{"id":"https://openalex.org/W2020774116","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1097/ede.0b013e3182126127","title":"Compound Treatments, Transportability, and the Structural Causal Model","display_name":"Compound Treatments, Transportability, and the Structural Causal Model","alternate_titles":[],"publication_year":2011,"publication_date":"2011-04-02","ids":{"openalex":"https://openalex.org/W2020774116","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1097/ede.0b013e3182126127","mag":"2020774116","pmid":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21464653"},"language":"en","primary_location":{"id":"doi:10.1097/ede.0b013e3182126127","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1097/ede.0b013e3182126127","is_oa":false,"landing_page_url":"https://doi.org/10.1097/ede.0b013e3182126127","pdf_url":null,"source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S15470582","display_name":"Epidemiology","issn_l":"1044-3983","issn":["1044-3983","1531-5487"],"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":true,"listed_in":["anvur-scientific","cwts-core","dongbi-b","doyens","jufo-3","ki-jl-2","medline","norway-2","poland-140","russia-white-list-1","vabb-shw"],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/P4310315671","host_organization_name":"Lippincott Williams & Wilkins","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/P4310315671","https://openalex.org/P4310318547"],"host_organization_lineage_names":["Lippincott Williams & Wilkins","Wolters Kluwer"],"type":"journal"},"license":null,"license_id":null,"version":"publishedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":true,"raw_source_name":"Epidemiology","raw_type":"journal-article"},"parent_works":[],"lineage":["https://openalex.org/W2020774116"],"child_works_count":0,"type":"editorial","is_traditional":true,"indexed_in":["crossref","pubmed"],"open_access":{"is_oa":false,"oa_status":"closed","oa_url":null,"any_repository_has_fulltext":false},"authorships":[{"author_position":"first","author":{"id":"https://openalex.org/A5088136001","display_name":"Maya L Petersen","orcid":"https://orcid.org/0000-0003-4941-2041","observed_orcids":["https://orcid.org/0000-0003-4941-2041"]},"institutions":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/I95457486","display_name":"University of California, Berkeley","ror":"https://ror.org/01an7q238","country_code":"US","type":"education","lineage":["https://openalex.org/I95457486"]}],"countries":["US"],"is_corresponding":true,"contributor_roles":[],"raw_author_name":"Maya L. Petersen","raw_affiliation_strings":["Maya Petersen, University of California, Berkeley, 101 Haviland Hall, Berkeley, CA 94720\u20137358. E-mail: [email\u00a0protected]","the Divisions of Biostatistics and Epidemiology, School of Public Health, University of California, Berkeley, CA"],"raw_orcid":null,"affiliations":[{"raw_affiliation_string":"Maya Petersen, University of California, Berkeley, 101 Haviland Hall, Berkeley, CA 94720\u20137358. E-mail: [email\u00a0protected]","institution_ids":["https://openalex.org/I95457486"]},{"raw_affiliation_string":"the Divisions of Biostatistics and Epidemiology, School of Public Health, University of California, Berkeley, CA","institution_ids":["https://openalex.org/I95457486"]}]}],"institutions":[],"countries_distinct_count":1,"institutions_distinct_count":1,"corresponding_author_ids":["https://openalex.org/A5088136001"],"corresponding_institution_ids":["https://openalex.org/I95457486"],"apc_list":null,"apc_paid":null,"fwci":null,"has_fulltext":false,"cited_by_count":52,"citation_normalized_percentile":null,"cited_by_percentile_year":null,"biblio":{"volume":"22","issue":"3","first_page":"378","last_page":"381"},"is_retracted":false,"is_pulled":false,"is_paratext":false,"is_xpac":false,"primary_topic":{"id":"https://openalex.org/T10845","display_name":"Advanced Causal Inference Techniques","score":0.9984999895095825,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/2613","display_name":"Statistics and Probability"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/26","display_name":"Mathematics"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/3","display_name":"Physical Sciences"}},"topics":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/T10845","display_name":"Advanced