{"id":"https://openalex.org/W2015202986","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1002/bult.2008.1720350206","title":"The thick of the fray: Open source software in libraries in the first decade of this century","display_name":"The thick of the fray: Open source software in libraries in the first decade of this century","alternate_titles":[],"publication_year":2009,"publication_date":"2009-01-22","ids":{"openalex":"https://openalex.org/W2015202986","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1002/bult.2008.1720350206","mag":"2015202986"},"language":"en","primary_location":{"id":"doi:10.1002/bult.2008.1720350206","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1002/bult.2008.1720350206","is_oa":false,"landing_page_url":"https://doi.org/10.1002/bult.2008.1720350206","pdf_url":null,"source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S105116163","display_name":"Bulletin of the American Society for Information Science and Technology","issn_l":"0095-4403","issn":["0095-4403","1550-8366","1931-6550","2163-4289"],"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":false,"listed_in":["anvur-scientific"],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/P4310315583","host_organization_name":"Association for Information Science and Technology","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/P4310315583"],"host_organization_lineage_names":["Association for Information Science and Technology"],"type":"journal"},"license":null,"license_id":null,"version":"publishedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":true,"raw_source_name":"Bulletin of the American Society for Information Science and Technology","raw_type":"journal-article"},"parent_works":[],"lineage":["https://openalex.org/W2015202986"],"child_works_count":0,"type":"article","is_traditional":true,"indexed_in":["crossref"],"open_access":{"is_oa":false,"oa_status":"closed","oa_url":null,"any_repository_has_fulltext":false},"authorships":[{"author_position":"first","author":{"id":null,"display_name":"K. G. Schneider","orcid":null,"observed_orcids":[]},"institutions":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/I4210100206","display_name":"Equinox (United States)","ror":"https://ror.org/012ap0z55","country_code":"US","type":"company","lineage":["https://openalex.org/I4210100206"]}],"countries":["US"],"is_corresponding":true,"raw_author_name":"K. G. Schneider","raw_affiliation_strings":["Community Library With Equinox Software, Inc"],"raw_orcid":null,"affiliations":[{"raw_affiliation_string":"Community Library With Equinox Software, Inc","institution_ids":["https://openalex.org/I4210100206"]}]}],"institutions":[],"countries_distinct_count":1,"institutions_distinct_count":1,"corresponding_author_ids":[],"corresponding_institution_ids":["https://openalex.org/I4210100206"],"apc_list":null,"apc_paid":null,"fwci":4.2352,"has_fulltext":false,"cited_by_count":9,"citation_normalized_percentile":{"value":0.93128613,"is_in_top_1_percent":false,"is_in_top_10_percent":true},"cited_by_percentile_year":{"min":86,"max":93},"biblio":{"volume":"35","issue":"2","first_page":"15","last_page":"19"},"is_retracted":false,"is_pulled":false,"is_paratext":false,"is_xpac":false,"primary_topic":{"id":"https://openalex.org/T13673","display_name":"Library Science and Information","score":0.8589000105857849,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/3309","display_name":"Library and Information Sciences"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/33","display_name":"Social Sciences"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},"topics":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/T13673","display_name":"Library Science and Information","score":0.8589000105857849,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/3309","display_name":"Library and Information Sciences"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/33","display_name":"Social Sciences"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},{"id":"https://openalex.org/T12863","display_name":"Web and Library Services","score":0.0706000030040741,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/3309","display_name":"Library and Information Sciences"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/33","display_name":"Social Sciences"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},{"id":"https://openalex.org/T11675","display_name":"Open Source Software Innovations","score":0.04749999940395355,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1706","display_name":"Computer Science Applications"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/17","display_name":"Computer Science"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/3","display_name":"Physical