{"id":"https://openalex.org/W2014722286","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1093/ejil/chn060","title":"Human Rights, International Economic Law and Constitutional Justice: A Reply","display_name":"Human Rights, International Economic Law and Constitutional Justice: A Reply","alternate_titles":[],"publication_year":2008,"publication_date":"2008-11-01","ids":{"openalex":"https://openalex.org/W2014722286","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1093/ejil/chn060","mag":"2014722286"},"language":"en","primary_location":{"id":"doi:10.1093/ejil/chn060","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1093/ejil/chn060","is_oa":true,"landing_page_url":"https://doi.org/10.1093/ejil/chn060","pdf_url":"https://academic.oup.com/ejil/article-pdf/19/5/945/1360042/chn060.pdf","source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S175405714","display_name":"European Journal of International Law","issn_l":"0938-5428","issn":["0938-5428","1464-3596"],"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":false,"listed_in":["abdc-a","anvur-class-a","anvur-scientific","jufo-3","norway-2","poland-100","russia-white-list-1","vabb-shw"],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/P4310311648","host_organization_name":"Oxford University Press","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/P4310311648","https://openalex.org/P4310311647"],"host_organization_lineage_names":["Oxford University Press","University of Oxford"],"type":"journal"},"license":null,"license_id":null,"version":"publishedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":true,"raw_source_name":"European Journal of International Law","raw_type":"journal-article"},"parent_works":[],"lineage":["https://openalex.org/W2014722286"],"child_works_count":0,"type":"article","is_traditional":true,"indexed_in":["crossref"],"open_access":{"is_oa":true,"oa_status":"bronze","oa_url":"https://academic.oup.com/ejil/article-pdf/19/5/945/1360042/chn060.pdf","any_repository_has_fulltext":false},"authorships":[{"author_position":"first","author":{"id":"https://openalex.org/A5110720348","display_name":"ROBERT L. HOWSE","orcid":null,"observed_orcids":[]},"institutions":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/I57206974","display_name":"New York University","ror":"https://ror.org/0190ak572","country_code":"US","type":"education","lineage":["https://openalex.org/I57206974"]}],"countries":["US"],"is_corresponding":true,"raw_author_name":"R. Howse","raw_affiliation_strings":["Lloyd C. Nelson Professor of International Law, New York University","Lloyd C. Nelson Professor of International Law, New York University. Email:"],"raw_orcid":null,"affiliations":[{"raw_affiliation_string":"Lloyd C. Nelson Professor of International Law, New York University","institution_ids":["https://openalex.org/I57206974"]},{"raw_affiliation_string":"Lloyd C. Nelson Professor of International Law, New York University. Email:","institution_ids":["https://openalex.org/I57206974"]}]}],"institutions":[],"countries_distinct_count":1,"institutions_distinct_count":1,"corresponding_author_ids":["https://openalex.org/A5110720348"],"corresponding_institution_ids":["https://openalex.org/I57206974"],"apc_list":{"value":2919,"currency":"GBP","value_usd":3849},"apc_paid":null,"fwci":2.5414,"has_fulltext":true,"cited_by_count":40,"citation_normalized_percentile":{"value":0.90086352,"is_in_top_1_percent":false,"is_in_top_10_percent":true},"cited_by_percentile_year":{"min":86,"max":100},"biblio":{"volume":"19","issue":"5","first_page":"945","last_page":"953"},"is_retracted":false,"is_pulled":false,"is_paratext":false,"is_xpac":false,"primary_topic":{"id":"https://openalex.org/T12156","display_name":"World Trade Organization Law","score":0.8550000190734863,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/3320","display_name":"Political Science and International Relations"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/33","display_name":"Social Sciences"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},"topics":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/T12156","display_name":"World Trade Organization Law","score":0.8550000190734863,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/3320","display_name":"Political Science and International Relations"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/33","display_name":"Social Sciences"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},{"id":"https://openalex.org/T10749","display_name":"International Law and Human Rights","score":0.11079999804496765,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/3320","display_name":"Political Science and International Relations"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/33","display_name":"Social Sciences"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},{"id":"https://openalex.org/T12040","display_name":"International Arbitration and Investment Law","score":0.014800000004470348,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/3308","display_name":"Law"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/33","display_name":"Social