{"id":"https://openalex.org/W1970501648","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1353/pew.2001.0004","title":"Reply to Stephen Phillips","display_name":"Reply to Stephen Phillips","publication_year":2001,"publication_date":"2001-01-01","ids":{"openalex":"https://openalex.org/W1970501648","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1353/pew.2001.0004","mag":"1970501648"},"language":"en","primary_location":{"id":"doi:10.1353/pew.2001.0004","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1353/pew.2001.0004","is_oa":false,"landing_page_url":"https://doi.org/10.1353/pew.2001.0004","pdf_url":null,"source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S196911494","display_name":"Philosophy East and West","issn_l":"0031-8221","issn":["0031-8221","1529-1898"],"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":false,"listed_in":["anvur-class-a","anvur-scientific","jufo-1","norway-1","poland-70","russia-white-list-2","vabb-shw"],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/P4310315682","host_organization_name":"University of Hawaii Press","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/P4310315682"],"host_organization_lineage_names":["University of Hawaii Press"],"type":"journal"},"license":null,"license_id":null,"version":"publishedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":true,"raw_source_name":"Philosophy East and West","raw_type":"journal-article"},"volume":null,"type":"letter","indexed_in":["crossref"],"open_access":{"is_oa":false,"oa_status":"closed","oa_url":null,"any_repository_has_fulltext":false},"authorships":[{"author_position":"first","author":{"id":"https://openalex.org/A5112413785","display_name":"Arindam Chakrabarti","orcid":null,"observed_orcids":[]},"institutions":[],"countries":[],"is_corresponding":true,"raw_author_name":"Arindam Chakrabarti","raw_affiliation_strings":[],"raw_orcid":null,"affiliations":[]}],"institutions":[],"countries_distinct_count":0,"institutions_distinct_count":0,"corresponding_author_ids":["https://openalex.org/A5112413785"],"corresponding_institution_ids":[],"apc_list":null,"apc_paid":null,"fwci":null,"has_fulltext":false,"cited_by_count":69,"citation_normalized_percentile":null,"cited_by_percentile_year":null,"biblio":{"volume":"51","issue":"1","first_page":"114","last_page":"115"},"is_retracted":false,"is_paratext":false,"is_xpac":false,"primary_topic":{"id":"https://openalex.org/T11563","display_name":"Indian and Buddhist Studies","score":0.7827000021934509,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1212","display_name":"Religious studies"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/12","display_name":"Arts and Humanities"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},"topics":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/T11563","display_name":"Indian and Buddhist Studies","score":0.7827000021934509,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1212","display_name":"Religious studies"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/12","display_name":"Arts and Humanities"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},{"id":"https://openalex.org/T10258","display_name":"Philosophy and Theoretical Science","score":0.10989999771118164,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/3205","display_name":"Experimental and Cognitive Psychology"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/32","display_name":"Psychology"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},{"id":"https://openalex.org/T11477","display_name":"Epistemology, Ethics, and Metaphysics","score":0.09359999746084213,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1211","display_name":"Philosophy"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/12","display_name":"Arts and Humanities"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}}],"keywords":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/nyaya","display_name":"Ny\u0101ya","score":0.7049999833106995},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/gangesa","display_name":"Ga\u1e45ge\u015ba","score":0.8320000171661377},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/qualia","display_name":"qualia","score":0.3610000014305115},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/indian-epistemology","display_name":"Indian epistemology","score":0.6340000033378601},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/language-and-perception","display_name":"language and perception","score":0.3160000145435333}],"concepts":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/C138885662","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q5891","display_name":"Philosophy","level":0,"score":0.6020611524581909}],"mesh":[],"locations_count":2,"locations":[{"id":"doi:10.1353/pew.2001.0004","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1353/pew.2001.0004","is_oa":false,"landing_page_url":"https://doi.org/10.1353/pew.2001.0004","pdf_url":null,"source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S196911494","display_name":"Philosophy