{"id":"https://openalex.org/W4246764580","doi":"https://doi.org/10.5325/philrhet.46.3.0351","title":"Obscene Demands","display_name":"Obscene Demands","publication_year":2013,"publication_date":"2013-07-01","ids":{"openalex":"https://openalex.org/W4246764580","doi":"https://doi.org/10.5325/philrhet.46.3.0351"},"language":"en","primary_location":{"id":"doi:10.5325/philrhet.46.3.0351","doi":"https://doi.org/10.5325/philrhet.46.3.0351","is_oa":false,"landing_page_url":"https://doi.org/10.5325/philrhet.46.3.0351","pdf_url":null,"source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S15273895","display_name":"Philosophy and Rhetoric","issn_l":"0031-8213","issn":["0031-8213","1527-2079"],"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":true,"listed_in":["anvur-class-a","anvur-scientific","cwts-core","erih-plus","jufo-1","norway-1","poland-70","russia-white-list-2","vabb-shw"],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/P4310320470","host_organization_name":"Penn State University Press","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/P4310320470"],"host_organization_lineage_names":["Penn State University Press"],"type":"journal"},"license":null,"license_id":null,"version":"publishedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":true,"raw_source_name":"Philosophy & Rhetoric","raw_type":"journal-article"},"volume":null,"type":"article","is_traditional":true,"indexed_in":["crossref"],"open_access":{"is_oa":false,"oa_status":"closed","oa_url":null,"any_repository_has_fulltext":false},"authorships":[{"author_position":"first","author":{"id":"https://openalex.org/A5016438947","display_name":"Sarah K. Burgess","orcid":"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-1989-4599","observed_orcids":["https://orcid.org/0000-0002-1989-4599"]},"institutions":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/I76766440","display_name":"University of San Francisco","ror":"https://ror.org/029m7xn54","country_code":"US","type":"education","lineage":["https://openalex.org/I76766440"]}],"countries":["US"],"is_corresponding":true,"raw_author_name":"Sarah Burgess","raw_affiliation_strings":["Department of Communication Studies, University of San Francisco"],"raw_orcid":null,"affiliations":[{"raw_affiliation_string":"Department of Communication Studies, University of San Francisco","institution_ids":["https://openalex.org/I76766440"]}]}],"institutions":[],"countries_distinct_count":1,"institutions_distinct_count":1,"corresponding_author_ids":["https://openalex.org/A5016438947"],"corresponding_institution_ids":["https://openalex.org/I76766440"],"apc_list":null,"apc_paid":null,"fwci":0.0,"has_fulltext":false,"cited_by_count":3,"citation_normalized_percentile":{"value":0.70246503,"is_in_top_1_percent":false,"is_in_top_10_percent":false},"cited_by_percentile_year":{"min":88,"max":93},"biblio":{"volume":"46","issue":"3","first_page":"351","last_page":"359"},"is_retracted":false,"is_paratext":false,"is_xpac":false,"primary_topic":{"id":"https://openalex.org/T11982","display_name":"Rhetoric and Communication Studies","score":0.8389000296592712,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/3315","display_name":"Communication"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/33","display_name":"Social Sciences"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},"topics":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/T11982","display_name":"Rhetoric and Communication Studies","score":0.8389000296592712,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/3315","display_name":"Communication"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/33","display_name":"Social Sciences"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},{"id":"https://openalex.org/T13814","display_name":"Cultural and political discourse analysis","score":0.07259999960660934,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/3310","display_name":"Linguistics and Language"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/33","display_name":"Social Sciences"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},{"id":"https://openalex.org/T11795","display_name":"Humor Studies and Applications","score":0.039400000125169754,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/3207","display_name":"Social Psychology"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/32","display_name":"Psychology"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}}],"keywords":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/apology","display_name":"apology","score":0.5799999833106995},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/political-rhetoric","display_name":"political rhetoric","score":0.4869999885559082},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/2012-presidential-campaign","display_name":"2012 