Sciences"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}}],"keywords":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/international-economic-law","display_name":"international economic law","score":0.9929999709129333},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/constitutional-review","display_name":"constitutional review","score":0.7950000166893005},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/substantive-due-process","display_name":"substantive due process","score":0.746999979019165},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/trade-liberalization","display_name":"trade liberalization","score":0.628000020980835},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/gatt","display_name":"GATT","score":0.7889999747276306},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/state-sovereignty","display_name":"state sovereignty","score":0.492000013589859},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/international-dispute-settlement","display_name":"international dispute settlement","score":0.6169999837875366},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/freedom-of-contract","display_name":"freedom of contract","score":0.5860000252723694},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/property-rights","display_name":"property rights","score":0.9160000085830688},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/non-state-actors","display_name":"non-state actors","score":0.5580000281333923},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/international-courts","display_name":"international courts","score":0.5149999856948853},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/lochner","display_name":"Lochner","score":0.3790000081062317},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/individual-rights-in-international-law","display_name":"individual rights in international law","score":0.6549999713897705}],"concepts":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/C169437150","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q8458","display_name":"Human rights","level":2,"score":0.6856510639190674},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C139621336","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q3190382","display_name":"Economic Justice","level":2,"score":0.6851856708526611},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C199539241","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q7748","display_name":"Law","level":1,"score":0.5802512168884277},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C17744445","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q36442","display_name":"Political science","level":0,"score":0.5722241997718811},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C190253527","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q295354","display_name":"Law and economics","level":1,"score":0.43450862169265747},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C55447825","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q4394526","display_name":"International law","level":2,"score":0.41618454456329346},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C144024400","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q21201","display_name":"Sociology","level":0,"score":0.3246118724346161}],"mesh":[],"locations_count":1,"locations":[{"id":"doi:10.1093/ejil/chn060","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1093/ejil/chn060","is_oa":true,"landing_page_url":"https://doi.org/10.1093/ejil/chn060","pdf_url":"https://academic.oup.com/ejil/article-pdf/19/5/945/1360042/chn060.pdf","source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S175405714","display_name":"European Journal of International Law","issn_l":"0938-5428","issn":["0938-5428","1464-3596"],"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":false,"listed_in":["abdc-a","anvur-class-a","anvur-scientific","jufo-3","norway-2","poland-100","russia-white-list-1","vabb-shw"],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/P4310311648","host_organization_name":"Oxford University Press","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/P4310311648","https://openalex.org/P4310311647"],"host_organization_lineage_names":["Oxford University Press","University of Oxford"],"type":"journal"},"license":null,"license_id":null,"version":"publishedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":true,"raw_source_name":"European Journal of International Law","raw_type":"journal-article"}],"best_oa_location":{"id":"doi:10.1093/ejil/chn060","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1093/ejil/chn060","is_oa":true,"landing_page_url":"https://doi.org/10.1093/ejil/chn060","pdf_url":"https://academic.oup.com/ejil/article-pdf/19/5/945/1360042/chn060.pdf","source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S175405714","display_name":"European Journal of International