{"id":"https://openalex.org/W2055929693","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-594x.2008.00295.x","title":"What Do We See In Film?","display_name":"What Do We See In Film?","publication_year":2008,"publication_date":"2008-03-01","ids":{"openalex":"https://openalex.org/W2055929693","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-594x.2008.00295.x","mag":"2055929693"},"language":"en","primary_location":{"id":"doi:10.1111/j.1540-594x.2008.00295.x","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-594x.2008.00295.x","is_oa":false,"landing_page_url":"https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-594x.2008.00295.x","pdf_url":null,"source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S26308392","display_name":"Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism","issn_l":"0021-8529","issn":["0021-8529","1540-6245"],"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":true,"listed_in":["anvur-class-a","anvur-scientific","cwts-core","erih-plus","jufo-3","norway-2","poland-140","russia-white-list-1","vabb-shw"],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/P4310311648","host_organization_name":"Oxford University Press","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/P4310311648","https://openalex.org/P4310311647"],"host_organization_lineage_names":["Oxford University Press","University of Oxford"],"type":"journal"},"license":null,"license_id":null,"version":"publishedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":true,"raw_source_name":"Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism","raw_type":"journal-article"},"volume":null,"type":"article","indexed_in":["crossref"],"open_access":{"is_oa":false,"oa_status":"closed","oa_url":null,"any_repository_has_fulltext":false},"authorships":[{"author_position":"first","author":{"id":"https://openalex.org/A5090582127","display_name":"Robert Hopkins","orcid":null,"observed_orcids":[]},"institutions":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/I91136226","display_name":"University of Sheffield","ror":"https://ror.org/05krs5044","country_code":"GB","type":"education","lineage":["https://openalex.org/I91136226"]}],"countries":["GB"],"is_corresponding":true,"raw_author_name":"ROBERT HOPKINS","raw_affiliation_strings":["Aff1 Department of Philosophy University of Sheffield Sheffield S10 2TN United Kingdom","Department of Philosophy University of Sheffield Sheffield, United Kingdom S10 2TN internet: r.hopkins@sheffield.ac.uk"],"raw_orcid":null,"affiliations":[{"raw_affiliation_string":"Aff1 Department of Philosophy University of Sheffield Sheffield S10 2TN United Kingdom","institution_ids":["https://openalex.org/I91136226"]},{"raw_affiliation_string":"Department of Philosophy University of Sheffield Sheffield, United Kingdom S10 2TN internet: r.hopkins@sheffield.ac.uk","institution_ids":["https://openalex.org/I91136226"]}]}],"institutions":[],"countries_distinct_count":1,"institutions_distinct_count":1,"corresponding_author_ids":["https://openalex.org/A5090582127"],"corresponding_institution_ids":["https://openalex.org/I91136226"],"apc_list":{"value":3492,"currency":"USD","value_usd":3492},"apc_paid":null,"fwci":15.9508,"has_fulltext":false,"cited_by_count":31,"citation_normalized_percentile":{"value":0.98600592,"is_in_top_1_percent":false,"is_in_top_10_percent":true},"cited_by_percentile_year":{"min":89,"max":98},"biblio":{"volume":"66","issue":"2","first_page":"149","last_page":"159"},"is_retracted":false,"is_paratext":false,"is_xpac":false,"primary_topic":{"id":"https://openalex.org/T12803","display_name":"Cinema History and Criticism","score":0.7813000082969666,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1213","display_name":"Visual Arts and Performing Arts"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/12","display_name":"Arts and Humanities"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},"topics":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/T12803","display_name":"Cinema History and Criticism","score":0.7813000082969666,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1213","display_name":"Visual Arts and Performing Arts"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/12","display_name":"Arts and Humanities"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},{"id":"https://openalex.org/T14092","display_name":"Ethics, Aesthetics, and Art","score":0.19760000705718994,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1211","display_name":"Philosophy"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/12","display_name":"Arts and Humanities"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},{"id":"https://openalex.org/T12632","display_name":"Visual Culture and Art Theory","score":0.00860000029206276,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1213","display_name":"Visual