{"id":"https://openalex.org/W2805955491","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1111/jaac.12431","title":"A Recalcitrant Problem for Abstract Creationism","display_name":"A Recalcitrant Problem for Abstract Creationism","publication_year":2018,"publication_date":"2018-02-04","ids":{"openalex":"https://openalex.org/W2805955491","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1111/jaac.12431","mag":"2805955491"},"language":"en","primary_location":{"id":"doi:10.1111/jaac.12431","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1111/jaac.12431","is_oa":false,"landing_page_url":"https://doi.org/10.1111/jaac.12431","pdf_url":null,"source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S26308392","display_name":"Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism","issn_l":"0021-8529","issn":["0021-8529","1540-6245"],"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":true,"listed_in":["anvur-class-a","anvur-scientific","cwts-core","erih-plus","jufo-3","norway-2","poland-140","russia-white-list-1","vabb-shw"],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/P4310311648","host_organization_name":"Oxford University Press","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/P4310311648","https://openalex.org/P4310311647"],"host_organization_lineage_names":["Oxford University Press","University of Oxford"],"type":"journal"},"license":null,"license_id":null,"version":"publishedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":true,"raw_source_name":"The Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism","raw_type":"journal-article"},"volume":null,"type":"article","is_traditional":true,"indexed_in":["crossref","datacite"],"open_access":{"is_oa":true,"oa_status":"green","oa_url":"https://figshare.com/articles/journal_contribution/A_Recalcitrant_Problem_for_Abstract_Creationism/21561495","any_repository_has_fulltext":true},"authorships":[{"author_position":"first","author":{"id":"https://openalex.org/A5036132335","display_name":"Stuart Brock","orcid":"https://orcid.org/0000-0003-1152-0581","observed_orcids":["https://orcid.org/0000-0003-1152-0581"]},"institutions":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/I41156924","display_name":"Victoria University of Wellington","ror":"https://ror.org/0040r6f76","country_code":"NZ","type":"education","lineage":["https://openalex.org/I41156924"]}],"countries":["NZ"],"is_corresponding":true,"raw_author_name":"STUART BROCK","raw_affiliation_strings":["Philosophy Department; Victoria University of Wellington; Wellington New Zealand"],"raw_orcid":null,"affiliations":[{"raw_affiliation_string":"Philosophy Department; Victoria University of Wellington; Wellington New Zealand","institution_ids":["https://openalex.org/I41156924"]}]}],"institutions":[],"countries_distinct_count":1,"institutions_distinct_count":1,"corresponding_author_ids":["https://openalex.org/A5036132335"],"corresponding_institution_ids":["https://openalex.org/I41156924"],"apc_list":{"value":3492,"currency":"USD","value_usd":3492},"apc_paid":null,"fwci":23.9786,"has_fulltext":false,"cited_by_count":35,"citation_normalized_percentile":{"value":0.99267495,"is_in_top_1_percent":true,"is_in_top_10_percent":true},"cited_by_percentile_year":{"min":88,"max":99},"biblio":{"volume":"76","issue":"1","first_page":"93","last_page":"98"},"is_retracted":false,"is_paratext":false,"is_xpac":false,"primary_topic":{"id":"https://openalex.org/T10258","display_name":"Philosophy and Theoretical Science","score":0.4731000065803528,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1211","display_name":"Philosophy"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/12","display_name":"Arts and Humanities"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},"topics":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/T10258","display_name":"Philosophy and Theoretical Science","score":0.4731000065803528,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1211","display_name":"Philosophy"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/12","display_name":"Arts and Humanities"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},{"id":"https://openalex.org/T11477","display_name":"Epistemology, Ethics, and Metaphysics","score":0.19429999589920044,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1211","display_name":"Philosophy"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/12","display_name":"Arts and Humanities"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},{"id":"https://openalex.org/T14092","display_name":"Ethics, Aesthetics, and Art","score":0.1793999969959259,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1211","display_name":"Philosophy"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/12","display_name":"Arts and Humanities"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}}],"keywords":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/fictional-objects","display_name":"fictional