{"id":"https://openalex.org/W2808026022","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1093/icon/moy045","title":"Courting the People: Public Interest Litigation in Post-Emergency India","display_name":"Courting the People: Public Interest Litigation in Post-Emergency India","publication_year":2018,"publication_date":"2018-04-01","ids":{"openalex":"https://openalex.org/W2808026022","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1093/icon/moy045","mag":"2808026022"},"language":"en","primary_location":{"id":"doi:10.1093/icon/moy045","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1093/icon/moy045","is_oa":true,"landing_page_url":"https://doi.org/10.1093/icon/moy045","pdf_url":"https://academic.oup.com/icon/article-pdf/16/2/710/25037296/moy045.pdf","source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S7938327","display_name":"International Journal of Constitutional Law","issn_l":"1474-2640","issn":["1474-2640","1474-2659"],"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":false,"listed_in":["anvur-class-a","anvur-scientific","jufo-3","norway-2","poland-100","russia-white-list-1","vabb-shw"],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/P4310311648","host_organization_name":"Oxford University Press","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/P4310311648","https://openalex.org/P4310311647"],"host_organization_lineage_names":["Oxford University Press","University of Oxford"],"type":"journal"},"license":null,"license_id":null,"version":"publishedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":true,"raw_source_name":"International Journal of Constitutional Law","raw_type":"journal-article"},"volume":null,"type":"article","is_traditional":true,"indexed_in":["crossref"],"open_access":{"is_oa":true,"oa_status":"bronze","oa_url":"https://academic.oup.com/icon/article-pdf/16/2/710/25037296/moy045.pdf","any_repository_has_fulltext":false},"authorships":[{"author_position":"first","author":{"id":"https://openalex.org/A5029582308","display_name":"Aparna Chandra","orcid":"https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5468-9446","observed_orcids":["https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5468-9446"]},"institutions":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/I866667741","display_name":"National Law University, Delhi","ror":"https://ror.org/03sz2k744","country_code":"IN","type":"education","lineage":["https://openalex.org/I866667741"]}],"countries":["IN"],"is_corresponding":true,"raw_author_name":"Aparna Chandra","raw_affiliation_strings":["National Law University, Delhi"],"raw_orcid":null,"affiliations":[{"raw_affiliation_string":"National Law University, Delhi","institution_ids":["https://openalex.org/I866667741"]}]}],"institutions":[],"countries_distinct_count":1,"institutions_distinct_count":1,"corresponding_author_ids":["https://openalex.org/A5029582308"],"corresponding_institution_ids":["https://openalex.org/I866667741"],"apc_list":{"value":2919,"currency":"GBP","value_usd":3849},"apc_paid":null,"fwci":89.3605,"has_fulltext":true,"cited_by_count":84,"citation_normalized_percentile":{"value":0.99919091,"is_in_top_1_percent":true,"is_in_top_10_percent":true},"cited_by_percentile_year":{"min":89,"max":100},"biblio":{"volume":"16","issue":"2","first_page":"710","last_page":"718"},"is_retracted":false,"is_paratext":false,"is_xpac":false,"primary_topic":{"id":"https://openalex.org/T10802","display_name":"Judicial and Constitutional Studies","score":0.9750999808311462,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/3308","display_name":"Law"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/33","display_name":"Social Sciences"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},"topics":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/T10802","display_name":"Judicial and Constitutional Studies","score":0.9750999808311462,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/3308","display_name":"Law"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/33","display_name":"Social Sciences"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},{"id":"https://openalex.org/T12332","display_name":"Comparative constitutional jurisprudence studies","score":0.013399999588727951,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/3320","display_name":"Political Science and International Relations"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/33","display_name":"Social Sciences"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},{"id":"https://openalex.org/T14259","display_name":"Legal Rights and Human Rights","score":0.0015999999595806003,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/3308","display_name":"Law"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/33","display_name":"Social Sciences"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}}],"keywords":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/public-interest-litigation","display_name":"public