{"id":"https://openalex.org/W4302008159","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1093/ml/gcac080","title":"\u2018Artes Novae\u2019","display_name":"\u2018Artes Novae\u2019","publication_year":2022,"publication_date":"2022-08-25","ids":{"openalex":"https://openalex.org/W4302008159","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1093/ml/gcac080"},"language":"en","primary_location":{"id":"doi:10.1093/ml/gcac080","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1093/ml/gcac080","is_oa":true,"landing_page_url":"https://doi.org/10.1093/ml/gcac080","pdf_url":"https://academic.oup.com/ml/article-pdf/103/4/772/47537759/gcac080.pdf","source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S134075208","display_name":"Music and Letters","issn_l":"0027-4224","issn":["0027-4224","1477-4631"],"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":false,"listed_in":["anvur-class-a","anvur-scientific","erih-plus","jufo-2","norway-2","poland-100","russia-white-list-2","vabb-shw"],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/P4310311648","host_organization_name":"Oxford University Press","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/P4310311648","https://openalex.org/P4310311647"],"host_organization_lineage_names":["Oxford University Press","University of Oxford"],"type":"journal"},"license":"cc-by","license_id":"https://openalex.org/licenses/cc-by","version":"publishedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":true,"raw_source_name":"Music and Letters","raw_type":"journal-article"},"volume":null,"type":"article","indexed_in":["crossref"],"open_access":{"is_oa":true,"oa_status":"hybrid","oa_url":"https://academic.oup.com/ml/article-pdf/103/4/772/47537759/gcac080.pdf","any_repository_has_fulltext":false},"authorships":[{"author_position":"first","author":{"id":"https://openalex.org/A5111390154","display_name":"Margaret Bent","orcid":null,"observed_orcids":[]},"institutions":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/I40120149","display_name":"University of Oxford","ror":"https://ror.org/052gg0110","country_code":"GB","type":"education","lineage":["https://openalex.org/I40120149"]}],"countries":["GB"],"is_corresponding":true,"raw_author_name":"Margaret Bent","raw_affiliation_strings":["All Souls College, Oxford"],"raw_orcid":null,"affiliations":[{"raw_affiliation_string":"All Souls College, Oxford","institution_ids":["https://openalex.org/I40120149"]}]}],"institutions":[],"countries_distinct_count":1,"institutions_distinct_count":1,"corresponding_author_ids":["https://openalex.org/A5111390154"],"corresponding_institution_ids":["https://openalex.org/I40120149"],"apc_list":{"value":4335,"currency":"USD","value_usd":4335},"apc_paid":{"value":4335,"currency":"USD","value_usd":4335},"fwci":0.0,"has_fulltext":true,"cited_by_count":0,"citation_normalized_percentile":{"value":0.15846016,"is_in_top_1_percent":false,"is_in_top_10_percent":false},"cited_by_percentile_year":null,"biblio":{"volume":"103","issue":"4","first_page":"772","last_page":"773"},"is_retracted":false,"is_paratext":false,"is_xpac":false,"primary_topic":{"id":"https://openalex.org/T10941","display_name":"Musicology and Musical Analysis","score":0.986299991607666,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1210","display_name":"Music"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/12","display_name":"Arts and Humanities"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},"topics":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/T10941","display_name":"Musicology and Musical Analysis","score":0.986299991607666,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1210","display_name":"Music"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/12","display_name":"Arts and Humanities"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},{"id":"https://openalex.org/T10595","display_name":"Medieval Literature and History","score":0.0038999998942017555,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1205","display_name":"Classics"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/12","display_name":"Arts and Humanities"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},{"id":"https://openalex.org/T12076","display_name":"Renaissance and Early Modern Studies","score":0.0015999999595806003,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1202","display_name":"History"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/12","display_name":"Arts and