Arts and Performing Arts"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/12","display_name":"Arts and Humanities"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}}],"keywords":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/film","display_name":"cinema","score":0.6809999942779541},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/film-aesthetics","display_name":"film aesthetics","score":0.42500001192092896},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/theatrical-representation","display_name":"theatrical representation","score":0.7110000252723694},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/film-spectatorship","display_name":"film spectatorship","score":0.9860000014305115},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/film-experience","display_name":"cinematic experience","score":0.4059999883174896},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/theatre-and-film","display_name":"theatre and cinema","score":0.3540000021457672}],"concepts":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/C2776359362","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q2145286","display_name":"Representation (politics)","level":3,"score":0.9150171279907227},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C177264268","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q1514741","display_name":"Set (abstract data type)","level":2,"score":0.6222515106201172},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C153349607","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q36649","display_name":"Visual arts","level":1,"score":0.47060665488243103},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C142362112","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q735","display_name":"Art","level":0,"score":0.4107731282711029},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C41008148","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q21198","display_name":"Computer science","level":0,"score":0.29105132818222046},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C199360897","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q9143","display_name":"Programming language","level":1,"score":0.046904057264328},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C94625758","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q7163","display_name":"Politics","level":2,"score":0.0},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C17744445","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q36442","display_name":"Political science","level":0,"score":0.0},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C199539241","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q7748","display_name":"Law","level":1,"score":0.0}],"mesh":[],"locations_count":2,"locations":[{"id":"doi:10.1111/j.1540-594x.2008.00295.x","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-594x.2008.00295.x","is_oa":false,"landing_page_url":"https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-594x.2008.00295.x","pdf_url":null,"source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S26308392","display_name":"Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism","issn_l":"0021-8529","issn":["0021-8529","1540-6245"],"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":true,"listed_in":["anvur-class-a","anvur-scientific","cwts-core","erih-plus","jufo-3","norway-2","poland-140","russia-white-list-1","vabb-shw"],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/P4310311648","host_organization_name":"Oxford University Press","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/P4310311648","https://openalex.org/P4310311647"],"host_organization_lineage_names":["Oxford University Press","University of Oxford"],"type":"journal"},"license":null,"license_id":null,"version":"publishedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":true,"raw_source_name":"Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism","raw_type":"journal-article"},{"id":"doi:10.1111/j.1540-6245.2008.00295.x","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6245.2008.00295.x","is_oa":false,"landing_page_url":"https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6245.2008.00295.x","pdf_url":null,"source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S26308392","display_name":"Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism","issn_l":"0021-8529","issn":["0021-8529","1540-6245"],"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":true,"listed_in":["anvur-class-a","anvur-scientific","cwts-core","erih-plus","jufo-3","norway-2","poland-140","russia-white-list-1","vabb-shw"],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/P4310311648","host_organization_name":"Oxford University