{"id":"https://openalex.org/W2140197593","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6245.2009.01349.x","title":"The Harmony of the Faculties in Recent Books on the Critique of the Power of Judgment","display_name":"The Harmony of the Faculties in Recent Books on the Critique of the Power of Judgment","alternate_titles":[],"publication_year":2009,"publication_date":"2009-05-01","ids":{"openalex":"https://openalex.org/W2140197593","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6245.2009.01349.x","mag":"2140197593"},"language":"en","primary_location":{"id":"doi:10.1111/j.1540-6245.2009.01349.x","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6245.2009.01349.x","is_oa":false,"landing_page_url":"https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6245.2009.01349.x","pdf_url":null,"source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S26308392","display_name":"Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism","issn_l":"0021-8529","issn":["0021-8529","1540-6245"],"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":true,"listed_in":["anvur-class-a","anvur-scientific","cwts-core","erih-plus","jufo-3","norway-2","poland-140","russia-white-list-1","vabb-shw"],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/P4310311648","host_organization_name":"Oxford University Press","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/P4310311648","https://openalex.org/P4310311647"],"host_organization_lineage_names":["Oxford University Press","University of Oxford"],"type":"journal"},"license":null,"license_id":null,"version":"publishedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":true,"raw_source_name":"The Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism","raw_type":"journal-article"},"parent_works":[],"lineage":["https://openalex.org/W2140197593"],"child_works_count":0,"type":"book-review","is_traditional":true,"indexed_in":["crossref"],"open_access":{"is_oa":false,"oa_status":"closed","oa_url":null,"any_repository_has_fulltext":false},"authorships":[{"author_position":"first","author":{"id":"https://openalex.org/A5091129857","display_name":"Paul D. Guyer","orcid":"https://orcid.org/0000-0001-7195-6710","observed_orcids":["https://orcid.org/0000-0001-7195-6710"]},"institutions":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/I79576946","display_name":"University of Pennsylvania","ror":"https://ror.org/00b30xv10","country_code":"US","type":"education","lineage":["https://openalex.org/I79576946"]}],"countries":["US"],"is_corresponding":true,"contributor_roles":[],"raw_author_name":"PAUL GUYER","raw_affiliation_strings":["Aff1 Department of Philosophy University of Pennsylvania Philadelphia Pennsylvania 19104","Department of Philosophy\u2028University of Pennsylvania\u2028Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19104\u2028:"],"raw_orcid":null,"affiliations":[{"raw_affiliation_string":"Aff1 Department of Philosophy University of Pennsylvania Philadelphia Pennsylvania 19104","institution_ids":["https://openalex.org/I79576946"]},{"raw_affiliation_string":"Department of Philosophy\u2028University of Pennsylvania\u2028Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19104\u2028:","institution_ids":["https://openalex.org/I79576946"]}]}],"institutions":[],"countries_distinct_count":1,"institutions_distinct_count":1,"corresponding_author_ids":["https://openalex.org/A5091129857"],"corresponding_institution_ids":["https://openalex.org/I79576946"],"apc_list":{"value":3492,"currency":"USD","value_usd":3492},"apc_paid":null,"fwci":null,"has_fulltext":false,"cited_by_count":67,"citation_normalized_percentile":null,"cited_by_percentile_year":null,"biblio":{"volume":"67","issue":"2","first_page":"201","last_page":"221"},"is_retracted":false,"is_pulled":false,"is_paratext":false,"is_xpac":false,"primary_topic":{"id":"https://openalex.org/T13712","display_name":"Kantian Philosophy and Modern Interpretations","score":0.9970999956130981,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1211","display_name":"Philosophy"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/12","display_name":"Arts and Humanities"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},"topics":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/T13712","display_name":"Kantian Philosophy and Modern Interpretations","score":0.9970999956130981,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1211","display_name":"Philosophy"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/12","display_name":"Arts and Humanities"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},{"id":"https://openalex.org/T14092","display_name":"Ethics, Aesthetics, and Art","score":0.0007999999797903001,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1211","display_name":"Philosophy"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/12","display_name":"Arts