Sciences"}}],"keywords":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/open-source-software","display_name":"open source software","score":0.996999979019165},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/library-technology","display_name":"library technology","score":0.7300000190734863},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/integrated-library-systems","display_name":"integrated library systems","score":0.972000002861023},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/proprietary-software","display_name":"proprietary software","score":0.8050000071525574},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/library-software-development","display_name":"library software development","score":0.46000000834465027},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/evergreens","display_name":"evergreens","score":0.6190000176429749},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/koha","display_name":"Koha","score":0.9959999918937683},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/library-discovery-systems","display_name":"library discovery tools","score":0.621999979019165},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/library-acquisitions","display_name":"library acquisitions","score":0.33000001311302185},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/software-licensing","display_name":"software licensing","score":0.3880000114440918},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/legacy-systems","display_name":"legacy systems","score":0.34299999475479126},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/blacklight","display_name":"Blacklight","score":0.5410000085830688},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/vufind","display_name":"VuFind","score":0.7960000038146973},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/umlaut","display_name":"umlaut","score":0.5699999928474426}],"concepts":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/C3018397939","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q3644502","display_name":"Open source","level":3,"score":0.6635479927062988},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C2988343187","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q1130645","display_name":"Open source software","level":3,"score":0.565988302230835},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C2777904410","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q7397","display_name":"Software","level":2,"score":0.4524780511856079},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C95457728","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q309","display_name":"History","level":0,"score":0.3991850018501282},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C41008148","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q21198","display_name":"Computer science","level":0,"score":0.38080325722694397},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C111919701","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q9135","display_name":"Operating system","level":1,"score":0.21024170517921448}],"mesh":[],"locations_count":1,"locations":[{"id":"doi:10.1002/bult.2008.1720350206","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1002/bult.2008.1720350206","is_oa":false,"landing_page_url":"https://doi.org/10.1002/bult.2008.1720350206","pdf_url":null,"source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S105116163","display_name":"Bulletin of the American Society for Information Science and Technology","issn_l":"0095-4403","issn":["0095-4403","1550-8366","1931-6550","2163-4289"],"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":false,"listed_in":["anvur-scientific"],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/P4310315583","host_organization_name":"Association for Information Science and Technology","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/P4310315583"],"host_organization_lineage_names":["Association for Information Science and Technology"],"type":"journal"},"license":null,"license_id":null,"version":"publishedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":true,"raw_source_name":"Bulletin of the American Society for Information Science and