{"id":"https://openalex.org/W2163663437","doi":"https://doi.org/10.15200/winn.142557.78481","title":"Now I am become DOI, destroyer of gatekeeping worlds","display_name":"Now I am become DOI, destroyer of gatekeeping worlds","publication_year":2015,"publication_date":"2015-03-05","ids":{"openalex":"https://openalex.org/W2163663437","doi":"https://doi.org/10.15200/winn.142557.78481","mag":"2163663437"},"language":"en","primary_location":{"id":"doi:10.15200/winn.142557.78481","doi":"https://doi.org/10.15200/winn.142557.78481","is_oa":true,"landing_page_url":"https://doi.org/10.15200/winn.142557.78481","pdf_url":null,"source":null,"license":"cc-by","license_id":"https://openalex.org/licenses/cc-by","version":"acceptedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":false,"raw_source_name":null,"raw_type":"posted-content"},"volume":null,"type":"preprint","indexed_in":["crossref"],"open_access":{"is_oa":true,"oa_status":"green","oa_url":"https://doi.org/10.15200/winn.142557.78481","any_repository_has_fulltext":null},"authorships":[{"author_position":"first","author":{"id":"https://openalex.org/A5089396175","display_name":"Tal Yarkoni","orcid":"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6558-5113","observed_orcids":["https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6558-5113"]},"institutions":[],"countries":[],"is_corresponding":true,"raw_author_name":"Tal Yarkoni","raw_affiliation_strings":[],"raw_orcid":null,"affiliations":[]}],"institutions":[],"countries_distinct_count":0,"institutions_distinct_count":0,"corresponding_author_ids":["https://openalex.org/A5089396175"],"corresponding_institution_ids":[],"apc_list":null,"apc_paid":null,"fwci":null,"has_fulltext":false,"cited_by_count":1,"citation_normalized_percentile":null,"cited_by_percentile_year":null,"biblio":{"volume":null,"issue":null,"first_page":null,"last_page":null},"is_retracted":false,"is_paratext":false,"is_xpac":false,"primary_topic":{"id":"https://openalex.org/T13607","display_name":"Academic Publishing and Open Access","score":0.4066999852657318,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1802","display_name":"Information Systems and Management"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/18","display_name":"Decision Sciences"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},"topics":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/T13607","display_name":"Academic Publishing and Open Access","score":0.4066999852657318,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1802","display_name":"Information Systems and Management"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/18","display_name":"Decision Sciences"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},{"id":"https://openalex.org/T13516","display_name":"Publishing and Scholarly Communication","score":0.3508000075817108,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1207","display_name":"History and Philosophy of Science"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/12","display_name":"Arts and Humanities"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},{"id":"https://openalex.org/T10102","display_name":"scientometrics and bibliometrics research","score":0.07100000232458115,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1804","display_name":"Statistics, Probability and Uncertainty"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/18","display_name":"Decision Sciences"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}}],"keywords":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/digital-object-identifiers","display_name":"digital object identifiers","score":0.9959999918937683},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/scholarly-publishing","display_name":"scholarly publishing","score":0.597000002861023},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/gatekeeping","display_name":"gatekeeping","score":0.6029999852180481},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/citation-practices","display_name":"citation practices","score":0.9810000061988831},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/scholarly-communication","display_name":"scholarly communication","score":0.5590000152587891},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/open-access","display_name":"open access","score":0.42800000309944153},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/citation-indexes","display_name":"citation