Humanities"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}}],"keywords":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/ars-nova","display_name":"Ars nova","score":0.8859999775886536},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/music-theory","display_name":"music theory","score":0.44200000166893005},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/medieval-music","display_name":"medieval music","score":0.4390000104904175},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/classical-reception","display_name":"classical reception","score":0.42800000309944153}],"concepts":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/C142362112","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q735","display_name":"Art","level":0,"score":0.41444748640060425}],"mesh":[],"locations_count":1,"locations":[{"id":"doi:10.1093/ml/gcac080","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1093/ml/gcac080","is_oa":true,"landing_page_url":"https://doi.org/10.1093/ml/gcac080","pdf_url":"https://academic.oup.com/ml/article-pdf/103/4/772/47537759/gcac080.pdf","source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S134075208","display_name":"Music and Letters","issn_l":"0027-4224","issn":["0027-4224","1477-4631"],"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":false,"listed_in":["anvur-class-a","anvur-scientific","erih-plus","jufo-2","norway-2","poland-100","russia-white-list-2","vabb-shw"],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/P4310311648","host_organization_name":"Oxford University Press","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/P4310311648","https://openalex.org/P4310311647"],"host_organization_lineage_names":["Oxford University Press","University of Oxford"],"type":"journal"},"license":"cc-by","license_id":"https://openalex.org/licenses/cc-by","version":"publishedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":true,"raw_source_name":"Music and Letters","raw_type":"journal-article"}],"best_oa_location":{"id":"doi:10.1093/ml/gcac080","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1093/ml/gcac080","is_oa":true,"landing_page_url":"https://doi.org/10.1093/ml/gcac080","pdf_url":"https://academic.oup.com/ml/article-pdf/103/4/772/47537759/gcac080.pdf","source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S134075208","display_name":"Music and Letters","issn_l":"0027-4224","issn":["0027-4224","1477-4631"],"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":false,"listed_in":["anvur-class-a","anvur-scientific","erih-plus","jufo-2","norway-2","poland-100","russia-white-list-2","vabb-shw"],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/P4310311648","host_organization_name":"Oxford University Press","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/P4310311648","https://openalex.org/P4310311647"],"host_organization_lineage_names":["Oxford University Press","University of Oxford"],"type":"journal"},"license":"cc-by","license_id":"https://openalex.org/licenses/cc-by","version":"publishedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":true,"raw_source_name":"Music and Letters","raw_type":"journal-article"},"sustainable_development_goals":[],"study_designs":[],"awards":[],"funders":[],"has_content":{"pdf":true,"grobid_xml":true},"content_urls":{"pdf":"https://content.openalex.org/works/W4302008159.pdf","grobid_xml":"https://content.openalex.org/works/W4302008159.grobid-xml"},"referenced_works_count":0,"referenced_works":[],"related_works":["https://openalex.org/W3014883268","https://openalex.org/W639884819","https://openalex.org/W4240999376","https://openalex.org/W1511191090","https://openalex.org/W4230948662","https://openalex.org/W2888856414","https://openalex.org/W7075320154","https://openalex.org/W2014021860","https://openalex.org/W2403493060","https://openalex.org/W572185875"],"abstract_inverted_index":{"The":[0,129,289,1019,1037,1111,1211,1451,1844,1891,2350,2511,2604,2871,4177,4525,4675,5657,5884,6172,6322,6506,6813,6843,7093,7575,7936,10045,10360],"following":[1,284,1691,1838,1853,2068,2322,5276,6479,8040,9712],"abbreviations":[2],"are":[3,108,117,123,192,201,1028,1319,1335,1345,1765,1823,2172,2309,2354,2658,2932,2980,3381,3505,3511,3523,3829,3872,3928,4237,4290,4607,4720,4745,4753,4774,4927,4977,5051,5460,5473,5623,6035,6077,6482,6492,6518,6545,6609,6682,6771,7026,7341,7414,7505,7659,8758,8815,9843,9977,10052,10064,10180,10352],"used:":[4],"Rome,":[5,12],"Biblioteca":[6,13],"Apostolica":[7,14],"Vaticana,":[8,15],"Reg.":[9],"lat.":[10,17,35,1627,2048