Causal Inference Techniques","score":0.9984999895095825,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/2613","display_name":"Statistics and Probability"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/26","display_name":"Mathematics"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/3","display_name":"Physical Sciences"}},{"id":"https://openalex.org/T11303","display_name":"Bayesian Modeling and Causal Inference","score":0.0007999999797903001,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1702","display_name":"Artificial Intelligence"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/17","display_name":"Computer Science"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/3","display_name":"Physical Sciences"}},{"id":"https://openalex.org/T10778","display_name":"Philosophy of Biology and Scientific Explanation","score":9.999999747378752e-05,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1207","display_name":"History and Philosophy of Science"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/12","display_name":"Arts and Humanities"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}}],"keywords":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/transportability","display_name":"transportability","score":0.9710000157356262},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/structural-causal-models","display_name":"structural causal models","score":0.8730000257492065},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/directed-acyclic-graphs","display_name":"directed acyclic graphs","score":0.8510000109672546},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/counterfactuals","display_name":"counterfactuals","score":0.8560000061988831},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/consistency-assumption","display_name":"consistency assumption","score":0.9700000286102295},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/causal-identification","display_name":"causal identification","score":0.4169999957084656},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/obesity-prevention","display_name":"obesity prevention","score":0.34599998593330383},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/causal-inference","display_name":"causal inference","score":0.3319999873638153},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/target-population","display_name":"target population","score":0.40799999237060547},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/policy-decision-making","display_name":"policy decision-making","score":0.41999998688697815}],"concepts":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/C11671645","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q5054567","display_name":"Causal model","level":2,"score":0.3353330194950104},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C71924100","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q11190","display_name":"Medicine","level":0,"score":0.21851575374603271},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C142724271","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q7208","display_name":"Pathology","level":1,"score":0.039454370737075806}],"mesh":[{"descriptor_ui":"D003131","descriptor_name":"Combined Modality Therapy","qualifier_ui":null,"qualifier_name":null,"is_major_topic":false},{"descriptor_ui":"D003657","descriptor_name":"Decision Making","qualifier_ui":null,"qualifier_name":null,"is_major_topic":false},{"descriptor_ui":"D005260","descriptor_name":"Female","qualifier_ui":null,"qualifier_name":null,"is_major_topic":false},{"descriptor_ui":"D006801","descriptor_name":"Humans","qualifier_ui":null,"qualifier_name":null,"is_major_topic":false},{"descriptor_ui":"D008297","descriptor_name":"Male","qualifier_ui":null,"qualifier_name":null,"is_major_topic":false},{"descriptor_ui":"D012680","descriptor_name":"Sensitivity and Specificity","qualifier_ui":null,"qualifier_name":null,"is_major_topic":false},{"descriptor_ui":"D015233","descriptor_name":"Models, Statistical","qualifier_ui":null,"qualifier_name":null,"is_major_topic":true},{"descriptor_ui":"D015340","descriptor_name":"Epidemiologic Research Design","qualifier_ui":null,"qualifier_name":null,"is_major_topic":false},{"descriptor_ui":"D015983","descriptor_name":"Selection