Press","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/P4310311648","https://openalex.org/P4310311647"],"host_organization_lineage_names":["Oxford University Press","University of Oxford"],"type":"journal"},"license":null,"license_id":null,"version":"publishedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":true,"raw_source_name":"Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism","raw_type":"journal-article"}],"best_oa_location":null,"sustainable_development_goals":[],"study_designs":[],"awards":[],"funders":[],"has_content":{"grobid_xml":false,"pdf":false},"content_urls":null,"referenced_works_count":2,"referenced_works":["https://openalex.org/W1587549126","https://openalex.org/W3125449229"],"related_works":["https://openalex.org/W2610827152","https://openalex.org/W2492651582","https://openalex.org/W3677907","https://openalex.org/W4243478942","https://openalex.org/W4413992935","https://openalex.org/W2888580927","https://openalex.org/W2491997428","https://openalex.org/W4287661312","https://openalex.org/W4388215969","https://openalex.org/W7036582702"],"abstract_inverted_index":{"Here":[0,3659,5738],"are":[1,12,17,68,92,328,526,606,643,726,736,895,1185,1420,1563,1779,1851,2064,2105,2186,2352,2443,2457,2469,2590,2598,2799,3162,3281,3301,3369,3548,3585,3676,3915,4038,4046,4302,4344,4380,4395,4738,4829,4865,4977,5258,5305,5417,5527,6067,6209,6242,6509,6602,6746,7080,7166],"two":[2,24,374,716,2709,2830,3971,5240,5296,6412,6484],"obvious":[3,1102,6397],"and":[4,35,65,82,89,238,310,316,362,394,399,413,463,499,597,627,785,789,847,858,871,1000,1131,1282,1342,1646,1846,1880,1905,1929,2028,2056,2420,2438,3127,3307,3446,3471,3490,3637,3644,3776,3826,3940,3958,4030,4036,4048,4054,4058,4098,4132,4184,4315,4393,4465,4522,4550,4620,4627,4682,4741,4870,5114,5148,5167,5254,5553,5580,5645,5788,5973,6029,6031,6038,6040,6089,6119,6238,6301,6379,6607,6611,6822,6977,7117,7256,7283,7312,7321],"widely":[5],"known":[6],"facts":[7,7113],"about":[8,561,1429,1836,2320,3431,5265,5298,5843,6500],"one":[9,572,692,1316,2016,2032,2615,2976,3511,3696,4413,4458,4784,4802,5195,5421,5426,5467,7471,7478,7486],"way":[10,183,293,433,816,960,1200,1915,2512,2563,2936,3419,3502,3512,3772,4241,4252,4594,5225,5328,5544,6728,7261,7564],"films":[11,16,273,349,381,462,517,525,893,956,1023,1149,1184,2044,2223,2263,2351,3542,3888,3917,3985,4017,4092,4148,4290,4332,4430,4736,4822,5144,5161,5753,5766,6240,6251,6771,7145,7162,7509],"made.":[13,1121,2354,3436,4890,7081],"First,":[14,2189,4284,6487],"many":[15,263,347,2680,2979,4663,6558,6612],"made":[18,180,465,1692,1731,2150,3383,3416,3572,3586,3697,3786,3889,3986,4018,4431,7021],"by":[19,85,199,213,466,963,1145,1481,1693,1751,1898,1993,2151,2744,3217,3384,3573,3587,3698,3787,3890,3987,4016,4121,4257,4309,4473,4601,4644,4672,4832,4886,4942,5123,5327,5572,6125,6253,6837,7122],"a":[20,118,122,126,475,502,587,613,621,666,684,689,759,762,812,827,837,901,939,942,1002,1109,1123,1136,1168,1192,1244,1284,1312,1378,1390,1444,1513,1720,1852,1883,1889,1902,1933,1937,1950,1974,2054,2141,2161,2193,2246,2256,2367,2394,2506,2520,2607,2625,2628,2634,2648,2652,2760,2771,2780,2826,2935,3008,3041,3096,3351,3372,3386,3475,3538,3685,3691,3713,3721,3736,3811,3832,3878,3944,4142,4168,4240,4244,4251,4255,4407,4466,4481,4553,4608,4853,4937,4954,5227,5282,5368,5424,5464,5519,5529,5617,5740,5770,5775,5778,5867,5889,6166,6425,6476,6535,6547,6561,6576,6630,6652,6658,6688,6778,6781,6851,6871,6899,7095,7103,7147,7188,7204,7218,7260,7358,7473],"process":[21],"that":[22,133,152,169,282,319,342,549,775,894,1037,1090,1103,1118,1210,1258,1268,1393,1556,1599,1636,1674,1696,1776,1800,1885,2068,2201,2209,2216,2292,2301,2303,2371,2413,2455,2467,2475,2522,2530,2555,2597,2659,2668,2728,2749,2943,3154,3170,3177,3189,3231,3249,3277,3378,3380,3448,3459,3499,3532,3535,3600,3718,3735,3816,3842,3956,3967,4045,4089,4099,4165,4186,4213,4227,4271,4289,4354,4365,4378,4446,4484,4494,4565,4584,4611,4630,4631,4676,4737,4769,4863,4894,4912,4966,5022,5064,5102,5135,5197,5214,5280,5303,5308,5325,5336,5351,5390,5412,5437,5459,5468,5488,5596,5665,5893,5923,5939,6066,6191,6198,6208,6213,6230,6241,6319,6349,6415,6420,6491,6527,6646,6664,6670,6690,6696,6704,6755,6768,6816,6850,6864,6968,7102,7183,7238,7308,7313,7380,7394,7400,7412,7465,7489,7502,7535],"involves":[23,593,601,3400,4759,7342],"levels":[25,1056],"of":[26,32,95,103,106,117,125,128,149,190,195,217,230,232,297,321,339,360,369,376,410,480,485,538,576,579,623,669,715,718,731,739,770,772,780,790,792,801,804,818,832,842,892,900,908,971,989,1012,1046,1061,1085,1098,1138,1163,1181,1246,1265,1287,1292,1305,1314,1325,1333,1381,1404,1435,1449,1476,1487,1572,1613,1685,1739,1747,1781,1788,1839,1854,1868,1940,1970,2011,2025,2051,2090,2124,2133,2155,2205,2214,2245,2284,2317,2323,2325,2335,2349,2366,2369,2385,2440,2529,2554,2609,2636,2654,2690,2711,2731,2741,2750,2774,2784,2803,2828,2834,2883,2962,2966,3