objects","score":0.7580000162124634},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/ontology-of-fiction","display_name":"ontology of fiction","score":0.6200000047683716},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/fictionalism","display_name":"fictionalism","score":0.8420000076293945},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/abstract-objects","display_name":"abstract objects","score":0.3529999852180481},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/sherlock-holmes","display_name":"Sherlock Holmes","score":0.6050000190734863},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/james-bond","display_name":"James Bond","score":0.6159999966621399}],"concepts":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/C15608057","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q130352","display_name":"Creationism","level":2,"score":0.9665119647979736},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C138885662","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q5891","display_name":"Philosophy","level":0,"score":0.4053526520729065},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C95124753","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q875686","display_name":"Environmental ethics","level":1,"score":0.3562270402908325},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C111472728","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q9471","display_name":"Epistemology","level":1,"score":0.25507718324661255}],"mesh":[],"locations_count":3,"locations":[{"id":"doi:10.1111/jaac.12431","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1111/jaac.12431","is_oa":false,"landing_page_url":"https://doi.org/10.1111/jaac.12431","pdf_url":null,"source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S26308392","display_name":"Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism","issn_l":"0021-8529","issn":["0021-8529","1540-6245"],"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":true,"listed_in":["anvur-class-a","anvur-scientific","cwts-core","erih-plus","jufo-3","norway-2","poland-140","russia-white-list-1","vabb-shw"],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/P4310311648","host_organization_name":"Oxford University Press","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/P4310311648","https://openalex.org/P4310311647"],"host_organization_lineage_names":["Oxford University Press","University of Oxford"],"type":"journal"},"license":null,"license_id":null,"version":"publishedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":true,"raw_source_name":"The Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism","raw_type":"journal-article"},{"id":"pmh:oai:figshare.com:article/21561495","doi":null,"is_oa":true,"landing_page_url":"https://figshare.com/articles/journal_contribution/A_Recalcitrant_Problem_for_Abstract_Creationism/21561495","pdf_url":null,"source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S4306402649","display_name":"Open Access Victoria University of Wellington | Te Herenga Waka (Figshare)","issn_l":null,"issn":null,"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":false,"listed_in":[],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/I4210132348","host_organization_name":"Figshare (United Kingdom)","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/I4210132348"],"host_organization_lineage_names":[],"type":"repository"},"license":"cc-by-nc-nd","license_id":"https://openalex.org/licenses/cc-by-nc-nd","version":"submittedVersion","is_accepted":false,"is_published":false,"raw_source_name":"","raw_type":"Text"},{"id":"doi:10.25455/wgtn.21561495","doi":"https://doi.org/10.25455/wgtn.21561495","is_oa":true,"landing_page_url":"https://doi.org/10.25455/wgtn.21561495","pdf_url":null,"source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S7407051402","display_name":"Victoria University of Wellington","issn_l":null,"issn":null,"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":false,"listed_in":[],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/I41156924","host_organization_name":"Victoria University of Wellington","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/I41156924"],"host_organization_lineage_names":[],"type":"repository"},"license":null,"license_id":null,"version":null,"is_accepted":false,"is_published":false,"raw_source_name":null,"raw_type":"JournalArticle"}],"best_oa_location":{"id":"pmh:oai:figshare.com:article/21561495","doi":null,"is_oa":true,"landing_page_url":"https://figshare.com/articles/journal_contribution/A_Recalcitrant_Problem_for_Abstract_Creationism/21561495","pdf_url":null,"source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S4306402649","display_name":"Open Access Victoria University of Wellington | Te Herenga Waka (Figshare)","issn_l":null,"issn":null,"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":false,"listed_in":[],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/I4210132348","host_organization_name":"Figshare (United Kingdom)","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/I4210132348"],"host_organization_lineage_names":[],"type":"repository"},"license":"cc-by-nc-nd","license_id":"https://openalex.org/licenses/cc-by-nc-nd","version":"submittedVersion","is_accepted":false,"is_published":false,"raw_source_name":"","raw_type":"Text"},"sustainable_development_goals":[],"study_designs":[],"awards":[],"funders":[],"has_content":{"pdf":false,"grobid_xml":false},"content_urls":null,"referenced_works_count":5,"referenced_works":["https://openalex.org/W1524683705","https://openalex.org/W2139038766","https://openalex.org/W2237353491","https://openalex.org/W2401127194","https://openalex.org/W3127955956"],"related_works":["https://openalex.org/W2800923125","https://openalex.org/W4210538204","https://openalex.org/W136688629","https://openalex.org/W2805898243","https://openalex.org/W2139038766","https://openalex.org/W2587496408","https://openalex.org/W2401127194","https://openalex.org/W7131630595","https://openalex.org/W849637369","https://openalex.org/W2490996038"],"abstract_inverted_index":{"Abstract":[0,183,524],"creationism":[1,27,184,189,203,266,548,2206,2227,2267,3442],"about":[2,28,153,298,477,582,591,606,623,752,787,831,938,1075,1271,1433,1475,1484,1748,1864,1868,2016,2076,2242,2345,2394,2564,2672,2704,2838,2978,3209,3211,3363],"fictional":[3,29,154,163,194,230,238,244,254,258,278,321,379,397,407,413,436,456,463,583,592,732,756,793,824,837,882,929,1080,1121,1140,1149,1162,1171,1184,1197,1479,1824,1869,1900,1955,2018,2034,2147,2256,2272,2284,2320,2400,2565,2571,2708,2846,2890,3035,3102],"characters":[4,1081,1870,1901,2273,2285,2321,2566,2572,2636,2677,3036],"is":[5,12,50,96,104,156,185,236,250,267,376,400,410,451,458,492,510,568,572,671,815,826,839,858,913,931,941,948,1091,1142,1164,1186,1430,1444,1455,1613,1631,1644,1707,1754,1767,1854,1877,1920,2005,2055,2121,2128,2228,2235,2254,2279,2311,2329,2348,2474,2479,2509,2542,2551,2558,2613,2658,2743,2767,2779,2808,2854,2858,2919,2982,3009,3123,3151,3185,3237],"a":[6,38,67,76,186,213,237,243,284,364,377,600,614,662,673,718,808,827,841,845,876,881,905,928,946,1034,1120,1148,1170,1195,1202,1409,1492,1582,1710,1770,1800,1823,1837,1894,2058,2142,2149,2255,2349,2373,2381,2475,2480,2490,2520,2539,2562,2638,2711,2726,2731,2737,2756,2768,2781,2791,2810,2861,2871,2910,2946,2959,3024,3067,3076,3100,3153,3161,3166,3172,3218,3227,3286,3292,3349,3367,3437],"popular":[7],"view.":[8,74],"But":[9,93,559,891,1222,1588,2119,2193,2308,2402,3177],"its":[10,2774],"popularity":[11],"undeserved.":[13],"In":[14,75,108,122,199,262,438,777,864,923,1123,1231,1688,1778,2618],"Brock":[15,561,656,778,1124,1232,1418,1671,1689,1994,2003,2208,2278,2800],"(),":[16,562,779,1233,1690,2801],"I":[17,45,64,111,125,128,146,563,915,1126,1234,1323,1691,1694,1731,2186,2313,2337,2431,2456,2463,2631,2647,2664,3105,3220,3229,3234,3242,3418,3430,3463],"explained":[18,1235],"why,":[19],"outlining":[20],"my":[21,99,118,781,920,1391,1468,2683,3414],"case":[22,418,2487,3415],"against":[23,1320,2204,3416],"all":[24,421,1364,1380,1984,2881],"forms":[25],"of":[26,41,79,171,188,253,277,283,327,352,373,383,389,404,422,468,630,675,690,708,743,755,792,823,836,861,870,878,959,1033,1107,1113,1119,1132,1205,1215,1312,1379,1386,1411,1413,1478,1556,1581,1594,1607,1616,1638,1704,1712,1793,1816,1898,1938,2033,2051,2061,2163,2399,2438,2472,2497,2522,2526,2582,2596,2614,2622,2626,2635,2676,2707,2764,2770,2812,2824,2845,2912,2917,2967,2973,3011,3014,3026,3033,3090,3155,3186,3197,3248,3259,3263,3268,3288,3294,3304,3322,3342,3347,3379,3441,3461,3471],"characters.":[30,1956,2656],"The":[31,570,734,1424,1702,2607,2685,2762],"argument":[32,2001,2203,2220,2259,2798],"was":[33,59,503,658,699,783,797,2314,2338,2342,2440,2928,2945,3059,3066],"never":[34,1859,2315],"intended":[35,2442,2955,3096],"to":[36,52,61,72,89,105,120,130,137,191,204,219,242,269,287,307,311,341,350,368,412,460,513,529,552,579,585,602,678,692,705,721,726,740,772,806,811,866,897,925,975,1007,1067,1069,1072,1088,1193,1210,1212,1247,1257,1332,1359,1375,1401,1446,1470,1502,1513,1533,1619,1674,1683,1696,1700,1709,1720,1738,1862,1891,1986,1990,1999,2014,2073,2124,2130,2180,2237,2264,2276,2281,2317,2340,2359,2390,2420,2443,2586,2690,2697,2701,2733,2736,2796,2833,2836,2876,2908,2956,2958,2985,3017,3039,3084,3097,3099,3110,3136,3168,3171,3190,3199,3226,3239,3256,3372,3376,3390,3420,3434,3439,3443,3466,3474],"give":[37,53,215,347,717,874,1408,2011,2415,3275],"decisive":[39],"refutation":[40],"creationism\u2014like":[42],"many":[43,257,1096],"others,":[44,1447],"do":[46,518,526,576,894,898,1471,1796,1860,2404,2457,3383,3399],"not":[47,519,527,577,598,651,672,700,767,895,1571,1725,1733,1768,1797,1804,1841,2122,2261,2303,2441,2458,2538,2559,2687,2780,2809,2816,3299,3384],"think":[48,147,2459,2986],"it":[49,58,210,450,661,681,857,940,1279,1357,1450,1560,1612,1643,1753,2113,2234,2356,2363,2488,2550,2694,2829,2857,2868,2873,2981,3194