Bias","qualifier_ui":null,"qualifier_name":null,"is_major_topic":false},{"descriptor_ui":"D015984","descriptor_name":"Causality","qualifier_ui":null,"qualifier_name":null,"is_major_topic":true},{"descriptor_ui":"D016021","descriptor_name":"Epidemiologic Studies","qualifier_ui":null,"qualifier_name":null,"is_major_topic":true},{"descriptor_ui":"D016032","descriptor_name":"Randomized Controlled Trials as Topic","qualifier_ui":null,"qualifier_name":null,"is_major_topic":false},{"descriptor_ui":"D018579","descriptor_name":"Patient Selection","qualifier_ui":null,"qualifier_name":null,"is_major_topic":false},{"descriptor_ui":"D019370","descriptor_name":"Observation","qualifier_ui":null,"qualifier_name":null,"is_major_topic":false}],"locations_count":3,"locations":[{"id":"doi:10.1097/ede.0b013e3182126127","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1097/ede.0b013e3182126127","is_oa":false,"landing_page_url":"https://doi.org/10.1097/ede.0b013e3182126127","pdf_url":null,"source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S15470582","display_name":"Epidemiology","issn_l":"1044-3983","issn":["1044-3983","1531-5487"],"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":true,"listed_in":["anvur-scientific","cwts-core","dongbi-b","doyens","jufo-3","ki-jl-2","medline","norway-2","poland-140","russia-white-list-1","vabb-shw"],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/P4310315671","host_organization_name":"Lippincott Williams & Wilkins","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/P4310315671","https://openalex.org/P4310318547"],"host_organization_lineage_names":["Lippincott Williams & Wilkins","Wolters Kluwer"],"type":"journal"},"license":null,"license_id":null,"version":"publishedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":true,"raw_source_name":"Epidemiology","raw_type":"journal-article"},{"id":"pmid:21464653","doi":null,"is_oa":false,"landing_page_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21464653","pdf_url":null,"source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S4306525036","display_name":"PubMed","issn_l":null,"issn":null,"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":false,"listed_in":[],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/I1299303238","host_organization_name":"National Institutes of Health","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/I1299303238"],"host_organization_lineage_names":[],"type":"repository"},"license":null,"license_id":null,"version":"publishedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":true,"raw_source_name":"Epidemiology (Cambridge, Mass.)","raw_type":"Comment"},{"id":"pmh:oai:CiteSeerX.psu:10.1.1.845.8005","doi":null,"is_oa":false,"landing_page_url":"http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/summary?doi=10.1.1.845.8005","pdf_url":null,"source":null,"license":null,"license_id":null,"version":"submittedVersion","is_accepted":false,"is_published":false,"raw_source_name":"http://works.bepress.com/maya_petersen/52/download/","raw_type":"text"}],"best_oa_location":null,"sustainable_development_goals":[{"score":0.7246000170707703,"id":"https://metadata.un.org/sdg/3","display_name":"Good health and well-being"}],"study_designs":[],"awards":[],"funders":[],"has_content":{"grobid_xml":false,"pdf":false},"content_urls":null,"referenced_works_count":8,"referenced_works":["https://openalex.org/W1537314526","https://openalex.org/W2056150680","https://openalex.org/W2062148796","https://openalex.org/W2107091653","https://openalex.org/W2143891888","https://openalex.org/W2169315100","https://openalex.org/W2496321160","https://openalex.org/W2521248647"],"related_works":["https://openalex.org/W2062148796","https://openalex.org/W1560639879","https://openalex.org/W2741663316","https://openalex.org/W6959879080","https://openalex.org/W2332230965","https://openalex.org/W2971344044","https://openalex.org/W3011393599","https://openalex.org/W2107091653","https://openalex.org/W7097900753"],"abstract_inverted_index":{"In":[0,86,156,1069,1095,1488,1643,1830,1859,1922],"\u201cCompound":[1],"treatments":[2,43,62,646,798,912,977],"and":[3,14,71,77,128,130,148,266,275,451,635,716,785,835,923,974,1048,1057,1099,1135,1193,1336,1347,1386,1409,1633,1658,1708,1745,1856,2003,2132,2178,2187,2215,2226,2241,2248,2275,2288,2304,2312,2332,2386,2408,2414,2428,2442],"transportability":[4,766,1747,1931