Law","issn_l":"0938-5428","issn":["0938-5428","1464-3596"],"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":false,"listed_in":["abdc-a","anvur-class-a","anvur-scientific","jufo-3","norway-2","poland-100","russia-white-list-1","vabb-shw"],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/P4310311648","host_organization_name":"Oxford University Press","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/P4310311648","https://openalex.org/P4310311647"],"host_organization_lineage_names":["Oxford University Press","University of Oxford"],"type":"journal"},"license":null,"license_id":null,"version":"publishedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":true,"raw_source_name":"European Journal of International Law","raw_type":"journal-article"},"sustainable_development_goals":[{"display_name":"Peace, justice, and strong institutions","id":"https://metadata.un.org/sdg/16","score":0.9595999717712402}],"study_designs":[],"awards":[],"funders":[],"has_content":{"grobid_xml":true,"pdf":true},"content_urls":{"pdf":"https://content.openalex.org/works/W2014722286.pdf","grobid_xml":"https://content.openalex.org/works/W2014722286.grobid-xml"},"referenced_works_count":0,"referenced_works":[],"related_works":["https://openalex.org/W2123309828","https://openalex.org/W1986649659","https://openalex.org/W1734284110","https://openalex.org/W1504403529","https://openalex.org/W7064649143","https://openalex.org/W2804938655","https://openalex.org/W925411358","https://openalex.org/W4251374811","https://openalex.org/W24697280"],"abstract_inverted_index":{"Together":[0],"with":[1,107,473,946,1290,1374,1522,1925,1950,1963,2117,2172,2209,2262,2311,2412,2755,2847,2964,3041,3321,3368,3375,3603],"developments":[2],"in":[3,14,58,187,249,277,283,349,397,418,434,449,489,548,619,637,656,716,765,804,874,890,925,1007,1019,1032,1054,1074,1076,1107,1153,1168,1191,1212,1226,1232,1272,1400,1406,1413,1425,1448,1461,1511,1671,1699,1741,1772,1843,1875,1880,1884,1927,1936,2017,2059,2087,2175,2180,2228,2260,2288,2355,2370,2427,2453,2471,2512,2544,2549,2603,2615,2656,2664,2699,2763,2888,2950,2989,2998,3113,3160,3197,3313,3337,3345,3381,3448,3506,3634,3661,3733],"international":[4,15,25,60,111,140,169,188,251,271,1055,1264,1310,1315,1881,1970,1996,2359,2375,2407,2449,2657,2678,2691,2704,2767,2855,2933,2971,3022,3071,3114,3149,3158,3277],"criminal":[5],"justice":[6,3559],"and":[7,38,86,93,100,109,117,124,128,159,165,364,446,471,481,485,514,520,536,545,551,561,679,699,708,738,799,912,923,968,1117,1158,1206,1261,1281,1309,1356,1470,1505,1537,1581,1628,1640,1647,1691,1749,1797,1809,1816,1834,2006,2179,2295,2366,2394,2417,2491,2494,2622,2663,2688,2710,2758,2809,2865,2870,3004,3144,3193,3214,3238,3274,3298,3303,3307,3320,3350,3374,3380,3392,3398,3453,3460,3498,3532,3546,3558,3575,3591,3653,3656,3665,3695,3704,3793],"humanitarian":[8],"law,":[9,273,2218,3116],"the":[10,24,47,59,101,134,146,154,163,183,193,195,204,211,222,229,250,263,266,278,284,290,303,317,320,346,353,358,370,381,386,400,430,435,450,459,499,530,549,577,584,589,593,609,612,620,638,646,654,739,758,763,770,774,793,809,833,839,860,864,875,878,897,904,928,947,959,966,969,985,1002,1025,1038,1050,1067,1077,1108,1113,1118,1121,1130,1140,1154,1192,1203,1210,1238,1262,1273,1276,1285,1302,1305,1320,1334,1347,1359,1377,1382,1387,1409,1420,1429,1439,1452,1462,1474,1485,1488,1501,1517,1539,1558,1579,1605,1617,1626,1637,1649,1653,1666,1703,1721,1724,1728,1731,1751,1769,1773,1807,1810,1857,1860,1877,1919,1976,2018,2020,2036,2048,2062,2065,2076,2080,2084,2095,2114,2120,2128,2154,2167,2176,2188,2194,2197,2200,2214,2230,2236,2239,2242,2265,2284,2316,2320,2331,2336,2346,2353,2364,2371,2386,2410,2435,2441,2462,2489,2496,2513,2532,2537,2540,2553,2558,2562,2565,2575,2591,2601,2611,2634,2653,2675,2695,2700,2713,2716,2722,2725,2740,2750,2756,2773,2778,2781,2793,2796,2804,2815,2818,2826,2829,2878,2899,2908,2915,2953,2959,2987,2990,2994,2999,3026,3042,3046,3056,3101,3105,3119,3125,3148,3154,3161,3164,3170,3179,3182,3188,3194,3230,3256,3270,3283,3288,3299,3305,3317,3338,3340,3348,3353,3356,3359,3382,3387,3399,3425,3441,3450,3464,3470,3478,3491,3496,3507,3510,3512,3518,3524,3578,3581,3597,3608,3617,3646,3654,3659,3666,3690,3724,3739,3764,3797],"human":[11,147,196,230,304,543,676,778,891,1051,1100,1137,1151,1188,1267,1306,1316,1339,1410,1442,1458,1478,1525,1535,1542,1669,1747,1763,1861,1888,2348,2360,2418,2445,2450,2541,2605,2612,2644,2679,2881,2928,3742,3757,3771],"rights":[12,148,197,231,257,305,475,544,565,667,677,779,803,892,1052,1073,1101,1152,1167,1189,1268,1307,1317,1340,1411,1443,1459,1526,1549,1670,1764,1862,1889,2361,2419,2446,2451,2542,2606,2613,2645,2680,2882,2929,3758,3772],"revolution":[13,149,198,232,306,1053,1308],"law":[16,112,522,538,607,1265,1292,1318,1345,1460,1615,1972,1998,2002,2174,2191,2408,2420,2452,2466,2543,2658,2681,2693,2768,2836,3023,3150,3159,3279,3306],"has":[17,113,640,937,956,2584,2706,3343,3394,3409,3483,3641,3787,3794],"had":[18,812,3469,3523,3788],"a":[19,29,178,215,246,311,331,403,416,441,462,492,525,910,988,1063,1096,1125,1135,1171,1295,1467,1530,1674,1706,1711,1738,1780,1799,1817,1844,1893,1932,1958,1964,1985,1989,2028,2040,2099,2105,2144,2150,2185,2248,2272,2277,2