,2464,2600,2643],"1146":[11,10377],"Barb.":[16],"307":[18],"Paris,":[19],"Biblioth\u00e8que":[20,87],"nationale":[21],"de":[22,26,42,63,73,77,152,543,735,800,1023,1578,2744,2884,4194,4707,5091,5101,5107,6414,6997,7106,7772,7989,8005,9858],"France":[23],"Corpus":[24],"Scriptorum":[25],"Musica":[27,1127,2331,3092,3419,3441,9417,10434],"\u2018Quoniam":[28],"per":[29,1956,2783,2790,2796,2803,2810,5450,7893,7899,7904],"ignorantiam":[30],"artis":[31,66,1920,1941,2479,2752],"musice\u2019":[32,1921,2469],"in":[33,40,147,167,206,247,344,405,440,476,537,559,598,606,613,647,651,658,679,697,716,773,867,888,909,964,1108,1204,1305,1347,1353,1375,1477,1526,1618,1663,1758,1849,1877,1936,1967,1991,2016,2036,2046,2089,2165,2199,2280,2299,2317,2357,2367,2380,2462,2473,2482,2509,2544,2598,2646,2684,2698,2727,2765,2920,3019,3051,3131,3151,3164,3230,3249,3320,3344,3349,3367,3413,3492,3497,3602,3653,3671,3717,3726,3772,3791,3809,3920,3958,3983,4003,4024,4196,4253,4293,4296,4310,4366,4409,4435,4518,4538,4577,4613,4640,4660,4709,4726,4746,4754,4763,4768,4811,4824,4869,4904,4944,4962,4972,4984,4987,4998,5052,5062,5141,5295,5314,5328,5336,5340,5343,5392,5430,5446,5454,5476,5500,5541,5556,5571,5616,5630,5798,5845,5882,6061,6141,6157,6182,6201,6209,6240,6261,6297,6307,6330,6352,6356,6378,6418,6439,6514,6523,6535,6568,6598,6629,6638,6658,6664,6704,6706,6720,6724,6726,6734,6747,6763,6790,6805,6832,6888,6894,6904,6914,6969,7017,7219,7300,7343,7374,7380,7419,7427,7510,7579,7607,7621,7847,7857,7877,7951,8063,8100,8141,8185,8234,8251,8360,8383,8446,8472,8487,8624,8662,8766,8805,8811,8848,8919,8942,8968,9001,9026,9031,9123,9147,9170,9348,9376,9406,9413,9419,9422,9441,9474,9529,9599,9604,9615,9631,9642,9655,9665,9715,9827,9834,9852,9864,9876,9889,9929,9980,10022,10190,10218,10285,10321,10375,10413,10436,10463,10494],"BnF":[34,59,1626,2047,2463,2599,3498,6175,6817,7375,9557,9561],"15128,":[36],"fos.":[37],"127\u20139.":[38],"Edited":[39],"Philippi":[41],"Vitriaco":[43],"Ars":[44,912,935,977,1002,1149,1760,2211,2522,2524,2528,2850,2899,2924,3889,3933,4008,4847,7463,9393],"nova,":[45,401,978,3936,5029,5904,6583,7339,7535],"ed.":[46,79,99],"Gilbert":[47],"Reaney,":[48],"Andr\u00e9":[49],"Gilles,":[50],"and":[51,203,244,318,330,361,366,395,414,468,486,602,615,669,692,699,731,748,750,759,780,811,818,844,927,947,967,1031,1104,1126,1188,1195,1207,1229,1233,1237,1256,1263,1294,1542,1576,1580,1657,1665,1833,1930,1984,1989,2018,2022,2091,2158,2175,2219,2294,2352,2382,2386,2461,2481,2557,2610,2645,2665,2701,2852,2985,2997,3016,3043,3078,3110,3121,3371,3421,3437,3443,3478,3480,3507,3555,3656,3756,3912,3943,3971,4041,4089,4181,4229,4260,4284,4287,4380,4415,4452,4458,4504,4521,4552,4601,4621,4637,4645,4670,4712,4767,4790,4815,4910,4916,4920,4954,5018,5030,5342,5371,5428,5488,5492,5582,5635,5676,5690,5723,5783,5800,5912,5949,6070,6075,6085,6107,6116,6160,6212,6289,6302,6316,6347,6412,6421,6433,6455,6528,6584,6594,6628,6666,6731,6793,6840,6862,6901,6919,7014,7031,7064,7147,7382,7384,7447,7476,7501,7537,7585,7595,7601,7762,7928,7968,7977,8020,8029,8034,8059,8076,8092,8109,8172,8175,8183,8196,8398,8419,8454,8494,8512,8532,8540,8547,8606,8615,8639,8697,8782,8799,8809,8824,8838,8916,8931,8938,9088,9101,9107,9259,9293,9351,9370,9379,9408,9415,9430,9476,9478,9485,9506,9532,9560,9581,9721,9789,9823,9963,9993,10056,10072,10139,10163,10295,10369,10476,10491,10502],"Jean":[52],"Maillard,":[53],"CSM":[54,82,102],"8":[55,2975],"(n.p.,":[56],"1964),":[57],"84\u201393":[58],"fr.":[60,3499,7376,9558,9646],"146":[61],"Johannis":[62],"Muris":[64,1024,1114,1411,1454,1915,2032,2081,2840,2990,3138,3315,3377,3410,3435,3827,3993,4049,5270,5290,5782,6921,7765,7773,9749,10048,10383],"Notitia":[65,561,1041,1121,1509,1654,1901,2035,2078,2152,2351,2447,2512,2543,2848,2978,5297,6905,7761,9391,10405],"musicae":[67,70,410,897],"et":[68,164,914,2213,3891,3935,4010,6977,6982,7002,7111,7677,7839,7856,7859,7870,7885,7996,8001,8008,8847,8850],"Compendium":[69,2532,2587,2629,2715,2726,2845,3002,3086,3107,4123,9412,10374],"practicae;":[71],"Petrus":[72,4193,4706,4765,6413],"Sancto":[74],"Dionysio":[75],"Tractatus":[76,7801,8266,8346,8652,8744,8843,9056],"musica,":[78,2525],"Ulrich":[80,1130],"Michels,":[81],"17":[83,4730],"(Dallas,":[84],"1972)":[85],"Montpellier,":[86,4716],"interuniversitaire,":[88],"Section":[89],"m\u00e9decine,":[90],"H":[91],"196":[92],"Jacobi":[93],"Leodiensis":[94],"Speculum":[95,235,409,478,896,3647],"musicae,":[96,236,479,2523],"7":[97,966,1267,1662,3366,3424,3790,3974,5482,9162