{"id":"https://openalex.org/W1968777737","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1086/675323","title":"Chinnery and Houqua: Questions of Attribution","display_name":"Chinnery and Houqua: Questions of Attribution","publication_year":2013,"publication_date":"2013-04-01","ids":{"openalex":"https://openalex.org/W1968777737","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1086/675323","mag":"1968777737"},"language":"en","primary_location":{"id":"doi:10.1086/675323","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1086/675323","is_oa":false,"landing_page_url":"https://doi.org/10.1086/675323","pdf_url":null,"source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S194950008","display_name":"Metropolitan Museum Journal","issn_l":"0077-8958","issn":["0077-8958","2169-3072"],"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":false,"listed_in":["anvur-scientific","norway-1","poland-70","russia-white-list-3"],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/P4310315672","host_organization_name":"University of Chicago Press","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/P4310315672","https://openalex.org/P4310315690"],"host_organization_lineage_names":["University of Chicago Press","University of Chicago"],"type":"journal"},"license":null,"license_id":null,"version":"publishedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":true,"raw_source_name":"Metropolitan Museum Journal","raw_type":"journal-article"},"volume":null,"type":"article","indexed_in":["crossref"],"open_access":{"is_oa":false,"oa_status":"closed","oa_url":null,"any_repository_has_fulltext":false},"authorships":[{"author_position":"first","author":{"id":"https://openalex.org/A5014857133","display_name":"Josephine C. Dobkin","orcid":null,"observed_orcids":[]},"institutions":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/I1286891280","display_name":"Metropolitan Museum of Art","ror":"https://ror.org/03cm0t424","country_code":"US","type":"archive","lineage":["https://openalex.org/I1286891280"]}],"countries":["US"],"is_corresponding":true,"raw_author_name":"Josephine C. Dobkin","raw_affiliation_strings":["Research Assistant, Department of European Paintings, The Metropolitan Museum of Art"],"raw_orcid":null,"affiliations":[{"raw_affiliation_string":"Research Assistant, Department of European Paintings, The Metropolitan Museum of Art","institution_ids":["https://openalex.org/I1286891280"]}]}],"institutions":[],"countries_distinct_count":1,"institutions_distinct_count":1,"corresponding_author_ids":["https://openalex.org/A5014857133"],"corresponding_institution_ids":["https://openalex.org/I1286891280"],"apc_list":null,"apc_paid":null,"fwci":0.0,"has_fulltext":false,"cited_by_count":2,"citation_normalized_percentile":{"value":0.25885041,"is_in_top_1_percent":false,"is_in_top_10_percent":false},"cited_by_percentile_year":{"min":89,"max":94},"biblio":{"volume":"48","issue":"1","first_page":"205","last_page":"216"},"is_retracted":false,"is_paratext":false,"is_xpac":false,"primary_topic":{"id":"https://openalex.org/T13922","display_name":"Historical Art and Culture Studies","score":0.9771000146865845,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1209","display_name":"Museology"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/12","display_name":"Arts and Humanities"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},"topics":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/T13922","display_name":"Historical Art and Culture Studies","score":0.9771000146865845,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1209","display_name":"Museology"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/12","display_name":"Arts and Humanities"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},{"id":"https://openalex.org/T14191","display_name":"Historical Art and Architecture Studies","score":0.019899999722838402,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1206","display_name":"Conservation"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/12","display_name":"Arts and Humanities"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},{"id":"https://openalex.org/T10893","display_name":"Chinese history and philosophy","score":0.00039999998989515007,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/3312","display_name":"Sociology and Political Science"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/33","display_name":"Social Sciences"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}}],"keywords":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/attribution","display_name":"attribution","score":0.7369999885559082},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/chinese-portraiture","display_name":"Chinese portraiture","score":0.734000027179718},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/metropolitan-museum-of-art","display_name":"Metropolitan Museum of Art","score":0.6690000295639038},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/china-trade","display_name":"China trade","score":0.5450000166893005},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/cantons","display_name":"cantons","score":0.3199999928474426},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/nineteenth-century-painting","display_name":"19th-century