],"possible":[51,1272,1878,2882,3343],"knock\u2010down":[54],"arguments":[55],"in":[56,101,114,174,417,537,560,599,613,655,687,844,919,950,961,984,1011,1236,1342,1417,1458,1541,1589,1670,1717,1813,1852,1932,1973,1993,2002,2099,2106,2189,2207,2213,2352,2409,2486,2519,2637,2641,2799,2880,2942,2988,3069,3145,3301,3352,3394,3457],"philosophy\u2014but":[57],"meant":[60],"outline":[62],"what":[63,127,234,1102,1223,1693,1745,2597,2602,2974,3206],"see":[65,1968,3221,3243],"as":[66,206,273,555,759,1063,1104,1201,1501,1512,2141,2174,2372,2787,2860,2994,3023],"serious":[68,3336],"and":[69,98,143,345,406,472,495,543,557,695,843,851,1013,1071,1082,1110,1199,1274,1292,1301,1383,1481,1486,1546,1611,1663,1788,1811,1911,1982,2176,2251,2386,2397,2413,2417,2435,2447,2505,2611,2849,2925,2998,3254,3315,3319,3448],"underappreciated":[70],"challenge":[71,1469,1992],"the":[73,138,157,169,172,217,221,251,270,281,291,309,353,423,428,466,538,587,628,643,676,679,683,688,709,722,744,753,770,788,821,834,917,951,957,969,988,994,1003,1022,1030,1042,1061,1077,1117,1128,1174,1229,1238,1282,1296,1302,1310,1336,1344,1348,1377,1381,1384,1414,1434,1442,1459,1476,1515,1534,1579,1590,1595,1614,1632,1639,1646,1668,1713,1739,1749,1755,1844,1896,1899,1936,1939,1960,1974,1991,2000,2031,2049,2161,2202,2214,2223,2232,2269,2353,2395,2429,2467,2470,2495,2548,2579,2590,2619,2623,2633,2667,2674,2705,2719,2788,2797,2822,2839,2843,2902,2906,2915,2920,2930,2934,2943,2950,3003,3012,3015,3019,3029,3031,3046,3061,3091,3143,3191,3200,3232,3240,3317,3323,3345,3377,3386,3401,3472],"recent":[77],"issue":[78,1004],"this":[80,102,263,393,566,812,868,899,979,1402,1617,1923,2164,2184,2198,2309,2483,2512,2534,2692,3178,3458],"journal,":[81],"David":[82,1253],"Friedell":[83,142,1569,1576,1657,1678,1930,1977,2158,2194,2377,2629,2717,3129,3409,3467],"()":[84,657,762,1125,1672,2004,2886,3333],"makes":[85,1356,2117,3160,3180],"an":[86,207,401,493,1105,1145,1167,1190,1366,1499,1510,1530,1537,1553,1564,1573,1603,1718,1775,1988,2006,2039,2097,2560,2583,2995,3158],"admirable":[87],"attempt":[88,739,896,1719,3371,3475],"answer":[90,95,220,296,312,475,586,603,642,706,720,741,773,810,867,978,1087,1460,1473,1532,1538,1549,1989,2391,2561],"that":[91,159,387,446,454,490,508,521,532,541,565,573,616,659,701,798,818,1005,1036,1206,1265,1325,1338,1355,1428,1439,1539,1634,1648,1667,1722,1763,1783,1790,1806,1831,1874,1886,1944,1951,1979,2043,2048,2167,2197,2218,2225,2283,2292,2319,2326,2343,2355,2445,2469,2514,2544,2650,2741,2746,2752,2783,2889,2933,2987,3064,3086,3112,3122,3131,3182,3404],"challenge.":[92,1403],"his":[94,1654,2062,2074,2107,2627,2968],"inadequate,":[97],"aim":[100,1615],"note":[103,1618],"explain":[106,144,1452,1620],"why.":[107,1621],"Section":[109,2410],"I,":[110,2411],"briefly":[112],"outline,":[113],"very":[115,223,644],"general":[116,224,289,354,589,645,710,1535,1853],"terms,":[117],"objection":[119,139,1246,1256,1362,2310],"creationism.":[121,3417],"Sections":[123,1586],"II\u2013IV,":[124],"articulate":[126],"take":[129,1695,3432],"be":[131,305,669,693,714,848,1039,1495,1697,2370,2454,2555,2734,2785,2831,2877,3134,3169,3196,3435],"three":[132,1130,1285,1396,1698],"different":[133,1097,1287,1290,1293,1349,1353,1566,2523],"but":[134,647,758,1029,1437,1773,3117,3282,3397],"related":[135],"responses":[136,1609],"advocated":[140],"by":[141,168,633,955,967,1179,1497,1528,1653,1735,1807,2466,2669,2714,2904,3072],"why":[145,1453,1503,1514,2212,3005],"each":[148,351,1243,1306],"response":[149,1584,1647,1737,1998,2792],"ultimately":[150],"fails.":[151],"Creationism":[152,2344],"objects":[155,195,259,584,825,838,1480,1851,2019,2035,2891],"view":[158,684,1283,1435,1443,2351,2468,2513],"there":[160,228,317,375,395,399,433,440,447,729,1048,1429,1454,2083,3132],"are":[161,196,260,396,434,441,483,596,730,1025,1044,1049,1226,1298,1307,1394,1489,1506,1520,1724,2084,2088,2286,2294,2322,2426,2449,2896,3251,3327],"(merely)":[162,193],"objects,":[164,398,757,2980],"brought":[165],"into":[166,885,2021,2026,2517,2575],"existence":[167,1897,2328,2518,2576,2605,3318],"authors":[170,2652],"works":[173],"which":[175,192,1111,2493,2527,2918],"their":[176,1015,1865,2327,2436,2599,2604],"names":[177],"(or":[178,384,1153,1259,2553],"designating":[179],"descriptions)":[180],"first":[181,935,1175,1625,1714,2620,2916,3473],"appear.":[182],"variety":[187,2521],"according":[190,367],"abstract":[197,202,265,547,574,702,727,799,1269,1791,1850,2205,2226,2266,2894,2996],"entities.":[198],"order":[200,865,924],"for":[201,303,359,370,486,854,859,909,1173,1517,1602,1661,1849,2501,2730,2790,2802,3165,3279,3468],"count":[205],"adequate":[208],"theory,":[209],"should,":[211,302,3310],"at":[212,609,638,840,904,996,1363,1461,1728,1916,2290],"minimum,":[214],"us":[216,295,432,769,875,1623,2263,2593,2818,3081,3276],"resources":[218,771],"following":[222,1129,2215,2720],"questions:":[225],"Ontology.":[226],"Are":[227,316],"any":[229,274,371,707,742,1361,1794,1814,2110],"objects