indexes","score":0.3889999985694885},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/scholarly-blogs","display_name":"scholarly blogs","score":0.3529999852180481},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/scholarly-communication-infrastructure","display_name":"scholarly communication infrastructure","score":0.44699999690055847}],"concepts":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/C73380752","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q609087","display_name":"Gatekeeping","level":2,"score":0.7601742744445801},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C17744445","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q36442","display_name":"Political science","level":0,"score":0.2451677918434143},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C199539241","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q7748","display_name":"Law","level":1,"score":0.12520357966423035}],"mesh":[],"locations_count":1,"locations":[{"id":"doi:10.15200/winn.142557.78481","doi":"https://doi.org/10.15200/winn.142557.78481","is_oa":true,"landing_page_url":"https://doi.org/10.15200/winn.142557.78481","pdf_url":null,"source":null,"license":"cc-by","license_id":"https://openalex.org/licenses/cc-by","version":"acceptedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":false,"raw_source_name":null,"raw_type":"posted-content"}],"best_oa_location":{"id":"doi:10.15200/winn.142557.78481","doi":"https://doi.org/10.15200/winn.142557.78481","is_oa":true,"landing_page_url":"https://doi.org/10.15200/winn.142557.78481","pdf_url":null,"source":null,"license":"cc-by","license_id":"https://openalex.org/licenses/cc-by","version":"acceptedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":false,"raw_source_name":null,"raw_type":"posted-content"},"sustainable_development_goals":[],"study_designs":[],"awards":[],"funders":[],"has_content":{"grobid_xml":false,"pdf":false},"content_urls":null,"referenced_works_count":0,"referenced_works":[],"related_works":["https://openalex.org/W2016382289","https://openalex.org/W2901134562","https://openalex.org/W7124871786","https://openalex.org/W2539818206","https://openalex.org/W3214256317","https://openalex.org/W2528116804","https://openalex.org/W1217482362","https://openalex.org/W4385213867","https://openalex.org/W3211084619","https://openalex.org/W4390489993"],"abstract_inverted_index":{"Digital":[0],"object":[1,30],"identifiers":[2,2483],"(DOIs)":[3],"are":[4,314,429,613,647,747,1339,2045,2148,2271,2542,2941,3000,3045,3082,3086,3188],"much":[5],"sought-after":[6],"commodities":[7],"in":[8,145,174,228,317,322,335,339,399,482,557,581,642,670,703,913,987,1020,1037,1091,1122,1207,1226,1236,1276,1350,1375,1393,1406,1437,1632,1681,1692,1765,1768,1798,1818,1838,1849,1866,1915,1944,2107,2170,2236,2333,2494,2509,2580,2585,2590,2592,2623,2647,2733,2916,3144,3209,3243],"the":[9,40,46,81,85,106,115,125,146,151,155,166,245,259,274,304,328,332,362,377,438,444,462,486,502,517,594,607,652,660,719,721,758,776,785,792,812,824,842,848,876,928,942,978,1038,1058,1078,1138,1209,1231,1247,1376,1381,1388,1399,1407,1410,1427,1448,1508,1518,1613,1649,1696,1711,1726,1743,1804,1809,1819,1830,1840,1850,1857,1867,1893,1912,1918,1927,1945,1958,2043,2050,2060,2108,2116,2133,2136,2143,2171,2218,2252,2258,2274,2352,2356,2372,2440,2463,2476,2610,2648,2659,2734,2776,2784,2996,3005,3017,3022,3030,3050,3063,3107,3123,3200,3205,3217,3228,3233,3246,3258,3262,3265],"world":[10,116,1093,2275],"of":[11,35,63,117,131,209,240,247,256,263,553,578,662,741,768,778,795,811,847,911,919,959,990,1026,1047,1061,1080,1094,1099,1145,1157,1230,1318,1347,1352,1358,1391,1401,1409,1419,1442,1504,1520,1562,1575,1586,1612,1655,1684,1770,1811,1821,1879,1929,1947,2110,2115,2202,2220,2238,2305,2354,2363,2439,2449,2465,2472,2479,2530,2532,2565,2613,2652,2664,2720,2762,2791,2912,2962,3013,3029,3076,3089,3109,3129,3204,3219,3223,3261,3264],"academic":[12,671,704,947,1120,1278,1650,1973,2008,2466,2824],"publishing.":[13,2467],"If":[14,2052,2365,2991],"you\u2019ve":[15,48,2327,2429,2982,2992],"never":[16],"seen":[17],"one,":[18],"a":[19,22,27,33,61,137,203,206,229,248,279,293,343,396,420,436,511,603,739,773,782,873,908,917,945,981,994,1062,1092,1108,1154,1215,1224,1241,1329,1333,1480,1486,1501,1553,1595,1599,1633,1644,1682,1693,1735,1846,1864,1888,1971,2006,2023,2033,2039,2079,2188,2198,2214,2227,2240,2243,2302,2323,2495,2536,2553,2557,2561,2587,2621,2680,2701,2742,2748,2816,2837