{"id":"https://openalex.org/W1987986552","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1642/auk-13-240.1","title":"Paul C. Mundinger, 1934\u20132011","display_name":"Paul C. Mundinger, 1934\u20132011","publication_year":2014,"publication_date":"2014-01-01","ids":{"openalex":"https://openalex.org/W1987986552","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1642/auk-13-240.1","mag":"1987986552"},"language":"en","primary_location":{"id":"doi:10.1642/auk-13-240.1","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1642/auk-13-240.1","is_oa":true,"landing_page_url":"https://doi.org/10.1642/auk-13-240.1","pdf_url":"https://academic.oup.com/auk/article-pdf/131/1/116/26883190/auk0116.pdf","source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S152904045","display_name":"The Auk","issn_l":"0004-8038","issn":["0004-8038","1938-4254"],"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":true,"listed_in":["cwts-core","norway-1","poland-140","russia-white-list-1"],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/P4310311648","host_organization_name":"Oxford University Press","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/P4310311648","https://openalex.org/P4310311647"],"host_organization_lineage_names":["Oxford University Press","University of Oxford"],"type":"journal"},"license":null,"license_id":null,"version":"publishedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":true,"raw_source_name":"The Auk","raw_type":"journal-article"},"volume":null,"type":"article","indexed_in":["crossref"],"open_access":{"is_oa":true,"oa_status":"bronze","oa_url":"https://academic.oup.com/auk/article-pdf/131/1/116/26883190/auk0116.pdf","any_repository_has_fulltext":false},"authorships":[{"author_position":"first","author":{"id":"https://openalex.org/A5072489428","display_name":"David C. Lahti","orcid":"https://orcid.org/0000-0003-2361-7356","observed_orcids":["https://orcid.org/0000-0003-2361-7356"]},"institutions":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/I111455621","display_name":"Queens College, CUNY","ror":"https://ror.org/03v8adn41","country_code":"US","type":"education","lineage":["https://openalex.org/I111455621"]}],"countries":["US"],"is_corresponding":true,"raw_author_name":"David C. Lahti","raw_affiliation_strings":["Department of Biology, Queens College, City University of New York, Flushing, New York, USA"],"raw_orcid":null,"affiliations":[{"raw_affiliation_string":"Department of Biology, Queens College, City University of New York, Flushing, New York, USA","institution_ids":["https://openalex.org/I111455621"]}]},{"author_position":"last","author":{"id":"https://openalex.org/A5025166116","display_name":"Fernando Nottebohm","orcid":null,"observed_orcids":[]},"institutions":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/I83399316","display_name":"Rockefeller University","ror":"https://ror.org/0420db125","country_code":"US","type":"education","lineage":["https://openalex.org/I83399316"]}],"countries":["US"],"is_corresponding":false,"raw_author_name":"Fernando Nottebohm","raw_affiliation_strings":["Dorothea L. Leonhardt Professor, Laboratory of Animal Behavior, The Rockefeller University, New York, New York, USA"],"raw_orcid":null,"affiliations":[{"raw_affiliation_string":"Dorothea L. Leonhardt Professor, Laboratory of Animal Behavior, The Rockefeller University, New York, New York, USA","institution_ids":["https://openalex.org/I83399316"]}]}],"institutions":[],"countries_distinct_count":1,"institutions_distinct_count":2,"corresponding_author_ids":["https://openalex.org/A5072489428"],"corresponding_institution_ids":["https://openalex.org/I111455621"],"apc_list":null,"apc_paid":null,"fwci":0.0,"has_fulltext":true,"cited_by_count":0,"citation_normalized_percentile":{"value":0.08444444,"is_in_top_1_percent":false,"is_in_top_10_percent":false},"cited_by_percentile_year":null,"biblio":{"volume":"131","issue":"1","first_page":"116","last_page":"119"},"is_retracted":false,"is_paratext":false,"is_xpac":false,"primary_topic":{"id":"https://openalex.org/T11665","display_name":"Animal Vocal Communication and Behavior","score":0.9980000257492065,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1309","display_name":"Developmental Biology"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/13","display_name":"Biochemistry, Genetics and Molecular Biology"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/1","display_name":"Life Sciences"}},"topics":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/T11665","display_name":"Animal