painting","score":0.5519999861717224}],"concepts":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/C162462552","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q134307","display_name":"Portrait","level":2,"score":0.7937483787536621},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C205783811","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q11629","display_name":"Painting","level":2,"score":0.7413149476051331},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C52119013","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q50637","display_name":"Art history","level":1,"score":0.5918789505958557},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C2781185075","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q211557","display_name":"Bequest","level":2,"score":0.5706839561462402},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C142362112","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q735","display_name":"Art","level":0,"score":0.5660784840583801},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C2776445246","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q1792644","display_name":"Style (visual arts)","level":2,"score":0.5513699054718018},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C67101536","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q5535910","display_name":"George (robot)","level":2,"score":0.513102650642395},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C81631423","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q10859","display_name":"Spanish Civil War","level":2,"score":0.4350617229938507},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C554144382","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q213156","display_name":"Performance art","level":2,"score":0.4182450473308563},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C191935318","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q148","display_name":"China","level":2,"score":0.417447030544281},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C95457728","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q309","display_name":"History","level":0,"score":0.35055577754974365},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C153349607","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q36649","display_name":"Visual arts","level":1,"score":0.29199206829071045},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C199539241","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q7748","display_name":"Law","level":1,"score":0.23043420910835266},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C17744445","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q36442","display_name":"Political science","level":0,"score":0.10990241169929504},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C166957645","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q23498","display_name":"Archaeology","level":1,"score":0.08795151114463806}],"mesh":[],"locations_count":1,"locations":[{"id":"doi:10.1086/675323","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1086/675323","is_oa":false,"landing_page_url":"https://doi.org/10.1086/675323","pdf_url":null,"source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S194950008","display_name":"Metropolitan Museum Journal","issn_l":"0077-8958","issn":["0077-8958","2169-3072"],"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":false,"listed_in":["anvur-scientific","norway-1","poland-70","russia-white-list-3"],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/P4310315672","host_organization_name":"University of Chicago Press","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/P4310315672","https://openalex.org/P4310315690"],"host_organization_lineage_names":["University of Chicago Press","University of Chicago"],"type":"journal"},"license":null,"license_id":null,"version":"publishedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":true,"raw_source_name":"Metropolitan Museum Journal","raw_type":"journal-article"}],"best_oa_location":null,"sustainable_development_goals":[],"sustainable_development_goals_aurora":[],"study_designs":[],"awards":[],"funders":[],"has_content":{"grobid_xml":false,"pdf":false},"content_urls":null,"referenced_works_count":15,"referenced_works":["https://openalex.org/W630585714","https://openalex.org/W637859294","https://openalex.org/W1525617288","https://openalex.org/W1544813496","https://openalex.org/W2001021477","https://openalex.org/W2032518442","https://openalex.org/W2043667301","https://openalex.org/W2132518299","https://openalex.org/W2152689725","https://openalex.org/W2275105482","https://openalex.org/W2325407837","https://openalex.org/W2796147846","https://openalex.org/W2797849642","https://openalex.org/W2970699031","https://openalex.org/W4285719527"],"related_works":["https://openalex.org/W7051762623","https://openalex.org/W7005024307","https://openalex.org/W612999238","https://openalex.org/W578766738","https://openalex.org/W2264843879","https://openalex.org/W7039428652","https://openalex.org/W224380173","https://openalex.org/W4235232443","https://openalex.org/W3002505152","https://openalex.org/W7036576309"],"abstract_inverted_index":{"Previous":[0],"articleNext":[1],"article":[2],"FreeChinnery":[3],"and":[4,79,112,277,349,359,387,390,437,459,476,537,639,667,675,679,686,689,704,718,725,728,736,743,764,815,824,865,871,961,964,991,1012,1076,1084,1102,1116,1154,1161,1183,1190,1200,1225,1235,1261,1270,1285,1292,1301,1336,1354,1382,1395,1427,1451,1514,1519,1654,1662,1672,1752,1834,1885,1938,1947,1952,2084,2250,2260,2285,2430,2437,2500,2542,