,9178,9213,10510],"vols.,":[98],"Roger":[100],"Bragard,":[101],"3":[103],"(Rome,":[104],"1955\u201373).":[105],"Individual":[106],"books":[107,2122],"referred":[109,3737],"to":[110,277,348,385,407,417,429,499,585,638,834,845,865,940,984,998,1063,1175,1201,1217,1342,1372,1423,1441,1487,1495,1516,1523,1528,1610,1775,1802,1825,1851,1862,1893,1908,1934,1975,2005,2014,2029,2054,2082,2104,2109,2138,2150,2161,2272,2312,2369,2455,2496,2498,2504,2565,2591,2617,2640,2724,2965,3069,3148,3203,3232,3241,3269,3384,3516,3563,3658,3678,3714,3738,3750,3761,3797,3806,3838,3843,3894,3908,4035,4081,4091,4127,4137,4171,4189,4207,4224,4272,4306,4316,4330,4350,4368,4377,4402,4412,4424,4568,4616,4684,4828,4883,4894,4908,4913,5134,5148,5163,5169,5183,5241,5262,5286,5358,5399,5406,5443,5462,5509,5568,5603,5609,5666,5677,5757,5793,5821,5866,5892,5907,5914,5958,5992,6049,6057,6063,6090,6096,6153,6179,6188,6224,6258,6269,6362,6385,6430,6441,6462,6470,6484,6555,6561,6625,6671,6739,6779,6870,6927,6951,7010,7021,7039,7072,7225,7247,7251,7368,7386,7392,7456,7493,7548,7557,7657,7705,7714,7750,7758,7912,7926,7944,8015,8151,8211,8227,8245,8336,8369,8385,8408,8442,8462,8474,8526,8529,8612,8633,8664,8679,8794,8835,8899,8911,8971,8993,9050,9068,9084,9152,9167,9190,9199,9214,9233,9256,9298,9311,9314,9754,9868,9927,10006,10054,10080,10126,10206,10300,10330,10342,10372,10388,10432,10456,10497],"as":[111,254,403,534,661,707,841,973,1000,1006,1086,1140,1159,1278,1280,1351,1448,1484,1507,1607,1648,2262,2316,2388,2413,2476,2488,2517,2679,2683,2930,2973,3032,3192,3244,3277,3329,3562,3782,3852,4060,4074,4405,4626,4692,4842,4857,5038,5077,5137,5200,5269,5505,5537,5539,5573,5679,5766,5849,5861,5906,5926,5957,5964,6027,6052,6167,6251,6271,6452,6552,6558,6577,6855,6926,7196,7293,7307,7398,7721,7738,7740,7766,7917,7958,8056,8098,8236,8239,8268,8273,8278,8348,8431,8610,8645,8716,8724,8732,8734,8852,8867,8879,8905,9204,9220,9225,9272,9287,9513,10070,10279],"SM":[112,114,965,1109,1181,1266,3165,3365,3414,3423,3464,3789,3973,4077,4727,5063,6353,6375,7684,8982,9161,9177,9212,10096,10307,10459,10509],"1,":[113,7680],"7.":[115,1110,3415,6376,10308],"Translations":[116],"mine":[118],"unless":[119],"otherwise":[120],"credited.":[121],"Some":[122,1755,4149,6291,7753],"adapted":[124,432,2690],"from":[125,274,433,636,653,756,881,962,968,1113,1119,1142,1230,1510,1569,1788,2252,2426,2691,2846,2905,3003,3160,3171,3219,3471,3689,3882,3930,3977,4047,4129,4146,4680,5931,6088,6405,6486,6767,6796,7166,7403,7531,7540,8044,8264,8422,8921,9040,9048,9295,9380,9544,9748,9816,9957,10001,10181],"Rob":[126],"C.":[127],"Wegman,":[128],"Mirror":[130],"of":[131,144,188,217,225,242,259,267,272,297,310,333,342,358,364,376,397,411,436,444,449,454,464,483,489,492,494,501,507,515,528,531,546,549,591,594,625,667,676,682,686,690,702,725,764,798,809,814,822,858,869,894,958,975,980,995,1015,1021,1035,1080,1090,1136,1147,1154,1169,1180,1191,1213,1222,1235,1243,1274,1291,1329,1357,1390,1406,1417,1445,1474,1539,1564,1572,1574,1589,1601,1632,1640,1652,1660,1778,1790,1835,1841,1856,1881,1923,1926,1979,1982,1995,2072,2076,2123,2156,2178,2205,2215,2222,2230,2283,2320,2325,2329,2399,2430,2507,2538,2541,2594,2649,2873,2876,2912,2942,2944,2976,3007,3135,3143,3176,3189,3257,3298,3355,3456,3501,3519,3534,3547,3593,3623,3645,3696,3709,3744,3753,3767,3775,3857,3859,3886,3897,3991,4015,4030,4037,4071,4109,4150,4200,4235,4242,4245,4256,4278,4282,4322,4325,4343,4373,4388,4440,4456,4473,4479,4489,4498,4515,4523,4533,4543,4566,4581,4597,4604,4635,4655,4688,4715,4718,4772,4784,4797,4807,4831,4837,4864,4890,4918,4934,4949,4981,5003,5007,5025,5033,5041,5070,5115,5126,5205,5214,5227,5245,5252,5279,5321,5348,5381,5439,5448,5480,5533,5548,5559,5585,5625,5640,5647,5660,5753,5781,5796,5804,5814,5839,5858,5888,5896,5898,5920,5940,5945,5980,5985,6024,6046,6121,6123,6137,6164,6169,6185,6195,6207,6278,6324,6410,6425,6435,6497,6538,6564,6581,6588,6600,6604,6648,6677,6694,6710,6717,6742,6816,6824,6838,6864,6879,7027,7033,7089,7145,7169,7181,7191,7199,7216,7256,7266,7268,7309,7329,7333,7412,7445,7487,7546,7561,7564,7577,7599,7604,7639,7650,7668,7674,7696,7711,7731,7743,7747,7754,7793,7797,7817,7827,7938,7961,7983,8066,8153,8169,8194,8203,8215,8249,8288,8308,8327,8351,8355,8401,8412,8435,8553,8559,8564,8586,8592,8619,8637,8650,8670,8684,8741,8772,8832,8854,8873,8981,9011,9054,9074,9098,9104,9121,9134,9149,9176,9187,9246,9253,9290,9328,9340,9346,9355,9395,9454,9467,9496,9522,9537,9556,9577,9660,9686,9698,9704,9768,9778,9794,9805,9808,9915