presidential campaign","score":0.7440000176429749},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/mitt-romney","display_name":"Mitt Romney","score":0.7960000038146973},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/barack-obama","display_name":"Barack Obama","score":0.9810000061988831},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/political-lying","display_name":"political lying","score":0.30399999022483826},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/campaign-advertising","display_name":"campaign advertising","score":0.33500000834465027},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/truth-telling","display_name":"truth-telling","score":0.3319999873638153}],"concepts":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/C197487636","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q49892","display_name":"Presidential system","level":3,"score":0.6567451357841492},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C94625758","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q7163","display_name":"Politics","level":2,"score":0.6209303140640259},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C199539241","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q7748","display_name":"Law","level":1,"score":0.5100913643836975},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C17744445","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q36442","display_name":"Political science","level":0,"score":0.4597509205341339},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C29595303","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q165650","display_name":"Media studies","level":1,"score":0.35923200845718384},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C144024400","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q21201","display_name":"Sociology","level":0,"score":0.31186529994010925}],"mesh":[],"locations_count":2,"locations":[{"id":"doi:10.5325/philrhet.46.3.0351","doi":"https://doi.org/10.5325/philrhet.46.3.0351","is_oa":false,"landing_page_url":"https://doi.org/10.5325/philrhet.46.3.0351","pdf_url":null,"source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S15273895","display_name":"Philosophy and Rhetoric","issn_l":"0031-8213","issn":["0031-8213","1527-2079"],"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":true,"listed_in":["anvur-class-a","anvur-scientific","cwts-core","erih-plus","jufo-1","norway-1","poland-70","russia-white-list-2","vabb-shw"],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/P4310320470","host_organization_name":"Penn State University Press","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/P4310320470"],"host_organization_lineage_names":["Penn State University Press"],"type":"journal"},"license":null,"license_id":null,"version":"publishedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":true,"raw_source_name":"Philosophy & Rhetoric","raw_type":"journal-article"},{"id":"pmh:oai:muse.jhu.edu:/article/519915","doi":null,"is_oa":false,"landing_page_url":"https://muse.jhu.edu/pub/2/article/519915","pdf_url":null,"source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S4377196299","display_name":"Project Muse (Johns Hopkins University)","issn_l":null,"issn":null,"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":false,"listed_in":[],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/I145311948","host_organization_name":"Johns Hopkins University","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/I145311948"],"host_organization_lineage_names":[],"type":"repository"},"license":null,"license_id":null,"version":"submittedVersion","is_accepted":false,"is_published":false,"raw_source_name":"","raw_type":"text"}],"best_oa_location":null,"sustainable_development_goals":[{"id":"https://metadata.un.org/sdg/16","score":0.47620001435279846,"display_name":"Peace, justice, and strong institutions"}],"study_designs":[],"awards":[],"funders":[],"has_content":{"grobid_xml":false,"pdf":false},"content_urls":null,"referenced_works_count":2,"referenced_works":["https://openalex.org/W2273886774","https://openalex.org/W2326671057"],"related_works":["https://openalex.org/W6887667362","https://openalex.org/W6960309003","https://openalex.org/W2686434872","https://openalex.org/W3014979049","https://openalex.org/W2956147168","https://openalex.org/W2941427315","https://openalex.org/W6921335876","https://openalex.org/W2167415721","https://openalex.org/W1533472370","https://openalex.org/W7011520559"],"abstract_inverted_index":{"The":[0,29,37,185,434,500,994,1005,1042,1220,1294,1659,1739,1991,2640,2667,2688,2961,3134],"contemporary":[1,2580,3087,3158],"American":[2,1681],"political":[3,277,306,406,440,487,498,1605,1737,1827,1923