?":[231,255,322],"Identity.":[232],"Under":[233],"conditions":[235,3321],"object":[239,245,380,408,414,457,497,883,1141,1163,1185],"x":[240,409],"identical":[241,340,411,459,512,3238],"y?":[246],"Plenitude.":[247,2813],"How":[248,256,329],"abundant":[249,833,2030,2821],"domain":[252],"there?":[261],"respect,":[264],"held":[268],"same":[271,424,539,3047],"standard":[272],"other":[275,429,462,745,2893],"theory":[276,292,310,1035,3287,3293],"objects.":[279,437,593,733,2401,2709,2847],"On":[280,465,2183,2533,2601],"basis":[282,467,2162,2789],"theory's":[285,3350],"answers":[286,349,482,1060,1415,2013,2419,2835],"these":[288,469,1089,1216,1504,1676,2053,2421,2662,2975,3445],"questions,":[290,646,1536],"will":[293,1820,2046,2665,3107,3338],"help":[294,2616,2817,3188],"questions":[297,313,355,476,590,605,667,711,751,775,786,830,1090,1337,1474,1483,1505,2015,2054,2361,2393,2422,2703,2837,3210],"particular":[299,478,607,2738],"cases.":[300,479,625,3365,3408],"We":[301,1826],"example,":[304,360,487,2246],"able":[306],"apply":[308],"such":[314,554,624,665,774,1836,1893,1946,2173,2870,3364,3395,3427],"as:":[315],"more":[318,849,852,1276,1681,2229,2295,2330,2360,2671,2850],"than":[319,856,1278,2010,2231,2297,2332,2362,2842],"753":[320],"Is":[323,337],"Sherlock":[324,331,338],"Holmes":[325,332,339,491,509],"one":[326,1398,1412,1525,1633,1756,2168,3470],"them?":[328],"does":[330,1570,1803,1929,2603,2815,3298],"differ":[333],"from":[334,685,804,992,1020,1252,1543,2745],"actual":[335,3034],"detectives?":[336],"James":[342,514],"Bond?":[343],"Meinongians":[344,362,473,542,2412],"fictionalists":[346,471,505,544,2414],"clear":[348,719,2416,3181],"posed":[356],"above.":[357,712],"So,":[358,1972,2569],"na\u00efve":[361],"accept":[363],"comprehension":[365],"principle":[366,2782,2863,3184],"which,":[369],"combination":[372,388],"properties,":[374],"unique":[378],"made":[381,1308,2248,2713],"up":[382],"associated":[385,1241,1304],"with)":[386],"properties.":[390,425],"Consequently,":[391,449,546,594,1957],"on":[392,427,785,1002,1101,1335,1365,1440,1744,2160,2222,2482,2547,2644,2679],"view,":[394,1895,2484,2535],"infinite":[402],"number":[403,822,2398,2634,2675,2911],"them,":[405,1076,2588],"y":[415],"just":[416,2485,3075,3152],"they":[419,648,716,738,748,765,977,1018,1488,1723,2024,2293,2403,2425,2460,3283,3326,3398],"share":[420],"Fictionalists,":[426],"hand,":[430],"tell":[431],"few":[435,3077],"fact,":[439,3085],"none":[442],"(we":[443],"only":[444,1395,1769,2688],"make\u2010believe":[445,520],"are).":[448],"trivially":[452,511],"true":[453,2879],"every":[455,461],"object.":[464],"answers,":[470],"can":[474,549,2169,2567,2573,2653,2784,2830],"Sometimes":[480,747,3157],"those":[481,1050,1224,3407],"counterintuitive.":[484],"Meinongians,":[485,2384],"have":[488,506,766,801,1376,1835,1842,1880,2095,2379,2875,3421],"suggested":[489,507],"incomplete":[494],"nonexistent":[496],"who":[498,1051,1058,1368],"existed":[499,2964],"before":[500],"Conan":[501],"Doyle":[502],"born;":[504],"Bond":[515],"(though":[516,3193],"we":[517,933,1024,1780,1948,2407,3207,3388,3451],"\u201che\u201d":[522],"is).":[523],"creationists":[525,575,595,703,800,819,872,892,982,999,1248,1326],"tend":[528,578,3255],"say":[530,580,1931,1950,2698,2977,3111,3208],"things":[531,1098],"conflict":[533],"with":[534,750,1027,1219,1242,1289,1305,1352,1922,2041,2191,2433,2511,2609,3140,3253],"commonsense":[535,621],"opinion":[536],"way":[540,615,877,2643],"do.":[545],"seem":[550,1339,1374],"preferable":[551,1445],"alternatives":[553],"Meinongeanism":[556],"fictionalism.":[558],"argued":[564],"appearance":[567],"illusory.":[569],"reason":[571,3004],"enough":[581],"important":[588],"also":[597,1645,1774,1969,2195,2275,2388,2695,3114,3431],"position":[601,1372],"salient":[604,853],"cases":[608,3141],"all,":[610],"let":[611,1741],"alone":[612],"coheres":[617],"or":[618,790,900,966,1329,1422,1448,1559,2028,2289,2325,2531,2537,2748,2794,3214,3291,3306,3358],"complements":[619],"our":[620,2240,3360,3392],"opinions":[622],"Creationists":[626],"avoid":[627],"problem":[629],"counterintuitive":[631,1220,1432,1457],"commitments":[632,637,3351],"dodging":[634],"making":[635,3436],"solid":[636],"all.":[639,997,1462,1729,1917],"They":[640],"should":[641,847,1280,1494,1871,2260],"choose":[649],"instead":[650,1601],"to.":[652],"My":[653,697,795,1245],"claim":[654,698,796,820,1438,2224],"leaving":[660],"mystery":[663,2270],"how":[664,832,914,939,945,976,980,1487,2023,2029,2673,2820,3356],"basic":[666],"might":[668,1407,1426,1451,1466,1526,1550,1561,1781,1827,2378,3133,3452],"answered":[670],"virtue":[674],"view;":[677],"contrary,":[680],"disqualifies":[682],"consideration":[686,1711],"list":[689],"theories":[691,3403],"compared":[694],"evaluated.":[696],"fail":[704,1985],"To":[713,2109,2453],"sure,":[715],"ontological":[723],"question.":[724,813],"According":[725],"creationists,":[728],"indeed":[731],"trouble":[735,1760],"comes":[736,884,1218],"when