and Humanities"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},{"id":"https://openalex.org/T12397","display_name":"Critical Theory and Philosophy","score":0.0003000000142492354,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/3312","display_name":"Sociology and Political Science"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/33","display_name":"Social Sciences"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}}],"keywords":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/immanuel-kant","display_name":"Immanuel Kant","score":0.6349999904632568},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/critique-of-judgment","display_name":"Critique of Judgment","score":0.9679999947547913},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/aesthetic-theory","display_name":"aesthetic theory","score":0.7049999833106995},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/imagination-and-understanding","display_name":"imagination and understanding","score":0.8180000185966492},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/teleology","display_name":"teleology","score":0.7670000195503235},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/teleological-judgment","display_name":"teleological judgment","score":0.33899998664855957},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/kant-interpretation","display_name":"interpretation of Kant","score":0.4339999854564667}],"concepts":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/C2776453491","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q5659234","display_name":"Harmony (color)","level":2,"score":0.8771067261695862},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C107038049","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q35986","display_name":"Aesthetics","level":1,"score":0.5646077394485474},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C163258240","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q25342","display_name":"Power (physics)","level":2,"score":0.5081737041473389},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C111472728","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q9471","display_name":"Epistemology","level":1,"score":0.4570262134075165},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C138885662","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q5891","display_name":"Philosophy","level":0,"score":0.39802730083465576},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C15744967","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q9418","display_name":"Psychology","level":0,"score":0.34141993522644043},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C142362112","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q735","display_name":"Art","level":0,"score":0.2868802845478058},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C153349607","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q36649","display_name":"Visual arts","level":1,"score":0.12229439616203308},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C121332964","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q413","display_name":"Physics","level":0,"score":0.026273667812347412},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C62520636","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q944","display_name":"Quantum mechanics","level":1,"score":0.0}],"mesh":[],"locations_count":2,"locations":[{"id":"doi:10.1111/j.1540-6245.2009.01349.x","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6245.2009.01349.x","is_oa":false,"landing_page_url":"https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6245.2009.01349.x","pdf_url":null,"source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S26308392","display_name":"Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism","issn_l":"0021-8529","issn":["0021-8529","1540-6245"],"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":true,"listed_in":["anvur-class-a","anvur-scientific","cwts-core","erih-plus","jufo-3","norway-2","poland-140","russia-white-list-1","vabb-shw"],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/P4310311648","host_organization_name":"Oxford University Press","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/P4310311648","https://openalex.org/P4310311647"],"host_organization_lineage_names":["Oxford University Press","University of Oxford"],"type":"journal"},"license":null,"license_id":null,"version":"publishedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":true,"raw_source_name":"The Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism","raw_type":"journal-article"},{"id":"pmh:oai:philpapers.org/rec/ZUCKOB-5","doi":null,"is_oa":false,"landing_page_url":"https://philpapers.org/rec/ZUCKOB-5","pdf_url":null,"source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S4306402130","display_name":"PhilPapers (PhilPapers