interest litigation","score":0.9909999966621399},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/judicial-populism","display_name":"judicial populism","score":0.7929999828338623},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/judicial-power","display_name":"judicial power","score":0.4819999933242798},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/judicial-activism","display_name":"judicial activism","score":0.40700000524520874},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/standing-requirements","display_name":"standing requirements","score":0.40700000524520874},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/fundamental-rights","display_name":"fundamental rights","score":0.6119999885559082},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/procedural-justice","display_name":"procedural justice","score":0.4320000112056732},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/supreme-court-of-india","display_name":"Supreme Court of India","score":0.703000009059906},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/amicus-curiae","display_name":"amicus curiae","score":0.5770000219345093}],"concepts":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/C2776475305","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q29627","display_name":"Public interest","level":2,"score":0.5609322786331177},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C144133560","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q4830453","display_name":"Business","level":0,"score":0.39604946970939636},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C17744445","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q36442","display_name":"Political science","level":0,"score":0.3567923903465271},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C199539241","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q7748","display_name":"Law","level":1,"score":0.29450637102127075}],"mesh":[],"locations_count":1,"locations":[{"id":"doi:10.1093/icon/moy045","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1093/icon/moy045","is_oa":true,"landing_page_url":"https://doi.org/10.1093/icon/moy045","pdf_url":"https://academic.oup.com/icon/article-pdf/16/2/710/25037296/moy045.pdf","source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S7938327","display_name":"International Journal of Constitutional Law","issn_l":"1474-2640","issn":["1474-2640","1474-2659"],"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":false,"listed_in":["anvur-class-a","anvur-scientific","jufo-3","norway-2","poland-100","russia-white-list-1","vabb-shw"],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/P4310311648","host_organization_name":"Oxford University Press","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/P4310311648","https://openalex.org/P4310311647"],"host_organization_lineage_names":["Oxford University Press","University of Oxford"],"type":"journal"},"license":null,"license_id":null,"version":"publishedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":true,"raw_source_name":"International Journal of Constitutional Law","raw_type":"journal-article"}],"best_oa_location":{"id":"doi:10.1093/icon/moy045","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1093/icon/moy045","is_oa":true,"landing_page_url":"https://doi.org/10.1093/icon/moy045","pdf_url":"https://academic.oup.com/icon/article-pdf/16/2/710/25037296/moy045.pdf","source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S7938327","display_name":"International Journal of Constitutional Law","issn_l":"1474-2640","issn":["1474-2640","1474-2659"],"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":false,"listed_in":["anvur-class-a","anvur-scientific","jufo-3","norway-2","poland-100","russia-white-list-1","vabb-shw"],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/P4310311648","host_organization_name":"Oxford University Press","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/P4310311648","https://openalex.org/P4310311647"],"host_organization_lineage_names":["Oxford University Press","University of Oxford"],"type":"journal"},"license":null,"license_id":null,"version":"publishedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":true,"raw_source_name":"International Journal of Constitutional Law","raw_type":"journal-article"},"sustainable_development_goals":[{"id":"https://metadata.un.org/sdg/16","display_name":"Peace, justice, and strong