,9919,9947,9953,10032,10047,10108,10167,10259,10287,10293,10317,10325,10345,10362,10365,10400,10404,10410,10420,10440,10473],"Music:":[132],"Book":[133],"the":[134,189,215,218,223,226,256,260,264,278,281,285,301,311,319,340,359,408,415,437,450,455,497,504,529,547,560,562,592,623,656,665,674,680,688,709,717,726,732,765,784,794,839,878,889,895,930,948,993,1049,1081,1087,1165,1178,1189,1261,1275,1296,1326,1336,1348,1354,1367,1396,1415,1442,1478,1508,1537,1562,1590,1592,1611,1622,1630,1638,1649,1653,1689,1762,1831,1839,1842,1854,1878,1882,1900,1906,1924,1968,1977,1980,2006,2034,2042,2066,2069,2073,2077,2098,2107,2111,2116,2120,2124,2127,2134,2151,2170,2179,2200,2203,2210,2216,2220,2223,2228,2231,2238,2244,2253,2284,2289,2292,2300,2318,2323,2326,2334,2370,2395,2400,2424,2431,2435,2443,2446,2474,2483,2486,2499,2542,2578,2583,2586,2592,2611,2621,2628,2647,2662,2666,2669,2685,2692,2714,2718,2722,2725,2844,2847,2859,2863,2874,2891,2910,2935,2939,2945,2951,2954,2963,2966,2977,2992,2995,3001,3040,3044,3057,3063,3085,3090,3106,3112,3115,3119,3124,3133,3136,3140,3144,3152,3187,3190,3252,3262,3278,3283,3296,3321,3368,3376,3418,3433,3440,3445,3459,3472,3493,3536,3581,3594,3618,3620,3624,3643,3646,3650,3667,3682,3690,3697,3724,3727,3735,3742,3762,3768,3770,3773,3810,3855,3860,3876,3883,3898,3909,3921,3925,3959,3965,3992,4007,4025,4031,4038,4048,4107,4110,4122,4190,4197,4208,4225,4251,4280,4297,4311,4334,4385,4427,4438,4487,4490,4496,4499,4519,4534,4541,4618,4686,4689,4702,4710,4739,4755,4764,4781,4793,4798,4804,4845,4854,4862,4924,4938,4947,4950,4973,5026,5031,5042,5047,5138,5152,5158,5166,5206,5210,5243,5250,5253,5277,5280,5315,5330,5344,5349,5378,5382,5396,5433,5468,5477,5518,5534,5549,5553,5583,5614,5626,5631,5652,5682,5751,5759,5779,5784,5815,5837,5846,5855,5870,5894,5899,5916,5932,6014,6022,6025,6044,6072,6097,6104,6108,6124,6133,6138,6158,6162,6170,6183,6193,6230,6234,6244,6252,6275,6279,6298,6331,6341,6426,6444,6495,6503,6515,6536,6542,6562,6569,6618,6626,6634,6649,6654,6659,6675,6698,6707,6711,6715,6735,6740,6768,6776,6797,6806,6853,6858,6875,6880,6889,6898,6920,6936,6952,7012,7028,7034,7040,7056,7062,7090,7131,7142,7156,7159,7167,7170,7179,7182,7189,7226,7235,7270,7279,7290,7326,7330,7345,7350,7354,7404,7431,7442,7457,7462,7478,7484,7488,7511,7532,7543,7569,7636,7640,7651,7666,7672,7693,7751,7755,7759,7791,7794,7798,7824,7828,7924,7932,7939,8039,8064,8089,8094,8112,8142,8154,8167,8231,8252,8261,8265,8289,8319,8323,8345,8361,8373,8377,8386,8410,8416,8420,8432,8447,8475,8480,8518,8530,8536,8543,8551,8560,8572,8584,8590,8593,8613,8620,8648,8651,8668,8719,8743,8749,8786,8806,8812,8830,8833,8855,8871,8912,8969,8987,9027,9032,9037,9046,9051,9055,9070,9075,9096,9099,9124,9173,9191,9215,9221,9235,9240,9250,9266,9277,9296,9299,9302,9315,9352,9377,9381,9404,9411,9416,9449,9455,9468,9488,9493,9502,9509,9523,9530,9535,9553,9575,9593,9602,9605,9625,9638,9684,9710,9719,9737,9755,9769,9792,9803,9806,9869,9890,9903,9913,9916,9935,9940,9944,9954,10023,10106,10119,10154,10156,10159,10164,10168,10170,10210,10283,10288,10291,10302,10314,10322,10326,10356,10366,10370,10373,10401,10408,10411,10433,10464,10468,10470],"Seventh":[135],"(Lexington,":[136],"KY,":[137],"2017).":[138],"Thesaurus":[139],"Musicarum":[140],"Latinarum:":[141],"Online":[142],"Archive":[143],"Music":[145,317],"Theory":[146],"Latin":[148],"<https://chmtl.indiana.edu/tml/>":[149],"Adhuc":[150],"sum":[151,172],"numero":[153],"Antiquorum":[154,6995],"quos":[155,3100],"horum":[156],"aliqui":[157,5084],"rudes":[158],"vocant.":[159],"Sum":[160],"senex,":[161],"illi":[162],"acuti":[163],"iuvenes.":[165],"...etsi":[166],"hoc":[168,5096,6991,7840],"opere":[169,6970],"dicturus":[170],"aliqua":[171,1699],"contra":[173],"dicta":[174],"Modernorum":[175,7003],"ubi":[176],"obviant":[177],"dictis":[178],"Antiquorum,":[179],"diligo":[180],"tamen":[181],"personas":[182],"illorum.":[183],"I":[184,197,228,369,1461,2113,2264,2494,2702,3640,4431,4464,5109,5194,5763,7466,7482,7496,7550,8036,8159,9065,9110,9322,9924,9994,10012,10309],"am":[185,198,10310],"now":[186,770,1339,1811,2576,3095,3096,3382,3830,3998,7524,8149,8427,8655,8762,8827,9078,9270,9324,9773,10204,10506],"one":[187,2344,2688,3013,4733,5125,5302,6785,7138,7438,7816,9282,9676,10399],"ancients":[190,6954,7041,7063],"who":[191,1258,1780,2842,2857,3281,7008,7052,7084,8514,8522,8566,8676,8709,8757,9458,9470,9518,9706,10406],"called":[193,2520,3225,4589,7164],"backward-looking":[194],"by":[195,566,713,777,832,898,916,1100,1248,1284,1410,