{"id":"https://openalex.org/W1978626348","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1097/00003086-200302000-00002","title":"The Medieval Medical Third Party: Compulsory Consultation and Malpractice Insurance","display_name":"The Medieval Medical Third Party: Compulsory Consultation and Malpractice Insurance","publication_year":2003,"publication_date":"2003-02-01","ids":{"openalex":"https://openalex.org/W1978626348","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1097/00003086-200302000-00002","mag":"1978626348","pmid":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12567121"},"language":"en","primary_location":{"id":"doi:10.1097/00003086-200302000-00002","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1097/00003086-200302000-00002","is_oa":false,"landing_page_url":"https://doi.org/10.1097/00003086-200302000-00002","pdf_url":null,"source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S191421250","display_name":"Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research","issn_l":"0009-921X","issn":["0009-921X","1528-1132"],"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":true,"listed_in":["cwts-core","dongbi-a","doyens","jufo-2","ki-jl-2","medline","norway-2","poland-140","russia-white-list-1","vabb-shw"],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/P4310315671","host_organization_name":"Lippincott Williams & Wilkins","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/P4310315671","https://openalex.org/P4310318547"],"host_organization_lineage_names":["Lippincott Williams & Wilkins","Wolters Kluwer"],"type":"journal"},"license":null,"license_id":null,"version":"publishedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":true,"raw_source_name":"Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research","raw_type":"journal-article"},"volume":null,"type":"article","indexed_in":["crossref","pubmed"],"open_access":{"is_oa":false,"oa_status":"closed","oa_url":null,"any_repository_has_fulltext":false},"authorships":[{"author_position":"first","author":{"id":"https://openalex.org/A5008130052","display_name":"Madeleine Pelner Cosman","orcid":null,"observed_orcids":[]},"institutions":[],"countries":[],"is_corresponding":true,"raw_author_name":"Madeleine Pelner Cosman","raw_affiliation_strings":["97/01.blo.0000049699.69467.2c","(Reprinted with permission from Cosman MP: The medieval medical third party: Compulsory consultation and malpractice insurance. Ann Plast Surg 8:152\u2013162, 1982.)","DOI: 10.1097/01.blo.0000049699.69467.2c"],"raw_orcid":null,"affiliations":[{"raw_affiliation_string":"97/01.blo.0000049699.69467.2c","institution_ids":[]},{"raw_affiliation_string":"(Reprinted with permission from Cosman MP: The medieval medical third party: Compulsory consultation and malpractice insurance. Ann Plast Surg 8:152\u2013162, 1982.)","institution_ids":[]},{"raw_affiliation_string":"DOI: 10.1097/01.blo.0000049699.69467.2c","institution_ids":[]}]}],"institutions":[],"countries_distinct_count":0,"institutions_distinct_count":0,"corresponding_author_ids":["https://openalex.org/A5008130052"],"corresponding_institution_ids":[],"apc_list":null,"apc_paid":null,"fwci":0.0,"has_fulltext":false,"cited_by_count":0,"citation_normalized_percentile":{"value":0.24385965,"is_in_top_1_percent":false,"is_in_top_10_percent":false},"cited_by_percentile_year":null,"biblio":{"volume":"407","issue":"407","first_page":"3","last_page":"10"},"is_retracted":false,"is_paratext":false,"is_xpac":false,"primary_topic":{"id":"https://openalex.org/T12339","display_name":"Medical Malpractice and Liability Issues","score":0.9595000147819519,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/3611","display_name":"Pharmacy"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/36","display_name":"Health Professions"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/4","display_name":"Health Sciences"}},"topics":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/T12339","display_name":"Medical Malpractice and Liability Issues","score":0.9595000147819519,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/3611","display_name":"Pharmacy"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/36","display_name":"Health Professions"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/4","display_name":"Health Sciences"}},{"id":"https://openalex.org/T13275","display_name":"Medical and Health Sciences Research","score":0.024000000208616257,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/2739","display_name":"Public Health, Environmental and Occupational Health"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/27","display_name":"Medicine"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/4","display_name":"Health Sciences"}},{"id":"https://openalex.org/T12324","display_name":"History of Medicine Studies","score":0.0052999998442828655,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1202","display_name":"History"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/12","display_name":"Arts