{"id":"https://openalex.org/W2062954100","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6245.2008.00298.x","title":"The Opticality of Pictorial Representation","display_name":"The Opticality of Pictorial Representation","publication_year":2008,"publication_date":"2008-03-01","ids":{"openalex":"https://openalex.org/W2062954100","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6245.2008.00298.x","mag":"2062954100"},"language":"en","primary_location":{"id":"doi:10.1111/j.1540-6245.2008.00298.x","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6245.2008.00298.x","is_oa":false,"landing_page_url":"https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6245.2008.00298.x","pdf_url":null,"source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S26308392","display_name":"Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism","issn_l":"0021-8529","issn":["0021-8529","1540-6245"],"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":true,"listed_in":["anvur-class-a","anvur-scientific","cwts-core","erih-plus","jufo-3","norway-2","poland-140","russia-white-list-1","vabb-shw"],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/P4310311648","host_organization_name":"Oxford University Press","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/P4310311648","https://openalex.org/P4310311647"],"host_organization_lineage_names":["Oxford University Press","University of Oxford"],"type":"journal"},"license":"public-domain","license_id":"https://openalex.org/licenses/public-domain","version":"publishedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":true,"raw_source_name":"Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism","raw_type":"journal-article"},"volume":null,"type":"article","is_traditional":true,"indexed_in":["crossref"],"open_access":{"is_oa":false,"oa_status":"closed","oa_url":null,"any_repository_has_fulltext":false},"authorships":[{"author_position":"first","author":{"id":"https://openalex.org/A5073804016","display_name":"Katerina Bantinaki","orcid":null,"observed_orcids":[]},"institutions":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/I28407311","display_name":"University of Manchester","ror":"https://ror.org/027m9bs27","country_code":"GB","type":"education","lineage":["https://openalex.org/I28407311"]}],"countries":["GB"],"is_corresponding":true,"raw_author_name":"KATERINA BANTINAKI","raw_affiliation_strings":["Aff1 Department of Philosophy University of Manchester Manchester M13 9PL United Kingdom","Department of Philosophy\u2028University of Manchester\u2028Manchester, United Kingdom M13 9PL\u2028internet: katerina.bantinaki@manchester.ac.uk"],"raw_orcid":null,"affiliations":[{"raw_affiliation_string":"Aff1 Department of Philosophy University of Manchester Manchester M13 9PL United Kingdom","institution_ids":["https://openalex.org/I28407311"]},{"raw_affiliation_string":"Department of Philosophy\u2028University of Manchester\u2028Manchester, United Kingdom M13 9PL\u2028internet: katerina.bantinaki@manchester.ac.uk","institution_ids":["https://openalex.org/I28407311"]}]}],"institutions":[],"countries_distinct_count":1,"institutions_distinct_count":1,"corresponding_author_ids":["https://openalex.org/A5073804016"],"corresponding_institution_ids":["https://openalex.org/I28407311"],"apc_list":{"value":3492,"currency":"USD","value_usd":3492},"apc_paid":null,"fwci":8.1104,"has_fulltext":false,"cited_by_count":5,"citation_normalized_percentile":{"value":0.97047899,"is_in_top_1_percent":false,"is_in_top_10_percent":true},"cited_by_percentile_year":{"min":88,"max":95},"biblio":{"volume":"66","issue":"2","first_page":"183","last_page":"192"},"is_retracted":false,"is_paratext":false,"is_xpac":false,"primary_topic":{"id":"https://openalex.org/T12632","display_name":"Visual Culture and Art Theory","score":0.7554000020027161,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1213","display_name":"Visual Arts and Performing Arts"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/12","display_name":"Arts and Humanities"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},"topics":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/T12632","display_name":"Visual Culture and Art Theory","score":0.7554000020027161,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1213","display_name":"Visual Arts and Performing Arts"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/12","display_name":"Arts and Humanities"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},{"id":"https://openalex.org/T14322","display_name":"Art, Aesthetics, and Perception","score":0.13330000638961792,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1213","display_name":"Visual Arts and Performing