,1308,1362,1376,1437,1440,1449,1484,1532,1615,1627,1690,1715,1727,1823,1888,1916,1922,1933,1937,1952,1957,1985,2032,2061,2129,2132,2145,2162,2257,2322,2343,2362,2386,2405,2445,2465,2488,2496,2603,2622,2662,2684,2701,2760,2777,2834,2848,2855,2875,2887,2892,2901,2928,2974,3022,3029,3037,3060,3095,3116,3128,3138,3152,3173,3183,3188,3192,3244,3269,3297,3312,3322,3350,3404,3408,3412,3463,3485,3541,3544,3556,3685,3698,3754,3819,3847,3861,3887,3893,3939,3950,3958,3966,4018,4023,4068,4111,4139,4182,4314,4375,4423,4554,4562,4604,4612,4631,4643,4704,4712,4732,4744,4789,4828,4851,4952,4961,5096,5101,5162,5184,5276,5356,5382,5392,5397,5443,5455,5496,5516,5537,5570,5586,5633,5709,5749,5763,5787,5965,5978,6037,6104,6155,6190,6201,6222,6241,6253,6337,6463,6500,6514,6582,6603,6623,6636,6654,6661,6671,6692,6704,6811,6868,6877,6906,6917,6928,6974,6993,7038,7156,7188,7212,7405,7407,7433,7474,7482,7485,7499,7506,7530,7553,7571,7590,7612,7655,7693,7703,7744,7771,7781,7815,7825,7866,7882,7898,7930,7951,7962,8009,8023,8030,8089,8102,8131,8138,8154,8173,8186,8192,8210,8247,8315,8353,8378,8392,8408,8420,8432,8463,8468,8495,8548,8624,8641,8649,8685,8697,8700,8714,8737,8764,8782,8800,8802,8810,8896,8914,8994,9056,9087,9096,9104,9150,9158,9186,9212,9247,9264,9277,9299,9312,9336,9350,9372,9399,9412,9431,9445,9466,9474,9485,9487,9513,9536,9559,9597,9609,9621,9633,9645,9673,9721,9745,9749,9801,9818],"bees,":[21,8244],"fungi":[22,30,1014,2788,2861,4069,4103,4120,4422,5150,5185,5238,7448],"tree":[24,360,380,411,3517,7307],"roots,":[25,8970],"lichen":[27,1650,1729,4575,7206,7230],"symbiosis":[28,98,144,192,217,259,331,439,454,624,816,921,1126,1164,1205,1226,1265,1369,1401,1422,1462,1833,1876,1913,2014,2040,2066,2122,2155,2240,2352,2385,2437,2454,2602,2687,2735,2767,2883,2931,2979,3038,3071,3364,3441,3453,3483,3635,3648,3675,3721,3787,3927,3957,4004,4202,4213,4249,4304,4350,4444,4485,4576,4616,4695,4781,4818,4834,4850,4910,4951,5275,5396,5406,5607,6583,6802,6833,6930,6958,6984,7003,7427,7644,7685,7698,7755,7965,8057,8809,9055,9263,9351,9383,9426,9520,9605,9620,9650,9652,9668,9682,9687,9770,9788],"algae,":[32,7061,7450],"even":[34,158,545,1718,2617,3566,4442,4884],"mitochondria":[36,129],"make":[38,689,1536,2434,2576,3141,3655,5149,5589,5601,9809],"chemical":[39],"energy":[40,2023,2782],"for":[41,137,299,328,750,869,924,976,986,1173,1322,1381,1414,1571,1587,1663,1677,1829,1846,1881,2179,2281,2301,2587,2781,2914,3048,3051,3383,3643,3649,3658,3711,3717,3788,3913,4198,4342,4542,4755,4810,4938,4955,5121,5231,5250,5520,5603,5793,6417,6435,6441,6609,6647,6708,6751,6770,6801,6818,6874,7393,7551,7582,7592,7739,7999,8159,8198,8261,8596,8667,9052,9194,9360,9655],"eukaryotic":[42,2259,6303,6904],"cells.":[43,6052],"In":[44,1122,1223,1859,2408,2779,3195,4059,4092,4128,4549,4627,4747,5192,5384,5561,5878,6563,6592,7013,7173,7908,7956,8166,8249,9250,9462],"this":[45,367,630,1025,1224,1315,1337,1415,1453,1670,1968,2409,2678,3204,3222,3280,3283,3295,3632,3671,3689,3735,4465,4748,4800,5285,5361,5794,5930,6284,6493,6564,7021,7099,7213,7369,7512,7580,7721,7862,7972,8014,8020,8267,8286,8305,8