2546,2559,2566,2578,2613,2639,2647,2666,2706,2714,2879,2920,2965,2981,3056,3072,3080,3124,3199,3248,3257,3328,3341,3367,3374,3399,3406,3435,3482,3495,3534,3545,3555,3611,3665,3750,3752,3757,3762,3782,3886,3890,3931,3954,4002,4048,4065,4093,4146,4161,4165,4182,4238,4258,4279,4304,4316,4373,4455,4661,4709],"Houqua:":[5],"Questions":[6],"of":[7,15,21,46,54,72,89,102,134,148,163,195,204,218,221,256,259,297,303,315,332,346,371,400,422,425,473,496,522,588,607,610,627,643,660,664,740,791,840,845,858,882,898,920,923,950,995,1027,1035,1050,1073,1079,1095,1134,1215,1218,1243,1275,1312,1317,1329,1333,1338,1430,1434,1464,1472,1511,1544,1564,1583,1606,1623,1645,1720,1773,1779,1782,1793,1865,1916,1922,1963,1968,2009,2015,2039,2052,2062,2077,2080,2088,2099,2105,2121,2153,2162,2219,2245,2280,2307,2310,2353,2368,2399,2443,2494,2526,2530,2581,2585,2592,2598,2607,2631,2664,2722,2735,2747,2770,2803,2830,2837,2871,2881,2889,2945,2983,2992,3010,3030,3068,3096,3102,3111,3132,3143,3155,3169,3186,3264,3267,3282,3310,3347,3357,3361,3394,3409,3417,3519,3607,3698,3734,3829,3844,3855,3883,3900,3935,4000,4014,4027,4060,4104,4124,4151,4158,4167,4177,4193,4282,4331,4345,4349,4354,4387,4411,4514,4531,4547,4552,4559,4581,4584,4593,4732],"AttributionJosephine":[8],"C.":[9,11,528,2221,4371],"DobkinJosephine":[10],"DobkinResearch":[12],"Assistant,":[13],"Department":[14,101,2309],"European":[16,1804,1836],"Paintings,":[17],"The":[18,69,87,104,165,253,268,604,621,878,918,989,1062,1283,1542,1568,1687,1856,1868,1981,2023,2265,2375,2396,2408,2524,3046,3242,3548,3651,3811,3833,3863,3933,4242,4251,4408,4422],"Metropolitan":[19,70,254,605,1208,2212,2397,2793,3134,3176,4006],"Museum":[20,71,255,606,2152,2161,2343,2398,2471,2734,2794,2798,3177,3360,3819,3828,3872,3999,4465,4558,4580,4592,4626],"Art":[22,73,2154,2736,3362,3830,4560],"Search":[23],"for":[24,142,167,272,343,355,394,543,714,730,782,812,1539,1587,1634,1741,2488,2576,2914,2978,3004,3078,3288,3325,3363,3438,3536,3542,3748,3755,3859,3995,4452],"more":[25,1428,1876,1896,2743,2787,3208,3249,3253,3851],"articles":[26],"by":[27,76,94,116,197,227,234,275,307,481,505,555,566,863,892,1250,1367,1385,1481,1550,1594,1630,1732,1750,1755,1850,1897,1977,2033,2446,2656,2785,2947,3014,3040,3061,3106,3215,3240,3273,3285,3291,3505,3531,3955,4024,4106,4135,4170,4277,4461,4510,4555,4568,4596,4623,4652,4678,4706],"this":[28,130,2357,2717,2826,3332,4046],"author":[29,1807],"PDFPDF":[30],"PLUSFull":[31],"Text":[32],"Add":[33],"to":[34,68,99,114,125,189,240,310,325,351,407,432,442,500,535,669,697,754,776,805,828,868,908,1479,1524,1527,1575,1611,1627,1641,1707,1745,1825,1878,1893,1974,1990,2030,2048,2072,2109,2127,2165,2194,2200,2273,2316,2321,2339,2363,2544,2572,2644,2654,2697,2720,2741,2745,2763,2782,2810,2855,2949,2996,3053,3089,3181,3219,3261,3322,3354,3391,3400,3429,3445,3491,3498,3615,3631,3635,3693,3746,3753,3866,3952,3959,4020,4090,4144,4262,4272,4292,4294,4307,4318,4321,4327,4369,4378,4466,4500,4516,4544,4561,4601,4627,4654,4668,4681,4711],"favoritesDownload":[35],"CitationTrack":[36],"CitationsPermissionsReprints":[37],"Share":[38],"onFacebookTwitterLinked":[39],"InRedditEmailQR":[40],"Code":[41],"SectionsMoreA":[42],"small,":[43,1397,1474],"full-length":[44,4225],"portrait":[45,169,559,671,922,1748,1775,1983,2025,2032,2123,2328,2682,2730,2752,2827,3009,3022,3110,3154,3238,3854,4023,4051,4276,4414],"an":[47,644,1104,1386,2495,2553,3656,4076],"elderly":[48],"Chinese":[49,110,140,190,304,483,568,948,998,1579,1631,1830,1964,2017,2054,2832,3016,3530,3601,3699],"gentleman":[50],"in":[51,74,139,199,280,336,353,373,410,471,479,511,548,561,637,677,684,733,747,799,903,910,936,970,1223,1228,1279,1295,1299,1342,1352,1392,1409,1442,1483,1530,1538,1603,1614,1649,1651,1691,1770,1795,1812,1874,1936,1942,1945,1948,1950,1958,1994,2028,2056,2236,2238,2248,2254,2276,2331,2347,2478,2522,2532,2537,2556,2609,2635,2671,2703,2834,2893,2901,2990,3075,3119,3158,3174,3183,3202,3223,3231,3331,3343,3420,3525,3637,3686,3730,3815,3824,3877,3887,3929,3948,4010,4062,4080,4102,4111,4114,4207,4217,4226,4256,4313,4336,4363,4374,4417],"the":[52,77,100,117,126,135,145,149,153,160,168,202,205,209,216,236,281,284,295,298,300,312,321,330,333,344,367,401,443,454,463,474,482,486,506,523,562,567,641,657,709,741,787,869,899,914,977,980,1014,1036,1040,1069,1074,1080,1088,1110,1229,1247,1280,1304,1313,1323,1330,1334,1339,1343,1346,1355,1364,1368,1393,1402,1410,1435,1438,1456,1473,1484,1488,1588,1643,1652,1723,1727,1771,1780,1803,1810,1820,1839,1862,1866,1919,1933,1955,1986,1995,2010,2016,2034,2040,2049,2053,2211,2217,2232,2246,2277,2281,2290,2299,2305,2308,2318,2340,2354,2485,2489,2508,2519,2528,2533,2549,2563,2573,2590,2596,2599,2610,2620,2636,2645,2672,2686,2691,2704,2712,2723,2732,2748,2751,2754,2771,2776,2792,2796,2801,2804,2811,2818,2850,2872,2918,2942,2963,3011,3019,3024,3036,3041,3054,3057,3062,3093,3097,3122,3125,3130,3133,3148,3167,3170,3175,3184,3196,3203,3237,3252,3262,3268,3300,3311,3345,3348,3358,3379,3395,3410,3469,3477,3502,3522,3529,3556,3600,3608,3612,3681,3687,3694,3731,3735,3740,3816,3825,3840,3845,3869,3916,3941,3993,4015,4021,4028,4032,4038,4050,4063,4068,4081,4085,4208,4301,4310,4322,4328,4332,4412,4453,4462,4511,4556],"robes":[53],"a":[55,63,193,290,405,420,493,513,520,531,556,716,829,835,851,929,947,955,971,983,986,996,1002,1006,1010,1020,1025,1032,1048,1054,1059,1092,1132,1219,1289,1374,1379,1396,1416,1448,1540,1637,1709,1718,1742,1767,1774,1777,1790,1817,1851