1598,2209,2881,2907,2934,2983,3060,3221,3291,3333,3351,3395,3485,3569,3739,3822,4055,4192,4204,4231,4239,4250,4658,4678,4734,4760,4776,5023,5036,5411,5829,6147,6328,6350,6755,6830,6849,6857,6882,7061,7135,7223,7276,7325,7435,7655,7789,8058,8129,8135,8256,8647,8700,8768,9164,9180,9384,9399,9410,9448,9516,9592,9624,9775,9784,9819,9831,9845,9856,9899,10050,10202,10243,10337,10481],"some.":[196],"old.":[199,7526],"They":[200,3902,4698,4737],"clever":[202],"young.":[204],"...although":[205],"this":[207,959,1685,1785,2026,2096,2373,2491,2572,2833,3008,3212,3299,3638,4102,4267,4304,4681,4785,4880,5044,5117,5150,5199,5528,5765,5777,6308,6597,6933,7059,7186,7410,7916,8018,8139,8309,8396,8932,8994,9154,9336,9656,9726],"work":[208,353,1072,1252,2177,5974,7805],"some":[209,448,1135,2258,3503,3599,3858,3990,4070,4100,4532,4643,5006,5293,5323,5897,6122,6865,7211,7588,7746,9327,9600],"things":[210,1756,1828,1866,3679,5294,5325,5401,6955,7025,7042,7504],"will":[211,370,1300,4858,8024,9323],"be":[212,308,522,754,1227,1301,1894,2055,2083,2139,2519,2566,2888,3266,3289,3591,3666,4317,4588,4665,4821,4859,5016,5075,5135,5180,5359,5373,5404,5444,5545,5610,5686,5708,6450,6780,7163,7252,7494,7715,8133,8228,8763,8964,9069,9082,9257,9492,10127,10207,10301],"said":[213,7132,7432],"against":[214,2410,8589],"opinions":[216],"moderni,":[219,320,6635,8779,10445],"where":[220,4961,5670,6380,6387],"they":[221,842,905,1769,1902,2256,2453,2931,2970,3245,4135,4511,4593,4802,5050,5073,5173,5273,5564,6373,6475,6681,6956,7043,7304,7701,8087,8533,9463,9671],"oppose":[222],"views":[224],"antiqui,":[227,6627,9469],"still":[229,1837,5429,5524,6237,7284,9208,9263,9995,10188,10275,10340,10446],"hold":[230],"them":[231,500,1203,2270,2303,2376,3394,4700,5357,6051,7712,9747],"dear":[232],"personally.":[233],"Jacobus,":[234,1101,1257,3614,4205,8784,9517],"book":[237,316,893,1245,1262,1520,1540,1565,1594,1633,1857,2539,2903],"7,":[238,1182,3166,4078,4174,4728,5064,5231,5432,6354,7685,10460],"chapter":[239,435,576,1661,2974,3201,4483,4906,6721,6727,7581,8310],"1":[240],"periods":[241],"rapid":[243],"conspicuous":[245],"change":[246,298,5930,5979,5984],"music":[248,273,346,599,616,723,1093,1332,1426,1434,1503,1524,2087,3339,3672,5501,10178,10226],"history":[249],"have":[250,737,982,1048,1076,1115,1380,1488,1533,1604,1873,2105,2421,3346,3488,3559,3567,3632,3693,3715,4136,4369,4432,4622,5530,5673,5864,6154,6313,6336,6477,6931,7053,7077,7288,7305,7365,7393,7516,8013,8456,8713,8726,9111,9547,9573,9621,9652,9731,9967,10026,10125,10253,10488],"repeatedly":[251],"been":[252,771,827,1008,1117,1381,1605,1646,1874,2384,2615,2711,3030,3347,3489,3560,3716,4624,5531,5674,5865,6314,6337,6478,7078,7152,7366,8460,9434,9548,9622,9653,9681,9732,10027,10043,10254,10489],"hailed":[253],"new:":[255],"ars":[257,400,1091,1192,1224,3597,3878,4299,4326,4491,4501,4693,4794,4872,4877,4974,5028,5078,5251,5256,5632,5786,5816,5850,5946,5966,5972,6007,6053,6065,6093,6262,6272,6299,6582,6661,6672,6695,6825,7227,7257,7296,7534,7571,7652,8163,8299,8314,8380,8390,8417,8423,8438,8594,8856,8868,8893,8913,8928,8944,8959,8997,9004,9041,9125,9226,9237,9244,9251,9285,9503,9524,10318],"nova":[258,915,1003,1092,1193,1225,2193,2214,2468,2529,3777,3879,3892,4011,4300,4327,4492,4795,4848,4878,5257,5633,5787,5817,5973,6008,6054,6066,6263,6273,6300,6662,6673,6826,7297,7572,8164,8381,8439,8914,8929,8945,8960,8998,9005,9042,9126,9227,9238,9245,9252,9286,9525,10319],"early":[261,1331,3369,3434,3922,3963,4026,4243,4298,5027,6660,6773,6791,6798,6876,7533,8162,8444,8943,9353,9626,9727,9766,9870,9941],"fourteenth":[262,727,7641,8144,8254,10120],"century,":[263,728,5398,8145],"seconda":[265],"prattica":[266],"c.1600,":[268],"many":[269,1290,1777,3698,6821,8237,8287,9105],"different":[270,6403,6519,8918],"currents":[271],"about":[275,1865,2086,2297,3364,4106,6040,8017,8659,9335,9445],"1910":[276],"present,":[279,5613],"especially":[280,402,2340,3848,6603],"\u2018new":[282,291],"music\u2019":[283,292,2508],"Second":[286],"World":[287],"War.":[288],"term":[290,7489,7570,9236],"continued":[293,8226],"through":[294,655,1999,4780,8026,8121,8603],"several":[295,641,7818],"waves":[296],"for":[299,518,555,627,695,793,1055,1272,1281,1295,1794,2102,2268,2563,2909,3035,3101,3118,3123,3310,3408,3432,3458,3509,3613,3680,3734,3799,3826,3989,4057,4069,4076,4363,4650,4853,4969,5414,5483,5493,5521,5577,5598,5668,5770,5835,5854,5874,6246,6394,6446,6502,6611,6614,6653,6683,6687,6775,6949,7208,7389,7480,7617,7733,8070,8199,8686,8693,8882,8978