,3088,3159,3254],"landscape":[4,2681],"is":[5,595,675,698,704,761,825,856,866,920,946,979,999,1016,1052,1064,1213,1241,1296,1316,1403,1411,1452,1519,1540,1601,1692,1696,1744,1751,1758,1820,1829,1849,1908,2126,2182,2213,2229,2237,2262,2276,2305,2310,2354,2389,2452,2474,2619,2657,2669,2686,2817,2915,3098,3136,3144,3165],"littered":[6],"with":[7,225,338,393,436,454,1182,1892,2556,3066,3146,3156,3235],"talk":[8],"of":[9,43,72,127,141,167,218,227,263,348,379,396,414,456,486,503,523,535,551,566,570,616,619,746,751,783,849,863,901,911,932,943,958,965,996,1044,1083,1106,1153,1164,1172,1185,1197,1208,1259,1267,1277,1287,1307,1329,1345,1387,1437,1505,1526,1620,1648,1654,1675,1741,1754,1853,1864,1906,1921,1937,1943,1993,2005,2010,2024,2035,2052,2056,2099,2190,2284,2343,2366,2376,2384,2393,2396,2406,2411,2430,2438,2465,2499,2532,2546,2572,2587,2597,2606,2636,2654,2662,2690,2714,2727,2760,2796,2861,2885,2925,2934,2963,2992,3008,3073,3131,3141,3193,3210,3229,3238,3244,3253],"apology.":[10,223,967,983,1779,2435],"Throughout":[11],"the":[12,48,90,95,106,111,139,165,202,280,301,309,320,324,344,349,372,376,412,431,449,470,484,519,536,549,561,567,574,598,636,685,707,722,744,808,832,842,847,861,875,902,909,930,963,971,977,985,997,1011,1014,1020,1031,1035,1055,1070,1078,1081,1086,1090,1101,1126,1151,1162,1165,1178,1193,1201,1206,1224,1243,1247,1253,1275,1302,1305,1318,1346,1352,1383,1417,1429,1440,1476,1479,1488,1494,1500,1503,1545,1574,1598,1610,1612,1637,1641,1646,1649,1652,1655,1666,1673,1676,1680,1689,1693,1716,1723,1736,1742,1752,1783,1793,1801,1854,1857,1859,1865,1885,1889,1904,1918,1940,1944,1958,1961,1974,1983,2003,2006,2011,2022,2030,2033,2097,2112,2121,2171,2176,2191,2224,2251,2255,2267,2282,2317,2332,2341,2348,2352,2364,2367,2374,2377,2391,2409,2412,2423,2458,2463,2479,2492,2500,2513,2527,2530,2547,2585,2595,2604,2621,2624,2631,2634,2637,2644,2652,2659,2675,2691,2697,2758,2784,2803,2806,2827,2834,2844,2883,2901,2923,2932,2977,2990,3005,3052,3055,3063,3071,3086,3094,3110,3124,3128,3139,3142,3147,3149,3157,3181,3189,3194,3208,3213,3218,3227,3250],"2012":[13],"presidential":[14],"campaign,":[15],"both":[16,427,592,1301,1362,1581,2363],"camps":[17],"sparred":[18],"over":[19,386,2969],"when,":[20],"why,":[21],"and":[22,129,180,236,346,381,451,495,509,521,540,582,594,657,820,890,917,1067,1232,1280,1292,1304,1359,1367,1409,1498,1651,1817,1927,2048,2082,2175,2373,2443,2462,2477,2481,2633,2695,2793,2839,2891,2927,2967,3080,3196,3223],"to":[23,88,105,108,110,123,130,159,201,242,284,318,384,482,633,642,660,679,682,688,754,763,769,791,810,844,974,1018,1215,1250,1382,1406,1443,1455,1521,1542,1589,1678,1727,1731,1745,1760,1811,1871,1878,1933,1953,1978,2021,2101,2108,2111,2145,2148,2153,2184,2265,2402,2487,2543,2584,2646,2710,2719,2724,2739,2748,2751,2755,2765,2772,2782,2841,2871,2894,2917,2945,2957,2984,3014,3024,3033,3050,3101,3122,3224,3247],"whom":[24],"apologies":[25,418,627,747,766,1116,1168],"should":[26,239,1465,1633],"be":[27,240,741,792,811,894,951,1251,1355,1901,2017,2290,2720,2733,2737,2749,2756,2773,2958,3004,3173],"made.":[28,2687],"most":[30],"striking":[31],"clash":[32],"occurred":[33],"in":[34,54,60,206,371,404,600,625,629,684,731,743,835,846,1010,1033,1085,1156,1180,1192,1246,1324,1378,1393,1433,1579,1640,1687,1768,1792,1823,1926,1966,1976,1985,2140,2162,2179,2226,2351,2476,2569,2608,2626,2651,2682,2699,2721,2729,2740,2757,2770,2846,2854,2882,2936,2976,3029,3054,3070,3115,3180],"July":[35],"2012.":[36],"Obama":[38,179,231,1599,1629,1662,3102],"camp":[39],"ran":[40],"a":[41,61,75,133,189,207,215,261,289,394,402,422,532,564,588,613,752,755,850,878,898,933,1025,1142,1210,1260,1283,1327,1426,1434,1534,1577,1617,1729,1732,1804,1842,1851,1897,1922,1934,2036,2053,2092,2129,2188,2196,2199,2211,2235,2246,2274,2285,2327,2338,2344,2394,2404,2431,2541,2544,2557,2565,2570,2577,2598,2663,2672,2678,2684,2722,2725,2768,2850,2855,2859,2880,2910,2970,3025,3043,3068,3107,3184,3191,3200,3236],"series":[42],"campaign":[44,134,1795],"advertisements":[45],"alleging":[46],"that":[47,94,161,169,209,230,237,253,293,458,553,572,626,691,726,801,860,867,877,948,961,1013,1093,1115,1139,1150,1175,1191,1212,1226,1242,1317,1334,1351,1364,1385,1399,1402,1424,1473,1478,1492,1531,1597,1684,1691,1703,1757,1782,1830,1899,2032,2066,2070,2077,2091,2131,2194,2210,2234,2245,2273,2446,2450,2466,2471,2495,2512,2559,2574,2591,2620,2712,2786,2865,2887,2897,2972,2986,2994,3045,3057,3126,3171,3206,3220,3240],"then":[49,1048,2508,2781],"presumptive":[50],"Republican":[51],"nominee":[52],"had":[53,67,97,678,2515],"fact":[55,732],"remained":[56],"at":[57,144,1229,1233,1502,1903,2808,3161],"Bain":[58],"Capitol":[59],"leadership":[62],"role":[63,2161,2605],"longer":[64],"than":[65,245,333,1608,1626],"he":[66,117,238,294,303,1770,1774