{"id":"https://openalex.org/W1903868356","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1002/1944-2866.poi326","title":"Addressing the policy challenges and opportunities of \u201cBig data\u201d","display_name":"Addressing the policy challenges and opportunities of \u201cBig data\u201d","publication_year":2013,"publication_date":"2013-06-01","ids":{"openalex":"https://openalex.org/W1903868356","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1002/1944-2866.poi326","mag":"1903868356"},"language":"en","primary_location":{"id":"doi:10.1002/1944-2866.poi326","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1002/1944-2866.poi326","is_oa":false,"landing_page_url":"https://doi.org/10.1002/1944-2866.poi326","pdf_url":null,"source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S2170549","display_name":"Policy & Internet","issn_l":"1944-2866","issn":["1944-2866"],"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":true,"listed_in":["anvur-class-a","anvur-scientific","cwts-core","jufo-1","norway-1","poland-100","russia-white-list-1","vabb-shw"],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/P4310320595","host_organization_name":"Wiley","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/P4310320595"],"host_organization_lineage_names":["Wiley"],"type":"journal"},"license":null,"license_id":null,"version":"publishedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":true,"raw_source_name":"Policy & Internet","raw_type":"journal-article"},"volume":null,"type":"article","indexed_in":["crossref"],"open_access":{"is_oa":false,"oa_status":"closed","oa_url":null,"any_repository_has_fulltext":false},"authorships":[{"author_position":"first","author":{"id":"https://openalex.org/A5038233956","display_name":"Helen Zerlina Margetts","orcid":"https://orcid.org/0000-0003-4597-8283","observed_orcids":["https://orcid.org/0000-0003-4597-8283"]},"institutions":[],"countries":[],"is_corresponding":false,"raw_author_name":"Helen Margetts","raw_affiliation_strings":[],"raw_orcid":null,"affiliations":[]},{"author_position":"last","author":{"id":null,"display_name":"David Sutcliffe","orcid":null,"observed_orcids":[]},"institutions":[],"countries":[],"is_corresponding":false,"raw_author_name":"David Sutcliffe","raw_affiliation_strings":[],"raw_orcid":null,"affiliations":[]}],"institutions":[],"countries_distinct_count":0,"institutions_distinct_count":0,"corresponding_author_ids":[],"corresponding_institution_ids":[],"apc_list":{"value":3570,"currency":"USD","value_usd":3570},"apc_paid":null,"fwci":8.0331,"has_fulltext":false,"cited_by_count":25,"citation_normalized_percentile":{"value":0.96870572,"is_in_top_1_percent":false,"is_in_top_10_percent":true},"cited_by_percentile_year":{"min":89,"max":98},"biblio":{"volume":"5","issue":"2","first_page":"139","last_page":"146"},"is_retracted":false,"is_paratext":false,"is_xpac":false,"primary_topic":{"id":"https://openalex.org/T14280","display_name":"Big Data Technologies and Applications","score":0.8779000043869019,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1802","display_name":"Information Systems and Management"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/18","display_name":"Decision Sciences"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},"topics":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/T14280","display_name":"Big Data Technologies and Applications","score":0.8779000043869019,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/1802","display_name":"Information Systems and Management"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/18","display_name":"Decision Sciences"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},{"id":"https://openalex.org/T10883","display_name":"Ethics and Social Impacts of AI","score":0.08730000257492065,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/3311","display_name":"Safety Research"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/33","display_name":"Social Sciences"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}},{"id":"https://openalex.org/T10953","display_name":"E-Government and Public Services","score":0.01360000018030405,"subfield":{"id":"https://openalex.org/subfields/3320","display_name":"Political Science and International Relations"},"field":{"id":"https://openalex.org/fields/33","display_name":"Social Sciences"},"domain":{"id":"https://openalex.org/domains/2","display_name":"Social Sciences"}}],"keywords":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/big-data","display_name":"big data","score":0.972000002861023},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/data-policy","display_name":"data policy","score":0.628000020980835},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/privacy","display_name":"privacy","score":0.5659999847412109},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/data-protection","display_name":"data