,1903,1907,2031,2081,2085,2096,2113,2196,2242,2255,2293,2326,2505,2657,2728,2766,2786,2807,2869,2877,2912,2967,3008,3015,3049,3109,3226,4011,4057,4162,4314,4339,4379,4385],"public":[56,1033],"official,":[57],"seated":[58,966,1372],"with":[59,366,632,662,822,880,916,967,985,1024,1053,1099,1103,1120,1126,1246,1685,1712,1861,1888,2021,2518,2615,2660,2700,2828,2911,3188,3317],"crossed":[60,969,3685],"legs":[61,968,3683],"on":[62,96,243,419,594,932,1013,1109,1143,1172,1202,1373,1401,1415,1581,1819,2129,2140,2173,2298,2386,2419,2452,2507,2589,2619,2925,2969,3129,3501,3521,3660,3795,3908,3915,4229,4235,4265,4520,4570,4604,4630,4684,4715],"red":[64,1021,1375,3197],"divan,":[65,3198],"was":[66,123,131,170,187,287,294,381,418,469,477,516,541,635,640,651,888,1522,1636,1666,1694,1703,1716,1738,1842,1930,2241,2287,2314,2337,2359,2552,2633,2683,2695,2739,2853,2868,3416,3489,3655,3857,3943,4070,4239,4359,4384],"bequeathed":[67,2338,4499,4543],"1941":[75,263],"architect":[78],"collector":[80],"W.":[81,260,893,4437],"Gedney":[82,261],"Beatty":[83],"(1869\u20131941)":[84],"(Figure":[85,578,876,886,942,1211,2091,2102,2224,2263,2349,2510,2737,2760],"1).":[86],"balance":[88],"his":[90,273,388,408,426,497,538,723,758,762,797,810,816,838,843,847,1018,1051,1465,1470,1502,1507,1512,1528,1531,1747,1796,1898,1923,2110,2332,2835,2861,2890,2902,2953,2984,2993,3005,3189,3318,3901,4218,4263,4274,4478],"bequest,":[91],"366":[92],"books":[93],"or":[95,182,1043,1315,1326,2795,3294,3515,3895,4083,4419],"Vitruvius,":[97],"went":[98],"Prints.1":[103],"lone":[105],"painting,":[106,2603,2638,4016],"then":[107,780,1753,2625],"titled":[108,4352],"A":[109,397,1389,1757,2226],"Merchant":[111,4348],"thought":[113],"be":[115,213,433,926,1480,1576,1612,1628,1985,2117,2373,2655,2698,2721,2742,2783,2950,3039,3147,3272],"English":[118],"artist":[119,569,1690,2055,2291,2813],"George":[120,222,1137,1166,1195,2135,2380,2412,4517,4565,4712],"Chinnery":[121,223,819,934,1482,1498,1557,1665,1731,1751,2214,2251,2267,2444,2948,3210,3234,3274,3754,3812,4278,4340],"(1774\u20131852),":[122],"assigned":[124],"American":[127,137,278,823,2037,2498,2812,3380,3549,3996,4194],"Wing.2":[128],"Undoubtedly":[129],"done":[132,1613,2014],"because":[133,3307,3606],"strong":[136],"interest":[138,3330],"goods,":[141],"which,":[143],"from":[144,357,503,774,786,928,1087,1303,1578,1705,2216,2516,2841,2909,2916,2931,2962,3221,3225,3528,3875,3950,4031,4205,4420],"early":[146,2496],"days":[147],"China":[150,282,524,1928,2237],"trade":[151,365,457,2555],"until":[152,329,485,691,749,796,2335,3966],"Civil":[154],"War,":[155],"New":[156,1943,1975,2538,4211],"York":[157,1944,2539,4212],"had":[158,767,2884,2906,2975,3957,4087,4222],"been":[159,2125,2865,3315,3384,3893,4088,4326,4401],"principal":[161,1688],"port":[162,323],"entry.3":[164],"sitter":[166,206],"later":[171,773,3165,3496],"identified":[172],"as":[173,192,215,681,683,1241,1253,1657,1675,1677,2093,2095,2112,2231,2361,2874,2876,3137,3139,3173,3539,3541,4246,4367,4376],"Houqua":[174,286,431,468,628,859,924,1046,1090,1210,1370,1545,1982,2024,2207,2320,2327,2602,2681,2729,2858,2946,2961,3013,3112,3156,3190,4291,4413],"II":[175],"(Wu":[176],"Bingjian,":[177],"1769\u20131843),4":[178],"also":[179,761,2066,2324,3425,3927],"spelled":[180],"Hoqua":[181],"Howqua5":[183],"(the":[184],"syllable":[185],"\u201cqua\u201d":[186],"added":[188,1913],"names":[191],"mark":[194,2584,3128,3914],"respect":[196],"Europeans":[198],"Canton).6":[200],"While":[201,1664],"identification":[203],"is":[207,552,629,854,861,965,982,1047,1064,1130,1213,1350,1357,1371,1383,1391,1460,1585,1590,1859,1891,1993,2026,2492,2806,2988,3066,3164,3212,3245,3277,3480,3691,3814,3823,3835,3850,4109,4253,4395,4424],"correct,":[208],"Museum\u2019s":[210,563,1209,2213,2266,2282,2675,2779,3135,3487,4033,4041],"painting":[211,237,626,737,857,1633,1678,1832,2358,2491,3037,4086,4252],"cannot":[212],"accepted":[214],"work":[217,1580,2780,3047,3244,4030],"Chinnery.71.":[219],"Style":[220,2442],"(English,":[224],"1774\u20131852),":[225],"possibly":[226,3271],"Esther":[228,3043,4562],"Speakman":[229,3044,4563],"(American,":[230],"1823\u20131875).":[231],"Houqua.":[232],"If":[233],"Speakman,":[235,3069],"would":[238,1609,1625,3000,3382],"date":[239,919,3142],"1843.":[241],"Oil":[242,1142,1171,2139,2172,2385,2418,2451,3794,4180],"canvas,":[244,1144,1173,2141,2174,2387,2420,2453,3796,4521,4571,4605,4631,4685,4716],"25":[245,1549,4632],"\u00d7":[246,250,597,601,1146,1150,1175,1179,2143,2147,2176,2180,2389,2393,2422,2426,2455,2459,3798,4248,4523,4527,4573,4577,4607,4611,4633,4637,4687,4691,4718,4722],"18\u215d":[247,1551,2177],"in.":[248,599,1148,1177,2145,2178,2391,2424,2457,4525,4575,4609,4635,4689,4720],"(63.5":[249,4636],"47.3":[251,2181],"cm).":[252,603,1152,1181,2149,2182,2395,2428,2461],"Art,":[257,608,2400,3997,4195,4582],"Bequest":[258,4731],"Beatty,":[262],"(41.160.405).":[264],"Photograph:":[265,618,1159,1188,2158,2189,2405,2435,2467],"Juan":[266,619,2406],"Trujillo,":[267,620,2407],"Photograph":[269,622,2409],"Studio,":[270,623,2410],"MMARevered":[271],"honesty":[274],"British":[276,402,825,1759,2283,3741],"businessmen":[279],"trade,":[283,3610],"melancholy-looking":[285],"not":[288,415,756,1351,1407,1500,1739,2058,3278,4254,4425],"just":[289,784,2907],"hong":[291,3550,3661],"merchant;":[292],"he":[293,650,653,695,700,721,745,752,771,833,1445,1787,1814,1872,1881,1890,2936,2958,2999,3229,4221,4287],"leader":[296