Foundation)","issn_l":null,"issn":null,"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":false,"listed_in":[],"host_organization":null,"host_organization_name":null,"host_organization_lineage":[],"host_organization_lineage_names":[],"type":"repository"},"license":null,"license_id":null,"version":"submittedVersion","is_accepted":false,"is_published":false,"raw_source_name":"","raw_type":"info:eu-repo/semantics/article"}],"best_oa_location":null,"sustainable_development_goals":[],"study_designs":[],"awards":[],"funders":[],"has_content":{"grobid_xml":false,"pdf":false},"content_urls":null,"referenced_works_count":6,"referenced_works":["https://openalex.org/W621505875","https://openalex.org/W630973842","https://openalex.org/W641887896","https://openalex.org/W2026380756","https://openalex.org/W2334646066","https://openalex.org/W2483443178"],"related_works":["https://openalex.org/W633815793","https://openalex.org/W4254223005","https://openalex.org/W4233776467","https://openalex.org/W369214051","https://openalex.org/W7100741528","https://openalex.org/W2501458206","https://openalex.org/W2330155982","https://openalex.org/W4210924160","https://openalex.org/W6973916879","https://openalex.org/W4231690748"],"abstract_inverted_index":{"When":[0],"I":[1,13,51,64,83,110,196,253,274,684,705,1007,1036,1207,2135,2862,2983,3005,3011,3345,3358,3533,3653,3686,3731,3998,4786,4932,5142,5331,5623,5775,5901,6055,6192,6227,6234,6254,6262,6287,6337,6379,6627,6656,6672,6868,6899,6929,6993,7038,7093,7120,7183,7196,7567,7580,7734,8085,8351,8465,8922,9055,9210,9853,9993,10001,10511],"began":[2],"working":[3],"on":[4,7,24,95,113,133,138,160,182,221,234,458,531,550,595,617,711,746,842,929,1082,1089,1105,1168,1175,1189,1369,1406,1742,1846,2057,2485,2957,2970,2993,3067,3092,3334,3446,3487,3670,3708,4581,4591,5256,5999,6507,6559,6683,6688,6816,6836,6855,7188,7381,7690,7882,7983,7988,7996,8014,8214,8338,8884,8950,9064,9106,9473,9479,9559,9800,10687],"my":[5,67,183,222,1042,3000,3017,3093,3121,3335,3447,3488,3895,5187,6560,6684,6705,6920,6940,6952,7139,7684],"dissertation":[6,94],"Kant's":[8,114,134,161,320,338,361,379,412,445,513,526,559,581,682,701,747,781,840,1048,1062,1075,1090,1111,1159,1374,1722,1941,2068,2142,2261,2489,2560,3020,3070,3364,3460,3536,4147,4162,4525,5191,5491,5625,5678,5777,5907,6201,6245,6265,6541,6881,7005,7084,7202,7236,7470,7604,7706,7748,7782,7860,7905,7928,8065,8142,8481,8746,8934,9217,9587,9632,9779,10424,10457,10532,10578,10656],"aesthetic":[9,349,514,529,560,702,784,955,1025,1173,1222,1341,1688,1702,2151,2206,2264,2302,2324,2414,2468,2564,2798,2826,2876,2955,2991,3038,3073,3082,3096,3170,3183,3381,3401,3675,3682,4163,4175,4311,4523,4584,4600,4623,4637,4712,4720,4736,4743,4802,4806,4828,4988,5052,5171,5194,5356,5430,5481,5920,6190,6217,6246,6446,6483,6546,6578,6594,6612,6969,6973,7047,7087,7608,7620,7707,7794,7863,7894,7916,7951,7965,8035,8446,8494,8664,8691,8777,8829,8861,9069,9111,9134,9221,9287,9424,9451,9507,9525,9742,9761,9816,9827,9844,9977,10169,10212,10271,10306,10325,10339,10595,10636,10645],"theory":[10,350,515,527,538,546,561,586,703,1092,1375,2992,3537,4422,7708,8696,9222,9229,9773,10334,10458,10540],"in":[11,29,177,192,203,255,271,289,291,316,351,360,394,497,624,848,861,876,957,966,1119,1219,1292,1312,1336,1340,1393,1413,1444,1534,1548,1555,1564,1567,1579,1591,1637,1647,1684,1761,1769,1774,1782,1849,1857,1939,2006,2038,2097,2123,2153,2247,2298,2310,2342,2357,2383,2429,2438,2453,2498,2509,2553,2625,2627,2637,2669,2710,2807,2841,2878,2884,2990,3052,3108,3150,3162,3191,3224,3287,3372,3396,3478,3603,3620,3918,4039,4080,4106,4199,4265,4302,4310,4326,4384,4406,4420,4494,4504,4583,4644,4665,4733,4741,4781,4809,4849,4864,4921,4957,4979,5020,5022,5025,5103,5202,5205,5213,5219,5226,5245,5368,5410,5490,5502,5507,5531,5547,5564,5578,5726,5759,5802,5822,5841,5878,6119,6153,6206,6244,6279,6291,6315,6353,6392,6485,6649,6694,6848,6922,6942,7026,7069,7075,7102,7205,7271,7290,7326,7343,7360,7550,7564,7627,7629,7644,7658,7662,7729,7754,7823,7826,7930,7998,8034,8049,8075,8141,8164,8371,8411,8417,8456,8493,8502,8516,8555,8558,8613,8648,8699,8797,8909,8914,8955,8963,9140,9220,9227,9286,9304,9310,9330,9351,9364,9614,9670,9673,9682,9752,9807,9829,9868,10020,10026,10097,10111,10183,10232,10254,10341,10350,10534,10549,10577,10594,10630,10644,10673,10684],"1971,":[12],"was":[14,76,227,723,2075,6796],"able":[15,8807],"to":[16,36,53,69,81,91,156,175,232,250,283,298,302,397,474,482,485,500,574,577,584,600,648,661,668,676,693,758,807,838,937,959,1044,1053,1057,1074,1123,1134,1164,1228,1305,1346,1355,1384,1477,1505,1516,1531,1544,1587,1624,1667,1672,1813,1880,1890,1913,1976,1992,2011,2044,2050,2103,2131,2182,2201,2204,2233,2255,2257,2312,2378,2459,2502,2529,2559,2588,2602,2607,2619,2657,2691,2697,2746,2766,2803,2831,2899,2912,2930,2978,2987,2999,3045,3047,3078,3088,3102,3110,3116,3124,