protection","score":0.9200000166893005},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/digital-footprint","display_name":"digital footprint","score":0.5370000004768372},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/nudging","display_name":"nudging","score":0.7360000014305115},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/social-media-data","display_name":"social media data","score":0.6470000147819519},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/it-infrastructure","display_name":"IT infrastructure","score":0.5139999985694885},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/data-ethics","display_name":"data ethics","score":0.44999998807907104},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/political-movements","display_name":"political movements","score":0.42899999022483826},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/citizen-participation","display_name":"citizen participation","score":0.7950000166893005},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/surveillance","display_name":"surveillance","score":0.33500000834465027},{"id":"https://openalex.org/keywords/big-data-governance","display_name":"big data governance","score":0.38100001215934753}],"concepts":[{"id":"https://openalex.org/C75684735","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q858810","display_name":"Big data","level":2,"score":0.6455162763595581},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C2522767166","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q2374463","display_name":"Data science","level":1,"score":0.502596378326416},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C41008148","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q21198","display_name":"Computer science","level":0,"score":0.3801005482673645},{"id":"https://openalex.org/C124101348","wikidata":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q172491","display_name":"Data mining","level":1,"score":0.1414290964603424}],"mesh":[],"locations_count":1,"locations":[{"id":"doi:10.1002/1944-2866.poi326","doi":"https://doi.org/10.1002/1944-2866.poi326","is_oa":false,"landing_page_url":"https://doi.org/10.1002/1944-2866.poi326","pdf_url":null,"source":{"id":"https://openalex.org/S2170549","display_name":"Policy & Internet","issn_l":"1944-2866","issn":["1944-2866"],"is_oa":false,"is_in_doaj":false,"is_core":true,"listed_in":["anvur-class-a","anvur-scientific","cwts-core","jufo-1","norway-1","poland-100","russia-white-list-1","vabb-shw"],"host_organization":"https://openalex.org/P4310320595","host_organization_name":"Wiley","host_organization_lineage":["https://openalex.org/P4310320595"],"host_organization_lineage_names":["Wiley"],"type":"journal"},"license":null,"license_id":null,"version":"publishedVersion","is_accepted":true,"is_published":true,"raw_source_name":"Policy & Internet","raw_type":"journal-article"}],"best_oa_location":null,"sustainable_development_goals":[{"id":"https://metadata.un.org/sdg/16","score":0.7297000288963318,"display_name":"Peace, justice, and strong institutions"}],"study_designs":[],"awards":[],"funders":[],"has_content":{"pdf":false,"grobid_xml":false},"content_urls":null,"referenced_works_count":13,"referenced_works":["https://openalex.org/W1487615702","https://openalex.org/W1585180166","https://openalex.org/W1786705216","https://openalex.org/W1846805760","https://openalex.org/W1898516104","https://openalex.org/W1929252804","https://openalex.org/W1979714823","https://openalex.org/W2028055861","https://openalex.org/W2036172168","https://openalex.org/W2130072374","https://openalex.org/W2152199665","https://openalex.org/W2272536545","https://openalex.org/W3122027301"],"related_works":["https://openalex.org/W1951228191","https://openalex.org/W2794003321","https://openalex.org/W2618318125","https://openalex.org/W4383852659","https://openalex.org/W2909014521","https://openalex.org/W941737076","https://openalex.org/W3016395765","https://openalex.org/W1898516104","https://openalex.org/W2714849969","https://openalex.org/W1899434258"],"abstract_inverted_index":{"This":[0,113,390,654,1812,2531,2882],"editorial":[1],"introduces":[2],"the":[3,18,61,65,76,153,175,228,263,289,301,364,378,449,481,497,500,536,555,563,577,585,597,601,609,637,645,657,671,697,740,748,805,810,819,825,833,842,873,885,903,913,928,953,1055,1074,1141,1150,1188,1264,1300,1338,1354,1371,1413,1422,1440,1457,1460,1482,1508,1518,1562,1574,1581,1587,1606,1626,1648,1720,1725,1759,1765,1768,1778,1788,1826,1847,1860,1865,1871,1914,1917,1920,1928,1931,1936,1955,1998,2004,2016,2023,2032,2091,2108,2158,2165,2208,2240,2274,2278,2317,2329,2355,2378,2381,2392,2399,2414,2418,2432,2453,2463,2476,2495,2498,2514,2573,2590,2611,2627,2631,2637,2668,2715,2724,2741,2751,2754,2763,2771,2782,2793,2807,2826,2834,2858,2899],"papers":[4,477,2900],"in":[5,172,377,397,493,562,576,608,691,712,800,832,912,962,1374,1418,1529,1531,1545