Arts"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/12","display_name":"Arts and Humanities"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},{"id":"https://openalex.org/T12444","display_name":"Art, Politics, and Modernism","score":0.06849999725818634,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1213","display_name":"Visual Arts and Performing Arts"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/12","display_name":"Arts and Humanities"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}}],"keywords":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/pictorial-representation","display_name":"pictorial representation","score":0.9890000224113464},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/pictorial-space","display_name":"pictorial space","score":0.6100000143051147},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/pictorial-perspective","display_name":"pictorial perspective","score":0.4970000088214874},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/pictorial-depth","display_name":"pictorial depth","score":0.4440000057220459}],"concepts":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/C2776359362","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q2145286","display_name":"Representation (politics)","level":3,"score":0.620943546295166},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C142362112","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q735","display_name":"Art","level":0,"score":0.4274994134902954},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C41008148","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q21198","display_name":"Computer science","level":0,"score":0.348688006401062},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C17744445","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q36442","display_name":"Political science","level":0,"score":0.08810138702392578},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C199539241","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q7748","display_name":"Law","level":1,"score":0.0},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C94625758","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q7163","display_name":"Politics","level":2,"score":0.0}],"mesh":[],"locations_count":2,"locations":[{"id":"doi:10.1111/j.1540-6245.2008.00298.x","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6245.2008.00298.x","is_oa":false,"landing_page_url":"https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6245.2008.00298.x","pdf_url":null,"source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S26308392","display_name":"Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism","issn_l":"0021-8529","issn":["0021-8529","1540-6245"],"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":true,"listed_in":["anvur-class-a","anvur-scientific","cwts-core","erih-plus","jufo-3","norway-2","poland-140","russia-white-list-1","vabb-shw"],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/P4310311648","host_organization_name":"Oxford University Press","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/P4310311648","https://openalex.org/P4310311647"],"host_organization_lineage_names":["Oxford University Press","University of Oxford"],"type":"journal"},"license":"public-domain","license_id":"https://openalex.org/licenses/public-domain","version":"publishedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":true,"raw_source_name":"Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism","raw_type":"journal-article"},{"id":"doi:10.1111/j.1540-594x.2008.00298.x","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-594x.2008.00298.x","is_oa":false,"landing_page_url":"https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-594x.2008.00298.x","pdf_url":null,"source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S26308392","display_name":"Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism","issn_l":"0021-8529","issn":["0021-8529","1540-6245"],"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":true,"listed_in":["anvur-class-a","anvur-scientific","cwts-core","erih-plus","jufo-3","norway-2","poland-140","russia-white-list-1","vabb-shw"],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/P4310311648","host_organization_name":"Oxford University Press","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/P4310311648","https://openalex.org/P4310311647"],"host_organization_lineage_names":["Oxford University Press","University of