and Humanities"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}}],"keywords":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/medieval-medicine","display_name":"medieval medicine","score":0.9359999895095825},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/professional-liability-insurance","display_name":"professional liability insurance","score":0.6819999814033508},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/peer-review","display_name":"peer review","score":0.7110000252723694},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/malpractice-legislation","display_name":"malpractice legislation","score":0.6480000019073486},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/medical-ethics","display_name":"medical ethics","score":0.5130000114440918},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/physician-patient-relationship","display_name":"physician-patient relationship","score":0.7300000190734863},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/health-insurance","display_name":"health insurance","score":0.3440000116825104},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/history-of-medical-law","display_name":"history of medical law","score":0.6520000100135803},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/15th-century","display_name":"15th century","score":0.5199999809265137},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/health-legislation","display_name":"health care legislation","score":0.625}],"concepts":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/C514090530","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q2565355","display_name":"Medical malpractice","level":3,"score":0.6220991015434265},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C2776798817","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q318836","display_name":"Malpractice","level":2,"score":0.5987551212310791},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C199539241","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q7748","display_name":"Law","level":1,"score":0.5985935926437378},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C71924100","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q11190","display_name":"Medicine","level":0,"score":0.5634349584579468},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C2777351106","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q49371","display_name":"Legislation","level":2,"score":0.549562931060791},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C94625758","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q7163","display_name":"Politics","level":2,"score":0.4302677512168884},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C17744445","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q36442","display_name":"Political science","level":0,"score":0.2596921920776367}],"mesh":[{"descriptor_ui":"D007351","descriptor_name":"Insurance, Liability","qualifier_ui":"Q000266","qualifier_name":"history","is_major_topic":true},{"descriptor_ui":"D008318","descriptor_name":"Malpractice","qualifier_ui":"Q000266","qualifier_name":"history","is_major_topic":true},{"descriptor_ui":"D012017","descriptor_name":"Referral and Consultation","qualifier_ui":"Q000266","qualifier_name":"history","is_major_topic":true},{"descriptor_ui":"D014481","descriptor_name":"United States","qualifier_ui":null,"qualifier_name":null,"is_major_topic":false},{"descriptor_ui":"D049673","descriptor_name":"History, 20th Century","qualifier_ui":null,"qualifier_name":null,"is_major_topic":false},{"descriptor_ui":"D049691","descriptor_name":"History, Medieval","qualifier_ui":null,"qualifier_name":null,"is_major_topic":false}],"locations_count":2,"locations":[{"id":"doi:10.1097/00003086-200302000-00002","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1097/00003086-200302000-00002","is_oa":false,"landing_page_url":"https://doi.org/10.1097/00003086-200302000-00002","pdf_url":null,"source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S191421250","display_name":"Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research","issn_l":"0009-921X","issn":["0009-921X","1528-1132"],"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":true,"listed_in":["cwts-core","dongbi-a","doyens","jufo-2","ki-jl-2","medline","norway-2","poland-140","russia-white-list-1","vabb-shw"],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/P4310315671","host_organization_name":"Lippincott Williams & Wilkins","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/P4310315671","https://openalex.org/P4310318547"],"host_organization_lineage_names":["Lippincott Williams & Wilkins","Wolters