],"cohong,":[299],"powerful":[301],"guild":[302],"traders":[305,429,1251,3613],"authorized":[306],"their":[308,395,489,1244,1496,3439],"government":[309,3602],"oversee":[311],"business":[313,1648,2979,3520],"dealings":[314],"Western":[316,428,972,1743,2060,2067,3250],"merchants":[317,339,445,2018,3533],"at":[318,383,545,656,1017,1765,1918,1932,2685,2731,2753,3023,3092,3468,3847,3868,3897,3944,3992,4075],"Canton":[319,502,806,832,1650,2910,3222,3526,4350,4441],"(Guangzhou),":[320],"only":[322,757,855,2059,2640,3306],"open":[324],"foreigners":[326,3605],"after":[327,518,807,1802,3113,3493,4564],"1757":[328],"opening":[331],"treaty":[334],"ports":[335],"1842.8":[337],"Hong":[338,1305,1411,1439,2150,2159,3159,3826,4347,4447],"paid":[340,492,802],"large":[341],"sums":[342],"privilege":[345],"selling":[347],"silk":[348,1022],"tea":[350],"Westerners":[352,487,1646],"exchange":[354],"opium":[356,460,1281,3609],"India":[358,748,901],"Turkey.":[360],"They":[361,1237],"controlled":[362],"all":[363,1287,1433,1463,1547,1622,1972,2104,2711],"foreign":[364,444,3532],"port,":[368],"earning":[369],"millions":[370],"dollars":[372],"revenue":[374],"annually.9":[375],"In":[376,451,647,693,1360,1553,2351,2595,2952,3083],"1834":[377],"Houqua\u2019s":[378,509,550,2122],"personal":[379,3006],"wealth":[380],"estimated":[382],"twenty-six":[384],"million":[385],"dollars,":[386],"villa":[389],"gardens":[391,1052],"were":[392,1238,1467,1477,1970,2007,2377,2570,2624,2649,3104,3517,4244,4415],"famous":[393],"beauty.":[396],"staff":[398],"member":[399],"embassy":[403],"recalled":[404],"visit":[406],"mansion":[409],"1817:":[411],"\u201cHowqua\u2019s":[412],"house,":[413],"though":[414,1509,1722,2860],"yet":[416],"finished,":[417],"scale":[421],"magnificence":[423],"worthy":[424],"fortune.\u201d10The":[427],"believed":[430],"fair,":[434],"friendly,":[435],"intelligent,":[436],"generous.11":[438],"He":[439,491,779,793,953,1420,1504,1521,1618,1715,1940],"offered":[440],"assistance":[441,3419],"who":[446,634,766,905,1702,2019,2202,2229,2883,3070],"\u201cfound":[447],"themselves":[448],"financially":[449],"embarrassed.\u201d12":[450],"1839,":[452],"when":[453,649,751,770],"emperor":[455],"ordered":[456],"halted":[458],"destroyed":[461,488],"during":[462,1469],"first":[464,654,906,1821,3217],"Opium":[465],"War":[466],"(1839\u201342),":[467],"put":[470,4312],"charge":[472],"burning":[475],"held":[478,1222],"chains":[480],"authorities":[484],"stocks.13":[490],"fine":[494,1324],"out":[495,2365,3678],"own":[498,1532,4275],"pocket":[499],"save":[501],"bombardment":[504],"British.14":[507],"After":[508,2677,3598],"death":[510,798],"1843,":[512,3144,4364],"clipper":[514],"ship":[515],"named":[517],"him;":[519],"relative":[521],"trader":[525,1744,2228],"Benjamin":[526,1271,2414,4470,4490],"R.":[527],"Low":[529],"composed":[530],"memorial":[532],"poem":[533],"dedicated":[534],"him;15":[536],"wax":[539],"effigy":[540],"displayed":[542],"years":[544],"Madame":[546],"Tussaud\u2019s":[547],"London.16":[549],"appearance":[551],"further":[553,2848],"documented":[554],"small":[557,673,1846,1863,2257],"watercolor-on-ivory":[558],"head":[560,2646],"collection":[564,2218,3007,4680],"signed":[565,1506,2259],"Tingqua":[570,580],"(Guan":[571,1699],"Lianchang,":[572],"born":[573,582,636],"ca.":[574,583,591,1140,1169,2137,2170,2383,2449,3792,3837,4434,4475],"1809;":[575,584],"active":[576,585,1704,2554],"1840\u201370)":[577],"2).2.":[579],"(Chinese,":[581,2167],"1840\u201370).":[586],"Portrait":[587,663,2079,4342,4353],"Houqua,":[589,1125,1139,1197,1969,2448,3791,4346,4433,4567],"signed,":[590],"1840.":[592,3793],"Watercolor":[593],"ivory,":[595],"6\u00be":[596],"4\u00bd":[598],"(17.1":[600],"11.4":[602],"Gift":[609,4583],"Mrs.":[611,4380,4480,4489],"John":[612,1254,1259],"de":[613],"Peyster":[614],"Douw,":[615],"1966":[616],"(66.109).":[617],"MMAThe":[624],"oil":[625,678,945],"traditionally":[630],"associated":[631,3316],"Chinnery,":[633,715,864,1912,2136,2997,3304,4432,4518,4566,4713],"London":[638],"son":[642],"amateur":[645],"artist.":[646],"1791,":[648],"seventeen,":[652],"exhibited":[655,1941,3116,3200,4338,4360],"Royal":[658,1934],"Academy":[659,1935,3095,4330],"Arts":[661],"His":[665],"Father":[666],"continued":[668],"show":[670],"miniatures,":[672,1833],"whole-lengths":[674],"portraits":[676,1466,1573,1864,1877,1962,2012,2046,2888],"crayon":[680],"well":[682,1676,1883,2094,2362,2875,3138,3540],"pencil,":[685],"finally":[687],"watercolors":[688],"landscapes,":[690,1831],"1846.":[692],"1797":[694],"moved":[696,772,3958],"Dublin,":[698],"where":[699,1823,3963],"gained":[701],"Irish":[702],"patrons":[703],"married":[705],"Marianne":[706],"Vigne.":[707],"When":[708],"marriage":[710],"proved":[711],"too":[712],"constraining":[713],"colorful":[717],"eccentric":[719],"character,":[720],"abandoned":[722],"wife":[724,763],"two":[726,2641,2886,3090],"children":[727],"sailed":[729],"Madras":[731,775],"(Chennai)":[732],"1802.17":[734],"Sketching":[735],"vibrant":[738],"scenes":[739],"people":[742],"country,":[744],"remained":[746,2330,3965],"1825,":[750],"fled":[753],"escape":[755],"creditors":[759],"but":[760,801,1487,1929,2065,3839,4399],"family,":[765,2986],"joined":[768,4008],"him":[769,850,1684,2253,2915,3286],"Calcutta":[777],"(Kolkata).":[778],"left":[781,1927,2621,2940],"Macao,":[783],"downriver":[785],"major":[788],"trading":[789,3553,3736,3742],"center":[790],"Canton.18":[792],"lived":[794],"there":[795,2551,3117,4095,4361],"1852":[800],"no":[803,1895,4097,4396],"visits":[804],"1832.19":[808],"Given":[809,1455],"propensity":[811],"accurate":[813],"likenesses":[814],"quick":[817],"wit,":[818],"became":[820,834],"friends":[821],"traders.":[826],"According":[827,4261],"contemporary,":[830],"\u201cat":[831],"general":[836],"favorite,":[837],"anecdotes":[839],"Indian":[841],"life,":[842],"powers":[844],"description,":[846],"eccentricities,":[848],"made":[849,1277,2292,2977,3744],"much-sought-for":[852],"guest.