Oxford"],"type":"journal"},"license":"public-domain","license_id":"https://openalex.org/licenses/public-domain","version":"publishedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":true,"raw_source_name":"Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism","raw_type":"journal-article"}],"best_oa_location":null,"sustainable_development_goals":[],"study_designs":[],"awards":[],"funders":[],"has_content":{"pdf":false,"grobid_xml":false},"content_urls":null,"referenced_works_count":2,"referenced_works":["https://openalex.org/W2166818537","https://openalex.org/W4230631525"],"related_works":["https://openalex.org/W3161005467","https://openalex.org/W2618951484","https://openalex.org/W589974202","https://openalex.org/W7005439231","https://openalex.org/W4398245999","https://openalex.org/W2319094892","https://openalex.org/W2978626457","https://openalex.org/W7114638704","https://openalex.org/W2735875246","https://openalex.org/W2578910463"],"abstract_inverted_index":{"In":[0,275,334,463,1139,2483,2766,3244,4586,5262,6386,6557],"Art":[1,730],"and":[2,15,39,132,185,196,287,321,394,430,457,500,549,919,956,1019,1084,1128,1291,1337,1405,1504,1521,1633,1692,1714,1758,1892,1920,1967,1973,2033,2175,2179,2188,2353,2435,2480,2514,2524,2583,2731,2768,2835,2926,3124,3141,3224,3247,3364,3379,3424,3500,3607,3719,3749,3892,3929,3953,4042,4053,4098,4176,4227,4276,4290,4401,4414,4417,4444,4450,4471,4496,4522,4536,4545,4561,4581,4635,4668,4716,4733,4864,4899,4946,4952,5088,5169,5386,5509,5545,5613,5621,5650,5707,5713,5716,5792,5814,5910,6022,6029,6204,6237,6442,6470,6551,6566,6586],"Knowledge":[3],"James":[4],"Young":[5,48,77,255,359,398,453,1146,5156,6364],"explores":[6],"the":[7,11,18,24,27,45,67,72,75,100,128,138,141,160,163,193,200,207,218,223,245,252,291,357,365,372,378,382,391,399,426,442,445,498,525,533,541,556,564,593,607,620,643,659,670,674,685,706,709,723,777,791,803,819,908,923,928,949,970,1010,1020,1025,1039,1049,1069,1072,1085,1092,1114,1123,1151,1162,1172,1175,1179,1191,1194,1210,1215,1222,1225,1272,1279,1302,1306,1323,1331,1338,1341,1345,1351,1361,1364,1373,1377,1392,1396,1399,1406,1409,1413,1419,1426,1435,1448,1466,1472,1482,1488,1511,1526,1544,1597,1605,1608,1620,1640,1645,1649,1658,1662,1670,1686,1694,1721,1724,1735,1741,1744,1763,1782,1793,1801,1816,1844,1851,1862,1900,1908,1924,1938,1941,1950,1955,1964,1979,1999,2037,2047,2070,2075,2080,2086,2094,2119,2142,2162,2207,2218,2245,2259,2282,2292,2296,2302,2315,2329,2340,2351,2357,2360,2370,2389,2399,2451,2495,2511,2525,2537,2555,2558,2561,2566,2578,2581,2584,2586,2595,2611,2626,2629,2640,2644,2657,2665,2672,2685,2691,2695,2714,2722,2725,2728,2732,2742,2745,2748,2751,2761,2772,2788,2796,2845,2856,2861,2865,2872,2882,2887,2894,2921,2929,2938,2948,2995,2999,3003,3013,3018,3021,3026,3043,3048,3057,3088,3094,3106,3109,3115,3133,3167,3174,3198,3206,3211,3214,3220,3230,3237,3263,3291,3302,3316,3344,3347,3390,3399,3413,3437,3444,3457,3486,3539,3573,3577,3586,3608,3613,3617,3640,3643,3654,3670,3678,3707,3714,3724,3729,3764,3786,3792,3806,3810,3818,3827,3839,3844,3864,3876,3882,3915,3940,3945,3951,3957,4012,4019,4027,4033,4049,4055,4093,4160,4170,4181,4204,4214,4225,4229,4259,4268,4302,4312,4334,4343,4350,4355,4363,4379,4402,4408,4415,4436,4484,4512,4525,4537,4556,4593,4606,4610,4621,4632,4639,4661,4675,4678,4694,4705,4719,4723,4726,4731,4734,4738,4741,4746,4750,4755,4774,4779,4783,4803,4815,4824,4828,4838,4855,4868,4872,4902,4950,4955,4965,4973,4983,5033,5044,5053,5082,5125,5130,5135,5146,5178,5199,5217,5228,5234,5238,5251,5256,5283,5286,5305,5308,5334,5353,5369,5394,5439,5443,5456,5459,5471,5474,5490,5493,5507,5512,5527,5540,5565,5569,5589,5593,5596,5600,5603,5611,5618,5630,5636,5648,5653,5656,5680,5691,5700,5724,5729,5736,5748,5760,5764,5767,5773,5787,5806,5810,5827,5838,5841,5844,5852,5859,5870,5873,5886,5889,5897,5918,5934,5941,5961,5999,6007,6013,6020,6036,6043,6052,6063,6068,6079,6090,6095,6108,6115,6121,6124,6127,6135,6142,6153,6174,6197,6200,6212,6215,6226,6248,6271,6277,6283,6295,6310,6316,6321,6358,6394,6397,6417,6430,6436,6454,6486,6492,6525,6531,6539,6546,6554,6564,6580,6583,6589,6595,6600],"visual":[8,93,134,154,402,405,434,446,461,534,553,668,806,936,1078,1269,1303,1342,1378,1410,1427,1652,2303,2521,2707,3264,4911,5108,5201,5280,5908,5962,6044,6186,6206,6241,6451,6512],"arts":[9],"of":[10,26,62,69,74,92,99,177,209,217,235,283,315,344,374,389,401,433,444,448,471,494,507,532,536,543,552,606,609,633,645,654,661,673,708,725,729,805,821,842,864,890,915,925,954,983,1012,1017,1022,1071,1108,1125,1136,1153,1174,1182,1193,1214,1254,1271,1334,1340,1360,1402,1408,1429,1450,1468,1474,1517,1607,1651,1672,1688,1743,1773,1791,1815,1881,1887,1912,1954,1975,1987,2007,2018,2039,2046,2061,2085,2093,2139,2173,2225,2234,2254,2295,2305,2342,2401,2405,2492,2539,2560,2568,2588,2608,2668,2747,2764,2790,2794,2896,2947,2952,2979,2988,3002,3010,3042,3093,3105,3146,3178,3189,3197,3210,3219,3232,3262,3266,3288,3369,3373,3377,3384,3393,3406,3446,3483,3494,3497,3520,3529,3541,3568,3575,3588,3593,3603,3616,3625,3634