Vocal Communication and Behavior","score":0.9980000257492065,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1309","display_name":"Developmental Biology"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/13","display_name":"Biochemistry, Genetics and Molecular Biology"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/1","display_name":"Life Sciences"}},{"id":"https://openalex.org/T13495","display_name":"Biographical and Historical Analysis","score":0.00039999998989515007,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1202","display_name":"History"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/12","display_name":"Arts and Humanities"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},{"id":"https://openalex.org/T10174","display_name":"Animal Behavior and Reproduction","score":0.00019999999494757503,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1105","display_name":"Ecology, Evolution, Behavior and Systematics"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/11","display_name":"Agricultural and Biological Sciences"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/1","display_name":"Life Sciences"}}],"keywords":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/vocal-learning","display_name":"vocal learning","score":0.777999997138977},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/bird-song","display_name":"bird song","score":0.7059999704360962},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/song-learning","display_name":"song learning","score":0.5979999899864197},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/song-imitation","display_name":"song imitation","score":0.39500001072883606}],"concepts":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/C205649164","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q1071","display_name":"Geography","level":0,"score":0.33694419264793396}],"mesh":[],"locations_count":2,"locations":[{"id":"doi:10.1642/auk-13-240.1","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1642/auk-13-240.1","is_oa":true,"landing_page_url":"https://doi.org/10.1642/auk-13-240.1","pdf_url":"https://academic.oup.com/auk/article-pdf/131/1/116/26883190/auk0116.pdf","source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S152904045","display_name":"The Auk","issn_l":"0004-8038","issn":["0004-8038","1938-4254"],"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":true,"listed_in":["cwts-core","norway-1","poland-140","russia-white-list-1"],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/P4310311648","host_organization_name":"Oxford University Press","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/P4310311648","https://openalex.org/P4310311647"],"host_organization_lineage_names":["Oxford University Press","University of Oxford"],"type":"journal"},"license":null,"license_id":null,"version":"publishedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":true,"raw_source_name":"The Auk","raw_type":"journal-article"},{"id":"pmh:10.1642/AUK-13-240.1","doi":null,"is_oa":false,"landing_page_url":"http://www.bioone.org/doi/10.1642/AUK-13-240.1","pdf_url":null,"source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S4306402358","display_name":"BioOne Complete (BioOne)","issn_l":null,"issn":null,"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":false,"listed_in":[],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/I4210111627","host_organization_name":"BioOne","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/I4210111627"],"host_organization_lineage_names":[],"type":"repository"},"license":null,"license_id":null,"version":"submittedVersion","is_accepted":false,"is_published":false,"raw_source_name":"","raw_type":"text"}],"best_oa_location":{"id":"doi:10.1642/auk-13-240.1","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1642/auk-13-240.1","is_oa":true,"landing_page_url":"https://doi.org/10.1642/auk-13-240.1","pdf_url":"https://academic.oup.com/auk/article-pdf/131/1/116/26883190/auk0116.pdf","source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S152904045","display_name":"The Auk","issn_l":"0004-8038","issn":["0004-8038","1938-4254"],"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":true,"listed_in":["cwts-core","norway-1","poland-140","russia-white-list-1"],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/P4310311648","host_organization_name":"Oxford University Press","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/P4310311648","https://openalex.org/P4310311647"],"host_organization_lineage_names":["Oxford