Kluwer"],"type":"journal"},"license":null,"license_id":null,"version":"publishedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":true,"raw_source_name":"Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research","raw_type":"journal-article"},{"id":"pmid:12567121","doi":null,"is_oa":false,"landing_page_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12567121","pdf_url":null,"source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S4306525036","display_name":"PubMed","issn_l":null,"issn":null,"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":false,"listed_in":[],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/I1299303238","host_organization_name":"National Institutes of Health","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/I1299303238"],"host_organization_lineage_names":[],"type":"repository"},"license":null,"license_id":null,"version":"publishedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":true,"raw_source_name":"Clinical orthopaedics and related research","raw_type":"Biography"}],"best_oa_location":null,"sustainable_development_goals":[],"study_designs":[],"awards":[],"funders":[],"has_content":{"pdf":false,"grobid_xml":false},"content_urls":null,"referenced_works_count":0,"referenced_works":[],"related_works":["https://openalex.org/W2803487674","https://openalex.org/W2473004330","https://openalex.org/W561828218","https://openalex.org/W332950752","https://openalex.org/W2315281388","https://openalex.org/W109828495","https://openalex.org/W7001014296","https://openalex.org/W2102147905","https://openalex.org/W2010224152","https://openalex.org/W381498646"],"abstract_inverted_index":{"Madeleine":[0,125],"P.":[1],"Cosman":[2,70,109],"(Fig":[3],"1)":[4],"is":[5,53,99,110,168,479,776,1210,2657,2922,2945,3289],"a":[6,18,25,32,38,54,85,117,187,211,235,330,348,466,514,536,553,562,574,756,764,777,979,1092,1183,1262,1317,1353,1382,1726,1755,1759,1818,1824,1973,2023,2070,2099,2126,2193,2235,2253,2279,2312,2325,2451,2476,2527,2533,2538,2560,2586,2649,2679,2685,2743,2823,2954,3207,3246,3280,3295,3405,3481,3487,3599,3628,3674,3687,3692],"genuine":[7],"New":[8,49,65],"Yorker.":[9],"She":[10,52,81,98],"has":[11,82,151,352],"an":[12,525,769,1174,2371,2755,3003,3648],"undergraduate":[13],"degree":[14,20,27,40],"from":[15,21,28,41,232,1063,1078,1083,1124,1149,1155,1157,1162,1426,1432,1474,1860,2218,2224,2349,3010,3088,3291,3727,3739,3741,3760,3773,3784],"Barnard":[16],"College,":[17,23],"Master\u2019s":[19],"Hunter":[22],"and":[24,78,93,95,157,197,210,234,238,256,267,301,307,357,376,384,414,438,461,484,503,538,570,586,595,669,733,794,798,820,834,861,873,879,890,916,948,959,1010,1019,1021,1087,1117,1133,1166,1180,1192,1205,1239,1251,1290,1298,1349,1400,1404,1442,1467,1565,1581,1639,1649,1656,1679,1708,1716,1721,1750,1840,1915,1932,1956,2007,2020,2036,2053,2058,2086,2102,2146,2271,2298,2323,2395,2416,2427,2438,2457,2604,2617,2628,2691,2705,2731,2764,2770,2773,2786,2796,2806,2812,2836,2838,2843,2876,2899,2904,2910,2933,2968,3085,3091,3101,3195,3204,3214,3253,3347,3367,3376,3399,3429,3440,3515,3576,3624,3710,3738],"PhD":[26,182],"Columbia":[29],"University.":[30],"While":[31,2952,3402,3795],"Jacob":[33],"Burns":[34],"Fellow,":[35],"she":[36,3323],"gained":[37,3412],"JD":[39],"the":[42,58,100,111,132,139,143,170,243,264,268,320,341,390,404,480,533,593,611,621,630,640,651,658,703,710,717,722,739,745,751,774,787,801,804,824,842,864,900,957,960,963,968,997,1008,1040,1046,1053,1076,1084,1125,1143,1151,1188,1227,1246,1258,1267,1274,1280,1358,1362,1374,1396,1416,1438,1448,1465,1500,1541,1549,1554,1557,1568,1582,1594,1605,1619,1677,1709,1719,1777,1787,1800,1861,1864,1872,1907,1912,1923,1992,2004,2045,2064,2079,2087,2094,2103,2186,2337,2344,2350,2378,2414,2472,2480,2485,2489,2496,2501,2551,2571,2575,2579,2590,2613,2645,2669,2689,2695,2716,2750,2776,2797,2810,2813,2817,2826,2831,2847,2897,2923,2940,2946,2975,2990,3035,3044,3072,3076,3080,3083,3098,3110,3170,3189,3193,3197,3202,3217,3230,3236,3242,3250,3275,3317,3325,3327,3337,3342,3361,3364,3371,3388,3394,3396,3400,3432,3450,3460,3494,3502,3505,3522,3525,3542,3553,3556,3561,3568,3570,3574,3585,3609,3622,3668,3705,3742,3801,3819],"Benjamin":[43],"Cardozo":[44],"School":[45],"of":[46,57,61,64,102,113,147,154,202,226,245,252,259,386,456,474,482,491,567,597,623,635,642,660,667,698,705,716,719,726,738,747,750,826,871,935,962,971,990,996,1003,1065,1069,1075,1153,1248,1266,1273,1283,1285,1292,1319,1330,1345,1361,1386,1402,1418,1437,1447,1455,1525,1556,1593,1618,1622,1702,1738,1748,1773,1786,1830,1871,1903,1922,1926,1970,2001,2143,2227,2257,2267,2282,2304,2374,2377,2388,2413,2526,2594,2621,2636,2654,2682,2700,2707,2745,2757,2759,2819,2825,2849,2961,2972,2992,2998,3023,3043,3055,3071,3159,3192,3199,3221,3241,3269,3277,3294,3300,3311,3339,3360,3363,3449,3489,3496,3509,3512,3524,3527,3567,3578,3587,3613,3691,3694,3778,3787],"Law":[47],"in":[48,247,309,383,518,520,561,650,657,823,941,954,1052,1256,1327,1424,1457,1480,1536,1559,1586,1599,1604,1610,1624,1700,1752,1879,1967,2010,2029,2056,2153,2170,2192,2197,2204,2524,2702,2713,2721,2749,2939,3102,3229,3245,3298,3408,3479,3590,3686],"York":[50],"City.":[51],"Professor":[55],"Emeritus":[56],"City":[59,62,2724],"College":[60,1747],"University":[63],"York.":[66],"For":[67,512,1999],"many":[68,2171,3031,3262],"years,":[69,2336],"taught