\u201d20There":[853],"one":[856,1214,1365,1967,2718],"that":[860,881,1068,1462,1562,1571,1620,1809,1992,2003,2044,2119,2289,2329,2484,2513,2623,2746,2829,2904,2921,2957,2998,3031,3035,3152,3280,3289,3476,3679,3729,4067,4074,4220],"assuredly":[862],"it":[866,1459,2286,2313,2336,2514,2694,2987,3201,3276,3876,3964,4234,4306],"belongs":[867],"Hongkong":[870,1153,1160,1182,1189,2429,2436,4454],"Shanghai":[872,1155,1162,1184,1191,2431,2438,4456],"Banking":[873,1156,1163,1185,1192,2432,2439,4457],"Corporation":[874],"(HSBC)":[875],"3).":[877],"portrait,":[879,2859,3172],"another":[883,2831],"merchant,":[884],"Mouqua":[885,2101,3856],"4),":[887],"commissioned":[889,2854],"about":[890,1495,1548,1555,1901,2089,2540,3848,3861],"1827":[891],"H.":[894,3402,3461,3463,4438],"Chicheley":[895,4439],"Plowden,":[896,3206,4440],"president":[897],"East":[900],"Company":[902],"Canton,":[904,2249],"returned":[907,2908,3180,3218,3230],"England":[909,1976,3220,3636,4145],"1830,":[911],"presumably":[912],"taking":[913],"pictures":[915,3312],"him.21":[917],"Plowden\u2019s":[921],"can":[925,1882],"construed":[927],"preliminary":[930],"drawing":[931,1668,1829],"which":[933,1535,1798,1813,2106,2199,3194,3939,4017,4335],"inscribed":[935],"shorthand":[937],"\u201cDecember":[938],"26th":[939],"[18]27.":[940],"Canton\u201d22":[941],"5).":[943],"Chinnery\u2019s":[944,1572,1615,1713,1721,2078,2100,2369,2960,3153,3853,4290],"shows":[946],"man":[949],"indeterminate":[951],"age.":[952],"has":[954,1446,1452,1491,1536,2863,3033,4400],"wistful":[956],"expression,":[957],"high,":[958],"wide":[959,1457],"forehead,":[960],"wispy":[962],"mustache":[963],"pose,":[973],"slightly":[974],"turned":[975],"toward":[976,3370],"viewer.":[978],"On":[979,1310,1838,2726,2800,2895,2933,4284,4296],"right":[981],"column":[984],"decorated":[987],"base.":[988],"furnishings":[990],"accoutrements":[992],"are":[993,1517,1546,1574,1799,2074,2669,3284,3684,3882,4096,4429],"those":[994,2004,2206],"wealthy":[997],"man:":[999],"elegant":[1000],"tables,":[1001],"tasseled":[1003],"hanging":[1004],"lantern,":[1005],"delicate":[1007],"porcelain":[1008],"teacup,":[1009,1083],"spittoon,":[1011,1082],"high":[1015],"table":[1016,1399],"elbow":[1019],"hat":[1023],"finial":[1026],"opaque":[1028],"lapis":[1029],"lazuli":[1030],"denoting":[1031],"official":[1034],"fourth":[1037],"grade.23":[1038],"Through":[1039],"tall":[1041],"window":[1042],"door":[1044],"behind":[1045,1418],"glimpse":[1049],"distant":[1055],"temple":[1056],"set":[1057],"against":[1058,2198],"stormy":[1060],"sky.":[1061],"picture":[1063,1307,1413,4303],"atmospherically":[1065],"lit":[1066],"so":[1067,3308,4094],"head,":[1070],"fur":[1071,1101,1331],"edgings":[1072],"sleeves":[1075],"robe,":[1077],"soles":[1078,1337],"shoes,":[1081],"sunset":[1085],"emerge":[1086],"shadows.":[1089],"wears":[1091,1421],"calf-length":[1093],"surcoat":[1094],"blue-black":[1096],"satin":[1097,1114,1118],"lined":[1098],"white":[1100,1121],"embroidered":[1105,3652],"phoenix":[1106,3653],"rank":[1107],"badge":[1108,3654],"chest,":[1111],"light":[1112,2352,2991],"blue":[1113],"trousers,":[1115],"black":[1117,4053],"boots":[1119],"felted":[1122],"paper":[1123],"soles.24":[1124],"elegantly":[1127],"attenuated":[1128],"wrists,":[1129],"fingering":[1131],"necklace":[1133],"semiprecious":[1135],"stones.3.":[1136],"Chinnery.":[1138,1167,1196,2381,2413,3114],"1828.":[1141,1170,2384,2417,3862],"24\u00bd":[1145,1174,4572,4717],"18\u00be":[1147,1176],"(62.2":[1149,1178,4576],"47.6":[1151,1180],"Corporation,":[1157,1164,1186,1193,2433,2440,4458],"Ltd.":[1158,1187,2434],"Ltd.4.":[1165],"Mouqua,":[1168,2169],"Ltd.5.":[1194],"1827.":[1198],"Pen":[1199],"ink":[1201],"paper,":[1203],"dimensions":[1204,4243],"unknown.":[1205],"Location":[1206],"unknownThe":[1207],"1)":[1212],"many":[1216,1274,3309],"variants":[1217,2715],"different":[1220,2658,3898],"composition":[1221],"museums":[1224],"private":[1226,4597,4620,4679,4698],"collections":[1227],"eastern":[1230],"United":[1231,2233,2534,2564,2574,3557,4599,4617],"States,":[1232,2565],"Great":[1233],"Britain,":[1234],"Ireland.":[1236],"brought":[1239,1973,2839],"home":[1240,4271],"souvenirs":[1242],"association":[1245],"great":[1248,2243,3012],"merchant":[1249,2833],"such":[1252,1319,2045],"Perkins":[1255],"Cushing,":[1256],"Nathan":[1257],"Dunn,":[1258],"M.":[1260],"Robert":[1262],"Bennet":[1263],"Forbes,":[1264],"Augustine":[1265,1978],"Heard,":[1266],"Samuel":[1267],"Wadsworth":[1268],"Russell,":[1269],"Chew":[1272,2415,4471],"Wilcocks,":[1273,2416,3107,4372,4472],"whom":[1276],"fortunes":[1278],"trade.25":[1282],"versions":[1284,2120,2713,4410,4428],"copies,":[1286],"showing":[1288],"frontal":[1290,1475,3258],"figure":[1291],"virtually":[1293],"identical":[1294,3052],"size,":[1296],"differ":[1297],"significantly":[1298],"quality":[1300,2029],"detail":[1302],"Kong":[1306,1412,1440,2151,2160,3160,3827,4448],"(see":[1308,3161,3191