,2847,2850,2904,2954,2966,3009,3126,3180],"DOI":[20,152,344,759,783,1225,1635,1736,2199,2241,2681,2702,3249],"is":[21,121,150,334,453,686,761,788,826,881,1328,1396,1425,1523,1531,1619,1863,1938,1965,2119,2124,2140,2205,2229,2242,2246,2266,2276,2280,2285,2655,2658,2843,3104],"unique":[23,2482],"string":[24,147],"associated":[25,153,1919,2048],"with":[26,154,327,606,679,738,821,890,1218,1541,1706,1953,2049,2086,2435,2635,2995,3194],"particular":[28,2470],"digital":[29,1948,2485,2721],"(most":[31],"commonly":[32],"publication":[34,227,348,1492,2024,2572,2964,3196,3225],"some":[36,532,766,955,971,1351,1620,2286,2359,2911,3040],"kind)":[37],"that":[38,94,129,231,285,313,331,372,374,470,541,687,711,733,771,805,827,878,902,921,1049,1112,1264,1285,1337,1366,1538,1729,1836,1872,2098,2122,2145,2163,2190,2226,2261,2267,2283,2290,2319,2341,2348,2378,2424,2455,2599,2626,2673,2758,2828,2892,2998,3053,3092,3117,3236,3244],"lets":[39],"internet":[41,943,979],"know":[42,56,1152],"where":[43,57,624,1097,1426,2422,2971,3147,3160],"to":[44,55,91,124,136,165,222,243,273,321,394,418,458,478,547,589,601,657,665,677,692,763,798,819,859,861,883,892,937,944,957,969,973,1003,1016,1072,1104,1115,1125,1151,1165,1175,1184,1259,1270,1364,1397,1414,1568,1589,1628,1658,1713,1782,1790,1794,1816,1911,1925,1940,1983,2000,2014,2022,2032,2038,2063,2077,2088,2101,2130,2156,2166,2184,2208,2233,2250,2255,2301,2358,2369,2394,2418,2484,2502,2524,2615,2637,2678,2682,2691,2703,2728,2770,2795,2806,2845,2864,2882,2890,2928,2944,2946,2960,2977,2987,3024,3048,3073,3105,3214],"find":[45,1196,1202,1260,3021],"stuff":[47,620],"written.":[49],"For":[50,290,319,901,1510,1992],"example,":[51,291],"say":[52,479,2399],"you":[53,58,134,143,171,181,370,409,566,636,1149,1162,1182,1200,1250,1269,1299,1312,1516,1537,1548,1760,1781,1792,1801,1922,1968,1979,1989,2020,2028,2053,2057,2067,2071,2074,2320,2349,2448,2694,2885,2942,3019],"want":[54,393,417,546,1150,1183],"can":[59,78,172,626,1195,1244,1535,1545,2058,2291,2446,2695,2812,2821,2879,3151,3170],"get":[60,215,459,1590,2914,3074,3215],"hold":[62],"an":[64,253,1044,1402,1438,1661,1766,2083,3145,3185],"article":[65,333,1767],"titled,":[66],"oh,":[67],"say,":[68,871,2832,3043],"Designing":[69],"next-generation":[70],"platforms":[71,2665],"for":[72,177,226,461,651,791,1284,1490,1570,1578,1643,1803,1843,1957,2128,2260,2342,2387,2415,2491,2538,2552,2556,2583,2603,2759,2793,2989,3192],"evaluating":[73,2355],"scientific":[74,754,1378,1491,1718,2203,2209,2269,2763,2963,3002,3149,3224],"output:":[75],"what":[76,904,1153,1517,1549,1967,2981],"scientists":[77],"learn":[79],"from":[80,258,303,775,2135,2560,2852,3056],"social":[82],"web.":[83],"In":[84,756,1137,1445,2870,3183],"real":[86,126],"world,":[87,127,608,1140],"you\u2019d":[88,103,212],"probably":[89,530,545,1068,1623],"go":[90,135],"Google,":[92,133],"type":[93],"title":[95],"in,":[96],"and":[97,141,197,338,341,346,355,403,516,803,863,886,988,1107,1147,1295,1309,1320,1322,1360,1493,1671,1679,1686,1703,1716,1832,1907,1950,1987,2278,2298,2310,2398,2433,2498,2505,2568,2573,2661,2698,2710,2877,2900,2932,3008,3111,3159,3165,3197,3257],"within":[98,361],"three":[99,2738,2974,3137],"or":[100,270,316,575,701,1343,1404,1572,1580,1807,2003,2437,2670,2715,2737,2765,2859,2919,2973,3136],"four":[101],"clicks,":[102],"arrive":[104],"at":[105,659,751,963,1057,1198,1204,1340,1482,2095,2308,2312,2854,3155],"document":[107],"you\u2019re":[108,161,2011,2035,2958],"looking":[109,3072],"for.":[110],"As":[111,1380,1956],"it":[112,406,467,508,802,806,1000,1067,1169,1203,1221,1237,1462,1525,1539,1550,1673,1708,1721,1784,1827,1855,1985,2069,2129,2212,2331,2675,2753,2985],"turns":[113,468],"out,":[114],"formal":[118,389,946,1420,3031],"resource":[119],"location":[120],"fairly":[122],"similar":[123,2605],"except":[128],"instead":[130,3128],"using":[132,3212],"website":[138],"called":[139,1475],"dx.DOI.org,":[140],"then":[142,2925],"plug":[144],"\u201910.3389/fncom.2012.00072\u2032,":[148],"which":[149,170,286,914,1478,1870],"aforementioned":[156],"article.":[157,490],"And":[158,237,528,537,744,1034,1543,2042,2909,3242],"then,":[159,538],"poof,":[160,1603],"automagically":[162],"linked":[163],"directly":[164,2256],"original":[167],"document,":[168],"upon":[169],"gaze":[173],"great":[175],"awe":[176],"as":[178,180,205,250,1740,1742,2200,2384,2620,2799,2801,2965,3125],"long":[179,2554],"feel":[182,658,2803,3038],"comfortable.":[183],"Historically,":[184