Technology","raw_type":"journal-article"}],"best_oa_location":null,"sustainable_development_goals":[],"study_designs":[],"awards":[],"funders":[],"has_content":{"pdf":false,"grobid_xml":false},"content_urls":null,"referenced_works_count":2,"referenced_works":["https://openalex.org/W1510316655","https://openalex.org/W6989909112"],"related_works":["https://openalex.org/W1466217821","https://openalex.org/W1444883736","https://openalex.org/W1909184801","https://openalex.org/W2303489788","https://openalex.org/W2248085530","https://openalex.org/W1445738696","https://openalex.org/W2228311006","https://openalex.org/W1491260257","https://openalex.org/W1474658491","https://openalex.org/W2222723890"],"abstract_inverted_index":{"The":[0,13,289,684,910,987,1292,1400,1606,1979,2108],"library":[1,40,56,82,136,145,192,269,488,988,1079,1144,1451,1659,1678,1688,2179,2187,2387,2520,2691,2727],"community":[2,950,2190],"has":[3,217,251,423,444,458,478,486,566,580,658,775,893,1258,1483,1656,1753,1826,1953,2312],"been":[4,293,894,1484],"a-buzz":[5],"of":[6,21,50,63,74,188,206,357,363,382,427,442,451,484,521,534,542,559,608,652,663,687,730,826,867,876,883,898,919,938,948,994,1007,1024,1050,1098,1106,1126,1238,1291,1346,1399,1415,1430,1450,1470,1521,1605,1612,1686,1735,1941,1970,1981,2046,2061,2080,2101,2106,2110,2172,2177,2233,2268,2305,2348,2435,2498,2506,2574,2620,2639,2667,2700],"late":[7],"about":[8,36,872,925,1326,1811,1860,1894,1977,2016,2244,2381],"open":[9,53,286,364,763,1511,1890,1916,1942,2462,2621],"source":[10,54,287,365,1237,1943,2463,2622],"software":[11,110,275,310,373,465,476,499,758,773,783,834,1214,1274,1457,1526,1559,1661,1689,1744,1835,1884,1944,1958,2008,2082,2111,2201,2304,2311,2353,2521,2671,2679],"(OSS).":[12],"air":[14,426],"is":[15,84,374,377,402,436,500,518,571,595,705,762,878,886,998,1015,1091,1116,1122,1131,1149,1163,1175,1268,1298,1307,1316,1601,1663,1743,2023,2096,2139,2147,2157,2182,2289,2415,2420,2426,2487,2531,2631,2656,2738],"thick":[16],"with":[17,97,109,132,277,295,318,831,979,990,1037,1041,1093,1160,1196,1354,1518,1552,1564,1584,1625,1674,1749,1796,1838,1904,2197,2250,2333,2337,2341,2373],"wildly":[18],"divergent":[19],"opinions":[20],"its":[22,220,234,247,445,576,611,991,1888,1917,2034,2193,2228,2298,2626,2674],"value":[23,450],"and":[24,33,88,94,119,151,162,164,173,182,203,222,281,311,335,348,355,394,409,455,515,545,550,557,579,614,636,642,681,733,738,752,785,810,842,853,858,912,930,972,984,996,1038,1058,1108,1121,1143,1152,1294,1402,1464,1475,1479,1495,1504,1528,1539,1554,1597,1799,1891,1994,2064,2088,2230,2241,2256,2356,2364,2379,2397,2437,2448,2469,2502,2539,2576,2587,2685,2720,2753,2769],"utility":[25],"for":[26,81,113,215,241,308,416,448,536,547,582,645,666,702,713,749,782,800,808,812,823,837,840,845,945,951,1000,1110,1154,1212,1219,1266,1320,1480,1652,1771,1804,1865,1877,1919,1938,2150,2294,2327,2386,2548,2624,2648,2660],"libraries":[27,51,64,92,314,583,694,711,1454,1478,1622,1741,2649],"even":[28,107,1420,1639,2231,2308],"as":[29,76,91,103,142,156,168,303,386,391,396,429,469,491,502,625,709,805,851,862,907,1055,1090,1719,1721,1725,1990,2496,2717],"wikis,":[30],"blogs,":[31],"conferences":[32],"journal":[34],"articles":[35],"OSS":[37,75,100,127,196,302,326,369,401,434,452,570,600,688,750,761,802,877,941,970,974,1013,1119,1130,1148,1183,1203,1206,1241,1267,1848,1982,2037,2074,2127,2162,2188,2223,2246,2338,2382,2414,2590,2644],"flood":[38],"the":[39,60,114,143,170,204,231,254,282,323,353,360,383,414,420,449,475,531,540,548,560,626,640,650,731,756,789,873,879,884,899,913,916,939,946,949,1004,1022,1048,1062,1074,1104,1127,1236,1247,1253,1255,1263,1271,1285,1295,1308,1327,1349,1357,1371,1385,1396,1403,1447,1456,1467,1488,1519,1547,1610,1626,1640,1650,1675,1684,1738,1757,1772,1883,1905,1920,1939,1951,1967,2010,2018,2028,2051,2077,2102,2124,2165,2173,2186,2234,2262,2266,2310,2324,2362,2403,2409,2433,2441,2483,2499,2504,2529,2537,2571,2577,2613,2636,2640,2701,2725,2729,2739,2776],"attention-economy.":[41],"To":[42],"no":[43,479,1259,1299,1336],"one's":[44],"surprise,":[45],"a":[46,77,124,175,225,304,424,519,602,673,706,723,778,832,865,936,963,1096,1124,1164,1177,1185,1216,1279,1442,1568,1878,1911,2006,2059,2072,2374,2427,2438,2632,2658,2698,2708,2757],"raw":[47],"\u201cbody":[48],"count\u201d":[49],"using":[52,242],"integrated":[55,144],"systems":[57,146,193,1471,1627],"indicates":[58],"that":[59,313,375,474,497,507,509,593,693,714,881,1167,1204,1244,1273,1306,1348,1370,1417,1458,1472,1486,1621,1644,1662,1677,1690,1745,1792,1882,1965,2024,2069,2115,2121,2145,2159,2260,2288,2315,2392,2460,2485,2532,2549,2602],"vast":[61],"majority":[62],"continue":[65],"to":[66,195,404,407,411,419,461,466,495,584,597,615,691,697,725,736,764,766,772,777,797,934,1035,1046,1069,1084,1103,1118,1156,1189,1202,1208,1301,1322,1364,1502,1530,1575,1588,1632,1648,1713,1821,1832,1836,1874,1902,1908,1910,1915,1922,1935,1963,1996,2050,2142,2191,2227,2276,2319,2360,2367,2390,2440,2479,2542,2551,2569,2581,2594,2673,2731,2743],"rely":[67],"on":[68,236,246,619,1270,1383,1595,1756,2085,2185,2238,2253,2635],"legacy":[69],"proprietary":[70,320,372,577,612,757,1190,1209,1213,1834,1866,2299],"systems.":[71,648,986,1461],