614,8673,9231,9418],"list,":[46],"go":[49,486,3604],"from":[50,207,287,351,518,671,832,884,1152,1546,1641,1821,1836,2159,2923,3070,3363,3470,3529,4870,5188,5438,5819,5825,5896,5937,5984,6061,6087,6335,6408,7559,8220,8423,8632,8710,8788,8968,9091,9428,9438,9443,9571,9738,9815],"relatively":[51],"loose":[52],"ones":[55],"ever":[58,8574,8693],"more":[59,132,199,1019,1328,1736,1763,2817,3265,3637,4519,4724,4945,5153,5447,5487,6470,7034,7051,7167,7439,7667,7871,8072,8319,8556,8690,9289,9684],"tightly":[60],"coupled.":[61],"While":[62,189,742,2904,3873,7575,7807],"flower":[64],"bee":[67],"interdependent":[69],"products":[70],"of":[71,97,115,236,246,265,277,319,358,361,369,418,453,459,502,524,541,568,597,617,623,632,640,680,692,696,715,717,719,731,776,790,848,855,873,881,896,906,928,962,997,1043,1129,1137,1154,1176,1181,1191,1204,1209,1217,1261,1270,1280,1295,1314,1325,1396,1400,1417,1429,1461,1467,1473,1529,1553,1559,1774,1783,1826,1947,1961,1970,2012,2022,2044,2052,2070,2081,2115,2121,2142,2154,2188,2196,2206,2209,2236,2272,2297,2309,2319,2351,2359,2402,2414,2422,2428,2447,2453,2463,2471,2477,2534,2559,2570,2580,2686,2725,2751,2764,2792,2798,2832,2838,2872,2899,2930,2944,2964,2985,3035,3097,3113,3122,3126,3171,3177,3181,3329,3355,3372,3417,3424,3439,3448,3552,3575,3615,3634,3652,3664,3679,3695,3734,3752,3790,3811,3831,3891,3900,3918,3964,3971,3980,3983,4003,4011,4015,4042,4108,4145,4149,4162,4171,4201,4212,4227,4302,4312,4329,4335,4348,4356,4362,4397,4403,4409,4429,4440,4481,4507,4523,4528,4532,4547,4552,4559,4565,4594,4609,4634,4649,4670,4694,4702,4714,4729,4738,4750,4786,4793,4817,4831,4842,4844,4860,4917,4942,4950,4964,4973,4978,5000,5041,5048,5072,5081,5136,5181,5210,5215,5242,5256,5259,5290,5316,5321,5327,5335,5342,5374,5404,5433,5453,5465,5503,5529,5564,5576,5606,5630,5637,5663,5669,5698,5715,5755,5770,5778,5808,5852,5872,5890,5910,5940,5947,5967,5987,6012,6017,6034,6045,6067,6089,6098,6112,6157,6216,6246,6250,6263,6298,6301,6350,6365,6374,6390,6398,6420,6453,6498,6527,6530,6549,6557,6560,6601,6625,6651,6665,6696,6711,6746,6764,6775,6790,6880,6909,6915,6921,6925,6937,6957,6961,6972,6982,6990,7016,7055,7079,7091,7164,7221,7274,7304,7308,7339,7348,7353,7382,7390,7412,7415,7426,7436,7458,7480,7496,7519,7522,7586,7606,7634,7637,7657,7682,7697,7713,7718,7720,7723,7751,7779,7856,7901,7916,7938,7977,8017,8025,8028,8034,8042,8053,8077,8092,8106,8116,8152,8181,8202,8269,8282,8294,8298,8308,8313,8327,8333,8357,8448,8454,8461,8466,8489,8504,8521,8532,8539,8566,8635,8638,8683,8712,8732,8745,8776,8795,8812,8816,8849,8855,8899,8906,8964,9009,9015,9043,9073,9122,9126,9138,9147,9165,9190,9209,9220,9227,9233,9268,9293,9306,9340,9369,9405,9435,9458,9468,9494,9505,9510,9553,9581,9616,9659,9665,9676,9681,9692,9742,9755,9774,9799,9821],"co-evolution,":[72],"they":[73,91,100,304,485,651,1030,1652,1681,2172,2283,2619,2845,3140,3577,3584,3602,5358,5906,6230,6270,6726,7111,7120,7133,7288,7557,7627,7949,8472,8571],"still":[75,166,1601,3901,5882,6918,7179],"distinct":[76,416,900],"distinguishable":[78],"organisms.":[79,1779,7806],"For":[80,656,768,1263,1853,2030