,1647,1655,1674,1695,1699,1772,1777,1852,1892,1899,2031,2090,2387,2502,2547,2558,2633,2718,2723,2746,2778,2876,2902],"issue":[6,15,469,2537,2905],"5":[7],"(2)":[8],"of":[9,22,31,69,98,127,174,177,187,195,209,230,257,269,306,343,366,368,380,399,425,455,557,587,595,618,795,809,816,818,836,844,855,859,872,889,892,930,939,941,990,1059,1073,1099,1103,1127,1140,1152,1207,1219,1227,1232,1251,1253,1261,1263,1266,1307,1321,1340,1356,1386,1415,1421,1447,1462,1481,1490,1499,1511,1517,1525,1533,1536,1568,1583,1611,1643,1663,1701,1724,1767,1790,1823,1825,1836,1867,1885,1896,1901,1916,1930,1945,1949,1957,1968,2000,2006,2062,2068,2093,2096,2127,2172,2184,2188,2210,2220,2243,2253,2267,2280,2288,2316,2337,2348,2375,2384,2402,2420,2497,2517,2534,2540,2610,2640,2670,2705,2726,2740,2753,2765,2770,2780,2791,2809,2830,2842,2857,2861,2879,2921,2930],"Policy":[10,486],"&":[11,163,199,212,356,728,1003,1222,1274,1379,1395,1401,2192,2650],"Internet;":[12],"a":[13,54,192,588,593,630,692,705,895,917,949,960,1012,1060,1196,1319,1435,1452,1465,1476,1493,1496,1634,1644,1821,1832,1868,1987,2073,2080,2141,2170,2217,2289,2362,2372,2408,2535,2703,2817,2839,2855,2877],"special":[14,468,1406,2904],"that":[16,57,100,140,291,373,423,539,550,567,649,702,718,781,955,1015,1026,1069,1108,1455,1622,1746,1804,1850,1853,1942,1984,2083,2204,2239,2262,2340,2422,2444,2452,2479,2506,2513,2575,2635],"addresses":[17,2319],"challenges":[19,197,2829,2848],"and":[20,27,84,89,91,104,110,133,156,159,180,185,207,224,238,252,259,278,294,304,321,340,350,371,451,458,503,527,566,614,640,663,736,744,770,773,802,804,852,857,925,967,979,985,1018,1033,1083,1091,1123,1160,1210,1225,1243,1255,1280,1292,1328,1343,1350,1367,1390,1409,1430,1467,1539,1552,1566,1571,1596,1608,1704,1708,1715,1756,1935,1972,1978,1982,2010,2038,2056,2099,2118,2147,2178,2186,2222,2234,2247,2323,2352,2417,2440,2459,2462,2471,2542,2561,2570,2582,2597,2616,2619,2621,2625,2660,2665,2673,2679,2682,2696,2699,2709,2735,2761,2796,2812,2819,2828,2846,2849,2874,2889],"opportunities":[21,2428,2662],"\u201cbig":[23,114,679,719,905,1211,2359],"data\u201d":[24,115,680,720,906,2360],"for":[25,121,215,250,265,300,319,324,348,606,633,750,791,916,974,1205,1345,1507,1658,1684,1808,1840,2273,2380,2404,2429,2467,2601,2663,2757,2762,2822,2833],"academics":[26,92,1087,2664,2823],"policymakers.":[28,1973],"Vast":[29],"amounts":[30],"transactional":[32],"data":[33,55,78,99,189,205,226,245,312,338,346,360,408,440,638,651,933,998,1021,1038,1105,1128,1154,1202,1234,1268,1309,1334,1388,1834,1976,2002,2385,2421,2454,2491,2525,2551,2594,2622,2657,2690,2794,2832,2863],"are":[34,285,328,361,384,424,441,462,714,850,1071,1106,2085,2101,2245,2269,2326,2334,2344,2473,2552],"collected":[35,442],"about":[36,41,573,910,1129,1464,1492,1600,2103,2311,2377],"us":[37,428,2049,2587,2801,2871],"as":[38,148,429,592,1076,1173,1514,1633,1653,1798,2072],"we":[39,79,233,401,417,434,461,681,732,956,1027,1070,2305,2713,2767,2773,2909],"go":[40],"our":[42,70,619,963,2134,2885],"daily":[43],"lives":[44],"online.":[45],"Shopping,":[46],"mobile":[47],"phones,":[48],"using":[49,996,1347,2301,2494],"transport,":[50],"entertaining":[51],"ourselves\u2014all":[52],"leave":[53,234],"trail":[56,229],"enables":[58],"companies,":[59],"even":[60,2107,2272,2545],"state,":[62],"to":[63,73,96,136,145,240,335,404,420,427,465,512,520,523,544,554,571,583,661,788,840,883,965,999,1029,1054,1148,1156,1177,1180,1187,1198,1297,1311,1352,1439,1475,1560,1586,1615,1667,1690,1740,1876,1912,1970,1990,2012,2035,2044,2050,2075,2216,2229,2307,2397,2410,2426,2475,2488,2521,2555,2564,2568,2629,2647,2685,2787,2802,2824,2891],"track":[64],"most":[66,874,2548],"mundane":[67],"aspects":[68],"lives.":[71],"Add":[72],"this":[74,456,467,540,665,1184,1405,1546,1696,2435,2445,2719,2747,2799,2903],"all":[75,670,2201,2781],"personal":[77,2541],"willingly":[80],"share":[81,1750],"on":[82,470,518,696,734,763,777,899,927,976,1728,1793,1919,1997,2125,2328,2413,2431,2448,2745,2866,2906],"blogs":[83],"social":[85,111,132,310,430,529,564,598,641,943,1047,1161,1603,1665,1794,1958,2221,2694,2758],"networks":[86,1610],"like":[87,152,766],"Facebook":[88],"Twitter,":[90],"potentially":[93],"have":[94,141,435,636,644,1052,1285,2065,2298,2894],"access":[95,403,787,1053,1179,1286,2489,2520],"terabytes":[97],"can":[101,246,1985,2341,2423,2509,2768,2869],"provide":[102],"new":[103,322,341,501,707,778,897,969,1031,1341,1588,2230,2810],"surprising":[105],"insights":[106,2675],"into":[107,275,2676],"human":[108],"behavior":[109],"structure.":[112],"not":[116,395,699,715,761,784,1024,1040,1050,2206],"only":[117,396,700,762,1856,1893,2297,2553],"offers":[118],"enormous":[119],"scope":[120],"understanding":[122,1262],"citizens'":[123],"willingness\u2014or":[124],"unwillingness\u2014in":[125],"terms":[126,173,398,1532,1700,1900],"civic":[128],"engagement;":[129],"it":[130,419,445,522,551,568,703,1066,1686,2868],"allows":