444,2468,2473,2482,2518,2586,2761,3029,3141,3314,3322,3333,3405,3416,3438,3745,3770],"profound":[20],"structural":[21,2365],"effect":[22,2274,3476],"on":[23,262,399,568,721,1245,1278,1394,1529,1546,1730,1789,1851,2134,2275,2633,2772,2868,2944,2993,3045,3104,3128,3249,3268,3780],"legal":[26,61,209,707,1325,1878,2376,2392,2718,2934],"order":[27,252,350],"as":[28,72,83,192,254,504,726,734,827,829,901,1183,1195,1327,1571,1603,1623,1659,1673,1759,1826,1828,2981,3028,3109,3200,3202,3437,3466,3564,3627],"whole;":[30],"we":[31,1715],"are":[32,703,1129,1368,1550,2051,2159,2227,3548,3623],"today":[33,448],"only":[34,64,757,1087,2026,2875,3092,3118],"beginning":[35],"to":[36,39,43,144,174,202,235,324,342,351,414,439,469,482,644,689,791,814,830,844,848,869,962,1010,1012,1022,1037,1066,1099,1123,1133,1149,1185,1196,1209,1235,1240,1248,1294,1349,1353,1370,1376,1379,1384,1392,1417,1432,1444,1450,1484,1490,1516,1524,1587,1635,1645,1702,1746,1762,1791,1822,1856,1867,1891,1923,1973,2147,2170,2207,2234,2258,2306,2401,2414,2461,2517,2527,2530,2573,2597,2707,2749,2792,2813,2825,2843,2850,2897,2919,2924,2957,2985,3063,3111,3153,3172,3181,3203,3228,3377,3390,3404,3432,3444,3485,3527,3555,3561,3577,3605,3645,3714,3737,3754,3789],"discern":[37],"digest":[40],"this":[41,237,374,767,881,1020,1288,1982,2054,2060,2162,2486,2509,2735,2770,3198,3761,3768],"effect,":[42],"say":[44],"nothing":[45],"of":[46,69,75,88,103,122,136,168,207,214,217,256,265,270,286,297,313,319,327,357,362,369,395,402,405,423,453,465,467,479,491,494,509,529,532,542,557,611,650,653,663,686,730,745,749,762,788,796,852,863,877,899,903,907,909,917,927,930,950,971,976,987,990,1004,1027,1040,1069,1079,1090,1115,1120,1165,1170,1173,1202,1266,1275,1287,1301,1304,1314,1323,1338,1361,1408,1438,1441,1454,1473,1477,1487,1492,1503,1534,1538,1541,1578,1592,1608,1614,1619,1630,1655,1668,1695,1705,1723,1733,1737,1775,1794,1802,1820,1831,1846,1859,1871,1886,1905,1921,1934,1942,1945,1969,1978,1994,2008,2035,2043,2068,2107,2138,2153,2164,2187,2190,2216,2244,2267,2297,2319,2338,2342,2345,2358,2378,2391,2396,2405,2425,2448,2464,2499,2515,2539,2552,2561,2577,2579,2600,2643,2652,2690,2715,2724,2760,2765,2775,2780,2795,2817,2828,2854,2863,2901,2905,2967,2969,2996,3001,3006,3021,3032,3048,3070,3107,3147,3156,3163,3190,3206,3216,3272,3276,3309,3332,3352,3355,3361,3384,3407,3420,3428,3472,3477,3500,3568,3580,3589,3596,3599,3610,3619,3621,3638,3649,3658,3668,3693,3741,3767,3774],"broader":[48,1990],"consequences":[49],"for":[50,139,182,238,539,608,743,808,895,1017,1127,1162,1329,1346,1782,1895,1961,2027,2075,2238,2291,2301,2314,2590,2674,3225,3243,3435],"global":[51],"politics.1":[52],"New":[53],"actors":[54,105,1332,1913,2303],"have":[55,77,90,227,1058,1915,1931,2282,2608,2733,2884,2920,3280,3456],"been":[56,78,96,2886,3281,3458,3484],"empowered":[57],"system":[62,2719,3357,3442],"(not":[63],"individuals":[65,245,1355,1949],"but":[66,337,623,1683,2476,3073,3117,3367,3544],"various":[67,1395],"kinds":[68],"non-state":[70],"collectivities":[71],"well);":[73],"conceptions":[74],"responsibility":[76,2070,2232],"altered;":[79],"classic":[80],"notions,":[81],"such":[82,191,731,1404,1928,1946,1979,2620,3260],"territorial":[84],"sovereignty":[85],"recognition":[87,1704],"statehood,":[89],"sometimes":[91,94],"subtly":[92],"radically":[95],"reshaped":[97],"or":[98,151,344,506,648,718,751,866,889,1035,1042,1048,1111,1381,1397,1422,1497,1544,1661,1708,1754,1966,2033,2253,2330,2351,2429,2455,2930,3504,3538,3687,3716],"adapted;":[99],"balance":[102,483,687],"institutional":[104],"charged":[106],"interpreting":[108,2472],"applying":[110],"shifted":[114,3344],"towards":[115,3325],"courts":[116,2400,3545],"tribunals":[118,160,2416,2638],"(a":[119],"major":[120,3451],"theme":[121],"Petersmann)":[123],"away":[125],"from":[126,518,842,1176,1576,1625,1918,2380,2522,3138,3358,3540,3586],"diplomats":[127],"their":[129,1250,1372],"ministers.2":[130],"What,":[131],"specifically,":[132],"is":[133,177,341,444,566,713,785,884,1182,1221,1229,1242,1269,1482,1560,1595,1865,1890,1897,1988,2004,2092,2123,2140,2184,2233,2421,2433,2659,2694,2728,2746,2783,2790,2801,2812,2873,2894,2911,2956,3075,3168,3221,3240,3570,3633,3713],"significance":[135,1453],"these":[137,208,722,853,999,1434,1548,1656,2406,3680,3718],"trends":[138],"economic":[141,170,189,219,272,292,355,534,537,659,700,797,963,992,1070,1109,1155,1166,1193,1311,1331,1362,1446,1814,1882,1912,1953,1971,1997,2692,3115,3278,3328,3446,3542],"law?":[142],"According":[143,790],"Petersmann,":[145,175,440],"alters":[150],"should":[152,1930,2682,2732],"alter":[153],"way":[155,2126,2329,2514,3511],"that":[156,296,326,409,573,629,705,859,870,1088,1419,1519,1557,1583,1685,1743,1756,1776,1785,1849,1869,1910,2094,2161,2182,2220,2225,2279,2440,2465,2523,2626,2636,2670,2677,2787,2834,2880,2952,3053,3097,3219,3235,3258,3401,3440,3595,3731],"academics,":[157],"practitioners,":[158],"look":[161],"at":[162,275,1061,1604,1841,2103,2142,2193,2437,2721,2976,3463,3488],"purposes":[164,3379],"normative":[166],"underpinnings":[167],"law.":[171,1056,1312,1907],"While