,1808,3058],"claimed,":[68],"bolstering":[69],"their":[70,1585,1591,2160],"characterization":[71],"Romney":[73,102,150,228,1593,1668,1695,1721,1780,1798],"as":[74,156,214,288,315,330,929,953,981,1022,1120,1169,1421,1469,1528,1715,1894,1910,2019,2084,2198,2223,2337,2416,2564,2594,2826,2833,2929,2981,3118],"businessman":[76],"whose":[77,2836],"business":[78],"was":[79,210,286,313,1038,2830],"not":[80,233,267,669,714,805,1049,1454,1482,1631,1634,1664,1839,1877,2135,2168,2319,2670,2825,3099,3176],"good":[81],"for":[82,132,164,199,221,246,260,305,375,401,444,472,538,563,590,621,650,795,807,935,1103,1263,1320,1326,1348,1375,1419,1513,1547,1556,1570,1576,1604,1616,1636,1661,1699,1706,1778,1841,1946,1948,2001,2013,2062,2074,2088,2094,2159,2170,2346,2362,2398,2408,2433,2540,2561,2576,2582,2674,2788,2912,2919,2950,2989,3106],"America.1":[83],"When":[84,177,265,2060],"Romney's":[85,219,311,336,1568,2948,2974,3031,3060,3096],"aide":[86],"failed":[87],"quiet":[89],"critique":[91],"by":[92,212,323,506,597,897,1357,1862,1888,2215,2239,2278,2792,2819,3075,3199],"claiming":[93,229,3067],"candidate":[96],"\u201cretired":[98],"retroactively\u201d":[99],"(DeLong":[100],"2012),":[101],"himself":[103,1397],"took":[104],"airwaves":[107],"speak":[109,2437,2842,3221],"situation.":[112],"On":[113,279,308],"Friday,":[114],"13":[115],"July,":[116],"appeared":[118,248],"on":[119,136,193,421,749,871,1002,1030,1050,1060,1332,1361,1496,1688,1710,1814,2292,2422,2518,2643],"five":[120],"different":[121,3201],"networks":[122],"condemn":[124],"these":[125,528,578,1994,2536],"types":[126],"attacks":[128,168,2993,3125],"call":[131,1347,1647,1840],"centered":[135],"issues,":[137],"sidestepping":[138],"question":[140,987,1882],"his":[142,173,181,1268,1445,1704,1762,1776,1790,2964,2998,3047,3132,3186],"tenure":[143],"Bain.":[145],"In":[146,556,719,1109,1487,1643,2340,2522,2550,2743,3226],"an":[147,222,316,646,817,822,912,954,966,982,1023,1045,1074,1095,1157,1256,1470,1524,1529,1571,1595,1846,1967,2046,2117,2156,2185,2216,2240,2279,2355,2382,2428,2434,2453,2504,2823,3035,3169,3204],"ABC":[148],"interview,":[149],"emphatically":[151],"stated,":[152],"\u201cHe":[153,2979],"[Obama]":[154],"sure":[155,258,2980],"heck":[157,2982],"ought":[158,2983],"say":[160,296,476,661,2209,2233,2272,2985],"he's":[162,266,2987],"sorry":[163,889,892,2988],"kinds":[166,2991],"are":[170,554,623,640,1117,1686,1766,1786,1868,1982,2064,2104,2143,2554,2779,2790,2995,3127,3232],"coming":[171,2996],"from":[172,276,464,494,648,1806,2029,2503,2694,2997,3168],"team\u201d":[174,2999],"(Shear":[175,1796,3000],"2012).":[176,342,1797,3001],"asked,":[178],"team":[182,1600],"refused":[183],"comment.":[184],"next":[186,377],"day,":[187],"however,":[188,364,429,1089,1149,2494],"video":[190],"advertisement":[191,1660],"posted":[192],"YouTube":[194],"titled":[195],"\u201cMitt":[196,255],"Romney:":[197],"Asking":[198],"Apologies\u201d\u2014attributed":[200],"\u201cTruth":[203,1613],"Team\u201d\u2014did":[204],"respond":[205,2152,2647],"manner":[208],"read":[211,287,314,328,390,420,952,1119,1559,2918],"pundits":[213],"blatant":[216],"refusal":[217,283],"demand":[220,312,337,537,589,603,645,729,879,934,1102,1225,1295,1319,1418,1546,1569,1650,1677,1705,1724,1743,1777,1837,1890,1945,1959,2012,2037,2093,2122,2197,2212,2220,2236,2256,2275,2286,2302,2318,2333,2345,2353,2432,2442,2501,2514,2528,2685,2692,2804,2812,2822,2851,2874,2911,2949,2965,3034,3053,3097,3111,3143,3164,3187,3214],"Interspersed":[224],"clips":[226],"does":[232,668,713,1481,1663,1838,1957,1970,2134],"understand":[234,831,1466,2603,2783],"freedom":[235],"apologizing":[241],"America":[243],"rather":[244,814,1607,1625],"it,":[247,480],"three":[249],"simple":[250],"blue":[251],"screens":[252],"read:":[254],"Romney.":[256],"He":[257],"asks":[259],"lot":[262],"apologies.":[264],"busy":[268],"launching":[269],"attacks.\u201dThis":[270],"exchange":[271,1325],"triggered":[272],"almost":[273,477,2866],"predictable":[274,382],"responses":[275,383],"commentators.":[278],"right,":[281],"Obama's":[282,1711,1815],"apologize":[285,683,1635],"white":[290],"flag\u2014an":[291],"admission":[292],"could":[295],"nothing":[297,478,2243],"without":[298,1587],"publicly":[299],"acknowledging":[300],"lies":[302,447,1603],"told":[304],"gain.":[307],"left,":[310],"attempt":[317],"evade":[319],"questions":[321,1938,1995],"raised":[322],"advertisements,":[325],"although":[326],"some":[327,1746,1911,2042,2741],"it":[329,355,361,365,493,674,703,915,919,1057,1228,1239,1313,1451,1539,1623,1671,1750,1831,1880,1893,2132,2154,2181,2228,2309,2359,2390,2491,2509,2629,2649,2701,2898,2930,2938,3020,3082,3090,3119],"even":[331,352,399,734,896,3117],"less":[332],"this,":[334],"equating":[335],"\u201ccrying":[339],"uncle\u201d":[340],"(Easley