052,3070,3134,3147,3173,3213,3232,3268,3296,3311,3333,3353,3356,3360,3363,3374,3389,3478,3488,3520,3541,3612,3652,3656,3662,3664,3715,3791,3814,3834,3861,3918,3935,3950,3984,4061,4144,4149,4171,4197,4235,4242,4253,4291,4333,4338,4350,4373,4460,4483,4519,4530,4535,4541,4547,4558,4574,4577,4583,4623,4641,4655,4665,4675,4702,4732,4789,4811,4892,4962,5009,5048,5075,5119,5145,5154,5172,5181,5204,5220,5232,5242,5261,5268,5289,5329,5354,5371,5381,5385,5400,5406,5474,5504,5512,5522,5535,5556,5587,5656,5670,5688,5744,5799,5812,5834,5891,5907,5912,5918,5928,5940,5989,6043,6050,6122,6274,6336,6344,6348,6408,6428,6436,6444,6456,6458,6463,6467,6475,6514,6532,6589,6639,6657,6663,6678,6759,6776,6788,6807,6833,6841,6863,6884,6906,6941,7009,7016,7035,7046,7053,7068,7091,7098,7114,7141,7159,7169,7172,7217,7235,7250,7304,7339,7346,7353,7390,7427,7442,7482,7526,7538,7555,7566],"representation.":[27,119,163,2287,2556,2805,3149,3234,4762],"Actors,":[28],"with":[29,151,3040,3529,4125,4141,4406,4510,4662,4713,4735,5186,5347,5628,5874,5995,6059,6100,6156,6441,6453,6924,6985,7062,7224,7368,7381],"the":[30,43,45,53,57,61,66,73,76,97,104,115,130,138,142,175,187,193,196,200,210,215,218,224,228,233,247,250,291,298,308,332,337,340,343,367,417,419,472,483,490,493,509,519,539,598,677,702,740,745,751,773,795,805,843,849,861,865,889,904,914,919,923,969,972,977,980,1043,1051,1059,1071,1073,1091,1114,1147,1161,1175,1198,1226,1229,1266,1280,1290,1303,1320,1334,1338,1364,1368,1412,1425,1433,1437,1488,1497,1509,1525,1551,1561,1575,1597,1605,1611,1614,1623,1641,1661,1667,1683,1708,1715,1728,1745,1748,1752,1763,1793,1805,1810,1818,1828,1837,1856,1859,1865,1869,1920,2020,2022,2059,2095,2122,2130,2156,2168,2172,2202,2225,2276,2281,2285,2298,2321,2332,2336,2363,2382,2490,2561,2569,2594,2640,2645,2663,2666,2682,2686,2699,2702,2712,2729,2734,2738,2745,2753,2757,2769,2796,2804,2829,2839,2842,2847,2857,2884,2890,2906,2916,2921,2926,2940,2954,2967,2986,2991,3003,3025,3032,3037,3045,3055,3068,3098,3132,3145,3155,3159,3211,3214,3218,3225,3247,3254,3259,3266,3275,3290,3294,3297,3320,3327,3342,3354,3357,3375,3390,3408,3413,3433,3443,3495,3501,3530,3544,3561,3580,3604,3650,3660,3665,3753,3758,3761,3763,3792,3797,3821,3828,3840,3851,3865,3913,3923,3970,4000,4034,4043,4059,4087,4107,4136,4160,4195,4209,4221,4233,4259,4269,4273,4280,4285,4297,4339,4366,4399,4426,4440,4444,4475,4490,4498,4511,4517,4528,4531,4539,4575,4578,4593,4599,4618,4624,4628,4639,4642,4670,4714,4730,4744,4753,4764,4787,4791,4796,4805,4834,4841,4880,4884,4899,4903,4906,4909,4914,4925,4943,4951,4960,4974,4980,5001,5010,5015,5042,5046,5062,5070,5098,5124,5152,5179,5202,5205,5224,5311,5318,5355,5357,5360,5401,5407,5523,5543,5550,5554,5557,5574,5584,5592,5603,5614,5621,5626,5643,5654,5671,5685,5689,5694,5697,5721,5735,5745,5757,5781,5790,5800,5813,5819,5879,5883,5929,5971,5987,5993,6006,6012,6036,6041,6048,6051,6071,6080,6107,6120,6126,6136,6177,6188,6302,6314,6334,6354,6409,6434,6454,6464,6501,6512,6518,6522,6533,6550,6553,6586,6622,6637,6640,6644,6655,6660,6676,6702,6727,6766,6774,6789,6792,6796,6811,6814,6831,6845,6881,6885,6889,6910,6933,6963,6990,7010,7014,7033,7044,7047,7112,7139,7173,7214,7257,7305,7344,7382,7388,7398,7428,7458,7467,7500,7524,7530,7536,7544,7563],"aid":[31,3651],"sets,":[33,63,86,395,5558],"props,":[34,64],"perhaps":[36,5287,6542],"some":[37,272,728,815,1104,1941,2026,2697,2764,2880,2960,3114,3418,4094,4724,4820,5032,5118,5136,5433,6459,6760,6940,7303],"live":[38],"special":[39,87,1379,5264,5633,5964,6022],"effects,":[40,88],"act":[41,314],"out":[42,2439,2894,2902,3020],"events":[44,52,59,74,77,131,201,207,225,248,848,859,920,1062,1695,1700,1753,2337,2370,2735,2754,2956,3219,3280,3291,3295,3313,3716,3754,3793,3798,3815,4270,4797,5524,5576,5594,5695,5736,5930,5974,5981,5984,6551,6791],"film":[46,304,550,614,850,902,1072,1110,1119,1134,1273,2169,2495,2507,2891,2928,3349,3556,3862,3876,4119,4236,4463,4503,4548,4595,4657,4720,4873,4900,5125,5686,6163,6190,6233,6275,6536,6725,6761,6793,6934,7020],"seeks":[47,4996],"to":[48,167,275,294,306,313,317,384,407,428,436,454,505,555,574,608,634,966,968,1018,1160,1194,1208,1214,1262,1319,1523,1652,1714,1833,1953,1977,1985,2017,2034,2043,2046,2113,2121,2144,2239,2250,2297,2307,2330,2345,2357,2380,2411,2461,2479,2483,2488,2513,2517,2539,2546,2564,2573,2623,2811,2938,2972,3044,3062,3075,3092,3124,3224,3252,3286,3371,3503,3551,3709,3744,3747,3767,3809,3823,3830,3873,3954,3980,4042,4073,4079,4086,4147,4167,4176,4205,4278,4382,4421,4456,4516,4524,4538,4590,4616,4685,4777,4825,4840,4879,4897,4931,4934,4950,4970,4984,4997,5059,5083,5087,5091,5111,5126,5159,5170,5209,5226,5238,5309,5316,5331,5429,5444,5472,5497,5508,5531,5547,5549,5565,5578,5897,5960,5970,5979,6005,6011,6026,6035,6070,6084,6153,6168,6181,6203,6257,6269,6306,6323,6352,6357,6373,6385,6399,6403,6405,6497,6528