,2064,2521,2968,3476,5610,8380,9171],"some":[81,275,879,1740,1794,6305,7389,8201,8860],"biologists,":[82,4019,6477],"including":[83,4680,6472],"Lynn":[84,2223],"Margulis":[85,463,2224,2310,3543,3802,3865,4022,6499,6513,6602],"Dorion":[87],"Sagan":[88,465,3545,3886,4024,6254,6501,6515],"(2002,":[89,466],"18),":[90],"do":[92,101,650,2096,2959,3230,3237,3318,3835,4855,5643,7911,8214,8973],"not":[93,102,382,445,701,877,1040,1894,2233,2525,2575,2667,3285,3836,3995,4434,4723,4768,4820,4883,5108,5644,5817,6059,6425,6433,6439,6612,6715,6779,6814,6952,7446,7912,7954,8917,9133,9527],"count":[94],"as":[95,228,426,440,493,612,614,766,839,1012,1110,1118,1186,1244,1288,1378,1402,1426,1520,1567,1738,1777,1885,2176,2330,2438,2673,2698,2932,3134,3158,3305,3419,3421,3432,3542,3601,3682,3692,3707,3863,3990,4005,4020,4028,4147,4187,4203,4223,4229,4232,4254,4390,4458,4487,4501,4537,4591,4625,4720,4735,4914,4926,5144,5226,5239,5264,5308,5332,5415,5547,5608,6165,6277,6785,6849,6897,7047,7052,7122,7384,7422,7725,7786,7828,7832,7896,8038,8121,8545,8658,8670,8694,8747,8818,8918,8922,9059,9352,9394,9440,9455,9491,9603,9639,9662,9704,9710,9789],"because":[99,707,996,1773,3080,3203,5003,5464,5478,6229,6258,6428,6805,7333,9180],"live":[103,992,1003,1988,2375],"in":[104,145,202,349,385,438,491,756,798,814,911,993,1021,1058,1070,1127,1168,1197,1219,1235,1277,1348,1358,1516,1797,1851,1867,1924,1941,1949,1989,1994,2003,2092,2106,2126,2156,2169,2193,2229,2246,2381,2474,2529,2546,2690,2867,3025,3161,3186,3221,3279,3332,3454,3496,3630,3726,3765,3829,3876,4008,4079,4121,4159,4283,4322,4327,4333,4372,4393,4416,4443,4556,4665,4699,4758,4784,4795,4931,4947,4958,4991,5069,5132,5253,5360,5401,5523,5527,5618,5641,5660,5666,5687,5700,5728,5741,5796,5812,5846,5849,5884,5929,5944,6049,6063,6108,6127,6131,6210,6237,6280,6292,6367,6394,6459,6473,6495,6503,6673,6681,6786,6857,6911,6985,7001,7025,7108,7253,7276,7357,7441,7455,7524,7579,7598,7624,7673,7701,7710,7728,7753,7796,7924,8002,8087,8304,8310,8316,8406,8418,8440,8643,9128,9204,9290,9318,9356,9549,9751],"close":[105,654,6621,6842,7442,7783],"or":[106,267,313,682,964,1018,1051,1356,1410,2027,2049,2215,2753,2936,3299,3654,3840,4231,4267,4425,4993,5026,5821,5915,6106,6327,6483,6755,7033,7049,7310,7361,7438,7449,7845,7853,8183,8359,8581,8603,8611,8664,8724,8753],"\u201cobligate\u201d":[107],"contact.":[108],"The":[109,244,326,355,379,398,778,971,989,1016,1581,1701,2723,2877,3336,3619,3780,4300,4662,4813,5801,5900,6179,7298,7711,7936,8814,8866,8891,9679],"wasp":[110],"can":[111,119,165,260,305,709,771,991,1002,1345,1383,1456,2394,2507,2543,3500,3518,3585,3603,3757,4155,4305,4696,4806,4835,4911,5114,5148,5303,5388,6667,6687,6733,6808,7419,7620,7810,7840,8134,8593,9270],"find":[112,4753,5115],"other":[113,123,810,1123,1686,2047,2090,2267,2612,3124,4086,4093,4275,5193,5427,5648,5734,6176,6267,6662,6674,7486,7782,8167,8349,9021],"sources":[114],"food;":[116],"orchid":[118],"be":[120,167,261,306,423,710,772,823,1346,1384,2285,2544,2668,2772,3392,3480,3509,3758,3778,4157,4208,4290,4307,4388,4456,4499,4512,4697,4807,4836,4912,5306,6649,6668,