,":[172],"according":[173,438],"there":[176,883,3074],"strong":[179,526],"utilitarian":[180],"case":[181,384,490,606,1274,1894,2771,2910],"trade":[184,279,3237,3290,3294,3312,3514],"liberalization":[185],"guarantees":[186,678,795],"treaties":[190,1405,1883,1929,2820,2961],"GATT,3":[194],"now":[199,3624],"permits":[200],"us":[201,234],"see":[203,236],"true":[205],"nature":[206],"dispositions:":[210],"\u2018constitutional\u2019":[212],"protection":[213,502,541,986,1190],"sphere":[216,989,1156,1194],"individual":[218,359,484,1887,1911],"liberty":[220],"against":[221,671,994,1333,1358,1567],"state.":[223],"As":[224,2546],"Petersmann":[225,600,856,920,944,1552,1569,1664,1757,1908,2390,2477,2547,2671,2832,2857,2940,3039,3098,3209,3364,3402,3423,3551,3628,3786],"would":[226,376,1084,1415,1956,1983,2072,2525,2595,2914,3083],"it,":[228],"allows":[233,2203],"two":[239],"reasons.":[240],"First,":[241],"because":[242,1103,1112,1143],"it":[243,634,1015,1220,1574,1686,1955,2111,2183,2222,2524,2627,2753,3220],"gives":[244],"juridical":[247],"status":[248],"\u2013":[253,258,360,503,508,661,668,837,846,1142,1205,1228,1634,1710,1778,1999,2003,2102,3293,3301,3372,3671],"bearers":[255],"thus":[259,857,2304],"focusing":[260],"attention":[261,2529,3574],"limits":[264,1850,2215],"existing":[267],"formal":[268],"structures":[269],"which,":[274],"least":[276,1562,1842,2104,2143,2438,3489],"area,":[280],"remain":[281],"mired":[282],"notion":[285,443,1694],"state-to-state":[287],"obligation":[288],"despite":[289],"underlying":[291],"activity":[293],"protected":[294,410,670],"being":[295],"private":[298,519,533,665,991,1214,1330,1445,2302,3445,3600],"actors,":[299,3447],"not":[300,323,602,616,641,983,1093,1727,1767,1787,2056,2255,2384,2423,2479,2571,2661,2838,2874,3084,3124,3169,3593,3751],"states.":[301],"Secondly,":[302,2936],"imports":[307],"into":[308,820,1456,2646,2685,2926,3065],"dispute":[309,2013,2121,2155,2567,2648,2890,3430],"settlement":[310,333,2014,2156,2568,2891,3431],"conception":[312,975,1540],"constitutional":[314,372,931,941,951,977,1081,1593,1952],"judicial":[315,527,631,680,932,952,978,1520,2686,3335],"review:":[316],"role":[318,1771,2811],"adjudicator":[321,2782,2917,2955,3058],"ought":[322,688,3389],"be":[325,377,669,690,1147,1601,1854,1957,1984,2256,2259,2307,2326,2402,2459,2488,2629,2683,2708,3085,3562,3738],"an":[328,411,617,1243,2630,2840,2921,2982,3060,3086,3174,3541,3635,3672,3781],"arbitrator":[329],"seeking":[330],"satisfactory":[332],"between":[334,692,1257,3025,3651,3700],"sovereign":[335,347],"states,":[336,1573],"rather":[338,1901,2738],"her":[339,419],"function":[340,949,1322],"discipline":[343],"constrain":[345],"state":[348,1144,1177,1348,2050,2069,2082,2097,2163],"protect":[352,1150,1354],"entrenched":[354],"autonomy":[356,993,1174,1218],"freedom":[361,660,662,964],"contract":[363,417],"property":[365,474,495,505,564,666,900,1116],"rights.":[366,1138,1479],"In":[367,2241,3134],"terms":[368,1034,1169,1885,3648,3670],"American":[371],"tradition,":[373],"vision":[375,1039,1260,1968],"termed":[378],"Lochnerian,":[379],"after":[380,2149,2492],"notorious":[382],"1920s":[383],"where":[385,2485,2777,3630,3679],"US":[387,431,585],"Supreme":[388,432,586],"Court":[389,433,452,587],"struck":[390,691],"down":[391],"legislation":[392,1161],"limiting":[393],"hours":[394],"work":[396,3205],"bakeries":[398],"basis":[401,1781],"concept":[404,422],"substantive":[406,424],"due":[407,425,570,579],"process":[408,426],"individual's":[412],"right":[413,1122,1239,1378,1383,3537],"make":[415,1892],"business.4":[420],"This":[421,1480,1693,2789,3167],"was":[427,596,872,1621,1644,1687,1726,1744,2086,2504,3536,3675],"abandoned":[428],"by":[429,477,583,1651,1678,1689,1948,2047,2079,2334,2373,2389,2443,2467,2507,2877,3415,3509,3614,3685],"1930s;":[436],"but,":[437],"similar":[442],"alive":[445],"well":[447,828,1230,1827,3201,3459],"European":[451,1475,2399],"Human":[454],"Rights":[455],"(ECtHR):":[456],"Even":[457],"though":[458],"ECtHR":[460,621],"respects":[461,3347],"wide":[463,1818],"margin":[464],"appreciation":[466],"states":[468,1367,1428,1755,1922],"limit":[470,645,1217],"interfere":[472],"(e.g.,":[476,488],"means":[478,1131],"taxation)":[480],"public":[486,521,2970],"interests":[487,513,694,2872,3455,3499],"taking":[493,898,1455],"without":[496],"full":[497],"compensation),":[498],"Court's":[500,555],"expansive":[501],"\u2018possessions\u2019":[507],"almost":[510,1638],"all":[511,1577,3763],"pecuniary":[512],"legitimate":[515],"expectations":[516],"arising":[517],"relationships":[523],"reveals":[524],"awareness":[528],"importance":[531],"activities":[535],"effective":[540,1187,2168],"personal":[546],"self-realization":[547],"economy":[550,655],"civil":[552],"society.":[553],"The":[554,781,1255,1612,2012,2089,2293,2322,2668,2973,3090,3330,3475,3566],"review":[556,979,1594],"governmental":[558,2869],"limitations":[559,1423],"of,":[560],"interferences":[562],"with,":[563],"based":[567,2784,2802],"\u2018substantive":[569],"process\u2019":[571,580],"standards":[572,581],"go":[574],"far":[575],"beyond