],"appendix).":[1309],"examination":[1311,3906],"originals":[1314,4206],"photographs":[1316],"eight":[1318,1824],"paintings,":[1320,1508,2284],"none":[1321],"contains":[1322],"highlights":[1325],"painterly":[1327],"treatment":[1328],"edging":[1332],"robe":[1335],"shoes":[1340],"found":[1341,2634,2740,4056],"HSBC":[1344,3243],"work;":[1345],"superbly":[1347],"painted":[1348,1629,1749,1815,2205,2252,2627,2784,2885,3071,3236,3858,3894],"teacup":[1349],"evidence,":[1353],"pose":[1356,3690],"less":[1358,2661,2767,3385],"refined.26":[1359],"these":[1361,1607,1692,2480],"iterations,":[1362],"including":[1363,1966,3108],"owned":[1366,2325,3105,3214,3239],"Metropolitan,":[1369,2749],"divan":[1376,3171],"rather":[1377,1423],"than":[1378,1424,1880,1900,2668,2790,3166,3251],"wood":[1380],"armchair":[1381],"framed":[1384],"octagonal":[1387],"window.":[1388],"pilaster":[1390],"background,":[1394],"low":[1398],"perches":[1400],"divan.":[1403],"An":[1404],"incense":[1405],"burner":[1406],"present":[1408],"sits":[1414],"pedestal":[1417],"him.":[1419],"striped":[1422],"plain":[1425],"trousers":[1426],"strings":[1429],"beads.":[1431],"Not":[1432],"faces":[1436],"resemble":[1437],"Houqua;":[1441],"some":[1443,1510],"cases":[1444],"acquired":[1447,3021],"faint":[1449],"beard":[1450],"aged":[1453],"significantly.":[1454],"variation,":[1458],"unlikely":[1461],"created":[1468],"lifetime.27Most":[1471],"full-lengths":[1476,1543],"assumed":[1478],"mid-nineteenth":[1485],"century,":[1486],"twentieth":[1489],"century":[1490],"seen":[1492],"much":[1493,1734],"conjecture":[1494],"authorship.":[1497],"did":[1499],"replicate":[1501],"work.":[1503],"rarely":[1505],"pen-and-ink":[1513],"pencil":[1515,2296,2617],"sketches":[1516],"initialed":[1518],"dated.28":[1520],"apt":[1523],"add":[1525],"notes":[1526,1808,3728],"drawings":[1529],"complicated":[1533],"shorthand,":[1534],"stood":[1537],"signature.29":[1541],"inches.":[1552,4250],"writing":[1554,1602],"them,":[1556],"expert":[1558,2001],"Patrick":[1559,3430],"Conner":[1560,2042,3639,3763],"explains":[1561],"\u201cproblems":[1563],"attribution":[1565,2809,3488],"become":[1566],"acute.":[1567],"once-cherished":[1569],"notion":[1570],"distinguished":[1577],"grounds":[1582],"\u2018quality\u2019":[1584],"inadequate,":[1586],"latter":[1589,1724,3834,4029],"often":[1591],"highly":[1592],"accomplished":[1593],"any":[1595,2367,3266,3281],"standards.\u201d30":[1596],"For":[1597],"Albert":[1598],"Ten":[1599],"Eyck":[1600],"Gardner,":[1601],"1953,":[1604,3453,3511,3574,3580,3583,3618,3714],"\u201cfew":[1605],"paintings":[1608],"seem":[1610],"characteristic":[1616],"style.\u201d":[1617],"concluded":[1619],"\u201calmost":[1621],"them":[1624,1887,3103,3283],"appear":[1626],"artists.\u201d31Chinese":[1632],"export":[1635],"particular":[1638],"genre":[1639],"developed":[1640,1906],"satisfy":[1642],"taste":[1644],"doing":[1647],"eighteenth":[1653],"nineteenth":[1655],"centuries,":[1656],"they":[1658],"experienced":[1659],"local":[1660,1681],"life":[1661],"customs.32":[1663],"deftly":[1667],"street":[1669],"scenes,":[1670],"animals,":[1671],"marine":[1673],"views":[1674],"portraits,":[1679,2208],"flourishing":[1680],"artists":[1682],"provided":[1683,4045],"competition.":[1686],"Cantonese":[1689],"endeavors":[1693],"Tingqua\u2019s":[1695],"older":[1696],"brother":[1697],"Lamqua":[1698,1729,1783,1905,1961,1991,2073,2128,2166,3747,3867],"Zuolin,":[1700],"1801\u20131860),":[1701],"1825":[1706],"1860,":[1708],"period":[1710],"coinciding":[1711],"stay.":[1714],"reportedly":[1717],"pupil":[1719],"emphatically":[1725],"denied":[1726],"claim.33":[1728],"undercut":[1730],"charging":[1733,4240],"lower":[1735],"rates.34":[1736],"It":[1737,2115,2503,4358],"uncommon":[1740],"have":[1746,2124,2195,2204,3002,3235,3313,3383,4325],"copied":[1754,3073],"Lamqua.35":[1756],"contemporary":[1758],"account":[1760],"describes":[1761],"him:":[1762],"\u201cThere":[1763],"resides":[1764],"Macao":[1766,3632],"singular":[1768],"character":[1769],"person":[1772,4418],"painter,":[1776],"Chinese,":[1778],"name":[1781],".":[1784,1785,1786,1853,1854,1855,4153,4154,4155],"shews":[1788],"[sic]":[1789],"wonderful":[1791],"degree":[1792],"talent":[1794,2111],"pictures,":[1797],"executed":[1800],"altogether":[1801],"style.\u201d36":[1805],"Another":[1806],"building":[1811],"included":[1816,3195],"workshop":[1818],"floor,":[1822],"ten":[1826],"assistants":[1827],"toiled,":[1828],"copying":[1835],"prints.":[1837],"top":[1840],"floor":[1841],"Lamqua\u2019s":[1843,3821],"studio,":[1844],"\u201ca":[1845],"unornamented":[1847],"room":[1848],"lighted":[1849],"skylight.":[1852],"whole":[1857,2943],"wainscot":[1858],"covered":[1860],"sitters.\u201d":[1867],"writer":[1869],"continues,":[1870],"\u201cAlthough":[1871],"has,":[1873],"general,":[1875],"paint":[1879,4113],"accomplish,":[1884],"finishes":[1886],"expedition,":[1889],"considered":[1892],"make":[1894],"profession":[1899],"\u00a3500":[1902],"year.