[131,2800],"political":[134,150,767,900,1329,1569,1584,1613,1623,1651,1780,2680,2706],"scientists":[135,642,1048],"tackle":[137],"longstanding":[138,559],"problems":[139,1385],"hitherto":[142],"been":[143,908,2299],"impossible":[144],"address,":[146],"such":[147,722],"how":[149,400,416,444,519,685,847,853,2798,2867],"movements":[151],"\u201cArab":[154,811],"Spring\u201d":[155],"Occupy":[157],"originate":[158],"spread":[160],"(Bastos,":[161],"Travitzki,":[162],"Raimundo,":[164],"2012;":[165,1005,1397],"Lindgren,":[166],"2012).":[167,358,389,730,867,1007,1276,1332,1403,2194,2604,2653],"It":[168,261,580],"also":[169,190,247,286,362,415,717,776,1011,1336,1820,1880,2607,2701],"holds":[170,262],"promise":[171],"design":[176],"efficient":[178],"policy":[179,277,459,504,525,1001,1213,1810,2697,2859,2880],"administrative":[181,1326],"change.":[182],"However,":[183,731,1230,1974,2059,2493],"collection":[184,2577],"use":[186,418,1631,1662,1735,2095,2598],"these":[188,650,789,972,1104,1233,1267,2063,2294,2550,2686],"raises":[191,391],"whole":[193,896],"range":[194,2171,2219,2878],"ethical":[196,2847],"(Mayer-Sch\u00f6nberger":[198],"Cukier,":[200],"2013).":[201,1036],"Obvious":[202],"issues":[203,256],"surround":[204],"protection":[206,2623],"privacy":[208,2620],"subjects":[210],"(Schroeder":[211,727],"Meyer,":[213,729],"2012),":[214,982,988,994,1224,1361,1381],"example":[216,975,1346,2496],"individual":[217],"identities":[218],"become":[219],"discoverable":[220],"from":[221,410,535,546,971,1088,1241,1303,1370,1737,2169,2265],"supposedly":[222],"disaggregated":[223],"\u201canonymized\u201d":[225],"sets;":[227],"digital":[231,887],"footprints":[232],"is":[235,446,542,569,581,627,629,655,704,721,870,920,1067,1110,1138,1451,1495,1672,1774,1785,1813,1951,2079,2106,2130,2358,2370,2532,2578,2599,2816,2883],"certainly":[236,947,1814,2335,2371,2887],"long":[237],"hard":[239],"erase":[241],"(Mayer-Sch\u00f6nberger,":[242],"2009).":[243],"Big":[244,488,490,1037,2727],"be":[248,298,690,958,1688,1806,1967,1986,2342,2424,2486,2510,2556,2608],"used":[249,2066,2425,2557],"algorithmic":[251],"probabilistic":[253],"policymaking,":[254],"raising":[255],"justice":[258],"equity.":[260],"potential":[264,454,1723],"more":[266,308,667,826,1208,2052,2737],"coercive":[267],"modes":[268,2187],"governance,":[270],"whether":[271,1488,2104,2589],"by":[272,508,739,747,1168,1269,1592,1601,1713,1787,1953,2133,2320,2457,2729],"introducing":[273],"conditionality":[274],"public":[276,771,1181,1278,1312,1325,1364,1705,1801,1902,2515,2835],"services":[279],"or":[280,406,412,443,995,1062,1247,1258,1382,1962,2567],"simply":[281,782,1016,1383],"exerting":[282],"\u201cnudges.\u201d":[283],"We":[284,2605,2893],"faced":[287],"with":[288,600,758,937,1086,1433,1681,1874,2407,2854],"challenge":[290,1989],"traditional":[292,764,1628],"databases":[293],"desktop":[295],"computers":[296],"may":[297,1049,1316],"inadequate":[299],"collection,":[302,339,2595],"storage,":[303,320,2470,2596],"analysis":[305,794,1979],"larger,":[307],"complex":[309],"media":[311,1666],"sets.":[313,1203,2492],"More":[314],"computing":[315,331],"power,":[316],"alternative":[317],"tools":[318],"methods":[323,1342,1736],"utilizing":[325],"computational":[326],"clusters":[327],"needed,":[329],"including":[330,2226,2838],"system":[332,2592],"architectures":[333],"suited":[334],"constant":[336,1943],"real-time":[337],"forms":[342],"fast,":[344],"flexible":[345],"storage":[347],"retrieval":[349],"curation":[351],"(Walker,":[352],"Eckert,":[353],"Hemsley,":[354],"Mason,":[355],"Nahon,":[357],"These":[359,1333],"often":[363,386,2282],"result":[365],"\u201cmechanisms":[367],"observation,":[369],"inscription,":[370],"representation":[372],"serve":[374],"specific":[375,2367],"ends\u2014ends,":[376],"case":[379,1294],"big":[381,471,509,1077,1308,1975,2656,2831,2862,2907],"data,":[382,472,510,2098,2783],"which":[383,473,878,1146,1193,2349,2733],"very":[385,463,922,931,1762,2060,2122,2895],"commercial\u201d":[387],"(Barocas,":[388],"its":[392,1675,1742,2405],"own":[393],"challenges:":[394],"obtain":[402],"proprietary":[405],"walled":[407],"(e.g.,":[409],"Google":[411],"Facebook),":[413],"but":[414,775],"answer":[421],"questions":[422,648,1034,2102,2766,2805],"interest":[426,687,745,1969],"scientists,":[431],"particularly":[432,591,1698],"when":[433],"no":[436],"control":[437],"over":[438,864,1199,1358,1434,1556,1882],"what":[439,626,1692,2792],"done.":[447],"Given":[448],"newness":[450],"largely":[452,1679],"unexplored":[453],"research":[457,502,560,647,779,1079,2146,2150,2695],"landscape":[460],"pleased":[464],"present":[466],"gathers":[474],"together":[475],"selected":[476],"first":[478,1450,2716],"presented":[479,754,2351,2901],"at":[480,952,1719,1859,1927,2144,2152,2354,2528,2806],"journal's":[482],"conference":[483,498,658,695,954,2330,2886],"Internet,":[484],"Politics,":[485],"2012:":[487],"Data,":