University Press","University of Oxford"],"type":"journal"},"license":null,"license_id":null,"version":"publishedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":true,"raw_source_name":"The Auk","raw_type":"journal-article"},"sustainable_development_goals":[],"study_designs":[],"awards":[],"funders":[],"has_content":{"grobid_xml":true,"pdf":true},"content_urls":{"pdf":"https://content.openalex.org/works/W1987986552.pdf","grobid_xml":"https://content.openalex.org/works/W1987986552.grobid-xml"},"referenced_works_count":0,"referenced_works":[],"related_works":["https://openalex.org/W2800542453","https://openalex.org/W2756658808","https://openalex.org/W1897731015","https://openalex.org/W2093832086","https://openalex.org/W170168824","https://openalex.org/W4232114218","https://openalex.org/W2922457290","https://openalex.org/W2322029782","https://openalex.org/W2483162208","https://openalex.org/W1978719956"],"abstract_inverted_index":{"Paul":[0,33,47,145,368,430,526,536,665,755,763,845,981,1249,1359,1515,1803,1907,1940,2153,2217,2410,2416,2453],"C.":[1],"Mundinger,":[2],"a":[3,7,45,49,63,83,103,109,119,206,218,238,248,312,338,359,401,422,432,481,491,661,676,720,729,819,841,878,903,960,985,1037,1045,1082,1086,1375,1459,1465,1488,1504,1562,1585,1683,1740,1749,1757,1795,1867,1932,1983,2066,2222,2227,2296,2418,2434,2448,2487,2566,2571,2580],"distinguished":[4],"scientist":[5],"and":[6,56,66,76,85,105,137,151,161,197,228,256,399,444,460,494,578,599,628,644,656,686,742,777,786,789,796,801,818,856,897,907,954,963,975,1019,1031,1062,1103,1112,1143,1157,1172,1180,1297,1315,1372,1387,1391,1551,1583,1615,1621,1640,1663,1668,1701,1725,1730,1767,1782,1790,1815,1876,1919,1922,1962,1966,1969,1979,1989,1993,2013,2024,2039,2050,2076,2092,2128,2154,2172,2225,2232,2245,2247,2272,2286,2303,2306,2316,2331,2342,2345,2355,2376,2397,2403,2411,2426,2436,2444,2450,2465,2468,2480,2482,2505,2510,2518,2523,2538,2543,2556,2574,2598,2610],"friend":[8],"of":[9,11,19,54,69,159,179,190,199,203,237,259,283,308,345,352,382,403,409,480,487,490,502,516,544,548,675,722,739,747,750,804,811,837,852,859,868,886,914,929,938,950,1043,1051,1136,1163,1167,1182,1284,1313,1334,1377,1441,1458,1464,1468,1474,1549,1564,1573,1587,1590,1618,1643,1652,1676,1689,1727,1744,1774,1784,1818,1879,1927,1945,1973,1977,1987,1997,2045,2068,2132,2179,2197,2211,2230,2278,2298,2324,2334,2382,2387,2394,2401,2405,2430,2442,2570,2593],"many":[10,254,282,1878],"us":[12,943,2594],"who":[13,2371,2422,2595],"are":[14,1126,1370,1447,1695,1787,2165,2182,2203,2606],"interested":[15],"in":[16,22,25,40,96,149,153,170,176,193,209,226,232,264,311,320,324,330,375,389,397,435,508,510,608,649,679,689,711,792,863,926,945,978,1015,1120,1150,1160,1196,1261,1352,1361,1539,1575,1627,1693,1793,1801,1813,1821,1831,1866,1885,2009,2029,2048,2062,2100,2121,2139,2150,2169,2190,2240,2269,2289,2314,2321,2352,2359,2471,2532,2535,2540,2544,2563],"the":[17,52,91,157,177,188,210,241,299,304,314,343,380,404,417,426,436,457,478,485,538,545,559,576,582,594,609,630,650,673,692,712,737,748,751,784,802,835,857,866,912,920,923,927,969,995,1013,1025,1041,1049,1052,1058,1117,1123,1129,1133,1144,1153,1197,1222,1252,1282,1311,1332,1397,1439,1451,1471,1482,1546,1559,1576,1588,1602,1616,1650,1664,1723,1733,1772,1780,1816,1822,1864,1880,1955,2000,2043,2052,2059,2078,2082,2096,2104,2108,2140,2170,2177,2187,2250,2257,2261,2275,2290,2332,2380,2383,2389,2406,2440,2554,2576,2588],"study":[18,276,408,449,672,836,858,1050,1484],"vocal":[20,280,309,322,465,517],"learning":[21,310,466,518,1494,1552,1608,1639,1671,2026],"birds,":[23,75,472],"died":[24],"Rye,":[26,2325],"New":[27,390,418,549,606,626,2101,2326],"York,":[28,550,627,2102,2327],"on":[29,36,78,187,590,622,768,840,1024,1438,1636,1660,1682,1722,1762,2249],"November":[30],"10,":[31],"2011.":[32],"was":[34,114,215,400,512,528,567,666,756,846,890,989,1011,1481,1829,1908,1941,1951,2221,2282,2309,2338,2477,2493],"born":[35],"October":[37],"12,":[38],"1934,":[39],"Highland":[41],"Park,":[42],"Illinois.":[43],"As":[44,634,2214],"boy,":[46],"had":[48,358,393,602,703,1229,1889,2413],"passion":[50],"for":[51,184,733,1055,1152,1169,1174,1192,1205,1294,1325,1477,1513,1605,1611,1779,2054,2201,2608],"lives":[53],"animals,":[55],"while":[57],"spending":[58],"time":[59,1914],"outdoors":[60],"he":[61,94,113,378,439,552,566,584,699,774,917,1069,1075,1080,1827,1837,1929,1960,2098,2220,2236,2253,2281,2294,2312,2317,2367,2474,2560,2604],"developed":[62,216],"quiet":[64],"patience":[65,2557],"keen":[67],"sense":[68],"observation