"However,":[72,741,1003,1172],"awareness":[73],"potentially":[78],"viable":[79,1532],"approach":[80,771],"technology":[83,2702],"much":[85,1318,1900,2161],"more":[86,900,953,1019,1337,2174,2290,2395],"widespread":[87],"growing,":[89],"particularly":[90,1028,2385],"use":[93,408,1061],"become":[95,1875],"comfortable":[96],"reliable,":[98],"high-performing":[99],"programs":[101,511,1988,2015,2038,2075,2087],"such":[102,139,155,167,490,624,804,850,861,906,1054,1989,2716],"Firefox.":[104],"Libraries":[105],"are":[106,121,315,721,829,976,1033,1200,1330,1410,1623,1680,1931,2271,2393,2510,2603],"reengaging":[108],"development":[111,197,734,774,786,959,1014,1051,1072,1105,1114,1670,2189,2202,2522,2672,2680],"projects":[112,128,141,166,975,1045,2339,2464],"first":[115,917],"time":[116,2709],"in":[117,130,135,224,230,261,267,284,379,387,392,397,453,470,503,639,718,722,753,904,965,1029,1073,1284,1333,1395,1446,1492,1544,1567,1658,1697,1722,1759,1782,1858,1871,1927,1945,1948,2005,2097,2123,2170,2195,2200,2446,2452,2457,2513,2516,2604,2652,2690,2697,2724,2745,2775],"decades,":[118],"there":[120,1199,1930,2138,2706,2754,2762],"at":[122,554,587,816,2116,2265,2376,2402,2555],"least":[123,817],"dozen":[125],"active":[126],"based":[129,2237],"or":[131,661,728,1009,1066,1192,1638,1642,1728,2003,2058,2273,2292,2321,2515,2547,2629],"their":[133,646,667,699,1225,1239,1460,1750,1768,1778,1797,2278,2342,2400],"genesis":[134],"organizations,":[137],"including":[138,670,2482],"better-known":[140],"Evergreen,":[147,838],"Koha,":[148],"OPALS,":[149],"OLE":[150],"xCatalog;":[152],"discovery":[153],"layers":[154],"LibraryFind,":[157],"Blacklight,":[158],"VuFind,":[159],"Fish4Info,":[160],"Scriblio":[161],"SOPAC;":[163],"component":[165],"Umlaut,":[169],"OpenURL":[171],"resolver":[172],"iVia,":[174],"search":[176],"engine/portal.":[177],"Major":[178],"grants":[179],"through":[180,888,1344,1366,1592,2280],"LSTA":[181],"Mellon":[183],"have":[184,198,292,632,689,696,795,1215,1342,1427,1509,1820,1899,2039,2048,2056],"helped":[185,2686],"fuel":[186],"some":[187,462,859,897,1535,1540,1783,1949,2117,2171,2232,2334,2413],"these":[189,510,827,2331,2477,2595,2597,2734],"projects,":[190],"while":[191,847,1078,1580,2155,2412],"committed":[194],"donated":[199],"sweat":[200,1010],"equity,":[201],"hardware":[202],"gift":[205,1049],"moral":[207],"support.":[208],"Even":[209,1181],"OCLC":[210],"-":[211,250,506,751,1027,1120,1140,1147,1278,1332,1845,1847,2009,2044,2083,2091,2340,2378,2418,2423,2546,2650,2768],"an":[212,262,285,955,1733,2099,2140,2251,2421,2558],"organization":[213],"which":[214,223,268,920,2017,2509],"years":[216,1345,1665,1870],"zealously":[218],"protected":[219],"data":[221],"public":[226],"relations":[227],"faux":[228],"pas":[229],"1990s":[232],"sicced":[233],"lawyers":[235],"New":[237],"York's":[238],"Library":[239,553,563,629,1558,1788],"Hotel":[240],"Dewey":[243],"decimal":[244],"numbers":[245],"hotel":[248],"rooms":[249],"gotten":[252],"into":[253,530,1012],"game.":[255],"OCLC's":[256],"Developer's":[257],"Network":[258],"now":[259,820,1819],"collaborates":[260],"\u201copen":[263],"source,":[264],"code-sharing":[265],"infrastructure\u201d":[266],"developers,":[270],"among":[271,2135],"other":[272,278,324,339,656,682,848,1128,1334,1839,2281],"things,":[273],"\u201cshare":[274],"code":[276,422,435,885,944,1226,1256,1889,1918,2168,2212,2500,2730],"network":[279],"members":[280],"community-at-large":[283],"environment\u201d[1].":[288],"chattering":[290],"classes":[291],"busy":[294],"OSS.":[296,703,824,1978,2107],"At":[297,322],"one":[298,2057],"extreme,":[299,325],"skeptics":[300],"condemn":[301],"low-grade,":[305],"poor-man's":[306],"substitute":[307],"licensed":[309],"argue":[312],"better":[316,2325],"served":[317],"off-the-shelf":[319],"products.":[321,1210,1841],"evangelists":[327],"intimate":[328],"it":[329,376,594,1315,2113,2156,2181,2215,2318,2323,2565],"can":[330,1251,1276,1868,1959,1974,1998,2021,2209,2247,2301,2566,2663],"cure":[331],"cancer,":[332],"dissolve":[333],"cellulite":[334],"always":[336,2592,2750],"out-perform":[337],"any":[338,719,1957],"software.":[340,366,537,740],"Between":[341],"both":[342,1696],"extremes":[343],"float":[344],"misconceptions,":[345],"assumptions,":[346],"anxieties":[347],"wish":[349],"fulfillment.":[350],"Somewhere":[351],"amid":[352],"fog":[354],"friction":[356],"myth":[358,937],"lie":[359],"simple":[361],"facts":[362],"What":[367],"makes":[368,1393,2112],"different":[370],"from":[371,525,655,1064,1246,1388,1984,2432],"free":[378,385,390,395,403,406,410,468,498,501,780],"every":[380],"sense":[381],"word:":[384],"\u201cno":[388,471],"cost,\u201d":[389],"\u201cunencumbered\u201d":[393],"\u201cnot":[398],"locked":[399],"up.