":[71],"medical":[72,74,76,79,94,119,194,248,344,364,387,424,442,475,502,559,564,678,859,892,1191,1259,1286,1806,1937,1944,1954,3434,3443],"students":[73],"law,":[75,3395],"business,":[77],"history.":[80],"long":[83],"been":[84,353,382,1990,1997,2042,2051,3748,3753],"popular":[86],"lecturer":[87],"on":[88,105,546,620,730,987,1185,1776,2633,2668,2739,2822,3603,3677,3699],"health":[89,91,335,2431,2461],"legislation,":[90],"policy,":[92],"legal":[96,743,840,1320,3186,3444,3611],"ethics.":[97,931,1253],"author":[101],"several":[103,584,2208],"books":[104],"medieval":[106,189,423,498,598,757,781,2205,3588],"medicine.":[107],"Currently,":[108],"President":[112],"Medical":[114,183,740,917,1134],"Equity":[115],"Inc,":[116],"national":[118],"law":[120,412,1144,1843,3461],"practice":[121,146,872,1186,1222,2307],"brokerage.Fig":[122],"1.:":[123],"Dr.":[124,3594],"Pelner":[126],"Cosman.The":[127],"following":[128],"classic":[129],"article":[130],"shows":[131],"old":[133,3820],"saying,":[134],"\u201cThe":[135],"more":[136,140,760,2222,2357,3264],"things":[137],"change,":[138],"they":[141,695,807,1057,1459,1682,1698,2122,2423,2800,2866,3060,3118,3130,3175,3232],"remain":[142],"same.\u201d":[144],"The":[145,604,866,1168,1207,1742,1977,2012,2129,2360,2652,2729,2996,3219,3378,3716,3723,3755,3781],"medicine":[148,955],"historically":[149],"always":[150],"had":[152,1112,1683,1782,1988,2050,2076,2089,2166,2207,2425,2867,2892,3048,3061,3329,3404,3752],"problems":[153],"risk":[155,762,3508],"management":[156],"medicolegal":[158],"problems.":[159,177,3116],"This":[160,579,700,742,1072,1723,2155,2188,3238,3442,3498,3580,3641],"paper":[161],"will":[162,3007,3014],"remind":[163],"us":[164,551],"that":[165,755,853,938,1015,1056,1160,1477,1553,1567,1987,2031,2445,2979,3094,3286,3391,3500,3552,3744],"our":[166,720,3655],"generation":[167],"not":[169,523,851,909,1571,2124,2319,2341,2447,2543,2567,2883,3015,3123,3223,3520,3617,3796],"first":[171,746,1774],"to":[172,219,221,317,428,434,486,543,557,629,709,780,800,809,816,876,956,999,1037,1039,1098,1114,1129,1176,1181,1198,1310,1395,1430,1488,1573,1597,1644,1673,1676,1684,1689,1695,1713,1718,1757,1783,1790,1853,1863,1910,1965,2084,2116,2120,2167,2301,2306,2310,2366,2492,2508,2512,2530,2544,2578,2589,2641,2734,2781,2829,2846,2868,2893,2896,2958,2966,3001,3049,3062,3106,3125,3132,3139,3144,3148,3169,3179,3210,3235,3274,3316,3330,3336,3356,3423,3493,3608,3631,3654,3703,3711,3792],"be":[173,1059,1674,1685,1714,1797,1890,2168,2217,2243,2285,2302,2330,2347,2434,2448,2493,2513,2531,2541,2678,2894,3107,3145,3357,3549,3790],"plagued":[174],"by":[175,329,355,441,471,572,691,895,927,930,1007,1226,1237,1245,1288,1352,1407,1464,1842,2173,2291,2393,2466,2495,2626,3172,3387],"such":[176,555,1614,3154,3306,3700],"Leonard":[178],"F.":[179],"Peltier,":[180],"MD,":[181],"third-party":[184],"intervention":[185,443,3428],"was":[186,713,759,856,923,1173,1233,1244,1261,1340,1740,1766,1867,1906,1963,2014,2097,2139,2529,2565,3355,3385,3446,3544,3598],"venerable":[188],"tradition.":[190],"Fifteenth":[191],"century":[192,589,1318],"London\u2019s":[193,731,975,1387,1745,2198],"malpractice":[195,212,275,287,416,425,505,529,752,883,921,1364,1612,1885,1980,2701,2980,3644,3661,3688,3799],"legislation":[196,485,922,1613,2177,2608],"court":[198,429,1966,2030],"cases":[199,280,365,426,884,1472,1504,1951,2891,3052,3121],"contained":[200,1603],"forms":[201,258],"peer":[203,377,1322,1337],"review,":[204,464],"compulsory":[205,272,398,544,1367,1904,2157,2390,2926,3039,3383,3425,3592,3805],"consultation":[206,273,323,399,545,1368,1822,1905,1989,2057,2148,2158,2482,2523,2929,3040,3384,3620,3751,3806],"for":[207,216,261,278,283,312,343,359,395,400,430,509,693,844,1023,1031,1107,1369,1451,1492,1792,1821,1834,2018,2135,2151,2238,2245,2278,2293,2384,2479,2569,2574,2584,2592,2619,2792,2856,2858,2861,2886,2925,2930,2937,2949,3135,3358,3370,3381,3452,3457,3465,3470,3538,3565,3573,3616,3637,3822],"critical":[208,401,1371,1503,1819,2368,2398,2890,2931],"cases,":[209,1848,2369,2932,3769],"insurance":[213,276,338,530,3601,3662],"\u201cfloater\u201d":[214,540,3602,3675],"policy":[215,541,3676],"conditions":[217],"likely":[218],"lead":[220,2642],"death,":[222,2121],"maiming,":[223],"or":[224,293,337,516,904,1048,1061,1122,1127,1483,1496,1511,1670,1693,1768,1811,1846,1896,2276,2468,2623,2666,2674,2860,3016,3032,3057,3127,3143,3147,3166,3181,3267,3279,3302,3322,3462,3511,3682,3735,3767],"accusations":[225],"malpractice.":[227],"A":[228,1779,1958,2386,3634,3664],"four-part":[229,580],"Latin":[230,581,1208,3582],"document":[231,649,2190,2977,3074,3243],"1415":[233,1363,2646,2976,2999,3073],"few":[236,554,627,2174],"earlier":[237,585,933,1611],"later":[239,587,1732],"manuscript":[240,2196],"rules":[241,2596,2835],"demonstrate":[242,886,1952],"role":[244],"politics":[246,928,1238],"ethics;":[249],"civil":[250,874,898,1032,2717],"enforcement":[251,1094],"surgical":[253,265,504,600,735,901,1105,1193,1275,2236,2269,2710,2747,3212,3756],"guild":