institutions","score":1.0}],"study_designs":[],"awards":[],"funders":[],"has_content":{"pdf":true,"grobid_xml":true},"content_urls":{"pdf":"https://content.openalex.org/works/W2808026022.pdf","grobid_xml":"https://content.openalex.org/works/W2808026022.grobid-xml"},"referenced_works_count":0,"referenced_works":[],"related_works":["https://openalex.org/W4414047989","https://openalex.org/W1565375587","https://openalex.org/W2623208131","https://openalex.org/W7131365934","https://openalex.org/W2746789352","https://openalex.org/W7161602434","https://openalex.org/W2762080624","https://openalex.org/W2019003172","https://openalex.org/W7165669962","https://openalex.org/W7223096066"],"abstract_inverted_index":{"Public":[0,300],"interest":[1,1639],"litigation":[2],"(PIL)":[3],"is":[4,205,289,328,391,418,575,665,1067,1186,1269,1292,1313,1719,1809,1881,2009,2070,2106,2354,2361,2404,2429,2486,2531,2660,2714,2721,2763,2796,2959,2998,3027,3048,3056,3138,3255,3257,3353,3358,3362,3370],"possibly":[5],"the":[6,13,22,25,56,63,135,138,159,163,191,206,212,215,243,257,268,277,298,349,388,400,471,476,487,496,514,522,535,541,547,565,573,612,617,624,642,655,670,703,716,725,731,741,745,759,764,777,788,812,821,829,835,847,855,888,895,910,918,927,931,934,941,946,950,953,965,972,978,990,994,999,1004,1007,1015,1019,1031,1038,1116,1120,1135,1150,1176,1179,1187,1200,1205,1229,1253,1272,1288,1300,1309,1323,1352,1395,1418,1429,1441,1469,1474,1506,1519,1526,1531,1540,1548,1563,1568,1577,1580,1593,1599,1610,1643,1649,1668,1703,1710,1715,1752,1764,1794,1840,1870,1876,1897,1916,1918,1921,1944,1949,1964,2033,2042,2044,2082,2096,2102,2120,2131,2154,2161,2183,2191,2200,2203,2217,2228,2237,2250,2259,2272,2285,2320,2323,2327,2337,2343,2346,2357,2370,2384,2443,2475,2496,2500,2516,2536,2563,2591,2604,2610,2620,2651,2674,2682,2704,2735,2738,2749,2757,2766,2790,2799,2803,2817,2825,2828,2834,2856,2866,2875,2881,2886,2891,2902,2943,2962,2984,2992,2999,3021,3030,3033,3045,3051,3071,3078,3099,3135,3156,3179,3186,3189,3192,3197,3202,3211,3216,3242,3249,3265,3298,3303,3311,3318,3328,3348,3367,3403,3408,3425,3428,3432],"best-known":[7],"and":[8,69,126,150,188,219,259,293,337,403,428,436,443,498,534,543,550,583,590,610,630,681,692,712,730,751,763,834,890,900,905,920,939,1051,1057,1099,1147,1159,1213,1233,1247,1250,1307,1341,1355,1360,1383,1409,1498,1618,1628,1637,1682,1724,1803,1817,1826,1847,1889,1920,1963,2014,2026,2076,2091,2128,2212,2360,2418,2525,2572,2583,2603,2669,2720,2836,2842,2877,2890,2920,3103,3105,3107,3167,3183,3207,3209,3246,3271,3289,3360,3411],"most":[9,548,2723],"emulated":[10],"feature":[11],"of":[12,28,31,46,51,97,124,158,166,246,261,273,279,312,315,399,407,433,470,473,502,517,524,546,553,596,615,645,654,673,695,706,715,728,733,761,766,779,811,815,828,844,849,872,892,936,943,967,987,993,1006,1018,1027,1034,1062,1081,1137,1169,1178,1189,1235,1238,1256,1267,1274,1287,1299,1319,1325,1351,1368,1420,1440,1449,1466,1490,1493,1505,1539,1542,1579,1609,1612,1625,1634,1671,1722,1738,1766,1774,1807,1839,1878,1900,1946,1960,1980,2067,2099,2137,2146,2160,2175,2182,2185,2193,2202,2205,2274,2304,2322,2329,2345,2356,2373,2379,2387,2409,2477,2499,2523,2580,2612,2641,2663,2671,2676,2730,2756,2793,2816,2827,2839,2844,2868,2873,2883,2888,2905,2936,2964,2970,2983,2986,3017,3024,3032,3044,3058,3061,3098,3110,3134,3142,3169,3178,3194,3199,3205,3233,3248,3268,3281,3302,3313,3331,3405,3414,3427,3431],"Indian":[14,2162,2717,3052,3368],"judicial":[15,230,401,408,656,663,734,767,873,1047,1224,1289,1304,1327,1388,1407,1533,1565,1596,1901,2111,2857,2944,3007,3025,3046,3075,3143,3269,3332],"system.1":[16],"In":[17,296,414,634,795,974,2673,2706,2907,2955,3172],"its":[18,186,285,291,294,360,376,397,405,519,631,913,956,1285,1585,1588,1813,2569,2731,2783],"inaugural":[19,361],"moment":[20,362],"in":[21,106,142,164,172,214,276,284,303,359,373,396,404,420,431,456,475,489,510,570,602,647,682,793,949,963,971,1001,1037,1074,1119,1167,1173,1207,1223,1303,1306,1322,1336,1345,1366,1468,1576,1595,1653,1655,1677,1702,1732,1850,1873,1948,1985,2030,2074,2088,2110,2122,2157,2236,2244,2366,2415,2432,2463,2491,2503,2521,2550,2593,2601,2616,2650,2716,2728,2737,2754,2778,2809,2814,2824,3011,3074,3077,3093,3116,3148,3164,3231,3252,3407],"late":[23,477,951],"1970s,":[24,478,952],"Supreme":[26,64,1796,2149,2654,2750],"Court":[27,65,103,136,160,911,932,954,979,995,1020,1206,1600,1797,2150,2655,2683,2751],"India":[29,3120],"conceived":[30],"PIL":[32,117,193,224,247,288,316,353,389,417,474,569,601,629,646,659,749,762,825,868,1257,1268,1543,1656,1718,1874,1906,1947,1968,2132,2138,2155,2358,2445,2480,2602,2727,2861,2911,2937,2965],"as":[33,130,529,531,958,984,1156,1842,1932,2309,2390,2947,3086,3088,3181,3223,3322,3388],"a":[34,72,83,143,167,177,318,321,332,342,355,421,467,483,576,710,857,870,883,961,985,1075,1275,1280,1333,1381,1403,1421,1483,1488,1573,1713,1736,1791,1977,2108,2281,2377,2450,2546,2599,2643,2661,2712,2725,2847,2909,3006,3059,3094,3129,3173,3226,3261,3338,3354,3421],"way":[35,123],"to":[36,81,87,110,119,133,145,153,169,179,182,221,334,381,482,491,560,580,623,721,743,747,752,860,875,878,902,916,925,997,1003,1009,1022,1029,1070,1086,1110,1199,1294,1347,1374,1390,1398,1417,1426,1509,1556,1560,1601,1603,1648,1659,1662,1679,1697,1769,1779,1819