\u201d":[400],"download,":[405],"modify":[412],"(though":[413],"process":[415],"committing":[417],"modifications":[418],"core":[421,1968],"slight":[425],"mystery,":[428],"will":[430,1088,2065,2130,2748,2755,2763,2773],"be":[431,467,1170,1234,1376,1815,1936,1975,1999,2131,2143,2248,2567,2600,2744,2751,2756,2765],"discussed":[432,1925],"below).":[433],"also":[437,459,1176,1317,1392,1827,2657,2764],"freely":[438],"viewable.":[439],"Each":[440],"definition":[441,457,483],"\u201cfree\u201d":[443,485,2026],"own":[446,700],"significance":[447],"libraries,":[454,792],"each":[456],"led":[460,487,690,776],"confusion.":[463],"For":[464,2133],"cost\u201d":[472],"means":[473,1881,2282],"itself":[477,1257],"licensing":[480,526,1578],"fees.":[481],"This":[482,704,891,1112,1158,1853,2737],"technologists":[489],"Eric":[492,908],"Lease":[493],"Morgan":[494],"observe":[496],"\u201cfree":[504],"kittens\u201d":[505],"is,":[508],"still":[512,1702,2183],"require":[513],"support":[514,701,732,747,784,799,822,1304],"maintenance.":[516],"It":[517,1482,2747],"matter":[520],"debate":[522],"how":[523,1812],"freedom":[524],"fees":[527,1715],"directly":[528,1123],"factors":[529],"total":[532],"cost":[533,588,607,2505],"ownership":[535,2666],"Marshall":[538],"Breeding,":[539],"director":[541],"Innovative":[543],"Technologies":[544],"Research":[546],"Jean":[549],"Alexander":[551],"Heard":[552],"Vanderbilt":[555],"University":[556,2434],"author":[558,2695],"popular":[561],"website,":[562],"Technology":[564],"Guides,":[565],"frequently":[567],"questioned":[568],"whether":[569,599],"overall":[572,604,2424],"less":[573,1901],"expensive":[574],"than":[575,610,954,1021,1914,2283,2297,2408],"counterparts":[578,613,2300],"called":[581,2001],"look":[585],"hard":[586],"factors.":[589],"He":[590],"tells":[591],"me":[592],"important":[596,1962,2646],"question":[598],"offers":[601],"lower":[603],"TCO":[605],"(total":[606],"ownership)":[609],"not":[616,744,968,1018,1169,1667,1704,1710,2119,2749],"base":[617],"decisions":[618],"philosophical":[620,1165],"preferences.":[621],"Meanwhile,":[622],"organizations":[623,657,717,1080],"Georgia":[627],"Public":[628],"Service":[630],"(GPLS)":[631],"reported":[633],"significant":[634,1020,1178,2466],"first-":[635],"second-year":[637],"savings":[638],"implementation":[641],"maintenance":[643,1303,1596],"costs":[644],"automated":[647],"In":[649,788,1732,1842,2557],"case":[651],"GPLS,":[653],"funding":[654],"underwritten":[659],"all":[660,729,969,1155,1691,2120,2126,2625],"part":[662,2098,2497,2517],"new":[664,2714],"services":[665,1086,1272,1679,2715,2735],"Evergreen":[668],"system,":[669],"acquisitions,":[671],"internationalization,":[672],"low-cost":[674],"non-SIP":[675],"(session":[676],"initiative":[677],"protocol)":[678],"self-check":[679],"alternative":[680],"features.":[683],"\u201cfree-as-in-no-cost\u201d":[685,742,874],"characteristics":[686,2079,2314],"concerns":[692],"would":[695,1233,1355,1374,1645],"provide":[698,726,798,821,856,864],"legitimate":[707],"concern,":[708],"few":[710,716,2073,2758],"(or":[712],"matter,":[715,2550],"profession)":[720],"position":[724],"most":[727,966,1545,2019,2533,2653],"required":[735,2541],"maintain":[737],"develop":[739],"does":[743],"preclude":[745],"commercial":[746],"models":[748],"fact,":[754],"unlike":[755],"world,":[759],"because":[760,1873],"anyone":[765,1250],"use,":[767],"this":[768,1173,1613,1823,1843,1928,2093,2694,2770],"vaguely":[769,2357],"communistic":[770],"strong":[779,992,1933],"market":[781],"services.":[787,2692],"world":[790,1921,2619,2740],"beyond":[791,1966,2068],"numerous":[793,1932],"companies":[794,819,828,849,1275,1350,1514],"arisen":[796],"various":[801],"products,":[803],"Red":[806],"Hat":[807],"Linux":[809,2053],"Acquia":[811],"Drupal.":[813],"Within":[814],"LibraryLand,":[815],"five":[818],"Several":[825],"associated":[830,2336],"specific":[833],"program":[835],"(Equinox":[836],"Liblime":[839,1057],"Koha":[841],"Media":[843,1059],"Flex":[844,1060],"OPALS),":[846],"Alpha-G":[852],"Galecia":[854,1607],"Associates":[855],"consulting,":[857],"companies,":[860],"IndexData,":[863],"little":[866],"each.":[868],"Another":[869],"common":[870],"misconception":[871,892],"nature":[875],"belief":[880],"none":[882],"produced":[887],"paid":[889],"development.":[890,1002,1598,1761],"supported":[895],"by":[896,1412,1477,1516,1683,1716,2518,2561],"woo-woo":[901],"philosophizing":[902],"found":[903,1561,1671],"works":[905],"Raymond's":[909],"Cathedral":[911,1293,1401],"Bazaar":[914],"[2],":[915],"half":[918,1290,1398],"tosses":[921],"around":[922],"speculative":[923],"theorizing":[924],"\u201chacker":[926],"milieus,\u201d":[927],"\u201cgift":[928],"cultures\u201d":[929],"reputation":[931,985],"game":[932],"analyses":[933],"create":[935],"noble":[940],"developer,":[942],"contributing":[943,1102],"good":[947,2081,2544,2553],"nothing":[952,1972],"enhanced":[956],"reputation.":[957],"Volunteer":[958],"efforts":[960,1527,2573],"certainly":[961],"play":[962],"role":[964,1023],"if":[967,1017,1182,1222,1487,1666],"development,":[971,2351,2623],"many":[973,1044,1135,1700,1708,2029],"thriving":[977],"communities":[978,2043],"leaders,":[980],"followers,":[981],"contributors,":[982],"audiences":[983],"community,":[989],"ethos":[993],"sharing":[995],"openness,":[997,1971],"well-suited":[999],"volunteer":[1001,1025],"pragmatic":[1005],"investment":[1006],"money":[1008],"equity":[1011],"equally":[1016],"contributions":[1026],"librarianship,":[1030],"where":[1031,1227,1863],"developers":[1032,1498,2047,2062,2721],"scarce":[1034],"begin":[1036],"usually":[1039],"involved":[1040,2063],"far":[1042,1288,1954,2122],"too":[1043,1692],"donate":[1047],"time.":[1052],"Companies":[1053],"Equinox,":[1056],"proceeds":[1063],"service":[1065],"special-project":[1067],"contracts":[1068],"fund":[1070],"future":[1071,1784],"products":[1075,1328,1867,2194,2391],"they":[1076,1087,1223,1232,1329,1351,1774,2579,2772],"support,":[1077],"contribute":[1081],"developer":[1082],"hours":[1083,2030],"developing":[1085],"need,":[1089],"happening":[1092],"Project":[1094],"Conifer,":[1095],"consortium":[1097],"Canadian":[1099],"academic":[1100],"librarians":[1101,1137,1341,1379,1507,1581,2711],"acquisitions":[1107],"internationalization":[1109],"Evergreen.":[1111],"blended":[1113],"model":[1115,1265,1913,2208],"unique":[1117],"result":[1125,1676],"ways":[1129],"\u201cfree.\u201d":[1132],"Like":[1133],"so":[1134,1262,2160],"things":[1136,1813],"hold":[1138],"dear":[1139],"information,":[1141],"books":[1142],"buildings":[1145],"themselves":[1146,1562],"open,":[1150,2206],"available":[1151],"visible":[1153],"see.":[1157,1923],"consonance":[1159],"librarian":[1161,1197],"values":[1162],"advantage":[1166],"should":[1168],"downplayed.":[1171],"openness":[1174],"strategic":[1179],"advantage.":[1180],"were":[1184,1352,1473,1550,1572,1582],"financial":[1186],"wash":[1187],"compared":[1188],"software,":[1191,2180],"only":[1193,1363,2220],"neutrally":[1194],"consonant":[1195],"values,":[1198],"benefits":[1201],"make":[1205,1649,1887,2322,2733],"preferable":[1207],"Vendors":[1211],"ready":[1217,1500],"excuse":[1218],"cloak-and-dagger":[1220],"development:":[1221],"developed":[1224],"everyone":[1228],"could":[1229,1814],"see":[1230,1252,1421],"it,":[1231],"compromising":[1235],"revenue.":[1240],"completely":[1242],"removes":[1243],"problem":[1245],"table.":[1248],"When":[1249],"code,":[1254],"monetary":[1260],"value,":[1261],"economic":[1264],"dependent":[1269],"deliver":[1277,1356],"point":[1280,2118],"made":[1281,1637,1937,2144],"quite":[1282],"well":[1283,1720],"second":[1286,1397],"(and":[1287],"superior)":[1289],"Bazaar.":[1296],"There":[1297,1440],"motivation":[1300],"reduce":[1302],"when":[1305,1453,2309,2678,2710],"company's":[1309],"primary":[1310],"revenue":[1311,1591],"stream.":[1312],"With":[1313],"OSS,":[1314],"easier":[1319],"customers":[1321,1541,1565],"perform":[1323,1705],"due":[1324],"diligence":[1325],"selecting":[1331],"words,":[1335],"false":[1338],"promises.":[1339],"Many":[1340],"lived":[1343],"reassurances":[1347],"working":[1353,2722],"next":[1358],"version":[1359],"Real":[1360],"Soon":[1361],"Now,":[1362],"learn":[1365],"terse":[1367],"press":[1368],"releases":[1369],"long-promised":[1372],"product":[1373,1880],"never":[1375,1573,2066,2608],"materializing.":[1377],"(Some":[1378],"recall":[1380],"being":[1381],"\u201ctrained\u201d":[1382],"Taos,":[1384],"never-to-emerge":[1386],"vaporware":[1387],"DRA.)":[1389],"As":[1390,1924,2693],"Raymond":[1391],"clear":[1394,1857,2114],"Bazaar,":[1404],"\u201cwhen":[1405],"your":[1406,1431],"key":[1407],"business":[1408],"processes":[1409],"executed":[1411],"opaque":[1413],"blocks":[1414],"bits":[1416],"you":[1418,1426],"can't":[1419],"inside":[1422],"(let":[1423],"alone":[1424],"modify),":[1425],"lost":[1428,2031],"control":[1429],"business\u201d":[1432],"[22,":[1433],"p.":[1434],"152]":[1435],"(Raymond's":[1436],"rather":[1437,2407],"needless":[1438],"emphasis).":[1439],"was":[1441,2681,2707],"time,":[1443,2771],"decades":[1444,1668],"ago,":[1445],"early":[1448,1497,2675],"days":[1449],"automation,":[1452],"built":[1455],"drove":[1459],"Melvyl,":[1462],"NOTIS":[1463],"LRS":[1465],"share":[1466],"proud":[1468],"heritage":[1469],"designed":[1474],"written":[1476],"libraries.":[1481,1946],"suggested":[1485],"Internet":[1489],"had":[1490,1499],"existed":[1491],"those":[1493,1496,2269],"days,":[1494