[254,2250,2406,2711,3398,3415],"regulations;":[255],"ingenious":[257],"protection":[260,1250],"patient,":[262,1762,1859],"practitioner,":[263,3439,3666],"profession,":[266],"English":[269,599,1164],"citizenry.":[270],"Pairing":[271],"with":[274,305,858,1091,1462,1548,1823,1939,2078,2230,2550,3216,3454,3459,3619,3804],"policies":[277],"high-risk":[279,548,3604,3678,3701],"offers":[281],"inspiration":[282,508],"alleviating":[284],"some":[285,920,2442,3414,3810],"modern":[286,299,322,405,449,848,3665],"perils.":[288],"Third":[289],"parties":[290,473],"hover":[291],"benevolently":[292],"lurk":[294],"maliciously":[295],"near":[296],"almost":[297],"every":[298],"physician":[300,515,1959],"patient.":[302,2561,3441],"Bipartisan":[303],"medicine,":[304],"patient":[306,358,1481,2088,2095,2497,2598,3307,3506,3717],"practitioner":[308,534,1807,2013,2046,2581,3503,3554,3724],"active":[310],"communion":[311],"healing,":[313],"seems":[314,3000],"no":[315,1805,2556,2852],"longer":[316],"exist.":[318],"Even":[319],"simplest":[321],"room":[324],"confidences":[325],"are":[326,418,813,821,1562,1589,1608,3272],"partially":[327],"overheard":[328],"silent":[331],"third":[332,350,370,420,453,472,1263,1354,1856,2071,2502,2547,2927,3067,3426,3720,3814],"party":[333,454,2503,2548,2928,3427,3721,3815],"payer\u2014the":[334],"plan":[336],"company":[339],"covering":[340],"fee":[342,2573],"services.":[345,2483],"Remarkably,":[346],"however,":[347,773,2404,2865],"quiet":[349],"presence":[351],"standing":[354],"doctor":[356],"over":[360,1301,1307,2726,3763,3776],"500":[361],"years.":[362,2259],"Modern":[363,3638],"requiring":[366],"hospitalization":[367],"meet":[368],"multiple":[369],"parties,":[371],"as":[372,925,929,994,1235,1242,1271,1445,1615,1662,1664,1838,1855,2247,2380,2382,2420,2459,2752,2754,3066,3227,3731,3733,3770,3772],"consultants,":[373],"specialist":[374],"investigators,":[375],"reviewers,":[378],"whose":[379,1764,3680],"functions":[380],"have":[381,465,1996,2041,2263,2735,3149,3747],"out":[385,3673],"fashion":[388],"since":[389,2073],"Middle":[391],"Ages.":[392],"Medieval":[393,882,3635],"London,":[394,1154,1458,2850],"example,":[396,513],"legislated":[397],"cases.":[402,1372,2399,3605,3812],"If":[403,1704,2317,2400,2562,3320,3535,3546],"doctor-patient":[406],"relationship":[407],"degenerates":[408],"into":[409,477,1342],"adversarial":[410],"battle,":[411],"courts":[413],"their":[415,688,991,1178,1434,1506,1516,1523,1660,1665,1706,2409,2417,2455,2760,2793,2934,2970,2986,3051,3103,3114,3120,3150,3167],"minions":[417],"vocal":[419],"participants.":[421],"Likewise,":[422],"went":[427],"ineffective":[431],"treatment,":[432,1493,2085],"failure":[433],"cure,":[435],"excessive":[436],"fees,":[437],"injuries":[439],"caused":[440],"(\"iatrogenic":[444],"sequelae\").":[445],"Therefore,":[446,3129],"excellent,":[447],"ethical":[448,889,969,3438,3823],"practitioners,":[450,907],"bridling":[451],"under":[452,1505,2234,2274,3314],"restraints":[455],"hospital":[457],"space":[458],"utilization":[459],"committees":[460],"professional":[462,1024,1228,1252,1397,1941,2209,2358,2614,3397],"standards":[463,870,3786],"noble":[467],"heritage.":[468],"However,":[469,2176,2484,2644],"transformation":[470],"duos":[476],"trios":[478],"result":[481,1479,3685],"theory":[483],"improve":[487],"public":[488,1940,2430,2460],"health.":[489],"Most":[490,2201,2863],"these":[492,830,1138,1590,1953,2887],"efforts":[493],"were":[494,637,664,673,696,943,1036,1050,1120,1137,1460,1486,1672,1699,1712,1851,1882,1894,2009,2308,2402,2464,2491,2511,2630,2790,3122,3417],"originally":[495],"medieval.":[496],"Ingenious":[497],"attempts":[499,556,1389],"at":[500,639,761,768,786,1390,3507,3729],"controlling":[501],"may":[506,1221],"offer":[507],"surgeons":[510,993,1148,1429,1476,1596,1621,1841,1985,2027,2105,2109,2134,2184,2780,2967,2983,3065,3095],"today.":[511],"surgeon":[517,1756,1781,3288,3328],"London":[519,652,788,855,942,1101,1623,2183,2206,3340],"1417":[521,3480],"did":[522,2062,3519],"pay":[524,1791,3331],"astronomical,":[526],"nonreturnable,":[527,3659],"yearly":[528,2477,3660],"premium.":[531],"Rather,":[532],"took":[535,3157],"returnable":[537],"renewable":[539,3643],"tied":[542],"each":[547,2758,3403,3411],"case.":[549],"Let":[550],"celebrate":[552],"legislate":[558],"ethics":[560],"municipal":[563,1727],"audience":[565],"proud":[566],"its":[568,1081,1108,1405,1537,2595,2834,3011,3455,3463,3714,3764,3779],"privilege":[569],"independence":[571],"examining":[573],"remarkable":[575],"ordinance":[576,934,1047,1365,1743,2487],"dated":[577,2178,3254],"1415.":[578],"document,":[582,711,1533],"plus":[583,2370],"fifteenth":[588],"rules,":[590],"preserves":[591],"splendidly":[592],"perils":[594],"pleasures":[596],"practice.":[601,1066,1334,2295],"Part":[602,1294,2600,3020],"1:":[603],"Complaint":[605],"Against":[606],"Surgical":[607,1230],"Malpractices":[608],"In":[609,973,1313,1356,2022,2069,3606],"1415,":[610],"same":[612,2361],"year":[613],"King":[614],"Henry":[615