6734,6743,6809,6854,6889,7044,7067,7143,7301,7420,7812,7842,8324,8478,8526,8656,9283,9588,9637],"pollinated":[121],"by":[122,341,372,456,712,782,922,1033,1423,1477,1543,1669,2264,2387,2784,3016,3056,3346,3365,3466,3673,3803,4579,4596,4622,5117,5425,5626,5732,5774,5919,6152,6174,6295,6476,6723,6860,7318,7472,7493,7528,7991,8070,8288,8329,8366,8444,8562,9077,9452],"species.":[124,560,4276,6268,6675],"But":[125,258,521,1029,1519,1831,2232,2806,3272,3357,3565,5244,5318,5511,6378,6707,6885,7203,7323,9223,9686],"mycorrhizae,":[126,3522],"lichens,":[127,3007],"much":[131,3362,6784,7843,8162,8438],"integrated.":[133],"Lichens,":[134,7444],"example":[136,2205,2716,5047,7750,8322,9195],"which":[138,315,334,363,432,578,799,815,1059,1291,2514,4399,4666,5141,5640,5650,5880,5969,6405,6608,6767,6870,7250,9129,9752],"biologists":[139,572,2920,7103,7178],"first":[140,339,2108,2255,3163,3334,4030,4584,4933,6040,6138,7314,8005,8927,9076],"used":[141,574,603],"term":[143,327,2536,3205,4098,6120],"late":[147,2219,2482],"19th":[148],"century":[149],"(Sapp":[150],"1994,":[151],"6),":[152],"look":[153,936],"like":[154,404,1048,1907,2078,3254,3385,5011,5024,5234,5798,7283,7588,8396,9156,9342],"a":[155,171,205,320,337,377,405,436,638,664,787,796,812,840,890,960,974,983,1041,1054,1111,1135,1146,1155,1160,1207,1229,1326,1359,1427,1433,1441,1508,1521,1568,1608,1612,1860,1878,1974,2009,2042,2050,2068,2185,2203,2226,2278,2302,2316,2615,2674,2699,2773,3020,3083,3232,3369,3395,3400,3623,3650,3693,3708,3747,3766,3977,4001,4012,4039,4055,4065,4071,4199,4224,4233,4310,4380,4391,4401,4451,4459,4467,4495,4538,4550,4618,4808,4915,4920,4939,5038,5045,5145,5171,5198,5206,5227,5248,5257,5271,5277,5295,5333,5338,5369,5416,5524,5597,5658,5670,5693,5729,5756,5866,5975,5997,6005,6019,6119,6124,6132,6166,6388,6447,6496,6572,6709,6731,6841,7144,7232,7269,7327,7336,7385,7469,7517,7540,7583,7638,7674,7705,7735,7829,7857,7870,7878,7887,8000,8039,8059,8079,8097,8122,8226,8229,8232,8238,8253,8301,8342,8372,8482,8553,8609,8612,8644,8659,8662,8681,8703,8721,8758,8828,8832,8871,8882,8903,8920,8934,8941,9048,9060,9071,9082,9085,9120,9361,9402,9414,9456,9469,9541,9554,9569,9625,9663,9711,9747],"single":[156,7561,7830,8046],"organism":[157,302,5173,9558],"if":[159,527,2618,3273,3567,3588,4722,6204,7204,9592,9769],"their":[160,181,187,610,697,1082,1775,2801,3241,3310,3324,3497,4089,4122,4261,4265,4272,4635,4650,4895,5042,5922,6758,6863,7036,7128,7170,7293,7447,7463,7497,7614,7629,8894,8900,8907,9731],"fungal":[161,7498,8995,9003,9029,9105],"algal":[163,7500],"partners":[164,7106,7440,7820],"observed":[168],"separately":[169,7107],"under":[170,1504,4975,7850],"microscope.":[172],"Mitochondria":[173],"fully":[175,6239,8575],"integrated":[176,7814],"into":[177,653,1066,1108,2326,3368,5578,5962,6183,6198,6357,6840,7465,8509,8955,9274],"cells,":[178,5935],"living":[179,1948,5172,5681],"inside":[180,8209,8391,8770],"membranes":[182],"utterly":[184],"dependent":[185],"on":[186,487,499,940,1150,1656,1983,2167,2253,2552,2598,2645,2738,3068,3494,3720,3953,4038,4235,4897,5974,6578,6589,6943,7088,7245,7321