3142,3168,3175,3186,3295,3305,3332,3347,3355,3390,3405,3442,3458,3467,3477,3482,3500,3522,3526,3545,3576,3611,3614,3622,3641,3712,3726,3763,3855,3880,3892,3952,4028,4033,4042,4047,4056,4074,4094,4114,4123,4142,4181,4215,4224,4239,4261,4283,4328,4340,4354,4359,4376,4434,4453,4478,4509,4551,4646,4674,4695,4723,4754,4833,4843,4886,4949,4976,4995,5013,5097,5148,5176,5247,5269,5276,5339,5346,5363,5377,5406,5422,5666,5681,5699,5739,5770,5780,5797,5807,5818,5833,5839,5894,5905,5910,5917,5930,5945,6002,6021,6038,6067,6133,6141,6160,6200,6221,6229,6252,6276,6298,6387,6396,6453,6469,6479,6514,6608,6619,6660,6717,6725,6814,6843,6852,6878,6893,6947,6956,6966,6997,7017,7033,7072,7109,7115,7124,7145,7157,7177,7179,7190,7234,7245,7283,7299,7314,7338,7348,7358,7369,7458,7501,7508,7518,7526,7547,7554,7557,7573,7593,7665,7759,7790,7841,7846,7869,7885,7935,7962,8020,8105,8135,8166,8210,8236,8297,8335,8390,8394,8413,8470,8522,8564,8655,8693,8706,8715,8801,8808,8842,8869,8906,8912,8958,8960,9008,9038,9073,9116,9123,9138,9157,9173,9236,9258,9268,9370,9427,9471,9527,9543,9551,9555,9639,9648,9736,9744,9757,9783,9822,9873,9922,9974,9982,10004,10006,10023,10088,10145,10152,10328,10413,10452,10456,10507,10588,10610,10670],"read":[17,54,251],"virtually":[18],"all":[19,78,287,963,2036,2430,2476,3804,3989,4908,5980,6186,8054,8203,8649,8669,8676,9184,9331,9352,10477],"of":[20,27,43,49,55,126,319,347,355,382,386,390,400,403,427,432,444,447,452,454,461,465,477,491,512,521,528,539,547,557,565,580,587,589,592,604,609,615,621,641,655,681,717,720,733,749,752,762,766,774,779,783,789,811,819,844,850,853,865,870,882,885,893,916,919,944,948,968,976,992,997,1004,1041,1047,1061,1071,1093,1096,1101,1110,1127,1131,1136,1161,1202,1233,1236,1249,1253,1257,1267,1277,1284,1287,1296,1309,1315,1327,1333,1376,1422,1426,1448,1462,1465,1486,1526,1551,1553,1557,1562,1596,1608,1611,1627,1630,1633,1650,1661,1687,1696,1700,1707,1716,1737,1745,1757,1772,1794,1798,1802,1807,1816,1820,1833,1854,1861,1864,1869,1878,1884,1894,1901,1904,1908,1911,1916,1921,1930,1936,1948,1966,1970,1978,1999,2013,2016,2025,2031,2035,2061,2067,2079,2094,2117,2155,2158,2169,2207,2218,2250,2263,2270,2276,2301,2338,2351,2360,2386,2392,2419,2422,2447,2467,2477,2480,2491,2494,2496,2507,2513,2515,2540,2563,2575,2578,2581,2586,2631,2646,2653,2667,2680,2742,2749,2819,2822,2824,2909,2917,2933,2937,2950,2953,2967,3008,3019,3022,3037,3072,3106,3128,3159,3222,3230,3241,3263,3278,3298,3316,3325,3343,3363,3367,3380,3400,3408,3423,3441,3452,3462,3480,3496,3506,3524,3549,3563,3588,3600,3606,3631,3649,3662,3673,3681,3697,3703,3743,3790,3834,3844,3883,3910,3930,3977,3994,4012,4024,4052,4083,4139,4146,4149,4153,4161,4170,4178,4189,4201,4211,4220,4234,4243,4256,4270,4285,4317,4349,4372,4382,4391,4404,4409,4412,4415,4423,4446,4465,4471,4490,4497,4527,4531,4538,4543,4548,4569,4572,4595,4613,4622,4628,4636,4653,4661,4670,4680,4701,4709,4711,4719,4726,4759,4767,4771,4790,4816,4824,4852,4861,4870,4878,4899,4940,4986,4999,5048,5058,5061,5065,5072,5080,5086,5088,5091,5100,5108,5118,5125,5167,5170,5182,5190,5193,5223,5237,5242,5251,5254,5289,5294,5304,5312,5316,5323,5355,5358,5366,5373,5381,5413,5417,5447,5456,5459,5468,5471,5475,5478,5494,5499,5524,5559,5567,5571,5582,5586,5589,5595,5609,5649,5728,5761,5835,5844,5866,5898,5934,5957,5977,5994,6011,6026,6048,6087,6091,6204,6208,6213,6216,6224,6232,6250,6267,6270,6284,6302,6308,6334,6346,6351,6376,6399,6421,6429,6448,6465,6472,6482,6504,6531,6566,6581,6584,6611,6622,6635,6642,6678,6691,6710,6752,6775,6809,6823,6830,6951,6961,6976,7010,7013,7021,7024,7086,7098,7105,7131,7138,7201,7208,7223,7226,7239,7241,7269,7275,7286,7304,7352,7403,7405,7409,7437,7447,7461,7475,7478,7495,7497,7541,7587,7589,7600,7603,7607,7619,7622,7642,7651,7655,7673,7678,7683,7705,7718,7723,7726,7732,7743,7763,7766,7771,7800,7804,7813,7817,7829,7836,7862,7872,7875,7888,7890,7902,7921,7924,7932,7938,7941,7946,7950,7970,7973,7981,7994,8011,8025,8029,8041,8044,8047,8053,8056,8067,8070,8073,8081,8100,8117,8123,8127,8139,8144,8184,8205,8208,8249,8259,8279,8301,8305,8311,8323,8341,8345,8357,8363,8450,8483,8486,8489,8509,8513,8526,8529,8546,8550,8570,8577,8592,8603,8616,8634,8663,8690,8697,8719,8723,8745,8759,8782,8791,8813,8817,8824,8834,8855,8860,8880,8898,8927,8939,8943,8947,8983,8986,8996,9015,9019,9047,9051,9067,9077,9080,9093,9098,9101,9109,9120,9132,9142,9162,9198,9215,9230,9244,9283,9293,9302,9324,9344,9359,9379,9384,9409,9415,9435,9450,9456,9464,9483,9490,9610,9618,9621,9631,9659,9664,9668,9685,9717,9748,9760,9774,9805,9826,9850,9870,9883,9895,9909,9913,9926,9931,9941,9944,9988,10009,10035,10042,10045,10061,10064,10079,10093,10107,10116,10120,10124,10130,10137,10140,10148,10157,10174,10186,10195,10206,10211,10217,10235,10243,10246,10252,10257,10295,10309,10319,10335,10338,10387,10399,10402,10407,10459,10464,10473,10480,10488,10497,10541,10545,10557,10601