,2211],"of":[5,11,39,73,81,103,124,132,154,174,218,228,235,261,329,348,350,356,359,366,372,380,392,408,420,426,436,465,475,540,583,631,643,670,699,710,719,726,731,751,754,767,793,805,810,817,867,892,910,937,946,967,990,996,1038,1060,1078,1084,1087,1101,1108,1123,1128,1166,1182,1295,1352,1407,1432,1435,1464,1484,1530,1601,1614,1687,1728,1802,1848,1877,1886,1944,1987,2020,2023,2035,2038,2053,2089,2097,2130,2135,2149,2152,2167,2197,2217,2256,2263,2329,2354,2364,2372,2384,2391,2395,2404,2416,2422],"causal":[6,19,26,105,109,126,143,152,158,180,204,320,343,398,617,655,741,795,843,846,859,870,907,1269,1325,1353,1419,1537,1570,1979,2121,2145,2192,2236,2242,2280,2365,2405],"inference\u201d":[7],"in":[8,65,197,206,238,314,345,369,389,400,405,423,467,576,610,905,987,1285,1299,1312,1358,1376,1517,1524,1567,1592,1611,1691,1732,1808,1814,1902,1981,2068,2078,2080,2106,2157,2170,2180,2194,2271,2315],"this":[9,87,160,688,896,928,997,1109,1304,1356,1359,1791,1831,1971,1996,2074,2119,2144,2373],"issue":[10,38],"Epidemiology,":[12],"Hern\u00e1n":[13],"VanderWeele":[15],"(H&V)1":[16],"argue":[17],"that":[18,28,290,496,506,510,536,543,572,594,607,619,665,768,789,815,823,893,940,947,953,1133,1149,1158,1187,1218,1458,1480,1527,1597,1625,1906,1956,1977,2071,2083,2142,2203,2296],"analyses":[20,82],"often":[21],"fail":[22],"to":[23,55,185,245,298,310,332,383,443,448,455,482,485,499,552,567,600,802,825,851,875,926,1026,1034,1055,1178,1222,1248,1252,1372,1397,1428,1439,1496,1506,1586,1645,1679,1698,1724,1764,1776,1796,1819,1840,1915,1968,2008,2065,2123,2163,2235,2285,2323,2344,2411,2425],"specify":[24,1145,1373],"a":[25,165,172,232,262,434,473,616,652,774,782,868,899,920,1018,1042,1066,1146,1175,1216,1266,1281,1296,1300,1329,1416,1440,1477,1492,1551,1647,1665,1688,1765,1927,2011,2090,2168,2206,2230,2330,2345],"question":[27,871,1305,1740,1754,2259],"adequately":[29],"addresses":[30],"the":[31,37,69,74,79,92,104,125,151,198,203,215,226,236,259,293,299,302,305,311,315,357,468,500,508,511,519,538,580,587,591,601,605,608,624,629,640,663,667,678,694,717,728,740,752,791,803,808,857,863,873,887,957,988,1036,1046,1063,1085,1092,1121,1138,1142,1152,1163,1169,1180,1286,1293,1310,1314,1320,1350,1374,1378,1384,1390,1395,1422,1433,1445,1450,1459,1473,1489,1518,1525,1536,1557,1568,1573,1580,1587,1593,1602,1606,1612,1626,1640,1656,1661,1675,1692,1712,1721,1729,1733,1781,1799,1803,1806,1809,1821,1851,1857,1867,1875,1878,1883,1888,1907,1916,1938,1942,1964,1978,1985,2021,2036,2051,2058,2069,2081,2095,2107,2128,2138,2150,2158,2165,2171,2181,2254,2293,2301,2326,2352,2361,2389,2402],"motivating":[32],"policy":[33,84,834,1153,1217,1298,2169],"issue.":[34],"H&V":[35,51,96,211,324,787,933,1012,1277,2117,2278,2308],"highlight":[36],"\u201ccompound":[40],"treatments,\u201d":[41],"or":[42,107,115,194,308,488,565,736,746,762,807,915,1032,1053,1702,1896,2093,2103],"with":[44,647,662,721,1718,1892,2092],"multiple":[45,648,958,2327],"versions.":[46,516],"An":[47,1756],"example":[48,1391,1954],"used":[49,184],"by":[50,95,189,231,336,433,472,531,615,623,693,1202,1242,1245,1262,1461,1560,1628,2205],"is":[52,162,223,241,286,352,549,620,676,714,723,828,897,903,1030,1051,1074,1080,1238,1404,1457,1466,1555,1562,1578,1583,1793,1805,1934,1973,2001,2006,2025,2040,2047,2112,2250,2260,2268,2320,2380],"an":[53,271,282,287,337,441,480,502,533,1183,1203,1211,1246,1430,1514,1540,1685,1726,1817,2198,2336,2381],"intervention":[54,338,442,481,512,520,1148,1167,1204,1212,1247,1818],"prevent":[56],"obesity.":[57],"They":[58,812],"discuss":[59],"how":[60,91,390,406,1709,1941],"compound":[61,263,797,914,1019,2207],"can":[63,97,182,526,545,558,955,1004,1015,1289,1369,1532,1715,1760,1835,1863,2016,2061,2335],"result":[64,1792,2077],"ill-defined":[66],"counterfactuals,":[67],"complicate":[68],"articulation":[70,804],"evaluation":[72,131,816,2430],"consistency":[75,630,679,718,806,818],"assumption,":[76],"threaten":[78],"relevance":[80],"for":[83,258,354,462,705,777,833,935,1082,1106,1255,1331,1337,1343,1355,1421,1572,1649,1667,1753,1790,2010,2027,2042,2127,2299,2431],"decision-making.":[85],"commentary,":[88],"I":[89,117,1361,1736,2435],"sketch":[90],"issues":[93,2314,2358],"raised":[94],"be":[98,183,527,682,691,826,1016,1115,1160,1200,1290,1370,1503,1533,1680,1716,1761,1882,1912,2063,2342],"addressed":[99],"through":[100,