East and West","issn_l":"0031-8221","issn":["0031-8221","1529-1898"],"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":false,"listed_in":["anvur-class-a","anvur-scientific","jufo-1","norway-1","poland-70","russia-white-list-2","vabb-shw"],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/P4310315682","host_organization_name":"University of Hawaii Press","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/P4310315682"],"host_organization_lineage_names":["University of Hawaii Press"],"type":"journal"},"license":null,"license_id":null,"version":"publishedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":true,"raw_source_name":"Philosophy East and West","raw_type":"journal-article"},{"id":"pmh:oai:muse.jhu.edu:/article/26514","doi":null,"is_oa":false,"landing_page_url":"https://muse.jhu.edu/article/26514","pdf_url":null,"source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S4377196299","display_name":"Project Muse (Johns Hopkins University)","issn_l":null,"issn":null,"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":false,"listed_in":[],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/I145311948","host_organization_name":"Johns Hopkins University","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/I145311948"],"host_organization_lineage_names":[],"type":"repository"},"license":null,"license_id":null,"version":"submittedVersion","is_accepted":false,"is_published":false,"raw_source_name":"","raw_type":"text"}],"best_oa_location":null,"sustainable_development_goals":[],"sustainable_development_goals_aurora":[{"id":"https://metadata.un.org/sdg/10","display_name":"Reduced inequalities","score":0.4099999964237213}],"study_designs":[],"awards":[],"funders":[],"has_content":{"pdf":false,"grobid_xml":false},"content_urls":null,"referenced_works_count":0,"referenced_works":[],"related_works":["https://openalex.org/W2004830126","https://openalex.org/W2152927549","https://openalex.org/W7170258949","https://openalex.org/W2013893568","https://openalex.org/W7151823257","https://openalex.org/W1991222281","https://openalex.org/W3003624579","https://openalex.org/W4395467028","https://openalex.org/W2143730525","https://openalex.org/W4251511347"],"abstract_inverted_index":{"Reply":[0],"to":[1,83,88,161,224,270,278,287,316,330,401,426,440,501,510,518,546,554,572,613,653,667],"Stephen":[2,12],"Phillips":[3,97,103,180,328],"Arindam":[4],"Chakrabarti":[5],"Much":[6],"as":[7,48,115,260,315,387,391,561,623],"I":[8,50,81,86,108,121,183,274,338,588,611,617,628],"am":[9,51,184],"honored":[10],"by":[11,67,230,563],"Phillips'":[13],"detailed":[14,78],"defense,":[15],"in":[16,123,251,285,340,395,404,424,552,582,599,638],"the":[17,24,32,60,90,125,132,166,234,240,271,333,349,355,368,372,382,405,415,472,494,548,600,670],"face":[18],"of":[19,23,31,45,63,76,118,128,134,146,168,171,216,242,246,257,311,325,335,352,357,367,371,417,429,481,485,489,496,539,542,660],"my":[20,56,94,345,497],"methodological":[21],"\"refutation,\"":[22],"Ny\u0101ya":[25],"thesis":[26],"that":[27,55,110,173,182,196,220,273,337,359,375,459,564,578,595,615,632,663],"a":[28,35,77,116,169,210,213,243,258,321,378,392,419,443,479,486,583,592,608,620],"raw":[29,326],"perception":[30,44,65,111,358,374],"qualifier":[33],"is":[34,112,145,198,209,239,262,362,377,477,607,646,650],"necessary":[36],"causal":[37,253],"factor":[38],"for":[39,203],"some":[40],"(not":[41],"all)":[42],"determinate":[43],"an":[46],"entity":[47],"qualified,":[49],"not":[52,175,247,276,302,423,516,569],"fully":[53],"convinced":[54],"deeper":[57],"qualms":[58],"about":[59,442],"very":[61],"idea":[62,416],"immaculate":[64],"unimpregnated":[66],"predicative":[68,373],"structure":[69],"have":[70,277,303,331,400,462,471,502],"all":[71,537,648],"been":[72],"adequately":[73],"addressed.":[74],"Instead":[75],"response,":[79],"which":[80,238],"intend":[82],"undertake":[84],"elsewhere,":[85],"wish":[87],"underscore":[89],"central":[91,642],"worry":[92],"behind":[93],"fifth":[95],"(which":[96,102],"calls":[98,104],"\"good\")":[99],"and":[100,155,227,389,422,454,466,504,506,508],"seventh":[101],"\"weak\")":[105],"objections.":[106],"When":[107],"claimed":[109],"introduced,":[113],"taxonomically,":[114],"variety":[117],"veridical":[119,143,176],"awareness,":[120],"had":[122],"mind":[124],"opening":[126],"line":[127],"Ga\u1e45ge\u015ba's":[129],"section":[130],"on":[131],"definition":[133],"perception:":[135],"s\u0101":[136],"ca":[137],"pram\u0101":[138],"caturvidh\u0101,":[139],"pratyak\u1e63\u0101numityupamiti\u015b\u0101bd\u0101-bhed\u0101t":[140],"And":[141,493],"such":[142,304],"awareness":[144,250,283,649],"four":[147],"kinds:":[148],"perception,":[149,244],"inferential":[150],"knowledge,":[151],"knowledge":[152,156],"from":[153,157,212,296],"similarity,":[154],"words.1":[158],"This":[159],"seems":[160,329],"be":[162,225,402,532,603],"flatly":[163],"incompatible":[164],"with":[165,449],"admission":[167],"subclass":[170],"perceptions":[172],"are":[174,536,656],"awarenesses!":[177],"Why":[178],"does":[179],"say":[181],"simply":[185,433,530],"mistaken?":[186],"True,":[187],"taxonomic":[188],"difficulties":[189],"cannot":[190,470,531],"overturn":[191],"empirical":[192],"evidence.":[193],"But":[194,475,610],"recall":[195],"there":[197,535],"no":[199,435],"direct":[200,490],"apperceptive":[201],"evidence":[202,208],"\"raw":[204],"perception.