],"DOIs":[185,200,249,1657,2614,2881],"have":[186,201,414,831,924,1083,1164,1371,1386,1567,1751,2181,2549,2578,2889,2903,2976],"almost":[187,2168,3094],"exclusively":[188],"been":[189,288,476,2550],"issued":[190],"by":[191,386,718,1054,2142,2773,3122,3134],"official-type":[192],"publishers:":[193],"Elsevier,":[194],"Wiley,":[195],"PLoS":[196],"such.":[198],"Consequently,":[199],"had":[202,1013],"reputation":[204,3168],"minor":[207],"badge":[208],"distinction\u2013probably":[210],"because":[211,239,383,455,568,780,1087,1331,1639,1860,2211,2273,2752],"traditionally":[213],"only":[214,283,311,1051],"one":[216,281,539,1025,1205,1342,1556,1611,1769,2450,2833,3006],"if":[217,494,688,855,1011,1148,1249,1754,1873,2010,2428,2829,2910,2957],"your":[218,400,1277,2016,2704],"work":[219,580,723,787,934,1121,2330,2511,2798,3096],"was":[220,232,724,980,1043,1188,2407],"perceived":[221],"be":[223,359,441,510,525,563,708,716,736,950,970,1032,1052,1434,1904,1981,2234,2392,2771,2788,2926,3152],"important":[224,789],"enough":[225,368,790,2175],"journal":[230,330,489,1065,2688],"(at":[233,2935],"least":[234,1341,2936],"nominally)":[235],"peer-reviewed.":[236],"perhaps":[238,2517],"this":[241,300,549,1176,1219,1273,1424,1446,1467,1529,1608,1763,1796,1895,1901,1963,2055,2186,2431,2456,2469,2896,2950,3210],"tendency":[242],"view":[244],"presence":[246],"something":[251,1474,2400],"like":[252,765,1240,1756,2072,2401,2666,2874,3039],"implicit":[254],"seal":[255],"approval":[257],"Great":[260],"Sky":[261],"Guild":[262],"Academic":[264],"Publishing,":[265],"many":[266,654,2760,3080],"journals":[267,1266,1844,2918],"impose":[268],"official":[269],"unofficial":[271],"commandments":[272],"effect":[275,1310],"that,":[276,1883],"when":[277,610,977,1040],"writing":[278,872],"paper,":[280],"shalt":[282],"citeth":[284],"hath":[287],"DOI-ified.":[289],"here\u2019s":[292],"boilerplate":[294],"Elsevier":[295,631,797,1382,1439,1757],"statement":[296],"regarding":[297],"references":[298,320],"(in":[299,1786],"case,":[301,1447],"taken":[302],"Neuron":[305,401],"author":[306,1383],"guidelines):":[307],"References":[308],"should":[309,358,1980],"include":[310,342],"articles":[312],"published":[315,839,1021,1190],"press.":[318],"press":[323,340],"articles,":[324,705,1022],"please":[325],"confirm":[326],"cited":[329,360,786,1436],"fact":[336,1728,2144],"accepted":[337],"number":[345,1622],"online":[347],"date.":[349],"Unpublished":[350],"data,":[351],"submitted":[352],"manuscripts,":[353],"abstracts,":[354],"personal":[356],"communications":[357],"text":[363,378,1408],"only.":[364],"This":[365,1936],"seems":[366,935,1124],"reasonable":[367],"until":[369,1528],"realize":[371],"citations":[373,1028,2100],"occur":[375],"\u201cwithin":[376],"only\u201d":[379],"aren\u2019t":[380,2029],"very":[381,749,2046,2522,2604,3051],"useful,":[382],"they\u2019re":[384,2153],"ignored":[385],"virtually":[387,1102,1471,2716],"all":[388,1370,2096,2293,2438,2492,2506,2531,2600,2789,2952],"citation":[390,439,774,1744,2930],"indices.":[391],"You":[392,416,432,1194,1243,1287],"cite":[395,419,435,548,667,693,916,1017,1272,1289,1301,1314,1762,1795,1984,2383,2503],"blog":[397,534,699,1177,1274,1354,1481,1626,1659,1667,1698,1731,2616,2641,2814,2835,2867,2923],"post":[398,1275,1291,1306,1468,1668,1699,1732,2836],"paper":[402,874,1800,2377],"make":[404,1817,2674,3026],"sure":[405,493],"counts?":[407],"Well,":[408,506,1854,2427],"can\u2019t!":[410],"Blog":[411],"posts":[412,535,1355,1627,2617,2642,2815,2868],"don\u2019t":[413,639,1253,1748,1923,2075,2336,3067],"DOIs!":[415],"what?":[421],"A":[422,1454,1458,1665,2222],"tweet?":[423],"That\u2019s":[424],"just":[425,617,694,830,1009,1117,1163,1593,2030,2346],"crazy":[426],"talk!":[427],"Tweets":[428],"140":[430],"characters!":[431],"can\u2019t":[433,829,1288,1300,1313,1433,1514,2321,2350],"possibly":[434],"tweet;":[437],"would":[440,509,523,544,707,714,852,867,906,1030,1385,1429,1774,1969,3102],"longer":[442,1723],"than":[443,485,2686,2819],"tweet":[445,702],"itself!":[446],"The":[447,673,683,815,1431,1476,1499,1563,1861,1874,1933,2026,2113,2138,2159,2263,2667,2875,3098],"injunction":[448,929],"against":[449,930],"citing":[450,722,833,932],"DOI-less":[451,668,1666],"documents":[452,2883],"unfortunate,":[454],"people":[456,543,625,655,1015,3041,3081],"deserve":[457],"credit":[460],"interesting":[463,480],"things":[464,481,851],"they":[465,471,561,2513,2802],"say\u2013and":[466],"out":[469,621