,8195,8260,8278,8335,8346,8474,9378,9507,9641,9647],"hosts.":[188],"word":[191],"commonly":[193],"mutual":[196,1120,1841,1950,8063],"benefit,":[197,216],"its":[198,262,1296,2004,2157,2324,2489,2705,2726,3461,3530,3826,4526,4824,5001,5122,5175,5343,5530,5533,5538,5550,6024,6293,6323,6771,6791,7201,7599,8011,8196,8203,8262,8394,8455,8783,8953,8969,9057,9373,9472],"specialized":[200],"meaning":[201,1790,8151,8344,8610],"biology":[203,448,492,755,2987,3728,5442,5615,6321,6462,7961,9512,9775],"is":[204,218,232,251,256,271,332,477,516,784,817,863,959,973,982,1039,1089,1131,1200,1227,1250,1266,1367,1408,1576,1857,1877,2015,2041,2067,2077,2270,2425,2625,2694,2815,2952,2980,3077,3248,3263,3394,3533,3537,3569,3611,3621,3746,3793,3814,3884,3911,3928,3994,3999,4243,4286,4340,4450,4466,4475,4489,4517,4540,4717,4838,4944,4970,5107,5129,5170,5246,5413,5462,5558,5596,5616,5624,5657,5684,5692,5718,5881,5956,6042,6054,6074,6095,6117,6140,6145,6286,6339,6406,6443,6446,6546,6611,6628,6678,6714,6778,6803,6813,6871,7004,7023,7086,7154,7183,7207,7231,7252,7329,7351,7372,7379,7539,7609,7730,7869,7877,7885,7953,8049,8108,8125,8129,8146,8225,8228,8231,8240,8256,8287,8300,8383,8442,8534,8588,8619,8674,8702,8824,8916,9036,9047,9178,9201,9331,9526,9530,9540],"continuum":[206,1101,7879,7888],"mutualism":[208,1071,2774,9371],"one-sided":[210],"parasitism.In":[211],"addition":[212,6364],"proximity":[214],"about":[219,878,917,1336,1648,1655,1742,1864,2486,2816,2925,3063,3399,3908,4518,5418,5441,5450,5488,5500,6606,6614,6619,7249,7257,8940,8946,8979,9000,9019,9054,9081,9112,9262,9760],"evolution.":[220],"As":[221,592,1507,3625,3844,4075,4367,4707,5218,6996,7148,8427,9618],"Angela":[222],"Douglas":[223,2849],"(2010)":[224],"puts":[225],"it,":[226,5007,8437],"evolution":[227,329,419,2053,4396,5444,5504,5772],"descent":[229,253],"with":[230,254,786,807,861,1145,1493,1872,1991,2046,2089,2266,2299,2376,2391,2436,2498,2517,2857,2884,2961,3091,3231,3314,3319,3452,3523,3701,3879,4054,4274,4353,4515,4826,4849,4864,4880,5035,5104,5174,5337,5553,5592,5646,5695,5780,6266,6314,6379,6519,7326,7397,8266,8348,8375,8486,8552,8728,8821,8831,8933,9007,9084,9217,9237,9244,9366,9381],"modification":[231,255],"dominant":[234,5883],"theory":[235,338,1136,1214,2051,2462,2479,4002,4200,4211,4347,4636,4651,4941,5209,5403,5563,5605,5795,7521,7555,7722,9478,9748],"how":[237,548,918,2273,2282,2373,3146,3909,4102,4248,4909,5350,5357,5419,5456,6346,6718,6977,8161,8475,9257,9717,9761],"organisms":[238,616,1011,1044,3785,5263,6588,6701,6725,6821,6856,9756],"vary":[239],"acquire":[241],"new":[242,321,1035,1077,1316,2093,2700,2736,3175,4258,4269,4804,5362,6211,7145,7736,7905,7988,8704],"traits.":[243],"assumption":[245,318,7248],"both":[247,743,1201,2127,2403,3683,5270,6460,6652,6875,6924,7504,7653,8388,8458,8541,8622,8647,8791,9245,9409],"Darwinism":[248,2444,5779],"Neo-Darwinism":[250],"gradual.":[257],"own":[263,2005,5002,5043,5123,5176,6324,6772],"source":[264,6745],"\u201cmodification\u201d":[266],"evolutionary":[268,279,307,1085,2247,2937,4998,5531,5980,6085,8093,9397],"variation:":[269],"There":[270,3506,3998],"unambiguous":[272],"evidence":[273],"traits":[276,296],"great":[278],"ecological":[281,702,1259,1349,1389,1431,1436,1447,2148,2540,2935,3608,7891,7928,8083,8251,8295,8708,9062,9248,9320,9406,9460,9548,9607,9646],"importance":[282],"have":[283,509,573,625,747,1787,1909,2123,2907,2992,3015,3291,3316,3558,3837,3852,4866,5037,5065,5673,6480,7070,7186,7285,7289,8400,8600,9483],"been":[284,748,1661,1675,1965,2124,2312,2718,2994,3089,3277,3559,3723,5311,9423],"gained":[285],"laterally":[286,294,6735],"different,":[288],"often":[289,602,2173,2695,2866,3156,4868,8484],"phylogenetically":[290],"distant,":[291],"taxa.":[292],"acquired":[295,311,5853,5918,6217,6264,6531,6550],"novel":[298],"recipient":[301],"innovations,":[308],"i.e.,":[309],"\u201cnew":[310],"structures":[312],"properties":[314,7138],"permit":[316],"function.\u201d":[322],"(Douglas":[323],"2010,":[324],"1)":[325],"through":[330,1134,1481,2288,3676,3923,4168,4271,4309,4891,5020,5371,5549,5573,5952,5996,6362,6793,7139,7468,7994,8013,8061,8984,9143,9577],"symbiogenesis,":[333,1307,3940,6607,7772,8031],"outlined":[340],"Russian":[343],"biologist":[344,5828],"lichenologist":[346],"Konstantin":[347],"Mereschkowski":[348],"papers":[350],"1905":[352],"1910.":[354],"famous":[356,4143,9124],"image":[357,4531],"life,":[362,542,5429,5736,7309,9343],"fails":[364,8212],"capture":[366],"reintegration":[368],"lineages":[370],"noted":[371,7535,7834],"Douglas,":[373],"gives":[374,7733],"way":[375,794,841,1208,1845,2244,2325,3108,3396,3931,5599,6416,6570,7338,7541,7626,7675,8341,9626],"network.":[378],"does":[381,1890,2524,2574,3284,3343,3489,4767,6432,6438,8840,9132],"only":[383,648,1132,2426,2508,4306,4471,5572,6613,6742,7189,7292,7822,7848,8171,8292],"branch":[384],"one":[386,808,1046,1060,1073,1765,2427,2664,2858,2981,3714,3941,3988,4252,4533,6455,6580,6650,6824,7187,7190,7466,7763,8217,9532,9643],"temporal":[387,3841],"direction,":[388],"so":[389,511,818,1351,1678,2097,3288,3768,4129,4867,5067,5385,6593,6783,7817,9251],"all":[391,792,1311,1666,2242,2258,2647,3000,3006,3211,3341,8054,8762,9187],"branches":[392,399],"lead":[393],"back":[394,937,3403,5054],"common":[396,7162,9050],"ancestors.":[397],"also":[400,2277,2353,2823,2881,3508,3622,4035,4156,4653,5223,5247,5323,5559,6075,6596,6688,6888,7841,7886,8109,8241,8944,9202,9330,9688,9784],"fuse":[401,9006],"reticulate":[403],"mycelium.":[406],"These":[407,2119,2821],"two":[408,415,857,1017,5079,6539,6837,7032,7437,7759],"powerful":[409,8104],"images,":[410],"mycelium,":[413,2754],"illustrate":[414],"processes":[417,716,732,3511,6540],"(and":[420,6234,7971,9259],"there":[421,770,1088,2951,3478,3745,3756,3854,4449,4969,6385,6812,6886,7876,7884,8169,8382,8587,8701,9329],"may":[422,3359,3479,3507,6852],"more,":[424],"such":[425,2329,2905,3133,4295,5351,6896,7895,8569,9499],"self-organization":[427,3760],"[Depew":[428],"Weber":[430],"1994],":[431],"no":[433,773,867,2953,3538,3759,3763,3868,4244,4971,4997,5152,5304,5908,7112,7290,8289,8589,8886],"doubt":[434,8277],"plays":[435],"role":[437,1239,2473,3024,4792,6908],"well).":[441],"They":