":[576],"\u2018procedural":[578],"applied":[582,2711,3393],"since":[588,2752],"1930s":[590],"[i.e.,":[591],"when":[592,1565,3094],"Lochner":[594,972,1181],"doctrine":[595,970,2655],"abandoned]":[597],"(at":[598,1253,3015,3121,3253],"779).":[599],"does":[601,635,982,1092,2055,2478,2837,3099],"cite":[603],"any":[604,913],"supporting":[605],"Lochnerism":[610,1091],"ECtHR.":[613],"I":[614,1057,1083,2382,2503,2617,2623,3177,3265,3707],"am":[615],"expert":[618],"jurisprudence;":[622],"my":[624,3207],"generalist's":[625],"observational":[626],"powers":[627],"suggest":[628],"Lochnerian":[630,1259,2350,2641,3746],"activism,":[632],"if":[633,727,1366,2053,2221,2907,3038,3710,3750],"exist":[636],"ECtHR,":[639],"done":[642],"much":[643,3412,3417,3571,3676],"scope":[647],"reach":[649],"government":[651,818,1504],"regulation":[652,798],"Europe.":[657],"Should":[658],"contract,":[664],"democratic":[672],"majoritarian":[673],"politics":[674,1805],"through":[675,1616,1812,2127,3481,3697,3720],"review?":[681],"If":[682],"so,":[683],"what":[684,867,1568,1896,2009,2508,2531,3378,3385,3529,3734],"kind":[685],"other":[693,697,914,2198,2312,2332,2533,2851,2931,3067,3494,3533],"(and":[695,1071,3550],"indeed":[696,1298,2007],"rights)":[698],"rights?":[701],"These":[702],"questions":[704],"engage":[706],"political":[709,850,1531,1632,1739,1836,1847],"philosophy.":[710],"Petersmann's":[711,786,1008,1199,1258,1436,1512,1590,1700,1872,1940,2650,2902,3139,3711],"article":[712,1009,3140],"utterly":[714],"lacking":[715],"detailed":[717],"rigorous":[719],"reasoning":[720],"questions;":[723],"he":[724,1224,1680,2731,3054,3735],"writes":[725],"mere":[728],"mention":[729,2480,3100],"high-sounding":[732],"concepts":[733],"\u2018self-realization\u2019,":[735],"\u2018human":[736,752,1043,2339],"dignity\u2019,":[737],"like":[740,3300],"could":[741,1600,2487,2510],"substitute":[742],"justification":[744],"his":[746,1207,1233,2550],"particular":[747],"view":[748,1201,1300,2344,2943],"\u2018self-realization\u2019":[750],"dignity\u2019.":[753],"We":[754],"can":[755,1216,2112,2324],"give":[756],"briefest":[759],"indication":[760],"here":[761,1086,1993],"manner":[764,2602],"which":[766,836,943,1011,1213,1547,1599,1636,2071,2110,2212,2604,2745,2948,3013,3186,3501,3622,3662,3674,3800],"rhetoric":[768],"distorts":[769],"moral":[771,1606],"sensibility":[772],"behind":[773,3316,3689],"post-World":[775],"War":[776,1735],"II":[777],"revolution.":[780],"most":[782,980,1270,1507,3009,3130,3755],"telling":[783],"example":[784,3436],"treatment":[787],"Nazism.":[789],"Petersmann:":[792],"wide-ranging":[794],"legally":[800],"enforceable":[801],"social":[802,1783,1824],"Germany's":[805],"1919":[806],"Constitution":[807],"\u2018Weimar":[810],"Republic\u2019":[811],"led":[813,847,868],"ever":[815,938],"more":[816,2146,2747,2938,3241,3396,3572,3677,3686],"restrictive":[817,1830],"interventions":[819,1821],"labour":[821],"markets,":[822,824],"capital":[823],"interest":[825],"rates,":[826],"expropriations":[831],"\u2018in":[832,2962],"general":[834,2766,3231],"interest\u2019":[835],"during":[838,2109],"Nazi":[840],"dictatorship":[841],"1933":[843],"1945":[845],"systemic":[849,905],"abuses":[851,873,1102],"regulatory":[854,996,2210,2250],"powers.5":[855],"suggests":[858,2833],"real":[861,1631],"sin":[862],"Nazis,":[865],"sin,":[871],"over-regulation":[876],"marketplace.":[879],"On":[880,2196],"perspective,":[882],"essentially":[885],"no":[886,2942,3076,3222,3259],"difference,":[887],"morally":[888],"terms,":[893],"between,":[894],"example,":[896,1365],"part":[902],"strategy":[906],"destruction":[908],"people,":[911],"unjustified":[915],"exercise":[916,1249],"eminent":[918],"domain.":[919],"invokes":[921],"Rawls":[922],"Dworkin":[924,955],"support":[926],"cause":[929,1933],"review;":[933],"yet":[934],"neither":[935],"thinker":[936],"advocated":[939],"Lochner-style":[940],"jurisprudence":[942],"identifies":[945],"key":[948],"review.":[953],"Indeed,":[954,1139],"explicitly":[957],"criticized":[958],"libertarian":[960,1033],"approach":[961,1065],"under":[965,1343,1386,3411],"constitution,":[967],"specifically.6":[973],"Dworkin's":[974],"decidedly":[981],"endorse":[984,2619],"egalitarian":[995],"intervention.":[997],"Beyond":[998],"brief":[1000],"indications,":[1001],"absence":[1003,2266],"sustained":[1005],"argument":[1006],"respond":[1013],"makes":[1014],"difficult":[1016,3678],"me":[1018],"comment":[1021],"address":[1023],"theoretically":[1024],"relationship":[1026,1303,1440],"\u2018economic":[1028],"freedom\u2019,":[1029],"whether":[1030,1720,1750,1995,2247],"understood":[1031],"otherwise,7":[1036],"\u2018humanity\u2019":[1041],"dignity\u2019":[1044],"arguably":[1045,1465,2093],"implicit":[1046],"in,":[1047],"driving,":[1049],"articulated":[1059],"elsewhere,":[1060],"length,":[1062],"conceptual":[1064],"place":[1068,1106,3171],"social)":[1072],"constitutionalism,":[1075],"context":[1078],"Canadian":[1080],"reform.8":[1082],"add":[1085,1684],"rejection":[1089],"entail":[1094],"turning":[1095],"blind":[1097],"eye":[1098],"they":[1104,1389,2226,3467