,9006,9015,9022,9160,9239,9725,9771,9934,9943,9991,10029,10090,10095,10305],"nearly":[300,5618],"whole":[302,2000],"twentieth":[303,5397],"century;":[304],"something":[305,7965],"similar":[306,3318,4058,4605,5319,6646,8948],"may":[307,1379,2420,3287,3343,3487,3566,3676,3692,4820,5672,5863,6310,6334,7273,7287,7401,8132,9571,10297,10486],"true":[309,5532],"fourteenth.":[312],"Karen":[313],"Desmond\u2019s":[314,352,855,1151,1214,1292,1388,2234,2828,3255,3387,3947,4151,4482,4905,6606,7580,8979,9195,9616,10015],"recent":[315,1355,7347,9446],"1300\u20131350":[321],"(henceforth":[322],"Desmond,":[323,4529,6895],"Moderni),1":[324],"together":[325,1068,2304,9044],"with":[326,541,571,1069,1208,1314,1676,1688,2133,2202,2445,2449,2513,2547,2634,3985,4019,4346,4562,4609,4667,4701,4705,4723,4732,4826,4871,4876,4941,5001,5013,5151,5249,5416,5637,5643,5689,5826,5923,6013,6114,6127,6293,6714,6941,7081,7141,7239,7278,7441,7566,7587,7980,8042,8178,8284,8297,8389,8489,8557,8667,8818,8986,9013,9019,9045,9172,9403,9482,9534,9552,9579,9709,9798,9836,9878,9931,10035,10129,10227,10382,10424,10443],"her":[327,377,441,1070,1244,1249,2185,3823,3986,4086,4323,7192,9157,9184],"2009":[328],"dissertation":[329,443],"a":[331,349,355,374,434,538,552,587,740,790,806,823,829,836,859,882,910,1010,1218,1269,1302,1363,1467,1490,1511,1599,1614,1641,1673,1677,2056,2173,2273,2313,2337,2389,2414,2427,2535,2548,2589,2624,2635,2650,2877,2895,3017,3076,3156,3181,3193,3317,3404,3427,3452,3517,3532,3574,3751,3807,3812,3867,3918,3931,3955,4020,4240,4275,4371,4441,4453,4470,4513,4544,4559,4563,4595,4835,4887,4967,5094,5120,5127,5130,5203,5282,5318,5389,5418,5437,5522,5692,5697,5725,5812,5929,5938,5961,5978,5983,6028,6083,6101,6401,6578,6585,6645,6685,6691,6743,6751,6756,6883,7082,7197,7200,7253,7359,7395,7519,7558,7596,7628,7646,7690,7722,7783,7804,7814,7959,8027,8052,8084,8189,8213,8279,8349,8498,8634,8680,8738,8769,8860,9007,9288,9425,9549,9611,9678,9696,9702,9795,9799,9811,9820,9824,9832,9837,9865,9872,9879,9951,9958,9988,10008,10030,10078,10091,10110,10143,10150,10257,10495],"series":[332],"ground-breaking":[334],"studies":[335],"published":[336,772],"since":[337,3607,8011,10077],"then,2":[338],"moves":[339],"mapping":[341],"newness":[343,8176],"fourteenth-century":[345,3596,7800,8325],"theory":[347,491,626,996,1525,2088,3340,3673,4156,4168,4520,6115,7475],"new":[350,1078,1220,1674,1889,2232,3228,4545,4619,4756,5550,6109,6348,6761,7015,7143,7418,7443,7518,8182,8519,8770,9106,9174,9316,9456,9460,9582,10280],"level.":[351],"shows":[354,3129,4416,9519],"deep":[356],"knowledge":[357,1978,9148,9521],"sources":[360,2440,3469,3688,4814,4936,4990,8238,9542,9570,10213],"is":[362,384,431,575,848,1177,1246,1268,1362,1401,1505,1521,1595,1861,1896,2097,2533,2553,2638,2654,2695,2867,2914,3179,3400,3417,3439,3609,3636,3721,3982,4179,4395,4429,4468,4530,4683,4779,5112,5133,5388,5435,5442,5470,5607,5700,5720,5778,5811,6010,6082,6111,6499,6534,6574,6669,6700,6753,6784,6788,6885,6897,7283,7523,7583,7688,7823,8057,8311,8484,8677,8690,8706,8792,8875,8884,8936,9116,9145,9279,9598,9781,9791,9814,9875,9886,9921,9987,10058,10086,10103,10172,10450],"full":[363,2274,2428],"stimulating":[365],"important":[367,569,1077,1250,2235,2824,4740],"observations.":[368,1298],"first":[371,1502,1519,2074,2196,2224,2327,2605,3621,4628,5621,5859,5878,6692,7914,9222,9527,9945,9989,10315],"review":[372,9325],"just":[373,1483,2423,5124,5716,8864,9205,9969],"few":[375,1479,2396,3467,6759,7360],"fine":[378,852],"achievements,":[379],"but":[380,480,1013,1374,1870,2002,2574,2730,3723,4132,4248,4892,4956,5171,5301,5452,5704,5982,6080,6494,6591,6636,6680,7229,7282,7299,7725,7921,7963,8316,8464,8528,8718,8760,9131,9364,9760,9892,9985,10037,10231],"my":[381,3052],"aim":[382],"here":[383,3730,5952,7260,7454,8556,9197],"address":[386],"more":[387,588,1061,1383,1428,1787,2306,2347,2549,3763,3815,3865,3944,4021,4209,4436,4553,4868,4896,5181,6247,6338,6570,6670,7346,7811,7942,8096,8688,9303,9959,10171,10335],"controversial":[388,9741,10039],"claims,":[389],"concentrating":[390],"on":[391,466,551,838,1073,1164,1253,1289,1317,1395,1672,2582,2672,2869,3186,3227,3338,4095,4113,4446,4558,5333,5620,5750,5823,5998,6031,6371,7058,7314,7409,8394,8765,8785,8950,9183,9658,9683,10134,10282,10458],"newly":[392],"proposed":[393,2061,3729],"datings":[394,1328,3725,3825,3988,4153,4324,9021,9186,9318],"definitions":[396],"what":[398,1143,1231,1306,1550,1644,3529,3564,3710,4399,4585,5754,5832,6447,6615,7248,7514,7622,8111,8125,8413,