,1868,1875,1882,1887,1893,1909,1925,1940,1952,1955,1971,1982,1991,2011,2055,2072,2080,2152,2167,2189,2223,2258,2261,2270,2300,2348,2363,2382,2405,2441,2460,2473,2533,2630,2666,2687,2698,2772,2805,2849,2870,3003,3028,3066,3090,3155,3219,3225,3259,3290,3294,3401],"remedy":[37],"fundamental":[38,84,1675,1928,2176,2286,2350],"rights":[39,85,113,258,1929,2186,2225,2665],"violations":[40,2174],"for":[41,44,201,228,357,445,841,945,1096,1231,1358,1516,1685,1740,1811,1896,2173,2636,2690,2759,2833,3005,3050,3146,3213,3390],"those":[42,98,369,1999,2613],"who,":[43],"reasons":[45,2941],"impoverishment":[47],"or":[48,79,234,679,1411,1415,1614,1727,1729,1757,2046,2542,2918,2929,3372],"other":[49,107,1025,3108,3382],"forms":[50,694,1237,1528,1899],"disempowerment,":[52],"could":[53,93,100,2278,2292,2801],"not":[54,75,141,176,265,372,959,1271,1435,1479,1720,1800,2118,2487,2843,2913,2923,2960,3039,3240,3309,3325,3343,3363],"approach":[55,220,1443,2054],"courts":[57,249,2800,2884,3406],"themselves.":[58],"To":[59,1789],"overcome":[60],"this":[61,310,975,1104,1131,1192,1377,1693,1745,1862,1956,2114,2399,2607,2617,2680,2956,3139,3273,3357],"hurdle,":[62],"relaxed":[66],"standing":[67],"requirements":[68],"held":[70],"that":[71,162,283,309,329,352,387,424,512,578,585,658,684,824,831,838,867,1091,1129,1162,1194,1202,1258,1376,1518,1592,1667,1683,1706,1721,1747,2104,2125,2241,2277,2331,2411,2419,2467,2479,2509,2606,2622,2657,2748,2765,2798,2859,2966,3020,3063,3176,3238,3320,3366,3373,3384],"petitioner":[73,139,168],"need":[74,1555],"be":[76,120,581,587,1164,1215,1460,1510,1910,2073,2293,2413,2850,2914,3220,3276,3419],"personally":[77],"injured":[78],"aggrieved":[80],"bring":[82,1010],"violation":[86,2662,2755],"court.":[88],"Rather,":[89],"any":[90,597,1995,2677],"public-spirited":[91],"individual":[92],"sue":[94],"on":[95,156,495,540,600,628,930,933,1079,1093,1141,1243,1451,1558,1844,2060,2095,2101,2249,2312,2369,2488,2495,2609,2679,2703,2775,2789,3286,3395,3424],"behalf":[96,157],"who":[99,263,370,2017],"not.2":[101],"The":[102,460,1181,1265,1446,1958,2007,2064,2134,2148,2219,2653,2934,3081,3392],"also":[104,1545,2268,3344],"engaged":[105],"procedural":[108,426,791,1127,1148,2097,2371,2595],"innovations":[109],"effectively":[111],"address":[112,3241],"violations.":[114,1930],"It":[115,592,923,1742],"allowed":[116,1598],"petitions":[118,2170],"filed":[121],"by":[122,368,411,486,606,886,1126,1315,1387,1621,1904,2004,2142,2289,2722,2864,2995],"letters":[125],"postcards;":[127],"appointed":[128,151],"lawyers":[129],"amicus":[131],"curiae":[132],"assist":[134],"where":[137,254,1339,1915],"was":[140,175,331,354,869,1124,1139,1329,1380,1402,1522,1535,1551,1571,1907,1938,1969,2139,2187,2196,2752,2770],"position":[144],"do":[146],"so":[147,161,1480,1641,2519,2745,2747],"effect":[148],"ively;":[149],"commissioners":[152],"gather":[154,1990],"facts":[155,174],"ability":[165,181,1765],"spend":[170],"resources":[171],"furnishing":[173],"hindrance":[178],"her":[180],"seek":[183],"justice.3":[184],"Despite":[185],"popularity":[187],"frequent":[189],"invocation,":[190],"judiciary\u2019s":[192,216],"jurisdiction":[194,390,2156],"has":[195,225,338,364,447,462,527,538,660,737,1454,1508,1853,1973,2318,2341,2608,3293],"increasingly":[196],"come":[197],"under":[198,2263],"attack,":[199],"mainly":[200,604],"two":[202,463],"reasons.":[203],"First":[204],"perceived":[207],"neoliberal":[208],"turn,":[209],"especially":[210],"since":[211,365,2436,2515],"1990s,":[213],"priorities,":[217],"hermeneutics,":[218],"adjudication.4":[222],"Second,":[223],"been":[226,366,2471,2741],"criticized":[227],"expanding":[229,2190],"power":[231,409,452,484,664,768,1328,1484,2321,2344,3274],"without":[232,1462,1994,2527],"checks":[233],"compliance":[235],"with":[236,336,348,375,450,506,564,675,688,784,802,808,820,1024,1144,1175,1284,1296,1645,1690,1717,1787,1805,1823,1861,1998,2457,2647,2743,2951,2991,3283],"fair":[237],"process":[238,446,1613,1816,1888,2582,2963],"norms.":[239],"For":[240,1227,2113],"example,":[241,1517,1793,2637],"given":[242,2294,2598],"wide":[244],"remit":[245],"cases,":[248,1734],"decide":[250,2041],"many":[251,2570,3123],"\u201cpoly-centric\u201d":[252],"disputes,":[253],"outcomes":[255,1172,1731,2490],"impact":[256,536,2066,2605,2788,2838,2935],"lives":[260,542,2001,2611,2792,2887],"people":[262,2889],"are":[264,371,1053,1196,1444,2002,2021,2518,2540,2545,2597,2619,2896,3381,3385],"represented":[266],"before":[267],"courts.5":[269],"Both":[270],"these":[271,700,1221,1438,1632,1700,2061,2078,2086,2439,2468,2492,2510,2544,2626],"types":[272],"criticism":[274,313],"believe":[275],"promise":[278],"PIL,":[280,518,616,707,729,2100,2996],"but":[281,363,964,1107,1279,1486,1524,1735,2335,2494,2514,2780,2821],"argue":[282,1295,3004],"current":[286],"practice,":[287],"failing":[290],"potential":[292,1005,1095],"purpose.":[295],"Courting":[297,572],"People:":[299],"Interest":[301],"Litigation":[302],"Post-Emergency":[304],"India,":[305,603],"Anuj":[306],"Bhuwania":[307,385,555,708,817,865,1113,1219,1372,1433,1476,1590,1665,1762,1855,2093,2242,2375,2397,3001,3036,3113,3316],"argues":[308,386,866,1666],"form":[311,594],"talks":[314],"\u201cas":[317],"romance\u2014if":[319],"anything,":[320],"romance":[322],"gone":[323],"wrong.