[489],"Challenges?1":[491],"Held":[492],"Oxford":[494,2917,2922,2926,2931],"last":[495],"September,":[496],"explored":[499],"frontiers":[505],"opened":[506,2688],"up":[507,1082,1875,2022,2474,2689],"aiming":[511],"encourage":[513],"discussion":[514,926],"across":[515,755,2200],"disciplinary":[516,2813],"boundaries":[517],"exploit":[521],"inform":[524,1000],"debates":[526],"advance":[528],"science":[530,944,1064,1739,2707,2759],"research.":[531,901,945],"What":[532],"was":[533,538,948,1010,1023,1166],"clear":[534,2818,2840],"discussions":[537],"area":[541,2092],"likely":[543,570],"benefit":[545],"genuinely":[547,741],"multidisciplinary":[548,589],"approaches;":[549],"could":[552,1236,1805,1863,2296],"lead":[553,710],"solution":[556],"many":[558,2347,2739],"\u201cproblems\u201d":[561],"sciences;":[565],"bring":[572],"substantial":[574,1238],"change":[575,863,2045],"policymaking":[578,2836],"process.":[579,1442],"difficult":[582],"overemphasize":[584],"importance":[586],"approach,":[590],"means":[594],"connecting":[596],"sciences":[599],"important\u2014and":[602],"relevant\u2014work":[603],"being":[604,861,881,1761,2131],"done,":[605,2346],"example,":[607,792,935,2121],"physical":[610,1061],"sciences,":[611,613],"computer":[612,1063,1738],"mathematics.":[615],"As":[616],"one":[617,817,871,1824,2251,2286,2366,2415],"keynote":[620,1133,2136,2318],"speakers":[621],"Duncan":[622,2138,2324],"Watts":[623,2139,2325],"pointed":[624],"out,":[625],"needed":[628,2466],"\u201cdating":[631],"service\u201d":[632],"engineers":[634],"(who":[635,643],"skills)":[639],"interesting":[646,1043,1689,1816,2123],"might":[652,675,957],"answer).":[653],"something":[656,1107,2884],"set":[659,1835,2021,2841],"out":[660,2309],"do,":[662],"indeed":[664],"journal":[666],"generally.":[668],"Despite":[669],"recent":[672],"buzz":[673],"(some":[674],"say":[676],"hype)":[677],"around":[678,2391],"were":[682,737,753,2198,2350],"initially":[683],"unsure":[684],"much":[686,2896],"there":[688,919,1009,2100,2105,2333,2369],"would":[689,783],"two-day":[693],"academic":[694,1092],"topic,":[698],"given":[701,1993],"relatively":[706],"talking":[708],"point\u2014and":[709],"times":[711],"academia":[713,2117],"short!\u2014but":[716],"an":[723,1096,1174,1515,1799,1815,2254,2559],"ontologically":[724],"tricky":[725],"concept":[726],"plunged":[733],"regardless,":[735],"gratified":[738],"warm":[742],"reception":[743],"received":[746],"call":[749],"papers.":[751],"Papers":[752],"three":[756,1445,1557],"tracks,":[757],"panel":[759],"sessions":[760],"areas":[765,780],"campaigning,":[768],"legislation":[769],"policy,":[772],"government;":[774],"exist":[785],"without":[786],"data:":[790,2544],"sentiment":[793],"entire":[796],"populations,":[797],"predictive":[798,1509,1961],"modeling":[799,2126],"economics":[801],"politics,":[803],"large-scale":[806,1669,1886,2001],"information":[807,983,1301,1618,1670,1857,2070],"dynamics":[808,843,1671],"Spring.\u201d":[812],"Jonathan":[813],"Bright,":[814],"winner":[815,1822],"conference's":[820,1827],"\u201cbest":[821,1828],"paper\u201d":[822,1829],"awards":[823],"analyzed":[824,1831,1908],"than":[827],"740":[828],"million":[829,1436,1558,1910],"words":[830],"spoken":[831],"U.K.'s":[834,1142,1921,2017],"House":[835],"Commons":[837],"since":[838,1843],"1936":[839],"uncover":[841],"parliamentary":[845],"discourse;":[846],"different":[848],"members":[849],"treated,":[851],"quantity":[854],"interventions":[856],"types":[858,2183,2764],"topic":[860,1743],"debated":[862],"time":[865,1359,1929],"(Bright,":[866],"Parliamentary":[868],"discourse":[869],"important":[875,1068,1097],"mechanisms":[876],"through":[877],"democracy":[879],"functions;":[880],"able":[882,2487],"analyze":[884,966,1412,1555],"complete":[886],"record":[888,1996],"75":[890],"years":[891],"debate":[893],"opens":[894],"window":[898],"While":[902,1502,1661],"term":[904],"has":[907],"bandied":[909],"(particularly":[911],"commercial":[914],"world)":[915],"while,":[918],"still":[921,1590,1630,1673,2086,2785],"little":[923],"work":[924,1185,1693,2124],"potentials":[929,1102,2827],"large":[932,1020,2007,2302],"sets\u2014for":[934],"dealing":[936],"populations":[938],"millions":[940],"individuals\u2014for":[942],"There":[946,2078,2815],"real":[950],"sense":[951,2082],"seeing":[959],"step-change":[961],"ability":[964],"draw":[968],"conclusions":[970],"data;":[973,2908],"collective":[977,1922,1947],"action":[978],"dissent":[980],"(Procter,":[981],"diffusion":[984,1541,2129,2166],"influence":[986,1766],"(Freelon,":[987],"prediction":[989,1477],"economic":[991,2223,2617],"trends":[992],"(Metreveli,":[993],"secondary":[997],"(Baumann":[1002],"Eulenstein,":[1004],"Blake,":[1006],"But":[1008,2357],"countervailing":[1013],"view":[1014],"accessing":[1017],"manipulating":[1019],"sets":[1022,1310,2455,2526],"sufficient;":[1025],"need":[1028,2306,2409,2628,2821],"develop":[1030],"theory":[1032,2784],"(Gonz\u00e1lez-Bail\u00f3n,":[1035],"does":[1039],"necessarily":[1041],"mean":[1042],"data.":[1044],"And":[1045],"while":[1046,1764,1888,2642],"generally":[1051],"brute":[1056],"machine":[1057],"force":[1058],"lab,":[1065],"part":[1072,1098,2533],"\u201cconversation\u201d":[1075],"data-driven":[1078],"capabilities":[1080],"open":[1081,1153,1209],"develop.":[1084],"Working":[1085],"other":[1089,1659,2460],"disciplines":[1090],"traditions":[1093],"will":[1094,1335,1687,1965,2485,2691,2700],"form":[1095,2563],"this.":[1100],"The":[1101,1449,1470,1782,2851],"government":[1109,1201,1206,1357,2112],"becoming":[1111],"increasingly":[1112],"(if":[1113],"patchily)":[1114],"aware":[1115,2609],"of;":[1116],"after":[1117],"all,":[1118],"they":[1119,1503,1521,1640,2260,2504],"sit":[1120],"on,":[1121],"guard,":[1122],"process":[1124],"vast":[1125,2241,2382],"quantities":[1126,2383],"us.":[1130],"Our":[1131,1710],"opening":[1132],"speaker":[1134],"Nigel":[1135,2321],"Shadbolt":[1136,2322],"(2012)":[1137,1907],"co-director":[1139],"Open":[1143],"Data":[1144],"Institute,":[1145,2919,2928],"aims":[1147],"catalyze":[1149],"evolution":[1151],"culture":[1155],"create":[1157],"economic,":[1158,2677],"environmental,":[1159],"value.":[1162],"In":[1163,1404,2014,2258,2434,2654,2711],"2009":[1164],"he":[1165,1862,2156],"appointed":[1167],"Prime":[1169],"Minister":[1170],"Gordon":[1171],"Brown":[1172],"Information":[1175],"Advisor":[1176],"transform":[1178],"sector":[1182,1313,1323,2632],"information;":[1183],"leading":[1186,1730],"highly":[1189],"acclaimed":[1190],"data.gov.uk":[1191],"site,":[1192],"now":[1194,2579],"provides":[1195],"portal":[1197],"9,000":[1200],"Potentials":[1204],"data\u201d-driven":[1212],"include":[1214],"efficiency":[1215],"savings,":[1216],"crowd":[1217],"sourcing":[1218],"knowledge":[1220,1288,2708],"(Stottlemyre":[1221],"Stottlemyre,":[1223],"harnessing":[1226],"citizen-based":[1228],"innovation.":[1229],"implementation":[1231,1254],"policies":[1235],"face":[1237],"barriers,":[1239],"ranging":[1240],"organizational":[1242,1597],"structural":[1244],"inefficiencies,":[1245],"conflicting":[1246],"legacy":[1248],"legislation,":[1249],"lack":[1250,1260],"instruments":[1252],"technical":[1256],"expertise,":[1257,1327],"simple":[1259],"utility":[1265,1414],"decision":[1270],"makers":[1271],"(Stefaneas,":[1272],"Tsiavos,":[1273],"Karounos,":[1275],"Few":[1277],"administrators,":[1279],"ever":[1281],"fewer":[1282],"elected":[1283],"officials,":[1284],"to\u2014or":[1287],"of\u2014the":[1289],"statistical":[1290],"skills":[1291,1983],"relevant":[1293],"examples":[1295],"necessary":[1296],"fully":[1298,2738],"utilize":[1299],"available":[1302,1858,2327],"burgeoning":[1304],"mega-databases;":[1305],"application":[1306],"decision-making":[1314],"processes":[1315],"therefore":[1317,2626],"require":[1318,1337],"merger":[1320],"private":[1322],"methodology,":[1324],"leadership":[1330],"(Milakovich,":[1331],"development":[1339],"tools,":[1344],"Web":[1348],"crawlers":[1349],"archives":[1351],"map":[1353],"presence":[1355],"(Hale,":[1360],"extracting":[1362],"reliable":[1363,1497],"opinion":[1365,1706,1802],"indicators":[1366],"approval":[1368],"ratings":[1369],"sentiments":[1372],"encoded":[1373],"online":[1375,1602,1650,1702,1800,2069,2097,2173,2312],"communications":[1376,1463],"(Lansdall-Welfare,":[1377],"Lampos,":[1378],"Cristianini,":[1380,1402],"solving":[1384],"scalable":[1387],"extraction":[1389],"automation":[1391],"(Furche,":[1392],"Gottlob,":[1393],"Grasso,":[1394],"Schallhart,":[1396],"Sudhahar,":[1398],"Lansdall-Welfare,":[1399],"Flaounas,":[1400],"issue,":[1407,1547,2436,2720],"Jensen":[1408],"Anstead":[1410],"(2013)":[1411,1554,1717,2442],"Twitter":[1416,1473,1512,1632],"posts":[1417],"predicting":[1419],"outcomes":[1420],"2011":[1423,1575,1773,1938],"Republican":[1424],"nomination,":[1425],"comparing":[1426],"aggregated":[1427,1534,2562],"polling":[1428],"figures":[1429],"electoral":[1431,1468,1483],"results":[1432],"tweets":[1437,1491,1559,1911],"relating":[1438],"nomination":[1441],"They":[1443,1485,1579,1620,1734,1940,2236],"consider":[1444,1487],"categories":[1446],"models.":[1448],"mentions":[1453,1513],"model":[1454,1741],"examines":[1456],"correspondence":[1458],"between":[1459,1754,2614],"volume":[1461],"candidate":[1466,1494,1537],"outcomes.":[1469],"second":[1471,2135],"treats":[1472],"similarly":[1474],"market,":[1478],"aggregating":[1479],"predictions":[1480,1535],"result.":[1484],"lastly":[1486],"rediffusion":[1489],"predictor":[1498],"their":[1500,1617,1751,1994,2088,2468,2576],"performance.":[1501],"find":[1504,1522,1621,1641,2036,2237,2261],"inconsistent":[1505],"support":[1506],"value":[1510],"estimate":[1516],"overall":[1519],"vote,":[1520],"some":[1523],"evidence":[1524,1642],"otherwise":[1526],"undetected":[1527],"shifts":[1528,1926],"momentum":[1530],"performance":[1538