\"":[205],"The":[206,641],"sole":[207],"generalization":[211,295],"whole":[214,487],"series":[215],"mediate":[217,298],"(parok\u1e63a)":[218],"awarenesses":[219,665],"can":[221,602,618],"happily":[222],"afford":[223],"instrumentally":[226],"crucially":[228],"caused":[229],"other":[231,235,282,297],"awarenesses.":[232],"On":[233],"hand,":[236],"immediacy,":[237],"hallmark":[241],"consists":[245],"having":[248],"another":[249],"its":[252,430],"nexus.":[254],"My":[255],"seeing":[256,418],"wall":[259],"white":[261],"direct,":[263],"rather":[264],"than":[265],"inferential,":[266],"analogical,":[267],"or":[268,451,521,523,525,556,558,574,576,625],"testimonial,":[269],"extent":[272],"did":[275],"go":[279],"through":[280],"any":[281,427,639],"first":[284,399,581],"order":[286,553],"arrive":[288],"at":[289],"this":[290,341,376,396,476],"visual":[291],"perception.":[292,492],"An":[293],"inductive":[294],"(cognition-generated)":[299],"cognitions":[300],"should":[301],"inexorable":[305],"probative":[306],"power":[307],"over":[308],"our":[309,664],"account":[310],"immediate":[312],"sensory":[313],"cognition":[314],"force":[317],"us":[318],"into":[319],"admitting":[320],"neither-true-nor-false":[322],"third":[323],"kind":[324],"awareness!":[327],"overlooked":[332],"metaphor":[334],"\"spelling\"":[336],"used":[339],"context":[342],"while":[343],"giving":[344],"second":[346],"objection.":[347],"If":[348],"step-by-step":[350],"picture":[351],"building":[353],"up":[354],"content":[356,370],"Ga\u1e45ge\u015ba":[360],"assumes":[361],"correct,":[363],"then":[364],"each":[365],"element":[366],"perceptual":[369,447],"flower\u2014the":[379],"universal":[380,420,633],"flowerhood,":[381],"actual":[383],"physical":[384],"object":[385],"identified":[386],"\"this,\"":[388],"qualification":[390,450],"cementing":[393],"relation,":[394],"case":[397],"inherence\u2014would":[398],"cognized":[403],"unconnected":[406],"\"raw\"":[407],"manner!":[408,587],"Now,":[409],"even":[410],"if":[411],"we":[412],"somehow":[413,551,630],"swallow":[414],"barely":[421],"relation":[425],"one":[428,456],"instances,":[431],"it":[432,606,637],"makes":[434],"[End":[436],"Page":[437],"114]":[438],"sense":[439],"talk":[441],"bare,":[444,584],"raw,":[445,585],"unstructured":[446],"acquaintance":[448],"inherence!":[452],"Logically":[453],"structurally":[455],"could":[457],"argue":[458],"unless":[460],"you":[461,469,514,567],"\"got\"":[463],"a,":[464],"b,":[465],"R":[467],"first,":[468],"complex":[473],"aRb.":[474],"admittedly":[478],"process":[480],"logical":[482],"postmortem":[483],"dissection":[484],"piece":[488],"qualificative":[491],"point":[495],"metaphorical":[498],"warning\u2014\"You":[499],"need":[500,517,545,571],"'L'":[503,520],"'O'":[505,522],"'D'":[507,524],"'N'":[509,526],"spell":[511,519],"'London,'":[512],"but":[513,566],"do":[515,568,589],"first.":[527],"Single":[528],"letters":[529],"spelled!\"\u2014was":[533],"this:":[534,647],"sorts":[538],"different":[540],"ways":[541],"\"getting.\"":[543],"You":[544],"\"get\"":[547],"qualifying":[549],"feature":[550,579],"see":[555,573],"hear":[557,575,619,631],"taste":[559,577],"something":[560],"qualified":[562],"feature,":[565],"therefore":[570],"alone":[580],"unqualified":[586],"believe,":[590],"like":[591],"good":[593],"Naiy\u0101yika,":[594],"high-pitchedness":[596],"(or":[597],"fifthness,":[598],"octave)":[601],"heard":[604],"although":[605],"sound-universal.":[609],"refuse":[612],"admit":[614],"before":[616],"sung":[621],"note":[622],"high-pitched":[624],"(the":[626],"fifth)":[627],"must":[629],"directly":[634],"without":[635],"hearing":[636],"note!":[640],"point,":[643],"once":[644],"again,":[645],"intentional,":[651],"according":[652],"Ny\u0101ya.":[654],"There":[655],"only":[657],"three":[658],"kinds":[659],"intentional":[661],"roles":[662],"assign":[666],"their":[668],"objects:":[669],"role":[671],"of...":[672]},"counts_by_year":[{"year":2025,"cited_by_count":1},{"year":2024,"cited_by_count":1},{"year":2020,"cited_by_count":1},{"year":2019,"cited_by_count":57},{"year":2015,"cited_by_count":1},{"year":2014,"cited_by_count":1}],"updated_date":"2026-07-14T23:27:15.235271","created_date":"2016-06-24T00:00:00"}