8874,8883,9329,9545],"constitutes":[399],"understood":[404,5506,5574,6146],"relation":[406,8473,8663],"Jacobus":[412,470,899,1200,1299,1530,3061,3083,3196,3236,3276,3330,3360,3391,3486,3514,3565,3585,3704,3747,3972,4051,5037,5059,5161,5208,6351,6381,6459,6548,6737,6929,6938,7075,7203,7245,7286,7460,7498,7552,7656,7699,7974,8170,8502,8708,9049,9144,9429,9586,9965,10051,10203,10397,10453,10484],"(SM),":[413],"moderns":[416,3537,5139,5167,7065,7157,7322,7348,8505,8661],"whose":[418,918,3800,4341,5562,8627],"innovations":[419,4329,4488,4549,7734,7749,8940,9447],"he":[420,1485,1514,2856,2999,3088,3158,3215,3312,3379,3542,3549,3711,3850,4358,4400,4406,4462,4467,5223,6388,6559,7068,7087,7249,7356,7664,7735,9094,9129,9137,10229,10232,10238,10265,10339],"objected.":[421,1534],"Desmond":[422,511,609,787,942,1059,1309,1421,1559,1681,2167,2569,2626,2677,2720,3780,3804,4079,4302,4332,4679,4789,4819,4930,5234,5665,5819,5891,6069,6242,6593,6684,7423,7536,7781,7907,8241,8292,8301,8426,8549,8654,8735,8826,9077,9361,9734,9893,9938,10071,10268],"ranges":[423],"widely.":[424],"Chapter":[425],"5,":[426,6722],"\u2018From":[427],"Trees":[428],"Degrees\u2019,":[430,4909],"same":[438,1443,1970,4631,5683,5885,8068,8262,8290],"name":[439,473,3903],"impressive":[442],"2009.":[445],"It":[446,1535,2391,2552,2886,3416,3635,4394,4778,5543,6265,6533,6868,7631,8705,10067,10392,10415],"addresses":[447,5209],"fundamental":[451,4897],"philosophical":[452],"debates":[453,2067,3271],"late":[456,3595,3612,3910,3960,3987,4152,6332,7331,7799,8143,8975,9020,9185,9756,10327],"thirteenth":[457],"century":[458,8233,8255],"that":[459,611,904,971,992,1198,1287,1453,1555,1684,1867,1917,2031,2062,2079,2092,2169,2191,2226,2237,2281,2288,2394,2403,2441,2585,2620,2637,2656,2713,2826,2832,2837,2853,2890,2921,2969,2989,2998,3056,3082,3105,3130,3254,3273,3301,3359,3425,3450,3522,3608,3642,3675,3703,3779,3792,3828,3846,3937,3997,4036,4120,4143,4155,4167,4266,4289,4382,4403,4443,4466,4531,4662,4742,4788,4833,5049,5058,5068,5165,5197,5222,5272,5292,5303,5353,5377,5402,5436,5485,5546,5591,5651,5681,5696,5705,5718,5724,5869,5960,6110,6132,6364,6390,6434,6464,6481,6490,6508,6541,7086,7139,7158,7202,7439,7450,7468,7503,7513,7541,7643,7803,8124,8305,8340,8451,8558,8701,8881,8889,8892,8934,9064,9114,9128,9343,9389,9462,9498,9585,9589,9633,9716,9751,9851,9881,9909,9964,10011,10017,10060,10076,10249,10270,10296,10313,10396,10429,10508],"centred":[460],"around":[461,1481,3341,3637,3900,4355,9648,9912,10186],"conflicting":[462],"interpretations":[463],"Aristotle":[465],"form":[467,2623],"matter.":[469],"does":[471,1459,2247,2392,2731,4958,5950,6560,6642,7955,8466,10099,10112,10147],"not":[472,738,1439,1872,1997,2248,2503,2696,2704,2732,3180,3198,3305,3422,3444,3665,3836,4270,4396,4469,4893,4928,4959,5129,5305,5498,5600,5608,5701,5721,5732,5951,5976,6056,6643,6892,6958,7037,7045,7633,7703,7717,7956,8166,8197,8312,8467,8516,8524,8707,8729,8909,9089,9117,9301,9365,9501,9508,9840,9978,10100,10113,10148],"Thomas":[474],"Aquinas":[475],"his":[477,484,490,502,556,617,634,648,659,924,1120,1322,1377,1418,1425,1431,1456,1471,1551,1557,1909,1918,2159,2295,2466,2477,2521,3036,3200,3234,3307,3654,4264,4449,5071,5296,6465,6942,7018,7310,7320,7469,7706,8216,8469,8569,8660,8665,8778,8795,8819,9366,9607,9628,9713,10061,10191,10250,10271,10421,10444,10499],"was":[481,920,1004,1144,1438,1536,2064,2195,2689,2839,2855,3062,3213,3331,3361,3530,4359,5385,5589,5755,5879,6460,7357,7553,7623,7632,7645,7810,8126,8181,8209,8358,8952,9397,9634,9897,10019,10083,10239,10266,10393,10398,10416,10454,10511],"aware":[482],"teaching":[485],"evidently":[487,921,3237,3392,3531],"approved":[488,6466,7088,7311],"unity":[493,8033],"forms,":[495,5217],"despite":[496],"opposition":[498],"hero,":[503],"English":[505],"Archbishop":[506],"Canterbury":[508],"Robert":[509],"Kilwardby.3":[510],"gives":[512,3075,3097],"clear":[513,1876,1933,1974,2655,2697,2836,4397,5221],"accounts":[514],"these":[516,1170,3570,4072,4829,4935,4963,5464,5661,5790,5921,8067,9779,9920],"debates,":[517,9401],"which":[519,583,703,846,981,1052,1183,1334,1376,1529,1546,1603,1808,2050,2406,2493,2676,2699,3681,4017,4114,4213,4461,4583,4719,6017,6303,6355,7024,7032,7269,7334,7400,7481,7549,7930,8158,8259,8491,8699,9017,9136,9217,9761,9923,10482],"musicologists":[520,586],"must":[521,1184,2716,3939,4157,4444,5175,5707,6312,6476,6794,9081,9491,9546,9619,9762]},"counts_by_year":[],"updated_date":"2026-10-30T12:39:25.321706","created_date":"2022-10-06T00:00:00"}