.":[70],"He":[71,81,468,682,715,992,1115,1855,2308,2337,2347,2458,2476,2492,2528],"particularly":[72,328],"enjoyed":[73,2459],"watching":[74],"fishing\u2014especially":[77],"Wisconsin":[79],"lakes.":[80],"lived":[82,95],"fun":[84],"rather":[86,1534,1872],"wild":[87,1304,1411,1508,1845,2198],"youth,":[88],"especially":[89],"during":[90,1670,2042,2065],"summers":[92],"when":[93,112,212,333,377,731,1537,2311,2489],"North":[97],"Dakota":[98],"with":[99,416,779,865,1425,1771,2507,2558],"his":[100,131,140,147,162,185,564,571,766,780,793,915,930,946,972,1006,1811,1840,1844,1917,1937,1948,2155,2242,2264,2267,2279,2299,2322,2353,2455,2460,2463,2503,2508,2520,2526,2530,2536,2541,2548,2600],"grandparents,":[101],"driving":[102],"car":[104],"working":[106],"full-time":[107],"at":[108,385,425,541,1216,1310,1322,1450,2364,2439,2497],"summer":[110],"resort":[111],"only":[115,288,832,1093,1393,2008],"15.":[116],"His":[117,586,1624,2512],"father,":[118],"very":[120,1247,2276],"conservative":[121],"but":[122,291,349,880,1097,1871,1947],"deeply":[123,2467],"intellectual":[124],"Lutheran":[125],"minister,":[126],"could":[127,475],"never":[128,1930],"understand":[129],"why":[130,2129],"son":[132],"came":[133,202,814],"to":[134,142,261,275,289,293,302,361,448,500,529,570,574,580,605,671,696,759,783,829,933,974,1022,1071,1095,1100,1109,1128,1274,1280,1331,1337,1347,1355,1381,1405,1423,1485,1520,1553,1568,1599,1673,1696,1702,1705,1717,1739,1799,1809,1850,1915,1954,2034,2080,2095,2145,2186,2301,2485,2501,2525,2579],"accept":[135],"evolution":[136,178,198,825,940,1467],"ultimately":[138],"devoted":[139,1953],"life":[141,2456],"its":[143,613],"study.":[144],"received":[146],"B.S.":[148],"1956":[150],"M.S.":[152],"1958,":[154,2363],"both":[155,1591,1637,1728,2055],"from":[156,167,612,658,765,1065,1138,1225,1265,1366,2424],"University":[158,169,388,547,2385,2441],"Michigan,":[160],"Ph.D.,":[163],"under":[164,395],"Bill":[165],"Dilger,":[166,172],"Cornell":[168],"1967.":[171],"an":[173,513,935,1431,1807,1942,1964,1994,2238,2339,2398],"early":[174,610],"pioneer":[175],"behavior,":[180,1057],"is":[181,1495,1756,1982,2084],"best":[182],"remembered":[183],"work":[186,271,767,1224,1659,1773,2601],"heritability":[189],"nesting":[191],"habits":[192],"lovebirds.":[194],"The":[195,386,616,869,1363,1686,1971,2143],"development":[196,1440],"learned":[200,704,1056,1194,1356,1460,1684,1690,1746,1785],"behavior":[201,1357,1461],"age":[204,2365],"as":[205,217,319,456,473,707,728,902,932,1209,1288,1358,1629,1806,2103,2216,2379],"scientific":[207,843,1949],"pursuit":[208],"1950s,":[211],"bird":[213,326,601,1087,1158,1469,1691,2105],"song":[214,637,695,706,726,1178,1195,1237,1267,1554,1577,1638,1654,1661,1692,1714,1786,2040,2090],"model":[219,1084,1119,1475,1976],"system":[220],"by":[221,668,833,1238,1430,1492,1498,1853,1936,2260],"two":[222,554,794],"Europeans,":[223],"Holger":[224],"Poulsen":[225],"Denmark":[227],"William":[229],"H.":[230,296],"Thorpe":[231,297,316,396],"England.":[233],"They":[234],"took":[235,2349],"advantage":[236],"new":[239,300,405,482],"instrument,":[240],"sound":[242,260,446],"spectrograph,":[243],"which":[244,284,1016,1445,1644,1959,2081,2559],"converted":[245],"sounds":[246,334,2031],"into":[247,370,522,877,883,1753,2207,2587],"visual":[249],"display.":[250],"This":[251,267,505,597,1480,1542],"display":[252],"allowed":[253,1422],"frequency":[255,1183],"timing":[257],"features":[258,2134],"be":[262,719,827,895,1001,2027],"analyzed":[263,2001],"great":[265,2357],"detail.":[266],"technology":[268],"prompted":[269],"wonderful":[270],"that":[272,412,470,495,520,641,684,701,773,821,848,891,898,984,994,998,1079,1088,1105,1200,1231,1271,1291,1487,1517,1544,1561,1748,1776,1826,1858,1877,2152,2252,2473,2584],"used":[273,298,440,463,1804,2454],"birds":[274,290,724,1412,1426,1518],"basic":[277],"issues":[278],"about":[279,1066,1910,1958],"learning,":[281,1096,1316],"were":[285,335,1189,1203,1246,1272,1292,1597,1645,1860],"relevant":[286],"not":[287,757,1092,1448,1737,1861,1890,1900,2161],"also":[292,497,790,806,1098,1496,1797,2348,2447],"humans.":[294,1802],"W.":[295],"tool":[301],"make":[303,1916],"first":[305,587,1483],"detailed":[306],"description":[307],"songbird,":[313,1122],"Chaffinch.":[315],"showed":[317,1632],"that,":[318],"humans,":[321],"imitation":[323],"this":[325,371,441,669,705,717,761,812,892,1338,1974],"occurred":[327],"well":[329,1108,2494],"juveniles.":[331],"Moreover,":[332,1506],"played":[336],"over":[337,558,1656,1715],"speaker,":[339],"young":[340,1232],