,989,1144,1647,1878,3113],"have,":[472],"on":[473,841,941,1170,1191,1324,1464,1498,1648,1898,2025,2217,2920,2937,2980,3004,3016,3179],"rare":[474],"occasion,":[475],"known":[477],"formats":[483],"other":[484,542,1129,1282,1417,2685,2718,2921],"traditional":[487,582,2562,2687,2823],"peer-reviewed":[488,584,2172],"I\u2019m":[491,1788,1814,2316,2345,2862],"pretty":[492],"Mark":[495,514,521,570,634],"Twain":[496,515,522,571],"were":[497],"alive":[498],"today,":[499],"he\u2019d":[500,529],"write":[501,531,1802,2078,2813,2822,2865],"best":[503,2309],"tweets":[504],"EVER.":[505],"maybe":[507],"tie":[512],"between":[513],"NIH":[518],"Bear.":[519],"But":[520,641,1077,1533,1823,1975,3059],"definitely":[524],"up":[526,753,1127,1631,2730],"there.":[527,1453],"insightful":[533],"too.":[536],"imagines":[540],"brilliant":[550],"21st-century":[551,569,615,633],"man":[552],"letters":[554],"named":[555],"@MarkTwain":[556,616],"their":[558,1771,1899,2388,2510,2797],"work.":[559,1974],"Only":[560],"wouldn\u2019t":[562],"allowed":[564,690,857,1014,1982],"to,":[565],"see,":[567],"doesn\u2019t":[572,1450],"publish":[573,2167,2796],"all,":[574,1483],"even":[576,609,1245,1932,2732,2888,3037],"most,":[577],"his":[579,591,619,2640],"pre-publication":[583,2566],"journals.":[585,1772],"He\u2019s":[586],"too":[587,2934],"impatient":[588],"rinse-and-repeat":[590],"way":[592,2109,2127,2645],"through":[593,2775],"revise-and-resubmit":[595],"process":[596,2118],"every":[597,939,992,1023,1128,1799,2329],"time":[598,720,993,1460,2254,2555,2897],"he":[599],"wants":[600,618],"share":[602],"new":[604,1109,2544,2906,3114,3148],"idea":[605,877,1403,1753,2997],"those":[611,712,1027,1353,2489,2533,2866],"ideas":[612],"valuable.":[614],"there":[622,646,706,967,1338,2123,2284,2786,2999,3187],"already":[623,2633],"see":[627],"it.":[628,1186],"Why":[629],"does":[630,2423],"hate":[632],"Twain,":[635],"ask?":[637],"I":[638,644,915,922,952,965,1252,1513,1534,1544,1565,1592,1747,1750,1773,1778,1824,1976,2178,2180,2366,2390,2443,2445,2474,2808,2811,2820,2830,2901,3060,3066,3101],"know.":[640,1749],"general,":[643],"think":[645,846,953,966,1159,1826,1978,2740,3061,3068],"two":[648,1344,2736,2972,3135],"main":[649],"reasons":[650],"disdain":[653],"seem":[656,2953],"thought":[661],"allowing":[663,2500],"authors":[664,832,858],"freely":[666],"objects":[669,713,2490,2508],"papers.":[672,2825],"first":[674,1189,1615,1851,2303],"reason":[675,817,1363,1842],"has":[676,818,1722,1734],"do":[678,820,1825,2945],"permanence\u2014or":[680],"lack":[681],"thereof.":[682],"concern":[684],"here":[685,1939,1964],"we":[689,828,856,1012,1088],"everyone":[691],"any":[695,834,1119,1281,1416,1574,1583,2343,2504,2717],"old":[696,835,3220,3266],"web":[697],"page,":[698],"post,":[700,1283],"no":[709,1362,1752,2126,2182,2856,3157],"guarantee":[710],"still":[715,1256,1977],"around":[717,2396,3216],"published,":[725],"let":[726,1759,1791],"alone":[727],"several":[728,1993],"years":[729],"hence.":[730],"Which":[731,1172,1262,1327,2826],"means":[732,784,1263,1871,2827],"readers":[734],"might":[735,2886,2902,3020,3036],"faced":[737],"bunch":[740,918,1156],"dead":[742,745],"links.":[743],"links":[746,1029],"not":[748,1257,1413,1966,1997,2004,2012,2094,2317,2368,2412,2416,2543,2887,3070],"good":[750,1070,2134,2743],"backing":[752],"arguments.":[755],"principle,":[757],"requirement":[760],"supposed":[762],"act":[764,910],"kind":[767,1418,1810,2719],"safety":[769,1928],"word":[770],"protects":[772],"ravages":[777],"time\u2014presumably":[779],"having":[781,1845,2192,2239],"watchful":[793],"eye":[794],"Sauron":[796],"periodically":[799],"scan":[800],"across":[801],"verify":[804],"hasn\u2019t":[807],"yet":[808],"fallen":[809],"off":[810,2979],"internet\u2019s":[813],"cliffside.":[814],"second":[816],"quality.":[822],"Here,":[823],"worry":[825,1004,1073],"opinion":[836],"someone":[837],"else":[838],"somewhere":[840,1374],"web,":[843],"because,":[844],"well,":[845,1961],"children!":[849],"Terrible":[850],"surely":[853],"happen":[854],"link":[860,2021],"unverified":[862],"unreviewed":[864],"works.":[865],"What":[866,2654,2940,3079],"stop":[868],"me":[869,1174],"from,":[870],"criticizing":[875],"human":[879],"activity":[880,1048],"contributing":[882,2927],"climate":[884],"change,":[885],"supporting":[887],"my":[888,1192,1290,1465,1576,1587,1730,1930,2089,2413,2839,2929],"argument":[889],"\u201ccitations\u201d":[891],"random":[893],"pages":[894,920],"I\u2019