,2677],"access":[1501,1641],"file-sharing":[1503],"online":[1505],"community-building,":[1506],"might":[1508],"invented":[1510],"source.":[1512],"Instead,":[1513],"founded":[1515],"people":[1517,1807,2404,2534],"best":[1520],"intentions":[1522],"took":[1523],"over":[1524],"fledgling":[1525],"struggled":[1529],"build":[1531],"businesses.":[1533],"While":[1534],"vendors":[1536,1560,1585,1770,1864],"proved":[1537,1542],"scurrilous,":[1538],"exasperating,":[1543],"cases":[1546,1934],"vendor-customer":[1548],"relationships":[1549],"riddled":[1551],"endemic":[1553],"unavoidable":[1555],"\u201cno-fault\u201d":[1556],"problems.":[1557],"dealing":[1563,1583],"who":[1566,2270,2274,2398],"chronically":[1569],"under-funded":[1570],"profession":[1571],"able":[1574],"pay":[1576,1714],"realistic":[1577],"fees,":[1579],"who,":[1586],"unable":[1587],"earn":[1589],"enough":[1590],"licensing,":[1593],"scrimped":[1594],"\u201cLearned":[1599,1654],"helplessness\u201d":[1600,1655,2638],"what":[1602,1634,1956,1997],"Lori":[1603],"Ayre":[1604,1617,1752,1825],"Group":[1608],"calls":[1609],"outcome":[1611],"folie":[1614],"\u00e0":[1615],"deux.":[1616],"writes,":[1618],"\u201cIt's":[1619],"ridiculous":[1620],"stuck":[1624],"they've":[1628],"got":[1629],"without":[1630],"options":[1631],"determine":[1633],"changes":[1635,1651,1773,2199,2689],"get":[1636,1833],"privileges":[1643],"allow":[1646,1711],"them":[1647,1747],"themselves.\u201d[3]":[1653],"resulted":[1657],"automation":[1660],"generally":[1664],"behind":[1669,2164],"outside":[1672,2203],"LibraryLand":[1673],"often":[1681,1693,1898],"cramped":[1682],"limitations":[1685],"aged":[1687],"falls":[1694],"short":[1695],"features":[1698],"(how":[1699],"catalogs":[1701],"do":[1703,1709,1903],"spell-check?":[1706],"How":[1707],"patrons":[1712],"credit":[1717],"cards?)":[1718],"functionality":[1723],"(such":[1724],"poor":[1726],"reindexing":[1727],"transaction":[1729],"load":[1730],"capabilities).":[1731],"era":[1734],"budget":[1736],"reductions,":[1737],"last":[1739,2306,2641],"thing":[1740],"need":[1742],"positions":[1746],"poorly":[1748,2011,2616],"communities.":[1751],"further":[1754],"commented":[1755],"stagnation":[1758],"ILS":[1760,1769],"\u201cLibrary":[1762],"system":[1763,1802],"admins":[1764,1803],"simply":[1765],"stopped":[1766,1800,1809],"asking":[1767,1801],"needed":[1775],"after":[1776],"seeing":[1777],"requests":[1779],"end":[1780],"up":[1781,2226],"release":[1785],"black":[1786],"hole.":[1787],"staff":[1789],"soon":[1790],"learned":[1791],"\u201cit":[1793],"wasn't":[1794],"possible":[1795],"system\u201d":[1798],"changes.":[1805],"Eventually,":[1806],"just":[1808],"thinking":[1810],"improved.":[1816],"Somehow,":[1817],"we":[1818,2020,2741],"reverse":[1822],"trend.\u201d":[1824],"shared":[1828,1912],"her":[1829],"experiences":[1830],"trying":[1831],"communicate":[1837],"vendor":[1840,1885],"area":[1844],"interoperability":[1846],"again":[1849],"presents":[1850,2645],"distinct":[1851],"advantages.":[1852],"superiority":[1854],"becomes":[1855,2383],"sharply":[1856],"discussions":[1859],"emerging":[1861],"standards,":[1862],"spend":[1869],"stalemate,":[1872],"compliant":[1876],"particular":[1879],"must":[1886],"available.":[1892],"Foot-dragging":[1893],"standards":[1895],"compliance":[1896],"may":[1897,2316,2591,2599],"vendor's":[1906],"reluctance":[1907],"hew":[1909],"earlier":[1926],"article,":[1929,2454],"adoption":[1940],"But":[1947,2761],"circles":[1950],"hype":[1952],"exceeded":[1955],"deliver.":[1960],"It's":[1961],"underscore":[1964],"characteristic":[1969],"else":[1973],"inferred":[1976],"quality":[1980],"ranges":[1983],"superior,":[1985],"industrial-strength,":[1986],"ever-adapting":[1987],"Firefox,":[1991],"Linux,":[1992],"Apache":[1993],"PostgreSQL,":[1995],"charitably":[2000],"GIAG,":[2002],"Guy":[2004],"Garage":[2007],"documented,":[2012,2617],"badly":[2013],"maintained":[2014],"say":[2022],"it's":[2025],"(less":[2027],"struggling":[2032],"within":[2033],"limitations).":[2035],"Some":[2036,2055],"grown":[2040],"huge":[2041],"contributor":[2042,2439],"thousands":[2045],"contributed":[2049],"latest":[2052,2078],"releases.":[2054],"handful":[2060],"grow":[2067],"number.":[2070],"Quite":[2071],"exhibit":[2076],"reliance":[2084],"modern":[2086],"service-oriented":[2089],"architecture":[2090],"but":[2092,2214,2222,2607],"desirable":[2094],"attribute":[2095],"accident":[2100],"relatively":[2103],"recent":[2104],"history":[2105,2109],"future,":[2125,2669],"known":[2128],"today":[2129],"obsolete.":[2132],"example,":[2134],"larger":[2136,2198],"applications,":[2137],"argument":[2141],"PostgreSQL":[2146],"replacing":[2148],"MySQL":[2149,2419],"serious":[2151],"database":[2152],"developers.":[2