,1640],"V":[616],"won":[617],"so":[618,626,646,1055,1534,1544,1563,1849,2879,3225],"gloriously":[619],"battlefield":[622],"Agincourt,":[624],"losing":[625],"Englishmen":[628],"French":[631],"warriors,":[632],"alarming":[633],"numbers":[634],"Londoners":[636],"dying":[638],"hands":[641],"unskilled":[643],"surgeons.":[644,2697,3579],"Or":[645],"this":[647,1532,1560,1616,1736,3351],"impassioned":[648],"Guild":[653,789,2473,2591,2602,2615,3365],"Hall":[654,3366],"asserts.":[655],"Inexperienced":[656],"art":[659,3099],"surgery,":[661,1658],"certain":[662],"practitioners":[663,685,945,970,1111,1119,1142,1308,1444,1513,1648,1652,2145,2203,2748,2960,3184],"taking":[665,1775,3292,3312],"care":[666,1106,1893,1927,1945,3158,3293,3315],"sick":[668,3161,3296],"injured":[670],"people":[671,718,3162,3263],"who":[672,952,1044,1049,1653,2215,2498,2638,3013],"often":[674,814],"worse":[675],"off":[676],"after":[677,1982,2252,2334],"attention":[679],"than":[680,767,1315,1899,3109,3249,3271],"before":[681,1028,2289,2332,2737],"it.":[682,1131,1803,1832],"Some":[683],"inexpert":[684],"seriously":[686],"maimed":[687],"patients,":[689],"defrauding":[690],"charging":[692],"services":[694,799],"incapable":[697],"rendering.":[699],"scandal":[701],"reduced":[702],"number":[704,2281],"faithful":[706],"citizens.":[707,964,1109],"According":[708],"it":[712,1243,2663,3547],"\u201cmanifest":[714],"destruction":[715],"Lord":[721],"King.\u201d":[723],"Moreover,":[724],"perfidies":[725],"malpractitioners":[727,2841],"reflected":[728],"poorly":[729,946],"skillful":[732],"discrete":[734],"practitioners.":[736,1004,3780],"Laws":[737],"Marketplace":[741],"lamentation,":[744],"four":[748,896,1629,1828,2375,2389,2411,2518,3433,3517],"sections":[749],"ordinance,":[753,3326],"suggests":[754,2180],"life":[758,2008],"beneath":[763],"surgeon\u2019s":[765,3372],"knife":[766],"enemy\u2019s":[770],"sword.":[771],"Truly,":[772],"complaint":[775,1376],"typical":[778],"introduction":[779],"market":[782],"laws,":[783,3621],"also":[784,885,1035,2261,2583],"preserved":[785],"Hall,":[790],"governing":[791],"all":[792,1001,1026,1257,1370,1453,1471,1475,1646,1650,2517,2746,2840,2871,2905,3798],"professions":[793],"crafts":[795],"offering":[796],"goods":[797],"populace.":[802],"Stating":[803],"problem":[805,1765,2066],"first,":[806],"proceed":[808],"solutions.":[810],"But":[811],"malpractices":[812],"exaggerated":[815],"justify":[817],"proposed":[818],"changes":[819],"described":[822,1609],"rhetoric":[825],"reformation:":[827],"\u201cto":[828],"overcome":[829],"scandals,\u201d":[831],"\u201cthese":[832,835],"oppressions,\u201d":[833],"evils":[836],"aforesaid\"\u2014attendentesque":[837],"prius.":[838],"With":[839],"reform":[841],"algorithm":[843],"dramatically":[845],"stated":[846],"abuses,":[847],"readers":[849],"must":[850,2540],"assume":[852],"fifteenth-century":[854,2182,3596,3669],"infested":[857],"quacks":[860],"charlatans.":[862],"Quite":[863],"contrary.":[865],"complaints":[867,1170,2699],"suggest":[868,1734,3704],"high":[869],"unwillingness":[875],"tolerate":[877],"shoddy":[878],"unprofessional":[880],"practices.":[881,2149],"distinctions":[887],"between":[888],"unethical":[891],"behavior":[893],"appreciated":[894],"constituencies\u2014the":[897],"authorities,":[899],"craft":[902,2394,3526,3577,3625],"organizations,":[903],"guilds,":[905],"individual":[906,1936],"and,":[908,1277],"least,":[910],"patients":[911,1598,1739,2165,3151,3679,3702],"themselves.":[912,3019],"Earlier":[913],"Medicolegal":[914],"Politics":[915],"Ethics":[918],"Nevertheless,":[919,1254],"ruled":[924],"much":[926,1236],"An":[932],"1376":[936],"explains":[937],"daily":[939],"arriving":[940],"\u201cforeign\u201d":[944,1141,1201],"trained":[947],"even":[949,2356],"less":[950,1314,3793],"skilled,":[951],"meddled":[953],"damage":[958],"deceit":[961],"Their":[965],"abuses":[966],"defamed":[967],"London.":[972,1880,3497],"remedy,":[974],"complainant":[976],"doctors":[977],"offered":[978],"neatly":[980],"worded":[981],"self":[982],"governance":[983],"proposal.":[984],"They":[985,1485,2789,2881,3137],"insisted":[986],"electing":[988],"two":[989,1436,2264,2779,3389],"own":[992,3737],"Wardens":[995,1005,1034],"Craft":[998],"oversee":[1000,2830],"activities":[1002],"empowered":[1006,2392],"mayor":[1009,1421,1466,1678,1720,2627,2690,2730,2777,2898,3084,3203],"council":[1011,2629,2732,3205],"would":[1012,1527,2241,2284,2329,2346,3697,3718,3725,3758,3808],"\u201crule\u201d":[1013],"surgeons,":[1014,1631,2637,3037],"is,":[1016,1161,2555],"inspect":[1017],"offices":[1018],"instruments":[1020,1661],"examine":[1022,1645,1690,2870],"competence":[1025],"\u201cforeigners\u201d":[1027],"recommending":[1029],"them":[1030,1575,2738,3165,3177],"licensure.":[1033],"report":[1038,1758,2839],"city":[1041,1085,1152,2396,2452,2751,3623],"authorities":[1042],"any":[1043,1410,1813,2993,3287],"violated":[1045,3324,3555],"\u201crebellious":[1051],"craft,\u201d":[1054],"could":[1058,1796,1808,1889,2040,2433,2499,2882,