":[737,880,927,1151,1485,2017,2725,3087,3163,3217,3246],"questions.":[746],"grapple":[749],"identity":[754,2396,2840,2865,3213,3290,3320],"Anthony":[760],"Everett":[761],"has":[763,1658,1758,1785,1903,2070,2302,2489,3127,3412,3424],"demonstrated,":[764],"given":[768],"adequately.":[776],"though,":[780,2776],"focus":[782,1743],"squarely":[784],"plenitude":[789,2706,2844],"abundance":[791,1477],"objects.1":[794],"universally":[802],"refrained":[803],"attempting":[805],"provide":[807,1987,3018],"substantial":[809],"This":[814,1548,2557],"surprising.":[816],"Given":[817],"contingent":[828],"matter,":[829],"realm":[835,2032,2823],"time":[842],"world":[846,3016],"pressing":[850],"them":[855,1519],"adherents":[860],"alternative":[862,1531,1554],"views.":[863,1230,1677],"sort":[869],"question,":[871,981,1023],"must":[873,934],"determining":[879],"(and":[886,2892],"goes":[887],"out":[888],"of)":[889],"existence.":[890,2600],"either":[893,954,1498],"alternatively":[901,1449],"merely":[902,2089],"gesture":[903],"woefully":[906],"underspecified":[907],"method":[908,3341,3346],"doing":[910],"so.":[911],"Here":[912],"put":[916],"point":[918,2382,3048],"original":[921],"paper:":[922],"learn":[926,936],"individual":[930],"created,":[932],"something":[937,1431,2543,2699],"created.":[942,1490],"One":[943,1406,1465],"explains":[944,2211],"character":[947,1198,2742,2753,3068,3162],"created":[949,1143,1165,1187,1954,2451,2898,2992,3071,3115],"relevant":[952,3020],"sense":[953,2354],"describing":[956],"act":[958,1106],"creation":[960,1118,2439],"terms":[962],"already":[963],"well":[964],"understood":[965,2859],"specifying":[968],"act's":[970],"proximate":[971],"cause.":[972],"With":[973],"respect":[974],"come":[983,2020,2025,2516,2574],"two":[985,1715,2803],"varieties.":[986],"First,":[987,2805],"majority":[989,1703],"simply":[990,3297],"refrain":[991,1019],"addressing":[993],"question":[995,1062],"These":[998,3271],"keep":[1000],"silent":[1001],"seems":[1006],"me":[1008,1742],"most":[1009,1637,1649,1759],"crucial":[1010,1341],"understanding":[1012],"assessing":[1014],"position.":[1016],"Because":[1017],"answering":[1021,1518,2052],"left":[1026],"nothing":[1028,1456],"barest":[1031],"sketch":[1032],"really":[1037],"can't":[1038],"evaluated":[1040],"until":[1041],"details":[1043],"filled":[1045],"in.":[1046],"Second,":[1047,2848],"echo":[1052],"John":[1053],"Searle":[1054,1093],"(1974\u201375;":[1055],"1979,":[1056],"73),":[1057],"famously":[1059],"follows:":[1064],"\u201cBy":[1065],"pretending":[1066],"refer":[1068,1211,2957,3098],"people":[1070],"recount":[1073],"events":[1074,3247,3258,3262,3267],"author":[1078,1146,1168,1191,1367,1772,2728,2750,3159],"creates":[1079,2138],"events.\u201d":[1083],"(,":[1084,1966,3175],"356)":[1085],"Searle's":[1086,1133,1557],"insufficient.":[1092],"could":[1094,1399],"mean":[1095],"here,":[1099],"depending":[1100],"counts":[1103],"pretend":[1108,1114],"reference":[1109,1115],"acts":[1112,1815,2437],"involve":[1116,1551,1562,2528],"individual.":[1122],"considered":[1127],"interpretations":[1131,1217],"thesis:":[1134],"Any":[1135],"Use":[1136,1158],"Account":[1137,1159],"(AUA).":[1138],"A":[1139,1161,1183],"whenever":[1144,1166,1188],"uses":[1147,1169],"name":[1150,1172,2951,3092],"writing":[1152,2923,3028,3056],"telling)":[1154],"her":[1155,1809,1847],"story.":[1156],"First":[1157],"(FUA).":[1160],"time.":[1176],"Intended":[1177],"Creation":[1178],"Pretense":[1180],"View":[1181],"(ICP).":[1182],"(i)":[1189],"intends":[1192,2729],"create":[1194,1822,2146,2153,2587,2655],"new":[1196,2757],"(ii)":[1200],"causal":[1203],"consequence":[1204],"intention,":[1207],"she":[1208,1784,1802,1819,1833,1839,1857,1889,1902],"pretends":[1209],"it.":[1213],"Each":[1214],"consequences.":[1221],"consequences":[1225],"varies":[1227],"between":[1228,2661],"detail":[1237],"specific":[1239,1482],"problems":[1240,1291,1303],"interpretation.":[1244],"thus":[1249],"draws":[1250,2038],"inspiration":[1251],"Lewis's":[1254,1318],"famous":[1255,1771],"ersatz":[1258,1266],"abstract)":[1260],"modal":[1261],"realism.":[1262],"Lewis":[1263],"complained":[1264],"realism\u2014that":[1267],"is,":[1268,1679,2036],"realism":[1270],"worlds":[1273],"individuals\u2014seems":[1275],"plausible":[1277,2984],"because":[1281,1752,1846,3010],"conflates":[1284],"importantly":[1286],"theories,":[1288],"virtues.2":[1294],"Once":[1295],"views":[1297,1313,2075,3378],"distinguished":[1299],"carefully":[1300],"salient,":[1309],"cluster":[1311],"becomes":[1314],"less":[1315],"plausible.":[1316],"Like":[1317],"complaint":[1319],"ersatzers,":[1321],"then,":[1322],"maintain":[1324],"\u201ckeep":[1327],"silent,":[1328],"explicitly":[1330],"decline":[1331],"commit":[1333],"themselves,":[1334],"\u2026":[1340,1346,2651,2970],"dividing":[1343],"versions.":[1345],"Since":[1347],"versions":[1350,1382],"meet":[1351],"objections,":[1354],"hard":[1358],"pin":[1360],"keeps":[1369],"neutral.":[1370],"His":[1371,2093,2258],"may":[1373,2145,2152,3195],"advantages":[1378],"drawbacks":[1385],"none!