\u201d6":[324],"Instead,":[325,384,864],"his":[326,415,785,2245,2402,2433,3117],"thesis":[327,823],"\u201cPIL":[330,2105],"tragedy":[333],"begin":[335],"over":[339,1587],"time":[340,2230,2339],"become":[341],"dangerous":[343],"farce.\u201d7":[344],"He":[345,2465],"takes":[346,818],"issue":[347,819,1283,2524,3426],"canonical":[350],"view":[351,687],"force":[356],"good":[358,1723,1728],"hijacked":[367],"tune":[374,1174],"original":[377,2169],"philosophy;":[378],"thus,":[379],"leading":[380],"problematic":[382,392,1254,1704],"outcomes.":[383,438,2585],"per":[393],"se,":[394],"both":[395,557],"understanding":[398,2103,2273,3193],"role":[402,957,992,1017,1122,1408,1520,1534,3008,3047,3404,3430],"deployment":[406,765],"untrammeled":[410],"processual":[412,1686,1879],"limits.":[413],"view,":[416],"rooted":[419,3163],"\u201cjudicial":[422],"populism\u201d":[423,1672],"rejects":[425],"safeguards":[427,1687,1880,2596],"institutional":[429,1145],"controls":[430,1146],"favor":[432,1168,1367,1584],"substantive":[434,1369,2123],"rationality":[435],"\u201cjust\u201d":[437],"This":[439,1311,2052,2195,2315,3151,3307],"purely":[440],"consequentialist":[441],"thrust":[442],"disregard":[444,1684,1739],"provided":[448,854],"judges":[449,832,1245,1396,1689,1814,1894,2917,2926],"unchecked":[451],"which":[453,479,1363,1530,1798,2164,2594,2880,2894,3253,3399],"they":[454,839,852,1203,1400,2266,2332,2633,2895],"deploy":[455,1815],"very":[457,676,1072,1622,2062,3095,3221],"capricious":[458],"ways.":[459],"book":[461,577,618,746,2069],"central":[464],"components:":[465],"first,":[466],"revisionist":[468],"account":[469,1041],"origins":[472],"he":[480,1707,2116,2428,2437,2538],"attributes":[481],"grab":[485,1485],"judiciary":[488,1151,2324,3106,3237],"order":[490,3251],"undercut":[492,926],"political":[493,928,1825,2948,3410],"attacks":[494,881],"institution;":[497],"second,":[499],"ethnographic":[500,639],"accounts":[501,640,2724,2832,2872],"three":[503],"PILs":[504,2458],"dealing":[505,2646],"urban":[507,2461],"governance":[508,2462],"issues":[509,2020],"Delhi":[511,2559,2564,2573,2779],"demonstrate":[513,641,1375],"\u201cprotean":[515,726],"nature\u201d":[516,727],"quotidian":[520,643,2385,2903],"working,":[521],"kinds":[523,732,2328,2476,2969],"politics":[525,657,735,2059,2971],"it":[526,537,736,1111,1865,1937,2039,2048,2166,2340,2530,2764,2797,2958,3254,3336,3352,3361,3441],"displaced":[528],"well":[530,1650,3087],"made":[532,2140],"possible,":[533],"had":[539,2151,2786],"material":[544,906,2025,3412],"realities":[545,644,2904,3413],"marginalized":[549],"impoverished":[551],"sections":[552],"society.":[554],"ties":[556],"themes":[558],"together":[559,1924],"then":[561,1502,1553,2427],"raise":[562,799],"concerns":[563,723,786,801,3069],"present":[566,1950],"narrative":[567,1225,2618],"surrounding":[568],"India.":[571,648,3391],"People":[574],"needed":[579],"written":[582],"one":[584,2251,2899],"should":[586,757,1163,1214,2035,2040,2049,3275,3324,3342],"widely":[588],"read":[589],"debated.":[591],"will":[593,874,1108,1389],"part":[595,2355,3057],"reading":[598,2145,2181,2209],"list":[599],"because":[605,1465,2925,3335,3351],"naming,":[607],"calling":[608],"out,":[609],"documenting":[611,2077],"public":[613,1629,1638,2776],"secrets":[614],"provides":[619,709,3337],"an":[620,651,809,1043,1087,1142,1316,1356,2143,2179,2295,2551],"important":[621,1044],"counter":[622],"mostly":[625],"hagiographic":[626],"narratives":[627],"dramatis":[632],"personae.":[633],"particular,":[635],"Bhuwania\u2019s":[636,722,774,803,1040,1297,1933,2068,2447,2556,2588,2810],"vividly":[637],"portrayed":[638],"They":[649,2586],"tell":[650],"alarming":[652],"story":[653,2848],"unleashed,":[661],"how":[662,755,1115,1428,1456,1559,1812,2019,2038,2423,3272],"deployed,":[666],"often":[667,2938],"significantly":[668],"altering":[669],"life":[671],"circumstances":[672],"millions":[674],"little":[677,1241,1293,1891,2787],"consultation":[678],"accountability,":[680],"ways":[683,1705,2592,2876],"foreclose,":[685],"indeed":[686,3122],"suspicion,":[689],"more":[690,769,898,1281,3131,3386,3420],"democratic":[691,2058,3034],"participatory":[693],"policymaking":[696],"outside":[697,2855],"courts.":[698],"Through":[699],"vignettes":[701],"into":[702,2216,2422,3327],"inner":[704],"workings":[705],"trenchant":[711,1261],"compelling":[713],"critique":[714],"jurisdiction.":[717],"I":[718,739,798,1101],"am":[719,1102],"sympathetic":[720],"about":[724,1011,1046,1406,2590,2853,2916,