,3653,3666,3680,3693,3706,3709,3713,3716,3720,3752,3761,3766,3782,3820,3829,3863,3898,3905,3917,3926,3934,3947,3956,3971,3985,4021,4062,4078,4095,4110,4138,4154,4164,4221,4232,4284,4348,4396,4404,4410,4433,4439,4481,4487,4514,4579,4595,4650,4677,4680,4698,4707,4761,4785,4805,4820,4830,4852,4858,4871,4954,4957,4988,5001,5046,5095,5133,5148,5198,5216,5220,5230,5250,5293,5313,5336,5346,5352,5355,5368,5450,5492,5500,5506,5526,5542,5586,5592,5599,5617,5652,5682,5693,5719,5738,5766,5789,5800,5809,5829,5840,5851,5875,5914,5927,5933,5940,5960,5964,5981,6015,6042,6046,6075,6097,6117,6123,6134,6176,6199,6211,6217,6240,6297,6320,6343,6347,6357,6378,6396,6404,6414,6439,6449,6523,6582,6602],"past":[12,3240],"hundred":[13],"years":[14],"notes":[16,4591],"that":[17,117,140,452,473,479,488,518,539,566,582,619,627,711,738,769,830,853,883,931,947,976,1004,1014,1044,1051,1063,1074,1087,1116,1147,1171,1200,1221,1256,1258,1297,1305,1325,1344,1363,1376,1380,1412,1454,1538,1564,1575,1619,1626,1657,1675,1696,1747,1766,1785,1821,1850,1926,1940,1943,1949,2002,2062,2077,2127,2161,2164,2181,2247,2317,2332,2339,2356,2396,2527,2554,2623,2636,2785,2871,2953,2993,3020,3039,3083,3098,3108,3112,3164,3201,3213,3245,3249,3318,3349,3386,3401,3428,3459,3467,3471,3506,3532,3612,3642,3656,3735,3788,3813,3832,3841,3913,3995,4032,4072,4087,4190,4203,4243,4277,4301,4308,4336,4359,4366,4386,4421,4527,4550,4558,4605,4609,4660,4687,4725,4740,4754,4781,4880,4931,4960,4982,4994,5052,5064,5068,5081,5097,5145,5165,5185,5285,5307,5340,5371,5413,5458,5473,5504,5515,5578,5633,5635,5802,5846,5917,5992,6009,6054,6078,6129,6161,6214,6231,6250,6255,6265,6273,6279,6323,6331,6336,6387,6416,6488,6533,6553,6558,6574,6591],"most":[19,794,1663,2547,5075,6345],"striking":[20],"development":[21],"has":[22,143,150,257,520,679,734,1000,1308,1347,1415,1421,1676,1699,1834,1841,2030,2322,2650,2837,3075,3361,3579,3990,4124,4236,4663,4743,5237,5288,5373,5556,5822,5943,5953,5994,6065,6102,6110,6419],"been":[23,680,735,2651,3203,4125,4962,5374,5944,5954,6465],"emergence":[25],"avant\u2010garde":[28,46,133,431,550,6205,6238],"style,":[29,47,3011,3140],"adopted":[30],"by":[31,303,486,690,797,1552,1601,2102,2169,2239,2394,2783,3205,3276,3337,3343,3415,3469,4008,4026,4127,4474,4648,4773,4901,4938,5196,5747,5805,5864,6147,6193,6270,6374],"artists":[32,583,2165,2333,3417,4428,4475,4502,4519,4560,6028],"such":[33,79,238,340,1296,1718,1847,2025,3185,3435,3814,3921,4200,4509,5424,5501,5551,5915,6098,6489,6603],"as":[34,81,95,197,239,280,341,589,657,744,753,781,967,1240,2262,2648,2671,2727,2734,2817,2911,3059,3128,3409,3511,3524,3702,3775,3836,4172,4492,4576,4817,5013,5181,5330,5447,5529,5554,5672,5686,5735,5778,5973,6086,6170,6228,6366,6472],"Marcel":[35],"Duchamp,":[36],"Mark":[37],"Rothko,":[38],"Andy":[40],"Warhol.1":[41],"All":[42],"works":[43,91,414,432,451,538,551,807,1016,4242,6239,6252,6346,6350,6390,6395,6463,6490,6513],"employing":[44],"argues,":[49,256,360],"are":[50,102,115,771,1015,1064,1569,2167,2183,2309,2334,2908,3126,3143,3183,3253,3404,3411,3462,3472,3479,3565,3596,3619,3923,3942,4004,4114,4371,4472,4563,4895,5127,5166,5384,5406,5572,5579,5643,5776,5782,5797,5803,6253,6328,6332,6391,6497,6535],"discourse\u2010dependent":[51],"representations:":[52],"they":[53,56,119,123,897,917,1094,1493,1635,1927,2907,3429,4113,4569,4574,5405,5409,5414,5781,6256,6260,6337],"represent":[54,105,270,300,324,895,1053,1631,1828,3056,3275,4937],"what":[55,122,251,262,329,354,390,634,691,896,913,1097,1161,1391,1585,1888,2203,2275,2501,2510,2779,2819,3258,3301,3805,3874,4285,4317,4551,4573,4620,4989,5026,5115,5124,5299,5314,5363,5732,5865,5928,6059,6148,6259,6524],"do":[57,260,307,741,828,2051,2497,4452],"via":[58],"an":[59,198,1102,1106,1148,1158,1252,1829,2022,2026,2132,2216,2620,2825,2991,3338,3353,3650,3861,4121,4128,4149,4173,4191,4281,4306,4329,4374,4528,4714,4717,4764,4790,4841,5027,5035,5448,5498,5876,5904,6166,6473],"associated":[60],"body":[61,176,314,5544,6377,6413],"discourse,":[63,178],"which":[64,182,186,226,677,748,802,1029,1109,1706,1903,2690,3030,3119,3125,3149,3290,3416,3449,4427,4445,4894,5129,5255,5937,6026,6177],"is":[65,165,171,188,267,278,330,347,386,396,424,529,597,650,666,688,855,881,900,907,934,944,1036,1047,1089,1157,1184,1286,1295,1317,1327,1577,1586,1593,1669,1733,1738,1760,1807,1825,1864,1890,2108,2116,2145,2288,2373,2386,2409,2412,2433,2553,2557,2597,2654,2798,2801,2823,2851,2891,2920,2928,3085,3102,3306,3325,3352,3451,3466,3557,3611,3638,3685,3737,3846,3937,3982,3997,4030,4052,4058,4090,4120,4141,4162,4186,4208,4252,4263,4280,4287,4297,4318,4361,4442,4490,4555,4601,4641,4674,4686,4689,4700,4711,4861,4885,4906,4914,4928,4943,4985,4996,5007,5011,5041,5055,5066,5077,5085,5119,5152,5188,5223,5246,5274,