"Chaffinches":[341],"imitated":[342],"songs":[344,1283,1301,1384,1408,1420,1523,1589,2115],"their":[346,464,1170,1176,1193,1210,1236,1242,1295,1886,1896,2122,2360],"own":[347],"kind":[348],"disregarded":[350],"those":[351,659],"other":[353,488,1201,1206,1219,1341,1398,1699,2191,2545],"songbirds.":[354],"That":[355,533],"is,":[356],"they":[357,496,635,702,1140,1415,1859,1882,1904],"bias":[360],"learn":[362,1235,1390,1406,1417,1582],"Chaffinch":[363],"song.":[364],"Inheritance":[365],"shapes":[366],"learning.":[367,410,1262,1479],"stepped":[369],"rich":[372],"emerging":[373],"field":[374],"1967":[376],"joined":[379,537],"laboratory":[381,1110,1228],"Peter":[383,1226],"Marler":[384,392,437],"Rockefeller":[387,414],"York.":[391],"trained":[394],"Cambridge":[398],"leader":[402],"integrative":[406],"biological":[407],"At":[411,911,2292],"time,":[413],"shared":[415],"York":[419,607],"Zoological":[420],"Society":[421],"research":[423,556,1369,1814,1975,2188,2537],"facility":[424,443],"Bronx":[427],"Zoo.":[428],"When":[429],"became":[431,982,1076,2237],"postdoctoral":[433],"fellow":[434],"Laboratory,":[438],"joint":[442],"Marler's":[445,1227],"spectrograph":[447],"how":[450,1251,1677],"cardueline":[451],"finches":[452],"(small":[453],"songbirds":[454],"such":[455,640,959,1044,1208,1287,1349],"American":[458],"Goldfinch":[459],"Pine":[461],"Siskin)":[462],"skills.":[467],"found":[469,1116,1360,1516,2356],"these":[471,503,2030,2133,2147,2163,2533],"adults,":[474],"closely":[476],"imitate":[477,1281],"calls":[479,486,2018],"mate":[483],"or":[484,1005,1214,1218,1510,1571,1735,1846,2181],"members":[489],"winter":[492],"flock,":[493],"responded":[498],"preferentially":[499],"playbacks":[501],"calls.":[504],"work,":[506],"published":[507],"1970":[509],"Science,":[511],"elegant":[514],"example":[515],"plasticity":[519,1574],"persisted":[521],"adulthood.":[523],"Its":[524],"function,":[525],"suggested,":[527,1769],"strengthen":[530],"social":[531,909,1493],"bonds.":[532],"same":[534,651,693,713,1198,2060],"year,":[535],"Biology":[539],"faculty":[540],"Queens":[542,1323],"College":[543,1324],"City":[546],"where":[551,1139],"conducted":[553],"main":[555,1364],"programs":[557],"next":[560],"40":[561],"years.":[562],"Throughout":[563],"career":[565],"extraordinarily":[568],"dedicated":[569],"questions,":[572,817],"passionate":[573],"discover":[575],"answers,":[577],"driven":[579],"advance":[581],"ideas":[583,772,2509],"developed.":[585],"enterprise":[588],"focused":[589],"cultural":[591,677,769,824,939,979,1017,1489],"evolution,":[592,770,980],"using":[593,725],"House":[595,646,1073,1764,2088,2113],"Finch.":[596],"gregarious":[598],"loquacious":[600],"been":[603,1148,1345,1891,2004],"introduced":[604,2141],"1940s":[611],"native":[614,1127],"California.":[615],"population":[617],"spread":[618,2106],"through":[619,1863],"suburban":[620],"neighborhoods":[621],"Long":[623],"Island,":[624],"mainland":[625],"eventually":[629],"entire":[631,2194],"East":[632,2109],"Coast.":[633],"spread,":[636],"dialects":[638,727,2074,2097],"emerged,":[639],"all":[642,2146,2472,2603],"male":[643,1750],"female":[645,1433],"Finches":[647],"living":[648],"neighborhood":[652],"sang":[653,691],"similar":[654],"songs,":[655,1378],"different":[657,1083,1161,1253],"just":[660],"short":[662],"distance":[663],"away.":[664],"fascinated":[667],"opportunity":[670,1808],"emergence":[674],"tradition":[678],"real":[680],"time.":[681],"noticed":[683],"males":[685,1264,1694,1700],"females":[687],"engaging":[688,1921],"courtship":[690],"dialect":[694],"each":[697,1835],"other;":[698],"suggested":[700],"juveniles":[708],"growing":[709],"up":[710],"neighborhood.":[714],"thought":[716,813,1798,1950],"might":[718,941,1751,2025,2051],"case":[721],"local":[723,744,2335],"criterion":[730],"shopping":[732],"mates,":[734],"perhaps":[735,1791],"facilitating":[736],"process":[738,997],"pair":[740],"formation":[741],"preserving":[743],"adaptations.":[745],"Because":[746,1579],"limitations":[749],"techniques":[752],"then":[753,1742,2427],"available,":[754],"able":[758,828,1279,1598,2484,2500],"test":[760],"theory.":[762],"generalized":[764],"developing":[771],"would":[775,826,894,900,918,999,1047,1106,1259,1838,1883,1905,2372],"share":[776],"discuss":[778],"colleagues,":[781],"present":[782],"behavioral-biology":[785],"bird-song":[787,2199],"communities,":[788],"examine":[791],"favorite":[795,873],"longest-running":[797],"courses,":[798],"Animal":[799,1841],"Behavior":[800,1842],"Evolution":[803],"Culture\u2014both":[805],"favorites":[807],"among":[808],"students.":[809],"Out":[810],"several":[815,2319],"recurring":[816],"conviction":[820],"biologists":[822],"studying":[823],"answer":[830],"them":[831,1168,1533],"placing":[834],"culture":[838,1030,1032],"firmly":[839],"quantitative":[842],"basis.":[844],"disappointed":[847],"Richard":[849],"Dawkins's":[850],"idea":[851],"memes":[853],"(cultural":[854],"elements),":[855],"memetics\u2014apparently":[860],"so":[861,2005],"promising":[862],"1976":[864],"publication":[867],"Selfish":[870],"Gene":[871],"(Paul's":[872],"book)\u2014never":[874],"fully":[875,904,2470],"blossomed":[876],"science,":[879,2461],"instead":[881],"degenerated":[882],"distracting":[884],"talk":[885],"mind-viruses.":[887],"Paul's":[888,1318,1367,1594,1658,1760,2193],"hope":[889],"detour":[893],"rectified":[896],"memetics":[899],"flourish":[901],"empirical,":[905],"integrative,":[906],"hypothesis-driven":[908],"science.":[910],"end":[913],"courses":[916],"raise":[919],"question,":[921,1957],"leaving":[922],"possibilities":[924],"lingering":[925],"imaginations":[928],"students,":[931],"whether":[934],"explanatory":[936],"science":[937,961],"guide":[942],"toward,":[944],"words,":[947],"\u201ca":[948],"mix":[949],"intelligently":[951],"self-interested,":[952],"democratic,":[953],"science-based":[955],"policies\u2026":[956],".":[957],"Would":[958,1263],"address":[962],"help":[964],"solve":[965],"big-issue":[966],"problems":[967],"facing":[968],"world?\u201d":[970],"Despite":[971],"contribution":[973,1548],"lifelong":[976],"interest":[977,1968],"convinced":[983,1078],"purely":[986],"cultural-inheritance":[987],"paradigm":[988],"too":[990,2019],"simple.":[991],"suspected":[993],"interactive":[996],"later":[1000,2265,2373],"called":[1002],"\u201cgene\u2013culture":[1003],"coevolution,\u201d":[1004],"preferred":[1007],"term":[1008],"\u201cbiocultural":[1009],"evolution,\u201d":[1010],"really":[1012],"way":[1014,1199],"change":[1018,2138],"diversification":[1020],"tended":[1021],"happen,":[1023],"long":[1026],"view.":[1027],"Genes":[1028],"affect":[1029],"affects":[1033],"genes,":[1034],"possibly":[1035],"yielding":[1036],"feedback":[1038],"loop.":[1039],"Testing":[1040],"components":[1042],"hypothesis":[1046],"require":[1048],"genetic":[1053,1101,1456,1499,1569,1603,1634],"basis":[1054,1604],"interaction":[1059],"between":[1060,1462,1501,1666,2021,2075],"nature":[1061,1667],"nurture.":[1063],"Thus,":[1064,1185],"1975,":[1067],"although":[1068],"continued":[1070],"record":[1072],"Finches,":[1074,1765],"increasingly":[1077],"needed":[1081],"system:":[1085],"exhibited":[1089],"behavioral":[1090],"variation":[1091],"due":[1094,1099],"variation,":[1102],"one":[1104,1266,1713],"take":[1107],"rearing":[1111],"breeding":[1113,1320,1595,2047],"experiments.":[1114],"ideal":[1118],"another":[1121,1285,1716],"canary.":[1124],"Canaries":[1125,1146],"Canary":[1130],"Islands,":[1131],"off":[1132,1698],"western":[1134],"coast":[1135],"Africa,":[1137],"colonized":[1141],"Madeira":[1142],"Azores.":[1145],"have":[1147,1348,2056],"bred":[1149,1165,1273,1293,1380,1512,1519],"captivity":[1151],"past":[1154],"500":[1155],"years,":[1156,2266],"fanciers":[1159],"parts":[1162],"Europe":[1164],"some":[1166,1186,1642,1894,2131,2159],"plumage,":[1171],"others":[1173],"song\u2014particularly":[1175],"pitch,":[1177],"length,":[1179],"extent":[1181],"modulation.":[1184],"canary":[1187,1254,1368,1848,2022,2073],"breeds":[1188,2064],"artificially":[1190],"selected":[1191,1204],"animals":[1202],"traits":[1207],"meat,":[1211],"size,":[1212],"color,":[1213,1514],"skills":[1215],"hunting":[1217],"work.":[1220],"By":[1221],"1970s,":[1223],"shown":[1230],"canaries":[1233,1290,1305,1379,1509,1511,1581],"normally":[1234],"imitating":[1239],"adults":[1240],"within":[1241,1503,2077],"hearing.":[1243],"These":[1244,1453],"imitations":[1245],"accurate.":[1248],"wondered":[1250],"breeds,":[1255,1593],"having":[1256,2003],"diverged":[1257],"genetically,":[1258],"differ":[1260],"strain\u2014say,":[1268],"German":[1269],"rollers":[1270,1386],"sing":[1275,1298,1382,1521,1525,1584],"low-pitched,":[1276],"\u201crolling\u201d":[1277],"songs\u2014be":[1278],"strain,":[1286],"Border":[1289],"plumage":[1296,2038],"bubbly":[1299],"high-pitched":[1300,1407],"much":[1302,1409,2215],"like":[1303,1308,1410],"do?":[1306],"Questions":[1307],"this,":[1309],"nexus":[1312],"genes":[1314,1550,2053],"guided":[1317],"continuous":[1319],"experiments":[1321,1596],"more":[1326,1418],"than":[1327],"three":[1328],"decades.":[1329],"Testament":[1330],"power":[1333],"artificial":[1335],"selection,":[1336],"day":[1339],"no":[1340,1435],"animal":[1342,1478],"species":[1343,2083],"has":[1344,1434,1566],"discovered":[1346],"pronounced":[1350],"differences":[1351,1500],"inherited":[1353,1607],"predispositions":[1354,1724],"canaries.":[1362],"results":[1365,1454,1881],"striking":[1371],"unambiguous.":[1373],"Given":[1374],"choice":[1376],"low-pitched":[1383,1394,1419,1522],"(e.g.,":[1385,2125,2135],"waterslagers)":[1388],"will":[1389,1416,1524,2173],"produce":[1392],"songs.":[1395],"On":[1396],"hand,":[1399],"typical":[1400],"canaries,":[1401,1763,2049],"including":[1402],"Borders,":[1403],"prefer":[1404],"do":[1413,2112],"(although":[1414],"if":[1421],"interact":[1424],"singing":[1427],"them).":[1428],"Cross-fostering":[1429],"alien-strain":[1432],"noticeable":[1436],"effect":[1437],"canaries'":[1442],"song-learning":[1443],"preferences,":[1444],"therefore":[1446],"acquired":[1449],"nest.":[1452],"demonstrate":[1455],"divergence":[1457],"strains":[1463],"species:":[1466],"song,":[1470,1741],"poster":[1472],"child":[1473],"systems":[1476],"show":[1486],"trait":[1490],"transmitted":[1491],"modulated":[1497],"individuals":[1502],"species.":[1505],"unlike":[1507],"nearly":[1526],"normal":[1527],"tours":[1528],"(repeated":[1529],"syllables),":[1530],"though":[1531],"assembling":[1532],"simplistically,":[1535],"even":[1536,1545,1648,1901],"reared":[1538],"acoustic":[1540],"isolation!":[1541],"suggests":[1543],"relative":[1547],"output":[1555],"can":[1556,1680],"evolve,":[1557],"raising":[1558],"possibility":[1560],"history":[1563,2044,2067],"selection":[1565,1679,1719],"led":[1567],"assimilation":[1570],"reduction":[1572],"system.":[1578],"hybrid":[1580],"combination":[1586],"parental":[1592],"elucidate":[1600],"further":[1601],"strain-specific":[1606],"predispositions,":[1609],"demonstrating,":[1610],"instance,":[1612,1834,2016,2202,2235],"polygenic":[1613],"control":[1614],"presence":[1617],"particular":[1619,1653],"sex-linked":[1620],"autosomal":[1622],"effects.":[1623],"final":[1625,1938],"experiments,":[1626],"review":[1628],"we":[1630],"write,":[1631],"distinct":[1633],"effects":[1635],"production,":[1641],"remarkably":[1646],"specific,":[1647],"influencing":[1649],"preference":[1651],"elements":[1655],"others.":[1657],"function":[1662],"interplay":[1665],"nurture":[1669],"contributes":[1672],"our":[1674],"understanding":[1675],"sexual":[1678],"operate":[1681],"behavior.":[1685],"primary":[1687,1874],"functions":[1688],"ward":[1697],"\u201ccharm\u201d":[1703],"females,":[1704],"use":[1706],"Darwin's":[1707],"term.":[1708],"For":[1709,1833,2015,2234],"heritable":[1710],"biases":[1711],"favoring":[1712],"emerge,":[1718],"must":[1720],"act":[1721],"preferences":[1726],"sender":[1729],"receiver.":[1731],"If":[1732],"receiver\u2014male":[1734],"female\u2014does":[1736],"respond":[1738],"regardless":[1743],"any":[1745],"details":[1747],"put":[1752],"it,":[1754,2609],"it":[1755],"wasted":[1758],"effort.":[1759],"observations":[1761],"goldfinches,":[1766],"siskins":[1768],"along":[1770],"others,":[1775],"brain":[1777],"pathways":[1778],"production":[1781],"perception":[1783],"tightly":[1788],"intertwined":[1789],"evolve":[1792],"concert,":[1794],"phenomenon":[1796],"occur":[1800],"teaching":[1805],"immerse":[1810],"students":[1812,1843,2156],"consideration":[1817],"unanswered":[1819],"questions":[1820,1825,2148],"field,":[1823],"often":[1824],"himself":[1828,1898],"engaged":[1830],"addressing.":[1832],"year":[1836],"give":[1839],"captive":[1847],"recordings":[1849],"reanalyze,":[1851],"individual":[1852,2224],"individual.":[1854],"made":[1856,2184],"clear":[1857],"going":[1862],"motions":[1865],"prefabricated":[1868],"lab":[1869,1887],"exercise,":[1870],"performing":[1873],"research,":[1875],"report":[1884],"manuals":[1888],"published.":[1892],"In":[1893,1924,2263,2362],"cases,":[1895],"professor":[1897],"did":[1899,2017,2087,2130,2561],"know":[1902],"what":[1903,2093],"discover.":[1906],"zealous":[1909],"teaching,":[1911,1928,2539],"taking":[1912],"inordinate":[1913],"lectures":[1918],"labs":[1920],"influential.":[1923],"35":[1925],"years":[1926],"missed":[1931],"class":[1933],"until":[1934],"weakened":[1935],"illness.":[1939],"indefatigable":[1943],"collector":[1944],"data,":[1946,1999],"always":[1952,2255],"current":[1956],"possessed":[1961],"conveyed":[1963],"intense":[1965],"single-minded":[1967],"excitement.":[1970],"outcome":[1972],"\u201coverproduction":[1978],"selective":[1980,2046],"attrition\u201d":[1981],"relatively":[1984],"small":[1985],"collection":[1986,2196],"dense":[1988],"carefully":[1990],"considered":[1991],"publications,":[1992],"enormous":[1995,2350],"repository":[1996],"unpublished":[1998],"portions":[2002],"far":[2006],"presented":[2007],"lectures,":[2010],"dissertations,":[2011],"theses,":[2012],"posters.":[2014],"diverge":[2020,2091],"strains,":[2023],"involved":[2028],"generally":[2032],"presumed":[2033],"lack":[2035],"it?":[2036],"Did":[2037],"coevolve":[2041],"migrated":[2057],"onto":[2058],"chromosomes":[2061],"certain":[2063],"coselection?":[2069],"Are":[2070],"there":[2071],"natural":[2072,2589],"islands":[2079],"native?":[2085],"How":[2086,2111],"Finch":[2089,2114],"happened":[2094],"reported":[2099],"throughout":[2107,2126],"Coast?":[2110],"vary":[2116],"across":[2117],"broad":[2118],"geographic":[2119],"stretches":[2120],"ancestral":[2123],"range":[2124,2229],"California),":[2127],"dialects)":[2136],"subsequently":[2137],"population?":[2142],"answers":[2144],"lie":[2149],"data":[2151,2164],"collected.":[2157],"Gradually,":[2158],"(but":[2160],"all)":[2162],"being":[2166,2183,2205],"placed":[2167],"back":[2168,2577],"pipeline":[2171],"likely":[2174],"yet":[2175,2483],"see":[2176],"light":[2178],"day,":[2180],"available":[2185],"community":[2189],"ways.":[2192,2546],"extensive":[2195],"recordings,":[2200],"currently":[2204],"accessioned":[2206],"Cornell's":[2208],"Macaulay":[2209],"Library":[2210],"Natural":[2212],"Sounds.":[2213],"liked":[2218,2516],"biology,":[2219],"well-balanced":[2223],"cultivated":[2226],"diverse":[2228],"activities":[2231],"interests.":[2233],"expert":[2239],"managing":[2241],"retirement":[2243],"accounts":[2244,2251],"stocks,":[2246],"returns":[2248],"managed":[2254],"beat":[2256],"ones":[2258],"handled":[2259],"professionals.":[2262],"interests":[2268],"physics,":[2270],"economics,":[2271],"politics":[2273,2305],"grew\u2014on":[2274],"week":[2277],"death,":[2280],"reading":[2283],"Freakonomics":[2284],"voraciously":[2285],"writing":[2287],"notes":[2288],"margins.":[2291],"times,":[2293],"kept":[2295],"journal":[2297],"responses":[2300],"national":[2302],"international":[2304],"events.":[2307],"unstoppable":[2310],"believed":[2313,2466],"something,":[2315],"spearheaded":[2318],"causes":[2320],"town":[2323],"achieving":[2328],"tax":[2329],"reform":[2330],"protection":[2333],"wetlands.":[2336],"avid":[2340],"boater":[2341],"loved":[2343,2462],"skiing":[2344],"snorkeling.":[2346],"pride":[2351],"family":[2354],"pleasure":[2358],"company.":[2361],"24,":[2366],"married":[2368],"Mary":[2369,2412],"O'Neil,":[2370],"achieve":[2374],"professional":[2375,2513],"public":[2377],"prominence":[2378],"Dean":[2381],"Columbia":[2384,2428],"School":[2386,2429],"Nursing,":[2388],"Edward":[2390],"M.":[2391],"Kennedy":[2392],"Professor":[2393],"Health":[2395],"Policy,":[2396],"outspoken":[2399],"defender":[2400],"nursing":[2402],"proponent":[2404],"nurse":[2407],"practitioner":[2408],"movement.":[2409],"four":[2414],"children:":[2415],"(1959),":[2417],"lawyer;":[2419,2449],"Ann":[2420],"(1960),":[2421],"graduated":[2423],"Stanford":[2425],"Nursing;":[2431],"Tom":[2432],"(1962),":[2433],"physiologist":[2435],"diabetes":[2437],"researcher":[2438],"Washington;":[2443],"Elizabeth":[2445],"(1964),":[2446],"seven":[2451],"grandchildren.":[2452],"well.":[2457],"family,":[2464,2542],"acted":[2469],"did.":[2475],"incredibly":[2478],"generous":[2479],"gracious,":[2481],"conjure":[2486],"storm":[2488],"treated":[2490],"unethically.":[2491],"liked,":[2495],"riveting":[2496],"dinner":[2498],"parties,":[2499],"fascinate":[2502],"neighbors":[2504],"friends":[2506],"stories.":[2511],"colleagues":[2514],"thoroughly":[2515],"him":[2517,2597],"admired":[2519],"kindness,":[2521],"integrity,":[2522],"devotion":[2524],"ideas.":[2527],"left":[2529],"mark":[2531],"relationships,":[2534],"Today":[2547],"family's":[2549],"beautiful":[2550],"Rye":[2551],"property":[2552],"exhibits":[2553],"perseverance":[2555],"everything":[2562],"life\u2014he":[2564],"sculpted":[2565],"perennial":[2567],"garden":[2568],"out":[2569],"brushy":[2572],"knoll,":[2573],"extended":[2575],"lawn":[2578],"peaceful":[2581],"sandy":[2582],"beach":[2583],"melds":[2585],"harmoniously":[2586],"waterside":[2590],"vegetation.":[2591],"Those":[2592],"knew":[2596],"appreciate":[2599],"celebrate":[2602],"did,":[2605],"grateful":[2607],"miss":[2611],"him.":[2612]},"counts_by_year":[],"updated_date":"2026-10-27T15:51:10.671819","created_date":"2016-06-24T00:00:00"}