153,2410],"So":[2154],"beneficial":[2158],"leaves":[2163,2527],"ratty,":[2166],"tatty":[2167],"used":[2169],"notorious":[2175],"examples":[2176],"elderly":[2178],"incumbent":[2184],"evolve":[2192],"concert":[2196],"LibraryLand.":[2204],"An":[2205],"collaborative":[2207],"facilitate":[2210],"healthy":[2211,2633],"evolution,":[2213],"cannot":[2216],"guarantee":[2217],"it.":[2218,2245],"Not":[2219],"that,":[2221],"occasionally":[2224],"lives":[2225],"stereotypes":[2229],"FUD":[2235],"(rumors":[2236],"Fear,":[2239],"Uncertainty":[2240],"Doubt)":[2242],"spread":[2243],"developer-centric,":[2249],"emphasis":[2252],"bare-metal":[2254],"interfaces":[2255],"text-heavy":[2257],"script":[2258],"configurations":[2259],"privilege":[2261],"technically":[2263],"savvy":[2264],"expense":[2267],"inexperienced":[2272],"prefer":[2275],"showcase":[2277],"mettle":[2279],"hand-editing":[2284],"lengthy":[2285],"scripts.":[2286],"Software":[2287],"time-consuming":[2291],"complex":[2293],"general":[2295],"users":[2296],"feel":[2302],"like":[2303],"resort,":[2307],"superior":[2313],"endear":[2317],"power-users":[2320],"choice":[2326],"high-end":[2328],"needs.":[2329],"Join":[2330],"problems":[2332,2598],"websites":[2335],"overly":[2343],"bright":[2344],"web":[2345,2350],"pages":[2346],"reminiscent":[2347],"mid-1990s":[2349],"cartoonish":[2352],"\u201cmascots,\u201d":[2354],"confusing":[2355],"cultic":[2358],"invitations":[2359,2366],"\u201cjoin":[2361],"community\u201d":[2363],"grudging":[2365],"download":[2368],"\u201cunsupported\u201d":[2369],"Windows":[2370],"\u201cbinaries\u201d":[2371],"(perhaps":[2372],"jab":[2375],"\u201cMicrosoft\u201d)":[2377],"hesitation":[2380],"understandable,":[2384],"administrators":[2388],"accustomed":[2389],"superficially":[2394],"polished":[2396],"direct":[2399],"appeal":[2401],"writing":[2405,2554],"checks,":[2406],"Also,":[2411],"exhaustively":[2416],"documented":[2417],"example":[2422],"documentation":[2425,2486,2495,2545],"pervasive":[2428],"problem.":[2429],"Stuart":[2430],"Yeates":[2431,2475,2526],"Oxford":[2436],"Educause":[2442],"blog,":[2443],"Open":[2444,2458],"Source":[2445],"Higher":[2447],"Further":[2449],"Education,":[2450],"observes":[2451],"his":[2453],"\u201cDocumentation":[2455],"Issues":[2456],"Source,\u201d":[2459],"\u201c[m]any":[2461],"face":[2465],"challenges":[2467,2478],"generating":[2468],"maintaining":[2470],"high":[2471],"quality,":[2472],"end-user":[2473],"documentation.\u201d[4]":[2474],"traces":[2476],"nine":[2480],"issues,":[2481],"fact":[2484],"rarely":[2488],"considered":[2489],"\u201csexy.\u201d":[2490],"Yeates'":[2491],"recommendations":[2492],"include":[2493],"requiring":[2494],"roll-out":[2501],"underwriting":[2503],"professional":[2507],"documentation,":[2508],"practices":[2511],"embraced":[2512],"whole":[2514],"several":[2519],"projects.":[2523],"One":[2524],"issue":[2525],"off":[2528],"table":[2530],"vastly":[2535],"underestimate":[2536],"skill":[2538],"resources":[2540],"write":[2543],"produce":[2552],"all.":[2556],"environment":[2559],"dominated":[2560],"brilliant,":[2562],"dedicated":[2563],"coders,":[2564],"easy":[2568],"devalue":[2570],"humble":[2572],"right-brainers":[2575],"skills":[2578],"bring":[2580],"writing,":[2582],"graphics":[2583],"design,":[2584],"project":[2585],"management":[2586],"information":[2588],"architecture.":[2589],"trend":[2593],"limitations;":[2596],"ones":[2601],"constant":[2605],"mitigation,":[2606],"fully":[2609],"resolved.":[2610],"That":[2611],"said,":[2612],"sometimes":[2614],"messy,":[2615],"developer-centric":[2618],"foibles":[2627],"(endemic":[2628],"otherwise),":[2630],"improvement":[2634],"\u201clearned":[2637],"two":[2642],"decades.":[2643],"opportunities":[2647],"though":[2651],"ventures,":[2654],"opportunity":[2655],"synonym":[2659],"risk.":[2661],"We":[2662],"take":[2664],"back":[2665],"our":[2668],"returning":[2670],"glory":[2676],"intimately":[2682],"intertwined":[2683],"with,":[2684],"drive,":[2687],"rapid":[2688],"wrote":[2696,2728],"biography":[2699],"pioneer":[2703],"Anne":[2704],"Lipow,":[2705],"envisioned":[2712],"major":[2713],"document":[2718],"delivery,":[2719],"right":[2723],"same":[2726],"help":[2732],"happen.":[2736],"want":[2742],"again.":[2746],"easy,":[2752],"spectacular":[2759,2766],"failures.":[2760],"successes":[2767],"happen":[2774],"open.":[2777]},"cited_by_api_url":"https://api.openalex.org/works?filter=cites:W2015202986","counts_by_year":[{"year":2021,"cited_by_count":1},{"year":2020,"cited_by_count":1},{"year":2017,"cited_by_count":1},{"year":2015,"cited_by_count":1},{"year":2013,"cited_by_count":1},{"year":2012,"cited_by_count":1}],"updated_date":"2026-11-16T12:05:36.265796","created_date":"2016-06-24T00:00:00"}