,6544,6605,6654,6701,6716,6720,6902,6915,6958,6966,7025,7072,7125,7150,7180,7199,7213,7226,7247,7263,7279,7287,7297,7328,7331,7420,7532],"narrate.":[49],"(Call":[50,72],"those":[51,242,604,655,732,856,1421,1594,1699,1782,1789,2065,2070,2107,2293,2312,2386,2548,2588,3174,3269,3312,3835,3847,4359,4696,4812,5160,5372,5536,5566,5726,5761,5765,5898,5982,6105,6770,7126],"story":[54,139,197,211,251,420,924,1074,1115,1230,1749,1829,2157,2173,2226,2968,3215,3298,3391,3722,3822,3852,4245,4256,4792,5672,5698,5722,5758,5814,6502,6534,6812,7174],"told.)":[55],"And":[56,3402,3757,4363,4956,5432,6695,6744,7027,7138],"complex":[58],"involving":[60,712],"actors,":[62],"like":[67,1155,4659,6568,6585,7267],"themselves":[69,134,1697,2372,3719],"recorded":[70,75],"photographically.":[71],"filmed.)":[78],"Since":[79,141,1569,2078,7324,7393],"photographic":[80,123,536,2364,3148,3654,3711,3812,5386,5520,5533,5588,5668,5711,5797,5810,5825,5832,5853,5926,5949,5990,6074,6141,6223,6272,6287,6366,6429,6439,6493,6530,6648,6692,6757,6786,6805,6835,6896,7007,7051,7066,7129,7167,7196,7215,7281,7351,7370,7415,7480,7528],"recording":[81,3655,6549],"acting":[83,2893,4619,4845,4869,4926],"(supplemented":[84],"so":[90,255,382,1177,1760,1799,1992,2878,3308,3340,4185,4928,4964,5236,5307,5581,5922,6718,7031,7042,7284,7322],"forth)":[91],"both":[93,769,1844,4556,4739],"forms":[94,1738,3860,4557,4664,6443],"representation,":[96,2027,2096,4521,4626],"film,":[98,481,2179,3230,3903,4032,4375,4418,5054,5089,5113,5835,6873],"or":[99,704,1961,2001,2694,2767,2816,2913,3021,4033,4056,4846,4905,4936,4999,5056,5090,5359,5559,5568,5786,5875,5878,6580,7085,7087],"at":[100,278,286,1217,1255,1456,2448,3089,3144,3207,3305,3910,4228,4603,5193,5469,5636,5713,5720,5725,6206,6276,6556,6798,6908,7022,7074,7221,7301,7387],"least":[101,287,1457,3911,5194,5470,6557,7075,7222,7302],"each":[102,2691],"sequences":[105],"which":[107,506,1350,1371,1502,2109,2134,3036,3514,4264,4645,4673,4833,4887,5127,5163,5613,5997,6129,6517,6600],"it":[108,161,266,283,355,421,507,567,592,600,625,629,636,694,781,820,822,1242,1344,1464,1530,1628,1672,1690,1773,2097,2110,2126,2159,2233,2327,2544,2577,2724,3086,3107,3381,3399,3422,3455,3463,3483,3524,3567,3729,3750,3755,3765,3794,3885,4124,4355,4513,4606,4693,4888,4967,4995,5107,5115,5128,5164,5189,5276,5278,5320,5481,5699,5715,5859,5869,5998,6130,6135,6145,6183,6185,6226,6304,6308,6317,6372,6384,6390,6685,6711,7040,7089,7110,7293,7484],"is":[109,111,121,165,203,257,267,284,290,336,350,434,488,518,551,586,616,646,660,683,748,782,821,869,961,1016,1036,1088,1101,1127,1135,1205,1228,1234,1240,1243,1254,1274,1328,1377,1406,1415,1466,1555,1607,1616,1644,1673,1691,1755,1759,1770,1807,1952,1976,2080,2111,2127,2149,2176,2231,2234,2328,2343,2359,2453,2465,2516,2523,2559,2614,2631,2725,2759,2814,2825,2918,2950,2975,3129,3142,3198,3222,3314,3344,3350,3440,3632,3667,3727,3730,3738,3741,3766,3785,3849,3863,3906,3943,3966,4014,4022,4188,4200,4250,4287,4307,4323,4353,4376,4471,4486,4492,4497,4533,4648,4658,4711,4781,4889,4927,4959,4968,5104,5121,5192,5263,5271,5335,5383,5487,5507,5664,5676,5691,5739,5754,5860,5865,5887,5920,5934,6061,6079,6131,6164,6176,6186,6227,6305,6318,6402,6419,6433,6506,6686,6708,6712,6735,6895,6998,7030,7093,7187,7192,7198,7209,7220,7245,7438,7452,7485,7534],"composed,":[110],"thus,":[112],"in":[113,154,181,249,302,331,346,391,416,431,458,516,564,582,619,638,657,701,710,723,727,761,814,860,880,888,913,928,957,979,1024,1049,1070,1078,1108,1191,1197,1219,1225,1250,1272,1330,1343,1349,1351,1363,1370,1389,1459,1496,1501,1503,1512,1543,1550,1560,1635,1660,1761,1804,1817,1886,1912,1955,1965,1981,1988,1995,2006,2019,2093,2167,2178,2187,2219,2222,2264,2272,2390,2437,2472,2493,2550,2593,2600,2606,2627,2717,2856,2889,2933,2959,2978,2985,2990,3002,3024,3054,3106,3136,3210,3228,3319,3330,3347,3417,3442,3497,3513,3543,3629,3684,3705,3749,3846,3857,3877,3895,3922,3947,3972,4025,4071,4093,4110,4117,4178,4246,4263,4336,4398,4432,4439,4592,4690,4804,4852,4876,5014,5072,5101,5162,5343,5391,5423,5463,5528,5542,5595,5601,5612,5684,5732,5751,5777,5822,5855,5962,5975,6020,6064,6111,6138,6165,6193,6331,6552,6575,6599,6621,6636,6726,6764,6918,6975,7006,7032,7043,7076,7190,7299,7334,7365,7373,7423,7488,7505,7546,7562],"origin,":[114,4151],"representation":[116,124,144,191,194,345,430,1047,1271,1405,1710,1724,1746,1857,1938,2207,2365,2492,2521,2531,2571,2965,3057,3212,3388,4632,5012,5408],"It":[120,469,687,1087,1100,1253,1758,2288,2464,2619,3141,3221,4249,4668,4710,6866,7244],"set":[127,6574],"events,":[129,137,3836],"filmed,":[132,202,921,4635,4798,5525,5931,6009],"represent":[135,209,1704,3720],"other":[136,467,639,1297,1544,1737,1862,2980,3420,3574,3657,3771,3892,4126,4179,4427,4433,4604,4621,5093,5365,5941,6239,6442,6581,7233],"told.":[140,925,1075,1231,1830,2174,2227,2969,3299,3392,