3548,3746],"fined":[1060,2017],"expelled":[1062,2348],"privileges":[1064,2971],"Civil":[1067,2605],"Enforcement":[1068],"Professional":[1070],"Rules":[1071,1413],"respectable":[1073],"policing":[1074],"profession":[1077,2351],"within":[1079,1187,1770,1827,3308,3516],"requested":[1080,3185],"mandate":[1082],"fathers":[1086],"got":[1088],"it,":[1089],"along":[1090],"powerful":[1093],"mechanism\u2014the":[1095],"city\u2019s":[1096,1281],"right":[1097,2616],"punish":[1099],"offenders.":[1100],"thereby":[1102],"indirectly":[1103],"controlled":[1104,2985],"Ethical":[1110],"codes":[1113],"encourage":[1115],"them,":[1116],"poor":[1118],"chastised":[1121],"eliminated":[1123],"fraternity,":[1126],"forbidden":[1128],"enter":[1130],"Xenophobia":[1132],"Monopoly":[1135],"Who":[1136,2915],"untrained,":[1139],"unlicensed,":[1140],"rails":[1145],"against":[1146,1171,1377,1884,2132,2597],"but":[1147,2582],"outside":[1150,1411],"\u201cUppelande,\u201d":[1156],"\u201cthe":[1158,1419,1518],"hills,\u201d":[1159],"other":[1163,1196,1591,2265,2428,2906,3092,3571],"cities":[1165],"towns!":[1167],"Londoners\u2019":[1169],"foreigners":[1172],"attempt":[1175],"restrict":[1177],"trade":[1179],"maintain":[1182,2833],"monopoly":[1184],"city.":[1189],"Such":[1190,1304,2684],"ordinances":[1194],"paralleled":[1195],"regulations":[1197,2363],"avoid":[1199],"competitive":[1200],"carriage":[1202],"makers,":[1203],"butchers,":[1204],"bladesmiths.":[1206],"formula":[1209],"\u201cnulla":[1211],"persona":[1212],"extranea":[1213],"indegena":[1214],"vel":[1215],"alienigena\u201d":[1216],"(\"no":[1217],"outsiders":[1218],"nor":[1219],"newcomers":[1220],"without":[1223,1409,2844,3163],"prior":[1224,2083],"certification":[1225],"community\").":[1229],"governance,":[1231],"then,":[1232],"animated":[1234],"private":[1240],"finance":[1241],"ideals":[1247],"consumer":[1249],"important":[1255,1326,1630,2189],"documents":[1260,1733,2443],"party\u2019s":[1264],"observation":[1265],"physician-patient":[1268],"relationship,":[1269],"acting":[1270],"warden":[1272],"craft,":[1276,2832,3437],"quietly":[1278],"implied,":[1279],"power":[1282,1425],"punishment":[1284,3380,3615],"perfidy":[1287],"fine":[1289,2588],"loss":[1291,3266],"license.":[1293],"2:":[1295],"Compulsory":[1296,1835,3813],"Consultation":[1297,1580,1836],"Peer":[1299,1302,2727],"Control":[1300,2725],"Review":[1303,2728],"gentle":[1305],"surveillance":[1306,3775],"led":[1309],"startling":[1311,2650],"developments.":[1312],"half":[1316,3560,3572],"maneuvering,":[1321],"review":[1323,1338,1385,1489,2706],"became":[1324,2067],"increasingly":[1325],"theoretical":[1328],"determinations":[1329],"good":[1331,2147,3281],"versus":[1332],"bad":[1333],"More":[1335],"important,":[1336,2864],"itself":[1339,1403,1547,2474],"transformed":[1341],"direct":[1343],"assessment":[1344],"practitioners\u2019":[1346,1490,1710],"treatment":[1347,3745],"plans":[1348,1491,3142],"physical":[1350],"examinations":[1351],"party.":[1355],"fact,":[1357],"second":[1359,2024,2326],"section":[1360,1561,3240],"mandates":[1366],"Following":[1373],"introductory":[1375],"malpractice,":[1378],"part":[1379,2226,2655,2703,2714,2722],"2":[1380],"contains":[1381],"convenient":[1383],"short":[1384,3581],"surgeons\u2019":[1388,2081,3409,3632],"self-regulation.":[1391],"It":[1392],"refers":[1393],"specifically":[1394],"guild\u2019s":[1398,2338],"supervision":[1399],"scrutiny":[1401,1507,2991],"members":[1406,2251,3416],"itself,":[1408],"monitoring.":[1412],"adopted":[1414],"during":[1415],"reign":[1417],"late":[1420],"Richard":[1422,1961,2787,2807],"Merlawe,\u201d":[1423],"1409,":[1427],"allowed":[1428],"select":[1431],"among":[1433,2516],"fellows":[1435],"most":[1439,1865,1874,1913,1916,3765,3777],"skillful,":[1440,2321],"wise,":[1441],"trustworthy":[1443],"\u201cmasters":[1446],"craft.\u201d":[1449],"Peer-selected":[1450],"regulating":[1452],"practices":[1454],"surgery":[1456,1795,3528],"invested":[1461],"authority":[1463,2718],"council.":[1468,1722],"Masters":[1469,2353],"investigated":[1470],"coming":[1473,2507],"might":[1478,1520,1928,1995,2216,2262,2354,2664,2672,2677,3646,3671,3684,3789,3817],"death":[1482,3056,3301],"maiming.":[1484,3058],"obliged":[1487],"either":[1494],"approving":[1495],"changing":[1497],"them.":[1498,2231,2643],"Often":[1499],"masters":[1501,1850,2365,2622,3112,3134,3523],"found":[1502],"where":[1508],"\u201cif":[1509,2675],"ignorant":[1510,1542],"indiscrete\u201d":[1512],"should":[1514,1543],"undertake":[1515],"management,":[1517],"which":[1519,1887,3173],"God":[1521],"forbid,\u201d":[1522],"lack":[1524,2000],"skill":[1526],"cause":[1528],"grievous":[1529],"errors.":[1530],"Suddenly,":[1531],"chatty":[1535],"tone":[1538],"(\"God":[1539],"forbid":[1540],"practice\"),":[1545],"interrupts":[1546],"word":[1550],"\u201cetcetera,\u201d":[1551],"meaning":[1552],"rest":[1555],"sentences":[1558],"commonplace":[1564],"predictable":[1566],"scribe":[1569],"need":[1570],"bother":[1572],"write":[1574],"down.":[1576],"He":[1577