5310,5342,5350,5376,5426,5435,5476,5496,5503,5562,5688,5726,5741,5843,5847,5862,5891,5902,5912,6126,6130,6145,6156,6183,6221,6224,6233,6245,6268,6280,6453,6530,6561,6598],"usually":[66,1206,1228],"theory":[68,224,6487],"art":[70,135,406,1018,3354,4405],"or":[71,417,845,994,1054,1267,1769,1907,2135,2542,2593,2614,2905,2914,2968,3090,3208,3227,3234,3242,3605,3866,4023,4145,4151,4157,4195,4248,4255,4406,4652,5194,5278,5538,5663,5795,6101,6291,6293,6354,6423,6482],"ideology":[73],"artist.":[76,2297],"regards":[78],"representations":[80,740,2899,3252,3403,3461,3468,4466,4542],"being":[82,871,4006,5038],"more":[83,2415,2541,2804,3184,3697,3851,3875,3887,6340,6481],"akin":[84],"to":[85,89,104,113,126,145,152,174,190,225,259,269,299,349,353,408,439,455,459,467,492,497,504,513,563,577,587,642,658,669,701,714,774,801,851,894,980,990,1001,1066,1091,1119,1166,1208,1288,1301,1311,1319,1322,1350,1387,1418,1422,1425,1438,1446,1465,1486,1562,1573,1603,1616,1630,1638,1643,1705,1753,1799,1826,1835,1842,1856,1869,1923,1998,2155,2201,2210,2236,2301,2323,2388,2429,2508,2517,2698,2703,2712,2720,2818,2838,2844,2859,2965,2971,3008,3028,3076,3096,3117,3172,3248,3295,3299,3309,3328,3334,3443,3456,3503,3580,3584,3598,3600,3723,3739,3757,3796,3803,3848,3885,3950,3964,3993,4011,4018,4082,4132,4142,4144,4179,4240,4253,4256,4270,4288,4291,4311,4342,4382,4391,4420,4449,4456,4464,4476,4508,4532,4540,4572,4583,4614,4626,4628,4644,4646,4655,4701,4730,4745,4770,4778,4794,4800,4802,4810,4813,4835,4837,4847,4866,4881,4888,4980,5057,5059,5101,5105,5113,5191,5212,5242,5282,5289,5297,5390,5399,5422,5442,5463,5602,5625,5647,5665,5743,5757,5762,5784,5823,5834,5885,5903,5923,5955,5968,5978,5987,6005,6057,6066,6072,6084,6103,6111,6165,6180,6196,6305,6314,6371,6382,6420,6428,6445,6479,6500,6519,6578],"language":[86,6172],"rather":[87,169,1186,3103,3279,3773],"than":[88,2416,2805,2998,3698,3852,3888,6341],"traditional":[90,110,131,338,429,548,6203,6236,6251,6367,6389,6440,6462,6511],"art,":[94,1469,6349,6542],"all":[96,460,816,981,1774,2485,2934,3144,3158,3504,3622,4971,5263,5798],"typical":[97],"instances":[98,982,3692,3751,3970],"latter":[101,142,1007,6159,6584],"thought":[103,348,3597],"in":[106,155,290,310,326,381,421,624,676,695,747,776,831,858,868,875,892,958,969,997,1005,1048,1096,1122,1178,1201,1219,1309,1348,1357,1385,1416,1458,1476,1491,1531,1679,1781,1846,1859,1902,2010,2036,2083,2152,2199,2281,2318,2440,2450,2470,2475,2487,2494,2536,2565,2628,2689,2710,2724,2750,2886,2923,2933,3170,3297,3323,3434,3441,3475,3517,3538,3546,3560,3582,3621,3664,3731,3763,3780,3789,3801,3826,3962,4038,4045,4048,4054,4080,4092,4130,4199,4272,4279,4321,4454,4462,4493,4511,4543,4565,4599,4604,4630,4748,4808,4840,4890,4964,5032,5103,5184,5248,5269,5295,5362,5397,5438,5468,5470,5531,5638,5769,5826,5832,5849,5869,5881,5894,5936,5950,6025,6032,6055,6070,6114,6132,6152,6157,6282,6303,6318,6335,6380,6426,6457],"a":[107,156,175,179,236,281,313,337,469,480,508,521,544,599,603,635,696,762,872,935,1030,1081,1133,1154,1185,1203,1245,1282,1312,1328,1335,1388,1403,1451,1497,1514,1518,1522,1673,1697,1700,1719,1750,1755,1789,1848,1866,1930,1976,2004,2015,2054,2091,2136,2194,2204,2230,2251,2268,2276,2285,2306,2343,2379,2407,2453,2458,2463,2467,2471,2476,2489,2569,2591,2631,2634,2669,2809,2889,2943,3061,3067,3070,3179,3190,3259,3271,3319,3357,3362,3367,3371,3375,3381,3394,3547,3759,3778,3868,3911,3980,3983,3999,4039,4046,4060,4139,4152,4197,4201,4219,4273,4293,4392,4440,4459,4488,4533,4566,4616,4690,4696,4709,4818,4859,4883,4910,4916,4922,4933,4990,5019,5116,5149,5204,5221,5224,5270,5276,5300,5315,5331,5411,5431,5466,5559,5584,5626,5666,5683,5720,5739,5744,5820,5907,5929,5957,5982,5995,6060,6171,6184,6301,6307,6375,6412,6446,6503],"direct":[108,5277],"manner:":[109,4843,5272],"works,":[111,3138,6441,6597],"according":[112,800,5967],"Young,":[114,127],"illustrative,":[116],"is,":[118,296,367,489,558,1884,2003,2123,2397,2786,3165,3356,5245,5462,5575,6100],"just":[120,760,1198,2776,4909,5430,5697,6257],"show":[121,6258],"represent.":[124,6261],"According":[125],"discontinuity":[129,546,6234],"between":[130,428,547,1330,1398,1918,2580,3746,4713,5511,6202,6235,6563,6594],"rests":[136,474],"on":[137,181,206,441,475,573,705,811,839,887,912,964,1028,1061,1495,1510,1648,1685,1723,1877,1929,1937,1978,1983,2466,2519,2705,2853,2902,2942,2959,2983,3012,3148,3285,3389,3419,3572,3870,3895,4106,4362,4426,4470,4478,4504,4524,4592,4722,4737,4849,5254,5759,6247,6411],"fact":[139,1073,2246,3317,3348,3400,4557,6008,6053,6272,6455,6532],"ceased":[144,151],"be":[146,153,203,319,578,630,693,702,718,809,1002,1120,1251,1266,1355,1423,1439,1444,1550,1854,1959,2099,2150,2223,2237,2324,2347,2575,2603,2677,2754,2839,3077,3335,3492,3508,3740,3758,4083