ve":[895,2338],"found":[896],"via":[897,1917,2643],"creative":[898],"Google":[899,2840,2938],"searches?":[900],"matter,":[903],"safeguard":[905],"prevent":[907],"brazen":[909],"sockpuppetry":[912],"myself":[923],"(anonymously)":[925],"written?":[926],"Loosening":[927],"formally":[931,1435],"non-peer-reviewed":[933],"tantamount":[936],"inviting":[938],"troll":[940],"dinner.":[948],"To":[949,2783],"fair,":[951],"there\u2019s":[954,1214,1361,2741,2767],"merit":[956,972],"both":[958,1829],"these":[960,974,1367,2913],"concerns.":[961,975],"Or":[962,1179,1280],"least,":[964,1199],"used":[968,2959],"Back":[976],"wee":[982],"nascent":[983],"flaky":[984],"thing":[985,1456],"winking":[986],"existence":[991,1123],"dial-up":[995],"modem":[996],"connection":[997],"went":[998],"down,":[999],"made":[1001,1069,1909],"sense":[1002,1071],"about":[1005,1074,1118,1160,1168,1292,1307],"permanence":[1006,1831,1858],"(I":[1007,2335],"mean,":[1008,2809],"think:":[1010],"GeoCities":[1018],"webpages":[1019],"last":[1024],"now":[1031,1084,1089,1607,1733,2696,3142],"dead!)":[1033],"similarly,":[1035],"back":[1036,2646,2895],"days":[1039],"peer":[1041,2194,2408,2528,2780,3077,3090,3177],"review":[1042,1116,2040,2195,2529,2567,2607,2781,3091,3121,3133,3178],"elite":[1045],"sort":[1046,2132,2292],"could":[1050,1201,2516],"practiced":[1053],"dignified":[1055],"gentlepersons":[1056],"cordial":[1059],"behest":[1060],"right":[1063,3099],"honorable":[1064],"editor,":[1066],"quality":[1075,1833,1959,2111,2204],"control.":[1076,2112],"merits":[1079],"such":[1081,1394,2507,2692,2724,3184],"concerns":[1082],"largely":[1085],"disappeared,":[1086],"live":[1090,3143],"marvelous":[1095],"technology,":[1096],"bits":[1098],"information":[1100,1348,1949],"cost":[1101,2860],"nothing":[1103,1141,2769],"preserve":[1105],"forever,":[1106],"post-publication":[1110,2606],"platform":[1111,1489],"allows":[1113],"anyone":[1114],"pop":[1126],"week":[1130],"(cf.":[1131],"PubPeer,":[1132],"PubMed":[1133],"Commons,":[1134],"Publons,":[1135],"etc.).":[1136],"modern":[1139],"ever":[1142,1876,2339],"goes":[1143,1877],"print,":[1146],"whole":[1155,1841,3127],"experts":[1158,2975],"something,":[1161],"ask":[1166],"them":[1167],"Twitter.":[1171],"brings":[1173],"post.":[1178],"paper.":[1180,2051],"Whatever":[1181],"call":[1185,1970],"It":[1187,3035],"blog.":[1193],"it\u2013or":[1197],"point":[1206],"time\u2013at":[1208],"following":[1210],"URL:":[1211,1220],"http://www.talyarkoni.org/blog/2015/03/04/now-i-am-become-doi-destroyer-of-gates.":[1212],"Unfortunately,":[1213],"small":[1216],"problem":[1217,1859,2139],"contains":[1222],"nary":[1223],"sight.":[1227],"Really.":[1228],"None":[1229],"eleventy":[1232],"billion":[1233],"possible":[1234,2165,2294],"substrings":[1235],"look":[1238,2846],"anything":[1239,2105,2169],"DOI.":[1242,1605,1920],"scramble":[1246],"characters":[1248,1505,1521],"like;":[1251],"care.":[1254],"You\u2019re":[1255],"going":[1258,2774,2844,2863,2943],"one.":[1261],"most":[1265,2268,2436],"won\u2019t":[1267],"allow":[1268],"officially":[1271,1761],"writing.":[1279],"matter.":[1286],"statistical":[1293],"power":[1294],"magical":[1296],"sample":[1297],"sizes;":[1298,1311],"Joe":[1302],"Simmons\u2019":[1303],"Data":[1304],"Colada":[1305],"Mturk":[1308],"Sanjay":[1315],"Srivastava\u2019s":[1316],"discussion":[1317],"replication":[1319],"falsifiability;":[1321],"so":[1323,2410],"ad":[1325],"infinitum.":[1326],"shame,":[1330],"it\u2019s":[1332,1640,1996,2005,2093,2164,2411,2804,3230],"reasonably":[1334,2287],"safe":[1335],"bet":[1336],"citation-worthy":[1345],"nuggets":[1346,1368],"trapped":[1349],"(or":[1356],"millions":[1357],"others),":[1359],"believe":[1365,2337],"must":[1369],"readily-discoverable":[1372],"analogs":[1373],"\u201cformal\u201d":[1377],"literature.":[1379],"guidelines":[1384],"it,":[1387,1571,1579,1886,2073],"appropriate":[1389],"course":[1390],"action":[1392],"cases":[1395],"acknowledge":[1398],"source":[1400],"finding":[1405],"article,":[1411],"but":[1412,1484,1777],"grant":[1415],"credit.":[1421],"Now,":[1422,2949],"typically,":[1423,2152],"story":[1428,1449,2537],"end.":[1430],"URL":[1432],"article;":[1440],"end":[1441,1452],"story.":[1443],"BUT!":[1444],"quite":[1451],"strange":[1455],"happens!":[1457],"short":[1459],"after":[1461],"appears":[1463],"blog,":[1466],"also":[1469,1546,2036,2518],"appears\u2013in":[1470],"identical":[1472],"form\u2013on":[1473],"Winnower,":[1477,1500,2027,2668