2212,2356],"standard":[101,1267,1837],"application":[102,2410],"graph":[106,237,321,330,344,367,381,399,421,501,771,860,950,1047,1064,1368,1538,1662,1782,1868,1992,2060,2091,2139,2243],"structural":[108,157,176,654,794,1268,1324],"model":[110,127,144,181,205,588,1270,1326,1420,1571,1980,2122],"framework":[111,772,792,861],"without":[112,1682,2049,2094,2359],"new":[113,1301,1441,1766,2346],"notation":[114],"assumptions.2":[116],"focus":[118,1737],"on":[119,191,252,270,323,339,361,514,590,712,739,756,1045,1089,1168,1205,1213,1437,1535,1739,1873,1961,2401],"2":[120,877,1002,1207,1607,1641,1810,2310],"distinct":[121,1589,2311],"issues:":[122],"specification":[123],"query,":[129],"transportability.":[133,416,1344],"CONSISTENCY":[134],"WITHIN":[135],"THE":[136,2376],"FRAMEWORK":[137],"OF":[138],"STRUCTURAL":[139],"CAUSAL":[140],"MODELS":[141],"A":[142,178,208,331,382,447,484,544,557,573,730,744,944,960,984,1079,1097,1102,1113,1403,1411,2046],"encodes":[145],"background":[146],"knowledge":[147,161,885],"assumptions":[149,1308,1334,1598,1651,1673],"about":[150,886,1652],"system":[153,173,618],"interest.":[155],"models,":[159,796],"represented":[163,528,622,692,1534,2048],"as":[164,171,225,759,819,932,962,1000,1025,1041,1117,1292,1564,1684,1699,1933,2030,2202],"directed":[166],"acyclic":[167],"graph,":[168,1833,1939],"or,":[169],"equivalently,":[170],"nonparametric":[175],"equations.2":[177],"well-specified":[179],"define":[186],"counterfactuals":[187,334,599,1159,1198,1243,1260],"indexed":[188,335,432,471,1201,1244,1261],"interventions":[190],"any":[192,249,463,632,906,965,1001,1009],"one":[193,2340],"more":[195,1504],"nodes":[196,466,1003,1616],"graph.":[199,469,625],"For":[200,517,1172,1470,1620],"example,":[201,440,479,518,1173,1471,1621],"under":[202,220,639,2143],"Figure":[207,325,1070,1096,1112,1118,1410,1622,1815,1903,1924,1982,2045],"(taken":[209,1412],"from":[210,304,586,1319,1413,1449,1711,1720,1774,1780,1866,1936,2219,2339],"Fig.":[212],"4),":[213],"Yr,":[214],"counterfactual":[216,637,1147,1282,1800,1822,1879],"value":[217,227,638],"Y":[219,229,713,722,1090,1438,1777,2085,2179],"treatment":[221,264,351,373,393,409,427,671,982,1010,1039,1124,1945,2024,2039,2054,2098,2153,2331,2413],"r,":[222,246],"defined":[224,461,715,1161],"generated":[230,296,411,614,1563,1584,1891,1947],"modified":[233,1832],"version":[234,668],"which":[239,346,370,401,424,1313,1377,1462,1629,2195],"R":[240,360,505,534,548,711,732,755,941,968,973,1088,1393,1436,1770,1843,1957],"deterministically":[242],"set":[243,444,464,483,539,550,1249],"equal":[244,551,566],"thus":[247],"removing":[248],"other":[250,592,1860],"influences":[251],"R.":[253,340,1829],"(Fig.":[254,1544,2056,2086,2101],"B).FIGURE.:":[255],"Causal":[256,917,1274],"diagrams":[257],"effect":[260,358,709,753,1086,1181,1294,1434,1677,1758,1909,1960,2337],"(R)":[265],"its":[267,515,636],"versions":[268,349,371,391,407,425,698,729,959,1037,1059,1122,1943,2022,2037,2052,2096,2134,2151,2328],"(A)":[269,318],"outcome":[272,1804,1823],"(Y).":[273],"(W)":[274],"(L)":[276],"represent":[277,384,884,1035],"measured":[278],"covariates.":[279],"(U)":[280],"represents":[281,507,1394,1415,1984],"unmeasured":[283,702,743,1007],"covariate.":[284],"(S)":[285],"auxiliary":[288,1541],"node":[289,504,535,1044],"determines":[291,1528],"whether":[292,727,911,1027,1280,1339,1671,1798,1842,1887,2004],"data":[294,603,609,1710,1719,1889],"are":[295,374,394,410,428,458,490,658,733,848,913,1103,1230,1341,1609,1635,1890,1946,2161,2228,2245],"according":[297,309,1585],"process":[300,312,889,1380,1460,1526,1590,1604,1854,2070,2082],"operating":[301,313,1591],"population":[303,307,1288,1316,1447,1475,1694,1714,1723,1768,1918,2160,2183,2341],"source":[306],"target":[316,1315,1387,1446,1474,1490,1594,1657,1693,1713,1734,1767,1917,2159,2172,2182],"population.":[317,1302,1322,1424,1442,1520,1575,1595,1735,2347],"Example":[319,342,397],"based":[322],"4.":[326],"(B)":[327],"Modification":[328,379],"generate":[333,1820],"(C)":[341],"measurement":[347,1077,1100,2156,2196],"required":[353],"identifiability":[355,1083,1107],"Y.":[362,1951],"(D)":[363],"Alternative":[364,418],"representation":[365,419],"A,":[368,696],"not":[375,413,429,748,764,1104,1231,1239,1949,1974,2113,2229,2368],"explicitly":[376,430,734,1040,2099,2324],"represented.":[377],"(