":[341],"Had":[343],"back":[345,3023],"forth":[347],"commentary":[350],"been":[351,2080,2484],"somewhat":[353],"novel,":[354],"might":[356,388,730,740,767,1098,1389,1509,1583,1900,2469,2526,2899,3003],"have":[357,653,694,1133,1390,1915,2078,2711,3038],"become":[358,1657,3017],"exhausting.":[359],"As":[360,1338,2116,2202,2703,3183,3203],"played":[362],"out,":[363],"just":[366],"lay":[367],"there":[368,2261,2451],"already":[369,2079,2421,2454,2505,2718,2878],"dead":[370],"water,":[373],"waiting":[374],"wave":[378],"issues":[380,1775],"wash":[385],"it.One":[387],"certainly":[389,1876],"this":[391,467,558,602,608,799,941,1062,1104,1154,1308,1336,1644,1824,1873,1971,1987,2141,2149,2163,2370,2380,2441,2472,2488,2520,2941,3078],"scene":[392,599,618,942,1562,2142,2424,2548,2664,2668,2698,2759,2769,2884,2933,3044,3072,3079,3140,3160,3209],"sort":[395],"cynicism":[397],"or":[398,417,491,655,696,700,724,758,788,907,924,1054,1130,1160,1537,1632,1844,1881,1963,2040,2058,2137,2151,2259,2307,2325,2388,2439,2680,2735,2863,3011,3178],"nostalgia":[400],"time":[403],"our":[405,452,1511,1560,2497,2946],"life":[407,1924],"when":[408,1122,1135,1998,2425,2952],"things":[409],"were":[410,419],"otherwise\u2014when":[411],"truth":[413,3246],"speech":[415,525,579,1036,1468,1816,2676,2890],"mattered":[416],"moral":[423,1733],"register.":[424],"I":[425,644,677,709,1136,1140,1273,1289,1299,2821,2873,2877,2906],"think":[426],"attitudes,":[428],"miss":[430],"larger":[432,1935],"point.":[433],"quickness":[435],"which":[437,577,601,836,1027,1034,1580,1807,1949,1986,2180,2227,2683,2700,2730,2905,2937,3015,3030],"we":[438,830,1415,1464,1558,1565,1685,1999,2068,2166,2322,2417,2426,2538,2553,2943,3231],"discount":[439],"speech,":[441,3216,3230],"having":[442],"seen":[443,3174],"years":[445],"what":[446,692,914,926,1051,1288,1311,1769,2371,2613],"behind":[448],"curtain,":[450],"obsession":[453],"memories":[455],"times":[457],"perhaps":[459,3153],"never":[460,1708],"were,":[461],"keep":[462],"us":[463,515,611,839,1916,1997,2602],"investigating":[465],"how":[466,587,765,918,1061,1544,1567,2525,2802,2920],"beastly":[468],"creature,":[469],"\u201cdemand":[471],"apology,\u201d":[473],"operates.":[474,2702,2939],"We":[475,2414,2468,2778],"about":[479,511,548,1533,1551,1939],"preferring":[481],"lament":[483],"state":[485,753,1584],"rhetoric":[488],"more":[489,1404,3154],"generally":[490],"reading":[492],"through":[496,576,1563,1928,2155,2478],"established":[497,2455],"stances.":[499],"rich":[501],"body":[502],"literature":[504],"produced":[505],"rhetorical":[507,568,1912,2177],"theorists":[508],"critics":[510],"apology":[512,591,622,647,664,712,796,818,843,865,949,992,998,1006,1046,1063,1075,1079,1096,1105,1158,1221,1248,1321,1349,1376,1388,1420,1527,1548,1572,1707,1947,2014,2025,2063,2095,2399,2562,2583,2607,2789,2824,2913,3036],"itself":[513,1199,1756,2133,2334,2956],"offers":[514,3188],"important":[516],"insights":[517],"into":[518,940],"potential":[520],"limits":[522],"such":[524,1121,2767],"acts.":[526],"Yet":[527,2612],"studies":[529],"rarely":[530,797],"include":[531],"sustained":[533],"investigation":[534],"apology,":[539,1024,1194,2157,2347,2951],"if":[541,829,1413,2496,2815],"they":[542,544,803,1123,2071],"do,":[543],"make":[545,1365,2849,3051],"certain":[546],"presumptions":[547],"operations":[550],"demands":[552,571,794,1073,1374,2061,2397,2461,2560,2581,2593,2787],"suspect.":[555,1236],"response,":[557,585],"essay":[559],"highlights":[560],"need":[562],"study":[565],"complexities":[569],"examines":[573],"conditions":[575,819,1032,1082,1984,2004,2178,2903],"acts":[580,1171,2076],"structure":[581,2531,2794],"invoke":[583,1845,1960],"another's":[584],"revealing":[586,1896],"constitutes":[593,2696,2931],"conditioned":[596,2791],"takes":[604,928,1672,1809],"place.":[605],"Implicitly":[606],"then,":[607,2125],"argument":[609],"pushes":[610],"toward":[612],"renewed":[614],"interrogation":[615],"rhetoric's":[617],"address.Demands":[620],"curious":[624],"proffered":[628],"response":[630,1619,1653,1712,1834,1843,2247,2328],"sometimes":[631],"fail":[632,768],"sufficiently":[634],"resolve":[635],"demand.":[637,851,1166,1694,1866,2268,2339,2413,2467,2489],"Such":[638,738],"scenes":[639,2795],"familiar":[641,1826],"us.":[643,2666],"you":[649,652,658,681,693,736,1138,2893],"something":[651],"said":[654,695,1053],"done,":[656],"turn":[659,2539],"\u201csorry.