,3663],"take":[1105,1350,2925,3064,3790],"sphere,":[1110],"seizure":[1114],"denial":[1119],"earn":[1124],"livelihood":[1126],"instance":[1128,3336],"used":[1132],"violate":[1134,2113],"person's":[1136],"reverse":[1141],"intervention":[1145,1178],"may":[1146,1390,1853,2252,2254,2270,2458],"required":[1148],"(equality":[1157],"affirmative":[1159],"action":[1160,1352,1935],"instance)":[1163],"conceiving":[1164],"zone":[1172],"secure":[1175],"\u00e0":[1179],"la":[1180],"likely":[1184],"undermine":[1186],"enhance":[1197],"it.":[1198],"unbalanced":[1200],"issue":[1204,1992,2323],"indifference":[1208],"ways":[1211],"power":[1215,3694],"(unless":[1219],"consumer":[1222],"autonomy;":[1223],"believes":[1225,1909],"anti-trust)":[1227],"reflected":[1231,2876],"reference":[1234],"collective":[1236],"bargaining:":[1237],"strike":[1241],"assault":[1244],"companies\u2019":[1246],"ability":[1247],"\u2018market":[1251],"freedoms\u2019":[1252],"18).":[1254],"tension":[1256],"positive":[1263,1351],"evident":[1271],"Covenant":[1277],"Economic,":[1279],"Social":[1280],"Cultural":[1282],"Rights.":[1283],"Examining":[1284],"interaction":[1286],"instrument":[1289,2705],"WTO":[1291,1324,1344,1401,1906,2001,2115,2173,2217,2263,2356,2415,2469,2474,2519,2566,2592,2637,2647,2797,2805,2819,2830,2835,2845,2864,2889,2916,2954,2960,3002,3057,3165,3191,3429],"leads":[1293],"dramatically":[1296],"different,":[1297],"anti-Lochnerian,":[1299],"Instead":[1313],"enhancing":[1319],"purported":[1321],"norms":[1326,2116,2362,2379,2614,3354],"protections":[1328],"activist":[1335],"state,":[1336],"consideration":[1337,2354,2599],"implies":[1341],"flexibility":[1342],"communities":[1357],"excesses":[1360],"globalization.":[1363],"For":[1364,3285],"fully":[1369,2624],"discharge":[1371],"obligations":[1373,1412,1879,1926,1947],"respect":[1375,1523,2413,2824,3376,3604],"food":[1380],"health":[1385],"CESC,":[1388],"need":[1391,2305,2526,2918],"rely":[1393],"exceptions":[1396,1421],"safeguards":[1398],"provisions":[1399,1424,2015,2569,2816,3127],"treaties.":[1402],"Interpreting":[1403],"light":[1407,2764,3383],"question":[1414,1426,3528],"help":[1416,1682],"ensure":[1418,1823],"allow":[1427,2574],"policy":[1430,1991,3291,3515],"space":[1431],"fulfil":[1433],"obligations.9":[1435],"presentation":[1437,2651],"activity,":[1447],"addition":[1449],"misrepresenting":[1451],"account":[1457,1472,2927,3066],"WTO,":[1463,2019,3339,3465],"also":[1464,2660],"provides":[1466],"very":[1468,1752],"one-sided":[1469,2861],"inaccurate":[1471],"legacy":[1476,1481],"reduced":[1483],"contribution":[1486],"judiciary":[1489,1559],"correction":[1491],"\u2018government":[1493],"failure\u2019.":[1494],"His":[1495],"anti-state":[1496],"anti-government":[1498],"bias":[1499,3324],"(indeed,":[1500],"notions":[1502],"failure":[1506,1920],"often":[1508,1898,2860,3701],"appear":[1509,2572],"together":[1510],"essay)":[1513],"blinds":[1514],"him":[1515],"extent":[1518],"activism":[1521],"itself":[1527],"depends":[1528],"culture":[1532,1740,1777],"supportive":[1533],"rights,":[1536,1748,1954,2349,3743],"personality":[1543],"humanity":[1545],"based.":[1551],"himself":[1553,1585,3552],"cites":[1554,2673],"Hamilton's":[1555],"observation":[1556],"\u2018the":[1561,3211],"dangerous":[1563],"branch\u2019;":[1564],"up":[1566,3427,3480,3796],"describes":[1570,1758],"\u2018Machiavellic\u2019":[1572,1657],"suffers":[1575],"weaknesses":[1580],"liabilities":[1582],"Machiavelli":[1584],"attributes":[1586,3403],"\u2018unarmed":[1588],"prophets\u2019.":[1589],"image":[1591],"really":[1596],"secularized":[1597],"Protestantism,":[1598],"recognized":[1602],"root":[1607],"Weimar":[1609],"liberal":[1610],"legalism.":[1611],"rule":[1613,2189],"caste":[1618],"judges":[1620,3547],"represented":[1622,3462],"redemption":[1624],"harshness":[1627],"squalor":[1629],"life":[1633],"inevitable":[1639],"fateful":[1641],"(anti-liberal)":[1642],"response":[1643],"try":[1646],"save":[1648],"\u2018political\u2019":[1650],"moralizing":[1652],"embrace":[1654],"features":[1658],"\u2018decisionism\u2019":[1660],"\u2018resoluteness\u2019.":[1662],"When":[1663],"presents":[1665],"triumph":[1667],"Europe":[1672,1742],"coup":[1675],"de":[1676],"grace":[1677],"judges,":[1679],"cannot":[1681],"accepted":[1688],"parliaments":[1690],"citizens.":[1692],"acceptance":[1696,1725],"seems":[1697],"equivalent,":[1698],"eyes,":[1701],"saviour":[1707],"redeemer":[1709],"mystical":[1712],"embrace.":[1713],"But":[1714,1981],"might":[1716],"ask,":[1717],"less":[1718,3688],"apolitically,":[1719],"ground":[1722],"creation,":[1729],"ashes":[1732],"World":[1734],"II,":[1736],"open":[1745],"governments":[1753,2206,3655],"Machiavellic":[1760],"resisters":[1761],"supremacy":[1765],"did":[1766,1786],"play":[1768],"decisive":[1770],"creation":[1774,3331],"building":[1779],"solidarity":[1784],"depend":[1788],"appeals":[1790],"chauvinistic":[1792],"versions":[1793],"national":[1795,3226],"identity,":[1796],"routing":[1798],"possible":[1800],"revival":[1801],"extremist":[1803,1835],"anti-liberal":[1804],"(on":[1806],"left":[1808,2505],