3070,3159],"produced.":[738],"use":[740,1945],"opportunity":[742],"review":[744,1066,3026,3076,3333],"interrogate":[748],"further,":[750],"reflect":[753],"upon":[754,1699,2482,3201],"we":[756,1554,1582,1749,1754,2989,3323,3341,3374],"theorize":[758],"practice":[760,1052,1507,2090],"generally.8":[770],"Section":[771,781,796,805],"2":[772],"examines":[773],"claims":[775,1591,2330,2466],"regarding":[776,787],"origin":[778],"PIL.":[780,794,816,1646,2374,2388,2906,2987],"3":[782],"engages":[783],"(lack":[789],"of)":[790],"elements":[792,2098],"4,":[797],"methodological":[800],"approach.":[804],"5":[806],"concludes":[807],"exploration":[810],"possible":[813,1252,2141],"futures":[814],"influential":[822,3015],"grew":[826],"out":[827],"remorse":[830],"felt,":[833],"legitimacy":[836,1059,3084,3262],"crisis":[837],"experienced,":[840],"their":[842,1824],"abdication":[843],"responsibility":[845],"during":[846],"Emergency":[848],"1975\u20131977,":[850],"when":[851],"essentially":[853],"government":[856,885],"carte":[858],"blanche":[859],"invade":[861],"personal":[862],"liberty.9":[863],"product":[871],"power\u2014an":[876],"attempt":[877,2403],"outmaneuver":[879],"sustained":[880],"from":[882,982,1482,1487,1657,1744,1777,1859,2171,2940,3188,3347,3377],"populist":[884,1301],"coopting":[887],"logic":[889,1419],"rhetoric":[891,1136],"populism.10":[893],"As":[894,1631,1712,1864,3112],"state":[896,1028,1063,1077,1090,1922,2305,2347,2804,3102,3170,3180],"became":[897],"interventionist":[899,1088,3132,3182],"attempted":[901],"create":[903],"social":[904,968,1097,1626,1635,1827],"change":[907,1013,1098,1453,1849,2921],"through":[908,1529,2199,2208,2879,2893,3215,3278],"law,":[909,1841],"redefined":[912],"own":[914],"mandate":[915],"mirror":[917],"\u201cactivist":[919],"capacious":[921,1623],"state.\u201d11":[922],"sought":[924],"attack":[929],"charge":[935],"being":[937,996,1021,1330,3162],"elitist,":[938],"claimed":[940],"mantle":[942],"speaking":[944],"people.12":[947],"Beginning":[948],"re-conceptualized":[955],"only":[960,1198,1620,2368,2915,2924,2961,3350],"partner":[962],"\u201cvanguard":[966],"revolution\u201d13":[969],"envisaged":[970,1908],"Constitution.14":[973],"reconfigured":[976],"role,":[977],"shifted":[980],"focus":[981,1557,2036],"law":[983,1000,1008,2214,2276],"tool":[986,1575],"oppression":[988],"(with":[989],"primary":[991],"keep":[998],"check),":[1002],"socio-economic":[1012,1032,1349],"(and":[1014,3121],"concomitant":[1016],"work":[1023,2396,3055],"branches":[1026,3109],"realize":[1030],"vision":[1033],"society":[1035],"contained":[1036],"Constitution).15":[1039],"underscores":[1042],"point":[1045,1105,1263,3158,3319],"power:":[1048],"adjudicatory":[1049,1457,3160],"theory":[1050,3016],"directly":[1054],"related":[1055],"to,":[1056],"derive":[1058],"from,":[1060],"theories":[1061,3168],"power.":[1064,3171,3235],"Judicial":[1065],"therefore":[1068,1270],"likely":[1069,2071,2362,3218,3258],"look":[1071],"different":[1073],"nightwatchman":[1076],"founded":[1078,1140],"suspicion":[1080],"law\u2019s":[1082,1094],"oppressive":[1083],"potential,":[1084],"compared":[1085,3224],"welfare":[1089,3184],"focuses":[1092,2094],"emancipation.16":[1100],"flagging":[1103],"here":[1106,2852],"return":[1109],"later.":[1112],"describes":[1114,2243],"ideological":[1117,1831,1871],"shift":[1118,1379,1430,1521,1550,1570,1594,1652],"Court\u2019s":[1121,1442],"conception":[1123,1286,3009,3097,3133],"accompanied":[1125],"moves":[1128],"facilitated":[1130],"new":[1132,1491,1495,1532,1564,1898],"role.":[1133,1290,1566],"Since":[1134],"populism":[1138],"impatience":[1143,1357],"safeguards,":[1149],"too":[1152,1884,1890],"began":[1153],"casting":[1154],"procedures":[1155,1195,1211],"unnecessary":[1157],"hurdles":[1158],"mere":[1160],"technicalities":[1161],"set":[1165,2408],"aside":[1166],"substantively":[1170],"just":[1171,1209,3321],"goals":[1177,1350],"Constitution.17":[1180],"oft":[1182],"used":[1183,2222,2269],"phrase":[1184],"\u201cprocedure":[1185],"handmaiden":[1188],"justice\u201d":[1190],"captures":[1191],"idea":[1193,3019],"useful":[1197],"extent":[1201],"help":[1204],"achieving":[1208],"outcomes\u2014otherwise":[1210],"can":[1212,1246,1750,1755,2333,2412,2506,2898],"done":[1216],"away":[1217],"with.18":[1218],"finds":[1220],"shifts":[1222,1475,1676,1832,1872],"problematic.":[1226],"him,":[1228],"contempt":[1230,2932],"procedure":[1232,1359,2501],"privileging":[1234],"teleological":[1236,2239],"reasoning":[1239,1362,2240],"provide":[1240,2406,2420],"check":[1242],"what":[1244,1399,2024,2032,2632,2997,3279,3287,3291],"cannot":[1248,3375],"do,":[1249],"make":[1251,2860],"uses":[1255,2438],"even":[1259,1835,3439],"less":[1260],"critics":[1262],"to.":[1264],"problem":[1266,1716,1737],"case":[1273,1694,2453,2557,2567,2645,2739,2769,2811],"few":[1276,2547],"bad":[1277,1725,1730,2489,2548,2581,2584],"apples,":[1278