],"isn\u2019t":[1479,1526,2618,3226],"rather,":[1485],"respectable-looking":[1487],"alternative":[1488,3087],"evaluation.":[1494],"Even":[1495,2609],"more":[1496,1676,1891,2231,2451,2570],"strangely,":[1497],"mysterious-looking":[1502],"set":[1503,1519],"appear":[1506],"alongside":[1507],"text.":[1509],"technical":[1511,2708],"reasons,":[1512],"tell":[1515,1536,1547],"actually":[1522,1737,2206],"(because":[1524],"assigned":[1527],"piece":[1530,1764,1797,1896,1902,1937,2457],"published!).":[1532],"starts":[1540],"\u201c10.15200/winn\u201d.":[1542],"is:":[1551],"It\u2019s":[1552,1555],"DOI!":[1554],"bona":[1557],"fide":[1558],"free":[1559],"DOI,":[1560,1695],"courtesy":[1561],"Winnower.":[1564],"didn\u2019t":[1566],"pay":[1569],"barter":[1573],"services":[1577,2873],"sign":[1581,2978],"away":[1582,2559],"little":[1584,1889],"pieces":[1585],"soul":[1588],"it*.":[1591],"installed":[1594],"WordPress":[1596],"plugin,":[1597],"pressed":[1598],"few":[1600,3189],"buttons,":[1601],"and\u2026":[1602],"instant":[1604],"So":[1606,1921,2421],"is,":[1609],"proudly,":[1610],"world\u2019s":[1614],"N":[1616,1618],"(where":[1617],"smallish":[1621],"below":[1624],"1000)":[1625],"dress":[1629],"itself":[1630],"nice":[1634],"(Figure":[1636],"1).":[1637],"Presumably":[1638],"getting":[1641],"ready":[1642,2805],"wild":[1645],"night":[1646],"town.":[1651],"Figure":[1652],"1.":[1653],"Effects":[1654],"assigning":[1656,2481],"posts:":[1660],"anthropomorphic":[1662],"depiction.":[1663],"(A)":[1664],"feels":[1669,1700],"exposed":[1670],"inadequate;":[1672],"envies":[1674],"its":[1675],"reputable":[1677],"counterparts":[1678],"languishes":[1680],"state":[1683],"torpor":[1685],"existential":[1687],"disarray.":[1688],"(B)":[1689],"Freshly":[1690],"clothed":[1691],"newly-minted":[1694],"same":[1697,2649],"confident,":[1701],"charismatic,":[1702],"alert.":[1704],"Brimming":[1705],"energy,":[1707],"eagerly":[1709],"awaits":[1710],"opportunity":[1712],"move":[1714,2558,3023],"mountains":[1715],"reshape":[1717],"discourse.":[1719],"Also,":[1720],"arms.":[1724],"Does":[1725],"mere":[1727],"change":[1738],"anything,":[1739],"far":[1741],"rules":[1745],"go?":[1746],"publishers":[1755],"will":[1758,1903,2754,2787,3093,3237],"guess":[1775],"not,":[1776],"strongly":[1779],"encourage":[1780],"try":[1783,1793],"anyway":[1785],"fact,":[1787,2871],"willing":[1789,1815,2013],"next":[1805,2735,2898],"year":[1806,2851],"so\u2014that\u2019s":[1808],"big-hearted":[1812],"sacrifice":[1813],"name":[1820],"science).":[1822],"solves":[1828,1856],"control":[1834],"issues":[1835],"are,":[1837],"theory,":[1839],"no-DOI-no-shoes-no-service":[1847],"policy":[1848],"place.":[1852],"How?":[1853],"Winnower":[1862,1875,2876],"participant":[1865],"CLOCKSS":[1868],"archive,":[1869,2497],"business":[1880],"(a":[1881,2459],"prospect":[1882],"let\u2019s":[1884],"face":[1885],"became":[1887],"bit":[1890,2955],"likely":[1892,2232,2249],"moment":[1894],"appeared":[1897],"site),":[1900],"immediately,":[1905],"freely,":[1906],"automatically":[1908,2638],"available":[1910],"worldwide":[1913],"community":[1914,3124],"perpetuity":[1916],"need":[1924,2076],"trust":[1926,2322],"blog\u2014or":[1931],"Winnower\u2014any":[1934],"more.":[1935],"stay":[1941],"forever!":[1942],"Rejoice":[1943],"cheapness":[1946],"librarians\u2019":[1951],"obsession":[1952],"archiving":[1954],"everything!":[1955],"argument,":[1960,2389],"clearly,":[1962],"high-quality":[1972,2007],"wherever":[1986],"whenever":[1988],"want.":[1990],"Why?":[1991],"reasons.":[1994],"First,":[1995],"exactly":[1998,2065],"difficult":[1999],"determine":[2001],"whether":[2002],"work\u2014even":[2009],"exercise":[2015],"own":[2017],"judgment.":[2018],"When":[2019],"linking":[2031,2037],"paper;":[2034],"platform.":[2041],"reviews":[2044],"prominently":[2047],"dislike":[2054,2068],"piece,":[2056,2471],"use":[2059],"comment":[2061],"form":[2062],"indicate":[2064],"why":[2066],"(if":[2070],"comment;":[2080],"instead,":[2081],"send":[2082],"envelope":[2084],"stuffed":[2085],"money":[2087],"home":[2090],"address).":[2091],"Second,":[2092],"clear":[2097,2757],"banning":[2099],"non-prepublication-reviewed":[2102],"materials":[2103],"accomplishes":[2104],"useful":[2106],"reliability":[2114],"peer-review":[2117],"sufficiently":[2120],"low":[2121],"simply":[2125,2768],"consistently":[2131],"bad.":[2137],"compounded":[2141],"rejected":[2146],"manuscripts":[2147],"rarely":[2149],"discarded":[2150],"