E)":[378],"potential":[385,1522,1653,1846,2239],"disparity":[386,402,1523,2067,2075,2079],"between":[387,403,972,1383,1605,1639,1655,1850,2232],"populations":[388,404,1608],"generated.":[395],"(F)":[396],"will":[412,1188,1881,1948],"impede":[414,749,765],"direct":[415,1930],"(G)":[417],"E,":[422,1904],"represented.Counterfactuals":[431],"conjunction":[435],"variable":[437,476,634,695,1547,1558,1582,2200],"values":[438,477,542,562,571],"(for":[439,478],"exercise":[445,1220,1250,1398,1465,1485,1497,1507,1531],"duration":[446,1221,1251,1406,1463,1529],"36":[449],"minutes":[450,487,1224,1237,1254,1483,1501,1511],"vitamin":[452],"dose":[453],"W":[454,1134,1634],"5":[456],"mg)":[457],"always":[459],"well":[460,492],"Counterfactuals":[470],"disjunction":[474],"30":[486,524,555,568,1223,1236,1253,1401,1500],"more)":[489],"likewise":[491],"defined,":[493],"but":[494],"require":[495,979],"we":[497,657,954,963,992,1834,1862,1871],"add":[498],"additional":[503,1307,1920],"restriction":[509],"imposes":[513],"\u201cexercise":[521],"at":[522,1234,1399,1498,1508,2388],"least":[523,554,704,1235,1400,1499,1509],"minutes\u201d":[525],"(following":[529],"H&V)":[530,1414],"including":[532,645],"restricts":[537],"possible":[541,970],"take:":[546],"if":[547,1072,1174],"\u201cat":[553],"minutes,\u201d":[556],"take":[559,2369],"only":[560,1225],"those":[561,1227],"greater":[563],"than":[564,1210,1512],"minutes.":[569],"The":[570,708,770,949,1021,1323,1366,1546,1787,1991,2223,2238,2258],"actually":[574],"takes":[575],"individual":[577,673],"i":[578,674],"(namely":[579],"function":[581],"Ai(r)":[582],"H&V),":[584],"emerge":[585],"depending":[589],"factors":[593],"influence":[595],"subject":[596,1493,1516],"i.":[597],"Linking":[598],"observed":[602,633,641],"requires":[604,872,1157,1306],"assumption":[606,627,822,1972,1986,1997],"our":[611],"study":[612,1287,1321,1385,1423,1451,1519,1574,1659,1722],"were":[613],"accurately":[621,883,1150,1240],"This":[626,1156,1521,1898],"guarantees":[628],"level":[642],"intervention,":[644],"versions.3":[649],"On":[650],"applying":[651],"conventional":[653,686,858],"model,":[656,742,2146],"no":[659,800,980,1959,2251],"longer":[660],"confronted":[661],"concern":[664],"\u201cwhen":[666],"...":[669,672],"receives":[675],"unknown,":[677],"condition":[680],"cannot":[681,1911],"articulated\u201d":[683],"(H&V).":[684],"Using":[685],"notation,":[687],"situation":[689],"would":[690,1513,2076,2184],"representing":[697],"treatment,":[700],"remaining":[701],"(at":[703],"some":[706,1618],"individuals).":[707],"YR":[720],"ensured,":[724],"regardless":[725,909,1885],"articulated":[735],"measured.":[737],"Depending":[738],"may":[745,747,761,763,1317,1381,1468,1502],"identification":[750],"Y,":[757,1630],"just":[758,961,2029],"it":[760,839,902,1029,1050,1565,2000,2005,2321],"effect.":[769,1110],"provides":[773,862,1065,1328,1664],"systematic":[775],"approach":[776,1966],"evaluating":[778,1338],"these":[779,1206,1333,1672,2264,2357],"concerns.":[780],"Specifying":[781],"Casual":[783],"Model":[784],"Question":[786],"acknowledge":[788,2437],"within":[790],"pose":[799],"challenge":[801],"definition":[809],"counterfactuals.":[811],"argue,":[813],"however,":[814,856,1963],"\u201ca":[820],"substantive":[821,2306],"needs":[824],"evaluated\u201d":[827],"\u201cthe":[829],"most":[830,2269],"relevant":[831,1164,1170,2041],"[approach]":[832],"decision":[836,1396],"making\u201d":[837],"because":[838],"guards":[840],"against":[841],"ill-posed":[842],"questions.":[844],"Well-posed":[845],"questions":[847,1022,2303],"clearly":[849],"crucial":[850],"informative":[852],"analyses.":[853],"Here":[854],"again,":[855],"tools":[864],"needed.":[865],"Specification":[866],"good":[869,2276],"researcher":[874,1143,1176],"do":[876,934],"things":[878],"well.":[879],"First,":[880],"she":[881],"must":[882,1144],"data-generating":[888,1379,1603,1853],"(and":[890,969],"limitations":[891],"knowledge).":[894],"Although":[895],"undeniably":[898],"challenging":[900,904],"task,":[901],"paradigm,":[908],"simple.":[916],"graphs":[918,1130,1354,2281,2297],"provide":[919,1725,2298],"rigorous,":[921],"accessible,":[922],"transparent":[924],"language":[925,1330,1648],"facilitate":[927],"translation":[929],"process.":[930],"Assume,":[931],"much":[936],"their":[938,1363,2125,2155,2283,2316,2409],