\u201d":[1387],"(Lewis":[1388],",":[1389,1686,1926,2156,2306,2760],"141,":[1390],"emphasis).":[1392],"There":[1393,2087,2657],"ways":[1397,2549],"respond":[1400,1527],"Direct":[1404],"Response.":[1405,1464,1523],"defense":[1410,1425,1493,2769],"canvassed":[1416],"():":[1419],"AUA,":[1420,1544,1980],"FUA,":[1421,1545,1981],"ICP.":[1423,1547,1701],"concede":[1427],"defended":[1436],"balance":[1441],"Indirect":[1463],"refuse\u2014despite":[1467],"so\u2014to":[1472],"Such":[1491,3381],"accompanied":[1496],"explanation":[1500,1511],"unimportant":[1507],"or,":[1508],"alternatively,":[1509],"prospects":[1516,1580,2050],"good.":[1521,2056],"Ambitious":[1522],"Finally,":[1524],"presenting":[1529],"differs":[1540],"substance":[1542],"giving":[1552,1563],"interpretation":[1555],"thesis,":[1558],"entirely":[1565,2188],"account":[1567,2595],"altogether.":[1568],"consider":[1572,1624,2909,3205],"ambitious":[1574],"response.":[1575,1605,1629,2008],"initially":[1577],"considers":[1578],"direct":[1583,1628,2580],"(see":[1585],"III\u2013V).":[1587],"final":[1591,1975,2624],"main":[1592,1997],"section":[1593,2625],"paper":[1596,1640,2766],"(Section":[1597],"VI),":[1598],"he":[1599,1635,1746,1757,1958,2037,2044,2064,2103,2116,2120,2962,3006,3095,3147,3411,3423],"opts":[1600],"indirect":[1604,2007],"Both":[1606],"Friedell's":[1608,1626,1705,1736,1996,2365,2765,3183],"fail,":[1610],"Let":[1622,3080],"(attempted)":[1627],"It":[1630,2508,2814],"spends":[1636],"developing.":[1641],"Yet":[1642],"clearly":[1650,3314],"fails,":[1651],"even":[1652,1828,1887],"own":[1655],"admission.":[1656],"no":[1659,1914,2085,2529,2615,3187,3426],"sympathy":[1660],"AUA":[1662],"FUA.":[1664],"He":[1665,1934,1942,2081,2127,2210,2301],"concedes":[1666,1935,1978],"counterexamples":[1669,1699,1727,3375],"succeed":[1673],"refute":[1675],"however,":[1680,1919],"sympathetic":[1682],"ICP":[1684,1983],"(Friedell":[1685,2155,2305,2759],"130).":[1687],"presented":[1692],"article":[1706],"devoted":[1708],"counterexamples,":[1716],"show":[1721,2282,2318,2341],"genuine":[1726,3455],"Although":[1730],"am":[1732,2187,2464,3464],"convinced":[1734],"cases,":[1740],"says":[1747,1959],"third":[1750],"counterexample,":[1751],"with.":[1761,3329],"Imagine":[1762],"J.":[1764],"K.":[1765],"Rowling":[1766,1952],"amateur":[1776],"philosopher.":[1777],"particular,":[1779],"suppose":[1782,1829],"nominalistic":[1786],"tendencies":[1787],"believes":[1789,3410],"entities":[1792],"kind":[1795,3249,3260,3264,3269],"exist.":[1798],"As":[1799,2406,3330,3366],"consequence,":[1801,3368],"believe":[1805],"telling":[1808],"stories":[1810,1845],"engaging":[1812],"referential":[1817],"pretense,":[1818],"thereby":[1821],"character.":[1825,3103],"further":[1830],"if":[1832,1888,2268,2383,2424,2570,2856,3053],"did":[1834,2999,3007,3118],"belief,":[1838],"would":[1840,1858,1949,2114,2554,2874,3049],"written":[1843,1904],"disdain":[1848],"so":[1855,2506,3000,3008,3119,3450],"great":[1856],"anything":[1861],"bring":[1863],"proliferation.":[1866],"Realists":[1867],"agree,":[1872],"first,":[1873],"Rowling's":[1875],"attitude":[1876],"(others":[1879],"certainly":[1881],"shared":[1882],"it)":[1883],"and,":[1884],"second,":[1885],"were":[1890,2869],"hold":[1892],"about\u2014Harry":[1905],"Potter,":[1906],"Hermione":[1907],"Granger,":[1908],"Ron":[1909],"Weasley,":[1910],"others\u2014is":[1912],"under":[1913,1945,2929,3060],"threat":[1915],"ICP,":[1918],"inconsistent":[1921],"intuition":[1924],"(Brock":[1925],"362).":[1927],"What":[1928,2336],"response?":[1933],"force":[1937],"thought":[1940,2059,2165,2366,2913,2963],"experiment.":[1941],"suggests":[1943],"circumstances":[1947],"accidentally":[1953,2654],"counterexample":[1961],"\u201cis":[1962],"genuine\u2014it":[1963],"refutes":[1964],"ICP\u201d":[1965],"130,":[1967],"134,":[1970,2682],"135).":[1971,3176],"analysis,":[1976],"().":[1995,2209],"Rather":[2009],"precise":[2012],"existence,":[2022,2027],"analogy":[2040,2430,2608],"carpentry":[2042],"hopes":[2045],"demonstrate":[2047],"Outlining":[2057],"experiment":[2060],"own,":[2063],"says:":[2065,2630],"Suppose":[2066],"Peter":[2067],"van":[2068,2135],"Inwagen":[2069,2079,2136],"stayed":[2071],"faithful":[2072],"composition":[2077],"(van":[2078],"1990).":[2080],"thinks":[2082,2196],"tables.":[2086,2118,2126,2139,2154,2277],"simples":[2090,2132],"arranged":[2091],"tablewise.":[2092,2133],"musings":[2094],"sparked":[2096],"interest":[2098],"carpentry.":[2100],"Every":[2101],"weekend":[2102],"carves":[2104],"wood":[2105],"garage.":[2108],"nonphilosophical":[2111],"observer":[2112],"appear":[2115],"intending":[2123,2179,3164],"make":[2125,2170,2181,3453],"trying":[2129,2236,2280,2316,2339],"arrange":[2131],"Intuitively,":[2134],"still":[2137],"Just":[2140],"nominalist":[2143],"storyteller":[2144],"characters,":[2148],"nihilist":[2150],"carpenter":[2151],"134)":[2157,2307],"concludes,":[2159],"experiment,":[2166,2367],"concrete":[2171,2299,2334],"artifacts":[2172],"tables":[2175,2446,2515,2612],"chairs":[2177,2448],"without":[2178,2577,2754],"anything.":[2182],"point,":[2185],"agreement":[2190],"Friedell.":[2192],"fact":[2199],"somehow":[2200],"undermines":[2201],"passage:":[2216],"Recall":[2217],"Brock's":[2219],"relies":[2221],"mysterious":[2230,2296,2324,2331,2350],"phenomena":[2233],"explain,":[2238],"namely,":[2239],"intuitions":[2241],"certain":[2243],"sentences":[2244],"(for":[2245],"\u2018Rowling":[2247],"Harry":[2249],"Potter\u2019":[2250],"\u2018Harry":[2252],"Potter":[2253],"character\u2019).":[2257],"persuade":[2262],"reject":[2265],"surrounding":[2271],"applies":[2274],"uniquely":[2287,2323],"mysterious,":[2288],"least":[2291],"mundane":[2298,2333],"artifacts.":[2300,2335,2452],"succeeded.":[2304],"misguided.":[2312],"Fictional":[2346],"Objects":[2347],"gives":[2357],"rise":[2358],"answers.":[2364],"therefore,":[2368],"cannot":[2369,3284],"taken":[2371],"tu":[2374],"quoque":[2375],"argument.":[2376],"had":[2380],"fictionalists,":[2385],"others":[2387],"refused":[2389],"principled":[2392],"not!":[2405],"saw":[2408,3230,3235],"straightforward":[2418],"(even":[2423],"counterintuitive).":[2427],"Moreover,":[2428],"raised":[2432],"carpenters":[2434,2610],"imply":[2444],"essentially":[2450],"clear,":[2455],"are.":[2461],"Instead,":[2462],"tempted":[2465],"property":[2471,2732,3167],"being\u2010a\u2010table":[2473],"functional":[2476],"kind.":[2477],"Something":[2478],"table,":[2481],"flat":[2491],"surface,":[2492],"serves":[2494],"purpose":[2496],"resting":[2498],"items":[2499],"used":[2500,2552,2786,2832],"eating,":[2502],"writing,":[2503],"working,":[2504],"forth.":[2507],"consistent":[2510],"ways,":[2524],"some":[2525,2594,2642,2659,3454],"agency":[2530],"intentions.":[2532,2646,2680],"whether":[2536],"table":[2540],"exists":[2541],"metaphysically":[2545],"depends":[2546,2640,2678],"used).":[2556],"creationist":[2563,2591],"give.":[2568],"being":[2578,3469],"product":[2581],"agent's":[2584],"intention":[2585],"then":[2589],"owes":[2592],"grounds":[2598],"depend?":[2606],"here.":[2617],"paragraph":[2621],"paper,":[2628],"claimed":[2632],"fiction":[2639],"authorial":[2645],"[also]":[2648],"conceded":[2649],"tension":[2660,2668],"claims.":[2663,2866],"resolve":[2666,2691],"saying":[2670],"(2016,":[2681],"emphasis)":[2684],"passage":[2686],"promises":[2689,2696],"tension,":[2693],"helpful":[2700],"address":[2702],"Generalizing":[2710],"suggestion":[2712],"Amie":[2715],"Thomasson,":[2716],"defends":[2718],"principle:":[2721],"Nothing":[2722,2771,2777,2806,2852,3125,3137,3273],"New.":[2723,2772,3138],"Generally,":[2724],"fiction's":[2727],"ascribed":[2735,3170],"pre\u2010existent":[2739],"character\u2014whether":[2740],"originally":[2744],"work":[2747],"another\u2014the":[2749],"represents":[2751],"creating":[2755],"one.":[2758],"135)":[2761],"remainder":[2763],"Whatever":[2773],"merits,":[2775],"New":[2778,2807,2853,3126,3150],"(ambitious":[2793],"otherwise)":[2795],"reasons.":[2804],"Principle":[2811],"establish":[2819],"fictionalia":[2825],"is.":[2826],"At":[2827],"best,":[2828],"ground":[2834,3285,3406],"rather":[2841],"importantly,":[2851],"false":[2855],"metaphysical":[2862,3402],"grounding":[2864],"If":[2867,3121],"principle,":[2872],"exceptionless\u2014universally":[2878],"worlds.":[2883],"Zs\u00f3fia":[2884],"Zvolenszky":[2885],"argues":[2887],"persuasively":[2888],"artifacts)":[2895],"often":[2897],"inadvertently.":[2899,3001,3120],"She":[2900],"illustrates":[2901],"idea":[2903],"asking":[2905],"reader":[2907],"experiments,":[2914],"following:":[2921],"While":[2922],"War":[2924],"Peace,":[2926],"Tolstoy":[2927,2954,2991,3088,3113],"mistaken":[2931,3062],"impression":[2932,3063],"protagonist,":[2935],"Prince":[2936],"Bolkonsky,":[2937],"like":[2938,3142],"Napoleon":[2939],"(also":[2940],"featured":[2941],"novel),":[2944],"real":[2947],"person.":[2948],"Introducing":[2949],"\u201cAndrei":[2952],"Bolkonsky,\u201d":[2953],"historical":[2960],"figure":[2961],"quite":[2965],"independently":[2966,2972],"novel.":[2969],"Quite":[2971],"theorists":[2976],"mythical":[2979],"overwhelmingly":[2983],"Scenario":[2989],"T,":[2990],"Bolkonsky":[2993,3041],"artifact,":[2997],"And":[3002],"non\u2010cooperation":[3013],"entity.":[3021],"Further,":[3022],"result":[3025],"Tolstoy's":[3027],"novel,":[3030],"range":[3032],"plausibly":[3037],"came":[3038],"include":[3040],"also.":[3042],"(319)":[3043],"Of":[3044],"course,":[3045],"apply,":[3050],"mutatis":[3051],"mutandis,":[3052],"Tolstoy,":[3054],"while":[3055],"Anna":[3057,3065],"Karenina,":[3058],"Middlemarch,":[3070],"George":[3073],"Elliot":[3074]},"counts_by_year":[{"year":2024,"cited_by_count":13},{"year":2023,"cited_by_count":3},{"year":2021,"cited_by_count":3},{"year":2020,"cited_by_count":15},{"year":2018,"cited_by_count":1}],"updated_date":"2026-10-16T09:59:22.235173","created_date":"2018-06-13T00:00:00"}