],"message":[1540],"via":[1542],"retweets.":[1543],"Also":[1544,1898],"Arag\u00f3n,":[1548],"Kappler,":[1549],"Kaltenbrunner,":[1550],"Laniado,":[1551],"Volkovich":[1553],"examine":[1561,1913],"activity,":[1563],"emotional":[1564],"content,":[1565],"interactions":[1567],"parties":[1570,1585,1614],"politicians":[1572],"during":[1573],"Spanish":[1576,1649],"national":[1577],"elections.":[1578],"discuss":[1580],"adaptation":[1582],"(and":[1589,2343],"unregulated":[1591],"election":[1593],"laws)":[1594],"communication":[1595,1637,2873],"paradigm":[1598],"brought":[1599],"networks,":[1604],"analyzing":[1605],"reply":[1607],"retweet":[1609],"seven":[1612],"assess":[1616],"dynamics.":[1619],"parties,":[1624,1629],"especially":[1625],"major":[1627],"one-way":[1635],"flow":[1636],"tool.":[1638],"Moreover,":[1639],"balkanization":[1645],"trend":[1646],"sphere,":[1652],"observed":[1654],"previous":[1656],"studies":[1657],"countries.":[1660],"networked":[1664,2128,2176,2303],"investigate":[1668],"early":[1676],"days":[1677],"(still":[1678],"concerned":[1680],"single":[1682],"platforms,":[1683,2175],"example),":[1685],"see":[1691],"emerges":[1694],"area,":[1697],"publics,":[1703],"monitoring":[1707,1954,1963],"modeling.":[1709],"next":[1711,1872],"article,":[1712],"Koltsova":[1714],"Koltcov":[1716],"looks":[1718],"agenda":[1721],"setting":[1722],"top":[1726,1748],"bloggers":[1727],"Russia's":[1729],"blog":[1731],"platform":[1732],"LiveJournal.":[1733],"structure,":[1744],"finding":[1745,1924],"LiveJournal's":[1747],"users":[1749],"attention":[1752],"evenly":[1753],"\u201csocial/political\u201d":[1755],"\u201cprivate/recreational\u201d":[1757],"issues,":[1758],"latter":[1760],"stable,":[1763],"Russian":[1769],"street":[1770],"protests":[1771],"clearly":[1775],"visible":[1776],"blogs'":[1779],"content.":[1781],"greatest":[1783],"volatility":[1784],"shown":[1786],"group":[1789],"topics":[1791],"centering":[1792],"issues;":[1795],"possibly":[1796],"serving":[1797],"barometer":[1803],"applied":[1807,2215],"proactive":[1809],"making.":[1811],"area.":[1817],"Chadefaux":[1818],"(2013;":[1819],"awards)":[1830],"comprehensive":[1833],"historical":[1837],"newspaper":[1838],"articles":[1839],"166":[1841],"countries":[1842],"1900,":[1844],"testing":[1845],"against":[1846],"two-hundred":[1848],"conflicts":[1849],"occurred":[1851],"period.":[1854],"Using":[1855],"time,":[1861],"predict":[1864],"onset":[1866],"war":[1869],"within":[1870,2111,2250,2285],"year":[1873],"85":[1877],"percent":[1878,1884,1895],"confidence;":[1879],"forecasting":[1881],"70":[1883],"wars,":[1887],"issuing":[1889],"false":[1890],"alarms":[1891],"16":[1894],"observations.":[1897],"\u201cbarometers,\u201d":[1903],"Lansdall-Welfare":[1904],"et":[1905],"al.":[1906],"484":[1909],"effect":[1915],"recession":[1918],"mood,":[1923],"negative":[1925],"spending":[1932],"cut":[1933],"announcements":[1934],"August":[1937],"riots.":[1939],"propose":[1941],"\u201cnowcasting\u201d":[1944],"certain":[1946],"properties":[1948],"society":[1950],"possible":[1952],"contents":[1956],"media.":[1959],"Any":[1960],"capacity":[1964,2011],"obviously":[1966],"governments":[1971,2084],"generation":[1977,2669],"requires":[1980],"expertise":[1981,2110],"particular":[1988],"governmental":[1991],"organizations,":[1992,2461],"dubious":[1995],"guardianship":[1999],"sets,":[2003],"management":[2005],"technology-based":[2008],"projects,":[2009],"innovate.":[2013],"2010,":[2015],"incoming":[2018],"Coalition":[2019],"Government":[2020],"Behavioural":[2024],"Insights":[2025],"Team":[2026],"(aka":[2027],"\u201cThe":[2028],"Nudge":[2029],"Unit\u201d)":[2030],"Cabinet":[2033],"Office":[2034],"innovative":[2037,2094],"cost":[2039],"effective":[2040],"(i.e.,":[2041],"cheap)":[2042],"ways":[2043,2634],"people's":[2046],"behavior;":[2047],"encouraging":[2048],"eat":[2051],"healthily,":[2053],"save":[2054],"money,":[2055],"stop":[2057],"smoking.":[2058],"few":[2061,2290],"experiments":[2064],"manipulation":[2067],"environments":[2071],"way":[2074,2089],"do":[2076,2205],"it.":[2077],"definite":[2081],"feeling":[2087],"right":[2109],"departments;":[2113],"compared":[2114],"with,":[2115],"say,":[2116],"business.":[2119],"For":[2120],"done":[2132],"speaker,":[2137],"(2012),":[2140],"principal":[2142,2149],"researcher":[2143],"Microsoft":[2145],"previously":[2148],"scientist":[2151],"Yahoo!":[2153],"Research,":[2154],"where":[2155],"directed":[2157],"Human":[2159],"Social":[2160],"Dynamics":[2161],"group.":[2162],"He":[2163],"described":[2164],"patterns":[2167,2197],"arising":[2168],"domains\u2014communications":[2174],"games,":[2177],"microblogging":[2179],"services\u2014each":[2180],"involving":[2181],"distinct":[2182],"content":[2185],"sharings":[2189],"(Goel,":[2190],"Watts,":[2191],"Goldstein,":[2193],"Strikingly":[2195],"similar":[2196],"found":[2199],"domains;":[2202],"ones":[2203],"fit":[2207,2600],"\u201cspread":[2209],"infectious":[2211],"disease\u201d":[2212],"analogy":[2213],"commonly":[2214],"wide":[2218],"adoption":[2224,2313],"processes,":[2225],"those":[2227],"related":[2228],"products,":[2231],"ideas,":[2232],"norms,":[2233],"behaviors.":[2235],"instead":[2238],"majority":[2242],"cascades":[2244,2276],"small":[2246],"simple,":[2248],"terminating":[2249],"degree":[2252,2287],"initial":[2255],"adopting":[2256],"\u201cseed.