3723,3853,5673,5723,5759,5815,6503],"latter":[143,1860,2758,2917,4035],"clearly":[145,1236,2983,4534,6243],"bears":[146],"strong":[147,2142],"points":[148,1729,2740],"contact":[150,5346],"found":[153,4154,5142,5150],"theater,":[155,4130],"we":[156,405,424,514,530,653,674,725,735,878,886,934,953,975,984,994,1007,1030,1067,1248,1259,1345,1353,1359,1366,1372,1387,1471,1494,1505,1519,1577,1585,1600,1620,1658,1802,1815,1922,2071,2087,2217,2340,2377,2397,2404,2426,2431,2456,2468,3178,3191,3194,3241,3250,3368,3536,3564,3578,3596,3608,3624,3627,3675,3707,3804,3807,3844,3855,3870,3881,3900,3932,3968,3977,4100,4139,4369,4379,4386,4402,4767,5337,5460,5526,5560,5590,5630,5666,5682,5708,5728,5749,5763,5807,5828,5924,5945,6094,6266,6290,6320,6369,6380,6421,6488,6772,6784,6828,6847,7362,7378,7405,7409,7454,7503,7514,7522],"may":[157,1520,2988,2996,3101,4008,6278,6877,6897,6916,6971,7202],"as":[158,325,383,528,535,811,997,1462,1538,1567,1590,1593,1655,1718,1766,2041,2045,2362,2647,2722,2937,3028,3095,3201,3258,3273,3415,4103,4112,4114,4129,4237,4326,4328,4527,4748,4923,4930,4979,5237,5252,5340,5518,5640,5648,5767,5792,5905,5911,6104,6294,6328,6360,6450,6635,6719,7262,7290,7475,7510,7548,7553,7559],"well":[159,553,4327],"call":[160,178,5818],"theatrical":[162,344,411,429,580,1270,1709,1784,2491,2885,2931,3056,3233,3387,3590,4520,4625,4761,5011,7170],"(That":[164],"not":[166,268,329,1041,1189,1565,1587,1617,1651,1666,1680,1702,2004,2033,2099,2279,2290,2454,2470,2497,2532,2560,2591,2632,2705,2726,2833,2853,2919,3102,3143,3152,3187,3246,3359,3406,3428,3457,3589,3668,3677,3732,3789,3838,4039,4153,4288,4377,4487,4493,4755,4772,4782,5029,5040,5109,5149,5441,5730,5847,5969,6004,6025,6161,6187,6201,6231,6244,6376,6394,6423,6673,6687,6819,6950,7094,7310,7456,7558],"assume":[168],"there":[170,642,645,1126,1204,3439,4021,4301,4343,4958,5191,5257,5270,5864,6505,6508,6545,6601,6734,6745,7186,7208],"aren't":[171],"important":[172,457,1089,4010,4708],"differences":[173,4011,4304,4330],"between":[174,460,1055,2418,2665,4012,4305,4331],"two.)":[176],"Let's":[177,1831,4275],"movies":[179,464,3193,3571],"this":[182,279,432,445,489,563,778,786,958,1025,1082,1150,1171,1256,1401,1477,1840,1914,2265,2558,2824,3066,3128,3139,3479,3506,3726,3801,3904,3928,4074,4115,4198,4651,4700,5199,5505,5632,5836,5936,6021,6087,6171,6525,6679,6751,6997,7029,7325],"two\u2010tier":[184,348,461,583,1157,1183,1743,2494,3229,3334,3348,3555,3875,3902,4031,4310,4374,4417,4462,4656,4719,4740,4757,4821,4842,5033,5513,5752,5805,5908,6174,6250,7054,7144,7407],"films.":[185,264,3553,5034,5514],"Second,":[186,2267,4489],"lower":[188,3226],"tier":[189,3227,4518],"here,":[192,7206],"told":[198,212,1750,3216,4793],"often":[204,285,379,1021,1756],"illusionistic.":[205,1275,1757,1771,2101,2525,2948,3163],"The":[206,929,1034,1053,1238,1553,1849,1944,2199,2391,2451,2526,2994,4321,4348,4727,4844,4872,5018,5079,5131,5218,5484,5500,5606,6296,6396,6417,6431,6569,6753,7056,7082,7425,7440,7463],"filmed":[208,226,333,1063,1754,2678,2736,2908,2955,3100,3292,3717,5575,5593,5983],"presenting":[214],"appearance":[216],"latter.":[219],"More":[220,882],"precisely,":[221],"someone":[222,2732,2751,2873,7123],"watching":[223,826,3603,4795,5602,5804,6870,6894],"from":[227,1170,1424,2737,2819,2946,3570,3680,3887,4506,4752,5248,5605,5620,6309,6516,6723,7271,7397,7542],"point":[229,1257,3166,4199,5486,6455,6513],"view":[231,2742,3901,5900,6457,6515,7406],"camera":[234,2746,6548,6631,6852],"would":[235,244,543,1167,1188,1212,1223,1578,2072,2098,2747,2887,3078,3087,3116,3179,3485,3493,3565,3882,3991,4004,4231,4403,4415,4428,4453,4785,5374,5837,5957,6001,6018,6056,6146,6234,6381,6563,6625,6801,6944,7417,7431],"have":[236,245,356,986,1009,1579,1843,2073,2676,2707,3151,3167,3180,3185,3451,3981,4159,4455,4750,4786,5377,5532,5631,5667,5679,5709,5809,5830,5925,5947,6147,6202,6267,6270,6424,6529,6773,6785,7280],"visual":[237,685,1430],"auditory":[239],"experiences":[240,375,1431,2067,3983],"matching":[241,1432],"she":[243,1962,2002,4265],"before":[246,742,807,852,917,982,1580,1821,2074,2360,2396,2915,3181,3199,3256,3282,3322,5031,6578,6769,7143],"themselves.":[252,2061,3799],"Perhaps":[253,3616,4300],"illusion,":[254,2499,3204,6255],"defined,":[256],"more":[258,1112,1826,3396,4081,4561,4867,5272,5741,6150,6297,6315,6477,7063],"aspiration":[259,289],"than":[260,1113,1723,1827,3397,3421,4562,4868,4978,5405,6341],"reality":[261,5448,5881],"for":[262,357,366,397,474,697,754,949,1279,1309,1442,1528,1626,1732,1736,2053,2108,2260,2311,2486,3007,3239,3424,3453,3619,3695,3960,4084,4162,4220,4469,4555,4729,4775,4877,4973,5003,5045,5178,5293,5454,5491,5599,6047,6668,6682,6699,6748,6874,7349,7384],"Certainly":[265],"always":[269,618,1031,2471,3195,4436],"even":[270,2706,2914,2952,4133,4202,4818,6148],"aspiration:":[271],"refuse":[274,6256],"attempt":[276],"illusion":[277,581,2180,2797,3053,3071,3135,3236,3276,3328,3394,3441,3449,4770,4788,4994,5004,6775],"level.":[280],"But":[281,401,734,992,1533,1639,1727,2557,2849,3393,3819,4105,4560,4817,5322,5943,6388,6411,6855,6995,7128,7292,7493],"an":[288,545,1473,2551,2963,4163,4707,5073,5362,5839,6143,6346,6732,6973,6999],"only":[292,491,675,1979,2191,2270,2399,2533,2562,3072,3315,3558,4120,4296,4419,4437,4499,4947,5116,5134,5717,6189,7121,7132],"make":[295,1263,2378,3067,3552,7264],"sense":[296,729,988,1765,4095,6905],"tremendous":[299],"care":[300],"taken,":[301],"much":[303,1269,2042,4718,5053,5065,6978],"making,":[305,3377,3445,7116],"get":[307,1834,6913,6967],"sets":[309,4847],"costumes":[311],"right,":[312,3916],"convincingly,":[315],"ensure":[318],"items":[320],"studio":[322,2987],"equipment,":[323],"such":[324,999,1001,2036,2721,2934,4128,4525,5251,5866,6103,6449,6560,6609,6706,7101,7161,7259,7385],"sound":[326,4938],"booms,":[327],"visible":[330,2379,2984,4949,5013],"scene.":[334,4955,5801,6523],"What":[335,352,612,659,1814,3854,4779],"significance":[338,492,4576,5047,5180],"fact":[341,565,1267,2200,2220,2473,3841,4088,4629,4715,5063,5842,5976,6815,7335],"illusionistic?":[351,1417],"consequences":[353,3238,3452],"does":[354,1040,1679,2278,2289,2864,3326,3405,3450,3456,3837,4725,5039,5066,5108,5129,5165,5216,6076,6200,6389,6650,6672,6856,7136],"our":[358,672,898,964,1038,1095,1156,1164,1331,1485,1534,1570,1786,2165,2261,2347,2428,3171,3309,3361,3403,3948,4450,4572,4660,5266,5394,5509,5562,5569,5916,6263,6756,6839,6857,7157,7178,7337,7366],"experience":[359,380,447,495,504,533,899,1039,1081,1097,1195,1247,1332,1434,1486,1571,1576,1588,1787,2730,3172,3196,3242,3310,3332,3362,3404,3460,3537,3566,3670,3884,3933,3969,4101,4145,4215,4372,4447,4502,4654,5231,5245,5267,5281,5338,5461,5511,5534,5591,5634,5669,5712,5798,5811,5820,5833,5854,5917,5927,6075,6199,6273,6288,6337,6440,6494,6531,6649,6693,6758,6787,6806,6836,6840,6858,6955,7008,7052,7067,7107,7130,7338,7352,7371,7416,7481,7507],"cinema,":[361,1165,3137,7369],"what,":[363],"if":[364,756,872,1411,1463,2086,2300,2568,2587,3482,4138,4368,4794,5028,5052,5704,5863,5944,6364,6629,6684,7028,7134,7194,7449,7470,7521],"any,":[365],"aesthetics":[368,4540,4546,5074],"film?":[370,3335],"Section":[371,440,7391,7443],"I":[372,403,558,757,765,798,829,854,3150,3168,3184,3264,3473,3509,3527,4193,4223,4749,5207,5678,6392,6480,6538,6876,6892,6931,6948,6970,7002,7355],"describes":[373],"film.":[377,584,1052,1099,2859,3783,4411,4543,5017,6843,7354],"We":[378,911,1020,1336,1541,1631,2355,2415,3284,3300,3410,3688,3701,3908,4076,4157,5244,5456,5538,5816,5956,6017,7153,7550],"reflect":[385,4686,5445],"how":[386,1182,2350,2406,2425,3240,3432,3577,3995,5187,5573,6739,6960,6989,7078,7160],"they":[387,521,1583,1711,2076,2836,3111,3261,3867,3997,4027,4341,4680,4864,4976,4982,6045,6214,6618,6817,7165,7175],"were":[388,2088,3871,3978,6633,6818,6935,6993,7163,7309],"made,":[389,1186],"seeing":[390,699,721,1436,1994,2094,2166,2262,2879,3317,3681,4790,5516,6367,6724,6777,7197,7543],"them":[392,534,1196,1573,1589,2945,3318,3599,3769,4102,4972,5517,7018,7265,7552],"actors":[393,2700,3038,4963],"standing":[396],"characters":[398,2703,4981],"events.":[400,541,2387,3183,4813,5537,6642],"sometimes,":[402,512],"argue,":[404],"cease":[406,6322],"be":[408,426,544,575,632,767,1190,1490,1521,1653,1824,2100,2295,2574,2585,2604,2651,2715,3018,3059,3079,3088,3103,3487,3494,3517,3559,3710,3810,3824,3831,3929,3992,4005,4009,4069,4276,4404,4588,4838,4849,4921,5021,5026,5141,5171,5184,5430,5473,5718,5784,5838,5904,6204,6279,6284,6339,6386,6540,6564,6626,6945,7041,7060,7119,7203,7285,7329,7433,7497],"aware":[409,730,738,768,800,817,831,841,2089],"representations,":[412,1785,2125,2831,3591],"simply":[414,1068,1546,1808,3850,6321,6482,6878,7004],"see":[415,515,654,758,855,879,887,912,935,955,976,995,1022,1069,1107,1215,1224,1337,1346,1354,1367,1373,1388,1495,1506,1524,1547,1622,1633,1659,1803,1816,1954,1964,1978,1986,2005,2018,2035,2114,2221,2280,2308,2331,2405,2484,2547,2888,3253,3271,3287,3412,3579,3598,3610,3621,3628,3748,3768,3808,3845,3856,3874,4971,5310,5317,5683,5731,5750,5764,6291,6324,7298,7551],"movie":[418,3434,4807],"tells.":[422],"That":[423,542,662,952,2175,3077,3235,4003,4181,4856,6888],"can":[425,985,1008,1923,2416,2603,4586,4991,5457,5716,5817,6095,6283,6338,6829,7003,7059,7118,7240],"blind":[427,3370],"thanks":[435],"its":[437,450,711,909,1872,1876,1881,1895,1900,1906,1917,2535,4229,5348,6342,6942,7450],"illusionistic":[438,1478,1557,1603,1648,1686,1783,2103,2128,2153,2206,2527,2964,4742,4760],"nature.":[439],"II":[441],"then":[442,3703,4158,4454,4957,5794,5951,5958,6002,6713,7432,7477],"explains":[443],"why":[444,4703,7038],"second":[446,494,1402,6432,7057],"matters.":[448],"Acknowledging":[449],"existence":[451