,4624,4702,4771,5090,5138,5210,5213,5327,5391,5400,5481,5518,5824,5835,5867,5879,5921,5924,6112,6150,6181,6372,6383,6480,6520],"visual.":[147,5378],"And":[148,1556,2599,3181],"it":[149,170,183,187,227,263,277,355,413,596,649,678,716,733,750,880,899,975,999,1255,1259,1298,1368,1442,1548,1749,2130,2148,2273,2411,2502,2529,2649,2780,2800,2820,2822,2828,2863,3006,3065,3074,3099,3101,3332,3450,3637,3703,3858,3996,4029,4123,4187,4286,4360,4548,4844,4889,4913,4919,4977,5010,5024,5243,5273,5324,5341,5349,5372,5420,5434,5671,5687,5704,5706,5911,6018,6168,6223,6324],"twofold":[157,5883],"sense.":[158],"On":[159,192,1068],"one":[161,213,221,510,519,628,786,1230,1771,2289,2417,2806,3976,3989,4050,5039,5049,5070,5078,5121,5733,5785,5984,5993],"hand,":[162,195,1981,3015],"artwork":[164,201],"not":[166,323,425,639,651,742,815,856,939,1370,1623,1734,1752,2184,2222,2374,2377,2574,2602,2616,2655,2775,2813,2824,2875,3055,3254,3274,3463,3480,3648,3663,3738,4059,4115,4319,4642,4908,4936,5189,5275,5319,5326,5343,5416,5436,5517,5660,5696,5892,6225,6509],"autonomous":[167,745,2826,5974],"anymore:":[168],"inherently":[172],"linked":[173],"theory,":[180],"draws":[184,2940,2982],"intended":[189,268,279,1165,1211,1802,1951,2641,3127,4182,4205,5083,6431],"illustrate.":[191],"other":[194,1980,2770,2960,3014,3691,3750,3965,4056,4315,5264,5614],"effect,":[199,1220,2217,6474],"cannot":[202,214,318,2662,3977],"understood":[204,320,4772,5893],"simply":[205,511,5985],"basis":[208,1070,1650,4676],"its":[210,230,941,1034,2124,2831,2854,3282,3854,3880,4926,5260,5321,5711],"manifest":[211,1961,2349,3938,5154,5520],"properties:":[212],"make":[215,505,1836,1870,2166,3867,5979],"sense":[216,506,3440,5980,6160],"work":[219,409,2432,3110,3559,4327,5561,5620],"unless":[220,3988],"knows":[222,5051,5063,5080,5123],"appeals":[228],"for":[229,233,397,524,570,836,986,1033,1038,1190,1779,2244,2382,2420,2755,2830,2849,2868,2931,3036,3153,3162,3194,3217,3281,3515,3669,3727,3770,4014,4103,4298,4497,4788,5163,5259,5534,5641,5752,5998,6362,6407,6495,6502,6528],"meaning.":[231,2972,6432],"Think,":[232],"instance,":[234,987,1780,1898,2421,2850,2932,2974,3037,3195,3218,3516,3544,3728,3857,3902,4015,4394,4789,5487,5642,5753,6363,6529],"painting":[237,246,253,266,295,343,392,2424,2683,2976,2985,3046,5658,6555],"Warhol's":[240,6567],"200":[241,6568],"Campbell":[242,6569],"Soup":[243,6570],"Cans:":[244],"shows":[247,3066],"soup":[248,273],"cans;":[249],"but":[250,2232,2571,3825,3931,3967,5160,5857,6140],"shows,":[254],"nothing":[258,1739,1761,2117,3086],"with":[261,312,328,371,1080,1145,1501,1525,1708,1809,1996,2193,2229,2328,2366,2414,2618,2679,2741,2803,2881,2963,2969,3017,3069,3431,4070,4238,4328,4346,4373,4827,4877,5043,5203,5233,5393,5675,5896,6035,6173,6393,6485,6538],"represents:":[264,356,2781],"The":[265,294,384,1234,1275,1459,1507,1533,1970,2425,2431,2546,2977,2986,3131,3744,4136,4323,4423,4683,5004,5172,5206,5478],"something":[271,1248,1578,3850,4147,5060],"besides":[272],"cans.":[274],"particular":[276,464,1430,2016,2240],"representation":[282,611,933,966,1127,1156,1163,1321,1811,2249,2313,2320,2345,2811,2939,2949,3268,3351,3438,3499,3570,3595,3658,3682,3711,3718,3754,4412,4535,4699,4710,4832,4884,4905,4959,5151,6048,6163,6219,6275,6298],"facts":[284,302,2310,3311,3721],"about":[285,332,1581,1588,1654,1666,1682,1740,1762,2118,2311,2577,2605,3087,3229,3236,3312,3879,4148,4224,4228,4258,4333,4378,4407,5333,6286,6294,6541],"images":[286],"quotidian":[288],"life":[289],"modern":[292],"world.":[293],"however,":[297,768,972,1189,1915,2369,4189,5304,6094,6507],"unable":[298],"these":[301,945,1558,1610,2182,2606,4665,4671],"itself.":[304,3277,5750,6299],"It":[305,528,943,1571,1947,3278,3674,4296,6155],"can":[306,629,692,717,1916,2257,2448,2530,3507,4193,4246,4309,4520,4623,5089,5142,5209,5480,5622,5866,5878,5920,6149],"so":[308,640,857,1261,2109,2147,2387,2481,3327,4112,4997,5162,6406,6587],"only":[309,1060,2233,2528,3533,3795,5161],"conjunction":[311,327],"discourse.":[316],"\u2026[It]":[317],"does":[322,938,1260,1369,2376,2615,2774,2812,3054,3081,3273,3647,4935,4969,5318,5695,6508],"except":[325],"said":[331,5211,5922],"[it].2":[333],"sharp":[335,545],"contrast,":[336],"painting,":[339,358,2848,2925,5533,5640,5771,6543],"Canaleto's":[342],"San":[345,362,375],"Marco,":[346],"give":[350,2552,2625,2777],"way":[351,675,1050,1093,1849,1939,1986,2253,2763,3655,4202,4526,4649,4695,5132,5370,5472,6213],"naturally":[352],"represents":[361,482,1247,2131,2270,2274,2513,2684,3808,5021,5025,5118,5317,6062],"Marco":[363],"because":[364,2610,4940,5913],"viewer\u2014that":[366],"any":[368,1381,2226,3330],"viewer":[369,385,1307,1346,1382,1414,1852,2208,2278,2287,2308,2873,3027,3116,3168,3292,3578,3618,3793,3883,4161,4984,5029,5037,5111,5207,5225,5287,5309,5631,5667,5919,6064,6311,6418],"familiar":[370,1808,2081,2740,3530,5042,6484,6537],"appearance":[373,3916],"Marco\u2014can":[376],"recognize":[377,1644],"Venetian":[379],"cathedral":[380],"painting.":[383,2936],"visually":[387,631,1960,2325,2348,4986,5153,5311,5925,6521],"aware":[388,632,1814,4163,4987,5215,5312,5926,6522],"represents,":[393,637,2206,2821,4992,5931,6527],"this":[395,411,422,530,655,854,906,1006,1088,1137,1263,1292,1536,1582,1589,1667,1732,1994,2367,2385,2767,2927,3632,3667,3932,4165,4299,4970,4995,5347,5882,5951,5969,6010,6158,6191,6266],"essence":[400],"art.":[403,435,462,554,6207,6242],"Avant\u2010garde":[404],"seems":[407,454,1572,3756,4549],"against":[410,415,4218],"trait;":[412],"visuality":[416,472],"illustrativeness.":[418],"My":[419],"concern":[420],"article":[423,5952],"relation":[427,2579,3442,3963,6071,6201],"Rather":[436],"I":[437,465,559,615,712,766,849,961,973,1058,1099,1110,1117,1130,1142,1169,1196,2447,2498,2506,2515,2532,2550,2572,2600,2701,2716,2737,2759,3661,4067,4085,4357,4752,4874,5359,5428,6002,6188,6262,6572],"want":[438,466,850],"focus":[440,962,1059],"conception":[443,470,531,557,863,1880,1886,3261,5959,5970,6011,6448],"character":[447,535,608,660,3001,3265,5354,5963,6045,6096,6438,6581],"especially":[449],"pictorial":[450,537,610,646,662,664,739,822,926,932,965,984,1126,1155,1289,1320,1477,1683,1810,2248,2312,2319,2344,2383,2810,3137,3251,3267,3313,3320,3350,3402,3460,3484,3498,3512,3521,3562,3569,3594,3626,3635,3657,3681,3694,3710,3717,3753,4096,4367,4411,4465,4534,4541,4553,4584,4762,4786,4831,4958,5002,5047,5150,5186,5266,5337,5356,5365,5382,5560,5619,5684,5701,5854,5965,6016,6037,6047,6137,6162,6218,6274,6308,6348],"endorse":[456],"extend":[458],"examine":[468],"two":[476,5774,6596],"presumptions:":[477],"(a)":[478,780,1613,4088],"picture":[481,509,636,1031,1204,1216,1246,1336,1389,1393,1404,1420,1453,1509,1698,1722,1764,1794,1957,2092,2120,2143,2205,2269,2408,2452,2512,2612,2630,2726,2752,2773,2797,2883,3022,3191,3215,3272,3303,3395,3807,3845,3877,3981,4119,4140,4171,4198,4441,4489,4816,4839,4860,4934,4942,4991,5020,5117,5136,5222,5257,5301,5316,5721,5725,5740,5749,5821,5842,5887,5890,5930,5942,5983,6061,6069,6109,6125,6317],"(in":[483],"Young's":[484,625,782],"words)":[485],"itself,":[487,2395,2784,3324,4939],"without":[490,2398,2787],"appealing":[491],"contexts":[493,841,889,2154,2404,2793,3145,3287,4109,4432,4480,4510,4851,5126,6403],"information":[495,581,843,891,916,1027,1653,2842,2866,3147,3576,3768,3948,4009,4016,4024,4079,4434,4482,4651,4853,5096,5253,5294,5831,6077,6322,6379],"external":[496,840,888,1026,1464,2403,2792,2843,3286,3767,4010,4108,5252,6402],"picture;":[499,2862],"(b)":[501,824,1634,4099],"that,":[502,720,1129,1594,2013,2391,2486,3553,5380,5446,6456],"thereby,":[503],"needs":[512,700,1437,2209,3169,3333,3794,3884,5986],"look":[514,5661,5988],"at":[515,684,731,3558,3817,4498,5227,5483,5522,5858,5989,6141],"it,":[516,2619,5709,5990],"provided":[517,4025,5991],"recognitional":[522,2213,2293,2659,3536,3614,3700,3799,3890,5996],"ability":[523,1642,5997],"object":[526,1830,3587,4150,4175,5054,6000],"represented.":[527,6001],"forces":[540],"idea":[542,1534,3787],"But":[555,1584,1661,1731,2114,3073,4516],"will":[560,616,1100,1111,1143,1197,1250,1265,1853,1875,1958,2221,2346,2533,2675,2874,3113,4168,4177,4340,4352,4389,4530,4612,4728,5360,6189,6312],"argue,":[561],"erroneous":[562],"extent":[565,671,1324,1925,2390,4932,5284,5628,5746,5906,6167],"pictures":[567,834,884,988,995,1013,1052,1076,1503,1689,2956,3150,3470,3505,3815,3831,4074,4100,4370,5423,5971,6330],"always":[568,885,2073,4602],"depend":[569,835,886,1928,1982,3152,4102],"their":[571,837,1056,1627,2170,2176,3154,3420,3432,3918,3935,4104,5790,5793,6033,6450],"meaning":[572,838,1035,1606,2321,2341,4105,5084,5681,5737,5801,5839,5845,5855,6122,6128,6138],"(and":[574,785,2359],"thus":[575,1440,2098,2836,3755,4430,4865,4875,4947,5120,5214,5407,6443],"have":[576,1384,1615,1637,1639,1712,1796,2211,2507,2516,2718,3032,3050,3121,3202,3294,3910,4448,4645,4799,4961,5100,5158,5389,6003,6179,6263,6313,6464,6477],"supplemented":[579,2840,6373],"by)":[580],"had":[584,2079,2238,2702,6081],"good":[585,772,873,6082],"reasons":[586,773,946,953,6083],"regard":[588,2964,2970,3835,4239,4575,6085],"shared":[590,4222,4505,6087,6281],"knowledge":[591,2438,2951,3104,3196,3209,3228,3705,3897,4223,4335,4347,4380,4395,4506,6088,6278,6342,6415],"among":[592,1231,4314,5071,6089],"anticipated":[594,4338,4387,6091],"audience;":[595],"therefore":[598,2499],"misleading":[600],"guide":[601],"toward":[602,2457,3448,4354],"right":[604,1528,5131],"appreciation":[605,1972],"across":[612,1690,2186,4998],"different":[613,1709