forever;":[2151],"quickly":[2154,2697],"resubmitted":[2155],"another":[2157,2539],"journal.":[2158],"bibliometric":[2160],"literature":[2161,2173],"shows":[2162],"given":[2174],"persistence.":[2176],"Third,":[2177],"suspect\u2014though":[2179],"data":[2183],"support":[2185,2386,3172],"claim\u2014that":[2187],"worldview":[2189],"treats":[2191],"passed":[2193],"and/or":[2196],"receiving":[2197],"markers":[2201],"counterproductive":[2207],"progress,":[2210],"promotes":[2213],"lackadaisical":[2215],"attitude":[2216],"part":[2219,2461,3028],"researchers.":[2221],"reader":[2223,2244],"who":[2224,2245],"believes":[2225],"claim":[2228],"significantly":[2230],"true":[2235],"virtue":[2237],"slightly":[2247],"less":[2248],"take":[2251],"extra":[2253,2857],"evaluate":[2257],"evidence":[2259,2357],"claim.":[2262,2453],"reality,":[2264],"unfortunately,":[2265],"claims":[2270],"wrong,":[2272],"complicated":[2277],"science":[2279,3055],"hard.":[2281],"Pretending":[2282],"accurate":[2288],"mechanism":[2289],"sources":[2295],"into":[2296,2747],"reliable":[2297],"unreliable":[2299],"buckets\u2014even":[2300],"order":[2304],"approximation\u2014is":[2306],"misleading":[2307],"dangerous":[2311],"worst.":[2313],"Of":[2314],"course,":[2315],"suggesting":[2318],"paper\u2019s":[2324],"conclusions":[2325],"unless":[2326],"read":[2328,2419,2430],"cites":[2332],"detail":[2334],"done":[2340],"paper!).":[2344],"saying":[2347],"abdicate":[2351],"responsibility":[2353],"shapeless,":[2360],"anonymous":[2361],"mass":[2362],"\u201creviewers\u201d.":[2364],"decide":[2367],"chase":[2370],"down":[2371],"Smith":[2373,2375,2403,2405],"&":[2374,2380,2404],"(2007)":[2376,2406],"Jones":[2379,2381],"(2008)":[2382],"critical":[2385],"shouldn\u2019t":[2391],"able":[2393],"turn":[2395],"later":[2397],"\u201chey,":[2402],"reviewed,":[2409],"fault":[2414],"bothering":[2417],"it!\u201d":[2420],"leave":[2425],"us?":[2426],"far,":[2432],"agree":[2434],"above":[2441],"arguments,":[2442],"hope":[2444],"convince":[2447],"tiny":[2452],"Namely,":[2454],"represents":[2458],"big":[2460],"of)":[2462],"future":[2464],"Not":[2468],"course;":[2473],"mean":[2475],"general":[2477],"practice":[2478],"(a)":[2480],"objects,":[2486],"(b)":[2487],"preserving":[2488],"posterity":[2493],"centralized":[2496,2526],"(c)":[2499],"researchers":[2501,2794],"however":[2512],"like.":[2514],"(We":[2515],"add":[2519],"(d)":[2520],"working":[2521,3084],"hard":[2523],"promote":[2525],"\u201cpost-publication\u201d":[2527],"objects\u2013but":[2534],"that\u2019s":[2535,3062],"day.)":[2540],"These":[2541,2576],"ideas,":[2545],"mind":[2546],"you.":[2547],"People":[2548],"calling":[2551],"gatekeeping-oriented":[2563],"model":[2564],"towards":[2569,3085],"open":[2571,3176],"evaluation":[2574,3115,3198],"models.":[2575,2608],"calls":[2577],"intensified":[2579],"recent":[2581],"years;":[2582],"instance,":[2584],"2012,":[2586],"special":[2588],"topic":[2589],"Frontiers":[2591],"Computational":[2593],"Neuroscience":[2594],"featured":[2595],"18":[2596],"different":[2597],"papers":[2598],"independently":[2601],"advocated":[2602],"actual":[2611],"attachment":[2612],"new;":[2619],"case":[2622],"point,":[2624],"consider":[2625],"C.":[2627],"Titus":[2628],"Brown\u2014in":[2629],"typical":[2630],"pioneering":[2631],"form\u2014was":[2632],"experimenting":[2634],"ways":[2636,3235],"DOIfy":[2639],"FigShare":[2644,2878],"dark":[2650],"ages":[2651],"2012.":[2653],"new,":[2656],"though,":[2657],"emergence":[2660],"widespread":[2662],"adoption":[2663],"FigShare,":[2669],"Research":[2671],"Gate":[2672],"increasingly":[2676,2756],"easy":[2677],"assign":[2679,2880],"academically-relevant":[2683],"works":[2684],"articles.":[2689],"Thanks":[2690],"services,":[2693],"effortlessly":[2699],"attach":[2700],"open-source":[2705],"software":[2706],"packages,":[2707],"manuals":[2709],"white":[2711],"papers,":[2712],"conference":[2713],"posters,":[2714],"document.":[2722],"Once":[2723],"efforts":[2725],"really":[2726],"start":[2727],"pick":[2729],"steam\u2014perhaps":[2731],"years\u2014I":[2739],"chance":[2744],"we\u2019ll":[2745],"fall":[2746],"positive":[2749],"feedback":[2750],"loop,":[2751],"become":[2755],"kinds":[2761,2790],"findings":[2764],"observations,":[2766],"gained":[2772],"cumbersome,":[2777],"time-consuming":[2778],"conventional":[2779]},"counts_by_year":[{"year":2015,"cited_by_count":1}],"updated_date":"2026-10-28T10:33:24.094632","created_date":"2016-06-24T00:00:00"}