"right)":[1811],"state-driven":[1813],"reconstruction":[1815],"variety":[1819],"equality,":[1825],"laws":[1829,3227],"racist":[1832],"speech":[1833],"movements":[1837],"(which":[1838],"pointedly":[1839],"shows,":[1840],"time":[1845,2723],"transition,":[1848],"\u2018laissez-faire\u2019":[1852],"essential":[1855],"fulfilment":[1858],"ideal).10":[1863],"It":[1864,2432,2727,2893],"important":[1866,2631,3242,3346],"understand":[1868],"one":[1870,2328,2374,2424,3095,3136],"primary":[1873],"objectives":[1874],"recasting":[1876,3730],"called,":[1899],"perhaps":[1900,2434],"loosely,":[1902],"\u2018direct":[1903],"effect\u2019":[1904],"who":[1914],"suffered":[1916,2078],"harm":[1917,2077],"comply":[1924,2171],"domestic":[1937,1943],"courts.":[1938],"Given":[1939],"identification":[1941],"enforcement":[1944],"Lochner-like":[1951],"natural":[1959],"reflex":[1960],"someone":[1962],"non-":[1965],"anti-Lochnerian":[1967],"oppose":[1974],"categorically":[1975],"possibility":[1977,2576,2635],"enforcement.":[1980],"mistake.":[1986],"There":[1987,2158],"particularly":[2000,2403],"\u2018underenforced\u2019":[2005],"\u2018underenforcement\u2019":[2010],"means.":[2011],"applicable":[2016,3024,3110,3152],"so-called":[2021],"Dispute":[2022,2806],"Settlement":[2023,2807],"Understanding,":[2024,2808],"provide":[2025,2839,3173],"prospective":[2029],"remedy,":[2030],"namely":[2031],"withdrawal":[2032],"modification":[2034],"offending":[2037,2096],"measure":[2038,2085],"within":[2039,2712,3723],"reasonable":[2041,3224],"period":[2042,2137],"time;":[2044],"unilateral":[2045],"countermeasures":[2046],"injured":[2049,2081],"available":[2052,2287],"happen.":[2057],"Apparently,":[2058],"respect,":[2061],"DSU":[2063,2945,3049,3080],"modifies":[2064],"customary":[2066,2965],"rules":[2067,2853,2966,2988,3020,3069,3388],"require":[2073],"reparations":[2074],"while":[2083,2119],"place.":[2088],"net":[2090],"result":[2091],"gets":[2098],"\u2018free":[2100],"ride\u2019":[2101],"couple":[2106],"years":[2108],"impunity":[2118],"complaint":[2122],"wending":[2124],"its":[2125],"system,":[2129,3584],"and,":[2130,3626],"quite":[2131,2895,3369],"likely,":[2132],"depending":[2133],"how":[2135,3373],"\u2018reasonable":[2136],"time\u2019":[2139],"interpreted,":[2141],"year":[2145],"implement":[2148],"final":[2151],"judgment":[2152],"organs.":[2157],"arguments":[2160,2883],"affairs":[2165],"undermines":[2166],"incentives":[2169],"first":[2177],"place,":[2178],"fact":[2181,2665,2879,3257,3449],"betrayal":[2186],"ideal":[2192],"WTO.":[2195],"hand,":[2199,3784],"current":[2201],"situation":[2202,2484,2794],"even":[2204,2481],"risk-adverse":[2205],"experiment":[2208],"options":[2211,2313],"push":[2213],"knowing":[2219],"turns":[2223],"out":[2224],"violation":[2229],"sole":[2231],"remove":[2235],"measures":[2237],"future.":[2240],"presence":[2243],"uncertainty":[2245],"about":[2246,2283,2536],"given":[2249,3052],"scheme":[2251],"found":[2257],"compliance":[2261],"rules,":[2264],"retrospective":[2268],"remedies":[2269,2286,2300,2317],"prevent":[2271],"\u2018chill\u2019":[2273],"regulation,":[2276],"concern":[2278],"many":[2280,3286,3587,3620],"progressives":[2281],"damages":[2285,2299],"investor\u2013state":[2289,3606,3611],"arbitration,":[2290,3607],"example.":[2292],"benefits":[2294],"costs":[2296],"providing":[2298],"carefully":[2308],"weighed,":[2309],"along":[2310],"changing":[2315],"regime":[2318,2377],"WTO.11":[2321],"hardly":[2325],"decided":[2327,3613],"simply":[2333,2422,3683],"invoking":[2335],"mantle":[2337],"rights\u2019.":[2340],"Regardless":[2341],"one's":[2343],"relevant":[2347,2460,2587,2654,2748,2852,2932,3019,3068],"otherwise,":[2352],"adjudication":[2357,3112],"raises":[2363],"hermeneutic":[2367],"issues":[2368],"entailed":[2369],"application":[2372,2689,2759,3351],"another.":[2381],"do":[2383,2570],"find":[2385],"lengthy":[2387],"discussion":[2388,2498,2551,3077],"cooperation":[2393,2501],"practices":[2395],"comity":[2397,2594],"among":[2398,3233,3262],"illuminating":[2404],"issues:":[2409],"problem":[2411],"overlapping":[2426],"personam":[2428],"subject-matter":[2430],"jurisdiction.":[2431],"case,":[2436,2490,2556,2737],"hypothetically,":[2439],"interpretation":[2442,2687,2757,2968,3000,3162,3349],"tribunal":[2447,2470,2534,2583],"pending":[2454],"on-going":[2456],"proceedings":[2457,2580],"use":[2463,2774,3155],"Agreement;":[2475],"hypothetical":[2483],"reading":[2493],"re-reading":[2495],"long":[2497],"Solange":[2500],"etc.":[2502],"baffled":[2506],"offer":[2511],"guidance":[2516]},"cited_by_api_url":"https://api.openalex.org/works?filter=cites:W2014722286","counts_by_year":[{"year":2026,"cited_by_count":1},{"year":2025,"cited_by_count":1},{"year":2024,"cited_by_count":4},{"year":2021,"cited_by_count":1},{"year":2019,"cited_by_count":22},{"year":2018,"cited_by_count":1},{"year":2017,"cited_by_count":1},{"year":2016,"cited_by_count":2},{"year":2014,"cited_by_count":2},{"year":2013,"cited_by_count":2},{"year":2012,"cited_by_count":1}],"updated_date":"2026-11-16T12:05:36.265796","created_date":"2016-06-24T00:00:00"}