,10641,10651,10658,10665,10678],"the":[21,25,85,96,164,204,235,246,258,284,308,345,352,356,367,369,383,387,416,424,430,437,440,448,459,462,466,475,486,498,501,505,510,519,522,532,536,551,555,563,566,578,585,590,596,601,605,607,613,618,622,625,632,642,652,656,671,679,718,728,734,750,759,763,772,801,817,851,866,877,883,891,914,926,930,942,977,990,1001,1039,1059,1069,1094,1120,1156,1169,1176,1198,1203,1217,1234,1247,1250,1275,1281,1310,1313,1330,1370,1407,1423,1429,1459,1463,1524,1541,1549,1558,1577,1603,1606,1609,1625,1631,1648,1679,1685,1694,1701,1705,1735,1743,1746,1755,1775,1795,1805,1808,1821,1834,1852,1858,1862,1867,1875,1881,1891,1898,1906,1914,1927,1934,1945,1967,1995,2014,2021,2029,2032,2058,2071,2091,2120,2138,2166,2272,2281,2290,2299,2305,2314,2332,2335,2343,2348,2372,2389,2393,2396,2405,2417,2420,2445,2448,2465,2478,2486,2492,2499,2503,2510,2516,2538,2551,2571,2576,2596,2603,2608,2611,2620,2628,2647,2670,2677,2740,2743,2820,2825,2834,2881,2906,2918,2922,2931,2934,2948,2951,2958,2962,2971,2975,3035,3079,3089,3117,3140,3193,3200,3231,3245,3248,3261,3264,3270,3288,3306,3312,3322,3397,3406,3420,3443,3449,3468,3483,3504,3527,3601,3628,3632,3635,3660,3671,3694,3727,3748,3780,3787,3805,3813,3881,3890,3974,3991,4009,4022,4049,4053,4058,4060,4081,4089,4107,4124,4150,4154,4158,4187,4212,4218,4237,4241,4257,4271,4347,4360,4392,4410,4426,4438,4444,4463,4468,4472,4495,4506,4510,4513,4528,4532,4561,4570,4573,4596,4611,4614,4618,4626,4629,4633,4642,4651,4654,4659,4667,4675,4681,4702,4705,4755,4772,4782,4801,4805,4814,4822,4827,4834,4850,4854,4875,4887,4896,4916,4930,4938,4950,4964,4984,4987,5015,5046,5056,5063,5074,5077,5081,5101,5104,5116,5121,5126,5150,5154,5168,5224,5227,5234,5238,5243,5249,5286,5321,5353,5364,5371,5383,5396,5407,5411,5440,5443,5457,5469,5500,5522,5525,5548,5553,5560,5565,5568,5572,5584,5587,5590,5593,5596,5607,5610,5642,5670,5724,5757,5803,5823,5842,5855,5864,5867,5875,5879,5896,5931,5941,5955,5992,6045,6088,6110,6259,6268,6294,6306,6310,6325,6332,6335,6354,6363,6394,6397,6403,6418,6445,6449,6460,6470,6480,6516,6532,6562,6582,6593,6620,6631,6636,6640,6689,6708,6711,6721,6726,6773,6807,6810,6817,6821,6827,6834,6856,6875,6890,6948,6968,6972,7008,7018,7022,7034,7070,7080,7096,7107,7170,7180,7186,7199,7206,7217,7220,7224,7229,7232,7254,7284,7287,7302,7321,7349,7382,7391,7401,7435,7438,7459,7472,7476,7532,7536,7542,7575,7584,7601,7612,7617,7625,7645,7649,7652,7659,7663,7703,7724,7727,7730,7741,7744,7764,7767,7797,7801,7810,7814,7827,7844,7870,7873,7886,7913,7919,7933,7936,7939,7947,7957,7968,7978,7984,7989,7992,8012,8015,8023,8026,8030,8042,8045,8068,8071,8076,8082,8115,8137,8174,8206,8211,8218,8228,8239,8245,8256,8264,8271,8298,8302,8308,8321,8376,8382,8385,8399,8451,8454,8484,8487,8504,8510,8514,8517,8527,8543,8547,8559,8578,8593,8631,8635,8643,8657,8695,8700,8710,8717,8720,8760,8766,8783,8788,8811,8814,8818,8828,8843,8857,8877,8881,8896,8899,8915,8945,8948,8951,8966,8984,8997,9016,9020,9048,9052,9059,9065,9078,9091,9099,9107,9118,9127,9189,9196,9207,9213,9228,9238,9241,9253,9259,9274,9280,9284,9300,9322,9357,9376,9395,9401,9421,9480,9488,9491,9505,9511,9518,9557,9601,9611,9615,9619,9629,9641,9665,9671,9674,9683,9686,9715,9718,9746,9758,9768,9801,9808,9823,9864,9871,9874,9879,9887,9890,9907,9924,9933,9942,9967,10007,10021,10039,10043,10058,10062,10065,10069,10073,10076,10091,10105,10127,10131,10135,10138,10184,10190,10193,10196,10209,10215,10233,10236,10240,10244,10249,10298,10304,10336,10342,10403,10437,10450,10478,10481,10484,10525,10529,10535,10542,10546,10550,10558,10566,10569,10590,10649,10666,10675,10679],"extant":[22],"literature":[23],"Critique":[26,98,166,237,358,568,591,608,658,673,719,748,1777,3833,5549,7746,7828,7874,7937,8712,8883,9620,9810,10537],"Judgment":[28,753],"English,":[30,178],"German,":[31,179],"and":[32,58,109,118,143,158,180,185,194,200,208,210,280,293,322,341,359,392,398,420,429,435,439,535,553,562,599,612,690,713,725,777,786,822,888,921,946,954,995,1016,1099,1103,1172,1184,1223,1294,1339,1366,1395,1398,1499,1522,1528,1560,1664,1683,1709,1727,1753,1786,1823,1987,2004,2144,2186,2241,2266,2518,2547,2610,2639,2845,2860,2961,2965,3057,3081,3284,3300,3340,3383,3425,3437,3617,3639,3764,3792,3799,3846,3877,3885,3912,3915,3970,3980,4098,4305,4321,4352,4487,4555,4601,4625,4678,4804,4891,4913,4968,5001,5024,5083,5119,5196,5264,5370,5592,5616,5646,5765,5820,5967,5996,6081,6240,6323,6365,6574,6614,6647,6719,6749,6820,6833,6927,6971,6989,7059,7066,7151,7310,7356,7422,7453,7482,7486,7530,7610,7621,7648,7692,7697,7786,7833,7878,7895,7898,7904,7918,7987,8032,8051,8079,8129,8133,8195,8220,8261,8287,8307,8314,8426,8491,8506,8553,8586,8630,8651,8838,8919,8929,8988,9061,9151,9177,9298,9634,9643,9697,9720,9731,9803,9834,9898,9915,10052,10122,10214,10220,10248,10330,10426,10434,10483,10538,10571,10615,10628,10633],"French":[33,181],"going":[34],"back