],"does":[1578],"not.":[1579],"City\u2019s":[1583],"Critical":[1584,3471],"List":[1585],"1390":[1587],"What":[1588],"duties":[1592],"master":[1595,1620,1780,1801,1825,2074,2510,2528,2696,2950,3036,3064,3695],"danger?":[1600],"Formulaic":[1601],"responsibilities":[1602],"phrase":[1606,2687],"\u201cetcetera\u201d":[1607],"oath":[1617],"1390.":[1625],"On":[1626],"April":[1627],"10,":[1628],"Drs.":[1632,2803],"John":[1633,1637,2047,3483],"Hynstock,":[1634],"Geoffrey":[1635],"Grace,":[1636],"Brademore,":[1638],"Suttone,":[1641],"swore":[1642,2028,2821],"faithfully":[1643,2869],"men":[1647],"women":[1651],"undertook":[1654],"cures":[1655,2799],"practiced":[1657],"investigating":[1659],"well":[1663,2381,2753,2909,3771],"educational":[1666],"credentials.":[1667],"Any":[1668,2505,2520],"imperfections":[1669],"\u201cdefaults\u201d":[1671],"reported":[1675,1844,2895],"aldermen.":[1680],"Furthermore,":[1681,3117],"prepared":[1686],"when":[1687,2878,2982],"called":[1688,1991,2055,2213,3537],"persons":[1691],"hurt":[1692],"wounded":[1694],"determine":[1696],"whether":[1697],"danger":[1701,3054],"death.":[1703,3128,3182],"so,":[1705,2563],"names":[1707,1711],"recorded":[1715],"presented":[1717],"undertaking":[1724],"created":[1725,3393],"\u201ccritical":[1728],"list.\u201d":[1729],"Other":[1730],"slightly":[1731],"how":[1735,2181,3030,3033],"list":[1737,2744],"established.":[1741],"creating":[1744],"Joint":[1746],"Physicians":[1749],"Surgeons":[1751,2260,3046],"1423":[1753],"required":[1754,1852,2309,2444,3041],"critically":[1760,3160],"ill":[1761],"one":[1763,1870,2509,2853],"\u201cdesperate":[1767],"deadly,\u201d":[1769],"three":[1771,1983,2026,2239,3252,3309],"days":[1772,1829,3310,3518],"cure.":[1778],"consult,":[1784],"irrespective":[1785],"patient\u2019s":[1788,1993,2005,2065,2130],"ability":[1789],"consultation.":[1793,3136,3593,3722],"No":[1794,3028],"performed":[1798,2908],"until":[1799,1816],"approved":[1802],"Similarly,":[1804],"prescribe":[1809],"medication":[1810],"follow":[1812],"curative":[1814],"regimen":[1815],"reporting":[1817],"case":[1820,2577],"physician,":[1826],"receiving":[1831],"Justifications":[1833],"Just":[1837],"physicians":[1839,2212,2969],"\u201cdeath":[1845],"maiming\u201d":[1847],"act":[1854,2419],"parties.":[1857,3068],"Every":[1858],"wealthy":[1862],"penurious,":[1866],"thus":[1868,2610,3430],"assured":[1869,3499],"best,":[1873],"clinically":[1875,3707],"sound":[1876,3708],"therapies":[1877],"available":[1878],"Practitioners":[1881],"protected":[1883],"suits":[1886],"otherwise":[1888],"brought":[1891,1964,2648,2736],"if":[1892,2044,3413,3501,3750],"questionable":[1895],"results":[1897],"poorer":[1898],"expected.":[1900],"Another":[1901,3419],"advantage":[1902,3191],"masters\u2019":[1908,2481,2987],"opportunity":[1909],"see":[1911],"interesting":[1914],"dangerous":[1917,3768],"cases;":[1918],"transmitting":[1919],"his":[1920,2091,2118,2133,2137,2546,3475,3513,3533,3734],"knowledge":[1921],"best":[1924],"modes":[1925],"favorably":[1929],"affect":[1930],"morbidity":[1931],"mortality":[1933],"rates.":[1934],"Balancing":[1935],"enterprise":[1938],"accountability":[1942],"improved":[1943],"markedly.":[1946],"Three":[1947],"Malpractice":[1948,1950,3467,3639],"Cases":[1949,3472],"checks":[1955],"balances.":[1957],"named":[1960],"Chayndut":[1962],"1377":[1968],"because":[1969],"ineffectively":[1971],"treating":[1972],"serious":[1974],"leg":[1975,1994],"wound.":[1976],"verdict":[1978],"confirming":[1979],"came":[1981],"expert":[1984,2002,2052,3732],"testified":[1986],"saved.":[1998],"advice,":[2003],"limb":[2006],"jeopardy.":[2011],"held":[2015],"culpable,":[2016],"damages,":[2019],"jailed.":[2021],"case,":[2025,2072],"Thomas":[2032],"de":[2033],"Shene\u2019s":[2034],"\u201chuge":[2035],"terrible\u201d":[2037],"jaw":[2038],"injury":[2039],"cured":[2043],"Le":[2048],"Spicer":[2049],"\u201chad":[2054],"assistance.\u201d":[2059],"Since":[2060,2422],"he":[2061,2564,3321,3531,3536],"not,":[2063],"incurable.":[2068],"consultants":[2075,2391,2432,2446,2490],"concurred":[2077],"local":[2080],"modalities":[2082],"given":[2090],"\u201cinformed":[2092],"consent,\u201d":[2093],"plaintiff":[2096],"dealt":[2098],"severe":[2100],"reprimand":[2101],"accused":[2104],"completely":[2106],"exonerated.":[2107],"When":[2108],"cauterized":[2110],"Mr.":[2111],"Forest\u2019s":[2112],"recalcitrant":[2113],"thumb":[2114],"wound":[2115],"prevent":[2117],"bleeding":[2119],"caused,":[2123],"unexpectedly,":[2125],"deforming":[2127],"scar.":[2128],"suit":[2131],"maiming":[2136,3126,3180,3303],"hand":[2138,3248],"deemed":[2140,2320],"unjust":[2141],"maligning":[2142],"excellent":[2144,3034],"Logistics":[2150],"Consultations":[2152],"1435":[2154,2179,2362,2486],"formidable":[2156],"idea":[2159],"worked":[2160,2229],"well,":[2161],"though":[2162,3651],"imperfectly.":[2163],"Many":[2164],"examined":[2169,2609],"places":[2172]},"counts_by_year":[],"updated_date":"2026-10-31T12:09:11.096373","created_date":"2016-06-24T00:00:00"}