\u201d":[2257],"addition":[2259],"adoptions":[2263,2281],"resulting":[2264],"chains":[2266],"referrals":[2268],"extremely":[2270],"rare;":[2271],"largest":[2275],"observed,":[2277],"bulk":[2279],"took":[2283],"place":[2284],"dominant":[2291],"individuals.":[2292],"Together,":[2293],"observations\u2014which":[2295],"obtained":[2300],"populations\u2014suggest":[2304],"reconsider":[2308],"assumptions":[2310,2508],"processes.":[2314,2683],"(Webcasts":[2315],"website.)":[2331],"So":[2332],"lots":[2336],"exciting":[2338],"things":[2339,2742],"being)":[2345],"discussed":[2353],"conference.":[2356],"really":[2361],"universal":[2363],"panaceum?":[2364],"Taking":[2365],"case,":[2368],"great":[2373],"deal":[2374],"enthusiasm":[2376,2446],"prospects":[2379],"held":[2386,2456],"health":[2388,2482,2523],"care":[2389,2395,2483,2524],"systems":[2390,2484],"world.":[2393],"Health":[2394,2500],"appears":[2396],"offer":[2398],"ideal":[2400],"combination":[2401],"circumstances":[2403],"exploitation,":[2406],"improve":[2411,2569,2872],"productivity":[2412],"hand,":[2416],"availability":[2419],"identify":[2427,2565],"improvement":[2430],"other.":[2433],"Keen,":[2437],"Calinescu,":[2438],"Paige,":[2439],"Rooksby":[2441],"argue":[2443,2505],"rests":[2447],"two":[2449],"assumptions.":[2450],"First,":[2451],"hospitals":[2458],"technological":[2464],"infrastructure":[2465],"acquisition,":[2469],"manipulation,":[2472],"task.":[2477],"Second,":[2478],"organizations":[2480],"outside":[2481],"detailed":[2490,2522],"National":[2499],"Service":[2501],"England":[2503],"both":[2507],"challenged;":[2511],"furthermore":[2512],"acceptability":[2516],"third":[2518],"party":[2519],"is,":[2527],"best,":[2529],"unclear.":[2530],"larger":[2536],"surrounding":[2538],"reuse":[2539],"behavioral":[2543],"if":[2546],"cases":[2549],"intended":[2554],"anonymized":[2560],"trends,":[2566],"personalize":[2571],"services,":[2572],"fact":[2574],"so":[2580,2583],"routine":[2581],"extensive":[2584],"should":[2585,2606],"make":[2586],"question":[2588],"regulatory":[2591],"governing":[2593],"purpose":[2602],"(Andrade,":[2603],"apparent":[2612],"tension":[2613],"innovation":[2615],"growth,":[2618],"regimes;":[2624],"regulate":[2630],"satisfy":[2636],"varying":[2638],"needs":[2639],"users,":[2641],"nonetheless":[2643],"allowing":[2644],"service":[2645],"providers":[2646],"innovate":[2648],"(Porcedda":[2649],"De":[2651],"Filippi,":[2652],"summary,":[2655],"promises":[2658],"powerful":[2659],"emergent":[2661],"policymakers,":[2666],"enabling":[2667],"new,":[2671],"precise,":[2672],"rapid":[2674],"social,":[2678],"practices":[2681],"Access":[2684],"newly":[2687],"inevitably":[2692],"impact":[2693],"making,":[2698],"demand":[2702],"re-examination":[2704],"theory.":[2710],"closing,":[2712],"mention":[2714],"article":[2717,2852],"\u201cSocial":[2721],"Science":[2722],"Era":[2725],"Data\u201d":[2728],"Sandra":[2730],"Gonz\u00e1lez-Bail\u00f3n":[2731],"(2013),":[2732],"reviews":[2734],"discusses":[2736],"briefly":[2743],"touched":[2744],"editorial.":[2748],"She":[2749,2775],"considers":[2750],"implications":[2752,2860],"\u201cdata":[2755],"deluge\u201d":[2756],"research,":[2760,2864],"ask":[2769],"world":[2772],"inhabit.":[2774],"explains":[2776],"why,":[2777],"spite":[2779],"matters":[2786],"build":[2788],"credible":[2789],"stories":[2790],"reveal,":[2795],"shows":[2797],"revisit":[2803],"old":[2804],"intersection":[2808],"technologies":[2811],"approaches.":[2814],"urgent":[2820],"understand":[2825],"process;":[2837],"methodological,":[2843],"technical,":[2844],"theoretical,":[2845],"concerns.":[2850],"closes":[2853],"consideration":[2856],"focusing":[2865],"help":[2870],"governance":[2875],"domains.":[2881],"highlighted":[2888],"sought":[2890],"address.":[2892],"enjoyed":[2897],"selecting":[2898],"hope":[2910],"you":[2911],"enjoy":[2912],"reading":[2913],"them.":[2914],"Helen":[2915],"Margetts":[2916],"Internet":[2918,2927],"University":[2920,2929],"(helen.margetts@oii.ox.ac.uk)":[2923],"David":[2924],"Sutcliffe":[2925]},"counts_by_year":[{"year":2024,"cited_by_count":1},{"year":2021,"cited_by_count":2},{"year":2020,"cited_by_count":1},{"year":2019,"cited_by_count":4},{"year":2018,"cited_by_count":3},{"year":2017,"cited_by_count":2},{"year":2016,"cited_by_count":5},{"year":2015,"cited_by_count":3},{"year":2014,"cited_by_count":3},{"year":2012,"cited_by_count":1}],"updated_date":"2026-10-14T16:39:01.820549","created_date":"2016-06-24T00:00:00"}