[442,1319,1644,1659,1770,1780,2596,4263,6851,7502,8550],"complementary,":[444],"mutually":[446],"exclusive.Theoretical":[447],"has":[449,1792,1964,2311,2656,2717,2733,3088,3275,3722,3783,4215,4478,4674,4996,5310,5864,6206,6354,9422],"seen":[450,4578,5066,9442],"many":[451,512,3123,3289,4663,5871],"explanations":[452,622],"accompanied":[455],"symptomatic":[457],"figures":[458,501],"speech.":[460],"Even":[461,2836,3587,4415,6203],"though":[462],"15\u201317)":[467],"quick":[469],"denounce":[471],"idea":[473,1969,2017,2606,2703,2963,3209,3259,3337,4980,5856,6329,6521,6948,7659,7915,8105,9038],"Darwinian":[475],"competition":[476],"\u201cmore":[478],"natural\u201d":[479],"less":[481,7046,9653],"anthropomorphic":[482],"than":[483,759,1008,1330,1687,1764,1955,2058,2818,3266,4338,4520,4954,5017,5062,5154,5428,5499,5735,6177,6478,7011,7169,7747,8692,9295,9522],"cooperation,":[484,2583],"criticize":[489],"anthropomorphism":[490,525,553],"such\u2014and":[494],"then":[495,3224,4903,6142,6273,7217,8205,8971,9088,9601],"rely":[497,2644,7244],"heavily":[498],"social":[500,569,599,634,1657,3030,4845,7680],"cooperation.":[503],"And":[504,7715],"why":[505,1706,1711,3287,6641,7791],"not,":[506,4476],"when":[507,1114,1379,1495,2646,3645,4021,4117,4582,5723,6082,7556,7799],"scholars":[508,2432,2947,5484],"established":[510],"times":[513],"metaphor":[515,4154,4245,4846,5230,7681],"inseparable":[517],"scientific":[519,915,4620,4676,7171,7238],"reasoning?":[520],"stakes":[523,2940],"change":[526,2361,5359,5928,5950,6976],"I":[528,544,935,1171,1419,1496,1564,1610,1636,1723,1731,1745,1862,1892,3218,3667,3704,3729,3874,4191,4432,4752,5346,5407,5672,6479,6644,6845,6978,7018,7534,7576,7602,7726,7773,7833,8119,8141,8156,8164,8560,8599,9242,9315,9327,9384,9516],"am":[529,3875,5408,6645],"unsure":[530],"where":[531,3032,3482,3487,7647,7687,8178,8577,8972,9199,9544],"draw":[533,2150,2597],"line":[535,3062,4749],"humans":[537,1932,1977,4982,5004,9095],"rest":[540,5939,5986],"whether":[543,3323,4690,6101],"should,":[546],"widely":[549,1373,3352,3563],"qualities":[551],"ostensibly":[554],"projects":[555,9594],"already":[557,3201,4000,6289,6387,6853,7453,8007],"distributed":[558,2902,9118],"among":[559,1768,1939,2982,5760,6383,6820,6830,7059,7362,9534,9562],"Jan":[561,2972],"Sapp":[562],"(1994)":[563],"details":[564],"wide":[566,2317,2721,2746,2879,4052,5139,6883],"range":[567,2318],"analogies":[570],"describe":[576,4026,4101,4282,4615],"symbiosis,":[577,1022,1306,3409,3666,4062,4679,4968,5036,5355,7017,7724],"include":[579,2455],"friendship,":[580],"hospitality,":[581],"neighborliness,":[582],"oppression,":[583],"slavery,":[584,4529],"imprisonment,":[585],"love,":[586],"games,":[587],"cost\u2013benefit":[588],"economics,":[589],"more.":[591],"he":[593,1511,1523,4076,4095,4583,5142,5222,5505,6535,6595],"argues,":[594,7152],"\u201c\u2018commonsense\u2019":[595],"views":[596]},"counts_by_year":[{"year":2026,"cited_by_count":10},{"year":2025,"cited_by_count":3},{"year":2024,"cited_by_count":1}],"updated_date":"2026-10-16T09:59:22.235173","created_date":"2023-01-07T00:00:00"}