":[35],"Hermann":[37],"Cohen's":[38],"Kants":[39],"Begr\u00fcndung":[40],"der":[41],"\u00c4sthetik":[42],"1889,":[44],"while":[45,1405,3027,9381,10068],"also":[46,456,1067,1754,2171,2457,2737,2929,3853,4366,4576,5327,6886,7056,7154,7333,7445,7757,8445,10015],"reading":[47,8344],"most":[48,9880],"what":[50,306,1196,1206,1496,1506,2271,3357,3463,3518,3663,3822,4450,5660,6004,6059,6233,6671,8179,8414,8856,9054,9169,10274,10310,10331],"wanted":[52],"eighteenth\u2010century":[56],"British":[57],"German":[59,193,5635],"aesthetics":[60,115,135,162,321,339,1112,1728,2146,7847,8747,9780],"before":[61,300,8750,9700],"Kant\u2014not":[62],"because":[63,74,800,3903,3921,5612,5630,6872,6887,8816,9487,10205,10308,10476],"had":[65,254,1641,4691,6851],"paid":[66],"dues":[68],"Evelyn":[70],"Wood,":[71],"but":[72,982,1064,1084,1511,1618,1671,1675,1721,1778,1959,2110,2334,2605,2616,2735,2759,2928,3002,3226,3319,3471,3578,4227,4492,4501,4686,4863,4955,5071,5701,6147,6885,6955,7041,7055,7376,7669,7753,8062,8157,8398,8444,9105,9154,9499,9536,9564,10689],"just":[73,213,277,645,3136,3206,4398,4934,5039,5133,6189,6798,7595,8770,9172,9486,9533],"there":[75,120,517,1614,1690,4925,5318,6413,6663,6800,9732],"not":[77,171,755,859,924,981,1193,1508,1666,2076,2331,2545,2601,2761,2774,2783,3204,3320,3472,3511,3516,3573,3655,3733,3872,3876,3940,4102,4228,4476,5006,5281,5298,5687,5886,5974,6082,6099,6140,6188,6194,6366,6596,6714,6870,6945,6985,7051,7367,7487,7563,7636,8087,8148,8263,8316,8349,9036,9114,9180,9234,9348,9439,9444,9502,9532,9582,9729,9786,9813,9855,9903,10302,10513],"that":[79,147,312,336,343,494,507,696,797,804,873,902,1115,1240,1488,1523,1556,1576,1819,1871,1944,1960,1988,2005,2090,2137,2150,2174,2179,2187,2196,2226,2238,2289,2307,2317,2328,2354,2370,2375,2395,2443,2455,2522,2537,2623,2665,2709,2739,2753,2772,2785,2797,2828,2836,2867,2903,2943,3004,3016,3066,3137,3234,3267,3273,3302,3395,3410,3492,3508,3535,3539,3565,3569,3634,3650,3657,3688,3693,3718,3735,3750,3754,3783,3794,3800,3808,3848,3935,3986,4019,4063,4086,4100,4109,4135,4173,4418,4441,4519,4557,4564,4616,4631,4657,4839,4845,4901,4928,4978,5035,5111,5152,5232,5279,5296,5335,5342,5375,5385,5398,5429,5437,5552,5555,5581,5634,5684,5716,5729,5746,5754,5762,5793,5814,5848,5850,5873,5888,5919,5927,5947,5971,6028,6040,6058,6063,6115,6127,6143,6162,6166,6196,6261,6274,6296,6312,6324,6356,6359,6382,6414,6444,6451,6467,6545,6623,6650,6662,6698,6723,6728,6732,6743,6788,6799,6812,6831,6839,6859,6898,6913,6917,6919,6928,6937,7037,7118,7146,7172,7198,7214,7320,7328,7346,7393,7400,7426,7442,7504,7510,7535,7549,7570,7634,7700,7722,7739,7792,7859,7926,7964,7975,8001,8022,8058,8107,8151,8170,8238,8251,8276,8375,8501,8533,8574,8607,8620,8668,8709,8726,8742,8774,8795,8864,8937,8953,8974,8999,9026,9040,9166,9178,9186,9194,9270,9277,9279,9295,9317,9326,9346,9372,9423,9520,9531,9548,9567,9594,9603,9645,9738,9776,9789,9811,9843,9852,9878,9916,9937,9971,10013,10029,10054,10080,10133,10159,10165,10182,10189,10204,10222,10270,10345,10353,10389,10410,10466,10554,10564,10593,10604,10619,10655,10668,10681],"much":[80,1187,4004,5135,8295,8353],"read.1":[82],"pity":[84],"graduate":[86],"student":[87],"who":[88],"sets":[89],"out":[90,231,2049,5338,6580,6880,7169,7661,10506],"write":[92],"a":[93,123,145,168,268,364,570,896,909,1028,1145,1212,1215,1269,1414,1420,1438,1445,1481,1484,1537,1616,1628,1642,1659,1673,1887,1909,1917,1981,1984,2001,2105,2124,2177,2199,2229,2236,2273,2295,2320,2358,2363,2381,2384,2410,2461,2520,2527,2555,2584,2589,2592,2642,2729,2732,2768,2792,2795,2816,2838,2842,2849,2870,2873,2888,2901,3053,3086,3111,3144,3151,3188,3207,3220,3373,3377,3414,3561,3586,3678,3701,3824,3828,3842,3927,3937,3960,4025,4072,4221,4315,4330,4368,4378,4389,4536,4539,4648,4734,4817,4825,4941,4958,5049,5059,5066,5109,5183,5230,5277,5292,5310,5333,5347,5433,5504,5512,5532,5576,5600,5661,5688,5702,5706,5713,5773,5788,5808,5829,5845,5923,5952,5958,5975,6023,6050,6083,6092,6130,6168,6173,6280,6299,6316,6369,6415,6569,6598,6666,6700,6740,6776,6803,6824,6861,6902,7027,7103,7112,7116,7125,7129,7135,7160,7260,7294,7340,7344,7371,7378,7415,7451,7456,7484,7539,7632,7638,7695,7712,7751,7971,7999,8124,8130,8328,8400,8476,8497,8524,8539,8556,8568,8589,8599,8626,8646,8660,8730,8739,8754,8792,8822,8874,8941,9012,9160,9200,9290,9307,9341,9406,9412,9429,9454,9457,9468,9538,9553,9570,9578,9679,9787,9797,9841,9847,9892,9950,9968,9997,10114,10117,10154,10172,10255,10266,10384,10471,10552,10584,10616],"third":[97,165,236,285,357,502,567,657,672,878,1204,1776,2072,4131,7745,8373,9875,10572],"now:":[99],"since":[100,151,214,224,405,5826,6180,6707],"Donald":[101],"Crawford,":[102],"Francis":[103],"Coleman,":[104],"Jens":[105],"Kulenkampff,":[106],"Eva":[107],"Schaper,":[108],"published":[111,202,288,2500],"books":[112,244,1122,7738],"between":[116,206,418,423,436,525,1158,2141,2947,4323