\u201d":[662],"Your":[663],"though,":[665,1701,3212],"however":[666],"uttered,":[667],"fully":[670,1954],"satisfy":[671],"me.":[672],"Perhaps":[673,702],"because":[676,1286,1298,1749,2218,2242,2281,2321,2331,2358,2628,2648,3138],"ask":[680,798,806],"first":[686,1794,2764],"place,":[687],"point":[689],"out":[690,3105],"done":[697],"wrong":[699],"injurious.":[701],"because,":[705],"given":[706,1702,1789],"injury":[708,2057,2480,2864],"incurred,":[710],"your":[711],"quite":[715,1147],"feel":[716],"like":[717,2615],"enough.":[718],"any":[720,864,1833],"case,":[721,2493],"anger":[723],"hurt":[725],"prompted":[727],"my":[728,1278,2869,2889],"remain":[733],"after":[735,1773],"apologize.":[737],"emotions":[739],"magnified":[742],"context":[745],"offered":[748,3167],"behalf":[750],"specific":[756],"group":[757],"population.":[759],"It":[760,1848,1931],"easy":[762],"imagine":[764,1543],"\u201cmake":[770],"up":[771],"for\u201d":[772],"historical":[773,2075],"atrocities.":[774],"\u201cWe're":[775],"sorry\u201d":[776],"can":[777,1549,2208,2232,2271,2600,2732,2736,2811,3172],"hardly":[778],"right":[779,1520,2838],"involuntary":[780],"internment,":[781],"abuse":[782],"indigenous":[784],"peoples,":[785],"institutionalized":[786],"racism,":[787],"genocide.":[789],"But,":[790],"fair,":[793],"much;":[800],"is,":[802,2067,2447],"do":[804,2167,2799],"situation":[809],"\u201cfixed\u201d":[812],"but":[813,1059,1370,1553,1875,2329,2832,3175],"addressed":[815,2183,2734,3177],"(ethically).That":[816],"performs":[821],"ethical":[823],"address":[824,1665,1679,2886,2935,3074],"worth":[826],"noting":[827],"only":[828,1118,1414,2320,2814,3234],"complex":[833],"ways":[834,1279,2785],"language":[837,2921,2962,3007,3061],"trips":[838],"up,":[840],"causing":[841],"stumble":[845],"face":[848],"Sara":[852],"Ahmed's":[853],"work":[854,876,964,2552],"here":[855,1870],"helpful.":[857],"She":[858,968],"argues":[859,1398,2590],"difficulty":[862],"its":[868,872,1003,1107,1514,2444],"utterance":[869,978,1021],"cannot":[870,893,2289,2323],"own":[873,3048],"perform":[874,1124],"demands.":[880],"\u201cOf":[881],"course,\u201d":[882],"she":[883],"explains,":[884,1340],"\u201cthe":[885,1195,1422],"gap":[886],"between":[887,2457],"saying":[888],"being":[891],"filled,":[895],"\u2018good":[899],"performance\u2019":[900],"utterance\u201d":[903],"(2004,":[904,1040,2114],"114).":[905],"Felicitous":[906],"not,":[908,1909],"performance":[910,1152,1852],"apology\u2014both":[913],"says":[916,1771],"said\u2014cannot":[921],"effect,":[922,2445],"guarantee,":[923],"authenticate":[925],"Ahmed":[927,945],"object":[931],"apology:":[936],"feeling":[937],"sorry.":[938],"Thus":[939,1069],"address\u2014and":[944],"clear":[947],"must":[950,2296,2418,2510],"interlocutionary":[955],"scene\u2014a":[956],"problem":[957],"recognition":[959,2051,2336,2361,2813],"appears":[960,1249],"confounds":[962],"explains:":[969,2206],"So":[970,984,1884],"receiver":[972],"has":[973,2483],"judge":[975],"whether":[976,1077,2250,2260,2299,2308],"readable":[980],"following":[986],"becomes":[988,1200,1573],"intelligible:":[989],"Does":[990],"\u201cthis\u201d":[991],"\u201capologise\u201d?":[993],"action":[995],"curiously":[1000],"dependent":[1001],"reception.":[1004],"may":[1007,1380,1718,2016],"\u201cdo":[1008],"something\u201d":[1009],"event":[1012],"other":[1015,1962,2523,2625,2645,2744],"willing":[1017],"receive":[1019],"willingness,":[1026],"will":[1028,1354,1630,2248],"depend":[1029],"act":[1037,1530,1753,2383,3205],"uttered.":[1039],"115)":[1041],"success":[1043],"depends":[1047],"emotion":[1056],"conveys":[1058],"\u201ctaken":[1065],"up\u201d":[1066],"read.":[1068],"one":[1071,2252,2264,2270,2295,2448,2459,2716,2731,2746,2753,2762,2816,3114],"who":[1072,2103,2253,2460,2829],"judges":[1076],"meets":[1080],"recognizability":[1084],"particular":[1087,2054,3116],"context.Paradoxically,":[1088],"very":[1091,2192,2902,3251],"terms":[1092,2034,3056],"render":[1094],"recognizable":[1097],"effectively":[1099],"strip":[1100],"force.":[1108],"recent":[1110],"work,":[1111],"Adam":[1112],"Ellwanger":[1113,1145,1189,1339,1396,1490,1518,2589],"suggests":[1114],"metanoia,":[1125],"subject's":[1127],"internal":[1128,1257],"conversion":[1129],"transformation.":[1131],"(I":[1132],"apologized":[1134],"show":[1137],"am":[1141,1300],"changed":[1143,1284],"person.)":[1144],"demonstrates":[1146],"convincingly,":[1148],"metanoia":[1155],"negates":[1159],"undermines":[1161],"force":[1163,1456,2689],"Understanding":[1167],"(speech)":[1170],"public":[1173,1183,1394,1506],"humiliation":[1174],"ultimately":[1176],"bring":[1177,1550],"offender":[1179,1431,1480],"line":[1181],"norms":[1184],"civility":[1186],"(2012,":[1187,1218,1271,1372,1447,1461,1485,1516],"309),":[1188],"claims":[1190,1491,1638,1800,1861,2090],"activity":[1196],"confession":[1198,1254],"punitive":[1202,1216,1343],"mechanism.":[1203],"This":[1204,1836,3002],"creates":[1205],"illusion":[1207],"self-censure,":[1209],"phenomenon":[1211],"crucial":[1214],"apologetics\u201d":[1217],"310).":[1219],"thus":[1222,2916,3166],"renders":[1223,1832],"occasioned":[1227],"best":[1230,1453],"irrelevant":