"article,":[939],"(treatment)":[942],"causes":[943,985],"(versions":[945],"treatment).":[948],"shows":[951],"us":[952],"treat":[956,964],"descendant":[966],"intermediate":[971,2199],"Y).":[975],"(Compound":[976],"similarly":[978],"special":[981],"when":[983,1258,1707,1769,2018,2033,2319,2334],"R;":[986],"interests":[989],"space":[991],"defer":[993],"further":[994],"discussion":[995],"case.)":[998],"Just":[999],"have":[1005,1749],"innumerable":[1006],"intermediates,":[1008],"(as":[1011],"point":[1013,2189],"out)":[1014],"considered":[1017],"treatment.":[1020,1061,2136],"then":[1023,1076],"arise":[1024],"(1)":[1028,1670,2318],"necessary":[1031,1052],"helpful":[1033,1054,2270],"separate":[1043],"(2)":[1049,1706,2333],"elaborate":[1056],"measure":[1058],"Again,":[1062],"clear":[1067,1742,1994,2141,2273,2351],"answer.":[1068],"C,":[1071],"U":[1073],"unmeasured,":[1075],"needed":[1081,1105,2026,2162],"(via":[1091],"front-door":[1093],"criterion).":[1094],"elaboration":[1098,2019,2034,2148],"Indeed,":[1111],"could":[1114],"specified":[1116,1418],"D,":[1119],"omitting":[1120],"all":[1125,1256,1772,1783,1826,1845],"together;":[1126],"inspection":[1127],"both":[1129,2220],"quickly":[1131],"reveals":[1132],"L":[1136],"satisfy":[1137],"back-door":[1139],"criterion.":[1140],"Second,":[1141],"reflects":[1151],"being":[1154],"considered.":[1155],"using":[1162,1539],"type":[1165],"variables.":[1171,1619],"wishes":[1177,1427],"estimate":[1179,1431,1678,1686,1727,1759,1910,2111,2164,2338],"obesity":[1184],"prevention":[1185,2415],"program":[1186],"\u201celiminate":[1189],"low":[1190],"physical":[1191],"activity":[1192],"high":[1194],"caloric":[1195],"intake\u201d":[1196],"(H&V),":[1197],"should":[1199],"variables,":[1208],"rather":[1209],"BMI.":[1214],"Similarly,":[1215],"increases":[1219],"among":[1226],"individuals":[1228],"who":[1229,1494],"currently":[1232],"exercising":[1233],"captured":[1241],"subjects;":[1257],"defining":[1259],"such":[1263],"dynamic":[1264],"interventions,":[1265],"again":[1271],"suffices.2,4":[1272],"Transporting":[1273],"Effect":[1275],"Estimates":[1276],"next":[1278],"address":[1279],"parameter":[1283],"estimated":[1284],"interpreted":[1291,1681],"proposed":[1297,1364],"Answering":[1303],"regarding":[1309,1599],"ways":[1311,1375],"differ":[1318,1382,1448],"paradigm":[1327],"expressing":[1332,1650],"transparently":[1335],"they":[1340,2031],"sufficient":[1342],"Recently,":[1345],"Pearl":[1346,2186],"Bareinboim5":[1348],"demonstrated":[1349],"use":[1351,1836,2118,2279],"purpose;":[1357],"study,":[1360],"outline":[1362],"approach.":[1365],"casual":[1367],"augmented":[1371,2064],"populations.":[1388,1642,1811,2221],"Consider":[1389],"where":[1392,1929,1970],"minutes,":[1402],"actual":[1405],"exercise,":[1408],"correctly":[1417],"One":[1425,1453],"now":[1426],"transport":[1429],"How":[1443],"might":[1444],"population?":[1452],"possibility":[1454],"(among":[1455],"many)":[1456],"determined":[1467,1636],"change.":[1469],"perhaps":[1472],"has":[1476,1958],"media":[1478],"campaign":[1479],"encourages":[1481],"45":[1482,1510],"per":[1486],"day.":[1487],"population,":[1491],"decides":[1495],"likely":[1505,2007],"equivalent":[1515],"node,":[1542],"S":[1543,1548,1554,1561,1577,1615,1775,1855,1893],"E).2,5,6":[1545],"functions":[1549],"like":[1550],"switch.":[1552],"If":[1553,1576,2044],"\u201coff,\u201d":[1556],"affected":[1559],"was":[1566],"original":[1569],"\u201con,\u201d":[1579],"same":[1581,1807,1884,1965,2108],"possibly":[1588],"Note":[1596,1976],"uniformity":[1600],"encoded":[1610],"absence":[1613],"affecting":[1617],"E":[1623,2102],"assumes":[1624,1955],"processes":[1627],"R,":[1631,1874,2175],"L,":[1632,2177],"remain":[1637],"constant":[1638],"addition":[1644],"providing":[1646],"disparities":[1654],"populations,":[1660],"also":[1663,1750],"tool":[1666],"visually":[1668],"assessing":[1669],"allow":[1674],"initial":[1676,1757,1908,2110],"adjustment":[1683],"policy's":[1689,1730],"impact":[1690,1731,2166,2429],"(a":[1695],"property":[1696],"referred":[1697],"\u201cdirect":[1700],"transportability\u201d":[1701],"\u201cexternal":[1703],"validity\u201d)":[1704],"and,":[1705],"combined":[1717],"here":[1738],"1;":[1741],"graphical":[1743,1838,1899],"criteria":[1744,1839],"resulting":[1746,2059],"formulas":[1748],"been":[1751],"developed":[1752],"2.5":[1755],"directly":[1762,1865,1913,2114],"transported":[1763,1914,2343],"blocks":[1771,1844],"paths":[1773],"after":[1778,1870],"deleting":[1779],"arrows":[1784,1827],"into":[1785,1828],"R.5":[1786],"intuitive":[1788],"motivation":[1789],"clear\u2014we":[1794],"wish":[1795],"assess":[1797,1841,1864],"distribution":[1801,1876],"As":[1812],"shown":[1813],"B,":[1816],"Yr":[1824],"removes":[1825],"sources":[1847],"dependence":[1849],"population-specific":[1852],"outcome.":[1858],"words,":[1861],"if,":[1869],"intervene":[1872],"outcomes":[1880,2240],"switched":[1894],"\u201con\u201d":[1895],"\u201coff.