],"allows":[452],"us":[453,918,1822,2318,2361,2482,3200,3257,3746,3963,3999,4295,4480,4515,4617,4684,5342,5451,6058,6086,6170,6259,6496,6722,6803,6862,7071,7278,7296,7327,7419,7541],"recognize":[455],"something":[456,793,1392,1396,1634,2920,3669,4024,4067,5085,5954,6097],"common":[459,476,4026,4108,4146,4182,4214,5086],"means.":[468,3575,3893],"thereby":[470],"provides":[471,568],"foundation":[473,4161],"(though":[477],"partial)":[478],"aesthetic":[479,4164,4210,4451,5095,5099,5284,5475],"whatever":[482,819,1581,1671,1809,2075,5275,5489,5963,5980,7088,7483],"means":[484,2302,2322,4600,4671,4831],"production.":[486],"Nor":[487,6248],"enjoys.":[496],"Sections":[497,3469],"III":[498,3470,7444],"IV":[500,1301],"describe":[501],"further":[503,2237,3522,5228],"opens":[508,2669,3500,5661],"door.":[510],"If,":[511,3894],"all":[513,1133,1218,3084,3090,3337,3919,4090,4474,4756,4987,5088,5112,5992,6162,6232,6277,6996,7023],"stories":[520,3866,6110,6155,6573,6598,6615],"tell,":[522],"then,":[523,3325,5703],"since":[524,1640,1647,4389,6710],"seen":[527,1458,1559,1566,3001,3012,3560,4438,4589,7120],"photographs,":[529,5269,6102],"might":[531,1260,1536,2620,2650,2675,3017,3516,3689,3702,3927,4216,4361,4837,4848,4861,4874,4920,5067,5140,5222,5482,5783,6219,6370,6489,7410],"also":[532,737,840,2542,4345,5215,6228,7294],"records":[537],"narrated":[540,6641],"aesthetically":[546,4041,4500,5137,5840,6090,6445],"striking":[547],"phenomenon":[548,3523],"uniquely":[552],"placed":[554,6083,7498],"support.":[556],"Although":[557,5256,5845,6173],"am":[559,799,830,6393,6893],"cautious":[560],"whether":[562,1241,3465,4783,4800],"occurs,":[566,6368],"another":[569,1347,1499,5659],"possible":[570,3476,6485,7246],"consequence,":[571],"promising":[573],"considerable":[577],"importance,":[578],"Cinema":[585,1678],"pictorial":[588,1326,3593,6890],"art.":[589],"Whatever":[590,5583],"else":[591],"(sound,":[594],"narrative":[595,6117],"structures,":[596],"like),":[599],"pictures.":[602,1298,1568,2048,3202,3615,4248],"More,":[603],"pictures":[605,651,724,873,916,1295,1419,1649,2050,3260,3648,3683,4262,5234,5250,5734,6327,7276,7545,7560],"fundamental":[607,4408],"what":[609,624,628,635,650,876,884,1013,1166,1410,1529,1627,1657,1801,1855,2079,2236,2315,2358,2794,2835,3197,3706,3806,3843,4013,4189,4208,4306,4358,4461,4470,4679,4801,5120,5262,5382,5420,5479,5681,5748,5851,6060,6909,7191,7227,7332],"cinema":[610,868,1277,1777,1819,2148,2616,3160,3272,4758,4990,5076,5919,5952,6055,6078,6175],"represents.":[611,823,1677,5321],"represents":[615,637,1395,1888,2929],"almost":[617,4435],"part":[620,4582,6920],"matter":[622,1137,1853,2635,3464,6898],"depicts,":[626],"depicts":[630,1311,1453],"cannot":[631,2305],"reduced":[633],"ways.":[640,3975],"Where":[641,5674,6504],"pictures,":[644,1558,1591,1604,1656,3306,7554],"seeing\u2010in.":[647,1383,1741,1931,2183,2198,2463,3064,4424,4559,5050,5243,6261,7424,7462,7519],"In":[648,1384,1398,1742,2374,2696,2719,2792,3047,3083,3468,3505,3602,3800,4650,4763,4986,5201,5515,5803,6053,6473,6555,6780,6795,6844,6869],"grasping":[649],"depict,":[652,1584],"things":[656,700,722,2638,3965,5366,5996,6361,6413],"them.":[658,706,1220,2309,3951,5901],"seeing\u2010in?":[661,1086,1492],"question":[663,1092,1239,7547],"has":[664,688,2140,2578,2900,3237,4633,5796,7229,7445,7479],"generated":[665,3740,6312],"good":[667,6900],"deal":[668,6901],"debate.1":[670],"For":[671,926,2388,2661,2756,3336,4581,6197,6330],"purposes,":[673],"need":[676,2341,2496,2704,3058,3427,4078,6949,6953,7455],"following,":[678],"relatively":[679],"uncontroversial,":[680],"claims.":[681],"Seeing\u2010in":[682,1797],"experience.":[686,2476,5387,5826,6092,6172,6224,6430],"distinctive":[690,5283,5384,5465,5895,6088,7565],"phenomenology,":[691],"setting":[693],"apart":[695],"from,":[696],"instance,":[698,755,927,1310,1443,1480,2389,2662,3961,5294,5600,6875],"flesh,":[703,1562,3004],"visualizing":[705],"Its":[707,1891],"distinctiveness":[708],"lies":[709,3209],"simultaneous":[713],"awareness":[714,747,6347],"kinds":[717,3921],"thing.":[719],"When":[720,1772,3365],"things.":[733,4299],"surface":[741],"us.":[743,3323],"Indeed,":[744,2310],"first":[746,5501,6418],"dependent":[749],"on":[750,864,938,1515,1927,2058,2164,2196,2424,2846,3138,3158,3994,4212,4479,4687,5398,5625,5850,6738,6750,6880,6921,6961,7019,7182,7357,7499],"second.":[752]},"counts_by_year":[{"year":2025,"cited_by_count":5},{"year":2024,"cited_by_count":2},{"year":2022,"cited_by_count":1},{"year":2021,"cited_by_count":3},{"year":2020,"cited_by_count":3},{"year":2019,"cited_by_count":5},{"year":2018,"cited_by_count":1},{"year":2017,"cited_by_count":4},{"year":2016,"cited_by_count":2},{"year":2015,"cited_by_count":2},{"year":2014,"cited_by_count":1}],"updated_date":"2026-10-16T09:59:22.235173","created_date":"2016-06-24T00:00:00"}