[1231,1240,1748],"worst":[1234],"logically":[1235,1314],"What":[1237,1819,1981],"makes":[1238,1312,2254],"self-punishment":[1244],"enacted":[1245],"self-motivated;":[1252],"evidences":[1255],"transformation":[1258],"subject":[1261,2410,2828,2835],"that,":[1262],"Ellwanger,":[1264,1564,2614],"occurs":[1265],"\u201cindependently":[1266],"accusers'":[1269],"demands\u201d":[1270],"324).":[1272],"see":[1274,1566],"error":[1276],"find":[1281],"myself":[1282],"person":[1285],"now":[1290,2105],"know":[1291],"understand.":[1293],"occluded":[1297],"origin":[1303],"effect":[1306],"self-transformation.":[1309],"And":[1310],"suspect":[1315],"promises":[1322,1791],"forgiveness":[1323,1366,1497],"form":[1328],"punishment":[1330],"predicated":[1331],"relationships":[1333],"prohibit":[1335],"forgiveness.":[1337],"\u201cThe":[1341],"covertly":[1342],"goals":[1344,1765],"ensure":[1350],"dialogue":[1353,1408],"defined":[1356],"agonism":[1358],"antipathy":[1360],"sides\u2014conditions":[1363],"reconciliation":[1368,1536],"all":[1369,2120],"impossible\u201d":[1371],"326).That":[1373],"end":[1377],"paradox":[1379],"lead":[1381],"conclusion":[1384],"discourses":[1386],"limited":[1391],"application":[1392],"arenas.":[1395],"\u201ca":[1400,1457],"space":[1401],"conducive":[1405],"honest":[1407,1902],"negotiation\u201d":[1410],"possible":[1412],"rethink":[1416],"kategoria":[1423,2586,2622],"initiates":[1425],"conversation":[1427,1578,2599,2627],"where":[1428,2658],"accused":[1430],"engages":[1432],"vocal":[1435],"defense":[1436],"himself,":[1438],"while":[1439],"accusers":[1441],"seek":[1442,2072],"prove":[1444],"guilt\u201d":[1446],"326).":[1448,1462,1486],"For":[1449],"him,":[1450],"necessarily":[1458],"dubious":[1459],"metanoia\u201d":[1460],"Instead,":[1463,1670],"apologetic":[1467,1507],"antagonistic":[1471],"debate":[1472],"allows":[1474,1725],"\u201cfor":[1475],"possibility":[1477],"want":[1483],"reconciliation\u201d":[1484],"end,":[1489],"\u201cminimizing":[1493],"emphasis":[1495],"admitting":[1499],"conflict":[1501],"heart":[1504],"discourse":[1508],"temper":[1510],"expectations":[1512],"outcomes\u201d":[1515],"326).Although":[1517],"caution":[1522],"against":[1523,3083,3093],"understanding":[1525,2661],"brings":[1532],"total":[1535],"transformation,":[1538],"hard":[1541],"anything":[1552],"stasis.":[1554],"If,":[1555],"instance,":[1557,2089],"original":[1561],"occasion":[1575,1674,2294],"parties":[1582],"case":[1586,1717,2342],"seeking":[1588],"reconcile":[1590],"positions.":[1592],"levels":[1594],"accusation":[1596,2567,2641],"telling":[1602,2375,2381],"gain":[1606],"engaging":[1609],"issues;":[1611],"Team\u201d":[1614],"opts":[1615],"preschooler's":[1618],"\u201che":[1621],"did":[1622],"first\u201d":[1624],"explains":[1627],"why":[1628],"made":[1639,2568],"advertisement.":[1642],"example,":[1645],"(non)apology":[1656],"unhinged.":[1658],"complaints":[1667],"levels.":[1669],"people,":[1682],"suggesting":[1683,2045],"joke":[1690],"no":[1697,2263,2516,3113],"worse":[1698],"wear,":[1700],"turned":[1709],"(or":[1713],"nonresponse,":[1714],"be).":[1719],"That":[1720],"issued":[1722,3100],"him":[1726],"stake":[1728],"claim":[1730,2558],"position":[1734,1805],"within":[1735,3222],"scene.":[1738,2639,2978,3095],"content":[1740,2365],"extent":[1747],"demanding":[1755],"meant":[1759,2311],"accomplish":[1761],"goals.":[1763],"These":[1764],"revealed":[1767,2350],"immediately":[1772],"comments":[1781],"president's":[1784],"allegations":[1785],"\u201cvery":[1787],"disappointing\u201d":[1788],"thereby":[1799],"high":[1802],"ground,":[1803],"authority":[1810,2632,2840,2870,3049],"pass":[1812],"judgment":[1813],"actions.":[1818],"so":[1821,2800],"interesting":[1822],"overly":[1825],"strategy":[1828],"inconsequential.":[1835],"other.2":[1847],"instead":[1850],"place":[1855,1973,2679,2881,3069,3197,3228],"(and":[1856,3084],"power)":[1858],"speaker":[1860,2807],"virtue":[1863],"All":[1867],"called":[1869,2106,2780],"witness":[1872,2110,3123],"spectacle":[1874],"engage":[1879],"it.":[1883,2820,3225],"\u201cconversation\u201d":[1886],"begun":[1887],"ends":[1891],"well,":[1895],"stasis":[1898],"cost":[1905],"truth.This":[1907],"scholars":[1913],"would":[1914,3037],"believe,":[1917],"necessary":[1919],"result":[1920],"constituted":[1925],"agonistic":[1929],"debate.":[1930,2611],"gestures":[1932],"set":[1936,2726],"rhetorical-ethical":[1941],"contours":[1942],"current":[1950],"scholarship":[1951],"fails":[1952,2665],"account.":[1955],"How":[1956,1969],"bind":[1964],"another":[1965,2300],"address?":[1968,2533],"invocation":[1972],"interlocutors":[1975],"relation":[1977,1988,2713],"each":[1979,2293],"other?":[1980],"functions":[1989],"ethically?":[1990],"complexity":[1992],"confound":[1996],"take":[2000],"granted":[2002