],"systemic":[1282,2541],"There":[1291,2846],"explication":[1298],"turn":[1302,1335],"discourse":[1305,1597],"after":[1308],"1970s.":[1310],"period":[1312],"marked":[1314],"increasing":[1317],"invocation":[1318],"\u201cthe":[1320,1961],"people,\u201d":[1321],"name":[1324,1987],"whom":[1326],"exercised19":[1331],";":[1332,1354],"purposive":[1334],"hermeneutic":[1337],"practices,20":[1338],"interpretations":[1340,1439],"decisions":[1342,1993],"were":[1343,1364,2234,2267,2307,2512,2628,2697,3064],"justified":[1344],"relation":[1346],"broad":[1348,1549,1569],"Constitution21":[1353],"\u201clegalistic\u201d":[1361],"eschewed":[1365],"justice.22":[1370],"However,":[1371,1931,2435,2734],"fails":[1373,1951],"juridical":[1378],"cynical":[1382],"self-serving":[1384,1574],"exercise":[1385],"motivated":[1386],"power.23":[1391],"More":[1392,1829],"benign":[1393],"explanations\u2014like":[1394],"conceding":[1397],"felt":[1401],"better":[1404,1561],"argument":[1405,1746,3365],"power;":[1410],"believing":[1412],"in,":[1413],"endorsing,":[1414],"adapting":[1416],"changing":[1422],"constitutional":[1423,1452,1471,1496,1500,1845,1848,2380,2424,3125,3165,3243,3250,3300,3305],"culture\u2014might":[1424],"suffice":[1425],"explain":[1427,1436,2624,3040],"came":[1431,1923],"about.24":[1432],"does":[1434,1799,2117,3038,3239,3308,3437],"why":[1437,2625,3041],"invalid.":[1445],"vast":[1447],"body":[1448],"scholarship":[1450,1843],"emphasized":[1455],"practices":[1458,2087,3161],"may":[1459,1583],"transformed":[1461],"formal":[1463,1837],"amendments,":[1464],"changes":[1467,2121],"underlying":[1470],"culture.25":[1472],"If":[1473,1547,1567,2988],"discusses":[1477,1708],"resulted":[1478],"much":[1481,1885,2746],"recognition":[1489],"articulations":[1492],"injustice,":[1494,3208],"aspirations,":[1497,3245],"emerging":[1499,3393],"legalities,":[1501],"our":[1503],"evaluation":[1504,1538],"suitably":[1511],"modified.":[1512],"We":[1513,2505],"might":[1514,1544,3418],"agree,":[1515],"required,":[1523],"contest":[1525],"specific":[1527,2968,3304],"instantiated.":[1536],"Our":[1537],"future":[1541],"change.":[1546],"necessary,":[1552],"implement":[1562],"simply":[1572,3334],"hands":[1578],"judiciary,":[1581],"rejection":[1586],"reform.":[1589],"arrogate":[1602],"itself":[1604,2753],"untrammelled,":[1605],"unaccountable":[1606],"power,":[1607],"free":[1608],"constraints":[1611],"prin":[1615,2254],"ciple,":[1616],"legitimated":[1617],"disciplined":[1619],"notions":[1624,1633],"justice":[1627,1636,3206],"interest.":[1630],"changed,":[1640],"did":[1642],"(dis)enchantment":[1644],"Referring":[1647],"documented":[1651],"priorities":[1654,1678],"poverty":[1658],"\u201cbourgeois":[1660],"environmentalism\u201d":[1661],"anodyne":[1663],"governance,26":[1664],"\u201c\u2018inherent":[1669],"instability":[1670],"allows":[1673,1688,2165],"such":[1674,1983,2005,2280,2313,2711,2908,2946,2980,3149],"take":[1680,1790,1833,1941,1992,2806,3295],"place,27":[1681],"undesirable":[1691],"(in":[1692,2568],"neoliberal)":[1695],"ideologies":[1696,1701],"act":[1698],"throughout":[1709],"book.28":[1711],"corollary,":[1714],"judges,":[1726],"distinct":[1733,3222],"process.29":[1741],"follows":[1743],"if":[1748,1936,3440],"fix":[1751],"process,":[1753,1808],"displace,":[1756],"substantially":[1758],"constrain,":[1759],"(problematic)":[1760],"ideology.":[1761,1771],"overstates":[1763],"pro":[1767],"cess":[1768],"constrain":[1770],"Rule":[1772],"skeptics":[1773],"various":[1775],"hues,":[1776],"realists":[1778],"radical":[1780],"Critical":[1781],"Legal":[1782],"Studies":[1783],"scholars,":[1784],"would":[1785,1856,2623,2912,2977],"disagree":[1786],"him.30":[1788],"comparative":[1792,1851,3314],"US":[1795],"play":[1801],"fast":[1802],"loose":[1804],"questions":[1806],"notorious":[1810],"principle":[1818],"reach":[1820],"results":[1821],"consistent":[1822],"ideology.31":[1828],"fundamentally,":[1830],"place":[1834,3296],"within":[1836],"structures":[1838],"culture":[1846,3175,3228],"contexts":[1852],"demonstrated.32":[1854],"have":[1857,2470,2740,2978,3127],"benefited":[1858],"engaging":[1860],"literature.":[1863],"currently":[1866],"stands,":[1867],"link":[1869],"lack":[1877],"give":[1883],"credit":[1886],"discredit":[1892],"themselves":[1895],"rationale":[1902],"deployed":[1903],"them.":[1905],"collaborative":[1911],"rather":[1912],"than":[1913],"adversarial,":[1914],"Court,":[1917],"petitioner,":[1919],"resolve":[1926],"pressing":[1927],"examples":[1934,2579],"show,":[1935],"meant":[1939,1970,1976],"suffering":[1942],"seriously,33":[1943],"live":[1953],"up":[1954,2692],"mandate.":[1957],"imagery":[1959],"oppressed":[1962],"bewildered\u201d34":[1965],"whose":[1966,1986,2000,2395,3284],"\u201csuffering\u201d":[1967],"ameliorate":[1972],"at":[1974,2227,2336],"best":[1975],"paternalistic":[1978],"denial":[1979],"agency":[1981],"people(s),":[1984],"legal":[1988