,4400,4599,4650,4800,5186,5352,6264,6670,6806,7616,7893,7899,7915,7977,8787,8917,9240,10208,10239,10531,10568,10626],"1974":[117],"1979":[119],"has":[121,148,239,372,754,2198,2398,2524,3591,3637,4388,4920,5336,5400,5575,5636,5922,6036,6319,6436,6733,7513,8893,9042,9250,9335,9979],"been":[122,314,374,828,4692,9336],"continuing":[124],"flood":[125,146],"articles":[127],"(this":[128],"journal":[129,5204],"receives":[130],"more":[131,218,487,4379,4396,4540,5913,6603,9458,9477,9928,9956,10267,10290,10691],"submissions":[132],"annually":[136],"than":[137,899,912,1585,1801,1897,2661,3115,3627,3645,4397,4545,5914,6527,8597,9255,9432,9510,9958],"any":[139,862,1712,2159,2533,2763,2778,4168,4231,4350,5791,5812,6154,6501,6761,6768,7891,8006,8155,8225,8356,8392,8460,8743,9024,9028,9084,9102,9534,9657,10555],"other":[140,409,666,1121,1177,1408,2487,2972,3624,3806,4050,4865,5026,5161,5302,5530,5784,6222,6434,7292,7383,7990,8016,8798,8967,9722],"historical":[141],"topic)":[142],"books,":[144],"only":[149,155,267,1085,1619,1925,2022,2065,2190,2291,2315,2373,2406,3502,3899,3906,3922,4079,4687,4836,4857,4894,5153,5637,5944,6111,6699,6871,6876,6891,7052,7377,7396,7429,7531,7670,7820,8255,8405,8598,9206,9537,9703,9901,10002,10363],"accelerated":[150],"2000.2":[152],"Confining":[153],"myself":[154],"monographs":[157,199,279,623],"anthologies":[159,201],"or":[163,667,1390,1440,1473,1483,1494,1503,1513,1520,1566,1698,1964,1997,2789,2805,3212,3280,3314,3583,3699,3715,3868,3917,3983,4037,4208,4436,4482,4620,4707,4778,4819,4821,4873,4990,5349,5536,5672,5799,5861,5863,5871,5891,6372,6680,6910,7175,7185,7373,8247,8331,8365,8785,8836,8990,8994,9164,9403,9476,10151,10289],"as":[167,242,252,363,415,469,471,542,544,569,629,631,771,895,908,986,1179,1181,1261,1350,1419,1434,1442,1748,1765,1811,1818,1828,1837,1886,1980,1983,2020,2119,2192,2235,2345,2362,2525,2532,2634,2655,2714,2719,2981,3040,3100,3172,3247,3328,3360,3393,3779,3959,4003,4015,4031,4045,4167,4273,4290,4296,4332,4394,4430,4587,4684,4688,4729,4752,4813,4868,4937,4963,5040,5042,5055,5134,5136,5229,5442,5483,5496,5511,5696,5805,6031,6219,6237,6442,6597,6605,6645,6674,6759,6767,7050,7062,7182,7253,7281,7411,7431,7450,7579,7750,8038,8112,8197,8232,8282,8407,8421,8496,8645,8876,9058,9087,9405,9453,9710,9992,10102,10171,10499,10501],"whole":[169,571,892,1982,4683,4758,7752],"(but":[170],"those":[172,335,342,687,4869,7900],"devoted":[173,10587],"exclusively":[174],"teleology)":[176],"shelves,":[184],"no":[186,1400,1601,2473,5144,5857,5903,8003,8222,8535,8853,9248,9734,10229],"doubt":[187,4924,8354],"missing":[188,8063],"some,":[189,10364],"at":[190,240,639,700,932,2475,2687,2921,3988,4443,4846,4889,5115,5852,5979,8810,9030,9328,9349,9356,9580,9794,9818],"least":[191,241,2688,3161,5853],"French,":[195],"find":[197,1306,2864,2942,3048,3898,3905,3967,3985,4021,4071,4088,4787,5019,5143,7574,9552,9975,10514],"twenty\u2010eight":[198],"period":[205,6503],"1980":[207],"1999":[209],"another":[211,3869,4284,4301,5719,5752],"twenty\u2010seven":[212],"2000.":[215],"(Indeed,":[216],"two":[217,653,694,802,864,974,1079,1762,4607,4794,6238,6675,7737,8162,8789,8971,9044,9242],"have":[219,313,826,1640,3139,3610,4377,4933,5268,6042,6100,6129,6167,6235,6255,6380,7039,7063,7094,7121,7666,8092,8149,8200,9056,9467,9792,9994,10412],"arrived":[220],"desk":[223],"this":[225,272,406,798,1083,1137,1162,1190,1298,1489,1717,2046,2195,2339,2508,2587,2651,2944,2968,3493,3604,3819,4338,4788,5203,5488,5518,5613,5638,5736,6060,6138,6181,6383,6731,6755,6991,7279,7316,7388,7597,7837,7883,8152,8611,9515,9985,10454],"article":[226],"written.)3":[228],"Someone":[229],"setting":[230],"work":[233,635,1073,4514,5110,9329,9350,10563],"now":[238,2984],"many":[243,4769,7850,8339,10432],"from":[245,257,1195,1874,3803,3827,4205,4281,4292,4952,5271,5301,5988,6390,7083,7219,7265,8064,8114,8684,8867,9420,9600,9656,9695,9886,10177,10366],"last":[247,2505],"decade":[248],"alone":[249,340],"1971":[256],"eight":[259],"preceding":[260],"decades.":[261],"The":[262,442,972,3258,4308,5390,6248,6625,7491,7769,8096,9860,10321,10405],"present":[263,1498,1510,4435,4668,4885,5114],"review":[264],"will":[265,275,685,1037,1116,1129,2941,3418,3609,3752,4893,4902,5452,5745,6409,6424,10370,10504],"make":[266,1573,2762,3268,3348,3560,3849,3856,4048,4057,4558,6263,6515,7002,8167],"small":[269],"dent":[270],"pile:":[273],"discuss":[276,686,860,925],"five":[278],"one":[281,533,597,633,1151,1170,1371,1928,2282,2426,2959,3540,3553,3558,3590,3608,3866,4043,4206,4282,4293,4300,4594,4847,4953,5328,5399,5639,6035,6358,6818,6850,7230,7512,7646,7909,7958,7985,8767,9530,10292],"introduction":[282],"Critique,":[286,879,1205,2073,8519,8702,9676,9876],"English":[290],"2006":[292],"2007.":[294],"A":[295,3837,5652,5964,9624],"natural":[296,1290,1391,1634,1796,1949,4942],"question":[297,476,520,556,7233,7317],"ask":[299,1154],"turning":[301],"these":[303,812,845,3296,5030,5089,6962,8346],"volumes":[304],"is":[305,480,518,674,799,837,936,1144,1197,1242,1363,1491,1497,1507,1582,1615,1691,1729,1759,1766,1779,1810,1826,1838,1943,2147,2176,2180,2189,2222,2232,2239,2304,2308,2318,2330,2355,2376,2388,2416,2456,2544,2568,2598,2751,2773,2794,2815,2829,2872,2887,2895,3024,3030,3075,3084,3275,3292,3330,3411,3456,3498,3554,3572,3594,3721,3757,3777,3785,3820,3852,3862,3889,3936,4078,4127,4134,4251,4313,4362,4428,4442,4449,4452,4474,4575,4590,4632,4750,4762,4798,4830,4883,4910,4945,5112,5163,5180,5233,5280,5319,5326,5344,5388,5392,5432,5438,5506,5556,5664,5686,5711,5717,5755,5790,5811,5828,5928,5951,5969,5973,6019,6062,6065,6075,6122,6139,6159,6182,6258,6362,6385,6405,6491,6548,6630,6664,6686,6713,6730,6757,6866,6874,6889,6915,6924,6944,7243,7250,7259,7399,7407,7428,7434,7444,7480,7499,7506,7538,7545,7635,7694,7775,7779,7857,7927,8059,8243,8262,8348,8402,8409,8415,8435,8671,8679,8737,8763,8904,8954,9011,9071,9113,9170,9179,9202,9289,9327,9347,9529,9577,9590,9626,9636,9733,9781,9785,9863,10014,10057,10075,10086,10134,10142,10192,10281,10352,10374,10395,10420,10463,10520,10574,10654,10661],"are":[307,572,659,697,980,1178,1226,1469,1530,1599,2624,2636,3007,3098,3276,3303,4605,4617,4658,4926,5012,5038,5157,5984,5997,6029,6104,6145,6164,6984,7329,7332,8103,8384,8468,8806,8863,9136,9155,9606,9725,10346,10378],"outstanding":[309],"interpretative":[310],"issues":[311,330,410,506,644,1114,2989,3003,4609],"raised":[315],"previous":[317],"discussions":[318],"might":[323,331,1051,1208,3541,3664,3871,3966,5306,8562,8653,9540,10293],"fruitfully":[324],"allow":[325,4914,8907],"for":[326,737,1148,1246,1274,1303,1321,1644,2081,2108,2293,2368,2408,2413,2435,2451,2464,2591,2694,2731,2856,2875,2890,3376,3865,3973,4641,4793,4911,4915,5146,5516,5537,5641,5872,5954,6401,7004,7078,7301,7324,7336,7747,8005,8061,8224,8320,8438,8459,8479,8537,8567,8582,8588,8659,8687,9023,9565,9572,9583,9628,9650,9770,9906,9976,10047,10104,10303,10348,10523],"further":[327,868,5601,7533,7676],"discussion?":[328],"These":[329],"be":[332,483,575,964,984,1010,1021,1124,1130,1381,1432,1517,1532,1926,2042,2051,2104,2379,2460,2900,2979,3166,3187,3333,3459,3517,3531,3580,3665,3810,4029,4034,4095,4225,4341,4535,4895,4903,5007,5094,5307,5340,5404,5420,5750,6117,6156,6329,6784,6802,6841,6864,6978,7073,7519,7524,7555,7821,8707,9009,9428,9448,9544,9569,9713,9858,10024,10100,10360,10371,10442,10470,10508,10606,10671],"divided":[333],"into":[334,3747],"concern":[337,344,989,2213,5162,7912],"place":[346,2675,9075,9599],"his":[348,545,787,809,1645,1770,1783,1814,2086,2112,2145,2148,2267,4407,4421,6008,6214,8617,9224,9584,9771,10187,10333,10539,10624,10685],"larger":[353,1859,2125,5184],"project":[354],"philosophy":[362,603,2078,7749,7907],"whole.":[365],"Among":[366,504],"former,":[368,5408],"key":[370,380,1460,9218,9225],"issue":[371,407,9861],"certainly":[373,2523,2705,3761,4387,4475,6657],"how":[375,478,558,651,670,939,2847,5010,6781,6999,8089,9391,10431,10621],"we":[376,1652,2716,2757,3309,3403,3474,3519,3870,3897,3904,3965,4087,4110,4183,4276,4343,4588,5011,5018,5267,5794,5815,5831,5837,5889,5983,6487,8779,8831,8889,9002,9006,9466,9692,9917,9938,10411],"should":[377,983,1009,1020,1514,2800,3559,3579,7174,7372,7701,9447,9513,10099],"understand":[378,6592],"concept":[381,852,1147,1163,1191,1485,1626,2231,2479,2539,2590,2730,3830,5671,8557,9219,9309,10664,10677],"harmonious":[384],"play":[385,464,2626,3451,3630,3929,3976,3993,4152,4185,4197,4309,4316,4470,4530,4728,4818,5241,5446,5461,5566,6301,6950,7137,7351,8028,8591,8722,8993,9050,9246,9282,10129,10544],"cognitive":[388,467,2621,3454,3932,3955,4155,4258,5449,5569,5597,5703,6272,6304,6953,7140,7354,8594,8724,9460,9653,9723,9750,10547],"powers":[389,3455,5570,5598,6273,6954,7355,9751,10548],"imagination":[391,2671,3424,4383,4393,4473,4533,8031,8490,8644,9669,9719],"understanding":[393,3426,8033,8313,8480,8492,8987],"our":[395,917,1655,1902,1962,2017,2115,2128,2183,2747,3163,3176,3285,3293,3317,3326,3368,3453,3465,3666,3709,3931,3948,3978,3995,4203,4244,4279,5098,5448,6000,6271,6277,6303,6495,6508,6522,6609,8840,8871,8961,9651,9701,9721,9749,9959,10048,10400],"response":[396,958,2859,3087,3711,8495,8692,10170]},"cited_by_api_url":"https://api.openalex.org/works?filter=cites:W2140197593","counts_by_year":[{"year":2026,"cited_by_count":12},{"year":2025,"cited_by_count":1},{"year":2024,"cited_by_count":20},{"year":2023,"cited_by_count":1},{"year":2022,"cited_by_count":2},{"year":2021,"cited_by_count":2},{"year":2020,"cited_by_count":1},{"year":2019,"cited_by_count":2},{"year":2018,"cited_by_count":19},{"year":2016,"cited_by_count":2},{"year":2015,"cited_by_count":1},{"year":2014,"cited_by_count":1},{"year":2012,"cited_by_count":1}],"updated_date":"2026-11-21T10:27:49.728292","created_date":"2016-06-24T00:00:00"}