],"demand's":[2007],"recognizability.":[2008],"Considerations":[2009],"(which":[2015],"treated":[2018],"supplemental":[2020],"exploration":[2023],"itself)":[2026],"often":[2027],"proceed":[2028],"premise":[2031,2392],"merely":[2038,2671],"represent":[2039],"narrate":[2041],"previous":[2043],"injury,":[2044],"ontologically":[2047],"temporally":[2049],"prior":[2050,2486],"history":[2055,2098,2130,2150,2172,2349,2357,2368,2387,2860,2971],"violence.":[2059],"made,":[2065],"presume":[2069,2403],"redress":[2073],"deemed":[2081],"recognized":[2083],"morally":[2085],"wrong.":[2086],"Ahmed,":[2087],"\u201cexposes":[2096],"violence":[2100,2862],"others,":[2102,2617],"upon":[2107],"bear":[2109],"injustice\u201d":[2113],"119).":[2115],"expository":[2118],"act,":[2119,2677],"seemingly":[2123],"does,":[2124,3059],"carry":[2127],"forward":[2128],"constitute":[2136],"color.":[2138],"Interlocutors":[2139],"asked":[2144],"\u201cbear":[2146],"witness\u201d":[2147],"accounting":[2158],"history.":[2164],"Because":[2165],"account":[2169,2429,2498],"itself\u2014its":[2173],"constitution":[2174],"audience\u2014we":[2186],"lose":[2187],"sense":[2189],"thing":[2193],"marks":[2195],"demand:":[2200],"risk.":[2201,2809],"Alexander":[2203],"Garc\u00eda":[2204],"D\u00fcttmann":[2205],"One":[2207,2231,2810],"marked":[2214,2238,2277],"uncertainty":[2217,2222,2241,2280],"every":[2219],"requires":[2221],"medium":[2225],"raised.":[2230],"ensures":[2244],"ensue,":[2249],"encounters":[2257],"indifference":[2258],"hear":[2266],"Finally":[2269],"seriousness":[2283],"(for":[2287,2303],"recognition)":[2288,2304],"guaranteed;":[2291],"decide":[2297],"anew":[2298],"person's":[2301],"feigned":[2306],"seriously.":[2312],"(2000,":[2313],"10\u201311)":[2314],"Risk":[2315],"attends":[2316],"predict":[2324],"guarantee":[2326],"also":[2330,2400,3021],"seeks":[2335],"uncertain":[2356],"needs":[2360,2717,2747,2754,2763],"(is":[2369,2379],"happened?)":[2372],"story":[2378],"laying":[2385],"bare":[2386],"joke?).Theorists":[2395],"seem":[2401],"kind":[2405],"standing":[2407,2975,3032],"are,":[2415],"be,":[2419],"always":[2420,2867],"give":[2427],"To":[2436,2534,2798,2848],"theorize":[2440],"presumes":[2449],"relationship":[2456,2473,2723],"addressee":[2464],"argue":[2470],"inaugurated":[2475],"therefore":[2482],"structured":[2485],"Is":[2490],"precedes":[2502],"inhabited":[2506],"scene,":[2507],"follow":[2511],"influence":[2517],"setting":[2519],"scene?":[2521],"words,":[2524,2745],"change":[2529],"answer":[2535],"questions,":[2537],"moment":[2542],"consideration":[2545],"itself.":[2549],"Ellwanger's":[2551],"met":[2555],"operate":[2563],"kategoria\u2014an":[2566],"court":[2571],"law":[2573],"calls":[2575,2642],"defense.":[2578],"Linking":[2579],"antiquity,":[2588],"rethinking":[2592],"beginning":[2596],"help":[2601],"creating":[2609],"productive":[2610],"many":[2616],"ignores":[2618],"binds":[2623],"invokes":[2630,3112],"conventions":[2635],"legal":[2638],"speaks":[2650],"name":[2653],"law.":[2655],"Here":[2656],"Burkean":[2660],"\u201ccontainer\u201d":[2673],"comes":[2693],"Judith":[2704],"Butler":[2705],"reminds":[2706],"us,":[2707],"\u201cIn":[2708],"order":[2709,2771],"responsiveness,":[2715],"others":[2728],"appealed":[2738],"way.":[2742],"disposed":[2750],"hearing,":[2752],"interlocution,":[2761],"establish":[2766,2900],"responsive\u201d":[2774],"(Murray":[2775],"2007,":[2776],"418\u201319).":[2777],"address.":[2797],"illustrates":[2801],"places":[2805,2852],"dislocated":[2818],"injured":[2831],"standing\u2014the":[2837],"before":[2843],"other\u2014is":[2845],"jeopardy.":[2847],"me":[2853],"tenuous":[2856],"position.":[2857],"Against":[2858],"revokes":[2868],"speak,":[2872],"\u201cas":[2875],"if\u201d":[2876],"inhabit":[2879],"authorizes":[2888,2973],"obligates":[2892],"respond,":[2895],"aware":[2896],"under":[2904],"suffered":[2907],"injury.To":[2908],"examine":[2909],"rhetorically":[2914],"mediates":[2922],"risk":[2924,3064,3135],"subjects":[2926],"histories":[2928],"With":[2940],"insight,":[2942],"return":[2944],"beginning.":[2947],"examined":[2953],"closely,":[2954],"shows":[2955],"simply":[2959],"obscene.":[2960],"carries":[2966],"covers":[2968],"\u201cfolksy\u201d":[3006],"George":[3009],"Bush":[3010],"Sarah":[3012],"Palin":[3013],"we've":[3016],"accustomed.":[3018],"But":[3019],"harkens":[3022],"1950s":[3026],"suburban":[3027],"vernacular":[3028],"gone":[3039],"unquestioned.":[3040],"While":[3041],"conjuring":[3042],"confirms":[3046],"mitigates":[3062],"associated":[3065],"sealing":[3076],"off":[3077],"placing":[3081]},"counts_by_year":[{"year":2022,"cited_by_count":1},{"year":2018,"cited_by_count":1},{"year":2017,"cited_by_count":1}],"updated_date":"2026-11-07T11:25:07.637180","created_date":"2022-05-12T00:00:00"}