,2013,2089,2718,3174,3195,3227],"elites":[1989],"necessary":[1996],"engagement":[1997],"impacted":[2003],"decisions.":[2006],"collaboration":[2008],"limited":[2010],"court-appointed":[2012],"technical":[2015],"experts,35":[2016],"determine":[2018],"framed,":[2022],"36":[2023],"evidence":[2027],"gets":[2028],"presented":[2029],"court,":[2031],"court":[2034],"on,":[2037],"matter,":[2043,3438],"guidelines":[2045,2758],"remedies":[2047],"pass,":[2050],"etc.37":[2051],"technocratic":[2053],"decision-making":[2056],"displaces":[2057],"issues.38":[2063],"greatest":[2065],"naming":[2075],"phenomena,":[2079],"disrupt":[2081],"positive":[2083],"consensus":[2084],"around":[2085],"academia.":[2092],"primarily":[2107,2198,3230],"revolution":[2109],"procedure.\u201d39":[2112],"reason,":[2115],"discuss":[2119],"doctrine":[2124],"brought":[2126],"about,":[2127],"fed":[2129],"into,":[2130],"phenomenon.":[2133],"ubiquitous":[2135],"presence":[2136],"expanded":[2144,2180,2296,2319,2342],"rights.":[2147,2177,2351],"ground":[2153],"article":[2158,2206,2264,2290],"32":[2159],"Constitution,":[2163],"entertain":[2168],"citizens":[2172],"Therefore,":[2178],"scope":[2184,2192,2204,3023,3267],"integral":[2188],"PILs.":[2194],"achieved":[2197],"expansion":[2201],"21,":[2207],"directive":[2210,2253,2302],"principles":[2211,2303],"international":[2213],"norms":[2215],"provision.40":[2218],"interpretative":[2220,2316],"techniques":[2221],"expand":[2224,2271],"(but":[2226],"same":[2229,2238,2338],"dilute":[2231],"limitations":[2232],"thereon)":[2233],"grounded":[2235,3010,3092,3229],"book.":[2246],"So,":[2247],"while":[2248,2284],"hand":[2252],"ciples":[2255],"gave":[2256],"content":[2257],"\u201cright":[2260],"life\u201d":[2262],"21,41":[2265],"\u201creasonable\u201d":[2275],"limit":[2279],"right.42":[2282],"Similarly,":[2283],"freedoms":[2287],"guaranteed":[2288],"19":[2291],"definition,":[2297],"laws":[2298],"framed":[2299],"advance":[2301],"policy":[2306],"viewed":[2308],"\u201creasonable":[2310],"restrictions\u201d":[2311],"rights.43":[2314],"technique":[2317],"(by":[2325],"extending":[2326],"entertain),":[2334],"sidestep":[2349],"This,":[2352],"too,":[2353],"story,":[2359],"get":[2364,2802],"lost":[2365],"focusing":[2367],"aspects":[2372],"employs":[2376],"method":[2378,2448],"ethnography":[2381],"excavate":[2383],"reality":[2386],"If,":[2389],"Kim":[2391],"Lane":[2392],"Scheppele":[2393],"(from":[2394],"borrows":[2398],"idea)":[2400],"suggests,":[2401],"\u201ca":[2407],"repertoires":[2410,2440],"found":[2414],"real":[2416],"cases":[2417,2469,2493,2511,2517,2627],"insight":[2421],"regimes":[2425],"operate,\u201d44":[2426],"definitely":[2430],"successful":[2431],"enterprise.":[2434],"question":[2442],"entire":[2444,3082],"jurisdiction,":[2446],"becomes":[2449],"problem.":[2451],"His":[2452,2484],"studies":[2454,2812],"all":[2455,2507,2578,2688],"deal":[2456],"relating":[2459],"Delhi.":[2464],"selected":[2472],"illustrate":[2474],"powers":[2478],"confers":[2481],"judges.":[2483],"emphasis":[2485],"\u201cprofound":[2497],"injustice\u201d":[2498],"adopted":[2502,3128],"them.45":[2504],"agree":[2508,2990],"problematic;":[2513],"focused":[2520],"terms":[2522,2729],"location,":[2526],"knowing":[2528],"more,":[2529],"hard":[2532],"understand":[2534,2901],"whether":[2535,2543],"problems":[2537,2993],"highlights":[2539],"apples":[2549],"otherwise":[2552],"well-functioning":[2553],"system.":[2554],"Further,":[2555],"studies\u2014the":[2558],"Vehicular":[2560,2767],"Pollution":[2561,2566,2768,2819],"case,46":[2562],"Industrial":[2565,2818],"iterations),47":[2571],"Slum":[2574],"Demolition":[2575],"case48":[2576],"\u2014are":[2577],"instantiate":[2587],"points":[2589],"go-by":[2600],"affected.":[2614],"Missing":[2615],"counterfactuals":[2621],"able":[2629,2771],"achieve":[2631],"did.":[2634],"Take,":[2635],"Vishaka":[2638,2829,2976],"v.":[2639],"State":[2640],"Rajasthan,49":[2642],"1997":[2644],"sexual":[2648,2658],"harassment":[2649,2659],"workplace.":[2652],"recognized":[2656],"women\u2019s":[2664],"equality,":[2667],"dignity,":[2668],"freedom":[2670],"occupation.":[2672],"absence":[2675],"legislation":[2678],"issue,":[2681],"passed":[2684,2710],"extensive":[2685,2931],"directions":[2686,2696,2736],"employers":[2689],"setting":[2691],"redressal":[2693,3214],"mechanisms.":[2694],"These":[2695],"operate":[2699],"until":[2700],"Parliament":[2701,2708],"legislated":[2702],"issue.":[2705],"2013,":[2707]},"counts_by_year":[{"year":2026,"cited_by_count":1},{"year":2025,"cited_by_count":8},{"year":2024,"cited_by_count":15},{"year":2023,"cited_by_count":17},{"year":2022,"cited_by_count":3},{"year":2021,"cited_by_count":21},{"year":2020,"cited_by_count":7},{"year":2019,"cited_by_count":7},{"year":2018,"cited_by_count":4},{"year":2017,"cited_by_count":1}],"updated_date":"2026-11-07T11:25:07.637180","created_date":"2018-06-21T00:00:00"}