,1909,2111,2153,2157,2680,3566,3591,3601,3899,4073,4076,4383,4999,5484],"traditions.":[614],"argue":[617],"further":[618,3551],"popular":[621],"belief,":[622,1720],"reflected":[623],"analysis,":[626,756],"corresponds":[638],"much":[641],"process":[644,3540,4513,5335,5692],"understanding":[647,665,1359,2526,2946,5187,5267,5338,5425,5460,5608,5718,5939,6099,6210],"(as":[648,848,3079,5155],"unqualifiedly":[652,5344],"true":[653,2224,3493,5345,5351],"process)":[656],"understanding:":[663],"distinctively":[667,5377,6105,6185],"that\u2014regardless":[672],"accomplished\u2014it":[681],"informs":[682,5856,6139],"and,":[683,910,1217,1934,3408,3960,5074,5976],"same":[686,2673,4034,4364,4756,5657,5730,5860,6143],"time,":[687,5731],"informed":[689,5028,5036,5863,6146],"seen":[694,3943,5563,5825,5868,6113,6151],"picture.":[697,1313,1352,2846,4001,4460,4873,5205,5871,6154],"A":[698,3453,4118,5110,6039],"note":[699],"made":[703,4664],"here":[704,789,4685],"significance":[707,3123,5412],"project":[710,1181],"wish":[713],"undertake:":[715],"objected":[719],"ever":[721],"since":[722,4704],"publication":[724],"Nelson":[726],"Goodman's":[727],"Languages":[728],"least,":[732,5523],"widely":[736,763,5645],"acknowledged":[737,764,882,1003,3078],"function":[743,1628,4137,4166,5972],"entities,":[746],"case":[749,874,909,1008,1011,1021,1449,2922,3641,3828,3984,4051,4057,4061],"could":[751,787,2149,2279,2551,2573,2601,3490,5030,5137],"seem":[752],"if":[754,757,879,1596,1822,3629,4518,5009],"my":[755,959,977,1045,1140,2444,2520,2706,5948,6209],"successful,":[758],"would":[759,1549,1614,1636,1795,2065,2072,2097,2624,2637,2717,2753,3293,4068,4447,4776,4798,5099,5157,5415,5516,5659,5669],"reiterate":[761],"fact.":[765],"believe,":[767,1131,5429],"there":[770,1249,1326,1576,1737,1759,2115,3084,3182,3564,3684,4089,4251,4688,5065,6232,6327,6560],"engage":[775,3534],"proposed":[778,950],"analysis:":[779],"claim":[783,1277,1366,1375,2220,2261,2372,3458,3489,3646,4981,5006,5175,5180,5306,5332,6244],"attests":[784],"cite":[788],"also":[790,1865,1936,4915,6588],"anti\u2010intentionalist":[792],"claim,":[793,1104,2646],"famously":[795],"stated":[796],"Monroe":[798],"Beardsley,":[799],"interpretation":[804,1183,1974,2549,2870,3188,3542,3862,4594,5489,5877,6409,6496],"should":[808,1354,1819,3024,3834],"based":[810,6246],"internal":[812,2125],"evidence":[813,2816],"alone),":[814],"theorists":[817,826],"acknowledge":[818,829,1170],"nonautonomy":[820,924],"representation;":[823,4787,5966,6017],"even":[825,878,1595,2647,3235],"who":[827,1806,2290,4766,4792,5040,5050,5079,5122,5208,5668],"some":[832,1553,4134,5464],"cases":[833,3436,3482,3496,3624,5265],"implicitly":[844],"explicitly":[846],"accept":[847,1199,3631,5144],"deny)":[852],"paradigmatic":[859,3481,3495,3525],"cases\u2014Dominic":[860],"McIver":[861],"Lopes's":[862],"basic":[865,3555,3747,3790,3837,3986,4000,4063],"picturing":[866,3556,3748,3791,3987],"(discussed":[867],"Section":[869],"II)":[870],"point;":[876],"(c)":[877],"order":[893,2200,2711,3171,3298,3583,3802,4081,4131,4455,4809,5104,5296,5398,5833,6056,6304,6381,6427],"do,":[898,3824],"still":[901,3639,4978],"worth":[902],"explaining":[903],"(1)":[904,3315,3673],"why":[905,1434,2594],"accordingly,":[911],"sorts":[914,4077],"depend;":[918],"(2)":[920,3346,3785],"why,":[921],"despite":[922],"representation,":[927,985,1290,1684,2715,3563,3636,3695,4097,5383,6309],"common":[929,2439],"insight":[930],"phenomenon":[937],"lose":[940,5320],"force.":[942],"merit":[948],"analysis.":[951],"For":[952,2973,3901,5486],"coherence":[955],"simplicity":[957],"discussion,":[960],"mainly":[963],"practiced":[968],"arts;":[971],"take":[974,1118,4216],"analysis":[978,1107,3519,3633,3668],"applies":[979],"used":[989,996,2151,5056],"illustrate":[991],"scientific":[992,1023],"data":[993],"advertisement\u2014although":[998],"(unlike":[1009],"illustrations),":[1024],"depends":[1032,2829,4266,5258],"ready\u2010to\u2010hand":[1037],"targeted":[1040],"audience.":[1041,6092,6505],"Further,":[1042,2885,2955,3784,4823,5553],"given":[1043,2180,4007],"interest":[1046],"assume":[1055,4753,5410],"meaning,":[1057,3522],"issues":[1062],"relevant":[1065,1090,1894,2105,2402,2791,3221,3310,3502,3722,3949,4017,4107,4230,4381,4419,4507,5291,5441,5898,6073],"interpretation.":[1067,2418,4656,5899],"representational":[1075,1212,1226,1332,1400,1703,1776,1952,2158,2666,2832,3033,3122,3155,3176,3283,3391,4183,4206,4437,4485,4856,4869,5218],"generate":[1077],"experiences":[1079,1945],"certain":[1082,1283,2252,2490,4891,5627]},"counts_by_year":[{"year":2018,"cited_by_count":1},{"year":2015,"cited_by_count":2},{"year":2014,"cited_by_count":1}],"updated_date":"2026-11-08T12:12:28.789561","created_date":"2016-06-24T00:00:00"}