\u201d37":[1904],"fluent":[1908],"style":[1909],"and,":[1910],"like":[1911],"vivid":[1914],"flashes":[1915],"color":[1917],"final":[1920],"stages":[1921,3899],"work.38Lamqua":[1924],"purportedly":[1925],"never":[1926,2864],"represented":[1931],"1835":[1937],"1845.":[1939],"1841":[1946],"Philadelphia":[1949,2227,2341,2465,2733,2797,3025,3182,3359,3949,3998,4473,4501,4557,4591],"1851":[1951],"1860.":[1953],"At":[1954,2548],"Boston":[1956,2545],"Athenaeum":[1957,4710],"1850,39":[1959],"five":[1960,2005],"merchants,":[1965],"displayed,":[1971],"Heard":[1979],"(1785\u20131868).40":[1980],"could":[1984,3146,3270],"waist-length":[1987],"likeness":[1988],"attributed":[1989,2071,2126,2762,3865],"Ipswich":[1996],"Public":[1997,4213],"Library,":[1998],"Massachusetts.41":[1999],"One":[2000],"effused":[2002],"works":[2006,2070,2838],"\u201csome":[2008],"finest":[2011],"ever":[2013],"dealt":[2020],"Westerners.":[2022],"equal":[2027],"most":[2035],"academic":[2036],"painter":[2038],"period.\u201d42":[2041],"agrees":[2043],"\u201cattest":[2047],"remarkable":[2050],"talents":[2051],"adopting":[2057],"techniques":[2061],"manipulating":[2063],"paint,":[2064],"conventions.\u201d43":[2068],"Other":[2069,4183],"good":[2075],"copies":[2076,2976],"Tanka":[2082],"Boatwoman":[2083],"half-length":[2086],"self-portrait":[2087,2215,2268,3813],"1850":[2090,3849],"6)":[2092],"skillful":[2097,2788],"version":[2098,2652,2769,2862,3864],"7),":[2103],"may":[2107,2203,3038,3297],"attest":[2108],"painter.44":[2114],"should":[2116],"noted":[2118,4066,4216,4245],"limited,":[2130],"if":[2131,2366,3305],"any,":[2132],"evidence.6.":[2133],"Lamqua.":[2134],"1850.":[2138],"9\u00be":[2142],"7\u00bd":[2144],"(24.7":[2146],"19":[2148,2456,4249,4634],"Collection":[2155],"(AH":[2156,3831],"1991-0003).":[2157],"Art7.":[2163],"Attributed":[2164,4509,4554,4595,4622,4677,4705],"1801\u20131860).":[2168],"1828\u201340.":[2171],"24":[2175],"(60.8":[2179],"Peabody":[2183,2190,2755,3411,3470,3817,3841,3870,4039,4624,4669,4674],"Essex":[2184,2191,2756,3412,3471,3818,3871,4040,4625,4640,4670,4675],"Museum,":[2185,2464,2757,3026,3398,3472,4007,4503,4641,4671],"Salem,":[2186,2758,3473,4642],"Massachusetts":[2187,2759,4643],"(M20450).":[2188],"MuseumIn":[2192],"order":[2193],"standard":[2197],"judge":[2201],"we":[2209,4018],"examined":[2210,2684],"B.":[2220,3443,4370,4656,4659],"Wilcocks":[2222,2240,2323,2355,2867,2905,2922,2939,2974,3079,3179,4273],"(1776\u20131845)":[2223],"8).45":[2225],"served":[2230],"States":[2234,2535,2575,3558],"consul":[2235],"1812,":[2239],"friend":[2244,2878],"artist\u2019s":[2247,3880],"splendid":[2256],"full-length,":[2258],"dated":[2261,3836],"1828":[2262,3187,4337],"9).":[2264],"underwent":[2269],"infrared":[2270],"reflectography":[2271],"prior":[2272],"its":[2274],"publication":[2275],"2009":[2278],"catalogue":[2279,3503],"discovered":[2288],"careful":[2294,4012],"preparatory":[2295],"sketch":[2297],"canvas":[2300,2486,2582,3126,3912,4099],"before":[2301,3633],"applying":[2302],"paint.46":[2303],"With":[2304],"cooperation":[2306],"Paintings":[2311,4133,4168],"Conservation,":[2312],"decided":[2315],"submit":[2317],"Metropolitan\u2019s":[2319,2490,2637,3055,4022],"X-radiography.":[2322],"immediate":[2333],"family":[2334],"Maritime":[2342,4502],"(Independence":[2344],"Seaport":[2345,2463,2469,2674,2688,2778,3397,3986,4464,4506],"Museum)":[2346],"1988":[2348],"10).":[2350],"connection,":[2356],"X-rayed":[2360],"find":[2364],"trademark":[2370],"underdrawing":[2371,2608,2632],"might":[2372],"discovered.":[2374,2650],"results":[2376],"largely":[2378],"negative.8.":[2379],"Self-Portrait,":[2382],"8\u215d":[2388],"7\u00bc":[2390],"(21.9":[2392],"18.4":[2394],"Rogers":[2401],"Fund,":[2402],"1943":[2403],"(43.132.4).":[2404],"MMA9.":[2411],"28":[2421],"18\u00bd":[2423,4524,4719],"(71.1":[2425],"47":[2427,4528,4723],"Ltd.10.":[2441],"(possibly":[2445],"him).":[2447],"1825.":[2450],"26":[2454,4247],"(66":[2458],"48.3":[2460],"Independence":[2462,2468,2600,2673,2687,2772,2777,3396,3985,4463,4505],"(88.10).":[2466],"MuseumMetropolitan":[2470],"conservator":[2472,4042],"Dorothy":[2473,3335],"Mahon":[2474,2604,3336],"shared":[2475],"her":[2476,3326,3339,3365,3377,4487],"expertise":[2477,3342],"assessing":[2479],"results.47":[2481],"She":[2482,3115,4072],"observed":[2483],"used":[2487,3535],"typical":[2493,3697],"nineteenth-century":[2497],"prepared":[2499,2557,3940],"stretched":[2501],"canvas.":[2502,2774],"bears":[2504,3048],"stencil":[2506,3051,4394],"back":[2509,2591,2802,2840,3131,3629],"11),":[2511],"indicating":[2512],"came":[2515,3628],"Philadelphia,":[2517],"initials":[2520,3058],"ES":[2521],"ink.48":[2523],"practice":[2525],"stenciling":[2527],"backs":[2529],"canvases":[2531,2558,2569,3074,3088],"started":[2536,4223],"1830":[2541],"spread":[2543],"Philadelphia.49":[2547],"time":[2550,3340],"pigments":[2560],"between":[2561,4173],"England,":[2562],"China.50":[2567],"Completed":[2568],"sent":[2571,4305,4317],"stretching":[2577],"framing.11.":[2579],"Replica":[2580],"maker\u2019s":[2583,3127,3913],"Ashton":[2586,3936],"&":[2587,3920,3937,4726],"Browning":[2588],"Figure":[2593,3162,3192],"112.":[2594],"X-ray":[2597],"Seaport\u2019s":[2601,2773],"perceived":[2605],"signs":[2606],"face,":[2611],"lips,":[2612],"hands,":[2614],"possible":[2616],"lines":[2618],"foot":[2622],"thickly":[2626],"up.":[2628],"No":[2629],"hint":[2630],"minor":[2642],"adjustments":[2643],"vase":[2648],"This":[2651],"seems":[2653,2719,3150],"hand,":[2659],"freedom,":[2662],"softness":[2663],"modeling,":[2665],"spontaneity":[2667],"evident":[2670],"portrait.":[2676],"being":[2678],"X-rayed,":[2679],"Wilcocks\u2019s":[2680,2857],"Museum.51":[2689],"Supporting":[2690],"earlier":[2692,4077],"findings,":[2693],"judged":[2696]},"counts_by_year":[{"year":2025,"cited_by_count":1},{"year":2018,"cited_by_count":1}],"updated_date":"2025-11-06T03:46:38.306776","created_date":"2016-06-24T00:00:00"}