\u201d":[1897],"criterion":[1900],"fails":[1901],"implying":[1905],"(without":[1919],"assumptions).":[1921],"contrast,":[1923],"F":[1925,1983],"illustrates":[1926],"case":[1928],"holds;":[1932],"obvious":[1935],"inspecting":[1937],"changing":[1940],"affect":[1950],"(This":[1952],"particular":[1953],"Y;":[1962],"applies":[1967],"examples":[1969],"made.)":[1975],"\u201cTreatment":[1988],"Variation":[1989],"Irrelevance.\u201d7":[1990],"makes":[1993,2140,2350],"what":[1995],"means,":[1998],"why":[1999],"useful,":[2002],"hold":[2009],"given":[2012],"applied":[2013],"problem.":[2014],"Graphs":[2015],"clarify":[2017,2032],"transportability,":[2028],"identifiability.":[2043],"making":[2050],"explicit":[2055],"D),":[2057],"still":[2062],"show":[2066],"generates":[2072,2084],"A;":[2073],"G).":[2087],"Inspection":[2088],"included":[2100],"G)":[2104],"results":[2105],"conclusion\u2014the":[2109],"transportable.":[2115],"Interestingly,":[2116],"specific":[2120],"motivate":[2124,2286],"argument":[2126],"importance":[2129],"elaborating":[2131],"measuring":[2133,2174],"However,":[2137],"neither":[2147],"nor":[2154],"population\u2014simply":[2173],"W,":[2176],"suffice.":[2185],"Bereinboim5":[2188],"out":[2190],"alternative":[2191],"structures":[2193],"(such":[2201],"created":[2204],"treatment)":[2208],"does":[2209],"enable":[2210],"careful":[2213],"selection":[2214],"combination":[2216],"information":[2218],"DISCUSSION":[2222],"current":[2224],"article":[2225],"commentary":[2227],"debate":[2231],"competing":[2233],"approaches":[2234,2424],"inference.":[2237],"frameworks":[2244],"logically":[2246],"equivalent,":[2247],"there":[2249],"controversy":[2252],"surrounding":[2253],"validity":[2255],"either.2,4":[2257],"simply:":[2261],"Which":[2262],"equally":[2265],"valid":[2266],"languages":[2267],"facilitating":[2272],"thinking":[2274,2355],"practice?":[2277],"throughout":[2282],"paper":[2284,2349],"arguments":[2287],"illustrate":[2289],"examples,":[2290],"implicitly":[2291],"acknowledging":[2292],"conceptual":[2294],"clarity":[2295],"posing":[2300],"right":[2302],"articulating":[2305],"knowledge.":[2307],"raise":[2309],"important":[2313,2322],"article:":[2317],"consider":[2325],"Their":[2348],"difficulty":[2353],"unleashing":[2360],"full":[2362,2370],"power":[2363],"graphs.":[2366],"Why":[2367],"advantage":[2371],"power?":[2374],"ABOUT":[2375],"AUTHOR":[2377],"MAYA":[2378],"PETERSEN":[2379],"Assistant":[2382],"Professor":[2383],"Biostatistics":[2385],"Epidemiology":[2387],"University":[2390],"California,":[2392],"Berkeley":[2393],"School":[2394],"Public":[2396],"Health.":[2397],"Her":[2398],"research":[2399],"focuses":[2400],"development":[2403],"inference":[2406],"methods":[2407],"improve":[2412],"HIV.":[2417],"Current":[2418],"work":[2419],"includes":[2420],"investigation":[2421],"resource-efficient":[2423],"patient":[2426],"monitoring":[2427],"community-based":[2432],"interventions.":[2433],"ACKNOWLEDGMENTS":[2434],"gratefully":[2436],"Judea":[2438],"Pearl's":[2439],"extensive":[2440],"insights":[2441],"suggestions.":[2443]},"cited_by_api_url":"https://api.openalex.org/works?filter=cites:W2020774116","counts_by_year":[{"year":2025,"cited_by_count":3},{"year":2024,"cited_by_count":2},{"year":2023,"cited_by_count":1},{"year":2022,"cited_by_count":5},{"year":2021,"cited_by_count":2},{"year":2020,"cited_by_count":5},{"year":2019,"cited_by_count":4},{"year":2018,"cited_by_count":5},{"year":2017,"cited_by_count":6},{"year":2016,"cited_by_count":3},{"year":2015,"cited_by_count":4},{"year":2014,"cited_by_count":5},{"year":2013,"cited_by_count":4},{"year":2012,"cited_by_count":2}],"updated_date":"2026-11-16T12:05:36.265796","created_date":"2016-06-24T00:00:00"}
